16 ms·
Fired App Reviewer Sues Apple
- malinens 6y agoWe currently have issues with approving our apps with app store as they demand using apple login. We have added it but they still do not approve changes. that is so annoying as it blocks some other things in our company...
- erikrothoff 6y agoWhat are they saying is wrong now that you’ve added Apple login?
- malinens 6y agoThey say app should be fully usable after apple login. We are e-mail provider and we are not startup. After apple is connected we ask user to enter existing credentials to add apple to his account (90% of cases) or register a new one (also You need to provide password there). Without password IMAP does not work for example..
- freeone3000 6y agoAppleID should be usable as the only login to the app. As in, if AppleID is offered, you should not prompt for another password. Treat it like an authorized OAuth login. Whatever other hoops you must jump through to make this work are irrelevant to the guidelines.
- malinens 6y agoSo in this case how the hell apple login can be added to existing accounts (millions of them) without violating TOS? the only way to make sure user has access to account is by providing existing credentials which most of times preceedes Apple Login existence in our case
- freeone3000 6y agoYou'll have to have some way of joining two accounts into one account, so that the AppleID login can create a new account. This isn't simple, it's just the only way to be compatible with Apple devices.
- echelon 6y agoSue them! They are so blatantly a monopoly. 50% of American consumers do their computing with a company that forces all interacting parties to jump through Byzantine hoops and pay outrageous taxes. I'm sorry, Apple fans, but this company isn't fair to the rest of the world. It's a dark specter, turning once open computing into an arcane serfdom.
- kdo1617 6y agoI recently published my first app to App Store and failed in the same requirement. Guess I was lucky since It was approved a few hours after I added it. However the bigger problem with Sign in to Apple is that they don’t follow the standard implementation of oauth/oidc as pretty much everyone else does...
- JimDabell 6y ago> However the bigger problem with Sign in to Apple is that they don’t follow the standard implementation of oauth/oidc as pretty much everyone else does... The OpenID Foundation seems to disagree: > Apple Successfully Implements OpenID Connect with Sign In with Apple — https://openid.net/2019/09/30/apple-successfully-implements-openid-connect-with-sign-in-with-apple/ https://openid.net/2019/09/30/apple-successfully-implements-... > Thank You Too Apple — https://openid.net/2019/10/22/thank-you-too-apple/ https://openid.net/2019/10/22/thank-you-too-apple/
- kdo1617 6y agoThanks. Obviously didn’t do my research. Based this on the information from the IDP has use.
- vezycash 6y agoDoes your app have sign in with google, Facebook? If not, what's their rationale for forcing you to implement theirs?
- shaolinspirit 6y agoI like apple devices, I always hated to develop for them. The burden of review on app store is just too much. I would rather prefer to do a web app and to be free, to make quick releases instead of chatting with apple reviewers for weeks when you need to publish some critical release. I don't need apple customers, neither they payment system. Web is king.
- threeseed 6y agoMobile web apps are universally terrible. So if you want happy customers then a native app is a necessity.
- meibo 6y agoThey are terrible because Apple sabotages the ecosystem that enables them by crippling the necessary APIs in Safari. PWAs can be a great experience, and they already are on android and desktop when they're well done.
- throw14082020 6y agocan you provide some examples, preferably the best you can find. I'm curious what great experiences of PWAs actually mean, as I myself have not found any.
- StavrosK 6y agoI don't know if it's a PWA by some strict definition, but Fastmail has always been the best web app I've seen.
- Aeolun 6y agoLittle Alchemy 2 is a PWA and it’s been great since I installed it on my home screen.
- nicoburns 6y agoTinder is a good example from a mainstream company. Also Facebook: better tha there mobile app.
- andybak 6y agoNot much info on the app but there's an Android version here: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.gnews.app&hl=en_US&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.gnews.app&...
