16 ms·
Over 80% of Covid-19 patients in a hospital study have Vitamin D deficiency
- elchief 6y agoIf you're interested in getting more Vitamin D from your diet: Natural Vitamin D Content in Animal Products https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3941824/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3941824/ The Catholics were right. Eat fish on Fridays Also, Carlson Labs is the highest rated Vitamin D supplement on LabDoor: https://labdoor.com/review/carlson-labs-vitamin-d3 https://labdoor.com/review/carlson-labs-vitamin-d3
- mensetmanusman 6y agoWow, tuna has 30000 ug/kg, cool paper
- elchief 6y agotuna liver, that is. yum!
- ryukafalz 6y agoAlso has mercury. Alright in moderation, probably don’t make it a big part of your diet.
- elchief 6y agoTurns out the Selenium in fish neutralizes the Mercury http://net-effects.und.edu/pdfs/Selenium-Mercury.pdf http://net-effects.und.edu/pdfs/Selenium-Mercury.pdf
- calvano915 6y agoI was not aware of the mitigating effect of excess selenium vs. mercury content. Thanks for sharing this!
- elchief 6y agoMore: You can use https://cronometer.com/ https://cronometer.com/ to track your micronutrients An easy way to get more (beef) liver is to grind it, real cold, in your food processor and add to ground beef. At about 20% you can't taste it
- tren 6y agoIf you want to go the vegetarian option, shiitake mushrooms are good: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6213178/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6213178/. Interestingly, the mushroom's D content is based upon how much exposure they have to UV. Shameless plug -- I wrote an article about growing them at home, it's not too hard. We eat a lot of them: https://www.mushroom.guide https://www.mushroom.guide
- jennyyang 6y agoPaper suggesting vitamin D might protect against COVID-19 earns an expression of concern https://retractionwatch.com/2020/10/26/paper-suggesting-vitamin-d-might-protect-against-covid-19-earns-an-expression-of-concern https://retractionwatch.com/2020/10/26/paper-suggesting-vita... This isn't a home run yet, even though I would like to believe that Vitamin D has protective nature.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoRedressing nutritional deficiencies to protect against disease doesn't work like taking antibiotics. It takes time for the body to incorporate the missing nutrient into underperforming systems and get them back up to speed and you typically need other nutrients along with the one you are obviously deficient in to make proper use of it. Generally speaking, I wouldn't expect much in the way of good results to give massive doses of vitamin D to people so sick they have been hospitalized with Covid-19. But I think there is plenty of evidence to suggest that a good recommendation is "If you are vitamin D deficient and would like to actually survive the pandemic, raising your vitamin D status is the smart thing to do." I mean, you should do that anyway, even if there were no pandemic. It's just a hair more urgently life threatening at the moment. It's sound advice generally to say "If you are vitamin D deficient, you should seek to remedy that." It's sound advice with or without a global pandemic happening around you.
- joshgel 6y agoNot sure that this is true. It might be. But more likely being active enough such that you get the 15 minutes of sunlight daily needed to maintain normal vitamin D levels is better advice.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoWe are in complete agreement there. You are inferring that I am recommending supplements as the means to redress this. I am not and have suggested otherwise elsewhere and, wow, has it gotten ridiculous levels of push back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24913072 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24913072
- fataliss 6y agoIsn't something like 40% of the population "vitamin D deficient" though? https://www.nature.com/articles/s41430-020-0558-y https://www.nature.com/articles/s41430-020-0558-y
- kolbe 6y agoYep. And it’s possible that being bedridden with illness and under lockdown could contribute further to Vitamin D deficiency.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoI keep seeing studies saying this but the only way I know about it is because the links run up to the top page on HN. It even gets pretty short shrift among some of my more COVID-skeptic follows on Twitter. Seems like just total silence from media and public health officials on it.
- andreygrehov 6y agoPublic health officials are not saints. They are common people, like all of us. There is a high chance that HN readers know about the latest news way before "public health officials".
- AndrewBissell 6y agoBut this isn't "latest" news at this point, these studies have been coming out for awhile now, and given that low/moderate doses of vitamin D are a relatively low risk thing to take, a campaign to educate the public and at least get people to ask their doctors about it could make a big difference to the hospitalization rate.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoVitamin D has been known to improve outcomes with respiratory diseases like tuberculosis for about a century.
