14 ms·
Pixel 5 review: Google spends its bill-of-materials budget unwisely
- cowmix 6y agoI bought the 4a, on a lark, but it turns out I LOVE the phone. I ordered the Pixel 5 because I figured, worst case, I could give the 4a to kid when I get my 5. I got the 5 and almost immediately returned it. The 4a is just the best spend money on a cell phone for my needs. This is coming from someone who's owned every Google phone since the G1.
- whitepoplar 6y agoWhat made you return the 5?
- cowmix 6y agoThe top speaker is horrible, I actually like having a headphone jack and the $350 price is cheap enuff that if I upgrade my phone in less than 2 years, I don't feel like an idiot.
- knappe 6y agoWhat makes you love it more than say a 3? I loved the 1 and still have it lying around but I just can't say I love the 3 as much which is my daily driver now.
- cowmix 6y agoIf I had the 3 XL, I would have kept that. I was coming from the 2, and this phone is better in almost all ways (except for water resistance.)
- comeonseriously 6y agoI'm typically an iPhone user, but I, too, bought the 4a. I got it originally for a backup as well as just to have an Android phone again. It is now my daily driver. It's enough phone for me even if it doesn't have the iPhone's blistering speeds. I am pretty sure I won't be spending much more than $350 on a phone going forward. I just don't need anything more.
- nottorp 6y agoYeah, a decent mid range Android phone would be great but it must have stock Android otherwise decent is gone. That means only Google phones, and Google has been known to change their mind randomly. Can you rely on them having a decent mid range phone the next time you need a new phone? They could just go back to $1300 flagships by then.
- kmonsen 6y agoI guess the best way of making sure Google has a cheap phone is to buy them and hope that makes a difference? If nothing else you had the phone you wanted for a while, who knows what the future will bring.
- bosswipe 6y agoIf their was a 4a XL it would be the perfect phone for me. Instead, I haven't been able to find a phone that meets all my criteria: • unlockable bootloader, rootable • headphone jack • > 6.2" screen
- commoner 6y agoYou're probably looking for the Pixel 4a with 5G, which will be released in the US on November 19 for $499: https://store.google.com/product/pixel_4a_5g https://store.google.com/product/pixel_4a_5g It has a 6.2" screen, which is not > 6.2", but close enough. It also retains the Pixel 4a's headphone jack, and is rootable and has an unlockable bootloader like all Pixels.
- mekster 6y agoCan't believe that they name it 4a again with even a different form factor. Now if you want to Google for the difference between the original 4a, you get so much results from 4a 5G...
- henryfjordan 6y agoHow does the screen in the 4a compare to the 5? Could you tell any difference in quality?
- Jedd 6y agoI also picked up a 4a a couple of weeks ago, and really like it. This replaced my Pixel (1) XL. Screen size is effectively the same while the overall size is much smaller. Better performance, keeps the 3.5mm audio, and cheap enough (even here in AU) to not engender much hand-wringing before or after purchase. I don't drop my phones, or throw them into bags of sharp things - and always have a soft rubber case anyway - so screen scratches aren't my problem. Most of my calls are via a bluetooth headset. I don't care about 1 or 2mm delta on thickness. While Australia will embrace 5G in urban areas quickly, I spend most of my time 20km away from the nearest 3G antenna, so that feature's mostly irrelevant for me.
- claydavisss 6y agoGoogle can't survive on a phone they are practically giving away, while Samsung outsells everyone while charging $1k per unit.
- SippinLean 6y agoI've owned every one since the G1 as well and the the 4a is their best value since my $300 Nexus 4
- meowster 6y agoHad a Nexus 5 and a Nexus 5X. This is my first Pixel phone. Price is a bit higher than I think it should be, but otherwise I love it. I don't want a "premium" phone, I want a great all-around phone. This one is it for me. Google dropped the ball on the gap issue though. Mine doesn't have the problem, but I'm disappointed that others are having an issue with an otherwise great phone.
- drcongo 6y agoIs this really the only comment mentioning that massive gap between the screen and the body?!
