10 ms·
An interesting offering from Amazon that is crippled by Apple and MacStadium, who deserve to be raked over the coals for their recent EULA changes. Just read th
by saagarjha 6y ago
An interesting offering from Amazon that is crippled by Apple and MacStadium, who deserve to be raked over the coals for their recent EULA changes. Just read the post on MacStadium's blog: https://blog.macstadium.com/blog/developers-big-sur-and-vindication https://blog.macstadium.com/blog/developers-big-sur-and-vind...
Under the new agreement, you must:
* Rent to only one organization
* Rent for 24 hours at the minimum
* Use it for some set of "approved" development work
…among other restrictions. And Brian Stucki is celebrating these changes?! This is a sick joke. You're enjoying a significantly tightened EULA that benefits nobody but yourself, a EULA that means that a single CI build now costs $26 on AWS instead of 50 cents; one that means that more than half the comments here are confused why AWS is ripping people off.
Shame on you Brian Stucki, shame on you MacStadium, and shame on you Apple. Your EULA changes are absurdly hostile to developers, since now they're either going to have to buy Macs themselves or rent from MacStadium-like services. Shame on you both for colluding together for making this situation horrible and then having the guts to write that blog post.
I can't believe I'm saying this, but Amazon, I feel so sorry for you. You didn't deserve this.
- pjmlp 6y agoMaybe those companies should focus their business in countries where EULAs have zero legal value, like EU countries.
- jraph 6y agoThough some of their statements probably don't apply, I think EULAs apply in EU. Software license do apply. Software patents are still not recognized, let's hope this continues for a long time.
- punnerud 6y agoEULA apply, but there is legislations in EU that make terms prohibiting you from reverse engineer, sell, rent or automating null and void.
- hnlmorg 6y agoEULAs definitely apply in the EU. As do software patents. But as always, things are a bit more complicated than either you or pjmlp summarised. eg - EULAs cannot deny permissions that are allowed under consumer rights. - It's also worth adding that software licences behave slightly differently to EULAs in that software licenses are designed to provide additional rights above what copyright laws typically allow (this is particularly true in the case of open source licenses) where as EULAs are often (though not always) designed to place restrictions on top of existing consumer rights. Hence why they're often considered invalid. - I'm not 100% on this specific point as it has been a few years ago since I've investigated it but there was once some contention about whether it's even legal to place a licence agreement to the user after said user has already purchased the product. However companies could still use an EULA to revoke support -- much like a company can revoke warranty if they suspect the device has been opened up (eg the tamper strips). The rules here might have been clarified in court since I've last investigated this point though. - "The European Patent Convention states that software is not patentable. But laws are always interpreted by courts, and in this case interpretations of the law differ. So the European Patents Office (EPO) grants software patents by declaring them as "computer implemented inventions"." source: https://fsfe.org/activities/swpat/swpat.en.html https://fsfe.org/activities/swpat/swpat.en.html - Even the FSFE (Free Software Foundation Europe) quote above only tells half the story regarding Software Patents within the EU. There are some restrictions on what counts as a "computer implemented invention" plus also there are also national level patent offices that override the EPO at a local level. Wikipedia has some good summaries about this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patents_under_the_European_Patent_Convention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_patents_under_the_Eur...
- himinlomax 6y agoEULA may not have much if any force in some jurisdiction, but that's typically for private individuals. Corporations can reasonably be expected to have lawyers to understand legalese, for one. Not saying the EULA would definitely be enforceable, just that it's not that simple in this case.
- casperb 6y agoAs far as I know, before these changes selling virtualized macOS was not allowed at all. That is what Brian was celebrating, to see some approval.
- saagarjha 6y agoAs far as I am aware, the new changes are clarification to the old terms, which didn't really say much at all. The situation where you have a clear "no" is significantly worse than the one where there's no specific rule prohibiting it. Many companies can and have decided that the latter was good enough to offer a service off of; no company with a competent legal department is going to offer such a service now.
- wut42 6y agoIt is still not allowed to virtualize macOS and rent that virtualized macoS: lease hardware and software ”in its entirety to an individual or organization”
- QuinnyPig 6y agoI really fail to see what Brian Stucki did wrong? He’s subject to the whims of Apple licensing way more than AWS is.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe license changes basically allow nobody other than MacStadium to exist–throughout the blog post he gloats about how their business model is a hand in the new EULA's glove. And, of course, MacStadium been in contact with Apple to work this out, as he mention at the end. What has clearly happened is Apple asked them what the EULA should look like, or suggested a EULA based on what MacStadium is doing, and they went along with it. There is no way they didn't know that this would hurt everyone else's business (actually, he mentions this in the article, so he is writing this with full knowledge of that fact). Even if MacStadium was not involved in this at all, making a blog post about a change that hurts your competitors and talking about how you are somehow better than them and deserve to exist is remarkably poor taste.
