10 ms·
A court ruling in Austria could censor the internet worldwide
- trowawayprivacy 6y agoThis has come up again because a terrorist attacked the center of the capital Vienna. The thing that makes this so incredibly ridiculous, is that the authorities actually knew the person tried to attend a IS training camp in Syria. They stopped him. So they knew very well about his intentions. Then a nearby state Slovakia told the Austrian authorities that this person was there and bout ammunition. The Austrian authorities did not further investigate and at the end he went to the center of Vienna and started shooting at people. The thing is, he also showed pictures on instragram or facebook with him holding guns. Now the EU representatives demand more censorship and want to end End-To-End encryption for the state by implementing a general key so that they can see any kind of encrypted messages. The proposed law also demands from platforms to implement a sort of filter to remove any kind of uploads that might be IP or maybe even offensive. I actually really like the ideology behind the EU. I think growing together and bringing the states together to strengthen the EU is great. But what is happening right now is pure authoritarian act that will hit anyone for the failure of authorities that would have had enough information and power from the beginning.
- st_goliath 6y ago> This has come up again because a terrorist attacked the center of the capital Vienna. No. Please read the article. This is about a law suit which has been going on for a few years. The case itself has absolutely nothing to do with recent events. Also, Austria does not have a case law system. Courts don't make laws (the constitutional court in Austria can strike down laws, but that's about it) and are not bound by previous court decisions. The fact that the supreme court ruled on it just means the decision on this case is final (as far as the Austria judicial branch is concerned). Besides, do you seriously believe a court could act based on something that happened 11 days ago? Have you ever dealt with a court? That said, I mostly agree with your ramblings, but that has simply little to no connection to the case and resulting problems discussed in the article.
- anigbrowl 6y agoJust flag it.
- choeger 6y agoThat's quite the problem we are in, as a global society. Obviously no one wants to give North Korea any say about what can and what cannot be published in the web. But between sovereign, free, democratic societies, different standards might exist. And if you want to do business with, say, the EU as, say, a US tech company you cannot expect US law and commons to apply everywhere. Then it becomes a race to the bottom indeed. I don't know a solution to this problem. But I also do not want to live in a world, where free speech is effectively limited by Austrian defamation laws and US prudery for everyone.
- YarickR2 6y agoYour statement about North Korea strikes me as a very discriminatory, as it implies your judgement about NK is somehow objective, and it's political system is a condition justifying them being denied equal treatment in various situations.
- dsr_ 6y agoNo, their judgement about NK is subjective but widely shared. It is perfectly reasonable to discriminate against political systems that you disagree with. It's pretty much the basis of international diplomacy, such as it is: a system of bargaining and coercion that usually prevents outright war.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe basis of international diplomacy isn't discrimination against systems you disagree with, it's about getting most power and resources possible. Caring about political systems is just spin used as an excuse. Indeed, the US at the same time went hard after Japan whose political system (even though in practice is barely it at all democratic) it created, but courted the Chinese one-party state. The rest is just rhetoric.
- puszczyk 6y agoOmg are you serious? Do you have any good things to say about NK political or judicial system? Would you defend Nazi Germany or Soviet Russia the same way?
- roadwarrior7822 6y agoThe title should be rephrased to "A Court Ruling in Austria Could Censor Internet Platforms Worldwide". The Ruling applies to Facebook as a legal person and has no direct effect on other publishers. A contrary example: The Gutenberg Project was ruled illegal (due to a select number of books still in copyright) in Germany and is blocking German IPs ever since, until the issue is resolved. Here the company has chosen another approach. Facebook could decide to withdraw from the Austrian market (which it won't). So it has to stick to Austrian court rulings or pay the sanctions. The problem is not the application of a law. The problem is the current centralization of public speech on huge platforms on the internet.
- bennysonething 6y agoDo you really see no problem with states demanding that their censorship laws apply world wide?
- eznzt 6y agoPeople here don't because the attitude here is "it's Facebook so fuck them".
