14 ms·
The real reason is buried in the article: You can’t buy a good webcam because the number of people willing to pay a lot of money for a high end webcam is very
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
The real reason is buried in the article:
You can’t buy a good webcam because the number of people willing to pay a lot of money for a high end webcam is very small.
At the lower end, people are satisfied with their built in laptop parts or a cheap webcam that sits on top of their monitor.
At the high end, people go down the rabbit hole of buying a do-everything mirrorless camera that they can use for so much more than just a webcam.
A high end webcam would have to be cheap enough that the first group doesn’t mind spending a bit more, but not so expensive that the enthusiast target audience just decides to buy a full-featured mirror less camera instead.
Granted, there is a lot of room for improvement in that budgetary middle ground, but how many people actually care? Common webcams actually perform decently when given proper lighting conditions. We’re not streaming high-bitrate 1080p H.265 on our 5-person Zoom calls. After compression and denoising the extra sharpness and low noise of a high end camera doesn’t add much benefit.
Enthusiasts are a difficult group to market to because they have extremely high expectations. They’d also rather spend weeks scouring the Internet for the perfect deal on a used mirrorless camera than to spend a dollar more than necessary to buy a high-end webcam.
- dota_fanatic 6y ago> We’re not streaming high-bitrate 1080p H.265 on our 5-person Zoom calls. After compression and denoising the extra sharpness and low noise of a high end camera doesn’t add much benefit. This was my experience exactly after testing different setups. I still use my Lumix GX8 for photography and home videos, but it wasn't even close to worth the trouble of maintaining the setup compared to a ~$100 Logitech option that I leave on top the monitor with good lighting and plug in via usb hub as needed.
- piranha 6y agoThis is plainly wrong. I use Sony a5100 (cheapest camera you can hook up as webcam) and in zoom meetings the difference between my image and others (even though some tried to use their phones) is just night and day. Disclaimer: I am that brother referred in the article. :)
- centimeter 6y agoI have to imagine that everyone who says this only tried a cheap lens with a teeny aperture. The narrow depth of field of a good camera+lens combo looks vastly different from a consumer webcam, and survives compression (easily, in fact, since the low frequency data in the background gets quantized less brutally than the high-frequency data of your face). In fact, I think that’s the primary visual cue for the “pro” look. Your GX8 is MFT, so you'd need a pretty wide lens (at least f/2, ideally f/1.4) to appreciate this.
- postalrat 6y agoA camera off a $50 budget phone will probably beat every $100 webcam on the market. So why can't I get that same camera module, minus the phone parts but plus a usb interface, for $100.
- izacus 6y agoMost likely because most of the difference is in the Qualcomm DSP attached to your phones SoC, not the actual camera module. The mobile phone images contain a lot of postprocessing which the webcams don't do.
- ramraj07 6y agoYou can https://www.e-consystems.com/13mp-autofocus-usb-camera.asp https://www.e-consystems.com/13mp-autofocus-usb-camera.asp I bought one of these for using with my lab microscope since the alternatives from thorlabs was 10x more expensive for no reason. It worked fine for a year then it stopped working. Maybe I spillled something on it? Who knows ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- dekhn 6y agothorlabs cameras, and scientific cameras in general, have very different response functions. useful if you want to make quantitative measurements, accurately represent a B&W scene, etc. I use a BlackFly (FLIR) camera on my scope, but have been looking to do something similar to you, since the camera API is not V4L2, but rather a custom framegrabber SDK.
- ghaff 6y agoAnd I'd add that there is a middle ground of higher end webcams that people can buy. Which in my experience as someone who would do the camera thing if I had no other option, works fine even for recorded video.
- foobarian 6y agoTo make your list even more dire, it seems hard to compete with something like the Logitech BRIO at $200.
- zitterbewegung 6y agoIn the middle it is everyone who has a phone that can take decent video.
- Swizec 6y agoYou can turn your old phone into a webcam. An iPhone X has camera quality that competes with a cheap DSLR in a webcam situation. Main thing real cameras are better at is bokeh, but you won’t get that in a webcam. And software can passably fake it these days.
