19 ms·
Toronto-area lawyer had to flee Canada after taking on the tow truck industry
- bpodgursky 6y agoThis sounds like typical mafia tactics, right? Is there a connection between this industry and traditional Russian / Italian / Irish groups? The industry checks out, the tactics check out, the fraudulent revenue stream sounds right...
- alexose 6y agoI often think about ways of disrupting businesses which rely on shady deals/regulatory capture/other anticompetitive measures. I just as often decide that it’s not worth it, since I don’t want my legs broken.
- ehnto 6y agoLook at that, the system works.
- crossroadsguy 6y agoOn a hill station winter night me and few friends were on a remote old bungalow drunk and contemplating life, as it usually goes. One topic became specifically heated, partly because one of the participants was the son of a notoriously corrupt politician. He hated his father, except when it came to enjoy luxuries that was paid for by the father. The topic was - how to deter, scare the criminals? How to make it less viable for them to be corrupt and criminals? They often commit crimes of various nature including corruption in the hope that if not them their children, family would get to reap the benefits and they make financial arrangements so that even if they are indicted and properties seized, at least a decent part of the proceeds indeed goes to the family. We reached an impasse with loosely discussing that vigilante justice is the only way. But then the family, wife, kids didn't really directly participate in the crime so how and when to punish them? For not denouncing the proceeds that was earned from the corrupt and criminal means? I mean there's a law against aiding and abetting in crime. So would that not work here? Besides, even if we proceed with the vigilante justice, where to draw the line? Is everyone supposed to be picking up arms. That would be total revolution, anarchy in other words. Part of the discussion also included how criminals, politicians intimidate and harm weaker adversaries and if society collectively starts hitting back and hard at them where it hurts - their business, family members - it could deter them. How long can they provide security to them? How often? All it needs one successful target among many. Yes, they can keep the family in a steel cage. Good for them! But we did reach an agreement that they should not be left untouched. How exactly? That remained the question.
- didibus 6y agoI recently started to think that inheritance should just be all together eliminated. It is still a root of inequality, and promotes all kind of bad behavior. Your accomplishments, your money, not your kids. When you die, the assets should go back to the people equally. That way all children, no matter their parents, citizen of a country, should have equality in opportunity. In theory, children with rich parents will still have plenty of advantages, connections, know how, good education, etc. But they shouldn't inherit any assets or financials. Now how would that be managed in practice, no idea, and I haven't fully thought through everything here, but I'm just surprised this isn't an idea I hear more about, as it seems to me this is a huge source of inequality remaining in our society.
- tasuki 6y agoWhat about gifts? Can people gift other people things? If we forbid gifts, because they're an obvious transfer of wealth, what about financial transactions that favour one party? Should it be legal for a rich parent to sell their car to their offspring for below market value? How much below market value? As you can see, none of this makes any sense to me. I believe people would get around whatever restrictions you put in place rather easily.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> If we forbid gifts, because they're an obvious transfer of wealth, what about financial transactions that favour one party? Should it be legal for a rich parent to sell their car to their offspring for below market value? How much below market value? In fact, this is already illegal, but there's no enforcement. (Enforcement would be challenging in any realistic scenario; it always is when every party to a transaction benefits from it.) According to the law, whenever you obtain anything from anyone (not just relatives) at a price below market value, you have to pay taxes on the difference.
- cgriswald 6y agoIn fact, neither of those is illegal. You’d have to be fairly wealthy and incredibly generous to actually trigger conditions needed to pay taxes on gifts. Aside from being able to give $15K per person per year (or twice that for married couples) you also get a lifetime gift-giving exemption of nearly $12 million for any gift giving over the annual amounts. You’re also allowed to sell your kid your car for $1. It’ll probably be counted as a gift of market value - $1. Your kid will probably be required to pay taxes on it as if he purchased it for market value. But it’s not illegal.
- chrischen 6y agoWorked for Uber/Lyft. The problem is whether or not you have more firepower than the incumbent.
- onetimemanytime 6y ago>>I just as often decide that it’s not worth it, since I don’t want my legs broken. Broken legs are still part of the warning phase. They see this as "theirs" and who they hell are you to cause them to lose $x Million a year? Any business or person would sue the hell out of you and try to ruin your life if you caused them millions in loses. The mafiosi are no different, with a slight twist, they skip the courts since they take too long ;).
