14 ms·
Facebook: Free as in Bullshit
- rpcwork 6y ago“Facebook’s argument is along the lines of arguing that the police shouldn’t crack down on burglaries because doing so might hurt pawn shops that have been thriving during a years-long crime spree.” Excellent comparison to put the point across.
- infogulch 6y ago> No fair! claims the company objecting to blinds being installed on windows it had long peered through unhindered.
- throw0101a 6y agoTwo key points IMHO. First: > It’s an unfortunate quirk of the English language that free as freedom and free as in beer are very different meanings of free. But when you see an ad headlined “Apple vs. The Free Internet”, most people would assume they’re about to hear an argument about free as in freedom. > Not Facebook. They’re arguing about free as in beer. I mean, they’re alleging that Apple is taking away freedom — the freedom of small business advertisers to benefit from unrestricted tracking for ad targeting — but their argument to the public is that such privacy initiatives will cost users their free beer. Second: > Apple clearly has no control over anything related to the advertising on websites, other than whatever privacy controls are built into Safari. Apple isn’t limiting the ability of apps on iOS to show personalized ads, either. They’re also not limiting the ability of ad-tracking technology to track users. What they’re doing is giving users awareness of and control over that tracking. In broad terms, changing tracking from opt-out to opt-in.
- dorkwood 6y agoWhat does "free as in beer" mean? In what way is beer free?
- samizdis 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_as_in_free_beer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_as_in_free_beer
- dorkwood 6y agoSorry, but I read this whole article and still don't understand. > The English adjective free is commonly used in one of two meanings: "for free" (gratis) and "with little or no restriction" (libre). To be clear, I understand this distinction. I'm just wondering in what context or culture beer is considered free (gratis). > For example, they are used to distinguish freeware (software gratis) from free software (software libre). Richard Stallman summarised the difference in a slogan: "Think free as in free speech, not free beer." This is just repeating the phrase and doesn't answer my question. > As the English adjective free does not distinguish between "for free" and "liberty", the phrases "free as in freedom of speech" (libre, free software) and "free as in free beer" (gratis, freeware) were adopted. Many in the free software movement feel strongly about the freedom to use the software, make modifications, etc., whether or not this freely usable software is to be exchanged for money. Therefore, this distinction became important. This article seems to only explain the distinction between "libre" and "gratis", and treats the idea of beer being free as a given. Is there a particular culture where "free beer" is a common phrase? Why not say "free as in beer, not free as in lunch"?
- Bakary 6y agoFree as in lunch also exists in anglo culture, with the notable example of There ain't no such thing as a free lunch (TANSTAAFL). The concept of free beer sounds natural because there are multiple contexts where you could potentially expect beer to suddenly become free for whatever reason (someone pays for a round, festivals, college dorms etc.) Free pizza would be a good substitute as well. Some consumables just have associations that aren't completely easy to explain to someone not familiar with them.
- mthoms 6y agoFrom the Wiki article > Richard Stallman summarised the difference in a slogan: "Think free as in free speech, not free beer." Free as in lunch would also work, but I'd hazard to guess that "free beer" is more relatable for the target audience Stallman was addressing. That being - computer enthusiasts ("nerds") who skew(ed) largely male, 16 - 35 (roughly).
- kordlessagain 6y agoI bet Facebook has forced updates.
- samizdis 6y agoI fail to understand Facebook's strategy/reasoning for running this campaign against Apple. It is generating a newsworthy backlash which serves only to draw attention to FB's practice of tracking users across domains/apps, when many of said users were unaware of this, and might not be comfortable with it. I would be really interested to hear arguments opposing my assumptions. There must be something that I am overlooking - Facebook isn't a stupid company, not by a long chalk. What is the strategy/reasoning behind this campaign?
- bonoboTP 6y agoTrying to reframe the discussion from privacy, tracking and spying to small businesses reaching customers, people finding relevant products, market efficiency, user experience and comfort and convenience, and also the price. People love zero price. The hurdle from 0 to 1 cent is enormous, so threatening with costs is also effective. I wouldn't be surprised if they tried to push an angle that it's immoral to withhold your data, that you become a leech, a free rider, a pirate.
- beagle3 6y agoIt’s true that the hurdle from 0 to 1 cent is much larger than 1 cent to 1 dollar - but Even though it is well known, to the point of being axiomatic for sellers, that it is not how it is perceived by buyers which often pretend it is a linear scale. Who are these ads directed at? It’s not the general public. But is it small business owners? Politicians? Regulators? I don’t have a good answer.
