26 ms·
How bad is your Spotify?
- MikeWazowski 6y ago> Spotify limiting how many people can use this app at once, so you'll need to wait or try again later. Patiently anticipating how bad my taste is
- dbrgn 6y agoI'm a bit wary of logging in. Does Spotify provide OAuth with fine-grained control, i.e. will the page only get access to the music history or could it in theory change playlists and billing information?
- as-j 6y agoYes. When you click auth you can see the permissive it asks for. Which is profile and history.
- xav_authentique 6y agoIt looks like they request these permissions: user-top-read, playlist-read-private, playlist-read-collaborative and they also gets your your name, username and profile picture.
- rapnie 6y agoSeems a neat way to collect information for their startup. Maybe a Spotify competitor, or a datamarket for selling people's music preferences.
- cpmsmith 6y agoThe Pudding is, per the footer on that page, "a digital publication that explains ideas debated in culture with visual essays". It's been around for a few years already. https://pudding.cool/archives/ https://pudding.cool/archives/
- as-j 6y agolol that’s really cute. Spotify permissions it asks for make sense. It was really confused by all the kid music I play. Why so much Raffi? Their training set must not include people with children. :)
- jedimastert 6y agoI was asked > "You listen to 'Super Simple Songs' a lot. I mean A LOT. Are you ok?"
- checker 6y agoThis looks really cool, but I wish it displayed some sort of lip service guarantee about not preserving my data. As-is I'm unable to determine whether this is a fun project or a kind of trojan horse to grab as much Spotify data as possible. (and obviously at the end of the day it comes down to trust)
- throwbacktictac 6y agoSad that this thought pattern is a thing. I was also too paranoid to sign in with Spotify.
- alkonaut 6y agoAny service that has third party integrations like this should let me get a token that is just valid e.g 24 hours.
- Lendal 6y agoInteresting. Judging by the people sitting next to me in traffic or at the beach, most people are perfectly fine with letting the entire world know what kind of music they enjoy listening to. Even when the rest of the world doesn't care and really really doesn't want to hear it.
- fooblat 6y agoBy my reading of their privacy policy, it seems they will keep data they collect as part of a story or project. Personally, I never use anything that asks me to sign in with something else. My data is my business and IMO there are plenty of ways to get a laugh without compromising privacy.
- etherio 6y agoThis is hilarious... > You are 26% basic. You're trying to be cool with Kapitan Korsakov, but your favorites are the same as everybody else's.. > Your spotify was please-read-my-manuscript-walmart-hawaiian-shirt-sitting-alone-in-the-cafeteria bad. Ouch. Really interesting project by all means. I hope they release the source - I'm curious about how it was built. Edit: This same link was posted 11 hours ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513886 here and is not at all getting the same popularity. Anyone got ideas?
- dkersten 6y ago> Your taste is so obscure that's so cool I bet you're super interesting.. After it picked the one very popular song I listen to in order to laugh at me for listening to non obscure things, ignoring the piles of weird random crap I normally listen to that nobody ever seems to know. Funny but not very accurate. Overall all I got a good laugh though.
- etherio 6y agoExactly what happened to me also
- mhh__ 6y agoI think the microtonal stuff I listen to is probably too unpopular to even have reviews to go on.
- squeaky-clean 6y agoIt picked out Brendan Byrnes as one of my obscure artists, though he is probably one of the more popular microtonal artists. It was able to pick out my own band as one of my "obscure artists", so I don't think "too unpopular" is a thing for it, haha.
- johnwyles 6y agoCool... you ok? [lol, jk.] [yeah, why?]
- Zealotux 6y agoHaven't used Spotify in over a year now so it'll judge an older me, but it apparently has my favorite Melon as a reference of good taste so it can't be all that bad.
- mahmoudhossam 6y agoIsn't that a younger you though?
- mhh__ 6y agoWell, it absolutely hated me (Possibly because I have one massive playlist) despite noticing enormous amounts of Death Grips on my profile, and recommending me a Neutral Milk Hotel song at the end (which I was quite impressed with although it could've been a lucky guess)
- DC-3 6y agoIt asked me to listen to a clip of Oh Comely and asked me if I liked it or not lmao.
- moojd 6y agoAs soon as I saw melon I knew I was in for a ride. > sad-knowledge-worker bad > wear-carhartts-to-your-desk-job > remember-when-williamsburg-was-cool bad I've never felt so roasted haha
- mahmoudhossam 6y agoI wouldn't call it AI, but I had a good laugh so thanks for that. I revoked access to the Spotify API shortly after use, and it didn't seem to do any harm to my account.
- hankchinaski 6y agothat is amazing
- andybp85 6y agoOr, how to get your app rate limited in one easy step lol. Patiently waiting... The concept of "objectively good music" is hilarious enough that this is already a win in my book.
- andybp85 6y agoAaaannd it's down. I can't wait until this comes back up so I can send it to a bunch of my ex-bandmates lol.
- mhh__ 6y ago> Oh wow Taim and Viper! Your taste is so obscure that's so cool I bet you're super interesting.. It's vaguely sentient. It has some really bizarre opinions about certain songs - Guthrie Govan is basically a god amongst men for guitar players but it absolutely hates his work. A final note: I assume this is a joke, but please don't try to objectively rank music.
- jedimastert 6y ago> Guthrie Govan is basically a god amongst men for guitar players but it absolutely hates his work. They apparently just took public reviews, but I geniuinelycan not imagine someone disliking Guthrie Govan. Maybe the score is also inversely proportional to popularity/# of reviews found? It'd fit into the hipster gag
- mhh__ 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaqbbjciqsE&list=RD6MexmN9vFlM&index=20 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaqbbjciqsE&list=RD6MexmN9vF... Like/Dislike ratio of 6600/98, they must be extrapolating from some bad data (or possibly extrapolating from the genre not being particularly melon-y). Excuse me, I need to go and practice...
- chrismeller 6y agoI don’t think I’ve ever been insulted that much by a computer before...
- andybp85 6y agoThat's how I felt when I was learning to compile stuff from source.
- chrismeller 6y agoThat’s more like the computer just slept with your sister even though you told it not to and now you’re horrified and no longer friends...
- tra3 6y agoHah, I'm always a bit self conscious about playing my music "in public", this took it to a new high...
- eecks 6y agoDoes it do anything but gives some hipster insults? My activity seems to have messed it up: "You only listen to Obama-era jams like Sleepy Brown Noise by White Noise for Reading" err.. How do I delete my data?
- dvtrn 6y ago*ponders if "Obama-era jams" means music that came out during the Obama-administration, or music Obama would have jammed to when he was younger Both have a lot of potential, as it would seem the former President and I have very similar musical tastes (that is: a very strong love for Stevie Wonder)
- Jamie9912 6y agoHuh, I didn't get the zoomer memes this thing spat at me
- nkrisc 6y agoIt used "stan" as both a noun and a verb and I have no idea what it means.
- laputan_machine 6y agoI think it means 'excessive fan', from Eminem - Stan
- rodiger 6y agoStalker + fan specifically
- _whiteCaps_ 6y agoVerbing weirds nouns.
- pimlottc 6y agoTo be a “Stan” is to be a truly diehard fan, bordering on obsession. The term comes from the Eminem song of the same name. It can be used as a noun or a verb.
- whymauri 6y agoJust some fun history, but "stan" is actually a millennial portmanteau courtesy of Eminem [0]. It came out around the time the older Gen Z's were born, actually. Although, yes, it has seen a revival amongst Gen Z. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stan_(song) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stan_(song)
- rmb177 6y agoThank you for the morning laugh!
- borishn 6y agoHi, I am collecting data for my own purposes, and in exchange for your data I'll give you some snarky comments. Sincerely, AI
- Dumblydorr 6y agoSpotify mobile has weird issues for me. I'll be playing podcast A, then when I switch to podcast B, the display on the bottom gets stuck on A. I can still use buttons, but unless I restart the app, it will always keep podcast A on display. It'll even keep the timestamp I was on for A, even if I start a new podcast fresh. Mildly annoying... In terms of recs, it does ok. There are weeks when every discover Weekly track is bizarre ambient music or very quiet music, like I'm supposed to be a spa owner. Then sometimes it has delivered great tracks. But as a musician, it's very rare for me to find new gems, I've heard of so many via friends, class, YT, etc. Overall, spotify is great, but the app and algorithm could use improvement.
- jedimastert 6y agoI love that the first pass for "objectively good music" is Fantano. They know their audience.
- pimlottc 6y agoAh, thanks, that was the one logo I didn’t recognize.
- dx87 6y agoI was hoping it was a questionnaire about how bad Spotify recommendations are. I have no idea why Spotify feels the need to clutter my recommendations with radio stations like "Rap Caviar" and "Music for when you know you're the bad bitch", meanwhile it doesn't show me new releases for music I actually listen to because of all the irrelevant suggestions taking up space. I ended up creating a new account because apparently listening to a couple of podcast episodes means you want half your page filled with recommendations for shows on the same topic.