- ehsankia 6y agoI think they spent it perfectly, up to mmWave, which btw is only in US (and maybe Australia?). They managed to add 2GB ram, double default storage to 128gb, increase battery by 50% and still make the phone $200 cheaper. It's the perfect BoM if it wasn't for mmWave. Paying $100 more for mmWave is ridiculous. That's a 15% price increase for something that most people don't need or care for. The fact that you can't buy the non-mmWave version in the US is what makes this a really bad decision. The same is not true for the 4a 5G, which is $500 on the Google Store without mmWave, but has a special $600 Verizon-only version you can get with mmWave. So I have no idea why they didn't do the same for the Pixel 5. Instead you are forced to buy the mmWave version even if you're getting the device through Google Store and will never use mmWave. Meanwhile here in Canada it's $800 CAD ($600 USD), so I'm happy I got the phone for a great price. That being said, if you don't care for 90hz display, wireless charging and waterproofing, 4a is definitely a fantastic deal at half the price.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe article points out that it’s slower than the 4a, which is half the price. That’s ... less than great.
- ehsankia 6y agoIn most benchmarks they are basically within the error margin, but I have indeed seen a few where Pixel 5 does strangely poorly. I am definitely curious to know what's causing that, Pixel 5 has a slightly newer version of the same chipset (765G/Adreno 620 vs 730G/Adreno 618). The two best guesses I have is either the waterproofing really messes up with the thermals, or there's some unlying bug causing bad performance in those specific benchmarks. That being said, in real-life use, unless you're playing some heavy games, phone devices are generally more memory bound than CPU bound in my experience, so the 2GB extra ram will go a long way.
- maven29 6y agoWaterproofing or not, phones are almost always effectively hermetically sealed from a convection point of view and do not rely on convection in any form for cooling. I do not see how waterproofing would interfere with conducting heat away.
- damnencryption 6y agoPixel 4a is the sweet spot for me. Small phone for 2020 standards and works just as I expect it to. I really love the casual design and how it feels in hand. I don't like the glass backs or pure metals. I don't want edge display. I don't care about wireless charging (why do people even feel it's necessary?). I would rather have faster cable charging. I want a practical phone. I don't care much about gimmicks. The new one plus has 3 useless cameras out of 4. They added two flash and extra cameras for marketing purposes. These little things added by the marketing departments only increase the amount you need to pay and make for a worse experience.
- shard 6y agoIt's super convenient for me to drop my phone in the phone holder when I get in my car and have it start charging, and to just take it out of the holder when I exit my car, without having to plug and unplug the phone. It's different from charging at home since when at home, I pick up and use the phone in my hand even while it's charging, so a wireless charger is less useful, while in a car the phone has to stay in the holder when I am driving, so saving the steps of having to plug and unplug makes sense.
- damnencryption 6y agoThat can be solved with magnetic usb type C charger docks.
- shard 6y agoAre you referring to the phone holder in the car? I can see how a phone holder with a magnetic charging cable can give similar functionality, with the addition that the home charger would also need to be magnetic so that there is no need to plug and unplug the adaptor. Also, I wonder how finicky aligning the magnetic connection would be in a phone holder -- it's has not been a problem with my wireless charger: either the wireless charger in my phone holder has pretty wide tolerances in alignment, or the holding clips were well designed, as I have not had any instances where it did not align and charge.
- 6y ago
- fourseventy 6y agoI loved the pixel 1. I used it from launch until it finally died on me a few months ago. I upgraded to the Pixel 4 and was really disappointed. My primary complaint is the lack of a fingerprint scanner, the face unlock is simply slower and less effective (especially now that I'm wearing a mask because of covid). With the fingerprint scanner on the Pixel 1 the phone was unlocked before i was even done taking it out of my pocket. The face unlock will never be able to match that. Im excited that the Pixel 5 reintroduced the fingerprint scanner. I am strongly considering tossing my new Pixel 4 and upgrading it to the 5.
- wffurr 6y agoThe 4a also has the fingerprint sensor. I think it was a big mistake to not include it on the Pixel 4, but that whole device was gimmicky and weird. Kind of the like the Pixel 5. Gimmicky and weird, but at least they put the fingerprint sensor back on it.
- modeless 6y agoI realize this opinion is very popular but I had the opposite experience. Fingerprint often took multiple tries or outright failed, while face unlock on Pixel 4 XL has been more reliable and plenty fast. Masks are really the only issue and personally I don't need them that often.