- DubiousPusher 6y ago> reducing high-quality free content I grew tired of paywall sites in my news feed a couple months back so I started hiding them in google news. It's nice to not run into them but the amount of "quality" content I now see is a number approaching 0.
- bonoboTP 6y agoSee how Fb's ad weasels its way out of even saying what Apple's change is that they are objecting to? Think with the head of the average print newspaper reader who has no context. The ad is just pushing mental buttons and appeals to emotion. Apple will introduce a pop-up permission dialog that asks the user if their personal data should be shared with the app for tracking purposes (including ad personalization). That's it.
- elliekelly 6y ago> The ad is just pushing mental buttons and appeals to emotion. Facebook has monetized manufactured outrage over half-truths. It only makes sense they’d employ the same strategies they’ve seen their best clients develop on their platform.
- isoprophlex 6y ago> The ad is just pushing mental buttons and appeals to emotion. Hehe well, par for the course, as the entirety of FB is exactly this. I hope that schools of the future will teach our children about the dangers of weaponized emotional manipulation.
- bonoboTP 6y agoThat's already been perfected by early 20th century propagandists. Do we learn it in school? Not much I guess.
- tedd4u 6y agoRight, it’s clear FB’s assumption is that a significant % of iPhone users will choose “Ask App not to Track.” Ie they know some significant % of people don’t want this. They just blow past that entirely. I wonder if Apple’s App Store rules allow them to charge a subscription fee if users choose not to allow it, as an alternative revenue stream.
- tonetheman 6y agoWhile this article is about Facebook. It is clear to me this is a fight of who gets to sell to me: either Apple or someone else. As long as Apple is disclosing the same information in their apps as they are forcing FB to do. Meh.
- rgovostes 6y agoNot sure if you have used macOS or iOS lately but for [edit: two years] now—and well before this public spat with Facebook—they show a privacy disclosure splash screen before turning on many features for the first time. And yes, the Apple apps in the App Store have the nutrition labels. These apps and some system features also go through the same dialogs for mic/camera/photos/etc. access as third-party apps. They also wrote an extensive webpage with several whitepapers on how different features are designed for privacy: https://www.apple.com/privacy/features/ https://www.apple.com/privacy/features/ Apple's own advertising network, iAd, was discontinued, and now as far as I know the only way they are involved in paid advertising of third-party products at all is through App Store search result placement.
- st1x7 6y ago> at least a year now (...) they show a privacy disclosure splash screen before turning on many features for the first time. This has been the case from the start of the Apple App Store. Here is a 3 minute video of Steve Jobs talking about it in 2010 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39iKLwlUqBo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39iKLwlUqBo (Zuckerberg comes up too funnily enough).
- rgovostes 6y agoI was referring to these, introduced two years ago in iOS 11.3: https://www.idownloadblog.com/2018/01/26/apple-privacy-icon-example/ https://www.idownloadblog.com/2018/01/26/apple-privacy-icon-... I think you are referring to the "Allow Facebook to use your location?" pop-ups. Notably, these have gotten progressively more sophisticated—apps now have to specify a reason for the data request. You can block access to backgrounded apps, and opt to provide a coarse location instead of your full GPS fix. Other protections apply to photo sharing, etc.
- eatonphil 6y agoThe linked tweeted image [0] at the end of the article is incredible. I haven't used Facebook in a few years and haven't used their app for longer so it's astounding to me how much variety of data Facebook tries to get at. The social media I do use (basically just Twitter) I use on my phone through Chrome, not through their app. But the NYT app is more convenient than their site, as is Spotify and Youtube. Perhaps these apps are as invasive as Facebook and I did not realize. [0] https://twitter.com/_inside/status/1339689228549181440 https://twitter.com/_inside/status/1339689228549181440
- Nextgrid 6y ago> Spotify and Youtube Spotify contains the Facebook SDK which is basically spyware and pings Facebook with your device fingerprint and a unique ID generated on first run every time you open the app. YouTube comes from an advertising company so it's safe to assume they've got their own equivalent of the above that's equally malicious.
- eatonphil 6y agoAccording to the permissions page in Android settings I have no permissions granted to Spotify or Youtube.