- sk5t 6y agoSpotify really wants people to listen to podcasts... it's oh so much easier to wedge some advertising into podcasts.
- BostonEnginerd 6y agoI’m really bummed at the amount of effort which is going into building walled gardens for podcasts. Yet another amazing thing on the open web which is dying. I keep hoping that someone will crack the micropayment idea and kill advertising on the web.
- smichel17 6y ago> I keep hoping that someone will crack the micropayment idea and kill advertising on the web. Trying! https://wiki.snowdrift.coop https://wiki.snowdrift.coop Ok -- technically not micropayments and technically killing advertising is not a goal. But many of us are personally against advertising, and a viable alternative for funding free/libre/open works would certainly put a dent in advertising coffers.
- thr0w__4w4y 6y agoYou're right, but I'm grateful anyway. I used to listen to Joe Rogan's podcast sometimes (on Overcast, which is awesome)... since he moved to the vastly inferior Spotify platform, I don't listen to him at all. The platform is pure shit for podcasts, so I've cut Rogan out of my life, and saved many hours per week in the process. Not that his $100M is going to notice my absence!
- chrismeller 6y agoI wish I could share my results.
- frankzander 6y agoWTF? ... I didn't get it. What's so great about it? What is moonshine-bommer bad?
- timlod 6y agoI listened to a number of audio books by the same author during a road trip last year, this tells me I listen to this author to an uncomfortable extent ;) I believe it focuses quite a lot on artists or tracks listened to a lot, and judging from the covers it shows it selects some top N songs for its analysis. Fun stuff though!
- pbronez 6y agoSo fun! My score plummeted when I answered the interactive questions. Hit a bug where it asked me “do you recognize this song?” And tried to play some audio, but nothing actually played. (Safari on iOS; could have been caused by an ad blocker)
- Jaxan 6y agoI also couldn’t hear anything. (Also safari iOS)
- f0rmatfunction 6y agoHappened to me but it was because the mute switch was set to vibrate. Turning the switch let the song play. I guess unless the ringer is on iOS controls whether Safari can play audio?
- torgard 6y agoIt played Don't Stop Believing by Journey, and then made fun of me for liking it loool
- Barrin92 6y agoMy score was pretty okay until it played me don't stop believing and I liked it, hard to argue with that one It also absolutely disliked the amount of Daft Punk I listened too, and called me pretentious for listening to Periphery, this was hilarious.
- rednum 6y agoLooking at title I thought it was rant about product quality. But it's not, so I'll provide mine. Since 2013 when I've started paying for Spotify it has turned from one of my favourite apps to one of those I hate most. On my previous Android phone it would freeze every other day when there was no internet. Why? Who knows. Could be related to me using SD card, or could be something else. The phone wasn't very old, but still on many days it was basically unusable. Somehow I was gifted a new phone and it kind of works. I say kind of, because sometimes when I click on a downloaded album it doesn't work - no tracks display. Why? Who knows. And few days ago something bugged out and tracks suddenly started setting volume to max. Apparently it's known issue that appears occasionally. Why? Who knows. Happily I wasn't wearing headphones so I did not get hearing damage. But who knows, maybe this will happen again. There is also desktop app which severely crippled local file support few years ago. That really sucked for me, because I record a lot of my own stuff and I want to listen to music in one place. I don't know if this was fixed since then because I pretty much switched to using web app, which usually works. There is also iPad app which seems to routinely delete stuff I have downloaded do my iPad; and sometimes it also freeze in offline mode when browsing my library. At this point I didn't even try filing a ticket with support, I lost hope of them fixing this. I suppose soon I will simply stop paying them and make switch to something else. EDIT: Why post this here? I hope people at Spotify see that submission about Spotify is on top of HN, and maybe, hopefully, someone sees my comments and thinks twice about setting 2021 OKRs and put some capacity into improving the app reliability. I know, this is optimistic, but who knows.
- city41 6y agoI canceled Spotify and switched to Amazon Music Unlimited, primarily due to how buggy Spotify is. AMU does have one annoying bug I've found (that seems to have emerged after the recent redesign) but other than that it's been totally flawless. Reliable apps are such a joy to use. I feel this side of software is not appreciated enough anymore.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoTo add to the list of complaints... The Chromecast streaming feature is also broken. It will randomly pause in the middle of playback. This bug has existed for months and months. My configuration is very vanilla. Common phone, TV with built-in Chromecast, no other devices you could stream to on the network, stable internet connection...
- m000 6y ago> You are 6% basic. Acrimonious and Inherit Disease? Where do you even find this shit?. Yup. That's me.
- wjvdhoek 6y ago> You are 2% basic. Wombripper and Blindfolded and Led to the Woods? Where do you even find this shit? m000, you are my new best friend.
- merovigiam 6y ago>You are 3% basic. Lost Symphony and VIRTA? Where do you even find this shit?. Liked those two, try these two.
- tossthere 6y agoFunny, but I was hoping this might provide some insight into why my Spotify is so bad, even by my own tastes. Spotify constantly queues and recommends songs to me that are so bad, I can’t even imagine how there could possibly exist any data indicating that any significant sample of listeners has ever enjoyed hearing them. Spotify has 5+ years of my listening history, and orders of magnitude more data from listeners all over the world, and yet every time I set it to recommend anything to me I just sit there pressing “skip” repeatedly until I give up. I always blamed myself, thought I was just becoming old and curmudgeonly in my 30s. But yesterday I finally discovered the problem isn’t with me. I switched to Apple Music, and it queued up 50 songs I’d never heard, and I enjoyed almost all of them. I can use my HomePod now, too. I’m really loving Apple Music so far, highly recommend it to anyone who thinks their Spotify account is permanently broken like mine was.
- Sebb767 6y agoI always thought my recommendations are that broken because I listen to two very different music directions. For now, I fixed it by finding new Music via YouTube and using artists playlists etc.. Apple Music is probably no option, though, as I'm exclusively on Android.
- CloudButWhy 6y agoApple Music does have an Android app. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.apple.android.music https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.apple.andr...
- bartread 6y agoI've had the same problem. I like multiple genres but Spotify recommendations tend ever more toward overly harsh and angular electronica. I've tried retraining it multiple times by intentionally listening in a different direction but it never fixes the problem for long. Really frustrating.
- adley 6y agoAndroid does have an app for Apple Music though it's been years since I've used it. I was quite happy to pay the subscription fee but an update broke the whole app for me. It would play only a part of the song and then suddenly skip to the next one. My music taste also diverges drastically but Apple seemed to handle it quite well IIRC.
- unnouinceput 6y ago"I can't judge your music without seeing your Spotify. I mean, I can guess from your browsing history and cookies that your taste is rough, but that's all I'll say for now. Log in with Spotify" I never used Spotify, so he was doing this assessment from my cookies...from where? Youtube? I don't login there either, I just browse it. Anyway, that's my test on this.
- pimlottc 6y agoIt’s part of the joke; it insults your tastes no matter what they are.
- unnouinceput 6y agoOh, it's a joke? I didn't realized that. I thought that legit it does some AI stuff, not just randomly takes insults from a database and throw it at you.
- mratsim 6y agoThis is just a generic statement. Even in a container with no cookies it gives that statement.
- newsbinator 6y ago> Your spotify was horny-soundtrack-movie-soundtrack bad. I suppose because soundtracks and 90s dance remixes are what I listen to while programming. For soundtracks, I made a playlist that goes for 28hrs 30 mins full of: * Hans Zimmer * James Horner * John Williams * Alan Silvestri * David Newman * Danny Elfman * Christopher Tin * John Powell * Michael Giacchino * Ramin Djawadi * etc
- perryizgr8 6y agoDo you mind sharing that playlist? Sounds interesting :)
- iamd3vil 6y agoPlease do share the playlist. Will love to listen to it.
- newsbinator 6y agoHere's the playlist link: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/31buZEaVGW9f5Y4cEcKtbt?si=271eZpdNSwi0ddednDSVag https://open.spotify.com/playlist/31buZEaVGW9f5Y4cEcKtbt?si=...
- jdc 6y agoHave you heard much Vangelis? I think you'd probably like him.
- bartread 6y agoAppears to be dead (likely hugged). Getting an application error from Heroku.
- traveler01 6y agoThing sh on my music tastes...
- partyfaker1 6y agoSeems like it was hugged to death within half an hour, ah Hacker News.
- DJBunnies 6y agoBest to worst in the last few years.
- dqpb 6y agoExcellent data mining strategy.
- rodiger 6y agoNot sure how much damage / utility music activity + profile pic + username have.