- bennysonething 6y agoWhich I don't really understand, it's an attempt at global censorship, that's the concern. But as it's a ruling against Facebook the general impression I get is casual dismissal
- hahaiscjaaka 6y agoBecause people here are thinking based on principles and values shared by the majority. They are thinking based on elitism that thinks highly of itself for disliking facebook. The same happens in US politics, where people disregard the “common good” (you know, healthcare) because “muh freedom trump good obama bad”
- herbst 6y ago
- btown 6y agoI’m particularly worried about the requirement that posts with the “same essential meaning” be detected. Should this become precedent, must every startup now run Content ID systems... based on NLP and word embeddings? Can a company be held liable for not setting the threshold correctly and allowing even the slightest negative sentiment about a subject through? Can a politician sue to have all references to a certain cartoon bear be removed on the grounds that the references’ very existence is offensive? Can HN be sued for failing to detect my oblique reference above? This is a dangerously slippery slope.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoLet me introduce Austria to the "Streisand Effect".
- Glavnokoman 6y agoSo you are not concerned about massive Facebook censoring but is really worried about Austrian court decision which apparently takes 3 years per case? To be clear I am not saying there is no problem, I am saying the Austrian court decision is really the least of it. But honestly enabling any psycho to shout whatever for the whole world to hear is also a problem.
- johnp314 6y ago"...enabling any psycho to shout whatever for the whole world to hear is also a problem" How can I be sure that it's not you that is the psycho? How do I know that your "nothing to see here folks" comment is not sponsored by the re-elected leader of Belarus? I prefer to read your comment and decide for myself to ignore it rather than have it blocked upstream by court, i.e. government, order. But yes, I am concerned also by massive Facebook censoring as well.
- _trampeltier 6y ago3 years is not so long, sadly. In Switzerland, an deadly accident from a young worker, took such a long time to even start in the court, until it was barred. https://www.tagblatt.ch/ostschweiz/justiz-tod-in-der-garage-ld.1012020 https://www.tagblatt.ch/ostschweiz/justiz-tod-in-der-garage-...
- AdrianB1 6y agoThis is a red herring, just because FB is arguably doing bad things it does not mean we should accept other actors to do bad things.
- save_ferris 6y ago> The case started with an April 2016 Facebook post, in which a user shared an article featuring a photo of Eva Glawischnig-Piesczek, then-chair of Austria’s Green Party, along with commentary labeling her a “lousy traitor,” “corrupt oaf,” and member of a “fascist party,” apparently in response to her immigration policies. This is core, protected speech in the United States. But it was deemed defamation under Austrian law. This reminds me of the reporting done regarding Larry Pozner[0], a father of a Sandy Hook shooting victim that was subjected to constant accusations, doxxing attempts and death threats from conspiracy theorists for years and decided to take legal action. Fundamentally, I believe that everyone has the right to not be subjected to death threats and systemic harassment from hate and conspiracy groups, especially those who've lost children to such senseless and brutal killing. American individualism so often deflects the responsibility of dealing with such trauma on those who are subjected to this kind of harassment because it's not impacting the vast majority of the population ("not my problem"). It's clear that much of the Western world have had much stricter free speech laws than the US does for decades, but somehow they don't devolve into the Orwellian nightmare that we always fear when we talk about limiting free speech. In fact, has there been another Western democracy more tested and compared to Orwell's 1984 in the last 5 years than the US? I don't know what the exact solution to these problems is, but I truly people need to be responsible for what they post online. We as a society also have a responsibility to demand that of our peers because big tech has already shown us that they're not up to this challenge. The worse that harassment gets online, I believe the more segmented and walled off and commercialized the internet will become. 0: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/670/beware-the-jabberwock/act-one-4 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/670/beware-the-jabberwock/a...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI just don't see the equivalence here. I agree that platforms have a responsibility not to enable harassment and death threats, but calling a politician "traitor", "corrupt", "fascist" is neither of those things. What are you supposed to do when a politician is corrupt or fascist, if you aren't allowed to talk about it?
- damnencryption 6y ago
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoDidn’t France try this with their right to be forgotten [1]? How did that go? EDIT: Paris was told to go stuff it [2]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jul/30/google-rejects-france-expand-right-to-be-forgotten-worldwide https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jul/30/google-re...
- cinquemb 6y agoYeah, I've got emails from CNIL telling me that I needed to remove information I collected on french citizens and seeing how I wasn't operating in their jurisdiction, I just ignored them.
- jeltz 6y agoPretty well given how it is now part of GDPR.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> given how it is now part of GDPR Does GDPR try to assert extraterritoriality? Austria requiring information be scrubbed from the Austrian Google is one thing. Austria censoring America’s search results is another.
