10 ms·
SARS-CoV-2 concentrations and virus-laden aerosol distributions in outdoor air
- dgritsko 6y agoThe study makes several references to "crowded" areas, and concludes that outdoor air is "safe" apart from these spaces. However, I was unable to find any clarification for what constitutes a "crowded" space (or not). I am not sure what the benefit of this study is supposed to be absent such a definition - am I missing something?
- umvi 6y agoI would assume "crowded areas" are areas where there are more than 1 person per [pi * <social distance recommendation>^2] So as a rough example, let's say social distancing recommendation is 6ft (this changes by jurisdiction). Then for a football field to be "crowded" you would need more than 57,600 / (pi * 36) = ~510 people evenly distributed on it. If the social distancing recommendation is 20ft, then you can only have 57,600 / (pi * 400) = 45 people on the football field before it starts getting crowded.
- everdrive 6y agoYour assumption is certainly a good one, but this should really be called out explicitly in the article. Perhaps the authors have a different idea about what constitutes a "crowded area."
- ummonk 6y agoWell this assumes uniform spacing between people. In reality it would be somewhat Poisson-like.
- DominikPeters 6y agoMy reading is that the authors were unable to find any air with appreciable COVID levels, but they’ve just added the caveat that maybe they didn’t find a sufficiently crowded area to take a sample.
- umvi 6y agoI've been stopped and scolded by "concerned citizens" before (even recently) for going on runs/hikes without wearing a mask... I tried to explain how outdoors masks are only really necessary where social distancing isn't possible and crowd density is high but they seemed to think I was just an anti-masker. At least now I can point to an actual study, for whatever good it will do...
- strogonoff 6y agoI saw a video where a person, walking alone on an apparently empty sidewalk, is not scolded but harassed for not wearing a mask (there is a mask, just not worn). The harasser was the one proudly filming their heroic act. (Addendum: there’s the obvious question, why not just wear a mask 100% of the time? There are no downsides, right? — There can be. Perhaps my mask had been in use for a while, I suspect it’s gotten dirty enough to be a potential health hazard, but I don’t have another mask to replace it? I’d still use it if people are around, but would try to reduce my exposure to it otherwise. Maybe I have asthma or some type of breathing difficulty, and wearing a mask makes it worse? I think those two are probably among the most common reasons.)
- deadmutex 6y agoThis seems like it risks having an opposite effect.
- pan69 6y ago> The harasser was the one proudly filming their heroic act. This behavior seems to be part of Call Out Culture. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2e9VYf9FKHo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2e9VYf9FKHo
- jhardy54 6y agoFor anyone interested in 'cancel culture' sans the reactionary right-wing propaganda: https://youtube.com/watch?v=OjMPJVmXxV8 https://youtube.com/watch?v=OjMPJVmXxV8
- NickBusey 6y agoOne day after LA county shuts down all outdoor restaurant dining, with no relief/bailout for service industry businesses or workers in sight. https://la.eater.com/platform/amp/2020/11/22/21590433/coronavirus-los-angeles-covid-19-closure-restaurants-outdoor-dining-public-health-order https://la.eater.com/platform/amp/2020/11/22/21590433/corona...
- mikeyouse 6y agoThe Federal Government is completely failing here. States can't run deficits, usually by force of law. They'd rather confirm judges than pass legislation to help, all of this damage is completely self-inflicted.
- bargl 6y agoIt's still a valid concern. The government has mandated these businesses shut their doors it should also mandate that they get the assistance needed (which I'm hoping will come next year). Small businesses can't afford a lot of the overhead of shuttering their doors and still paying mortgages etc. The employees there can't afford it either. I'm not saying it's a bad/good call by leaders. I'm just saying if you are mandated to shut your business, you should be able to "turn off" the economic issues associated with that. Mortgage gets extended, taxes get deferred, etc. This is definitely a weakness of pure capitalism in a regulation environment like today. We cant shut down a businesses income and expect their expenses to remain the same.
- 18pfsmt 6y agoIn a free market, the government doesn't have the right to take the decision away from the individual about how much risk they can tolerate. Some politicians infringing on the rights of others doesn't justify further intrusions on the natural rights of others.
- bargl 6y agoWe don't have a free market, or we wouldn't have fire departments, police departments, schools, military, funding for crops, or any government budgets. The idea that we are a pure free market is as absurd as saying that china is pure communism. There is no pure government out there that meets the academic definition of the market they espouse. It's just not possible, never has been, never will be (I usually don't speak in absolutes but feel pretty 99.999% comfortable with this statement). There will always be gray outside the academic setting.