- fbelzile 6y agoThe problem with this service is that most times, I don't chose what I listen to. Spotify does. I play music all day while working and I'd love to listen to more artists but most times, I'm stuck in the routine between my Release Radar on Fridays, Discovery Weekly on Monday, and Daily Mixes during the rest of the week. I add songs I like to a variety of personal playlists and sometimes I start a "Song Radio" for a song I like. But even then, I just end up getting the same songs Spotify seems to think I liked only because they've already played them to me over and over. Part of me wonders if their algorithm favours songs that costs them less in royalties... Playlists made by real people seem way better than any Spotify playlist, but they are difficult to discover. I'd love a feature that recommends me playlists from people that share my music tastes. One example, is a playlist called "Sexy Bath" by Nicoleta Tataru.
- ubermonkey 6y ago>The problem with this service is that most times, I don't chose what I listen to. Spotify does. This is one reason I never really clicked with it, or with Pandora, and why I have really enjoyed and used Apple Music. I'm not really interested in algorithmic playlists most of the time. I want what I want. I've been listening to music a long time; I can make connections on my own. ;)
- kwakja 6y agoI follow artists I like as a way of adding them to my library and "like" particular songs if I want them more accessible without having to go to the artist page. This is the way I listen to what I want (along with occasionally making playlists). I actually really enjoy the ability to effortlessly discover new music I never would have found otherwise that Spotify gives. The recommendation algorithm can be weird at times, but I hear liberal use of likes and dislikes helps though YMMV. As an aside, everyone else I've seen using Spotify tends to strictly build playlists and not really follow any artists. Not really sure what to make of that.
- ubermonkey 6y agoI don't mean to dismiss algorithmic discovery entirely, I should say. It's good if you want it. But mostly I play stuff I've gleaned from elsewhere (read that article, got a suggestion, whatever).
- makbol 6y agoDoes not work for me :(
- guidovranken 6y agoIt looks like the API is overloaded. With regards to taste, you usually need to find a suitable gateway into an unpopular genre to begin appreciating it. I always hated jazz until I turned 30, when I heard the melodic jazz of Avishai Cohen [1] and Phronesis [2], which led me to Eric Dolphy [3] and ultimately to free jazz outfits like Alexander von Schlippenbach and Peter Brotzmann. Having grown bored of everything else also helps. I recently cancelled my paid subscription to Spotify after 10 years and I use Youtube a lot now. The Spotify web app is not great and Youtube recommendations are a lot better in my opinion. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D6KYbpDditU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D6KYbpDditU [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lEw0swsmqYk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lEw0swsmqYk [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ln8naZpOJ0o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ln8naZpOJ0o
- runarberg 6y agoI’ve never had a spotify account and whenever I want to listen to a specific song I go to youtube, even if I had already bought the song on bandcamp. It is amazing, sometimes I discover for the first time that the song has an amazing music video, or—better yet—a fan made music video (see e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOeL6PYrU8M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOeL6PYrU8M). I can’t speak much for the recommendations, as I am fine with getting my recommendations from the radio and I prefer listening to whole CDs over playlists.
- mariusor 6y agoGreat suggestions. You might know them but I want to add Nik Bärtsch's Ronin[1], The Bad Plus[2], Nils Petter Molvær[3] and maybe some Ibrahim Maalouf[4]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8eL95fIQbk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8eL95fIQbk [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNI-2i6t7Zs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNI-2i6t7Zs [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edT6QGBmkrc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edT6QGBmkrc [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpg8jBFaj3c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpg8jBFaj3c
- simplify 6y agoThe Bad Plus (version 1) is such an unreasonable concentration of extraordinary talent, I haven't yet found anything else that comes close.
- welcometomiami 6y agoEw.
- Finnucane 6y agoIt doesn't seem to work with the desktop web player. I keep getting application errors.
- fireattack 6y agoIt doesn't care which player you use, does it? It just uses the API to read your account. For what it's worth, I exclusively use web player and it can get my data fine.
- Finnucane 6y agoOKay, I got it to work. It was disturbed that I listen to Daniel Kahn, and seemed to disapprove of listening to jazz. Zero percent basic, whatever that means. I guess it would be even worse, except that most of the Tzadik Records catalog isn't on Spotify.
- iamsaitam 6y agolong gone are the days of Pitchfork having "objective good taste"...
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoWell that was dumb. The entire thing was generic insults that could be applied to literally anything. > You are 0% basic. Have you considered there's a reason nobody listens to Perihelion Ship?. Screw you, they're great. Its Opeth with growling.
- animal_spirits 6y agoThats the point. Its designed to make fun of you
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoSo much AI for something that seems like a list of random insults that could be used in any situation. Why bother?
- animal_spirits 6y agoSome things can be done just for the fun of it
- brobinson 6y ago>Its Opeth with growling. So... Opeth before Heritage? lol
- scamify 6y agoSounds like a scam, no way am I connecting this to my Spotify account for them to leech out my personal data.
- Peskier 6y agoAnyone that wants to revoke the access this (or any previously used) app had to your spotify account, you can revoke access here: https://www.spotify.com/uk/account/apps/ https://www.spotify.com/uk/account/apps/
- humanistbot 6y agoYeah, the absolute lack of any privacy statements makes me wary. They get access to my entire music history and personal info, and just say that they won't post anything? Pass.
- aroman 6y agoTo be clear, it looks like the oauth scope they're requesting only allows read-only access to your account. So it's not like they could actually post on your behalf without additional express permissions, barring a Spotify API bug (as far as I understand). That said of course I agree they should have an explicit privacy policy regardless.
- samename 6y agoThe privacy policy is here: https://pudding.cool/privacy/ https://pudding.cool/privacy/
- solarkraft 6y ago> The Pudding collects your data so that we can: > Personalize stories > Create content for stories from reader-generated inputs Is this clear enough to forbid them from long term storage and passing the data on?
- IndySun 6y agoOnly if it is law; and even then, tough to police.
- dieg0 6y agoFor taste... We have colors
- ausbah 6y agoI know the bot is spewing nonsense when it starts insulting Queen, Van Halen, and Electric Light Orchestra very funny to get roasted by a machine though!
- Jaxan 6y agoThe insults don’t really work on me. It is also contradicting itself > Your spotify was jazz-everyones-heard-of-jazz-snob-never-turn-down-a-microphone bad. > You're too trendy for your own good. You know there's good music from before 2019, right?
- andybp85 6y ago> You are 1% basic. Jimkata and The Disco Biscuits? Where do you even find this shit?. That might be the highest compliment I've ever received!
- stemlord 6y agoClearly this is flawed solely based on the fact that its "objective" taste in allegedly non-basic music culture is learned from a corpus of Pitchfork reviews and subreddits. I guess that's part of the joke
- fireattack 6y agoThis is pretty funny, that "fuck marry kill" one throws me off a little bit though.
- rurban 6y agoThat's where it didn't respond anymore, and I had to kill it. The comments before were not enlightening enough, as I was music editor and dj on a local indie radio station, so it should be the other way round. The general taste sucks. Spotify's release radar only recommends shit, but nevertheless it's still the best to find the hidden gems. You won't find them on radio shows, other than KTRU or WFMU.
- bleeding 6y agoFirst time I've ever seen KTRU mentioned on the internet!
- rurban 6y agoKTRU is legend even in Europe. The strongest radio station that times, then destroyed by Rice and politics, now online only. The most uncompromosing programming, in the most corrupt state. Still no mp3's, only Vinyl. Legendary DJ's. I'm sure you don't know 95% of what they play. They hate all the major labels. They have a huge blacklist.
- boh 6y agoHonestly it's not too bad. I've pretty much tried every platform, including the ones no longer with us (RIP Rdio) and no Spotify isn't perfect, but it's pretty good in relative terms. Every platform, after some time, gets stuck in a recommend loop. If I listen to enough recommended tracks, it gives me more recommendations of similar tracks, but if I keep listening, the recommendations eventually just become the songs they've already recommended and they get recommended over and over. Spotify does that but their tree of recommendations has far more branches and playlists from users adds randomness to the recommend algorithm. The other platforms aren't as good with that (haven't tried Apple Music in a while though).
- ryneandal 6y agoIt really dragged me through the mud about all the German hip hop in my history when my Spotify was hacked checks calendar 4 years ago.
- jonplackett 6y ago> You are 25% basic. Yeah, you've got some obscure artists like Mojave 3, but your real top ones are ultra-mainstream like Taylor Swift.. You're stuck in the early 2010s. For you, music's been all downhill since Auli'i Cravalho made How Far I'll Go. Connecting my Spotify account to the Alexa my 3 year old has figured out how to use was a definite mistake.
- joshgel 6y agoRight, I'm not sure I should get dinged for letting my daughter listen to Baby Shark or Taylor Swift on repeat, but I guess that's life...
- young_unixer 6y agoIt says the same things that someone from 4chan's /mu/ would say about my music taste.
- mgh2 6y agoI have been logged out and the recovery process through email does not work. Basic error caused me to never use it again. I can start over with a new account, but I will lose all my bookmarked songs. QA did not bother to check this simple on boarding process for long time users.