- meowster 6y agoIt sounds like the Pixel 5 fingerprint scanner might be hit-or-miss. A few people have reported it not reading fingerprints very well, and even for me, occasionally it doesn't work well (but most of the time it does).
- Tehhund 6y agoI traded in my Pixel 4 XL for a 5, and despite the 5's weaknesses that are laid out in the article I'm very happy with the switch. I'm running all the same apps but everything feels smoother. I'm not sure why but I'm not questioning it. And the huge battery is awesome.
- x87678r 6y agoI had a 6p and a Nexus 7 (I think) tablet, both were really disappointing and I vowed to never buy Google hardware again. OnePlus has been great, mostly stock android, cheap and reliable.
- shaicoleman 6y agoOnePlus has great software, great hardware and maintain software updates for a decent amount of time. It's what I'd recommend for people who want a phone that just works. That said, I have a Xiaomi 9T Pro myself because I wanted a phone without a notch/holepunch, a flat display and a 3.5mm jack.
- tjoff 6y agoA bit off topic but google keep their mouth shut on this issue. I've got a Pixel 4a and my camera doesn't work. (I have to wait 15 seconds before the "viewfinder" even shows an image and then it might update the picture once every third seconds (if I'm lucky) - completely unusable). And it seems to be a very common issue. The ratings on the camera apps tell that users of seemingly all pixel devices have had this issue since recent updates (for at least a month now). Not a word from google. I have no idea how to even figure out if this is a hardware or software issue. Anyone know anything about this?
- gecko 6y agoNope, but the fact that the Pixel 4a's screen glass is absolute shit compared to any other phone I've had means it scratches stupidly easily. This is kind of known, as far as I can tell, looking at forums, and Google notably was willing to let me RMA over it. Not a damage warranty, straight exchange. There being camera issues sounds entirely in line with that. I really, really miss my Pixel 3. It was easily my favorite phone. The 4a is simply not a match.
- londons_explore 6y agoGoogle engineers internally only really work on the latest device and next year's device. At this point, while you are technically supported, practically no bugfixes are coming your way. Return it and buy another phone.
- dont__panic 6y agoThe 4a is the latest phone in the "a" series, being the smaller version of the 4a XL. The phone came out in July 2020.
- kllrnohj 6y agoYou should skip to contacting support & getting a replacement. That's unlikely to be a software issue.
- mattlondon 6y agoI have to agree that the under-screen speaker in the pixel 5 is awful. I don't know where to "put my ear" every time I get a call, and as a result the audio quality for calls is terrible - muffled, muddy, unclear, awkward. Switch to speakerphone and it is like someone pulled cotton wool out of your ears so it is not like the network connection is poor, just the speaker. It has been a pain in the backside to use as a result since day one of getting it, and the times when I borrow someone else's phones I am just blown away by their "HD audio" they get compared to the pixel 5. What were they thinking. This must have been brought up during testing?! Surely? Its not even like the full-height screen adds anything really as you have a stupid extra-large notification bar as it physically needs to be larger to fit the front-facing camera in. Finally, it does not connect to 5G where Vodafone UK says there is 5G on their coverage maps (and yes my account is enabled for 5G). Either Vodafone is telling porkie pies on their coverage maps, or the pixel 5 can't connect to 5G and so is a total disaster?
- meowster 6y agoAt first I thought the call audio was extremely bad on the Pixel 5, because I've always put the corner of the phone in my ear. Once I read that you have to place your ear over the phone glass instead, the audio became completely normal-sounding.
- gundmc 6y agoGoogle taking the Steve Jobs "you're holding it wrong" approach.
- meowster 6y agoI remember that debacle. I suppose there is a parallel, but with the Pixel 5, it still is very usable with almost zero adjustment, nothing convoluted like changing how you hold an iPhone to avoid shorting the antenna.
- P_I_Staker 6y agoDisagree that this is anywhere close to as bad. Asking users to place their ear over the speaker is not a huge deal and reasonable IMO, versus having it not work at all when holding it like a normal person. If you don't like the speaker placement, I understand though.