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWhat? Where I’m from, competitors routinely put others out of business by offering better products or pricing and you don’t get sued the hell out of.
- gnopgnip 6y agoSunshine laws or the equivalent are the start. Without data on the problem it is easy for criminals to stay under the radar, or for the public to know if it is really a problem. A number of states have towing laws that require reporting any towed vehicle to the state within an hour. If a car is towed without being reported, in theory it is theft, or could lead to the business license or drivers license or insurance being revoked if enough people complain. And the second part is going after the money. The tow company can't legally charge anything if they didn't report the tow and follow the law. They can be sued for 3x the cost of the tow and any other out of pocket costs, and attorneys fees, so it is worth it for attorneys to take these cases on instead of small claims, and just a few of these to make this scheme more expensive than doing things the right way
- hansvm 6y ago> A number of states have towing laws that require reporting any towed vehicle to the state within an hour. This is a start but not near enough. In many states the tow company isn't required to take photos or produce any kind of proof that the car deserved to be towed. In my experience they just lie to the police about why they stole your car, and the police will vehemently argue that car theft is a civil matter and not a crime.
- rl3 6y ago>I often think about ways of disrupting businesses which rely on shady deals/regulatory capture/other anticompetitive measures. I just as often decide that it’s not worth it, since I don’t want my legs broken. Any smart organized crime is going to realize that directly intimidating startup founders with violence on American soil is a great way to a) get an overwhelming amount of federal heat on them and b) turn whatever it is they're doing into a scandal immediately.
- sneak 6y agoI think perhaps you overestimate the FBI’s willingness to do routine policework.
- getlawgdon 6y agoThat's a beautiful, committed, and complete fantasy.
- rl3 6y ago>That's a beautiful, committed, and complete fantasy. Nice drive-by zinger. Care to, I don't know—cite evidence to the contrary? Despite being Canada, the facts of the original article support my point of view: "Three separate police services – YRP, Toronto Police Service and Ontario Provincial Police – joined forces to launch Project Platinum to investigate the violence associated with the tow truck industry. They carried out a series of raids this past spring, which netted dozens of high-powered weapons and led to the arrests of 35 people who face almost 500 charges, including the attempted murder of Carr."
- specialist 6y agoI'd like a Good Government guidebook for citizens. List some general principles, some case studies, cites for further research. I tried to read some books on auditing and financial accounting. Way over my head. I need the ELI5 layperson versions. Am a recovering activist. So much (wasted) effort. I did learn two heuristics. #1 Talk About Quality "Fraud" is a convo full stop. Don't talk about fraud, theft, grift. Mistakes are indistinguishable from fraud. And combatting both has the same remedies. So only talk about quality, confidence, reducing errors, etc. Nice safe blame-free neutral 90/10 language that gets everyone on board and is less likely to trigger overt opposition. (Covert sabotage will continue, because the grifters won't be fooled by your Aw Schucks demeanor.) #2 Follow The Money Per quote from The Wire upthread. I learned from Bev Harris (Black Box Voting) that (mis)appropriations is a huge threat to election integrity. And in many places, that's the sheriff's office. They don't care about machines, voting, elections. For them it's just about the grift. Twenty years later, I still don't have a clue how to mitigate this. One half-baked notion was to advocate for solutions that both more in line with the public interest and had more potential for grift. Another is, since scandal is evergreen topic, is feed info to opposition. That didn't work at all against Bob Moses (The Power Broker), so probably not a great plan.
- h2odragon 6y ago"recovering activist" ... I wish you peace, and healing. Getting people to do something towards better governance requires they have some faith that such a thing is possible in the first place. Met a non-cynical Civics teacher lately? I liked to read people the preamble to the Declaration of Independence: "We hold these Truths to be Self Evident..." but many disagreed with those words and never heard the rest.
- tebura 6y agowhat does mean by police cant protect her anymore ? smells fishy !
- refurb 6y agoNow back in Canada, Carr says police have told her she is likely no longer in danger, but with one caveat. “The police said we believe the risk is low. As long as you don't go back to work, as long as you don't restart the firm,” she says.
- frequentnapper 6y agoYep, sounds like the incompetent canadian police I've encountered.