- hans1729 6y agoLove how polarizing this is on HN. Half the comments are afraid of their precious data being leeched, other half is divided into "eww" and "this is amazing" :-) I'm stuck in "Loading your music library...Spotify limiting how many people can use this app at once [...] I'll try again in n seconds" limbo :(
- RiXeN 6y agoIf it doesn't work it might be because your privacy related browser plugins are blocking the Spotify requests. My privacy badger was blocking the request by default.
- blhack 6y agoHuh, I wonder if this is just a mad lib that is being used to gather information about people? It's sayin stuff like "You know music existed before 2019, right?", but also criticizing me for liking Stan Rogers, who died in 1983, Jay Z, and Trevor Hall, who seemed to peak in the early 2000s. Maybe I just haven't finished my coffee yet, but I was kindof hoping that this would actually use AI to figure out the musical variety of my listening history and suggest more people to listen to or something like that. Seems like it was just a bunch of mad libbed insults though.
- Agentlien 6y agoI had the same feeling. It made a spot on joke about how much AC/DC I listen to followed by a funny and relevant comment about too much Slipknot. But then it followed it up by calling me obsessed with two bands I can't even remember listening to in recent years. One of which I never really listened much to.
- semi-extrinsic 6y agoFor me also, the big punchline revolved around a song from the Dirty Dancing movie that I had to actually look up to find out if I've ever heard before. Now I'm a sucker for 80s synth-pop, don't get me wrong, but that specific song I'm 99.9% sure I've never actually played on Spotify. So it kinda seems like they've hard coded some insults with pop culture cross-references. The "AI" be like select case (person%likes) case ('80s-synth-pop') print *, 80s_pop_insult_char case ('single-specific-artist') print *, person%likes_artist//'-stan' ! (...) end select
- Talanes 6y agoYeah, it called out Todd Barry as one of the most listened to things, and I haven't listened to comedy on Spotify since I started listening to a weekly stable of podcasts like six years ago.
- nwsm 6y agoYeah some of it seemed tailored and accurate, specifically the insults at the end (They pegged my music perfectly with "stoner-frat-bro bad"), but most of it was just pulling most played artists and songs and making vague jokes.
- martin_a 6y agoThis obviously isn't a real AI. My results and text pieces are pretty much the same as everyone else's here in the comments. It just fetches some playlists, fills the blanks in its text pieces and that's it.
- sinemetu11 6y agoAI means a chat bot in this case or? I don't see anything that would imply more interesting computation is going on under the surface here.
- anarbadalov 6y agoi cannot wait to try this, but currently my wife is using Spotify to listen to the Lion King soundtrack with my 3-yr-old for the 50th time this week. The kid has for sure ruined the algorithm. But even before that happened, Spotify was bad when it came to discoverability. Reading the other comments here, it sounds like it hasn't improved.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jariel 6y ago"4% basic, manic-pixie-dream-girl-jazz-flex-boomer bad." Too much beebop and nothing past 2015. A lot of people here revelling in their 'not basic' results, the thing is, that's maybe something interesting, but the vast majority of arcane music is straight up bad. Just because it's 'different' doesn't make it good. Most artists who are actually 'pretty good' have some kind of following - they get picked up, at least marginally. Of course there's nothing wrong with 'liking that band with 2K views'. One reason this happens if if they are 'genre' meaning, a newer band, playing into a past sound or genre, people may not pick up. A local band here in Montreal is really good, but they play a kind of specific Cajun country/rock, so their appeal is 'respectable' but 'quaint'.
- mromanuk 6y agoI love it, really funny. It's great how the AI make a coherent critic, feels real.
- chadlavi 6y agoTo whom does my listening history get sold if I hook my Spotify up to this?
- balozi 6y agoThis contraption is the digital equivalence of the proverbial white van that kids are told to never climb into. Don't do it, even if the man said he has puppies or snarky retorts inside.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoThis was fun. I like that the AI had a bit of a personality. In terms of bad vs. good, though, music is like a lot of things in life, so subjective that you can't judge another person's taste. If for no other reason than people care about music to wildly different degrees. I've met people who say they don't listen to music. As in ever. Others cannot let a minute go by without having something playing in their head. It's akin to judging taste in food or recreational activities or movies. It's not really about what's good, rather, what gets a positive mental response. That point aside, I'd say that what would be interesting is measuring how broad a person's musical tastes are. I.e., how much have they been exposed to and how much of that have they assimilated into their regular listening rotation. Pandora does a pretty good job suggesting artists I've never heard. When I hear one I like, I'll incorporate some songs into my regular rotation on Spotify. If you must know, I have Bad Taste. The bad as in Hawaiian shirt-etc.-etc.-etc.... bad.
- naravara 6y agoI'm pretty sure it flags everyone as having bad taste and the algorithm is tuned to customize its mockery. The AI is simulating a record store snob. That said, I thought it was funny because I realize people making fun of me for not being cool doesn't have any effect on me anymore. Is this what middle-age is about? It also focused on mocking my musical tastes being stuck in the early 2010s, but I haven't actually used Spotify since 2015 so I guess that checks out from its perspective.
- slowwriter 6y agoI kind of felt like yelling at it for judging my music taste based on tracks and artists I haven't listened to for years.
- hedora 6y agoMost of the comments here are people that use Spotify complaining about Spotify. I don’t understand what makes it a “sticky” service that people feel they have to put up with. They have many competitors, and tools to copy your music selections between services exist. For example: https://www.tunemymusic.com/ https://www.tunemymusic.com/ Also, Spotify pays musicians less than most other services: https://www.dittomusic.com/blog/how-much-do-music-streaming-services-pay-musicians https://www.dittomusic.com/blog/how-much-do-music-streaming-... Spotify’s pricing is also inline with competitors. I don’t get it.
- citrus1330 6y agoSpotify is better than the competitors. HN is just filled with grumps who love to complain about everything.
- hedora 6y agoIn what way is it “better”? I tried three competitors as I moved away from Spotify, and found they were all substantially better than it. I care about music selection, recommendation quality, and library stability (not deleting stuff from my collection).
- g-erson 6y agoI've also noticed songs disappearing from my library, & crappy recommendations in Spotify. What service did you end up going with?
- hedora 6y agoI ended up with Tidal.
- chaorace 6y agoThe API, for example. It's a ton of fun to bang out toy projects. Just the other day I built my own podcast picker script that curates a playlist of subscribed podcast episodes in exactly the way I want (balance-wise/order-wise). Sounds minor, but it has been huge for my smart-home listening experience, given how terrible the out-of-box podcast experience is with Alexa.
- scottbucks 6y agoThis algorithm is bloody rude! But I get it, and to be honest it's not my fault I keep listening to the same stuff, Spotify doesn't recommend anything good. And I'm sorry but nobody can convince that Fleetwood Mack isn't one of the best groups of all time!
- joshuaheard 6y agoLove this! It needs some way to save your score.
- watermelon0 6y agoMy problem with Spotify is that it almost exclusively plays music that I listened to in the past, or that's on my playlists. The more times I listen to a song, the more frequently they play it. You can get around this by closing the account, and opening a new one, but this is too time consuming, since you need to do it frequently.
- taneq 6y agoAh, the old "this guy bought a car, let's show him ads for cars since he's clearly a car-buyer" style of advertising/recommendation.
- sabellito 6y agoI have such a different experience. Perhaps we use different bits of the service? I almost always listen to the Discovery Weekly playlist, and very often create radio statations for new tracks, which in turn show me more stuff I haven't listened to before.
- nmz 6y agoYou can get around this by using the Release Radar and Discover Weekly playlists which update and are fine tuned to your likes on music.
- miralize 6y agoIf you wanted to build this with Apple Music, you'd need a $99 developers account for the privilege
- frakt0x90 6y agoI see a lot of comments about how bad spotify recommendations are. I have had great experience but I follow a methodology to keep the recommendations curated. I'll also note that I listen to a wide variety of music ranging from EDM to metal to high enery jpop to classical. What I have found is: - Adding things to playlists makes a big difference. If you really love a song, hit it with a heart, if you want to hear more but don't love it, add it to a relevant playlist - skip mildly bad songs - actively dislike terrible songs (hide it on mobile, hit the no smoking sign on desktop) I got into a chill beats phase and it took a couple months for me to eradicate it from my discover weekly but now it's pretty on point. Just my 2 cents.
- kamaln7 6y agoHonestly all I want is for Spotify to differentiate between music I actually like to actively listen to and music that I like to play in the background 24/7 (e.g. chill hop)
- bmhin 6y agoI've wanted this for video streaming too. After getting rid of cable, I'll often want to put something on in the background while I'm browsing the web or playing switch or something. I feel like almost everyone has a completely different thing they are looking for in active vs passive consumption and being able to tailor it would be very nice. Very straightforward example: I really don't need subtitled shows when I will be half paying attention at best. I also don't want to watch something that is new to me and also "good" when I won't really be paying attention.