- Nextgrid 6y agoYou don't need any specific permissions to collect a near-unique device fingerprint. iOS is even more restrictive when it comes to that and yet fingerprinting devices is very easy if you collect the data over time and correlate with other data (from other apps or websites).
- ffpip 6y agoYou need zero permissions to get a list of all apps you have installed, your unique advertising ID and a common things like sensors and WiFi names. Plus full unrestricted internet access.
- 6y ago
- neodymiumphish 6y ago> Facebook’s argument is along the lines of arguing that the police shouldn’t crack down on burglaries because doing so might hurt pawn shops that have been thriving during a years-long crime spree. Except that Facebook isn't benefitting from criminal activity, is it? This is a case of a classically naive public who really doesn't care one way or the other.
- legulere 6y agoAt least in Europe you could very well think so with the GDPR.
- neodymiumphish 6y agoThey've been fined for where they've violated the law. I'd argue not enough, but that's the fault of the regulators and lawmakers. Still doesn't put FB's activities comparable to the pawn shop analogy unless there are valid claims that these other apps and sites are breaking the law in the data they collect and provide to Facebook.
- d3nj4l 6y agoFacebook has only been fined once for GDPR violations, and that has to do with a bureaucratic technicality. The actual cases against Facebook have been held up for ages [1]. You can look up all GDPR fines here: https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ 1: https://noyb.eu/en/open-letter https://noyb.eu/en/open-letter
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y ago> This is a case of a classically naive public who really doesn't care one way or the other. It is hard to know whether or not someone cares about something when they have no choice. Most of my family members think their devices are listening to them constantly, but what are their options? They aren't going to get rid of their phones and TVs.
- inetknght 6y ago
- croes 6y agoFacebook is always against the choice of privacy and all about control disguised as socializing. Didn't Zuckerberg once claim the time of privacy is over? Except his of course.
- cm2012 6y agoIf it wasn't really exhausting to argue about FB on HN I would put a long post here. But in short, FB ads are a net good for society. 1) They replace worse and spammy ads. 2) The tracking is really mild. If a big bad government or hacker wants to get dirt on you, they don't dig into FBs tracking algos, they go straight to the ISP or they hack the website you visited. FB also doesn't sell your data. 3) People genuinely find products they like all the time through ads. 4) Whole categories of businesses get a chance for customers to discover their products. Almost every new Shopify store selling cool new products relies on FB ads to get in front of customers. Many really cool useful b2b tech products rely on FB to be discovered. Advertising isn't magic. It's not mind control. 90% of it is clearly showing a product to the market and you pray you find product market fit.
- reedf1 6y agoAnd targeted political ads? What about those?
- cm2012 6y agoHonestly both sides suck at using them and they have little impact on the national elections as is. But both sides want them to continue existing. They make it possible for challenger politicians in small races to get their names known.
- rocho 6y agoHow do you know that they have little impact? That's just pure speculation on your part.
- crakhamster01 6y ago> How do you know that they have little impact? There's no research proving or denying this claim, but as anecdotal evidence: Mike Bloomberg spent more on advertising than any candidate in history for his primary election campaign (~$500 million), which he lost spectacularly. People often credit Facebook Ads for Trump's 2016 victory, and it's an interesting claim considering that he spent substantially less than Bloomberg on the platform (~$40 million).
- boffinism 6y agoUtterly lost me at 'There’s nothing “forced” about the software update', which is true only in the narrowest, least useful sense.
- sonotmyname 6y agoIn what sense are iOS updates ‘forced’? It’s a single binary slider in prefs - auto update/don’t.
- izacus 6y agoAnd then you get constantly badgered by notifications and your apps start shutting down because they need a new version of iOS and up-to-date version of app to run. It's not just about the slider.
- macintux 6y agoApp developers are making the decision to prioritize newer iOS versions because Apple has been successful at supporting older devices and making updates seamless... ...and suddenly that's a bad thing, despite the security and support advantages. Apple can't win.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sergiomattei 6y agoThen 1. Don't use the offending developer's apps 2. Ignore the notifications It really is that simple
- ksk 6y agoApple uses dark patterns and doesn't provide a "stop bothering me" option. I used to get nagged by Apple so I turned on the auto updates just to not have these popups. I guess it worked.. https://imgur.com/7ErVNiw https://imgur.com/7ErVNiw
- person_of_color 6y agoGet ready for the FB smartphone, totally free (ad supported) of course!