- djsumdog 6y agoI've heard people ask "Will all of this go away after the election," and we're seeing the same hysteria over COVID-19 in places like Canada and VIC, Australia, so my gut response would be 'no' ... But you cannot deny there is an extreme US-centric political angle to this; especially when you see stuff like this getting pulled or "fact checked" on major media platforms (who have shown their political colors). Maybe the American Media Propaganda machine is just bleeding out into the rest of the world? I cannot say, but I do think that COVID-19 is a case of mass hysteria, possibly the largest we've ever seen. I do not deny many have gotten sick and died, but I also think this is nowhere near as bad as people are making it out to be. The elderly should have been protected. The rest of us should have been allowed to make our own choices about risk. And the "long COVID" stories might be true or might be purely psychological. This is not a time of honor.
- justinzollars 6y agoThis is the kind of post that gets restricted on Twitter these days.
- josefresco 6y agoI didn't see it in the article, did they measure vitamin D levels in the general public or is that in another study?
- joshgel 6y agoThis was a retrospective study. Meaning the 'general population' they drew from were people with vitamin D tests during the period (Jan-Mar 2020) already drawn for some reason.
- jvanderbot 6y agoThe general population has vit-d deficiency, esp older and minority folks (in the US). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21310306/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21310306/
- itcrowd 6y ago> The overall prevalence rate of vitamin D deficiency was 41.6%, with the highest rate seen in blacks (82.1%), followed by Hispanics (69.2%). So doesn't explain the whole observed effect Edit: also the study was in Spain, not USA
- spikels 6y agoFrom the study: > Vitamin D deficiency was found in 82.2% of COVID-19 cases and 47.2% of population-based controls (p<0.0001).
- nradov 6y agoThere are numerous studies now showing a correlation between vitamin D deficiency and serious COVID-19 symptoms. I don't understand why public health officials aren't doing more to conduct widespread vitamin D level tests, and give out supplements when needed. Those interventions could save many lives at a low cost today while we work on more effective vaccines and treatments. https://vitamin-d-covid.shotwell.ca/ https://vitamin-d-covid.shotwell.ca/
- jopsen 6y agoI would suspect it's harder to prove that supplements have any effect. I mean vitamin D prevalence could be an indicator of something else.. On the other hand, it's been used as a supplement for a long time. So hopefully it's not outright dangerous in limited quantities.
- william_T 6y agoTrump got vitamin D infusions in the hospital. It's also something that taking a daily pill for will not have immediate effects. If you take OTC supplements today you won't see your levels increase for days or weeks.
- sdenton4 6y agoOf course, starting now is better than starting later to get the effects. That said, I can totally imagine people downing a megadose of vitamin D, declaring themselves immune, and going out to lick doorknobs immediately.
- jaden 6y agoOver 80% of COVID-19 patients are right-handed too.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sharken 6y agoAnd quite old, more than 70 percent who died with Corona in Sweden were 80 years or older, https://www.statista.com/statistics/1107913/number-of-coronavirus-deaths-in-sweden-by-age-groups/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1107913/number-of-corona...
- jjnoakes 6y agoWhich would be notable if that ratio was significantly different from the general population...
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoMost of the severe cases are old people, most old people are vitamin d deficient. This could be a whole non finding.
- jdminhbg 6y agoThey controlled for demographics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- electrondood 6y agoRight-handedness doesn't attenuate immune response, which happens to be what puts COVID patients in the hospital.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- graeme 6y agoIt would be instructive to know the vitamin d deficiency rate of the typical 2019 hospitalized population. Or the rate of, say, hospitalized patients in taiwan or new zealand (no covid) compared to their general populace’s. I’m a big proponent of the idea that vitamin d will likely help against covid 19 but this headline is missing some crucial comparative context. —— Edit: I’m rather wrong in the part below. Patient only refers to people receiving treatment, so this is an accurate use. Keeping it there for posterity. I believe the rest of my comment still stands. The headline is inaccurate. The study looked at hospitalized patients. That is a group in much worse health. And all manner of health conditions are correlated with low vitamin d.
- OJFord 6y agoIt says 'patients', feeling a bit squiffy and calling in sick doesn't make you a patient (not even an out-patient), medical treatment or attention does.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- graeme 6y agoYou’re quite right, I hadn’t properly thought through what patient means precisely. I edited my comment, thanks!
- dbbk 6y agoWhat is a non-hospitalised patient?