- squeaky-clean 6y agoSame, my spotify thinks I'm very obsessed with Ambient and Classical. I mean I enjoy those genres, but they're not my typical "active listening", I just always want some sort of sound going on in my apartment. Also whenever I'm DM'ing a D&D game the majority of my daily mixes change to video game music for weeks because I use them as backing music.
- 6y ago
- madamelic 6y agoI have to give huge applause for the quality of writing. I genuinely can't tell how expansive the responses are, which is huge for AI. It definitely has the UX feel of being a bit creepy on how well it responds.
- corytheboyd 6y agoMy friends and I all did it, the punchlines all seem to be the same. I think it feels “creepy” if you attach emotion to songs (I certainly do!) and then listen to them often, but it’s really not all that hard to pick out your top tracks/artists to do that with. Anyway it’s still fun, I liked it
- anupamchugh 6y agoExactly, I love the wittiness in writing. But wonder if the AI responds similarly to other users.
- majinuub 6y ago> Your spotify was pretentious-hip-hop-god-rock bad. > Thank your obsessions with Childish Gambino and christian rock for that. > Based on your listening habits, I can also tell you your spotify was... > awkward-beatboxing bad Bruh
- bitsoda 6y ago"Your spotify was midwestern-stoner-potty-training-baby-shark-prison bad." As a 35 y/o with a toddler I'd say they nailed it.
- shireboy 6y agoI thought this was going to help me get rid of that annoying ad for a "Charmin fresh booty", but all it did was criticize my listening. Don't care what you say, SkyNet, REM rocks.
- shanemlk 6y agothis triggered me
- absolutelyrad 6y agoDamn, stop criticizing my taste in Taylor Swift's music!
- squeaky-clean 6y agoThis was great, really spot on and snarky. Though there are some ambient playlists I sleep to and so it weighed those far more than it probably should, but I guess how is it supposed to know that. My spotify recap thingie said the same thing about some of the ambient artists. > Based on your listening habits, I can also tell you your spotify was... > stoned-itunes-visualizer bad > cling-clang-pots-and-pans-music bad Gotta say, that's a pretty perfect call out of my average music listening.
- wreath 6y agoEveryone is blaming the Spotify algorithm for bad suggestions. I ran this test, it's my OWN TASTE that turns out to be bad according to this :( Jokes aside, I think this is a really neat toy with a great sense of humor
- JakeStone 6y agoMy badness made me laugh. I like certain show tunes when I program. Don't judge me, the web site already did. But because I read a news story about The Chicks rebranding and got curious about their new album, it got added to my gestalt. Thus: Your spotify was like-country-but-smoke-weed-with-your-gay-friends-drama-club-tonys-watch-party bad.
- shakow 6y ago> Have you considered there's a reason nobody listens to Orchestre Lyrique de la RTF? Thanks, AI.
- monksy 6y ago> You're stuck in the 2000s. You know there's been good music since Metalocalypse: Dethklok, right? False. Time to throw this into the death pit.
- supuun 6y agoIt made fun of me for listening to BTS :(
- thankfullyfired 6y agoA lot of people in this thread have no sense of humor and need to seriously lighten up.
- edm0nd 6y agoA tale as old as the internet itself.
- earwaxauditor 6y agoHaving only one comment on an account and it being about how other people are ornery is the most curmudgeon thing I’ve seen.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- henry_bone 6y agoThat'd be me. Wasn't in a good mood when I commented. :-) ironically, my comment is funny to me (at least) now.
- Agentlien 6y agoThis seems to be just a few canned quips with fields to insert a few of your most listened to artists and tracks. Quite funny though. What's actually more fun is Spotify's yearly playlists with your most listened to songs. I always get a kick out of analysing those.
- WhoCaresLies 6y agoamericans really despise when foreign companies are successful
- rubyist5eva 6y ago```> Your spotify was moonwalk-BFG bad. > Thank your obsessions with Michael Jackson and Doom (Original Game Soundtrack) for that. > But wait, it gets worse: You listen to these tracks too much: Enter the Cipher by Follow The Cipher Afterlife by Metalite Winterfall by Follow The Cipher Valkyria by Follow The Cipher My Soldier by Follow The Cipher You stan these artists to an uncomfortable extent: Amaranthe Mick Gordon Nightwish Celldweller Little V. You are 1% basic. Have you considered there's a reason nobody listens to monomer?. You're stuck in the early 2010s. For you, music's been all downhill since Amaranthe made Leave Everything Behind. Well, that was really something. I need to go recalibrate my taste levels. Shutting down.``` well shit
- the_only_law 6y agoSororities statistics are weird, all sites like this tend to pull up stuff I haven’t listened to in 3-4 years and don’t have in any playlists. Similar to this, I’ve noticed a lot of sites that pull your top artists, will pull artists I’ve listened to once or twice recently, but not ones that be listened to continuously over time.
- adolfoabegg 6y agoHilarious! Nice work
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shoulderfake 6y agoOh please tell me whats good music two random guys who wrote an algorithm .... Gimme a break
- JeanSebTr 6y agoSomehow, the one time we babysitted a friend's kid made a kid song go to the top of my most listened tracks... I definitely don't use my Spotify account enough for it to do meaningful recommendations. Too much time on the Discover Weekly and it is more and more diverging from tracks I actually like. The algorithm feed itself and lose precision. I miss the recommendation capabilities of rdio.
- dcolkitt 6y agoWhat's really clever about this bot is that it mostly seems to criticize the good music in your library. Nobody is going to feel insecure about their guilty pleasures. I already know that Mambo Number 5 and Achy-Breaky Heart aren't musical masterpieces. But when it starts telling us the stuff we think is high-brow stuff is actually crap, that's when people really start feeling insecure and second-guessing our personal taste. You start thinking wait, what's wrong with Nine Inch Nails and Haim? I thought they're supposed to be good...
- djmetzle 6y agoThat's great!
- rahkiin 6y ago> You're stuck in the 1970s. Forget about Eagles's One of These Nights (2013 Remaster) and move on. Hah.
- anotheryou 6y agotries a bit too hard to be negative to really get what it finds.
- tonystride 6y agoWow reading discussion of music consumption on HN is so surreal for me as a working pianist / keyboardist / accordionist / educator. There’s a guilty pleasure I derive from mostly feeling unworthy when reading through HN posts about tech, you all are amazing! At the same time I really appreciate that HN is aware of your minority tech nerd preferences compared to the greater consumer population who are perfectly happy in their walled gardens. I practice tech in the same way some one casually dabbles in piano. I wish I didn’t have to be in a walled in garden but not enough time (for now) to make a website that’s not a godaddy template. The disdain for using gd services must be similar to how I feel about music industry discussion, but I accept that I’m a minority since I can see the ‘source code’ to everything I hear. But yeah pretty funny to be judged by the AI as a consumer for something that I actually use more of as a professional reference tool. I got, 2% basic, jazz-everyones-heard-of-jazz-flex-stuck-in-the-fifties bad. It also made fun of me a lot for listening to every episode of Marion Mcpartland’s ‘Piano Jazz’ that’s available on Spotify...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pjmorris 6y ago> made fun of me a lot for listening to every episode of Marion Mcpartland’s ‘Piano Jazz’ that’s available on Spotify... That's not you, that's bad AI :)
- slmjkdbtl 6y agoYou've been listening to a lot of Yo La Tengo lately. u okay? love some of the jokes, i wonder if they hard coded these in or what
- dartharva 6y agoThis was fun. Trigger-inducing, but fun.
- antidaily 6y ago"OMG. Hold up. Do you really listen to Day of the Diesels by Thomas and Friends?" (sigh)
- t0mbstone 6y agoAs someone who listens to spotify all day while programming, here's my secret to success: I create a playlist to fit a mood (for example, ambient electronic music with a good beat and no words), and I seed it with at least 10 songs. Then, I go down to the "Recommended Songs" section and I just play whatever it recommends. If I don't like a song, I hit the skip button on my keyboard. The vast majority of what it recommends and plays is tolerable but not great. Every now and then (maybe one out of every 20-30 songs) I will discover a shiny new gem of a song that really resonates with me. So I drag that song up and add it to my slowly growing playlist. This has the effect of subtly changing the recommendation algorithm for that playlist over time. Eventually I end up with a playlist with about 100 songs on it, and recommendations that at least roughly align with the mood. I tend to get bored of songs pretty quickly though, so when a playlist gets too stale, I will prune the old and tired songs from it. This approach has worked pretty well for me so far, but I really wish that there was a way to explicitly tell Spotify that I "dislike" a song and to never recommend it to me again.
- ckosidows 6y agoI do the same thing now, but the recommended section leaves a lot to be desired on mobile. There's no way to prevent songs from getting suggested (other than maybe blocking a song entirely?). My recommendeds don't seem to get updated until the playlist has changed dramatically. And repeat songs get added to the section even if I haven't added it the umpteen times it was suggested prior. Is the experience different on desktop or am I doing something wrong?