- tallgiraffe 6y agoThey tried it circa 2012/13. It was a partnership with Microsoft/Nokia, meant to get people in developing countries hooked on Facebook at a very low price. The phone was crap though, even by dev county standards. I remember testing it, and everything took foreeeever. On a bright side, it was the same time when FB put a ton of effort into improving their mobile web experience, realizing how bad it was on bad phones with slow networks.
- tedd4u 6y agoSeems like they would need to have a compatible Android fork for this ... anyone know what pieces would need to be carved out and rebuilt for FB to mount a successful effort? Ie they don’t want this to benefit Google in any way. Or is there some other viable mobile OS they could use? Not obvious to me.
- person_of_color 6y agoFuchsia?/
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoI'm completely on Apple's side on this one, or rather on the side of user choice. I just wish Apple would also give users a choice where it doesn't so clearly benefit Apple's own business interests, such as choosing which apps to install, where to buy them or how to pay for them.
- pyrrhotech 6y agoFacebook is the most unconscionably bad company in tech, and it's a shame Zuck and friends try to pretend they are on this grand mission to make the world better. Come on, just admit it's all about the money and we'd have a little more respect for you. All FB does is lead to time-wasting, fake news, bigotry, envy etc. I'm glad I've signed out from desktop
- Nextgrid 6y agoI wonder if Zuckerberg or the Facebook leadership really believes they're doing something good for the world and that the current problems caused by it are only a result of Facebook either not having enough data or not being present enough in our daily lives. For example, disallowed/undesirable content on Facebook wouldn't be an issue if Facebook knew everyone's thoughts and prevented them from posting even before they wrote a single word. Ad fraud wouldn't be an issue if the only money that mattered was a Facebook coin (Libra?) and can be recalled or made invalid remotely. Election interference wouldn't be an issue if the only government you can elect is a Facebook-sponsored one. Etc. It's an insane idea, but maybe not that insane if you look at it from the aforementioned sociopaths' points of view?
- ip26 6y agoPsychology has found almost everyone has rationalized their beliefs & behaviors in some form or another, even if it's fairly transparent such as "The best thing for everyone is if I'm in charge"
- tleb_ 6y agoWatched Star Wars 3 yesterday and it's exactly this. I wasn't convinced anyone would ever act like this though, seemed too fake to me (maybe the acting was the issue?).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ksk 6y agoWhich company ISN'T performing a greedy money grab? Certainly not Google, or Apple or Microsoft.
- pyrophane 6y agoWhat Apple is doing here seems like a good change! It is aiming to give users some control of tracking. If FB wants to engage in such tracking, it is up to them to convince users of the benefit so that they will choose to enable it. When it comes to defaults being rolled out to millions of users, I like this approach. They aren't blocking everything a la uBlock Origin, or putting themselves in the middle as the gatekeeper like Adblock Plus. Ultimately, though, I think Facebook's business model is the problem. It depends on users giving them something for free that the user really has little incentive to provide. Sure, on its own the argument that users prefer personalized ads over generic ones makes some sense, but when I think when users have to consciously evaluate that trade-off (personalized ads BUT you have to allow someone to track everything you do on the internet), that is a hard sell.
- LordHumungous 6y agoNeither company has pure motives here. Apple just so happens to take a 30% cut of in-app purchases, so they stand to benefit immensely from a change to that model. They also have their own ad platform that will benefit from this. Both sides are concealing their selfish motivations under the guise of altruism.
- chrisoverzero 6y ago> They also have their own ad platform that will benefit from this. No, not since 2017: https://developer.apple.com/support/iad/ https://developer.apple.com/support/iad/
- LordHumungous 6y agoInteresting that they are posting a bunch of new reqs for their ads platform https://jobs.apple.com/en-us/search?search=ads%20platform&sort=relevance&location=united-states-USA https://jobs.apple.com/en-us/search?search=ads%20platform&so...
- chrisoverzero 6y agoApple still has search ads: https://searchads.apple.com/ https://searchads.apple.com/ From the first of those listings: “Today, our technology and services power advertising in Search Ads in the App Store and Apple News.” This meets one of the criteria you specified (“They also have their own ad platform […]”), but not the other (“[…] that will benefit from this”).
- LordHumungous 6y agoSearch Ads don't count why?