- SippinLean 6y agoA patient that is no longer hospitalized > 216 patients aged ≥18 years, with confirmed COVID-19 [admitted] from March 10 to March 31, 2020, and > 197 sex-matched population-based controls recruited from the Camargo Cohort during their last follow-up visit on January-March of the past year
- Barrin92 6y ago
- sajithdilshan 6y agoIn case you've forgotten correlation does not imply causation
- lincolnq 6y agoI feel silly responding to a downvoted comment, but here goes anyway: Correlation does not imply causation, but it wiggles its eyebrows suggestively and points “look over there!” (Thanks Xkcd) In this case, we are in a position of not knowing very much about what causes/prevents COVID. Based on this study, we can learn Vitamin D seems to be involved, and there is an obvious causal mechanism that one can hypothesize might exist, even if not proven. Even if there’s only a 10% chance that vitamin D supplementation could be helpful, knowing it as a possibility could be useful to many, and justify action even if uncertain about the causality.
- pazimzadeh 6y agoJust a stray thought from someone who knows little about vitamin D, but is there any way that vitamin D could be used up by cells with replicating viruses, and that's why the levels are low in patients?
- KerryJones 6y agoIt's been shown in other studies that COVID-19 does not _cause_ Vitamin D deficiency, if that's what you're implying.
- rossdavidh 6y agoThat sounds really interesting! Do you happen to have a link to that? I'm not "challenging", I would just be interested in reading that, if you happen to remember where you saw it.
- electrondood 6y agoNo, it's the deficiency of vitamin D that makes a runaway immune response possible, which is what typically kills people with COVID.
- outside1234 6y agoCould this be simply because they have been trapped inside in bed (not getting sunlight)?
- djsumdog 6y agoVitamin D doesn't go up or down in a few days. It's a cumulative thing.
- beagle3 6y agoStudies show that a Month after a megadose of 60,000IU blood levels revert to base level, - so it does, in fact, change significantly over a few days. Furthermore, it’s possibly the body uses more for some processes when in distress, which would complicate reasoning.
- JohnTHaller 6y agoAbout 45% of the US population has Vitamin D deficiency. It's higher among some populations (elderly as they are more likely to be home-bound, African American as darker skin inhibits UV absorption, obesity due to adipose tissue storage, etc). Those of us further North are more likely to be deficient as well due to decreased exposure during much of the year and being inside or bundled more in winter months.
- agotterer 6y agoThe article wasn’t very detailed and I wasn’t able to figure out if you are more likely to catch COVID because you have a vitamin D deficiency or if catching COVID causes a vitamin D deficiency. Anyone know?
- JohnTHaller 6y agoFrom other articles and study abstracts I read, it seems that an existing vitamin D deficiency is correlated with worse Covid-19 outcomes (worse symptoms, higher levels of death).
- SippinLean 6y agoThis particular study found no causation > No causal relationship was found between vitamin D deficiency and COVID-19 severity as a combined endpoint or as its separate component
- btilly 6y agoThat doesn't mean what you (and possibly they) think that means. Suppose that characteristic X (eg vitamin D deficiency) puts you at risk of doing worse at Y. If we pick a population based on how poorly they do at Y, we expect to see that X will be more common than it is in the general public. But within that population there is no reason to believe that having characteristic Y makes you do worse - it just made you more likely to do badly enough to be selected. This can be seen quite precisely with a toy model. Suppose that we have a population evenly split between 2 subpopulations with a characteristic that varies on a normal distribution. However one population averages 1 standard deviation worse. If we pick the bottom 5% of the population on that characteristic, we will find about an 80-20 split based on having the risk factor. The bottom 1% also has the same 80-20 split. Ditto the bottom 0.1%, 0.01%, and so on. The reason is that the sum total of how many are in the tail of the normal falls off exponentially fast, with the same exponent in both populations. So the ratio stays constant. No amount of analysis of people in that tail will suggest that characteristic matters. But comparing the population in that tail to the general population, that standard deviation stands out like a sore thumb as a major risk factor. Therefore the fact that about 50% of the general population has vitamin D deficiency while over 80% of those hospitalized with COVID-19 do suggests that vitamin D deficiency is a risk factor. But we should draw no conclusions from the fact that vitamin D deficiency doesn't indicate different outcomes within the population landing in the hospital. (However other research found that patients given vitamin D once landing in the hospital were significantly less likely to wind up in the ICU or dead. We should definitely draw some conclusions from that!)
- m0zg 6y agoI've seen people argue _against vitamin D supplementation_. WTF? I mean, sure, it's not "proven" to work, and there haven't been any "gold standard" studies. But why not just have everyone take 5000IU a day for the duration? What's the downside here?