- anonuser123456 6y agoI've had a lot of Google/Android phones - Nexus 5X - Pixel 1 - Pixel 3 - Pixel 4 Im going back to iPhone. There are too many problems w/Google HW. The supply chain sucks if something breaks (which happens much more often than my iDevices). My pixel 1 mic stopped working, and it was impossible to find parts to fix it (including for 3rd part repair stores). My wife's Pixel 3 won't reliably charge wirelessly. You have to reboot the phone 1x per week inorder to get wireless charging to work. So you put it down... And wake up to a dead phone. My pixel 4 had a terrible Chrome problem until very recently. Chrome would basically lock up the system. The gesture navigation also kind os sucks. Also, the pixel 4 glass really sucks. I had scratches all over it with the first month... Vs my Moto G7 which has none. Don't even get me started on the new Android TV chrome cast or the 2 WearOS watches or my chromebox that can't have more than 2 BT devices connected (or it stops working).
- spiznnx 6y agoThe Google/Nexus/Pixel series phones never seem to be perfect. I just don't think Google has the hardware DNA. On the other hand, pretty much every Samsung and Apple phone I've owned has been perfect hardware-wise.
- dessant 6y agoSamsung hardware is indeed excellent, but there's still much room to improve around delivering updates. Samsung's current commitment is to deliver 3 major OS updates after device launch [1], which is still not enough for a flagship that will work fine even after 5 years. [1] https://news.samsung.com/global/samsung-raises-the-bar-for-mobile-experience-innovation-committing-to-three-generations-of-android-os-upgrades https://news.samsung.com/global/samsung-raises-the-bar-for-m...
- thaumasiotes 6y agoThe Nexus S was made by Samsung. It'd be nice to see that happen again. On an unrelated note, my Nexus 4 and Nexus 5 both failed in different ways, but the Nexus S, from the year before the 4, still hasn't.
- rch 6y ago> the Pixel 5 offers little over the Pixel 4a The subtitle captures how out of touch I am with regular phone users. I'll be upgrading from a Pixel 2, and had a Nexus 7 before that. My purchase cadence seems different than what I perceive to be typical for iPhone users in particular. For me, mmWave seems like a nice to have future-proofing feature. And this reads like a sales pitch crafted specifically for me: There's no squeeze to activate the Google Assistant, no "Project Soli" hand-waving air gestures, and no Face ID style facial recognition. The only thing you get for biometrics is the tried-and-true rear capacitive fingerprint reader, which works great. There's no headphone jack and no microSD slot, but there are two features you might not normally find in the midrange market: wireless charging and IP68-rated dust and water resistance. ...strangely negative review for a product that seems like a step in the right direction in a number of areas.
- detaro 6y agoHow out of touch you are with tech reviewers :D (who obviously follow each cycle). While there's plenty people buying new phones often (or at least in some places getting them regularly replaced through their phone plan), plenty people do not always go for the newest thing too.
- wffurr 6y agoNo one will be upgrading from the Pixel 4a to the Pixel 5. Both phones are available now, new from Google. Instead, they're comparing your choices for an upgrade to your Pixel 2. I'm in the same situation, and considering buying a Pixel 4a to replace my Pixel 2 now that security updates have stopped.
- blacksmith_tb 6y agoI just made exactly that jump, from a Pixel 2 to a new 4a, and I am pretty happy with it (nice screen, battery life is great). It's also an experiment for me, I have been rooting to block ads, but I decided to try do that via DNS over TLS (aka 'Private DNS') and NextDNS. So far it's working pretty well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- paulpan 6y agoInteresting tidbit on camera sensor and output. I forgot how much ahead of its time the Nokia 808 PureView was! Its sensor size still dwarfs the latest and greatest from Samsung - and especially Apple's new 1/1.7 on the 12 Pro Max. Pixel 5 using the Snapdragon 765G also grosses over the fact image processing is no longer being handled by Google's custom Visual Core (in Pixel 2 & 3). Inevitable perhaps given performance parity, but shows how much of its photography lead Google has relinquished.
- phonon 6y agoSamsung's latest smartphone sensors are 1/1.33 in format...only slightly smaller than the Nokia 808 PureView (1/1.2 in). The ISOCELL GN1 is 50 MP and 1/1.31, even closer. https://www.samsung.com/semiconductor/minisite/isocell/mobile-image-sensors/isocell-gn1/ https://www.samsung.com/semiconductor/minisite/isocell/mobil... https://www.dxomark.com/vivo-x50-pro-plus-camera-review-aiming-for-the-top/ https://www.dxomark.com/vivo-x50-pro-plus-camera-review-aimi...