- johnwyles 6y agoAnyone here remember turntable.fm? I do. Sad. JQBX.fm isn't the same either. That was a great way to get a higher "hit" ratio though.
- MivLives 6y agoI miss it so much. Nothing else has come close. I'm surprised Spotify hasn't added a feature like it.
- 6y ago
- voqv 6y agoLove this. Although I haven't listened to Kanye West for like several months and yet I got roasted into oblivion for listening to him.
- earwaxauditor 6y agoThe dialog was just saying that I listen to x, y, and z in a snide way. The summary was cool.
- doiwin 6y agoI'm always curious to broaden my musical taste. But I would not want to let that site log into my Slotify account. Gnoosic is a site I love. It creates AI based recommendations without any login: https://www.gnoosic.com https://www.gnoosic.com
- coffeekitkat 6y agoDidn't expect it will play a music for me haha, had to pick up my earphones. Anyway it was hilarious. - Your spotify was anime-slow-dance bad, On "You listen to these tracks too much:" part, well that is because they are on the top of the playlist. I usually start my Spotify day by just playing the playlist (Liked Songs) so it goes just play the music on whats on top and go down to the first song I fav'ed. - You are 2% basic. Oh wow The Contes and Crown Jewels! Your taste is so obscure that's so cool I bet you're super interesting.. This one got me :) I really like "The Contes" and "Crown Jewels" - You're stuck in the early 2010s. Hmm... Kinda not accurate. Does it know when the track was originally released to make accurate one? Like there was an album on my list that it was originally released on 1998-2004 but was released on Spotify earlier this year 2020. "fuck marry kill.. fast" was fun but got off took me a while to figure it out, I quickly clicked "fuck" and "marry" on SCANDAL (why not right? haha) and thought the A.I. is dead, later I figured out that I need to choose on others too.
- jsmith99 6y agoThe years are even worse for classical. I've just been told "You're stuck in the 1990s. Forget about Johann Sebastian Bach's Bach, JS : Sacred Cantatas BWV Nos 4 - 6 and move on."
- richrichardsson 6y agoI got stuck at the "marry fuck kill" question twice and gave up.
- szatkus 6y agoYour spotify was pour-over-coffee-too-much-symphonic metal bad. > Thank your obsessions with Of Monsters and Men and symphonic metal (e.g., Luca Turilli and Van Canto) for that. > Here's what else I learned in that hellscape: You listen to these tracks too much: [too embarrassing] You stan these artists to an uncomfortable extent: You are 4% basic. Мёртвые Осы and Zabili Mi Żółwia? Where do you even find this shit?. You're too trendy for your own good. You only listen to music made in the last year like... It's amazing that it correctly spotted objectievely shitty songs on my playlist.
- parliament32 6y agoCalling this AI.. I had a few friends run it and it turns out it's just madlibs. Fun regardless.
- medium_burrito 6y agoI miss Rdio- I got a free subscription back in 2013 courtesy of an employer and it had amazing auto-play features- always good new exciting music. Spotify by comparison is a crime against good taste.
- marianov 6y agoYou've been listening to a lot of Guns N' Roses lately. u okay? Awesome project
- blhack 6y agoYeah I think this confirms that this is just a madlib. Mine was: You've been listening to a lot of Monolink lately. u okay?
- fao_ 6y agoThis is good but it didn't seem to pick up on my constant listening to the Native Tongues group or artists like Del the Funky Homosapien and Queen Lahtifah
- cgriswald 6y agoI see a lot of comments here (and some in the YouTube recommendation thread currently on the front page) suggesting sometimes a Rube Goldberg-esque series of behaviors to trick the algorithm into performing properly. I see this mentioned as "easy" and "trivial". I consider it "abrasive" and "tedious." The algorithms should work through normal use of the app. I shouldn't have to tell an app "Ignore this one-off piece of content I reached through an external link that is different from all the other content I've enjoyed and especially different than what I've searched." If I get to the point where I have to curate at that level of detail, what's the point? It's less work to do what I've been doing all along: get recommendations from friends, family, articles, collabs, biographies, etc. (And it's a lot more fun.)
- Avamander 6y ago> I shouldn't have to tell an app "Ignore this one-off piece of content I reached through an external link that is different from all the other content I've enjoyed and especially different than what I've searched. Do you _really_ think they wouldn't've already implemented it already if it were possible in a reasonable way?
- farias0 6y agoActually I'd bet on the opposite: They don't think it makes sense to ignore it. They want to process this data, and they're confident in the weight it's assigned to it.
- jvanderbot 6y agoIt eviscerated me for listening to a lot of soothing piano songs (mostly from one album). For the last year, we learned that was the best thing to play for our foster kid so she'd sleep. My recommendations will probably never recover. Same for netflix.
- celestialcheese 6y agoMan that was fun - great project!
- betaby 6y agoOn the last step - empty screen
- abalashov 6y agoThat was funny. However, I'm one of those people with a bona fide, DRM-free MP3 collection[1] But I only use Spotify a) in the car and b) while riding my bike/bike trainer. I have an actual DRM-free MP3 collection[1] for the important stuff--which has a little overlap with Spotify, but not too much. [1] Small - only about 20 GB - and has been contiguously curated, over five distinct "generations" in my life, since I was in 7th grade (1998), when I had a 486 DX4/75 that could just about play an MP3, downloaded over dial-up from a shady FTP server, over my SoundBlaster 16 if I wasn't running X or doing anything else.
- triangleman 6y agoWhat are your feelings about AAC 128kbps?
- abalashov 6y agoUndefined value. :)
- triangleman 6y agoI'm getting back into collecting and I think that's what I'm going to use for mobile play. And to think just a few years ago I was encoding with LAME...
- corytheboyd 6y agoThat was fun, if not maybe a bit TOO judgmental! Tangential: I wish one-off applications like this also offered a one-click de-authorization step at the end to remove access to my account. It’s a pain to go figure out how to do it for certain accounts, especially if you’re mobile and there’s a decent chance you’ll just forget to do it later. I do not like leaving access tokens around in other people’s databases unless I have to. I understand this would require the service to provide such functionality to the application developer, which I’m sure isn’t always available..
- jagged-chisel 6y ago> Where do you even find this shit? uh ... Spotify?
- numbers 6y agoAs someone who has a lot of very obscure artists in my library due to a dialect of my native language, this did a bad job of judging that. About half or more of my listening is not English language music and that was also disregarded.
- greyhair 6y agoSo I am just supposed to go though a site and give them my spotify credentials? In 2020?
- sl1ck731 6y agoNo. It uses oauth and scopes for stuff like playlists and activity.
- greenie_beans 6y agoOne of my top songs is the absolute worst. It always comes on and I always click next and cuss at Spotify about it. It came on twice in one day recently. Somehow that song is the artist’s top song, despite it being a bonus track and not even on the official album. Too bad they took away the “dislike” button.
- greyhair 6y agoOddly, I signed up for Spotify family so it would be more affordable for three kids. I spend way more time in Pandora (premium) because after several years of use, it has built up a good idea what I want to listen to. I find Spotify repeats far to often, but that is possibly from my lack of use. I listen to my own music collection more than I listen to Pandora.
- meowsnow 6y agoIt didn't roast me, weighted on my most recent listening, and instead went for analyzing my whole history at once.
- markus_zhang 6y agoOnce I see how many basic features got cut from the free plan I immediately decided to not use Spotify for my life. Period.
- ironmagma 6y agoKind of annoying that the site is down, but you still have to wait through 30 seconds of non-functional pauses to get that information. And there's no "retry" button.
- factsaresacred 6y agoCheck uBlock or Privacy Badger if you have them installed - they may block the Spotify API. Took five refreshes before I figured that out.
- rosstex 6y agoAs soon as I saw Tiny Desk Concerts in the list of "objectively good music" at the beginning, I was dying. It knows me too well! I'm gonna check out that list... Spotify has done an excellent job of recommendations lately. It took several years of liking songs and making playlists, but I've been very impressed with Discover Weekly. The shuffle function is still broken, however. It only "shuffles" from like the top 50 songs. UPDATE: It told me JERRY MARTIN is basic?! The composer for Sims and Sim City? Bruh...
- 0xbkt 6y ago> You are 0% basic. Elliot Berger and Elènne? Where do you even find this shit?. This is just awesome, man.
- cionescu 6y agoMost of the other comments talk about why Spotify's recommendations are bad, but I think they are great. Discover weekly is my favourite playlist when I feel like listening to something new. This tool is also awesome -- `Finding a lot of Above & Beyond.` Yes, you are and there should be even more!
