8 ms·
Is This the End of the Repairable iPhone?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> But the main camera module is not a security component. I wonder if this is related to the fact that iOS now shows an indicator light when the camera is active? If your phone ended up with a modified camera, perhaps it could spy on you without you knowing.
- fouc 6y agoThe article is arguing that it shouldn't be treated like a security component, but I'd probably disagree with that.
- manmal 6y agoThe indicator is purely software driven though. But, I could imagine that a complete spying device could be inserted instead of the camera module.
- speedgoose 6y agoThe light is not very useful anyway. Source: http://xlab.berkeley.edu/connect/Portnoff%20-%20WebcamPaper.pdf http://xlab.berkeley.edu/connect/Portnoff%20-%20WebcamPaper....
- supernova87a 6y agoI think the story isn't the end of the repairable iPhone. It's about the end of the consumer (or consumer segment) who cares enough to vote with their dollars for repairability more than new functionality and price. We are all free to vote with our money what we want. We collectively choose not to, on average.
- simongr3dal 6y agoHow would the consumer ever get to "vote" tho? There never was a year where Apple released a mediocre repairable phone and a slicker unrepairable phone, so the vote has never happened.
- gear54rus 6y agoThe first step of the process is to not buy anything apple recognizing there hardly ever was a company more hostile to user freedom both on software and hardware side.
- lokar 6y agoApple is not a computer company. They are a consumer electronics company.
- taejavu 6y agoAn alternative first step might be for other companies to make products that are as good as Apple’s.
- gear54rus 6y agoIt's happening every year on both desktop and mobile. You can't call walled gardens good sorry.
- taejavu 6y agoMaybe you can’t, and that’s fine, but for most people the superior user experience delivered by that walled garden is more appealing than any alternative. I’m not defending Apple’s user-hostile practices, I’m just saying that if this situation is going to change by people voting with their wallets, it’ll be because of changes to things that matter to the masses, and not the (totally legitimate) philosophical concerns of technology enthusiasts.
- OrwellianChild 6y agoI think this assumes a level of savvy in the average smartphone customer (aka the entire world)... Most people don't understand "repairability" in the context of less complicated systems (their cars, refrigerators, etc.). They can't vote for what they don't understand. This can be seen in product faults that remain fixed for many years in other consumer products. (see Samsung washing machines, GM ignition systems, etc.) Folks don't know how to evaluate design considerations at this level, I think this supports robust right-to-repair regulation as a counter-veiling force.
- jhanschoo 6y ago> It's about the end of the consumer (or consumer segment) who cares enough to vote with their dollars Is it though? Many competitor smartphones are still repairable, and they still control a good share of the market.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoActually I think most users would vote for a more reliable device over a repairable one. If using more glue means getting the phone wet is less likely to damage it or stops it breaking when dropped then that's a good tradoff. The fact my aging phone is still getting updates is more important than being able to replace the camera. I tend to buy my devices second hand so knowing it's difficult for a repairer to use sub standard parts is also good.
- nerbert 6y agoWait until the EU commission hears about it. I have a feeling that they’re not going to let this fly.
- pedro2 6y agoI hope so. But we have to be vigilant: “Big Tech's aggressive EU lobby caused a shift in power” [1] [1] https://www.europeandatajournalism.eu/News/Data-news/Big-Tech-s-aggressive-EU-lobbying-has-caused-a-power-shift https://www.europeandatajournalism.eu/News/Data-news/Big-Tec...
- supernova87a 6y agoI am actually a little puzzled by this, and maybe you can explain the position. Suppose that there is a consumer market for something, and people have shown their preferences, and are actually demonstrating that they actually don't want something (issue, feature, functionality). Are you saying that regulators should come in and force rules that satisfy the desires of say, 5% of users (if even that), to the detriment of the rest? Who are they to contradict the choices of the rest of the people? I mean, this is not like carbon regulation or pollution where someone's individual action has a negative shared cost on everyone else. What principle are we to apply then? There are tons of other 5% issues too -- which ones will be put into regulation? I think it's important to differentiate when your desire for something is personal and you want a company to do something despite others not caring about it, versus when there is actually harm being done and needs to be regulated.