- Fogest 6y agoWhat do you want them to do? Give her 24/7 security? They are telling her that if there are people against her she should be cautious. It's hard for police anywhere to prevent something that hasn't happened yet.
- yoavm 6y agoIn what world are we living that protecting an innocent citizen is portrayed as a crazy idea? I don't mind if they give her 24/7 security, if they watch 24/7 people who they suspect want to harm her, whatever. IMHO police #1 role should be protecting the people. I would also argue that in the long term this should pay off. Protect the lawyer, stop crime organizations, save much money later because less security needed. Don't protect the layer == more crime == more future expenses.
- Fogest 6y agoThe problem is more where do you draw the line with that protection. What kind of risk warrants you getting special round the clock police presence? What if a criminal leader is having problems with another gang who keeps putting hits out on him? Maybe he had multiple attempts made on his life already. Should he also get protection? Or would he not count because of his criminal history? If anything what should be happening here is the insurance company who is paying her should be helping protect her. Otherwise why wouldn't she just drop the client? If it is unsafe for her she may as well just cave in and drop that high risk client. I don't see how her career had to end because she couldn't drop a single client. The insurance companies also could have put pressure on the prosecutors to go after these criminals. What I find interesting is that in the story we heard nothing from the insurance companies despite them being the main one going head-to-head against these guys. In my city in Ontario our police department is already underfunded and has less officers per 100 000 people than most other departments in Ontario. And because of the BLM movement one of their proposed budgets would end up forcing them to cut 216 officers. Unfortunately people want to ask for things like these 24/7 protections but then they are unwilling to properly fund the police and instead look to defund them. A lot of police services in Ontario are understaffed and can barely keep up with 911 calls for service, how do you expect them to protect someone 24/7 for who knows how long when they can barely keep up with normal 911 calls?
- refurb 6y agoReminds me a bit about the Quebec snowplowing business - bribes, organized crime, threats and beatings... https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/snow-removal-montreal-collusion-report-1.3331293 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/snow-removal-montrea...
- unsrsly 6y agoAs dramatized in Bad Blood? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_Blood_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_Blood_(TV_series)
- cowpig 6y agoI don't have a source for this, but I grew up in NJ and now live in Montreal, and I am pretty sure the local corruption here is worse than where I grew up (where three of the four mayors of my hometown served time in jail after their time in office). Things got a lot better there and I think a lot of the organized crime might have moved up north. The construction industry is very clearly siphoning billions of dollars of tax money into organized criminals' hands. Every few years a given street gets torn up with a new excuse. And it seems to be consensus that it's much worse these days than it used to be.. this year in particular I think something like one out of every five blocks downtown is closed off for "construction". Cops saying "just don't look into it" regarding organized crime sounds about par for the course anywhere I've ever been though.
- ABCLAW 6y agoThe corruption in Montreal is more visible than in many other metropolitan regions places, but the city and province do a lot more than other areas to bring it to light and fight it. My estimation is that if we had a similar level of effort into looking into other regions, we'd see similar or greater issues. The refusal to look into real-estate or casino based money laundering as well as substantially counterproductive financial secrecy laws make for lots of issues in Canada. Is there grift in Montreal? You betcha. Is there grift in Toronto? You betcha, but it doesn't make the news.
- busterarm 6y agoI mean, that grift extends all the way to your PM and political dividing lines are preventing it from being properly investigated. This is a great shame.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThe US president made his career in casinos, development, and high end real estate... It's shameful but not really rare.
- 6y ago
- denni9th 6y agoSome insurance companies where I live prevent extortion from tow truck companies by including a list of authorized tow companies as a part of the policy. Cars that aren't towed by those companies won't get paid out (or get less paid out, not sure on the details). Perhaps something similar could help here? Given this situation though, it seems like the tow trucks might just violently threaten someone until they agree to let them tow their car while they wait for an authorized company to arrive. But perhaps that is easier for the police to deal with than organised crime.
- Gibbon1 6y agoThought of mine would be change the rules so you can specify a towing service for you car. Like say you have AAA on file. To tow your car cops _must_ call AAA and have them handle it. Advantage AAA will have the tow guy drop it off on some random street. Or maybe in front of your house.