- notretarded 6y agoHow?
- redler 6y agoOn iOS there's an app called Camo. There are probably others.
- inickt 6y agoCamo (https://reincubate.com/camo/ https://reincubate.com/camo/) has been absolutely fantastic. I wanted to use my iPhone Xs when on calls and not have to fiddle with with plugging it in every time I needed a video, so I ended up using an old iPhone 6 and it still destroys every webcam. $40/year isn't the cheapest but it works so much better than EpocCam (which I had been using before).
- bamurphymac1 6y agoI’d second this. Camo is fantastic and with an armature mounted above my monitor I can get a much more flattering angle with a great picture even on an old 6+ front facing camera.
- egorfine 6y agoCamo is fantastic.
- aendruk 6y ago“Droid”Cam does a good job of turning my iPhone Xs into a USB webcam for Ubuntu.
- stock_toaster 6y ago
- sambroner 6y agoI'm just not sure I buy this... The number of people willing to pay significant money for a high end webcam was very small. Now my parents and their friends are talking about better lighting and camera angles. It seems like this industry is unusually ripe for a "better webcam" that "just works"
- chadlavi 6y agoand unfortunately Amazon and Facebook's spy-on-you-all-the-time FaceTime call-style communication products are going to dominate, especially with that demographic.
- gimmeThaBeet 6y agoDid somebody say iSight 2?
- yboris 6y agoiSight was such a beautiful-looking product! It's rather mind-blowing that back then its 640×480-pixel VGA resolution was considered good.
- rasz 6y agoIt wasnt just good, it was almost broadcast quality :) This was still a time of CIF 352x288/QVGA 320x240 webcams with interpolated 640x480 modes. "High-End" Logitech QuickCam Pro 3000 produced something like this https://secure40.securewebsession.com/mikeshardware.site.aplus.net/pics/qc_example_qc2.jpg https://secure40.securewebsession.com/mikeshardware.site.apl...
- throwaway201103 6y agoIt's still good enough. 1080p or 4k is totally unnecessary for a Zoom meeting.
- dogsgobork 6y agoRight now they're talking about better lighting and camera angles. Will they still be interested in six months? In a year? There's a lot of uncertainty for any prospective manufacturer, they could spend a significant amount of money and time developing a product only to launch it into a world that never wants to do another zoom meeting again.
- usrusr 6y ago> You can’t buy a good webcam because the number of people willing to pay a lot of money for a high end webcam is very small. And the subset that is not easily fooled by proclaimed premium versions of the same cheap junk is even smaller.
- bob33212 6y agoI realized the same situation exists with Mail Boxes. At homedepot/amazon you can get a $20 mailbox or a $40 mailbox which are both shitty. Or you can get a 300-900 mailbox which is very high quality. I finally found a decent one on wayfair for 60.
- Reedx 6y agoI don't know, a $400 Apple Cam™ might do the trick.
- siverson914 6y agoiCam. :)
- marta_morena_9 6y agoThis doesn't make any sense. Mirrorless cameras cost a couple thousand dollars (I have one) and the last thing I am going to wear down/abuse this equipment with, is to jump into daily meeting lol. At the low end, there are decent webcams, like Logitech HD 1080p, but it costs over 100$ and honestly, it's a couple of years behind the current. There don't seem to be webcams of around 100 to 200$ that are state of the art. If you look at mobile phones, you see the difference. Those mobile cameras are like 1/5 or 1/10th of the size a webcam could be, so there is LOTs of room for improvement, even in this price segment. I am pretty sure we could easily get 4k recording with decent, artificial depth-of-field (LIDAR & all) under decent lighting conditions (which is why this can be done cheap) at a price point of 100 to 200$. Just nobody seems to be doing it. And yeah we definitely do stream 1080p over meetings and most people are always like "Oh wow, what kind of webcam are you using". That's for my years old logitech... The bitrates are pretty low, even for 4k. You can definitely have a couple of those over almost any current internet connection without issues. My main gripe is depth-of-field. Add some LIDAR and I am happy. Apple webcam anyone?