- likpok 6y agoThe argument is generally: Vitamin D has a lot of complex interactions in the body and is fat-soluble. That makes it very easy to overdose, and the recommended doses are substantially higher than normal dietary intake. Most studies on vitamin D don't really differentiate between vitamin D from supplementation and vitamin D from going outside, meaning that the protective effect might be from the activity not the vitamin. If everyone takes 5K IU/day, then you'd expect issues from about half of people (if baseline of 50% of people are low is correct). Those issues are nontrivial. I personally think that most people (especially those who spend a lot of time indoors) should probably supplement, and most of the reaction is overstated.
- im3w1l 6y ago50% deficient doesn't mean 50% have too much. It's not a hair-thin line you are balancing. There is a wide band of acceptable values.
- ahelwer 6y agoVitamin D supplementation has side effects, or at least it does for me. On three separate occasions I've tried to take some X,000 IU pill and spent the next 24-48 hours extremely lethargic and unable to summon the willpower to do anything. Very similar to depression.
- soganess 6y agoThis was wrong.
- scythe 6y ago>I'm sure there is a very good reason for this 50 year old, really high impact, supposedly peer reviewed, journal of medicine to have a single line Wikipedia page. Is this a serious comment? Take a look at their editorial board: https://academic.oup.com/jcem/pages/editorial_board https://academic.oup.com/jcem/pages/editorial_board
- soganess 6y agoUgh, I'm a complete idiot. I always just run sources that I don't really know that much about through the first pass filter of who is the publisher of the article and how are they related to the journal and the authors. Then do a Wikipedia search to see if they at least have visibility there. This failed the sniff test in my book, but clearly I was wrong.
- stakkur 6y ago"Study finds over 80 percent of 200 COVID-19 patients in a single hospital in Spain have Vitamin D deficiency" is the accurate title. And behold: "most studies in Spain show a high prevalence of vitamin D deficiency" https://www.nature.com/articles/ejcn2010265 https://www.nature.com/articles/ejcn2010265
- itcrowd 6y agoFrom your link: > One-third (33.9%) of the Spanish population may be at risk for Vitamin D deficiency. So that doesn't explain the >80% from TFA.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vhold 6y agoThe study is linked to this article.. people should try reading or at least scanning it before dismissing or speculating on it. In particular read the discussion and look at Table 1. https://academic.oup.com/jcem/advance-article/doi/10.1210/clinem/dgaa733/5934827 https://academic.oup.com/jcem/advance-article/doi/10.1210/cl... I'll point out one important thing, the non-vitamin-D-supplement taking patient group, and the control group (which also is not taking supplements), both have a median age of 61.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoOr is just as simple as frail people don’t go outside?
- twic 6y agoExactly this. Vitamin D level is a proxy for general health. Studies that have controlled for other factors affecting health have not found a protective effect from vitamin D [1]. Hacker News is obsessed with vitamin D because it seems like a hack. A cheap and simple way to solve a tough problem that you can feel smart about having found. [1] https://www.nice.org.uk/advice/es28/evidence/evidence-review-pdf-8777674477 https://www.nice.org.uk/advice/es28/evidence/evidence-review...
- graeme 6y agoIt’s rather poor form to link a 60 page report without specifying which section supports your argument. I skimmed it and didn’t see what you said, and the summary recommends vitamin d supplementation in general. Further, this spanish RCT suggests vitamin D had incredibly strong effects in preventing patients from needing to go to the ICU. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960076020302764?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096007602...
- stefan_ 6y agoWith the added bonus that while Vitamin D is a proxy for general health, supplementing it does nothing. It's the perfect science ignorance bonfire.
- itake 6y agoI see this idea posted a lot. Do you have any sources to back this up?