- dhnajsjdnd 6y agoApple’s search ads will indeed benefit greatly from this change. When an app developer runs an ad on Facebook, and a user converts and buys the app, attributing that conversion requires “cross app tracking” that will be banned by this update. On the other hand, if the developer runs the ad though App Store search, Apple will be happy to attribute the sale to get paid. One could reasonably guess that the real purpose of this change is to take that market from Facebook.
- tallgiraffe 6y agoI understand why people are upset with Facebook. I find it interesting that same people don't seem to be upset with Apple, while Apple is largely playing the same game. Forget all you know about Facebook ad practices for a second, and take a look at what Apple is doing, but putting "Mom and Pop LLC" in place of Facebook. Apple is using their enormous power to essentially pick and choose what is allowed to execute on your device. Sure, they give user a "choice" to either restrict and app, or to allow it, but they never, ever, give user the same choices about Apple itself. Apple "helping" users to restrict others is no different from Microsoft installing internet Explorer for everyone, to "help" users browser the internet. In this case Apple is getting all the goodies about the user: their location, their usage, their connections, everything. Meanwhile, they are blocking others from having it. The difference is that Apple is waving the freedom-fighter flag first, thereby making everyone else look bad in comparison.
- turboturbo 6y agoThis is quite the false equivalence. > their location, their usage, their connections, everything Which Apple-made apps have access to your location without your prior explicit approval?
- tallgiraffe 6y agoThe iPhone itself? I mean, I am more than happy to be proven wrong. But can we know, for 100% that while I am simply using my phone, Apple isn't actually collecting its location via their own APIs, or those of my cell carrier?
- ryukafalz 6y ago>In this case Apple is getting all the goodies about the user: their location, their usage, their connections, everything. Meanwhile, they are blocking others from having it. Because Apple doesn't seem interested in collecting all this data in the first place. If they were, it'd be straight up hypocrisy, but that doesn't appear to be the case. Don't get me wrong, I value open platforms myself, but right now it seems like the choice in mobile OSes is largely between an open platform that leaks data like a sieve and a restrictive platform that at least has some semblance of privacy. I keep flipping back and forth and hope for a better option one day, but I'm glad there's at least someone putting pressure on the advertising panopticon.
- mawise 6y agoI've been working on a side-project that aims to be a self-hosted alternative to centralized social media. The core idea that anyone should be able to easily host their own private website where they control access and retain control over their data. With RSS protected by http basic auth, people can create their own feeds. I'd love some feedback on this model if anyone cares to share some thoughts: https://simpleblogs.org https://simpleblogs.org
- 082349872349872 6y agoTangent: the title is unfair to bullshit, which is a useful substance in its own right, as fertiliser.
- ezequiel-garzon 6y agoAbsolutely, it made Peru extremely prosperous for decades [1], though you must use bird instead of bull. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guano_Era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guano_Era
- thefrog 6y agoHey Gruber: Fuck off. You may be randomly right sometimes, but your shitty attitude (https://blog.codinghorror.com/standard-markdown-is-now-common-markdown/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/standard-markdown-is-now-commo...) and air of total self importance is offputting.
- ykevinator 6y agoPeople who don't like facebook should stop using it. I don't get people treating it like a utility that they are entitled to.
- bsenftner 6y agoNow, seriously, why are you still on Facebook? No, seriously. I left when Cambridge Analytica broke. Reflecting back, FB gave me very little. Now, 4 years later, it feels like complacent inertia there has not been a mass exit from them.
- ezequiel-garzon 6y agoFacebook's statement referenced in the ad: https://www.facebook.com/business/news/ios-14-apple-privacy-update-impacts-small-business-ads https://www.facebook.com/business/news/ios-14-apple-privacy-...
- yzxben01 6y agoCan someone put in plain terms what this actually means for advertisers? I realize this is about protecting privacy, and I fully support that, but putting that aside for a second, I am part owner of a small business and an advertiser - what consequences could this have? I rely on Facebook ads to market to parents in the local area (as well as Google). We use several FB tools to try to make the target audience as specific as possible. This helps, because not everyone is interested in the services our business offers, and saves us ad money. Does this mean that the campaigns I run could become less effective, because FB is less capable of figuring out what the user is like? What will breaks exactly? Is it just retargeting?