- goldcd 6y agoLogitech Brio is probably the most "state of the art" webcam you can find (and it's a few years old). Decent quality 4k (or 1080 at buttery FPS) with all manner of gubbins to correct lighting - amount, flicker, hue etc Oh, and does have depth sensing - with separate lens that'll scan your face and log you into windows (or out when you walk off).
- kevin_thibedeau 6y ago> with separate lens that'll scan your face and log you into windows And hence the problem. Now you have a camera is dependent on custom drivers deeply entwined with your OS that are a security risk. It also isn't likely to have usable drivers five years down the line.
- balfirevic 6y agoIt works like normal webcam if you don't need face recognition login.
- jandrese 6y agoWebcams have been a race to the bottom product for many years now, just like optical drives. All of the quality manufacturers were driven out the market ages ago and all that's left now is the absolute cheapest garbage sold to people who just need to check a box. You would think there would be a secondary market for all of the fancy phone cameras now being made, but sticking one in a box with a USB connector hanging out the bottom (or Bluetooth) seems like too much of an ask when you can just put an absolute garbage 720p sensor in the same box and save a few bucks.
- TheRealPomax 6y agoAnd then there's folks at the mid end, who buy an $80 Razer Kiyo purely for the decent video with built-in ring light so you're never backlit, with a separate $99 microphone and $150 audio interface. Buying all the bits separately gets you what this author wants, just not in a single tidy package.
- Already__Taken 6y agoThe price for audio stuff seems truly out-of-this-world compared to everything else. I get microphones have a lot of design/testing that might justify it. But all the interfacing gear seems ridiculous.
- digikata 6y agoIf you have niche requirements then expect to pay some premium for the gear because the development costs are amortized into the unit price. It’s that way for AV gear as well as many other niches. If the market won’t bear the price then people or companies able or willing to bear the development risk will shrink, or in this case maybe never develop.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoWait till you realize that they actually want to pay more for it because the idea it cost so much makes it sound better to you.
- TheRealPomax 6y agoI'm not sure I follow, you consider $100 for a microphone that sounds like you're standing next to the person instead of listening to them over the internet expensive? As for audio interfaces: if you don't want one, don't buy one, get the same mix as USB version instead of XLR, and done.
- ahelwer 6y agoI have this exact setup except I just bought the Samson Q2U microphone ($100ish with stand) which has USB output (in addition to XLR). I doubt I'd be able to tell the difference.
- xwdv 6y agoWait can you really use a Canon R5 as a webcam? Could be a business expense.
- thayne 6y agoI think there is a market for consumers who want a better webcam though. Especially in a post-covid world with more remote workers. I know several people who are unhappy with their laptop webcams for web conferences, but discover that external webcams aren't much better. And these people don't want an expensive mirrorless camera, they just want a webcam with comparable quality to a smartphone camera.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> We’re not streaming high-bitrate 1080p H.265 on our 5-person Zoom calls. Right, even on my higher end webcam, on a connection with 200mbps up, Zoom shows my video (set to HD), as 720p15.
- dheera 6y agoPro tip: If you want a good webcam, don't search for a webcam, search for USB machine vision cameras and find a good lens to go with it. The Sony Exmor or Starvis series of sensors are great. Or use a Pi HQ camera which is an IMX477 (an excellent sensor at its price point) and turn it into a USB webcam with a Pi Zero: https://github.com/geerlingguy/pi-webcam#readme https://github.com/geerlingguy/pi-webcam#readme https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fcbP7lEdzY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fcbP7lEdzY
- jobigoud 6y agoFinally someone suggesting machine vision cameras! These are awesome devices for many applications and they have become way more accessible in the past few years, both in terms of price and by moving to USB3 instead of GigE interface. They are still targetting industrial and medical applications in their marketing but it's such an untapped potential. Many manufacturers, huge choice of models.