- drchiu 6y agoWasn't the taxi industry also one where it had its own corruption and connections with people who may resort to guns to protect their turf? How did companies like Uber and Lyft gain marketshare without incurring some physical penalty?
- mimikatz 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxFQYw_MmAA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxFQYw_MmAA
- jamesmishra 6y agoActually, there was a considerable physical penalty. Uber ran into old-school taxi corruption and violence all around the world. - South Korea [1] - France [2] - Kenya [3] - Malaysia [4] - South Africa [5] - Mexico [6] - Brazil [7] - Indonesia [8] - ...and I could go on. [1]: https://www.vice.com/en/article/qvyzn5/south-korea-uber-kakao-taxi-protests-self-immolate https://www.vice.com/en/article/qvyzn5/south-korea-uber-kaka... [2]: https://www.stripes.com/travelers-caught-in-cross-fire-as-french-taxi-drivers-smash-cars-to-protest-uber-1.354901 https://www.stripes.com/travelers-caught-in-cross-fire-as-fr... [3]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/23/uber-taxi-set-on-fire-nairobi-kenya-industry-dispute https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/23/uber-taxi-set-... [4]: https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2016/06/22/more-than-50-taxi-drivers-attack-uber-driver-tourist-couple/ https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2016/06/22... [5]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/08/violence-erupts-taxi-uber-drivers-johannesburg https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/sep/08/violence-erupt... [6]: https://time.com/3915705/uber-mexico-dispute/ https://time.com/3915705/uber-mexico-dispute/ [7]: https://techcrunch.com/2015/10/01/the-fight-against-uber-is-getting-violent-in-brazil/ https://techcrunch.com/2015/10/01/the-fight-against-uber-is-... [8]: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/23/world/asia/indonesia-jakarta-taxi-uber-grabcar.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/23/world/asia/indonesia-jaka... (Disclosure: I am a former Uber employee.)
- istjohn 6y agoOne of those links are not like the others. I was not prepared for the first story to be about self-immolating taxi drivers.
- renewiltord 6y agoI wonder what the properties are of a gig that permits mafiafication. I think it helps to have ties to the police, some sort of notion in the public's eye that you're legalish, and perhaps be able to use an army of foot soldiers as a human shield. I think if I were in organized crime, a good one would be privatizing parking enforcement of city spaces and then being in charge of meter maids. But it can't be a single organization in charge of meter maids because then it's too obvious. You need it to look diffuse, through a network of companies. Oh, I think body shops are a good one, but auto glass companies too. You could just stage some break-ins that just vandalize car glass. People will blame the guy whose glass was broken (why did you park there, was your car empty, blah blah). You're just a glass repair shop so everyone sees you as the good guy. And no one will see that your network of auto glass companies is actually controlled by you. Yeah, auto glass companies in cities are a tremendous opportunity for mafiafication. If they aren't already.
- motohagiography 6y agoOrganized crime is just unofficial government, and "mafia" is just another word for municipal procurement. Anything that is legally mandatory is a target for corruption and extortion. If it's licensed, it's going to be corrupt because the license holders are protected from more honest competition. The more complex the rules, the more exploited they will be. I don't see how the towing industry is any different from healthcare in the U.S. Same scam of driving you to an "out of network" hospital. There was even a story about how the healthcare bill collectors all went through the same legal guy in New York who rubber stamped their judgments against debtors. In Canada, get a CAA membership for your vehicles. It's cheap, trustworthy, and you can tell those roadside pirates to GTFO.
- Kalium 6y ago> Oh, I think body shops are a good one, but auto glass companies too. You could just stage some break-ins that just vandalize car glass. People will blame the guy whose glass was broken (why did you park there, was your car empty, blah blah). You're just a glass repair shop so everyone sees you as the good guy. And no one will see that your network of auto glass companies is actually controlled by you. Once upon a time, something similar happened with an upholsterer in the SF Bay area. They had the contract to repair seats on the train system. Then someone figured out that more repairs meant more money, so they hired some people to go around slashing seats...
- Laforet 6y agoOne of the unintended consequences of cannabis legalisation is encouraging criminals moving on to a non-drug related enterprise and take their old methods with them. Not that I think progressive drug reform is a bad idea, but they clearly oversold the idea that legalising a few substances would reduce crime when it's the economic incentive that drives people to break the law.