- s9w 6y agoJust for comparison: If you insult a green party member in Germany, the police will literally raid your home. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24981251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24981251
- anigbrowl 6y agoPretty sure there was more to the situation than that one-line summary.
- s9w 6y agoThe German article in the comments has more info, which states that some of the raids were for insulting a female German politician - which very likely means Renate Künast since she's been on a warpath down that line multiple times in the recent past. And she is a high ranking member of the green party.
- nelaboras 6y agoWhat a nonsensical article. Such power of courts already exists, but it mostly boils down to US law as most of the platforms are in the US. Think about the debates on photos of breastfeeding, a fully natural act that happens to show a part of the body that all humans possess. But as the US has a double standard where female nipples are sinful and obscene - and male nipples totally fine - a mom in Germany or France or Austria will not be able to upload such photos (similar to e.g. some regions in Africa where going topless is not unusual for women). Similarly if you dare use content of a US media organisation you'll get a global DMCA takedown. Even if you do e.g. a critique or it's playing as background in a video recorded in a public space, all of which are protected under most countries' legislation. Hell videos of families singing Happy Birthday are DMCAd as one of many american troll companies claims to own the copyright to the lyrics. On the other hand, gruesome and deeply intrusive/personal videos of e.g. murder or violence are tolerated on Facebook and similar sites as those are in the US context not undedstood to be harmful. In germany public holocaust denial can be punished with five years in prison (although it very rarely goes so far), but Facebook serves as wonderful breeding ground of conspiracy theories about Jewish world conspiracies and the holocaust being a lie. Cause "free speech" is final, even blatant falsehoods. I don't think a regional Austrian court should be the judge for the internet, but the only reason it is trying to take this role is because these sites' host country applies absurd laws (what's more harmful for a 15 year old to see, a beheading or some lady's nipples?) and the sites refuse to apply common sense. This lady was harassed quite intensely and Facebook refused to take action - that's the case here. So what's the solution? Some global court system? Agreed minimum standards? Companies localising content more? I have no idea, but its pretty clear that the US giants have a harmful effect not just on US but global public discourse as they refuse to address misinformation, lies, harassment, holocaust denial, etc etc
- nradov 6y agoFacebook does allow photos of breastfeeding. https://m.facebook.com/help/340974655932193 https://m.facebook.com/help/340974655932193
- zxcmx 6y agoUsers everywhere have had to put up with U.S law for a long time. The laws and norms of the USA are more or less "fully baked in". Try posting a nipple or copyrighted track, for example. If Facebook had come from a different place, all songs and body bits might be Ok but perhaps discussion of government would be banned. I can't tell if that would actually be a better facebook than the one we got.
- beepboop77 6y agoI think you don't give American companies enough credit when it comes to appealing to various countries laws and opinions. It is disingenuous to say Europe or the rest of the world does not care about copyright when they have historically and increasingly laws that are as strict if not stricter than the US' when it comes to preventing copyright infringement. [1][2] Nipples do reflect American sensibilities although it is understandable that many companies do not want to go down that road as it could lead to becoming distributors of porn. I think you will find that many countries outside of Europe agree or don't think that these rules go far enough. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_Digital_Single_Market#Draft_Article_13_(Directive_Article_17) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_... [2] https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/06/33f524714d35-japan-enacts-copyright-control-law-to-ban-pirated-manga-downloads.html https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/06/33f524714d35-japa...
- the8472 6y ago> It is disingenuous to say Europe or the rest of the world does not care about copyright when they have historically and increasingly laws that are as strict if not stricter than the US' when it comes to preventing copyright infringement. [1][2] Those laws are to some extent pushed through by the US in international treaties on behalf of american copyright holders.
- pessimizer 6y agoThey're the obvious tariff required in every "free trade" treaty.
- legulere 6y agoNo it doesn’t. It just means if you offer a service in a country, you have to follow its laws. The problem is that we have huge multinational companies centralizing the internet.