- devilduck 6y agoJust had to get warranty exchange on a 4XL due to hardware issues. Probably the last Google phone I get. I really miss the Nexus 5
- gman83 6y agoNow that I got a Pixel 4a I'm never spending more than $400 for a phone ever again. It's fantastic.
- whitepoplar 6y agoI'm still bitter about the Nexus One I purchased 10 years ago. It was a defective model, with connectivity issues from day 1, and reports saying as much all over the internet. Google basically shrugged their shoulders and told me to fuck off. I paid more for it than the equivalent iPhone, too!
- meowster 6y agoI guess this would be a good place to mention to anyone who wants to buy hardware directly from Google: Create a separate account and purchase the device through it, that way if you have to do a charge-back because Google's customer service sucks, you can do so without them banning your main account. (This is not a victim-blame, just a suggestion on how to avoid becoming a victim. Google is definitely in the wrong when it comes to this.)
- kyle-rb 6y agoI was planning on getting the Pixel 5, but ended up choosing the 4a 5G. Despite the name, it's closer to the 5 than to the 'plain' 4a in nearly all specs [1]. Same camera, processor, and resolution. The 5 supports higher framerate and contrast, has a bit more RAM, and has some wireless charging features, but the 4a 5G has a headphone jack and is $200 less, so... [1] https://store.google.com/magazine/compare_pixel https://store.google.com/magazine/compare_pixel
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoHow are you finding it? I'm planning to make the leap off iPhone once my current phone is out of warranty (2 months left) and am in the market for a high quality but not obscenely priced Android phone. Google phones seem to be the least weighed down by manufacturer crapware. The 4a is the one I'm looking at. I do plan to flash either Lineage or some other custom ROM though.
- nl 6y ago> I do plan to flash either Lineage or some other custom ROM though. If you get a Pixel don't do this. You'll just get worse battery life, more bugs etc. Google clean Android is great.
- damnencryption 6y agoOne plus Nord is pretty sweet.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoYeah was just looking at the OnePlus phones for the first time today... look pretty amazing. Definitely a price premium but if it gets the job done without a Bixby button hey.. could be a winner.
- me_me_me 6y agoI was in a need of new phone and waited for P5 announcement with my final decision. P5 is underwhelming if not disappointing. In the end I am a happy owner of OnePlus Nord. Shame it lack slot for expandable memory but i got a bit over 200GB on it so it should last a while. And on paper it beats every Pixel in bang for money category. Highly recommend it.
- claydavisss 6y agoRon is being too charitable in this review. Google is phoning it in, pun intended. The Pixel phones are now half-assed, just last year's hardware riding on Google's brand. At this point it really does seem like they are, once again, about to throw in the towel.
- Animats 6y agoThe review is missing the point of millimeter wave 5G. The one place you really need that is where there are huge, dense crowds, and many low-power high-frequency cells to support them. Convention centers. Stadiums. T-Mobile CEO: “Millimeter wave (mmWave) spectrum has great potential in terms of speed and capacity, but it doesn’t travel far from the cell site and doesn’t penetrate materials at all. It will never materially scale beyond small pockets of 5G hotspots in dense urban environments.” [1] https://www.fiercewireless.com/5g/t-mobile-says-5g-mmwave-deployments-will-never-scale https://www.fiercewireless.com/5g/t-mobile-says-5g-mmwave-de...
- mekster 6y agoYeah but marketers want to sell using the buzzword as if people's network speed will see a new generation. Besides, who needs more than 100mbps on a phone? You don't need 8k steaming on a phone.