- iLemming 6y agoYeah, look at that lawless Portugal for example.
- istjohn 6y agoThis calls to mind an incident from a couple years ago in Columbus, Ohio. After a negligent lane-changing sedan spun my car 360 degrees and into the rail guard, the responding police officer ordered a tow truck for me without my knowledge. When the truck arrived, the driver told me he could either take my car to his body shop or the city impound lot, in which case I would need to pay later for a second tow to the body shop of my choosing plus any storage fees. I did not appreciate this strong arm sales tactic and told him he wasn't touching my vehicle. The cop insisted that I allow the tow. She apparently was required to stay at the scene until the disabled vehicles were removed and did not want to wait for a tow truck of my choosing. I held firm. After several minutes of back and forth, the cop begrudgingly allowed me to drive my heavily damaged vehicle a few hundred yards to an exit ramp and park it on a side street. An accident report was never filed, so my insurance company wasn't able to collect damages from the other party's insurance on my behalf. Perhaps there was a clerical error or perhaps the cop wanted to punish my assertiveness.
- nobrains 6y agoAnd you did not follow-up why the accident report was not filed? I usually keep following up on such cases, until all issues are resolved. It is a net negative investment for me, since the time and effort I have to put in it, is not worth it, but I get 2 satisfactions out of it: 1) Hopefully whoever "played" will learn a lesson not to again. 2) Hopefully the overall problem (whether it is bad customer service, strong arm tactics, etc.) will slowly be fixed. I guess in your case, you already used up your quota of fighting-the-system when you had to argue with both the cop and the tow-man.
- istjohn 6y agoI considered filing a complaint with the police department, but I'm skeptical anything would have come of it. Ideally, I would have done it regardless. It's true that the root problem will not be addressed if people don't pursue things. I think on net I do more than my fair share of tilting at windmills though. Ask me about self-storage companies sometime.
- 6y ago
- Reason077 6y agoIf this is such a big and expensive problem (reportedly $2 billion annually), why are insurance companies hiring a small private lawyer operating out of a strip mall? Aren’t there big corporate law firms who would have more resources, and more protection/anonymity for their staff?
- achow 6y agoGood point. Maybe this one was visible and behind the scene the big firms are still at it? This lawyer was probably was working on some specific local cases but was also 'more accessible' by the criminals for intimidation?
- refurb 6y agoI'm assuming because of the fragmented insurance market. Ideally, all of the insurers would band together, but in reality, you've got a bunch of players with 2-5% of the market who can't afford the big time Toronto legal firms.
- donmcronald 6y agoWhy wouldn't the insurance companies just offer to deal with arranging a tow truck for you? If they're getting scammed so much wouldn't it make sense to have someone answering the phone and calling a preferred towing provider? The service itself would have some value because knowing you can call your insurance provider after an accident and having them deal with everything would really help to reduce the stress of the incident. My hunch is the insurance companies are a bunch of babies that would rather whine than solve problems. My sister got in an accident in AB last year and it took her insurance company forever to have her vehicle re-towed from a small garage in a little town to Edmonton. IIRC it took more than 6 weeks for her to deal with insurance. Contrast that with SK where between the city police and SGI you don't have to do anything. They just deal with it and the rates we pay are probably the best in the country. It's ~1500 CAD per year for insurance and as long as you have a decent driving record you don't get penalized for getting in an accident. You can even cause an accident and pay $0 if you don't make a claim on your own vehicle. Plus they typically get everything dealt with very quickly. If the police are calling corrupt tow truck companies that's it's own problem. That kind of corruption shouldn't be tolerated and if the police are calling a tow truck for you after an accident it should be a regulated process.
- MattGaiser 6y agoEliminating crap like this is a big benefit of an industry being consolidated. Towing needs Uberization.
- mellavora 6y agoum, a company which relentlessly violates all laws and social norms? this is better?
- nojvek 6y agoI think OP is advocating for a market where consumer gets to choose their towing truck evil. I don’t think Uber would have ever been a thing if they played Fair. The taxi industry is full of mafias. They had to get at their level. Uber is a classic example of “grow at all costs” Silicon Valley culture. I don’t endorse it, but I acknowledge why it is the way it is.
