11 ms·
>The scarcity of block chain space has led people to re-invent every last feature of the banks they thought they were going to be escaping. This is a pretty fu
by Barrin92 6y ago
>The scarcity of block chain space has led people to re-invent every last feature of the banks they thought they were going to be escaping.
This is a pretty funny point because every time I go on twitter and see people talk about crypto, what they're essentially having is a discussion about public policy, and often they seem to try to reinvent institutions that already exist without even knowing it. From market-makers, exchanges, insurance and so on, precisely as the author points out all the dreaded middlemen they were trying to avoid
- darawk 6y agoThis isn't a very good criticism. Lots of new things recapitulate the structures they are replacing in many ways, while improving on them in just one or a few areas. The fact that ground is being retread is not itself a criticism or a sign of a lack of innovation. Yes, Bitcoin requires many of the same structures as traditional finance. That does not make them equivalent. Traditional finance does not allow you sovereignty over your money. Bitcoin has central custody, sure. But it's opt in. That's what makes it different. You may or may not care about this property, but its undeniable that it's novel in the digital realm, and empirically many people do care about it.
- ineedasername 6y agoIt's not that the structures are inherently bad, it's that such structures are, philosophically, the exact sorts of things that many early (and current) proponents of crypto wanted to avoid. In that sense bitcoin hasn't failed as a system in & of itself, but it has failed to achieve the philosophical goals of those people. Bitcoin & crypto also might not be sovereign in origin but they have plenty of sovereign influence, basically as much as any sovereignty wants to impose on it. Especially as entities like the SEC & IRS come to terms with it, it will be just as vulnerable to government control as fiat currency. This is especially the case because any wide-spread adoption will require adoption by large financial institutions, which cannot avoid regulatory regimes of their local jurisdictions. From the US government's standpoint, US citizens holding bitcoins is not much different than US citizens holding Euros. How that money enters into the US economy & interacts with US financial institutions or changes hands from person to person are basically subject to the same rules & regulations. If you're conducting a a transaction in excess of $10,000 then whatever mechanism facilitates that will still be subject to CTR's, and any "suspicious" transaction of lower limits will still be reported, by law, to the government. Basically, if you want to convert bitcoin to the local currency to buy something, you'll need to use some sort of off-ramp that will be a regulatory bottleneck. Want to build a "shadow" economy purely driven by crypto exchange? Well, you'll still have to deal with the IRS knocking on your door & saying "You have things of value that you are performing work to receive. We don't care what currency or form you received them in, you received things of value. Give us our cut." In short, it doesn't matter that it wasn't created by a sovereign authority: The control a sovereign authority can exert over it is, contrary to many of the most philosophical hopes for crypto, indistinguishable from sovereign currency in everything but name & source of origin. Let me be clear though: I'm not anti-crypto. I'm probably a little ambivalent, and a little optimistic that it might replace high-friction mechanisms that exist in current financial infrastructure. What I do believe is that crypto cannot both go mainstream and fulfill the philosophical hopes that many had wanted for it.
- darawk 6y ago> It's not that the structures are inherently bad, it's that such structures are, philosophically, the exact sorts of things that many early (and current) proponents of crypto wanted to avoid. In that sense bitcoin hasn't failed as a system in & of itself, but it has failed to achieve the philosophical goals of those people. I'm not sure that's quite true. Decentralization was a goal, but it wasn't necessarily the case that that decentralization had to pervade all use of the currency. The values of the ecosystem are that more decentralization is better - that's true, so Satoshi et al would have preferred to make decentralized transactions sufficiently scalable not to require centralized exchanges, but I don't think that it has fundamentally failed in its goals just because a lot of transactions happen in bank-like entities. The point is that users have the power to do it in a decentralized way. > Bitcoin & crypto also might not be sovereign in origin but they have plenty of sovereign influence, basically as much as any sovereignty wants to impose on it. Especially as entities like the SEC & IRS come to terms with it, it will be just as vulnerable to government control as fiat currency. This is especially the case because any wide-spread adoption will require adoption by large financial institutions, which cannot avoid regulatory regimes of their local jurisdictions. From the US government's standpoint, US citizens holding bitcoins is not much different than US citizens holding Euros. How that money enters into the US economy & interacts with US financial institutions or changes hands from person to person are basically subject to the same rules & regulations. If you're conducting a a transaction in excess of $10,000 then whatever mechanism facilitates that will still be subject to CTR's, and any "suspicious" transaction of lower limits will still be reported, by law, to the government. This just isn't accurate. It may in fact be vulnerable to some level of government influence, due to the fiat gateways involved. But it's just not true that it's equivalent to fiat in that regard. Cryptocurrencies will never be as regulable as fiat is, and I think it's pretty clear that that's true, given how widely they've been adopted by cyber criminals and darknet markets. Governments have been completely unable to prevent their use in this way, and will continue to be unable to do so. It's true from a legal perspective that the government views it just like foreign currency (actually, in the US, they treat it like property, not currency, but we can ignore that for now). But from a technical perspective, its very very different. The technical differences make it very difficult to regulate. Think about music. When music got digitized, its legal status didn't change. It was just as illegal to download an MP3 as it was to steal a CD. What changed is the topology of the technical landscape underneath it, and that is what made all the difference. > Basically, if you want to convert bitcoin to the local currency to buy something, you'll need to use some sort of off-ramp that will be a regulatory bottleneck. Want to build a "shadow" economy purely driven by crypto exchange? Well, you'll still have to deal with the IRS knocking on your door & saying "You have things of value that you are performing work to receive. We don't care what currency or form you received them in, you received things of value. Give us our cut." I think you are under-weighting the significance of friction. In principle, sure, the IRS might do that - but we don't live in principle. We live in a physical world with resource constraints. If you make something harder to accomplish, it may no longer be economical to do it. Collecting income taxes from people that keep their money in crypto who don't want to pay them will never be as efficient as doing so in the fiat banking system.