- toyg 6y ago“The only civilian media in the world that regards takedown of the Chinese Communist Party as the sole stand in the current Expose revolution” I just don’t understand why the PRC would have a problem with this. /s
- yawaworht1978 6y agoThe firing might be legal and within the selective corporate guidelines, however, to me, this is the final straw, will never buy or even use any apple product again. The cowardice displayed by the managers and the company bending to a hysterical authoritarian regime borders a comedy. Too often have people "just followed orders" in the name of a payslip. Apple is a company of crooks (tax evasion, in bed with the chinese government) with a clientele of mostly fanboys/fangirls.
- simonh 6y agoOk, so who do you go to that isn't? Even Fairphone is up to their eyeballs in Chinese suppliers and they say in their own literature they can't account for all their upstreams. Apple are always the ones that get walloped publicly on issues like this, and actually I'm ok with that. It's good these issues get air time at all, if Apple didn't exist and it was all Microsoft, Samsung and such none of this would ever get out and if it did nobody would care. But pretending this is all about Apple, slagging them in a comment and then going and buying the next Chinese made gear from Amazon or whoever is just brushing this under the rug.
- strogonoff 6y agoPurism’s Librem 5 seems to be a worthy alternative. They publish[0] schematics and aim to allow users to verify that hardware hadn’t been altered by a supplier. [0] https://puri.sm/posts/a-different-kind-of-transparency/ https://puri.sm/posts/a-different-kind-of-transparency/
- simonh 6y agoBoth efforts are great and well worth pursuing, but Purism don’t really talk at all about their hardware supply chain. Their focus in on the software and end user privacy, so they’re exposed to exactly the same hardware supply chain risks.
- strogonoff 6y ago
- crististm 6y agoChinese gov to Apple: so, we've heard you are building (edit: and selling) your products here huh?
- xuki 6y agoManufacturing is one thing, the purchasing power of Chinese is another thing. China is about 15-20% of Apple's business and they can't afford to lose it. China will happily ban iPhone while letting Apple keep manufacturing.
- crististm 6y agoIt's an interesting twist. It doesn't change the fact that Apple takes shit from Chinese gov to be able to make money. I understand, rule of the land and all that, but I won't pull any punches: Apple knows exactly what they are doing and they are no fluffy angels.
- TheChaplain 6y agoReading the PDF I really can't understand how the court says there was no harassment.. And 80 app reviews per day? Do they even have time to eat or take a dump?
- schappim 6y agoYikes! That is less than 6 min per app.
- simonh 6y agoMany, possibly the vast majority are probably reviews of minor updates to existing apps.
- gregoriol 6y agoShouldn't the reviewer check every update? What if the "minor" update contains some rule breaking changes? They can't know/assume from the developer's update description that it is a minor update, and don't have much other information about what has changed. Otherwise it would be very easy to first publish a "normal" app, and then just publish an update with bad stuff added.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- simonh 6y agoThey do review every update, but they have a lot of automated tools that help a lot when reviewing minor changes. So for example, if only a few bytes have changed and the binary is only a few bytes different in size they can mostly rely on the tools. That’s probably most bug fix updates right there.
- gregoriol 6y agoAutomated tools will probably check private api usage and maybe some basic technical stuff, but they won't be able to catch a feature change. And even if you were right, changing some text or url would pass your test as only a few characters change, but that could make a big difference regarding the feature.