- neya 6y agoAlongnside, I recommend you also watch this video episode of what the lawyer is fighting against. It's ridiculous how they're able to get away with such criminal behaviour in broad daylight. Tow truck tricks: Don't get scammed after an accident (CBC Marketplace) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOboCgIhcfk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOboCgIhcfk
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoNo surprise. The way you make it in the towing industry (in cities) is to make friends with the police. It's no surprise that people with those friends feel emboldened to do things normal people can't get away with. This dynamic is the fault of the government for creating a captive market and secondarily the fault of insurance for divorcing many consumers from the costs of that captive market. In rural areas where there's not much money to be made towing the tow operators don't do bad business to make a buck. They use their capital investment to haul things other than cars to make their gravy money.
- jessaustin 6y agoThis calls to mind the USA lawyer who had nowhere to flee after taking on Chevron. https://www.salon.com/2020/08/27/the-case-of-steven-donziger-and-chevron-how-those-who-fight-corporate-tyranny-are-crushed/ https://www.salon.com/2020/08/27/the-case-of-steven-donziger...
- CamelCaseName 6y agoI never understood why towing isn't a function of the provincial government. The government entering the industry would reduce violence, corruption, and insurance costs for all. It is well known here in Toronto that tow trucks are scum of the earth. Earlier this year [0] there were 10 charged, including one police in a corruption scandal in Toronto. They were so brazen that they stole from the police! Then a month later, Toronto suspended 5 more police in the same tow truck scandal. [1] All this to say, the corruption is a well known issue in Toronto. The provincial government has repeatedly claimed to go after "gangs", yet no solution has been put forth to end what is one of the biggest gangs in the province and the punishments that are doled out are pathetically light. [0] https://www.google.com/amp/s/beta.ctvnews.ca/local/toronto/2020/6/22/1_4994654.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/beta.ctvnews.ca/local/toronto/2... [1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cbc.ca/amp/1.5649083 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cbc.ca/amp/1.5649083 [2] https://correspondence.premier.gov.on.ca/EN/feedback/default.aspx https://correspondence.premier.gov.on.ca/EN/feedback/default... Edit: After writing this, I realized it would be more productive to write to my premier, so I did. You can too. [2]
- jariel 6y ago"The government entering the industry would reduce violence, corruption, and insurance costs for all." ??? Conversely, one would ask why on earth the government would ever get into such a thing it has clearly no business doing? You could make the same arguments about Taxis, Entertainment, Auto Manufacture, R&D, Convenience Stores - hey, let's 'socialize the entire economy' - think of how much more efficient it would be! The government doesn't really have a good track record in most of those things, so we like to regulate and have interventions where needed i.e. single point of failure. The government in Quebec and Ontario control Liquor and Beer distribution (beer in the latter) and the result is vastly overpriced goods. The liquor stores admittedly are 'really nice' but there are long line ups, and prices are out of this world. Even as wine sales are allowed in grocery stores in Quebec, the 'Gov. Liquor Monopoly' thuggishly enforced rules such that the quality of the wine out of their stores is so bad it's undrinkable. The only wine that made it out of their mafia control was what you'd get in the US for $4 a bottle, i.e. undrinkable. So no, some transparency, good laws and regulation would be appropriate, we don't need a cabal forming within the government taking over that system.
- jariel 6y agoFYI Vaughan/Woodbridge is literally the HQ of the actual Mafia in Canada, and the industry is in fact infiltrated by organized crime [1] [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-tow-truck-inspector-general-organized-crime-1.4083420 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-tow-truck-i...