- markonen 6y agoApple's angle here is that everybody who needs a Mac has to buy or rent one. That seems super obvious. It also happens to align them with people who are in the business of selling or renting Macs, sure. But the point is not to screw AWS or MacStadium's competitors. The point is to sell Macs.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe obvious side effect of selling more Macs is that it hurts AWS and MacStadium's competitors. Developers don't want to buy more Macs from Apple that they don't need. Apple knows this and has known this for decades and so their actions are essentially the same as telling developers to suck it up and buy new Macs.
- mosselman 6y agoWhich isn’t strange, seeing as their business is selling macs. Having a Mac is not some fundamental right or essential for survival. It is just a product.
- mbreese 6y agoThe thing that Stucki is celebrating can be summed up with this line from the blog post: > I’m happy to have an absolute guideline from Apple Before this, it was a legal grey area. Now at least the rules are spelled out and are clear. More importantly, they are the same for everyone. I think we could all argue over what the "right" limits might be (or if there should be any), but at least MacStadium, AWS, and whomever else wants to rent out cloud-based Macs now know where they stand.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe legal gray area where Apple specifically called out their service by name in a presentation and how great their Mac Minis would be for their usecase?
- kgantchev 6y agoWho else was offering Mac Mini rentals prior to this change? MacStadium appears to be the only major player in the space prior to Amazon jumping in.
- oefrha 6y agoMacminicolo has been around since at least 2005. They were acquired by MacStadium in 2016 though.
- kgantchev 6y agoMacminicolo appears to have been Brian Stucki's company (as he said in his original post) and it was acquired by MacStadium: https://blog.macstadium.com/blog/macstadium-and-macminicolo https://blog.macstadium.com/blog/macstadium-and-macminicolo
- oxfordmale 6y agoAWS are offering the first ever officially supported macOS virtualisation, I would call that a milestone. Given the costs, you would only use these instances for "approved" development work only. It is aimed at larger companies where maintaining a MacBook Mini build server is relatively expensive. Such companies will be using more than one instance of a MacBook mini to have a level of redundancy in case of a failure. If they are used in earnest, such instances would have to be replaced at least every year with old instance disposed off professionally (scrambling hard drive contents, etc). Yes the instances are expensive, but there is a definitely an use case for these.
- kbumsik 6y ago> AWS are offering the first ever officially supported macOS virtualisation AWS is offering dedicated bare metal Mac Minis for rent with virtual NICs and virtual storage powered by AWS Nitro, there is no macOS virtualisation.
- sudhirj 6y agoTechnically no, but the word has come to mean something different. Because even bare metal instances come under the same APIs, security, architecture and usage model as the other "real" VMs, the difference is very slim now. We can think of them as VMs of a specific size with a minimum billing time and get on with using them with our existing tooling.
- saagarjha 6y agoVirtualization means virtualization. Nobody's changed the definition of a VM.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y ago> but the word has come to mean something different No, it hasn't. If you're using "VM" to include bare metal, then you are using the wrong term for something. The definition of the word "virtualization" has not changed.
- 6y ago
- em500 6y agoNot a lawyer, I do wonder if such terms would hold up in court. I can see the case for EULA around virtualization when you're running multiple instances of macOS. But say I just buy a bunch of Mini's and rent (full access to) them out (bare metal, full system) per hour, rather than 24hr. Or for non-"development" work, whatever that means. Could Apple really put up a good case in court? It seems unlikely that they could successfully sue me if I buy a bunch of Macs and give some people physical time-limited access (say, students in a classroom). What makes the difference? Remote access? Charging rent? I'm not sufficiently invested in these matters for a deep dive, so hoping someone with legal knowledge could chime in.
- tiborsaas 6y agoThis does sound absurd, how would people react if a car manufacturer would try to raise arbitrary limitations against car rental businesses?
- est31 6y agoInevitably, this inconsistency will be resolved, but not in the way you or I would like. Tesla is already removing features that previous owners unlocked at sale of the car.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- m3at 6y agoIt sounds absurd, but NVIDA has been doing it for a few years, so it certainly can be done...
- dannyw 6y agoYou’re describing the first sale doctrine. Unfortunately, it doesn’t apply to digital licenses; at least not today.