- vladvasiliu 6y ago> We are all free to vote with our money what we want. We collectively choose not to, on average. While I agree with this on principle, to me it looks like it gives the collective us an agency which I would argue isn't really there in that not enough people consider it as a factor. I think that many people don't really care. As another commenter said, people seem to care more about "specs" (like in the commenter's example with people preferring Samsung phones because of the bigger screens) and about having the latest phone. This makes me wonder what percentage of people actually have to repair their phones, and of those, how many would have opted to do it themselves with off-brand components. While I understand the philosophical concerns around repairability and mostly like my laptops to be repairable, I also get the feeling that for phones it only now may become important, if at all, because of their usable life. My previous phone was a Galaxy S5, with a user replaceable battery. A new Samsung battery from a reputable store (not Amazon) costed 50-60 €. A battery replacement for the iphone costs 70 € at an authorised shop (I'm in Paris, France). I know I could have used an "alternative brand" battery in the GS5, but after a terrible experience with such a battery for a camera, I wouldn't go through that again. Now I understand that this or that model may have design issues which would have random components fail prematurely. But I doubt that replacing the component with an off-brand one would be that great. I'd consider that model a lemon and avoid it. Even if it would be simple, I'd hate to have to replace my phone's [x] every two weeks.
- supernova87a 6y agoWe live within many systems where what the majority wants determines what we get. Some things, if you can't build up enough support, you either live with or create your own environment where it is possible. If I live in a neighborhood where it takes 7/10 households to vote to improve the paved road, or install fiber internet, if only 3 of them want it, we're not getting any of those things. I can move to a different neighborhood, or pay for my own solution. This is life.
- emsy 6y agoVoting with money doesn’t work, regulations do.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 6y agoIMO it’s more direct to ask companies to be responsible for their externalities than it is to ask for repairability.
- adrianN 6y agoIt's infinitely harder to accurately put a dollar cost on externalities than to check whether a piece of hardware can be repaired.
- ashtonkem 6y agoIt’s tricky in some cases, but consumer electronics are actually pretty easy because most of the harm done is during manufacture (Apple estimates that more than 75% of an iPhone’s emissions come from manufacture). You could either expect Apple to pay for the externalities at production, or mandate that they’re required to accept back all dead Apple electronics and recycle them at a specific standard.
- adrianN 6y agoEven assuming that CO2 is the only relevant externality here (and not, say, electronic waste, mining runoff, chemicals used during manufacturing...), we don't have accurate models that can tell you a dollar cost per ton CO2. Estimates I've seen range from "climate change is not real" to 600 Euros. On the other hand you only have to disassemble an iPhone and check the availability of replacement parts to see whether it's repairable or not. It's easy to say exactly what damage can be repaired and what not. Very little room for discussion.
- threatofrain 6y agoBut as consumer devices become miniaturized and waterproofed, these kinds of advances come into natural tension with ease of repair. They are also the keys of somebody's data kingdom, and external repair shops bring in some risk.
- fouc 6y agoI have mixed feelings about this. I can see the need for security but at same time I can see why the big companies love to pursue "security", it gives them an incredible opportunity to exert even more control.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI'm going to guess that spare parts and repairs are a net loss for Apple. It's a cost of doing business. What they don't want is shody spares and repairs sullying their image.
- jmnicolas 6y agoAnd it can avoid bad actors replacing parts in your phone to spy on you but I don't think it's Apple's main motivation.
- yoz-y 6y agoI think image is the important thing. The one time I bought a used iPhone from a shop (reputable one), I received a device sold as "refurbished as new" with a clearly subpar third party display (protruding, wrong colors). Had I not known how the phone is supposed to look like I wouldn't have a great opinion of Apple's build quality. Now, Apple does have authorized and official repair shops. Clearly they don't have enough of them and they treat them quite poorly too. When I called one that I needed replacement AirPods Pro (already with a ticket from apple), they told me the wait time is 3 weeks because they can only source 1 part per week (and the two earpieces and the box are counted separately). Apple is fine if you live in a country with Apple stores, but outside of that it's a big risk.
- OrwellianChild 6y agoApple's choice of "buggy behavior without notification" over interoperability of parts with a permanent "non-Apple part" notice is a clear signal of intent. This is not a security issue - this is locking out 3rd party repair in a way that sows doubt in people who attempt these repairs (with "buggy" behavior present after replacement).
- buildbot 6y agoI feel like it’s exactly the opposite - buggy behavior is very anti apple, having a phone say “this part is unauthorized” is very clear and tells you that apple is invalidating 3rd party repairs, vs adding something that requires tuning/training via a software tool and fails sorta later. I feel like locking out 3rd party camera repairs via buggy behaviors is very...roundabout.
- OrwellianChild 6y agoI think we agree on the optics. I conclude that this is underhanded on Apple's part.
- bitwize 6y agoIf you had a pirated copy of Autodesk 3D Studio (before MAX, for DOS), everything would work and appear normal. But eventually, the geometry of your models would become corrupted -- subtly at first, then with continued use each model would become a spiky mess, like a fruit fly with an unfortunate hedgehog gene mutation. IHVs and ISVs can have subtle ways of punishing you for using their products in a manner not explicitly authorized. If you do not like the terms, do not buy the product.