- djsumdog 6y agoIf you're a game streamer or other type of streamer and are willing to fork over the cash, it's probably easier to buy an $800~$1k Sony Handycam and USB-C capture device. The majority of game streamers don't really need that though, although they might fork it over because they already have HDMI capture cards with dual inputs. But for the most part, most streamers don't care about their little picture in the bottom 1/4 to 1/8 of the screen. Good lighting in the filming room is much more important than the camera anyway.
- ako 6y agoJust upgraded my webcam to a very cheap action cam (60 euros). Huge upgrade compared to the laptop camera, but still pretty bad with low lighting. Using a good action cam like the insta360 might be a good fit for someone looking for a better webcam.
- leokennis 6y agoRight on the money. I’m not sure I get people’s use cases here. Ok, if you’re creating/streaming video, I get that you need a good webcam. But for your teams’ standups, refinements etc...is video quality really an issue? Usually I’m in a call with 5-10 others. One will be sharing a screen or we will be collaborating on a whiteboard. Other people’s webcam feeds are stamp-sized somewhere in the periphery of my vision. Most people want to hide their surroundings and will use a lame backdrop or a blur filter. So we’re talking about spending hundreds of dollars to make your 100x100 pixel face that no one is looking at anyway a bit sharper?
- bsder 6y agoErm, I bought an Avaya HC020 (about $250) back at the beginning of the pandemic. It's quite nice--my images are always better than everyone short of pro streamers. You can flip the image, color balance, etc. all in the webcam with a remote control (this is why I got it--"flip the image" was causing my laptop fans to screech at max RPM for a different webcam) I've never used it, but if you really need microphone arrays, then probably the Avaya CU360 is probably for you. Bonus: it's standalone Android so you can install all the streaming apps on the device instead of on your computer. And, why not microphone arrays? Because echo cancelling is a nightmare technology that requires real R&D. Somebody always gets the setup wrong on conference calls. The new macs haven't been out long enough for me to trust that Apple actually solved the problem any better.
- praxulus 6y agoIt matters less for internal meetings (maybe improving audio quality could help meetings run more smoothly, but that's just a microphone issue). If any of your employees talk to external clients, I can absolutely see value in getting them set up with a better webcam and internet connection, and I don't think you'd want every sales rep and partner engineer spending a day futzing around with an enthusiast-grade setup.
- randycupertino 6y agoI think you're underestimating personal vanity. Plastic surgery and teeth whitening has SPIKED since the pandemic started because people are looking at their own faces on zoom all day in tiny boxes next to their coworkers. People will drop endless cash to make themselves look better on camera. I frequent the reddit beauty forums and hobbyist non-engineers who have zoom meetings for work are dropping $$ on Diva Lights and video filtering apps etc. Just today driving to the carwash I passed three strip mall aesthetic places advertising fillers and botox. I posted a tutorial on how to set up a green screen and diva light and within a week I had three coworkers order them- I joked with DVE Store that I should start getting a commission.
- seppin 6y agoAlso, as someone that recently upgraded their wifi router and runs a ping script to make sure my connection is always good, upgraded my mic for better sound quality, etc only to have zoom video calls with people on an iPhone with shit reception, fixing your end only does so much.
- Groxx 6y agotbh I'm surprised that GoPro hasn't been exploding into this category. Granted, their cameras do a heck of a lot more than just webcams (... which is good for longer-term use), but they're small, cheaper than a mirrorless, wider angle than a normal mirrorless camera lens, and already have a stable market and existing users.
- pedrosorio 6y ago> A high end webcam would have to be cheap enough that the first group doesn’t mind spending a bit more, but not so expensive that the enthusiast target audience just decides to buy a full-featured mirror less camera instead. This makes it sound like the two requirements are in contradiction but in both you're asking for the price to be lower.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago> the number of people willing to pay a lot of money for a high end webcam is very small. More kids today want to be “youtubers” than astronauts and almost all YouTube work is done off tower PCs. Might not be enough a market for all brands to make one but definitely think someone’s missing a trick of being the Go Pro of streaming.