- syshum 6y agoDepends on if the courts look at this as a hardware issue or "digital" software one. I have a feeling they would look at like renting physical hardware in which the first sale doctrine would absoltely apply. of course like with anything in the legal system it will take a company like Amazon that has their own team of $1,000/hr lawyers to face up against Apple's team of $1,000/hr lawyers in order to get a precedent setting case
- BillinghamJ 6y agoThis seems like an absolutely bizarre take on the situation. You don't really think Apple added those EULA terms for MacStadium now right? They were clearly added for AWS! MacStadium just happens to be happy that there's crystal-clear red lines. These rules are 100% down to Apple, absolutely nothing to do with AWS and MacStadium in terms of decision-making. Apple don't want the perceived value of their machines to become lower, want to make sure there's no possibility of performance issues due to multiple tenancy, and want to make sure this doesn't become a way for people to have a personal Mac without having a Mac. Maybe in another year or two, assuming nothing came out of this which Apple didn't like, they might loosen the rules slightly.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe terms seem to be a perfect fit for MacStadium and a poor fit for everyone else, including AWS. Do you think AWS wants to bill by the second…with 24 hours up front? Does this match their business model at all? It's really not Apple's business to try to protect people from "performance issues due to multiple tenancy". People who buy these things already know how this works.
- BillinghamJ 6y agoNo I'm sure AWS don't want it either. And it absolutely is 100% typical of Apple to do this kind of thing. They don't want third party companies to provide offerings which might cause them problems or degrade their brand/perception. I'm not at all saying these terms were added to benefit AWS. More that they were a condition of Apple doing this first official cloud partnership.
- skohan 6y agoIt's also 100% in line with Apple's recent trends of being hostile to developers. It's absolutely absurd to have to rent an server for 24 hours to do a single build. It's incredibly wasteful to have this much hardware sitting around and doing nothing.
- BGStucki 6y agoBrian Stucki here. If I had the power over Apple that you think I do, I definitely would have pushed for iPhone Socks first. Joking aside, the software license agreement was certainly a cause for personal celebration. It might be helpful for you to compare macOS 11 to previous versions. (Linked in my post.) If I/MacStadium did anything, we showed that there was a need for this sort of service and that both Apple and developers would benefit with some official way to do it. Amazon joining is further proof of that. I’ve always pushed for the safe road at MacStadium (and my company Macminicolo before that) even if it meant losing out on gray area business. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve answered “but what if Apple shuts this service down?” Not anymore. With the new Eula, the guidelines are now set. Doing everything above board paid off.
- lultimouomo 6y agoI get that you're happy because Apple has now explicitly permitted what you were doing. I'm less clear on why you're happy that they didn't allow more stuff, like renting by the minute or for arbitrary purposes. You seem to depict companies that were doing this as "below board", while you as "above board". This is certainly true now, but before the changes both would have been a grey area - I don't see much of a difference. Would I be correct saying that you're happy because in one stroke Apple has moved you from grey area to explicitly permitted, and part of your competition from grey area to explicitly forbidden? For the record in no way I think that Apple took this decision to favor you or anyone else except themselves. It just seems that you won a regulatory lottery.
- hobby-coder-guy 6y agoWhy did you say he is happy that apple “doesn’t allow more stuff”?
- pbronez 6y agoRegulations benefit incumbents. That holds whether the regulations are national laws or corporate policies. When you make new rules, the established ecosystem adapts and doubles down while new players have a harder time getting started.
- sydd 6y agoLuckily there are still cloud services that you can use for iOS CI like Bitrise.
- vishnuharidas 6y ago...or Codemagic.io
- shaicoleman 6y agoLink to Apple's EULA: https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/macOSBigSur.pdf https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/macOSBigSur.pdf Under: "Leasing for Permitted Developer Services"
- wayneftw 6y agoThe EULA applies to leasing the whole OS. I don't need a whole virtual Mac to run CI jobs. It doesn't sound like there's anything stopping anyone from offering a Mac CI job runner that gets shared with multiple organizations at the same time.
- em500 6y agoThere are some fairly broad usage restrictions in section 1.J.[1]. Except as otherwise permitted by the terms of this License or otherwise licensed by Apple: (i) only one user may use the Apple Software at a time, and (ii) you may not make the Apple Software available over a network where it could be run or used by multiple computers at the same time. You may not rent, lease, lend, sell, redistribute or sublicense the Apple Software. Make of it what you will. https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/macOSCatalina.pdf https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/macOSCatalina.pdf
- strobe 6y agoif I've mac with accepted EULAs and share it via network to wife, kids or neighbor (might be even wife/neighbor used it to do some business activities) - how it does works from legal perspective? is it will viewed as EULA violation?
- himinlomax 6y agoWhy do they restrict the use to development work?