- howlgarnish 6y agoThere have been a lot of studies done on vitamin D supplements, and there is essentially no significant evidence that supplementation is useful for anything. The sole exception is rickets, which is caused by vitamin D deficiency. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D#Use_of_supplements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D#Use_of_supplements There is also considerable debate over the comparative efficiency & effects of natural synthesis via sunlight vs ingesting supplements, compounded by the difficulty of accounting for things like exercising outdoors vs being sedentary indoors.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoVitamin D is critical to strong bones. Please note that bone marrow is where a lot of our immune cells are produced, such as white blood cells. It is also critical to the ability of the body to absorb and utilize calcium. Inability to properly absorb calcium tends to also foster a magnesium deficiency and vitamin K is the other vitamin you should be taking when taking calcium supplements to make sure you are able to absorb it and make use of it. Vitamin K is critical to the clotting process, as is calcium. Calcium is necessary to start the cascade of chemical processes that lead to clotting. I have a genetic disorder and I have a long history of being prone to nose bleeds. Tendency to bleed is a common problem for my condition, which is also known to be associated with osteoporosis at very young ages (sometimes starting in the teens), though bleeds that this population most often is concerned with is lung bleeds. When an online friend of mine was dealing with lung bleeds in their child with the same condition, I did some looking around for info and found that calcium is critical to the clotting process. I don't know if that info helped her help her child, but as a consequence I eventually began taking 600 to 1000 mg of calcium carbonate in response to gushing nose bleeds (as opposed to the constant low-level blood seepage in my nose that was my norm for years). This practice stopped my nose bleeds cold in twenty minutes without other intervention and after six months I stopped having nose bleeds. Covid-19 significantly impacts blood health. Anyone interested in understanding the role of vitamin D deficiency in Covid-19 should be curious about the relationship between vitamin D and blood health. Covid-19 was initially talked up as primarily a respiratory infection, but ventilators were not performing very well for helping the sickest of the sick with this condition and there was a shockingly high mortality rate for people who ended up on ventilators -- high even for what is "normal" for people who typically end up on ventilators. Everything seems to point to the idea that the way Covid-19 impacts the blood is a critical detail of why it is so deadly in some populations. If you have reason to believe you are vitamin D deficient, you should address that. If you address it, you most likely also need calcium, magnesium and vitamin K as well in order to redress the negative impact this has had on your health. They work together and not getting enough of any one of those tends to negatively impact your status for all of them. (I am not a doctor. This is not medical advice. I am someone with a serious medical condition running my mouth on the internet. Please leave me alone with your bizarre delusions that leaving comments on this topic means I am "practicing medicine without a license" while you refuse to acknowledge the obvious inference that your concern is rooted in "Damn. That woman knows too damn much and we aren't happy about it for various reasons.")
- lend000 6y agoHow long does it take for Vitamin D levels to fall to "deficient" levels from healthy levels? If you don't supplement and stay quarantined inside for a week in the winter, what effect does that have on your levels?
- frank2 6y agoI once took too much vitamin D, and it took months of avoiding dietary D and sunlight before the symptoms went away.
- jodrellblank 6y agoIt's surely possible to take too much, but it's a lot. A typical over the counter tablet is 500-1500 IU of Vitamin D. Here[1]'s a study giving an oral dose of 100,000IU to a hundred people, and here[2]'s a paper suggesting muscular injections of 600,000IU in 10 people showed no evidence of metabolic abnormality. The Mayo Clinic[3] site says: > Taking 60,000 international units (IU) a day of vitamin D for several months has been shown to cause toxicity. This level is many times higher than the U.S. Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) for most adults of 600 IU of vitamin D a day. That's 100x the recommended dose, every day, for months. Were you using powdered vitamin D instead of protein powder by mistake or something? [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28328526/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28328526/ [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28492140/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28492140/ [3] https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/expert-answers/vitamin-d-toxicity/faq-20058108 https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-h...
- frank2 6y agoHow much a person can take without producing symptoms varies. My threshold was much lower than average probably because of chronic infections, e.g., Lyme disease. https://mpkb.org/home/pathogenesis/th1spectrum https://mpkb.org/home/pathogenesis/th1spectrum
- beagle3 6y agoDeva Boone’s blog (an MD featured often on HN) describes a case where an extra 5000IU supplement caused neurological problems. IIRC, there was no regard to other sources - e.g. she might have gotten 30,000 other IU per day from Milk and another amount from fish. Very unlikely - much more likely that something else made it toxic in that case. Regardless, it is clear that the upper safe limit has significant variance and is not well characterized. (Personally have been on 10,000IU daily for the past 7 years with no ill effects and possibly good effects, n=1 standard disclaimer)
- fortran77 6y agoMany studies suggest that vitamin D deficiency is a consequence of Obesity. (See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6780345/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6780345/ ) Given that the obese are more likely to be hospitalized after getting COVID-19, this may be a reason they're seeing this. This subject is taboo, so it doesn't get considered.
- SamBam 6y agoI don't think the topic is particularly taboo. It's well-known that obesity is a factor in Covid mortality.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe actual title of the thing you linked to: Vitamin D Deficiency: Consequence or Cause of Obesity? As someone who dropped several dress sizes by improving my nutritional status with zero intent to slim down, I am of the opinion that obesity is caused by eating empty calories. You keep eating and eating because you aren't getting enough nutritional value. Your constant hunger subsides if you actually eat nutritious foods that actually meet your nutrient needs. I used this theory to also help one of my sons drop several sizes without doing anything else. He had really gotten quite large and it was negatively impacting his back issue. His brother told me "It's because he sucks down chocolate pop tarts all day." so my response to that was "Let's get you some good quality dark chocolate. You are likely craving the actual chocolate for some reason and chocolate pop tarts don't have all that much." He slimmed down dramatically after that and it was the only thing we did different.