- simonh 6y agoChina is a major problem for 'western' companies. From sports and media companies that are walking on egg shells in case actors or sports stars, or even fans, say things critical of the Chinese government. De-funding or sidelining of movies potentially critical of the Chinese government. Imagine a film like The Manchurian Candidate being made now? It's not gong to happen, not from a major film studio anyway. The problems Apple is having here, and also with Chinese supplier companies possibly using transported Uighur labourers working under some form of coercion, can affect pretty much any foreign company operating in China. In this case the App in question was pulled from the App Store in China. On the one hand I can understand it's the Chinese market so Chinese Government rules apply. Clearly this would not be acceptable if the App was pulled internationally. On the other hand, if the US government tried to get an App pulled when it's not clear the App violated any US law or App Store rules, Apple would fight it to the courts. That's a tricky course to take with China, but it's obviously the right thing to do. If Chinese law says the App has to be pulled and a Chinese court says so then fine, I've no problem with Apple complying with that, the alternative would be to expect them to criminalise Apple employees in China. That's clearly not a reasonable expectation on any company. But at least it would force the Chinese authorities to account for their actions and make it clear what they are doing and why. The problem is it's not really possible for individual companies to fight the Chinese government. Even for a company like Apple, the asymmetry in the power of the CCP relative to Apple is overwhelming. The CCP could crush Apple, and they know it. They hold enough economic power now that they could quite feasibly drive a major film studio to the wall, or slice off the whole profit margin of many US media or sports organisations. It's time for western governments to work together on this. Congressional hearings in the US, debates at the G7 and G20. The WTO is pretty crippled at the moment and that needs to change. Whatever side of the US political fence you are and think about US imports, surely you all want to support US exports and the rights of US companies abroad right? I'm a Brit and ok we're out of the EU now, but on things like this we're all in the same boat and need to work together. We need to all support Australia in their current spat with the CCP. We are desperately in need of a broad and international political debate about these issues. It affects all of us.
- felipelemos 6y agoI don't know why you are being downvoted. It's a very reasonable way to think. We should have a policy of reciprocity with China. This must be discussed urgently.
- oefrha 6y agoThe app in question seems to be the outlet of Guo Wengui, a fugitive businessman wanted for corruption charges in China. (Whether the charges are valid or not I have zero idea. Incidentally I learned about this guy from the news of Steve Bannon’s arrest on this guy’s yacht.) So stating that this app is merely critical of Chinese government is lacking quite a bit of context. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guo_Wengui https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guo_Wengui
- ladyanita22 6y agoCorruption charges is how you take down dissidents in China
- girvo 6y agoConsidering how often the Chinese government outright fabricates charges and “crimes” committed by those who oppose it directly, you’ll have to forgive me for being less than credulous regarding what he’s been accused. This is how the CCP takes down dissidents.
- oefrha 6y agoThe guy is now entangled in fraud in the U.S. (see Bannon link) and his outlets have been fabricating and disseminating election misinformation targeting Biden like crazy, so I see a pattern there.
- altitudinous 6y agoIn this thread - People complaining about Apple generally and their own app review issues and not this specific case.
- tobr 6y agoAlso people complaining about the thread and not this specific case.
- altitudinous 6y agoI have nothing to say about the specific case - I think the app reviewer has an extremely valid case if he was following the app review process that Apple built.
- zepto 6y agoHe wasn’t fired for following the review process. He was fired for ignoring his supervisors to promote a far right app developed by a financer of Steve Bannon.
- dirtyid 6y agoSomeone else already covered that this is Guo Wengui's app, same man funding Bannon's rule of law society report on covid lab leak recently. > Guo Media App does not contain violent content or incite violence; ... Hilarious recent drama among antiCCP Chinese diaspora in west: Surrey assault victim: “They attack the real anti-CCP, actual pro-democratic activists” >The protesters are part of the New Federal State of China campaign created by Steve Bannon and Guo Wengui, who are also involved in the media startups GNews and GTV. Associates have staged protests against critics in other cities around North America. Gao has been critical of Guo, who is wanted for corruption in China. https://thebreaker.news/news/surrey-protest-victim-talks/ https://thebreaker.news/news/surrey-protest-victim-talks/ ... Granted CCP hates Guo. Like a lot. But I think this is mostly western politics due to Bannon association. If Apple was really sucking Chinese dick, Epoch Times would not be #2 app in magazines and newspapers. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/epoch-times-live-breaking/id670443321 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/epoch-times-live-breaking/id67... E: is this about pulling from Chinese app stores? That's even less of a non story. Peak American exceptionalism thinking Apple should decide whether Chinese dissidents get media platforms in China or not. Not.
- antihero 6y agoI mean the guy sounds like total shitheel, but how is it "American exceptionalism" to be against helping enacting state censorship? As a libcom and an internationalist I think no government has the right to determine what information people do or do not see. If your state relies on information control to exist then it is a fucked state. Get out of here with this pro-authoritian crazy talk.