- lottin 6y ago> Traditional finance does not allow you sovereignty over your money. What do you mean sovereignty? Do you mean property? Traditional finance is not only compatible with the ownership of money, it relies entirely on it!
- darawk 6y agoI mean sovereignty in the sense of actual control. When you put your money in a bank account, you give up control of it to that bank. The money may legally be yours, but they physically possess it, and can keep you from transacting with it whenever they wish. I in fact just had this issue the other day. I have a company, and due to a clerical error with the state its registered in, my company was listed as being "not in good standing", and because of this, Wells Fargo froze my accounts and wouldn't let me transact for two weeks until I got the whole thing cleared up. That could never happen with a crypto wallet, because I have actual sovereignty over my crypto wallets, nobody can freeze them for any reason.
- lottin 6y agoOk, that's not sovereignty. Sovereignty refers to the highest authority in a territory. Yes, in traditional banking, customers cede control of the money they deposit with the bank to the bank. They do not cede the ownership of that money, which they continue to own. Now, transferring money without making a deposit is possible with any currency, not just BTC. You make it sound like it's a feature of BTC but it's not. It's a feature of the financial industry, whether it provides this particular service.
- darawk 6y agoHighest authority means actual physical control. When your money is in a bank, the highest authority is the bank. Not you. This is the literal definition of sovereignty, and it's used in many digital contexts, not just crypto. E.g. 'self-sovereign identity'. This isn't a word usage made up by crypto, it's quite common, and this is its meaning.
- tyre 6y agoYour inalterable blockchain either dies young or lives long enough to see a hard fork.
- idclip 6y agoIronic isnt it
- hombre_fatal 6y agoI don't see the irony. The point is that Bitcoin has introduced an actual "digital cash" currency without institutional/governmental middlemen. That institutions can be built on top of that, and that some people want such institutions, doesn't change the novel utility of finally having a currency that functions like digital cash. It's like saying it's ironic that people use physical USD for anonymous p2p transactions when USD banking systems have KYC laws. It's a non sequitur.
- oblio 6y agoWhat's "digital cash" in this context? What does it offer extra compared to regular cash and online payments?
- zik 6y agoWith cash you can hand it to another person in payment. With conventional digital payments you request a trusted intermediary (your bank) to transfer that value to them. What if you don't trust banks but still want to be able to pay people? Bitcoin was born in the Global Financial Crisis when the world was discovering the massive scam which the financial services industry had perpetrated, causing the whole problem. People wanted a way to do transactions without having to trust institutions which demonstrably couldn't be trusted. Hence Bitcoin which acts like digital cash with no trusted intermediary.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoWell, take the upsides of cash (e.g. don't need to open a bank, prove residence, etc.) and now add the ability to exchange it digitally without the pointless gatekeeping of large corporations like Paypal.
- rjurney 6y agoWho will be the largest Bitcoin vendor because they are trusted.
- 6y ago
- jbob2000 6y agoIt’s like refactoring a codebase without understanding the problems behind the current implementation, and then acting surprised when the code is just as ugly.
- smabie 6y agoI agree with you mostly, but market makers on exchanges are not middle-men, they are simply market participants like any other. Conceptually, there's no difference between a professional market maker and a individual who puts a limit order on the book.
- option 6y agonothing wrong with reinventing the old stuff as long as the new ones are better.
- mrjin 6y agoWell, obviously the designer of bitcoin or any so called cryptos did not take a serious thought why centralized financial authorities are there. They believed books kept by those financial authorities are the real problems and thus they made the books public and introduced the mining process. The real problems have never been about records, they are really about the integrity of the transactions, which in turn pointing to the trustworthiness of the counterpart. By making books public can never ever resolve those trustworthiness issue and actually introduced more problems such as everyone is storing heaps of info which does not concern them at all, 51% attack etc. To establish trust between parties in the transactions, as you mentioned, market-makers, exchanges etc came into play, which defeats the purpose: to decentralize by introducing other centralized authorities which are actually less trustworthy than current ones. In other words, catch-22.