- kinghajj 6y ago"Your spotify was retiree-softball-league-tommy-bahama-africa-on-touchtunes bad. Thank your obsessions with Steely Dan, mellow gold, and Africa for that. Based on your listening habits, I can also tell you your spotify was... 60s-acid-flashback bad mercury-idolizer bad parody-song bad midwest-classic-rock bad punk-with-grandchildren bad But wait, it gets worse: You listen to these tracks too much: Calling Occupants Of Interplanetary Craft by Klaatu Working Man by Rush WEIT WEG by Rammstein While My Guitar Gently Weeps - Remastered 2009 by The Beatles The Dope Show by Marilyn Manson You stan these artists to an uncomfortable extent: Ninja Sex Party Rammstein Led Zeppelin Steely Dan Rush You are 15% basic. You're trying to be cool with Klaatu, but your favorites are the same as everybody else's.. You're stuck in the early 2010s. You must have peaked right around Ninja Sex Party's Under the Covers. That's it. I'm done. I need to go recalibrate my taste levels. Shutting down." Yeah, I'm a 90's kid who listened to their parents' music from the Classic Rock stations they always had on. If anything, I'm more stuck in the 70s; the early 10s is just when I stopped paying much attention to new music, though my wife is trying to change that. You can't shame me, A.I.! What's funny to me, is that I actually discovered Klaatu via Spotify. I'd never heard them before, but they came up in one of my weekly playlists, and (obviously) I took quite a liking. "Calling Occupants" was my #1 song of 2020.
- kraf 6y agoThe cynic in me says this is a project to mine some data. I think Cambridge Analytica used IQ tests?
- mancerayder 6y agoIt's a shame because "Discover Weekly" is a complete flop for me. It's beyond strange what it's sending me. I tried hitting the "-" / don't like button several weeks on almost everything... but eventually I gave up. I'm not sure how customized it is to me, honestly. Your Daily Mix # - that works better but it's mostly repetitive stuff I already have in my Library. They need toggles of some sort, or some dial of some sort rather than put blind trust in these algorithms.
- mancerayder 6y agoIn contrast, I continue to pay for Pandora in the U.S. because the artist radios work very well for somehow knowing what stuff-that-others-liked-that's-similar is. Downside is Pandora gets repetitive quickly in its playlists.
- Avamander 6y agoDiscover weekly is better if you spend time during the previous week listening to songs you like (and also add them to likes).
- heavyset_go 6y agoI can't stand Spotify recommendations. I've been spoiled by Last.fm's recommendations.
- utf_8x 6y agoThis is funny but for some reason focused on my listening history from like 5 years back and completely ignored anything I've listened to since...
- O_H_E 6y agoOff topic: I really suggest you take a look at other stuff on the site. pudding.cool does some seriously awesome interactive visualisations about social/hot topics.
- SylvieLorxu 6y agoIt just crashes for me when getting my final score (on Firefox). Guess my taste is so bad I broke the AI... https://pastebin.com/3Q70EiKY https://pastebin.com/3Q70EiKY
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThat was fun as hell. I didn't realize how enjoyable hipster AIs would be.
- replwoacause 6y ago> Your spotify was romcom-trailer-music-walmart-hawaiian-shirt-slow-dance bad. > Thank your obsessions with Ed Sheeran, mellow gold, and Wonderful Tonight for that. > Based on your listening habits, I can also tell you your spotify was... > mainstream-country bad > like-country-but-smoke-weed-with-your-gay-friends bad > DMB-die-hard bad > wear-carhartts-to-your-desk-job bad > requests-bohemian-rhapsody-at-weddings bad > Here's what else is going on in your aural trash fire: You listen to these tracks too much: Highwomen by The Highwomen WAP by Cardi B Classic by Cam Forgetting You by Cam Bridge Over Troubled Water by Willie Nelson You stan these artists to an uncomfortable extent: Ed Sheeran George Strait Sturgill Simpson Cam Dolly Parton You are 18% basic. Yeah, you've got some obscure artists like Brooks Dixon, but your real top ones are ultra-mainstream like Taylor Swift.. You're stuck in the early 2010s. You only listen to Obama-era jams like Poison & Wine by The Civil Wars and Emmylou - Spotify Sessions by First Aid Kit.
- tomrod 6y agoIcecast+VLC or Groove.FM work great for my needs. Is Spotify really that useful for folks? What is it that yall like?
- savrajsingh 6y agohangs for me at "f marry kill choose fast" fyi
- jedberg 6y agoTo everyone complaining about how to trick the Spotify AI: This is why I still listen to the radio/watch DJ streams on Twitch. Because a human still curates the experience. It's just a matter of finding a human you tend to agree with, and then you literally do nothing but listen.
- snug 6y agoI wish it only looked at my last year, or two. It seems to look at all of my music from the beginning of my account, which is about 10 years old, when I listed to a lot of shitty rave music. Not saying my score would have been better.
- pmlnr 6y ago> You are 0% basic. Oh wow Menschdefekt and Culture Kultur! Your taste is so obscure that's so cool I bet you're super interesting.. (In Bender's voice) You think you're all high and mighty, just because you're an AI? Well, I guessed so. EDIT On a real note, how do you feel about doing the same for my last.fm that has data since 2007?
- Geminidog 6y agolol omg okay hold up Do you really listen to Tennis Court by Lorde? I felt I was being shamed so I clicked No.
- desireco42 6y agoYoutube Music on other hand is fantastic and after it, trying to use Spotify was painful experience. Just giving you a hint.
- Borlands 6y agoWondering what happens to the data they read from each user?
- kkdaemas 6y agoPlease, please make this work without Spotify (e.g. type in a few favorite albums from Musicbrainz or something)
- richardwhiuk 6y agoIt's only funny if you don't get to deliberately select the music yourself to make yourself seem more edgy/cool/punk/folk/etc.
- d0100 6y ago> Your spotify was sinatra-mug-shot-poster-in-your-dorm-room-massage-franchise-bed-bath-and-beyond-christmas soundtrack bad I resent this comment
- circa 6y agoNot sure why the first post didn't catch on - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513886
- hurlingfrootmig 6y agoTried both, Spotify and Pandora. Moved to Pandora. The algorithms work ways better for me on Pandora. On both platforms the rule is to actively rhumba up or down the music.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stuaxo 6y agoWithout trying it - my spotify is terrible. I used a website to feed 8 years of lastfm and all my youtube plays, but Spotify just thinks I want versions of all the most annoying songs.
- zeristor 6y agoSo I need to provide them with my Spotify credentials? Isn’t this like one of those personality harvesting Apps on Facebook? Can’t we permission The Pudding to see our place instead of logging in as us?
- Miner49er 6y agoIt was just permissionig for me. They didn't need my credentials.
- torgard 6y agoThis made me laugh a couple of times. Pretty good :) Really well written. Unique responses to many (I thought) relatively unknown songs and artists. The final score, a rambling "BAD" rating, was very funny. Great job!
- vijucat 6y agoWow, that was great. Very engaging UX / text. By the way, I hated the Spotify ads so much I paid up for YouTube Music + Premium. Even though the Spotify Windows app is VERY usable compared to https://music.youtube.com https://music.youtube.com. Good Lord, I hated those ads. I know the conspiracy theory that they were designed to be irritating so that you pay up, but that only works in a world without much choice; ;now you have YouTube Music, Apple Music, Amazon Music, and Deezer. Spotify, I'll readily pay up and switch if you improve those awful ads.
- LandR 6y agoI have the same opinion on spotify ads, they are so annoying I refuse to subscribe to spotify. It just feels like if I subscribe to remove the awful ads then Spotify has won. I refuse to subscribe because they've annoyed me so much I pay to make it go away! I'd rather just not use spotify at all.
- 1MachineElf 6y agoI've never used Spotify. I'm not sure I want to. Pandora was OK. The issue I had with it is that "Liking" or "Disliking" a song seemed to poison the playlist. YouTube is what I use to discover music today. It can take me down a rabbit hole, but going down one never seems to adversely impact song recommendations the next time I go searching for music. Newer stuff I tend to like usually ends up being on Bandcamp.
- prodtorok 6y ago"You listen to a lot of Drake. Like, A LOT. You okay?" ... LMAO. love it.
- StratoTako 6y agoI'm so offended now.
- StratoTako 6y ago>You are 0% basic. Have you considered there's a reason nobody listens to Pryapisme?. I'm so offended now. I mean, not surprised...
- scottmcdot 6y agoIs anyone fed up with seeing a song in their Release Radar, getting excited about your favourite artists releasing a new album, then being disappointed that the artist has decided to only drop one song from the album, which you will likely get sick of before the album releases?
- forgetcolor 6y agoThis drives me nuts. I want to listen to an album, not a song. But I'm guessing this is an old-school POV that the younger demographic doesn't agree with.
- Raphael_Amiard 6y agoI'm not young anymore (35) but I really don't care about albums
- emerged 6y agoI’m tired of having subscribed to one of my favorite artists, then release radar gives me a horrible song by an artist who apparently took their name. Then when I hit dislike every single week and unsubscribe it still keeps giving me their garbage. I thought it was a fluke at first but it has happened now with about 4-5 artists.