- _nothing 6y agoWhen the Samsung Galaxy S20 FE was released, I was so sure I was going to prefer it over the Pixel 5. I even liked its photos better in all the camera comparisons-- all except for excessive blue-ing of the sky and the softening of features in selfies that doesn't go away even if you turn off the beautifying feature. It's just so much better on paper. Faster charging (with separate charger), expandable storage, zoom lens, wider wide-angle lens, 120 Hz refresh, MUCH faster processor. All for the same price as the Pixel 5. I'd already preordered the Pixel so I figured I'd just let it come and return it after testing both together. Well, I did test them both together, and I'm returning the Samsung. (Remains to be seen if I'll keep the Pixel 5 or stick with my Pixel 2.) I really wanted to like the Samsung; I had really high hopes when people said OneUI had gotten better. But it somehow just feels so sluggish. The face unlock doesn't recognize my face a lot of the time, and the on-screen fingerprint sensor (which only lets me register 3 fingers apparently?) doesn't recognize my finger like 60% of the time. So instead of just being able to pick it up and use it instantly like I can with my Pixels, it usually takes 5-10 seconds for me to get into my phone, as I fiddle around to get either the fingerprint sensor or face unlock to recognize me before sometimes having to just swipe my pattern. The refresh rate is 120 Hz yet for some reason it feels like there's a delay whenever I try to swipe through the UI. The camera is good but it bothers me even more than I expected, how much it tries to smooth my face. Anyway, the point of this comment isn't to be a review of the Samsung phone, but just to highlight how jarring it was to experience all of that after having a Pixel phone that just worked. Even at my P2's 60Hz it feels more snappy than this brand new phone with a 120Hz display and top-of-the-line processor. Granted, I haven't tried many other phones than a Pixel in a while so maybe they're better, but I would just remind everyone that specs aren't everything. The Pixel 5 runs smooth and does everything I want it to well (although it does take longer than I'd like to process photos). My only problem is that my Pixel 2 also ran smoothly and did everything I wanted it to. The only reason I'm considering the Pixel 5 is the bigger screen and wide-angle camera. So we'll see how I feel in a few days.
- liminal 6y agoGoogle really blew it with the camera. Pixels are known for taking amazing shots and that's where they needed to retain dominance. Instead they removed the telephoto lens and stayed with an ancient sensor. I might have upgraded from my Pixel 4 XL if it was actually an upgrade. The face recognition is useless when wearing masks so just the fingerprint reader would have been enough motivation if the rest of the phone was even competitive.
- nl 6y agoI agree. In a world where companies are shipping working 5x optical zooms, and things like the Vivo X50 Pro have a built in gimbal[1] that make the digital zoom usable too I just don't see how the Pixel competes. The software is but that isn't enough. Just look at the comparison with other cameras: https://www.androidauthority.com/google-pixel-5-super-res-zoom-1167007/ https://www.androidauthority.com/google-pixel-5-super-res-zo... [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/bensin/2020/07/16/vivo-x50-pro-review-gimbal-camera-works-but-theres-more-to-like-elsewhere/?sh=3c1f10b7c93f https://www.forbes.com/sites/bensin/2020/07/16/vivo-x50-pro-...
- Johnyma22 6y agoI really miss my headphone jack :(
- antisthenes 6y agoIdk how anyone with a straight face can say that $700 is mid-range. That's the price of a well performing desktop computer. What happened to the actual mid-range? The specs for the current $300 phones seem to be worse than the specs for $300 phones 3-4 years ago. How come?
- akhilcacharya 6y agoMeanwhile that's about the price of a base model iPhone 12 Mini which a SoC that's significantly faster.
- dmead 6y agoI still have my nexus 5x. AMA.
- someperson 6y agoI have been very impressed with the Samsung's M-series phones. Extremely cheap phones with extremely good specifications (great screen, massive battery life). Also not made in China (made in Vietnam). The biggest downside is the factory firmware has Samsung bloatware.
- mekster 6y agoSamsung apps are so much better than stock Google's. Too bad most can't be installed on non Samsung phones.
- Shivetya 6y agoWhile I have never been in the market for an Android phone I do appreciate that this review compares Android to Android and did not blunder off into some comparison with iPhones. It makes it far easier to understand the underlying issues this phone has when compared to other offerings with similar hardware
- foxhop 6y agoI use GoogleFI and my daily driver is a Samsung Note 20 Ultra. It's my first time ever using a top end smart phone (always used budget before) and it's awesome. Ask me anything.
- mekster 6y agoWhat made you go high end when phone product cycles are so small that even 2 years old device starts to make you feel you're using an old model?