- louwrentius 6y agoYes, I see the irony. So much talk about the benefit of crypto currencies seems - in my eyes at least - based on a fundamental misunderstanding of how societies work. And most of all: you can’t replace trust with tech.
- xapata 6y ago> fundamental understanding From the tone of your statement, I think you meant mis-understanding. I'll add also a misunderstanding of macroeconomics and a rejection of empiricism. The cryptocurrency folks read a bit too much of von Mises.
- louwrentius 6y agoYes, sorry.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> And most of all: you can’t replace trust with tech. I'd say, you can (Bitcoin is one of many recent exercises of replacing trust with math). But it's not worth the price. Or, put another way, trust is a ridiculously powerful optimization that enabled humanity to form societies in the first place. It's very similar to how introducing a central node into a network reduces communication costs from O(n^2) to O(n). In the general case, it's stupid to not take advantage of it. I consider Bitcoin to be the closest we've came so far to expressing trust in units of energy. POW shows us how much computation has to happen to achieve mathematical guarantees in lieu of trust. Somebody could probably derive some upper and lower bounds on the energy costs of trust in terms of information theory. I'd love to read such a paper.
- briatx 6y agoBitcoin doesn't solve any trust problem outside of how many bitcoins are in each wallet. Even in the very basic ecommerce use case: buyer purchases item online with bitcoin. The buyer must necessarily trust the vendor to deliver. There's no recourse outside of the good graces of the vendor. There's no chargebacks or third party mediation. Thus Bitcoin actually reverses the risk assumed by online purchases from the vendor to the buyer. This is the reason why Bitcoin is a failure outside of niche grey and black market concerns. It is far worse for the consumer than existing solutions that isolate them from transaction risk, and will usually kick back a small percentage in cash back.
- ab3rC1te 6y agoYou know I thought about doing some type of crypto, but after finding out you have to pay to even establish a certificate and everything else. Shit your right back to being controlled by your balls to be recognized as a legitimate digital coin system. Just like SSL certs, yes you can create one, but will your browser say its authenticated, nope! Done with the entire system. Live in a tent and live off the land.
- duxup 6y agoBitcoin has done a great job educating me as to why we have the rules we have regarding financial orgs, and currency. Every new scam or venture that runs into regulatory issues is a fascinating trip that often results in "well yeah that's a terrible idea..."
- echelon 6y ago> re-invent every last feature of the banks they thought they were going to be escaping. > centralized mining activity in a country where centralization means it's effectively owned by exactly the kind of government most people thought they DIDN'T want looking up their butts and where the people who that government allows to "own" this whole business work together as a cartel. It looks to me like an attack on the reserve currency status of the USD. It's not a sure bet, but China is willing to tolerate it in the event it succeeds. Chins holds the mining power, so they effectively win if Bitcoin takes over. It's easy for them to clamp down and control. > This is a pretty funny point because every time I go on twitter and see people talk about crypto, what they're essentially having is a discussion about public policy, and often they seem to try to reinvent institutions that already exist The Bitcoin early adopters want to replace the incumbent systems with their own so that they can enrich themselves. Now that Bitcoin has had time to play out, it feels like an attack on USD with way too many downsides.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoBut in bitcoin they aren't mandatory and there are essentially no borders. I'm not a fan of it personally but you can cut out the middlemen if you like. As to if that will be the case in the future as more and more regulations (and criminal precedents are set) are added on then it because much murkier.
- harwoodleon 6y agoThere’s a problem with this argument. The middlemen are being created again yes, but they are being replaced with mostly open-sourced software solutions like smart contacts and auditable ledgers. Bitcoin started the party, but the other projects are now finding their feet with technology that uses open consensus as the basis for open, functional, opt-in systems. Look at Gitcoin, this would not have been possible without the Bitcoin project gaining traction.
- clemens2000 6y agoThe problem is not with Bitcoin. The problem is the 1mb block size cap. The block size cap restricts the number of transactions that can be processed in a block. It's an artificial restriction of supply. When demand increases the price (tx fee) goes (way) up. There is some magical thinking within the Bitcoin community that only a fixed block size will prevent centralization. I have never heard a solid argument to back that up. Everything in technology is growing exponentially (cpu power, network throughput, disc space). So in relative terms the block size is decreasing exponentially. Technically Bitcoin mining should get exponentially more decentralized. This is not happening. If we let the block size grow at the same rate as the surrounding tech, or at least at some rate, the supply problem would go away. The transaction fee would go down and we would not need to use flaky and centralizing tech like the lightning network that mimics the financial system that we wanted to escape. For a long time this was a theory. However several forks of Bitcoin have tried it in practice (eg BCH, LTC, BSV). Over several years these experiments have shown that if you stop restricting the block size you get a system that is dependable, cheap to use, and scalable. My wish for 2021 is for people in Bitcoin to reconsider if they have made a mistake in restricting the blockchain. I hope they will have the courage to change their minds in light of data.