- Karupan 6y agoGood to see some research on this. Where I live, mask rules have been relaxed outdoors as long as one can maintain social distancing. It is still mandatory to carry a mask with you everywhere should you run into a crowd and can’t maintain distance. I am still going to be wearing mine everywhere until I can get vaccinated.
- rebuilder 6y agoWow. Where is this, if I may ask? Here in Finland, there is no mandatory mask usage, largely because the government hasn't been able to find a constitutionally acceptable way of mandating it. Instead, we have increasingly stern "recommendations". OTOH, the situation is relatively well in hand here still, so I suppose the political pressure to act is not as heavy as it is elsewhere.
- Karupan 6y agoVictoria, Australia. It was relaxed just this Sunday after three weeks of no new cases and no community transmission. However given the progressive relaxation of rules over the past month, some of us are rightly concerned and choose to wear masks and avoid indoor venues whenever possible.
- WildGreenLeave 6y agoThe Netherlands has a mask rule that doesn't even require you to wear them inside with other people around. If I am not mistaken the requirement is that you are required to wear them when you cannot maintain the 1.5M distance, but that of course is just shifting the enforcement to the business owners instead of the government. In any other situation you are strictly recommended to wear them. I don't get why the Dutch government and the 'average' dutch person isn't wearing it all the time. People still consider it 'weird' to wear it and even in the capital city (Amsterdam) people look at me weirdly when I wear it outside. About 10% isn't wearing it in stores or even the airport is a place where people still skip out on the face mask. They should just enforce this rule instead of closing other places where it is actually possible to maintain the distance.
- tomisalive 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- krona 6y agoSimilar results to a paper (April, China), where of 1245 confirmed cases only 1 outbreak (involving 2 people) was found to have happened outdoors: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.04.20053058v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.04.20053058v...
- usrusr 6y agoIs virus exposure a threshold mechanism (some form of initial defense exists that gets saturated at some point) or is exposure to more virions simply the equivalent of a higher number of lottery tickets from the virus perspective? I seem to remember having read wording in one of the many papers that we surely all skimmed in 2020 that looked suspiciously like a statement declaring side in a scientific community that still considered both possible. (something like "We are working with the Independent Probability per Virion Assumption here" or something like that.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoI get the sense that it's reasonable, and perhaps understood, that the magnitude of exposure is correlated with severity.
- colechristensen 6y agoIs there really much of a difference between one and the other?
- tgb 6y agoThe "lottery ticket" model is additive: 100 minor exposures adds up. The "threshold" model isn't: 100 minor exposures is no risk.
- knaq 6y agoIt's not a threshold. For getting infected, it's like lottery tickets. For severity of infection, a bunch of "winning" lottery tickets make it difficult for your immune system to catch up. Getting a large exposure is like giving the virus multiple viral generations of a head start without being noticed by the immune system.
- nikolay 6y agoIt's a combo of both, actually!
- pizza 6y ago
- jhardy54 6y agoThese comments have vastly reduced my opinion of HN.
- justajot 6y agoMe too.
- dang 6y agoIn that case your opinion of HN may have needed some adjusting. Any large-enough population sample reflects the divisions in society at large—or societies, rather, since HN is a highly international site. There's no avoiding this. Sometimes when people get shocked by what they read here, the shock experience has more to do with encountering voices that (often loudly and/or at length, and sometimes even eloquently) express opinions we don't run into in our circles. We're all pretty good at siloing ourselves among the like-minded. Even when we're aware that a topic is divisive, we don't relate much with people on the other side of the divide. Mostly we label them as idiots or worse, and don't encounter them in their complexity. HN is a non-siloed site [1], meaning we're all in one big room here, so it doesn't work that way. The reality is that on any divisive topic, there are millions if not billions of people on the other side of the divide, a bunch of them are here, and they tend to be otherwise normal people whose different beliefs derive from their different backgrounds rather than them being idiots or worse. One might think that makes for an easier experience, but in fact it makes things much harder. I wrote a longer description of this a while ago if anyone is interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23308098 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23308098. Also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23716395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23716395. [1] https://hn.algolia.com/?query=silo%20by%3Adang&dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=silo%20by%3Adang&dateRange=all...