- lvturner 6y agoThe laws of thermodynamics apply - calories in calories out. The real difficulty though, is that for some, to be in a calorie deficit is intolerably difficult. So while I agree with your hypothesis, and also believe that the cure is "simple" I think it's important to not forget the individual in all of this. A huge deal of it is behavioural and educational too - a lot of people think that because they spray olive oil on to their pan, instead of drizzle it, it has zero calories!
- riverdroid 6y agoI know vitamin D is inexpensive to manufacture, but with all of this new demand, I really hope that there is testing going on. I would not be surprised if Amazon has a bunch of fake supplements mixed into their supply chain for example. The vitamin supplement industry is notoriously under-regulated.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoVitamin D is not a true vitamin in that vitamins are defined as critical nutrients we cannot manufacture and vitamin D can be manufactured in the body (by most people). It also available to some degree in various foods. It often gets added to milk in the US by the manufacturer and certain fish oils are high in vitamin D, like cod liver oil. People can make a point of adding more dietary vitamin D or making sure to get a little more exposure to sunlight daily. It is absolutely not necessary for this to only be addressed by buying supplements in pill form and that is probably not even a best practice for improving vitamin D status. (Edited. Not sure if for "typos" or because "God, I hate auto-corrupt so much sometimes.")
- outworlder 6y agoVitamin D is also special in the sense that it's a hormone. > People can make a point of adding more dietary vitamin D or making sure to get a little more exposure to sunlight daily. Getting sufficient vitamin D from diet alone is difficult. UV exposure also has risks, which may be higher for some. The required exposure time is measured in minutes a day. If you are still deficient it may be better to supplement, rather than getting exposed to UV for more time.
- mgberlin 6y agoThere is not enough UV-B in sunlight for your body to manufacture vitamin D when the sun is less than fifty degrees above the horizon. This means that for the majority of the northern half of the United States and all of Canada, you can't make _any_ vitamin D from the end of fall to the beginning of spring.
- Raphmedia 6y ago
- hikerclimber 6y agothis is false. I hope covid spreads even more and kills 2 million people worldwide and half a million people in the U.S.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoIt doesn't say when they took the blood sample that was used. The issue being, if someone is ill they typically don't go outside. They also likely eat less. At some point vitals are going to tail off. I'm not disputing the value of Vitamin D. But without details this could be a simple case of correlation.
- SamBam 6y agoVitamin D always to remain in the body for months, so I think that's unlikely to cause a significant difference. https://www.nutraingredients.com/Article/2013/10/30/Vitamin-D-has-longer-than-expected-half-life-Tests-may-not-show-true-plateau https://www.nutraingredients.com/Article/2013/10/30/Vitamin-...
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThe opening paragraph says it studied ppl after one year of high dose Vitamin D. That doesn't really apply to most people.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Threeve303 6y agoIt’s all kind of obvious when you stop and think about it. Humans as a species used to get far more sunlight. Is it a coincidence when you consider a disease from a nocturnal animal was able to jump over? Humans have become more nocturnal in the sense that while we don’t sleep during the day, we often fear going outside. This has consequences. Now a step too far on the cynicism side might be to point out how coincidental it is that a bunch of racists came to power across the globe and not too long after a pandemic happens that seems to disproportionately target people who can’t absorb vitamin D very well.
- technocratius 6y agoThat is indeed a step too far
- TedShiller 6y agoAs does everyone else who doesn’t have Covid 19
- m3kw9 6y agoHave they also rule out COVID-19 causing vitamin D deficiency?
- vvpan 6y agoIt's a correlational study, so that'd be difficult. Although an experimental double-blind study was posted here a couple of weeks ago that had impressive results.
- smallnamespace 6y agoVery unlikely given what we know about biochemistry. Vitamin D is fat-soluble so your body stores it in fat. Because of this, levels are generally stable over a period of months. Although there are health conditions that cause vitamin D levels to fall (particularly chronic kidney disease), it's highly implausible that COVID-19 itself could cause vitamin D deficiency directly. Even if COVID-19 were to cause kidney issues and you didn't see sunlight for two weeks, it wouldn't move someone with adequate vitamin D levels into the deficient range. The time period is simply too short.
- kylebenzle 6y agoMost people with depression are D deficient too. Either D deficiency causes EVERYTHING or this means nothing. Science is broken and has been for a long time.