- definitelyhuman 6y agoThat’s the right question, and it doesn’t seem clear yet. FB will have iOS 14 specific ad accounts due to how different everything is, and I’d expect CPA, VO, and LAL + retargeting to be neutered They aren’t losing their audience for impressions, or their targeting data for FB users - unless shadow accounts won’t work as well, but I’m not sure how that data is gathered. The removal of IDFA and shimming SKAdNetwork between the app and ad networks means the ping back of rich app usage is useless, which is what breaks more advance campaign types. Traffic, app install, engagement etc will still be valid, and you should still be able to use existing FB audience details since that’s backed by FB usage data. So I’d guess the impact depends on your ad type usage, and how you target users. Targeting parents in specific geos should work fine on IG and FB. FAN is going to suffer though since it doesn’t have FB account backing and relies on IDFA
- nojito 6y agoThe interesting part of this campaign is that targeted advertising doesn’t even work. I wonder how Google and Facebook will fare when that becomes common knowledge.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoI think you are right but I have no data only analogy. It feels like when your new girlfriend tries to buy you a Christmas gift based on your interests, but because you are so deep into the esoterica of your passion it is near impossible for her to get you something you don't already have or have already passed over. At least with the gift it was the thought that counted. ;-)
- cmlars 6y ago> Without personalized ads, Facebook data shows that the average small business advertiser stands to see a cut of over 60% in their sales for every dollar they spend. It seems like the not-so-thinly veiled complaint is that Facebook wants to change what they’ve been charging but that their service will no longer provide the value it once did. That doesn’t sound like an Apple problem to me.
- frouge 6y agoJust saw a green dot in my iPhone toolbar while scrolling in Instagram, meaning Instagram looks at me when I watch at pics... Boy I'm about to delete my account, haven't found the button yet because it's well hidden, but trust me, I'll do it! (haha)
- SeriousM 6y agoOn the German language we have the word "gratis" that's equal to "for free". It's heavily used in advertisements like "get this phone gratis and for 0 € (but pay 29€ per month)". I don't trust advertisements and never did. I hate it how the customer gets lied to with every word, sound and visual. Facebook is nothing different, they are a company kept up for selling ads. I not mad at them, it's just hard to ignore them when they start to cry because they try to lie to their customers...
- majewsky 6y agoGerman does a better job of separating the words for free as in speech ("frei") and free as in beer ("gratis", "kostenlos", "umsonst"). But curiously, it's exactly the other way around for "einfach", which has two drastically different meanings ("easy" and "simple") that Germans tend to conflate because German only has one word for it. </linguistics-funfact>
- SeriousM 6y agoYou're absolutely right! In English it's easy for me to distinguish the meanings but in german it's hard to find the difference and to find alternatives.
- fossuser 6y agoI land on the Apple side of this argument, but the best defense of Facebook comes from Ben Thompson’s Stratechery. He does a podcast with John Gruber so they’ll likely talk about it at some point. Privacy Labels and Lookalike Audiences: https://stratechery.com/2020/privacy-labels-and-lookalike-audiences/ https://stratechery.com/2020/privacy-labels-and-lookalike-au...
- sneak 6y ago> It’s actually quite interesting that Apple does not force software updates, or perform them in a hard-to-disable-or-detect manner. Since at least iOS 14, automatic updates are defaulted to on in the out of box setup flow, and it's up to you to go in and turn them off, several screens later in the settings app once the OOBE is complete. It tells you it's doing this but offers no ability to opt out. Subsequent updates have restored the autoupdate switch to on, explicitly reverting my choice. It's now part of my iOS point release update checklist to ensure that autoupdates are disabled. I don't think Gruber is being entirely up-front here. Apple very aggressively wants all iOS devices on the latest supported version.
- 3gg 6y agoThis guy is an Apple fanboy. How can you even argue in favour of its "privacy protections" when the OS has embedded advertising IDs you can only reset but not remove, logs and reports every application you launch to the motherboard, etc? The FB case is embarrassing, but let's not also drink the Apple kool-aid too.
- agloeregrets 6y agoThe embedded advertising is is designed to be a single point of data that resets on its own so that advertisers can only use it for fingerprinting. It’s a thin line to protect privacy without scaring away the whole industry and dear god, the Android situation is much, much worse.
- 3gg 6y agoLet's not kid ourselves; an OS with an advertising ID is an assault on people's privacy and basic computing freedoms. The android situation is much worse, yes, but apple is still giving in to surveillance capitalism and nothing they do short of staying away from it can be regarded as a "privacy protection". Their advertising ID endorses surveillance, it does not protect you from it.