- dirtyid 6y agoEvery state requires information control to exist, secrecy is basis of national security. Multinational companies conforming to local laws and customs is status quo. Most companies sell products and services not ideology even if ideology gets imbued via marketing. Sometimes pre-existing ideology comes preloaded in because regionalization and cultural competence cost extra. The entire trade will export western values narrative - an economic bug that westerners have conflated as a soft power feature because non-western markets have been too small to advocate for themselves. Now they're not. Global market =/= global values and global trade is not trade between peoples but governments. CCP wants to import phones, NBA games, blockbuster films not western values and certainly not western propaganda. No one expects US soybean farmers to bundle exports with bibles, but somehow expect Google or Facebook to operate in China without complying to censorship laws that domestic companies must adhere to. And the have the audacity to suggest these western platforms are "banned" in China when they chose not to operate there legally. That's peak exceptionalism mindset. It's time to separate trade with imperialism and stop expecting companies to execute foreign policy. US companies are already foreign policy instruments subject to National Security Letters, that's enough.
- echelon 6y ago> Apple supervisors stated that the Guo Media App is critical of the Chinese government and, therefore, should be removed from the App Store. Plaintiff Pham responded stating the Guo Media App publishes valid claims of corruption against the Chinese government and Chinese Communist Party and, therefore, should not be taken down. > Apple became aware of plaintiff Pham’s criticism and defendant Apple’s managers responded by retaliating against plaintiff Pham and ultimately terminating plaintiff Pham. Apple is a spineless piece of shit. How anyone can defend these assholes and the horrible things they do to US software developers is beyond me. But to defend this - their kowtowing to a regime that conducts slavery, rape, and organ harvesting - that's appalling. Anybody jumping to disagree - I strongly encourage you to think of all the suffering going on, and how this company would rather make gobs of dirty money than take the moral high ground. We cancel people and companies for far less than this. Cancel Apple.
- AnHonestComment 6y agoTalking honestly about China or communists gets you shadowbanned. I’m a good example. People wonder how the Holocaust happened or why IBM did business with Nazis. What we’re seeing is the answer.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI am no Apple defender, but I am not even sure what you advocate by saying cancel, which has specific political and cultural connotations. Do you want to boycott them? Say so. Do you want US to stop using the services? Do you want financial sector to divest? Do you want them to withdraw from China? Say so. It is difficult for me to guess without projecting my own thoughts on the matter. My recommendation is that you stop saying 'cancel'. As for the suffering, while absolutely accurate and true, I would like you to consider certain sad truth: “The tears of the world are a constant quantity. For each one who begins to weep somewhere else another stops" You think people are suffering now, but they have been for a while. The only difference now is that we can't pretend we don't know about it.
- barnacled 6y agoChina are a god-awful totalitarian lying genocidal state and Apple are ruthless hypocrites but as another comment here also points out, there's real uncertainty around Guo Wengui (whose app it is) and whether he in fact was corrupt (it's just difficult to know given China's absolute lack of rule of law). Xi JinPing did kick off a huge crackdown on corruption so everything's murky unfortunately. Will be interesting to see the outcome of this! EDIT: It is clear people are not actually reading what I said here or the article. 'At this meeting, defendant Apple supervisors stated that the Guo Media App is critical of the Chinese government and, therefore, should be removed from the App Store.' - this is what is claimed. I am pointing out that this claim is not necessarily true (or at least not as clear-cut as this) and if so it makes you question the whole thing somewhat. For the record I DESPISE censorship and DESPISE the CCP and DESPISE apple's rank hypocrisy. But I also care a great deal about accuracy and truth hence my pointing this inconsistency out.
- MikeUt 6y agoSuppose he was corrupt - does that justify censorship? Does everyone that is corrupt get censored, or is it selectively applied?
- barnacled 6y agoCan you re-read my post and explain which part of it advocates for censorship? You (and the downvoters) have entirely misunderstood what I said. I thought opening with 'China are a god-awful totalitarian lying genocidal state and Apple are ruthless hypocrites' would make it abundantly clear my stance on this. Apparently not.