- afrojack123 6y agoVitamin D and artificial sunlight can even prevent seasonal flu. But it wouldn't be good for the vaccine industry.
- Havoc 6y agoCan’t they just add it to the tap water? At least in high risk areas temporarily. Ugly solution but so is running out of ICU beds
- charliebrownau 6y agoAlmost like the whole thing was a PLANDEMIC #agenda21 #id2020 #globalreset #2030 #plandemic
- pupdogg 6y ago80% reported deaths relating to COVID are also pneumonia related deaths categorized as COVID for government subsidy of approx $33k per patient.
- fuckyah 6y agoDue to lock downs
- TeeMassive 6y agoAnd what is most shocking is that nobody is talking about this.
- MichaelMoser123 6y agoNobody seems to be asking a related question: in a sunny country like Israel vitamin D deficiency should be less common, does that translate into fewer Covid-19 cases? Well, there seem to be differences between different ethnic & religious groups, but on average vitamin D deficiency seems to be less prevalent in Israel: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28647929/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28647929/ However Covid-19 cases don't seem to have been lacking in Israel https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/israel/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/israel/
- mixmastamyk 6y agoDon’t they have a lot of old folks as well? It’s a multi-factor situation.
- wk_end 6y agoI don't see how it would mean fewer SARS-CoV-2 infections. It might mean fewer infections proceed to symptoms, hospitalizations, and death. Just from your source, their CFR is around 0.8%. That's not IFR, so it's hard to really do a serious comparison, but for the heck of it Canada's CFR is ~4.4%, Sweden's is ~5.1%, the US' is ~2.5%, Germany's is 2.2%.
- MichaelMoser123 6y agoMakes sense. Thank you! Is it possible to know how certain the CFR measures are? I would have guessed that the CFR depends on the test coverage and maybe other factors as well; With what degree of confidence are the CFR figures treated? however these are all countries with not too different level of health care, so that my armchair guess would be that this is a meaningful number (would have to be corrected for different age distribution, somehow)
- wk_end 6y agoCFR is just confirmed deaths divided by confirmed cases. It's absolutely certain, but that's also why it's not a great basis for a serious analysis of most things. We can comfortably say the numerator is roughly correct, but the denominator is likely too low because we probably missed a lot of cases, given limited testing capacity and just how asymptomatic COVID often is. IFR is actual deaths divided by actual infections. It's the most important number, but also much harder to figure out, because the delta between confirmed cases and actual infections is, by definition, unknown. So, in context, if we look at CFRs, it looks like Israelis are 3x less likely to die from COVID than Americans. Maybe that's vitamin D, or maybe instead Israel tested and identified every single person with COVID, whereas America missed two for very case they identified. If we could instead see the IFRs in that case, they'd actually be roughly the same, and it'd turn out (all other things being equal) that vitamin D was irrelevant.
- kgc 6y agoI feel like 80% of the US population has a vitamin D deficiency already...
- sgtnoodle 6y agoVitamin D is involved in the regulation of the body's immune system and inflammatory response. There's a known correlation between low vitamin D readings and inflammatory diseases. Severe COVID complications seem to be primarily inflammatory in nature. It seems to me that folk that are prone to inflammatory problems are likely to both measure low on a vitamin D test and be prone to having a severe reaction to COVID. A low vitamin D reading doesn't necessarily mean you are vitamin D deficient. There are two forms of vitamin D in the body, inactive and active, and the more common/cheaper blood test only measures the inactive form. The active form is what affects the body, though. High levels of active vitamin D can cause serious damage to your body. It's probably not a good idea to supplement vitamin D without consulting a doctor.
- caryd 6y agoVery fascinating study. Thanks
- nolim1t 6y agoSo staying at home actually gives the opposite effect
- lucas_membrane 6y agoDr John Campbell (a PhD nurse educator) who has been putting out youtube videos of research-based plain English explanations of various aspects of the COVID-19 pandemic, has been beating this drum regularly for eight or nine months. One of his videos did mention that vitamin D deficiency is very high in Spain, particularly in some specific regions of Spain, so don't jump to conclusions about the amount of risk reduction from adequate vitamin D levels. Dr Fauci is reported to be taking 6000 units per day, way higher than the recommended daily allowance in the USA.
- Wolfenstein98k 6y agoEvidence builds, but that's still just correlation.
- hannofcart 6y agoDoes anyone here have any idea of the percentage of Covid related fatalities that DON'T make it to the hospital before death? Asking here since HN is filled with people of erudition. And because am not a medical researcher and have no idea where they hang out.