- nimbius 6y agodisclosure: I work as a diesel engine tech in a midwestern city. Ive seen and dealt with a lot of tow companies, and a plurality are pretty shady but the worst are the police-centric ones. Lock-in deals with police departments for example are astroturfed as "the official tow company of $city police" without so much as an audit. Bidding almost never takes place for this service model, its just a cop whos wifes brother owns a tow company. These are generally the worst, as they rarely respond to anything but a parking enforcement dispatcher. The tow lot is derelect dirt property, and the only thing in the office is a credit card machine and a television. They exist to collect a fee and send a cut to the city, and rarely employ anyone who understands how to hook up a car safely, just quickly. If you hire a tow driver: look for the words "recovery" or an endorsement from your insurance company. Avoid AAA towing as shady companies habitually stencil that logo on everything. If there is a heavy recovery truck with a crane in their lot, you're in professional hands. If you're being towed: do not argue shout at or threaten the driver/operator, they're just paying their bills and if its an "official city" tow company it can get you a quick night in jail. instead document everything you can, take pictures and tak your time if you think you're being wrongly towed (it happens.) keep track of your vehicle after this. call and check up on it, as some of the shadiesst tow companies will actually send you a letter warning you of an intent to auction your property after a set date if you dont pay. Somethines this is just a scare tactic, other times its real (im told in Los Angeles they can do this.) Fighting a parking violation tow should be straight forward at your local courthouse unless the citys come to depend on tow revenue. If you're booted: call the city and confirm it! ask them to confirm the device by its serial number or markings and that information about your vehicles violation EXISTS With them. If you call the number on the boot to pay your fine, ask the person on the other end when the car was booted, who booted it, and at what time (all of which should be documented by the tow company.)
- _trampeltier 6y agoWhy is towing such a business in north america? Here in europe, you see rarely towing trucks. I remember, when I stayed in Vancouver in 2004, almost on every street corner was a towing truck.
- known 6y agoTRUTH is suppressed in the name of trust/loyalty/compliance/conspiracy/discipline/patriotism/sedition/job/national security/intellectual property https://yts.mx/movies/citizenfour-2014 https://yts.mx/movies/citizenfour-2014
- t0ughcritic 6y agoThe canadian government is run by a bunch of clowns. Law and order is a secondary thought, we’ve filed for ltb evictions 3 months ago with no hearing date even scheduled. Our tenants have been living rent free for 8 months, we can’t do anything. Now a lawyer doing her job can’t do it because the government has failed to clean up organized crime.
- ygjb 6y agoYou are criticizing the "Canadian government" as being run by a bunch of clowns, then complaining about evictions, which is a provincial matter. The LTB reference leads me to think you are in Ontario. I agree that there are problems, but at least be more precise in what you are complaining about.
- intrasight 6y agoI lived in Toronto for a couple of years in the early 90s. My apartment in a house had no off-street parking. No problem as all residents on street get a parking pass. But mine was never sent and so I got a ticket every day for many months. I ignored them. My wife and I went out to dinner with some friends one weekend evening. Parked on a side street even though there were temporary "no parking" signs posted on lampposts. Left restaurant to find a movie shoot in progress on that street. Someone gave me the name of the impound lot and our friends drove us there. I had a sick feeling in my stomach because of those unpaid tickets. Certainly a much larger dollar amount than the value of my 15 year old Honda. Told my wife and friends that the best case was that they'd keep the car but that they may still come after us for the balance. But information flowed more slowly in 1991, and the tow lot had no knowledge yet of those unpaid tickets when I arrived to get my car, and I only had to pay $75 to get it back. If I'd waited, they perhaps would have accessed the ticket database. Some time months later, we finally got our parking permit sticker. And somewhere in a file in the Toronto traffic department there's probably a couple hundred tickets with my license plate. As for the Accord. I had purchased used in Pittsburgh for $5000. Got married. Drove to Toronto where I lived for 2 years during graduate school. Drove it to MA where I worked for 5 years. Had a baby. Bought a 2nd car (also an Accord). Drove it to CT where I did consulting for a year. Then drove it back to Pittsburgh where I sold it for $500. Haven't thought of that story for many years.
- RocketOne 6y agoWell, the "kickback from an unscrupulous auto body shop, which then submits wildly inflated repair fees to an insurance company" part definitely makes sense. I do autobody and have painted my own cars in the past. Total cost for basic materials for an entire car is less than $600, depending on type of paint, color and finish. But earlier this year my truck tapped, quite literally TAPPED the back of an SUV when it rolled three feet forward from its parked position. The SUV owner and I had to look several times, and wipe off dirt and dust to see a 2 inch crack in the paint in the hatch. Total repair bill? $1800 for that damn 2" crack! It's robbery and there's no way it should cost that, but that was a 'discount' rate. I could've painted his entire SUV three times for that price! The autobody industry is out of control and insurance claims are often ridiculously inflated.