- avhon1 6y agoIf I host my own website in the United States and post writing which is non-protected speech in Australia, might I be required to block Australian IP addresses from accessing it, or even to remove it altogether? Even though I don't have any Australian presence, my content is available in Australia, which might meet a standard for offering a service in Australia. I know this is not what this ruling is about, but it does bring reality closer to my hypothetical. Secondly, why should local laws be enforcable globally? Should Australia really be able to globally forbid speech which is prohibited in Australia? Facebook's initial response was to follow Australian rules in Australia, and geoblock the contested posts. According to this ruling, this is insufficient, and Facebook is required to block these posts, and "equivalent" content, globally. edit: I did indeed misread "Austria" as "Australia" throughout the entire article
- notimetorelax 6y agoThis seems symmetrical to me to all the cases where EU copyright violators or varying US national security threats would get extradited to the US for a trial.
- lopmotr 6y agoAustralia can and will block your website locally. That's the pressure for you to conform to their laws. You don't have to but they don't have to let their citizens access it either. If Facebook ignored other country's laws, they would find themselves excluded entirely, such as has already happened in places like China.
- Sniffnoy 6y agoMinor note: You mean Austria, not Australia.
- victorbstan 6y agoFree speech without universal free education is a mistake.
- generalizations 6y ago> universal Depends on who gets to choose the curriculum...don't assume it's people you like or fundamentally agree with. And, if you do put hard limits on the sort of things that should be taught - and from what perspective - then it really sounds like you're saying that in order to have free speech, people should be taught to agree with you. Edit: to be clear, I like both ideas. But coupling them, saying we shouldn't have one without the other, is dangerous.
- rcoveson 6y agoYour statement has a nice ring to it only because it takes advantage of the very confusing English word "free". In the "free speech" context, it's free as in liberty. In the "universal, free education" context, it's free as in beer; the implication being government funded and managed (and mandatory, implied by "universal"). So while your statement seems to be all about freedom, it's really about predicating one freedom on the restriction of another. Here's how I would rephrase your statement: "It's a mistake for the government to let people speak freely before they have been educated by the government." Which I think is significantly less compelling.
- AdrianB1 6y agoLogical exercise: 1. If it happened to FB it can happen to anyone else, especially to small companies or people with less financial power to fight in court. It means it can apply to the entire Internet presence in Austria. 2. If any country can do such a ruling, then the entire Internet (see #1) is either abiding to all rules, being reduced to almost zero, or cut out extreme countries. This means Austria should be excluded from Internet? In the end Internet interlinks come from neighboring countries and an Austrian court cannot force them to connect the country to the rest of the world. Not very sound logic, but the conclusion is quite scary to me.
- root_axis 6y agoFacebook is not "the internet worldwide", it is one website among hundreds of millions of websites available on the internet.
- josephcsible 6y agoThis really has nothing to do with Facebook. They just happen to be the website that got used to set the precedent. This can now happen on any of those hundreds of millions of websites that have any presence there.
- yesenadam 6y ago> Facebook is not "the internet worldwide" It's really not that simple. For most people in many countries[0], FB is the only internet they have. It comes packaged free with their phones. [0] I believe, dont have exact figures. I know from experience that it's true of a large majority of people in the Philippines.
- effnorwood 6y agoNo it can’t.
- rstuart4133 6y agoI am getting a little tired of the continual equating of FAANG companies with "the internet". This article is predicated on the assumption Austria asking Facebook to ban some comment about a greens politician means all such posting are banned from the internet. Clearly, they aren't. At worst, that comment might be banned from web sites owned companies operating in Europe. Obviously, there are a lot of web sites out there owned by people who won't care what Europe thinks. If you don't like any of them create your own. The "internet" is bigger than one site, or country, or even the EU. If you doubt that, just ask the MPA how they are going with eliminating links to pirated content from the internet. If you asked them in a bar, after a few drinks and out of earshot of their paymasters, I reckon there is a good chance you might even hear them say "it isn't possible". Or you could ask some UK pollie whether they think it's possible to prevent kids from seeing hard porn. I don't have to guess their response - they tried, and gave up.
- oldgregg 6y agoThe multinational tech companies are EXISTENTIALLY motivated to weaken and dissolve national identity for this very reason. Every country they operate in they will algorithmically and politically oppose any nationalist movement. The tech companies moved quickly and captured the vast majority of the world-- their greatest terror is that, like china, countries will realize that allowing an american company to monitor and manipulate their population might not be in the best interest of the people. The multinationals will do their best to influence and when necessary but off political leaders around the world. The war is just beginning.