- depressedpanda 6y agoYou are getting downvoted because you leverage criticism against 1) China 2) Apple Especially the latter is an egregious sin on HN, for some reason.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- boopmaster 6y agoThere’s a lot going on in that complaint. This US based employee approved the app in the Chinese App Store, and it was not the first screw up they had made. I’m sympathic to a lousy job experience at any employer. While it sounds more like a DEI issue at heart, and possibly a training or hiring failure, I’m doubtful that the courts would not side with Apple here.
- drewwwwww 6y agothe plaintiff’s core allegation is that the other “screw ups” were concocted (or at least exaggerated in severity) as a retaliation for approving the app and/or discussing the situation with peers.
- berdario 6y agoI haven't looked into the other screw ups, but I basically agree with everything in the snippet of the complaint that appears in the article, except one thing: "it should remain on the App Store as a matter of free speech" Free speech is a matter for the government, not for private business decisions... If you as an employee are pushing back against your employer because of "free speech", you're going to have a bad time (i.e. risk losing the job, as it happened). That said, I'm curious about this Guo Media, and the first thing I found when looking that up is: https://huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/steve-bannon-guo-wengui-gtv-media-sec-probe_n_5f3eed87c5b697824f964ed9 https://huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/steve-bannon-guo-wengui-g... "Free speech" is often used as a fig leaf for the alt right, so this is unfortunately unsurprising :/ I wish good luck to Trieu Pham, even if personally I wouldn't have picked Guo Media as the hill to die on
- sneak 6y agoIt's Apple's fault that they've built a system that is so perfectly suited for state-mandated censorship. They had to have known this would have happened. The lack of sideloading on iOS doesn't just protect users from malware: it protects repressive governments from criticism and protects corrupt organizations with political power from reporting and attempts at organization or reform. Furthermore, it's reprehensible for Apple to tout their commitment to human rights, but also appoint themselves the decider that you're not permitted to choose to see nudity in the apps on a device that you purchased. Only assholes decide for other competent adults what they're not allowed to watch, see, or read. Inserting rent-seekers hellbent on surveillance into every single little purchase we engage in on a daily basis is the worst thing that's happened to our society in a very long time.
- cageface 6y agoYes this exactly. If Apple insists that they have absolute control over what you can install on hardware that you ostensibly own then they also bear the blame for for kowtowing to every jurisdiction's whims. The ability to install the software we want on hardware we own should be every user's irrevocable right. Wrap it in three layers of warnings and opt-in dialogs if necessary to protect people but it needs to be possible. Maybe you trust Apple enough to decide what software can run but are you also comfortable giving this power to whoever is in power in your government at any given time? It's an extremely dangerous precedent.
- andi999 6y agoThe full text PDF linked at the top is interesting. I am wondering what bone apple had to pick with him.
- zepto 6y agoTake a look at some of the comments which explore the nature of the App. Also, frankly it’s not actually his decision to make. If someone doesn’t want to carry out company policy, they can choose to resign or expect to be fired. This looks like someone with a political agenda who is using this situation to advance it.
- andi999 6y agoThe app was just the final issue, in the document it starts with a manager ordering him to work slower and then another complaining about his slowness.
- zepto 6y agoMaybe. But this is someone who is choosing to fight for a far right app created by a financer of Steve Bannon to remain in the store on the grounds of free speech. How certain are you that everything in the complaint is true?
- FpUser 6y agoExcept for a couple of short contracts I am trying to ignore mobile app market. I just can't stand that I need anybody's permission to install / sell my products. Instant critical updates delivery that saved my bacon quite a few times is also out of question on mobile. I am aware about sideloading on Android but how many regular users are willing to follow through on that model.
- LeicaLatte 6y agoInformation control is no different from border control. Is it wrong for China to enforce it via Apple?