- amelius 6y ago> and shame on you Apple > (...) > either going to have to buy Macs Why not ditch the entire Apple ecosystem while you still can? Show them that we, developers, don't like feudal lords that like to tell us what we can and cannot do with our systems. So others won't dare to copy them.
- ftio 6y agoBecause there's money to be made by not "ditching the entire Apple ecosystem." If you were able to run a business that was fun, that made you money, and that enabled you to help other people have fun and make money (i.e., your employees), would you not do that out of principle? I'm genuinely asking.
- amelius 6y ago> Because there's money to be made by not "ditching the entire Apple ecosystem." That's very shortsighted. You can make money without Apple. And by doing so, you show that you value open, generic compute systems. Also, the prosperity of your business won't be at the whim of Apple.
- ftio 6y agoYou could also make money by selling paperclips or by creating satellite constellations. Which path you choose comes down to interest, expertise, and luck/chance. All businesses have constraints. In this business, you're subject to the Apple EULA. In others, you're subject to government regulation or pricing pressure due to commoditization. That's not short-sighted — no industry is forever, and there's money to be made now. Why not deploy their expertise toward financial success (and, presumably, fun)? There's demand for these services — someone's going to fill it. For folks who don't value 'open, generic compute systems' over 'putting food on the table', the closed nature of Apple's ecosystem is just the reality they need to deal with. They're not making a moral tradeoff, just a practical one. Are you suggesting MacStadium and co should shut down their businesses out of principle? Will you employ them once they do? Where will their customers go?
- Spooky23 6y agoA little dramatic, eh? Apple obviously doesn't want companies like AWS to be renting Mac Minis as some sort of VDI solution. That's consistent with the (shitty) practices of Microsoft with respect to Windows, which confines Windows 10 hosting to Azure services. Given the nature of Mac, an AWS MacOS service is unique in that it's very clear who the manufacturer of the underlying hardware is. Apple, given it's control-freak nature wanted to have a model that accommodated both their needs and the provided a clear, multi-provider model to do what developers need.
- hobs 6y agoMicrosoft simply doesn't do what you are saying. Windows 10 hosting is not confined to azure services, you can even bring your own license to AWS, or host your own terminal services, or run your own virtual apps, or literally anything.
- Spooky23 6y agoI was imprecise in my wording. You cannot bring a shared Windows 10 virtual desktop to any provider that is not Microsoft Azure. Azure uses a delivery model based on tech for education customers that allowed 4-5 K-12 students to work from 1 PC via thin clients, and that model is only available on Azure. (And it's really cheap.) If you do BYOL of Windows 10 on a non-Azure cloud service, you need to meet specific Microsoft EA requirements, and you must run on dedicated hardware. If you look at the AWS BYOL model for Workspaces, it very similar in cost to the Apple on AWS model. (https://aws.amazon.com/workspaces/pricing https://aws.amazon.com/workspaces/pricing)
- eric_cc 6y agowow man. Get a life. This is such a dramatic reaction. Is this hurting you somehow?
- 013a 6y agoThe wording and language in that blog post is absolutely wild. Its demonstrably and undeniably better to have access to smaller virtualized Mac instances, or per-hour/per-second billing, or general use. Undeniably. There is literally no cogent argument I can think of to the opposite, on any of these points, but I understand why Apple is making these guidelines; If I had to follow them, I wouldn't be happy about it, but similar to the App Store guidelines you just gotta do what Apple wants. That post exudes happiness at the guidelines, like an oil company that just got a regulation passed banning solar energy. I understand the happiness at finally getting validation that Apple is alright with this business model, but that's separate from exuding happiness at the terms of that validation.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't do the "shame on" trope on HN. We don't want the online shaming culture here (https://hn.algolia.com/?query=online%20shaming%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true https://hn.algolia.com/?query=online%20shaming%20by%3Adang&s...). The vast majority of the time, situations are complex than internet users think they are. There are two sides to every story, &c. It's fine to make your point, but please stick to the HN rules and make it substantively and thoughtfully. The fact that rage rants get heavily upvoted makes this more important, not less. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThank you for taking the time to write that! The comment was rubbing me the wrong way when I first saw it, but I wasn't able to put my finger on why, because I agreed with all of the individual points expressed.
- saagarjha 6y agoYou're right, of course. As I mentioned downthread, I was somewhat angry when I wrote this; Brian has stepped in to provide more detail from his side. I'm still a bit resentful, but I understand that displeased or not ranting on Hacker News is not something I should have done. I'm not ready to apologize to the people I included for the concerns I mentioned yet, but I am sorry (both to them and Hacker News itself) for commenting in this way. The blog post gave me a specific set of things to be mad at and I let that get the best of me.