- dh2424 6y ago"The information used for tracking belongs to the users whose behavior and interests is being tracked" I don't understand why this should be considered true. If I had a business and I jotted down in a notebook how rich I guessed each customer was as they walked in, based on things like what they're wearing and what they bought, and then used that to determine how rich I thought my average customer was, why would that information belong to anyone else but me?
- criddell 6y agoIn some places, following a person around and building up a dossier on them is considered stalking and is illegal.
- dh2424 6y agoTrue, but I'm talking about the data collected specifically. Not all of it is gained from tracking users across the internet - lots of it is just building a profile based on what you do on their site, and potentially their partners' sites. That data doesn't seem to me to be owned by the users. But I totally agree that what is an obvious problem is the following of users around the web.
- annadane 6y agoYou know, I think there's a number of separate issues in general. Assume the tracking and collecting of personal data from other sites is fine, that there's nothing wrong with it. They could still a) not try to buy up all their competition and b) not pollute the feed with things people don't want to see. Why should clicking 'interested' in an event broadcast it to all my friends? Why do I get pages in my feed my friends commented on? One action in particular may not tell you anything about the company but when you keep getting predatory behavior it maybe says something about how the company (or 'engagement engineers' or whatever) views the public
- coldtea 6y ago>There’s nothing “forced” about the software update Facebook is talking about either, which, I think, is going to be iOS 14.4. It’s actually quite interesting that Apple does not force software updates, or perform them in a hard-to-disable-or-detect manner This part is bogus, and Gruber knows it. The update might not be "forced" in its installation, but it's forced in many other ways (Apple stops signing old versions, quickly moves on, new phones can't install it, you can't revert back, etc). Forced updates are neither good nor bad in themselves, for me. For one, they help move the platform forward faster, bring everyone to the same page, and serve to land new features which is good (as a counter-example, remember how long Windows XP or IE6 took to die, with tons of security and compatibility issues dragging the platform behind?). On the other hand, they can potentially break features someone depends on, or introduce new bugs. Same at OS X. Sure, you can stay 2-3 releases behind. But often those releases are not supported on new devices, they stop getting updates fast, and new third party programs assume you have the new version and even require it. It's not like Windows, where you can stick with a 10-15 year old version and still be fine. In MacOS after 2-3 years, you're stretching it! In any case, the forced updates are a clear tradeoff, coming from two different ideas about how an OS (move fast, be opinionated and ocassionally break things vs always-be-compatible-and-flexible). Gruber to say iOS updates aren't forced is misingenuous.
- radley 6y ago> The update might not be "forced" in its installation It's forced passive-aggressively. Update notifications are sent daily, sometimes 2-3x in a day. There's no opt-out or blocking the system notification. Users can only defer and the defer options change each time.
- coldtea 6y ago>It's forced passive-aggressively. Update notifications are sent daily, sometimes 2-3x in a day. There's no opt-out or blocking the system notification. You can however set the system to manual update, and you wont see any notification.
- 6y ago
- Triv888 6y agoHow can a post with 453 points posted only 5 hours ago not be on the front page? Currently # 37 another post's stats: 26. Cyberpunk 2077: How 2020’s biggest video game launch turned into a shambles (theguardian.com) 126 points by helsinkiandrew 15 hours ago | hide | 209 comments You need to give less weight to flagging, maybe?
- wilhow 6y agoLook at the verbiage of the ad, Facebook lost its way. It needs to be replaced.
- kgin 6y ago> Apple’s change will limit their ability to run personalized ads. To make ends meet, many will have to start charging you subscription fees... It's pretty audacious for Facebook to try to protect its 42% profit margin / $70 billion yearly profit with a story about the little guy just trying to make "ends meet".
- edmundsauto 6y agoFor the sake of accuracy, FB's recent margin has been 28-35%, and the $70B number was 2019 revenue, not profit. They made $18B profit in 2019, and look to do around $25B profit this year.
- stephie2514 6y agoFor 2021, we have great things in the pipeline, with new and enhanced tools and resources to help you improve the performance of your app or game to reach a wider audience.
- messo 6y agoThis ad from Facebook reads like something an abusive partner would say to force the abused not to leave them.
- greyhair 6y agoI guess Facebook wouldn't be happy with tab containers I use in Mozilla, or the pihole I use for DNS.
- urza 6y agoI sometimes forget there are ads on the internet.. occasionally when I am on new devices without blockers set up and I see the ad layer net, it feels so dystopian.. almost unreal..