- foxhop 6y agoI've never had a high end phone before and I did it for the camera. My entire YouTube workflow is done on a mobile phone. I have 512G internal and a 512G Micro SD card on the phone holding both my raw videos and the renders. Here is an example: https://youtu.be/97YkBdfk7rM https://youtu.be/97YkBdfk7rM
- nmlnn 6y agoSo far my smartphone history has been: HTC Desire (approx. Nexus1) -> Galaxy Nexus -> Nexus 4 -> Nexus 5 -> Nexus 5X -> Pixel 1 -> Pixel 2 -> Pixel 3 -> ? My favourites where the N4 and P2. The P2 fixed the shitty cameras, and now it looks like finally the P5 will fix the shitty battery life. Can anyone with a P5 comment on how it compares. I'm glad they finally realized the 4 was a mistake. And from the reviews/specs/features the 5 seems perfect - but I'm worried I'm missing something. I don't want to keep changing phones, it just happens because there is always one deal breaker built in.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- RobertRies 6y agoI don't think you're missing anything. Coming from a Pixel 1 XL and got Pixel 5 at launch. This is the perfect phone. It finally made me embrace no headphone jack (my single reservation before). If I could personally design a phone from scratch, I don't think I would do anything different. -Processor: Not "flagship" - great, save battery, don't get too hot. Not pushing boundaries of reliability. Love the 5g is included for "future-proofing," despite not particularly caring about it now -RAM: Any more would not be useful, any less would have me wanting -Storage: I understand this isn't the absolute fastest (ufs 2.1 instead of 3) - this is imperceptible to me. In terms of size, 128gb as the only option removes any sense of FOMO for not dropping more money on space I wouldn't use anyway. No SD, but I never used SD card on any phone ever, despite always popping one in). -Screen: 432ppi, anything more is just wasting battery. 90hz refresh big increase on 60hz, saves battery from 120hz. OLED color/quality is fantastic. I'm a weirdo that keeps 100% bright on any phone. Any brighter would be unnecessary, indoors or outdoors. -Battery: Over 4000mAh and has ridiculous battery life; essentially 2 days of normal use. Not the fastest charger ever (18w) but still more than fast enough -Camera: front high quality for calls; more than acceptable for selfies which I nearly never take. Rear camera is arguably best photography of any phone despite aging (but affordable, reliable) sensor. Video stabilization is remarkable. Video quality is good enough. Love the wide angle sensor. Never had a desire for a dedicated portrait sensor (or any others). -Software: Obviously the best possible Android experience period. Additionally, when support eventually ends (whenever it does), it's a good gamble that LineageOS (or equivalent) will support Google flagship -Speakers: under screen ear earpiece. No idea what others are talking about "muffled". It sounds like any top speaker on any phone ever to me (and I have great hearing?). Perhaps I accidentally place it correctly. Additionally I nearly never talk "on the phone", and when I do, it's with headphones. Prefer this to adding a speaker and possibly ruining the aesthetics. Bottom speaker: I expected this to be a big weak spot based on reviews but it exceeded my low expectations. I'm positive other phones may have louder/better speakers but this is perfectly adequate for any circumstance I'm using the phone's speaker -Design: no gimmicks. The perfect shape, size, and thickness of a phone. Perfect bezel width for aesthetics versus accidental touch input from holding it. Uniform bezels look so nice. Hole-punch selfie camera left offset is the least obtrusive option short of under-screen. Rear fingerprint is my preferred unlock. Face unlock gone, but I strongly prefer that than to ruin the clean design of the front for an unlock option I don't care much about (especially considering Smart Lock options) -Materials: Love that it's metal and feels solid and durable as such. Not a fan of fragile glass, or "cheap" plastic. Love that despite being metal, retains wireless charging. Resin feels high quality and grippy, but I put a minimal case on it anyway. Overall summary is the Pixel 5 is the best overall phone out there. Feature-for-feature it is "Second best" at everything (with good tradeoff explanations/decisions), but still first best at Software and Camera. Because of that, it makes the entire package the best possible Android overall phone by my standards and I don't have to feel guilt about not getting "a real flagship."
- LocalPCGuy 6y agoAnd yet, I'll still probably get the 5 cause I want wireless charging, the faster screen, slightly bigger battery and I prefer a slightly smaller phone (my reason for not going 4a5G, but may still end up with that to save the $200. We'll see how the Black Friday/Christmas sales are). And I stick with Pixel because I prefer the "pure-Google" experience and get updates as soon as they come out, no waiting on carrier (Fi) or company.
- acarl005 6y agoAm I the only one who cares about the 4a-5G's bottom bezel? It is thicker so the bezel isn't symmetrical making it an eyesore. I would pay a bit more to have a symmetrical bezel.