- marojejian 6y agoAnd my opinion of hacker news, already high, just got higher. Where else can you get to the very bottom of the comment thread for a random post, find one not particularly insightful or helpful comment, and then see it carefully replied to with intelligent and empathetic detail by the main curator of the service? Thank you dang. I hope you are going to give yourself a holiday.
- strogonoff 6y agoThere’s the obvious question, why not just wear a mask 100% of the time? There are no downsides, right? There can be. Perhaps my mask had been in use for a while, I suspect it’s gotten dirty enough to be a potential health hazard, but I don’t have another mask to replace it? I’d still use it if people are around, but would try to reduce my exposure to it otherwise. Maybe I have asthma or some type of breathing difficulty, and wearing a mask makes it worse? I think those two are probably among the most common reasons.
- fairity 6y agoI don't understand how the conclusion in the title can be drawn based on the data presented in the paper. Basically, the researchers sampled 2 outdoor locations, and found low viral loads. Why is it reasonable to conclude that all outdoor non-crowded areas are safe? I assume that not all outdoor environments are created equal. Variables like weather, wind, humidity, and population density probably all play a large factor in transmissibility. Certainly, more than 2 samples are required before making such a generalized conclusion?
- nextaccountic 6y agoThat's the last statement of the conclusion sections of the paper: > Considering a typical inhalation rate of about 1 m3/h, as average between rest and light exercise (Adams, 1993), the concentrations would be low to spread the contagion via airborne transmission even assuming the mentioned increase of a factor 2.
- fairity 6y agoYes, but the viral load measurements they're using were taken at only 2 different locations. I don't see why you would, then, feel confident in making a generalized statement about all locations.
- ummonk 6y agoThe paper was about aerosolized virus. The title here misleadingly implies any kind of outdoor transmission (including droplet not just aerosol transmission) is unlikely.
- nikolay 6y agoWe should all carry a weathervane with us and make sure that we're not in the received end of the airflow. Isn't it simpler to just freakin' wear lower-grade masks outside? I'm tired of self-entitled people who don't know why a saying like: "Better safe than sorry!" exists or "Hope for the best, plan for the worst!" Use common wisdom, and let's stop this redundant polemic about face masks as it only pours fuel into the fire and accomplishes nothing positive for the humanity!
- strken 6y agoMasks are one part of risk management, but they're not 100% effective. An effective strategy might involve wearing masks and social distancing and limiting how far you can travel and limiting the size of gatherings and banning indoor gatherings. Wearing a mask is in many ways a lot like using a keep-cup: effective, but highly visible and a distraction from other useful measures.
- nikolay 6y agoYou confuse "one part" with "the essential part"!
- strken 6y agoNo, I did not. Masks are around 67%[0] effective at protecting the wearer, but that's not enough to actually stop SARS-CoV-2 quickly, assuming it has an R0 somewhere around 3[1]. You cannot go about your day to day life like normal, wear a mask, and think you are doing your part, because 33% of 3 is still around 1, which means the number of infected will not be shrinking very quickly if at all. You MUST stop going to large events, visiting friends and family indoors, going to restaurants, and work from home if you are able. This cannot be stated enough. Masks are necessary but not sufficient. They are neither 100% effective, nor effective enough to rapidly control SARS-CoV-2, unless used in conjunction with other measures. [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02801-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02801-8 [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590053620300410 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259005362...
- ummonk 6y agoThe title is highly editorialized misinformation. The study is saying that aerosolized virus is pretty much nonexistent outdoors (as everyone expected - fresh air works), but does not deny droplet transmission outdoors, which is what social distancing and mask wearing is designed to prevent. From the abstract: "Transmission by contact or at close range due to large respiratory droplets is widely accepted, however, the role of airborne transmission due to small respiratory droplets emitted by infected individuals (also asymptomatic) is controversial"
- tomisalive 6y agoOnly terrorists wear masks.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI’ve paid very little attention but haven’t we known this for at least 4 months? Both the effectiveness of “indoor only” measures and the lack of spikes after BLM protests told us this. We also know it’s airborne, worse if you’re old, obese or diabetic (which effects the immune system so no surprise there). There seems to be a huge amount of effort and attention being put into covid research to reprove things we already knew. Is science always like this?
- spion 6y agoSo what happens if we put air purifiers with HEPA filter (1) indoors then? Has anyone measured this? (1) HEPA filters have good filtration efficiency even at particle sizes smaller than MPPS https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/high-efficiency-particulate-air-filter https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/high-effici... and an adequately powered one can recirculate room air in 10-15 minuters