- gwright 6y ago> I could've painted his entire SUV three times for that price! I have no opinion on how much car paint materials cost but your logic that the $1800 is unreasonable because you can do the work three times for three times the bill of materials (~$600) illustrates a substancial misunderstanding of the cost structure of a business. This idea that the selling price of a good or service should be some minimal amount above the bill of materials shows up quite a bit on HN and it is just wrong.
- thedrbrian 6y agoI’d like to know what sort of modern car you can paint for a mere 600 dollarydoos. With the modern paints being multiple layers of pigment/metallic flake/other layers of translucent colour I’d bet manufacturer correct paint is more than 600 dollarydoos just to buy for a small car. Soul Red is 2 layers of colour/metallic flakes with clear on top. According to the shop where I got my car fixed you do 2 shots of each layer. For the new Renault red it’s 9 layers in total. http://www.roadster.blog/2015/02/mx-5-roadster-nd-colours.html http://www.roadster.blog/2015/02/mx-5-roadster-nd-colours.ht...
- clairity 6y agoi seem to recall that a tap under 5mph is not considered an accident in many (most?) jurisdictions. in any case, that's what bumpers quite literally are for (tested & certified for <5mph bumps), so the claim should be a warranty claim to their auto manufacturer, not an insurance claim. moreover, most (all?) insurance creates perverse incentives (see: healthcare) unless strictly and carefully defined (which is likely never, since the incentive is to rope in as many policyholders as possible).
- curation 6y agoThe tow truck industry is the first the I think of when someone says Toronto. (I lived there for 20 years).
- bdauvergne 6y agoNever heard of such kind of corruption in western Europe. You never call a tow truck directly, you call your insurance which has a register of tow trucks and body shop. If any would overprice regularly, it would be out of the register. The same for the cons in construction, all constructions of sufficient size are audited by Veritas or something alike, it's not possible to replace concrete with garbage. How is it possible that things are so different in northern america ?
- namdnay 6y agoI guess it depends whether you consider Italy to be part of Western Europe? Construction fraud is unfortunately extremely common in southern Italy
- cheeze 6y agoConstruction in Europe is always somewhat mindblowing to me as an American. Seems like most EU countries have the work-safety comparable to a third world country. I don't know anything about corruption, but man being a construction worker in say, Belgium, seems dangerous.
- bdauvergne 6y agoI have no number specifically for the constructions sector but in 2018, there were 5250[1] death attributed to work in the USA for 327,2 millions, which 16 deaths for 1 million inhabitants. This number was 136[1] deaths for 11.4 millions or 11.86 for 1 million. But the construction sector in the USA is so protected that if I was working in this sector I suppose I would still prefer to work in the states (higher pay for low qualified work). In western europe those jobs are mostly filled by eastern european or immigrants. [1]: sorry my references are in French, https://www.pressegauche.org/Pourquoi-tant-d-accidents-du-travail-aux-USA https://www.pressegauche.org/Pourquoi-tant-d-accidents-du-tr... (I would have preferred something with a domain less politically oriented, but the number seems safe), https://www.dhnet.be/actu/societe/136-accidents-du-travail-ont-cause-la-mort-en-2018-5deab9709978e272f9608e38 https://www.dhnet.be/actu/societe/136-accidents-du-travail-o...
- tpkahlon 6y agoI wish there was an app that could serve during time of emergency crisis. Based on your city, province, country of location, it could provide you step by step guide of handling next course of action. Right away, it tells user what is their crisis location address which will be required by insurance, and 911. Users can have option to start audio recording in app background to monitor themselves after crisis that they can use as proof later on. Based on crisis location, app can predict nearest locations of recommended service centres, hospital, fire, police stations and emergency contact location. For long term, it could shape up like Waze where people could report where crisis happened, which guideline they followed post crisis, rate them so other readers can read, interact etc. It would be nice if app can ask a series of questions and can dispatch info to your insurance company, CAA towing service etc. For example, all preliminary questions can be asked by app like How many passengers in car, any serious injuries, health related questions, license info etc. Once that is complete, it automatically submits this data to insurance for starting a case and dispatching tow service by recommeded parties like CAA at one touch of fingertip. This same info can be saved as PDF for distributing it to Police at scene. An app in form of educating people in a guided way can put an end to this corrupt business.