- deadbunny 6y agoHow is pirating software and repairing a device you have purchased comparable?
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago
- whytaka 6y agoNot too long ago, I went to the Apple store to get my MacBook Pro looked at for a faulty key and degraded trackpad. As I had a Genius diagnose the issue, the screen brightness of my iPhone 7 had dropped nearly completely. While it was true that the glass of the screen had cracked due to a fall, the phone had operated just fine for many months since. The Genius told me it was likely a display issue while I told him it's much more likely a software issue. The Genius gave me the unfortunate advice of restarting the phone by holding down the power button and the lower volume button. The phone restarted, with the Apple logo in full brightness but would turn black when it came to logging in. Pity, since my password is too long to type it in without visual aide. The Genius told me that to repair the display was $200+. I scoffed at the price and told him it's not the display, and it was unacceptable as I planned on buying the iPhone 12 next month. The manager came by and made it clear there's no room to budge on the price. I resigned and left the device with them. When I was called in to pick up my phone, they told me that replacing the display did not work, so now my option was either to upgrade or to buy another iPhone 7 for $400+. I told them that's unacceptable and that it's clear it's not the hardware. I told them I am immersed in their ecosystem and I would easily spent another $2000 this year and to cut me a break. They told me, take it or leave it. I took the phone back and started making my way home. Descending into the metro, I walked past an ill-lit part of the platform. I looked at my phone again and realized I could faintly make out the log in screen. I typed in my password, logged in, went to control center and raised the brightness back up. Perfect. Now, even if I lower the brightness to its lowest setting, it works as normal. Not only is Apple's moves to cut out 3rd party repairs egregious, their own solutions and staff are rife with incompetence and their offer to you once you've immersed yourself into their ecosystem is, "Money now or go away". I am not buying the iPhone 12 and my next machine will run Linux.
- sdfhbdf 6y agoI had the same issue with iPhone 7 this August. I ended up letting the battery deplete leaving it for some time and then recharging it and that helped. I couldnt brighten the screen :( because of the Apple logo being at full Brightness i was also positive its software not hardware
- sebmellen 6y ago
- tinus_hn 6y agoSo how does this play out with the recently announced third party repair program?
- MikusR 6y agoThat program makes the repair shop order each part individually based on serial numbers.
- Kwpolska 6y agoIf you’ve got 16 minutes, listen to Louis Rossmann describe how much of a joke it is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rCUF-V1esM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rCUF-V1esM The short version is that Apple (a) does not let those stores order components in bulk, which means 2+ week turnaround on a repair that an independent store can do in 15 minutes, and (b) limits those stores to screens and batteries for iPhones. You can’t fix iPads, can’t fix Macs, can’t fix anything other than these two components.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoJust need to look at display replacement prices, with cracked displays being the most frequent damages (aka Spiderman app). Where these used to be around 60-80 EUR for iPhone 6 (third-party replacement parts), for the X and newer it's basically approaching the price of a new device. Samsung phones, or any other modern Android phone, are just as uneconomically to repair. It seems the only thing to stop the trend for extremely expensive throw-away phones is consumer-/eco-friendly legislation.
- bartvk 6y agoThere are more options. Sometimes the vendor offers extended warranty, like AppleCare. Also, some creditcards offer additional insurance, up to two years. And finally if you reall want the ultimate in repairability, there are phones like the FairPhone, or the Librem or the PinePhone.
- nbzso 6y agoI hate to repeat my self but this articles keep piling up. Vote with your money first, then if you have a way search legislative measures. They will never stop to search a way to profit more. This is just a beginning. Fully closed macs are coming. I don't care anymore for iPhones, my professional problem is with apple desktops and laptops. If we follow Apple logic in near future I will have to Jailbreak my personal computer that costs arm and a leg and cannot do 3rd party repairs on it. I am filling now very good about the decision to invest in multi platform software and avoid mac only apps. On a phone side someone suggested Fairphone (https://www.fairphone.com/en/ https://www.fairphone.com/en/) as an alternative. I can see a lot a value in this proposition, after rooting and removing Google crap/spyware.
- speeder 6y agoI wish Fairphone and their german competitor existed in Brazil. My last Android phones all of them failed in ways that were obvioous and simple to repair if it weren't for the fact they were glued shut.
- e_proxus 6y agoThere aren’t many (if any) realistic options. It basically boils down to Apple, Android or some extremely niche third party special phone (Fairphone etc.) which are mostly Android anyway. So either you pay Apple for premium hardware and software quality but loose out on repairability. Or you get Android which is a potential or actual privacy nightmare. Or you get an obscure other phone which is less supported and usually not as good value for money. The only thing that can really fix these problems is proper regulation. That’s the only language these companies understand.