- Shacklz 6y agoThe same happened to me; one of my liked bands apparently released an album; it then turns out that it was some other band that just happened to have the same name. Seems they compare band-names instead of some unique-ids; no idea how they thought this would be a good idea.
- Kluny 6y agoI've been seen and mocked :D I love it, super funny bot.
- wmurmann 6y agoThis gave me a good laugh. Shared with all my friends and made my group chat blow up for a while. Great job!
- Joshkop 6y ago>You are 14% basic. Have you considered there's a reason nobody listens to Headache Migrane Relief?.< I envy those people
- winrid 6y agoI was very harshly judged for my interest in KFMDM :p
- winrid 6y ago*KMFDM
- kristopolous 6y agoI've worked on various music recommendation systems just for my own private consumption for 15 years. My current approach at least makes me really happy. The problem is I'm likely radically different. The general problem is so are many people. But all in different, incompatible ways. For instance, my (current) approach is fundamentally label based. Things are organized by label and I "rate" releases as I listen to them. This leads to a generalized "label rating" which can be partially extended to (1) a rating of the artists who released on the label along with (2) albums and eps which may see a release under another label. Then there is a similarity index to other labels based on a percentage of artists who release on both labels and this leads to something going into a big "consider" pile which then gets treated randomly. It's not really a "recommendation" as much as it is a "might be related? i dunno" system. For people who want familiar songs they can sing along with, this is a terrible no-good system. For people who like to listen to the same song multiple times a day, this is equally useless. For those who want steadfast genre uniformity and things to sound more or less the same, this is also useless. This is designed to be exclusively long-tail and stay firmly within the confines way out at the end of the tail. But that's exactly where I want to be. In the pareto principle, everyone in the 80% looks more or less the same but everyone in the 20% is strange in a different kind of way. There is no 1 recommendation system that works for all customers. Users have to be segmented. It's utterly inescapable. That's why these systems try to just service the 80% and just not put any effort to the other 20%. The problem with this approach is the 80% is no longer 80%. More people are becoming snowflake 20%ers and this trend is likely to continue. The mainstream orientation engines of radio and cable television aren't influencing like they used to and the 'service the 80' approach just won't work any more. It's over. The single recommendation system approach is being tweaked to try to service this coalition that no longer exists. So what happens? Everything starts to suck. Google results, youtube recommendations, spotify, they all start to be unfocused, scattered messes that just discard all the signal, amplify the noise and return piles of nearly identical derivative garbage. Socially we've moved beyond the assumption that simply everyone in society will be in some conventional nuclear family with the wife vacuuming at home and the daughter playing with dolls but technologically we still seem to model humans using utterly conventional and outdated single purpose models that simply do not apply and are increasingly a poor fit for everyone. The new normal is that there isn't one and it's time for tech to play catch up.
- alvarlagerlof 6y agoMy biggest issue with spotify is that when a playlist is played to completion, it alternates randomly between a set of 20 or so recommendations. However I usually don't notice right away, and this ends up polluting the recommendation system at large, to the point that my most-played song of 2020 is one that I now absolutely hate, by it keeps on coming back.
- dmart 6y agoYou can turn this off in settings, under "Autoplay".
- hokkos 6y ago>You're stuck in the early 2010s. You must have peaked right around Gorillaz's Plastic Beach. Truth...
- abeppu 6y agoI think music now serves multiple purposes in a way that makes some judgements a kind of type error. When we judge whether music is "good" or "bad", we're evaluating it as a work of art. Being novel, smart, well performed etc are all naturally important considerations. But when you listen to music for hours while working, studying, workout out, either alone or through headphones ... music is no longer art exactly. Music becomes a tool which helps us guide our own moods or quality of attention. Music becomes a cognitive aid. My desk is bad as sculpture. My documentation is bad as literature. My thinking-music is generally bad as art-music.
- henry_bone 6y agoThat AI can fuck right off. 21% basic, my arse. Pretentious cunt of thing. I like pop music of all kinds, and I don't feel even slightly "bad" about that. I'm certainly not going to start listening to random indie garbage (actually, I like Garbage :-) ) that makes my ears hurt, just so my "taste" gets a positive rating on some cock-smoker's AI driven site.
- klmadfejno 6y agoI was 4% basic. Feels pretty good to me. The AI had some strong, and frequently stated about me listening to Best Frenz's (Joywave + Sir Sly) first and only EP which came out this year haha.
- class_struggle 6y agoI don't know I didn't really learn anything new from that AI that Spotify doesn't tell me for their End of the Year stuff.
- alienspaces 6y agoMusic without words for programming
- TheSmoke 6y agoi enjoyed this, really nice. every metal band, every metal album and song decreased my score. :) > Your spotify was music-to-stalk-boys-to-hail-satan-heavy-eyeliner-post-punk bad. > allegations-of-abuse-have-never-been-proven-in-court bad > gallagher-brother bad > instagram-your-tent-at-sunset bad
- nbzso 6y agoWhat is Spotify? Looks with smile at NAS Folder "Music" with .flac collection.
- S_A_P 6y agoI just wish the Spotify app would stream properly on my car’s Bluetooth connection.
- chrismsimpson 6y agoA troll bot. Cool.
- thr0w__4w4y 6y agoMight have missed the point of the site here (just speculating) -- I got a lot of sarcastic criticism (hey cool, I don't care) but not a single suggestion. Spotify has helped me find lots of music that I like. This site didn't. Fuck this site.
- ubiquitysc 6y agoI think it's pretty clearly only intended to provide snark about your listening habits and not made to give suggestions.
- heimidal 6y ago... it’s comedy. Have a sense of humor.
- wlonkly 6y agoAh, but it didn't promise suggestions, it promised to analyze how bad your Spotify is, and it delivers as promised, regardless of what you listen to!
- SoulMan 6y agoMy Spottily is filled with children music like Coco-melon etc which I never listen. But kids play this from Alexa and Google home all the time. Spotify should have profiles.
- shostack 6y agoIs there a way to reset the logic for a recommended play list or set it to not factor in songs played for the next hour? I often find myself playing songs for others I myself wouldn't want to listen to and as a result my Discover Weekly feed is unusable with no apparent fix.
- anonytrary 6y agoHow did a data-mining operation get 800 upvotes on HN with hundreds of suckers? Dang should remove this post, absolutely horrific.
- JasonPiao 6y agohilarious product! Super curious though.. what data did you use to get the model to write super accurate slang
- longnguyen 6y ago> Finding a lot of Super Simple Songs. > Like... a LOT. > Your spotify was moms-spaghetti-movie-soundtrack-baby-shark-prison bad. > Thank your obsessions with Eminem, soundtrack (e.g., Hans Zimmer and Two Steps from Hell), and Baby Shark for that. LOL my kids used my spotify a lot...
- chewz 6y agoI am still missing Rdio..
- stubish 6y agoMight have been some viral marketing and publicity for Spotify, but instead will just dribble away here due to rate limiting of the API.
- anta40 6y ago> Your spotify was retiree-softball-league-walmart-hawaiian-shirt-allegations-of-abuse-have-never-been-proven-in-court bad. You stan these artists to an uncomfortable extent: The Beatles Cream Led Zeppelin Rush Yes Whoops sorry, I'm a big prog fan :p
- asyrafql 6y agooh damm, I'm a big fan of Parcel. 90% ACCURATE
- threwawaysoff 6y ago< 8% indicates official hipsterdom.
- antihero 6y agoI just wish they put radio back as what it used to be. Now if you create artist/song/playlist radios they seem to be the same few tracks and artists looping, it used to be infinite, ie, the whole point of radio. If you do radio for a decently sized playlist, it is basically just akin to using shuffle. What is the point in that? Absolutely useless for music discovery.
- IndySun 6y agoSuccessful auto-playlisting is going to vary on the demands made. There is no 100% music (or any creative output) recommender because everyone feels differently about what 'energy', 'easy', 'powerful', 'touching', and 'rock' all mean, and to each person individually. These terms are meant to, and always will be, necessarily ambiguous; and that is how these terms work best. AI currently cannot 100% give you a track without drums even if you check the 'no drums' box (because along the way one track with drums was put in the no drums box). Incidentally I've used various searchers (now referred to as) AI for years to try and find tracks requested by clients, it remains somewhat helpful though unable to compete with a human first listening to the human making the request. AI is improving, but it is going to be beyond our lifetime before it replaces communication, human to human, eye to eye. Until AI knows what it means to be human, so it shall remain.
- zmix 6y agoAll I get is (after granting access): Loading your music library...Spotify limiting how many people can use this app at once, so you'll need to wait or try again later.
- sitzkrieg 6y agobeen throttled trying it every few hours for me , seems to be hosed by the popularity. checking network requests spotify may have enabled cors and killed it outright?