- objclxt 6y ago> Information control is no different from border control. Well, no, it's quite different. A border can be controlled, information cannot. East Germany could stop people crossing the border to West Germany (at least, those who weren't willing to take the risk of being shot at). They couldn't stop West German radio stations being broadcast back across the border. Information control isn't anything like border control, because information is permeable to your physical border. You can shoot-to-kill people crossing your borders, but good luck doing that with electromagnetic radiation. At best you can jam it or attempt to control the flow domestically (by, for example, banning radios), but in both cases it's easily circumvented.
- LeicaLatte 6y agoBorder control should, apparently, exclude information control. Why?
- jedberg 6y agoI think I just realized while Apple doesn't allow side loading apps. Because if you could side load apps, then Chinese citizens could side load apps, and Apple would no longer be favored in China. This complaint makes me feel like it's as simple as that. Apple just fears China.
- Lammy 6y ago> Apple doesn't allow side loading apps HN readers might be surprised at the extent of modded-iOS-app communities (just like APK communities for Androids) that manage to exist within the meager 7-day signing window Apple allows a free-tier developer account. Tools like AltStore and ReProvision are the standard for sideloading and renewing (respectively) legitimate jailbreak-entrypoint apps: https://github.com/rileytestut/AltStore https://github.com/rileytestut/AltStore https://github.com/Matchstic/ReProvision https://github.com/Matchstic/ReProvision Even for un-jailbroken devices there are entire alternative ecosystems based around sideloading modded/pirated apps. They are obviously full of pirated stuff, usually work by abusing an enterprise cert from an endless list of Chinese companies (not insinuating anything bad, just firsthand experience), and they probably have some nasty malware mixed in here and there as well. Zero endorsement for any of these examples from the first page of a DDG search, but you get the idea: https://www.tutuapp.com/pc/ https://www.tutuapp.com/pc/ https://iphonecake.com/ https://iphonecake.com/ https://sideload.tweakboxapp.com/ https://sideload.tweakboxapp.com/ https://ipaspot.app/ https://ipaspot.app/ https://www.valuewalk.com/2019/04/spotify-up-tweakbox-users-tutuapp-lite/ https://www.valuewalk.com/2019/04/spotify-up-tweakbox-users-...
- Veen 6y agoThat's a possible reason, but do you have any evidence that it's the real reason beyond it being vaguely plausible while making Apple look as bad as possible. Preventing side-loading improves iOS device security, which is just as plausible as your theory.
- jedberg 6y ago> do you have any evidence that it's the real reason This lawsuit. > Preventing side-loading improves iOS device security Yes, this is true. Welding the doors to your house shut also improve security. But it does so at the expense of usability. There is a reasonable trade off between usability and security and Apple makes an unreasonable choice.
- dang 6y agoThe submitted URL was https://mjtsai.com/blog/2020/12/31/fired-app-reviewer-sues-apple/ https://mjtsai.com/blog/2020/12/31/fired-app-reviewer-sues-a..., which points to several other articles. Of those, Volokh seems to have the most information, so we've changed the link above to that. If there's a better URL, we can change it again.
- lph 6y agoSeems like a stretch to claim that approving an app on behalf of an employer is protected political activity, but is this really so different from the pharmacist who refuses to fill a birth control prescription on religious grounds?
- Animats 6y agoChina's attempts to censor the rest of the world have become a big deal.[1] Hollywood caved in some time back. The NBA caved. Now Apple. There was an attempt in 2012 to pass the "Global Online Freedom Act of 2012", prohibiting US companies from assisting foreign censorship operations. Didn't pass. Apple's history of censorship is strange and amusing. They have, at various times, caved in to both China and Russia. Sending the word "Taiwan" from an iPhone with a Chinese country code at one time crashed iPHones. [2] [1] https://fair.org/home/chinese-censorship-of-us-media-new-spin-on-an-old-tactic/ https://fair.org/home/chinese-censorship-of-us-media-new-spi... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Apple https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_Apple
- thefounder 6y agoI'm still amazed how many people(myself included) accept the Apple's censorship and planned obsolence/drm policies.
- still_grokking 6y agoHow could possibly something like a "Global Online Freedom Act" pass? This would only mean that US companies would get banned from most countries shortly thereafter. I don't think US companies would like that.