- alisonkisk 6y agoAnd how will you feel if after legislation phones cost even more TCO than they do now?
- benhurmarcel 6y agoThe price of those phones don't follow their cost. They are purely down how high they can market them.
- meibo 6y ago> design choices so that products are easier to repair. What's more fun to me is that people actually still buy that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sudhirj 6y agoSince no one else seems to be doing so, I’ll do devil’s advocate: this is a really good idea. The last thing I want with an expensive phone is to give it in for repair and find it’s been stripped for parts and replaced with low quality knockoffs. Apple doing this makes me more confident giving it in for repair, because I know that when I get my phone back all the parts in it are still real. There are enough horror stories out there of cars and computers having their parts removed or replaced with older / cheaper ones when in the shop - if an article had been posted about this we’d all be asking why Apple didn’t do a crypto verification of all system components on boot.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoThis isn't an issue for the core demographic which buy Apple products (which is wealthy Americans). IDK, Apple is able to command such respect and prices not because of consumer confidence (in my opinion) but because they are the company who made the iPhone, which was a huge leap forward in terms of device innovation. Regular people don't think about or care how their phones get fixed. They don't care about app stores and all the kinds of things we on HN talk about. They care about user-friendliness and bang for their buck. Because Apple used to be so technologically innovative, even at high prices it felt like a bang for your buck. Now I don't think people think that's what you get with Apple anymore. They play it safe, they don't release innovative technology anymore. They just do what other people do. Apple TV+. Wireless earbuds. Slightly better components in each phone. I don't see them releasing anything that captures people's imagination the way the iPhone did anytime soon. And if they don't, they'll be just another phone/computer company to a lot of people. That's my humble opinion. Feel free to tell me I'm wrong and why.
- deniska 6y agoApple effectively disallowed repair even if a shop uses genuine parts from another identical phone. The only thing you can now be confident in is that nobody will be able to fix your phone.
- sschueller 6y agoStop buying Apple while you still can. It will not be long before you will not be able to install unsigned apps on your arm MacBook. Apple will have complete control of what you can and can not do which in effect gives a government full control of your device. It is extremely dangerous for democracy. Security is hard but can be achieved to a reasonable degree without a complete lock down. If Apple starts to loose market share other will stop copying these horrific practices.
- rmrfrmrf 6y agoI can't be the only one not shedding a single tear for the five 65-year-old tech retirees who have the time on their hands to perform manual repairs on their consumer devices.
- barnacled 6y agoIt does somewhat amuse me to see the degree to which people rationalise Apple's ongoing, consistent control freakery with excuses and justifications. Every time a story like this comes up the amount of people defending what they do really shocks me. I used to work for Imagination Technologies, whose GPU all Apple mobile devices are based upon. I was at the company when Apple announced that they would no longer require IMG and would be using their own entirely independently developed GPU (knocking 75% off the share value of the company and effectively bankrupting them). Looking from the inside of the story, the degree to which people both here on HN and in the media at large including, amazingly, the BBC, a state-funded UK news organisation took Apple's side of the issue when they were very clearly talking complete nonsense shocked me. Apple simply relied on the fact that a. they'd poached a ton of top people at IMG b. IMG could not afford to battle the decision in court (an aside - IMG and Apple have quietly signed a deal for IP again recently - hardly suggesting that Apple have gone entirely independent of IMG). We could get into the fact that the 'independent' GPU was bug-for-bug identical to IMG HW, or documentation for it literally referenced PowerVR enums but I don't want to dwell too much on that. My point is that Apple have for years taken an approach of trying to vertically integrate EVERYTHING and gain independent control of EVERYTHING. Many suppliers went the way of IMG, and this lack of repairability is in my opinion simply the latest episode of Apple not wanting anybody else whatsoever involved in their products. The trend continues with Apple moving to all-ARM chips (we'll see what happens with ARM IP, nvidia can fight longer in court so perhaps Apple will leave that alone) and will, in my opinion, continue in all areas for all of their products. Whether you think it's right or wrong it surprises me that people seem to lose sight of or deny this ongoing trend.
- tartoran 6y agoI agree with you but it doesn’t shock me at all, Apple knows very well what kind of users they are targeting and do enough to excite them every year with new toys. For a while they had taken the lead on many fronts but they seem to have lost that advantage due to their prevailing goal that isn’t likely to change anytime soon and for which they are doing better than anyone: money. I am not enamored with the alternative either and would avoid google’s tentacles even with more vehemence so the only thing i’m hoping for is an opensource phone os that isn’t controlled by any corp. I’m looking at the PinePhone which is very promising for a linux phone but they still need to catch up with the competition. If we all supported these types of initiatives we’d have what we really want even sooner.