- kesor 6y agoOver 99% of Covid-19 patients are going to die in the next 100 years. If only we could add about 50-60 years to their lifespans, we could cure Covid-19!
- iso1210 6y agoYes, a better number when looking at the impact would be in life-years lost when looking at the cost of covid. That's about $130k per quality-adjusted life-year, or $60k per year for dialysis paitents. [0] US Covid Deaths by age 85+: 63,864 75-85: 55,089 65-75: 45,015 55-65: 26,525 45-55: 11,093 35-45: 4,206 25-35: 1,628 <25: 462 Lets assume a 2:1 male:female death ratio and mid points for all groups except 85+ (which will use 85). Just an approximation Life expectency [2], woman, man, combined 85: 7y, 5+10m, 6 80: 9+8m, 8, 9 70: 16+6, 14+3, 15 60: 24+6, 21+6, 22 50: 33+2, 29+8, 31 40: 42+6, 38+7, 40 30: 52+1, 48, 49 20: 61+9, 57+3, 59 So years saved 85+: 383k 75-85: 825k 65-75: 990k 55-65: 580k 45-55: 340k 35-45: 170k 25-35: 80k <25: 27k So total years: 3.4 million, an average of 16 years per death. At $60k a year that's $200b. At $130k a year that's $440b As the cost to the US economy is estimated in the 10T range, it seems a poor use of funds. However that assumes more intervention would save more lives. With an IFR of 0.9% (even assuming no collapse in health system, but IFR estimates also overread) you'd be looking at 2.5-3 million dead overall depending how many got it. That still would come out at 5T tops, so on a financial basis better to just let it rip. However the big assumption is that there would be no cost to economy without intervention as many people decide to stay at home, as confidence is lost and people stop spending, and that runs into a recession anyway. The 2008 recession cost $70k per person [3], that's 23T. It also assumes that the 5T could be spent elsewhere in saving lives. [0] https://www.valueinhealthjournal.com/article/S1098-3015(10)60676-6/pdf https://www.valueinhealthjournal.com/article/S1098-3015(10)6... [1] https://www.heritage.org/data-visualizations/public-health/covid-19-deaths-by-age/ https://www.heritage.org/data-visualizations/public-health/c... [2] https://coolconversion.com/heath/life-expectancy-calculator-us/Life-expectancy-at-age_74_in-US_w https://coolconversion.com/heath/life-expectancy-calculator-... [3] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-much-the-2008-financial-crisis-cost-you-in-dollars/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-much-the-2008-financial-cri...
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoSpains Lockdown was particularly strict - would being locked inside for a month with less sun cause noticable Vitamin D deficiency? I'd guess that Vitamin D deficiency is a symptom of the same health/lifeystyle/diet that raises the likelyhood of being hospitalized with Covid-19, rather than a cause of it - but I'm no expert. "Vitamin D insufficiency is highest among people who are elderly, institutionalized, or hospitalized. In the United States, 60% of nursing home residents and 57% of hospitalized patients were found to be vitamin D deficient." https://www.medscape.com/answers/128762-54281/what-is-the-prevalence-of-vitamin-d-deficiency-in-the-us https://www.medscape.com/answers/128762-54281/what-is-the-pr...
- neilwilson 6y agoOne data point for anybody interested. Getting enough Vit D in modern life is more difficult than it first appears. Initial test: https://new-wayland.com/blog/onward-to-100-nmol/ https://new-wayland.com/blog/onward-to-100-nmol/ Follow up: https://new-wayland.com/blog/to-100-nmol-update/ https://new-wayland.com/blog/to-100-nmol-update/
- robarr 6y agoVitamine D guide by Steve Gibson https://www.grc.com/health/vitamin-d.htm https://www.grc.com/health/vitamin-d.htm
- hkt 6y agoWinter is coming - if memory serves, rates of vitamin D deficiency double at northern latitudes during winter.
- huffmsa 6y agoGo outside. Walk around in the fresh air. Does the body wonders.
- PeterStuer 6y agoSince I see many confused comments below, keep in mind that while causal relations are unclear (a very hard thing in anything metabolic), the correlation is well established and uncontested, and holds across sub-population characteristics including age, sex, race etc. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0239252#pone-0239252-g001 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- madrox 6y agoWorth noting case control studies like this have inherent bias because your sample is of very sick people. It’s like saying out of all car accidents a disproportionate amount of them were Uber drivers. Being an Uber driver won’t get you in an accident. Uber drivers just drive more. This is correlation at best. That said, this was also the type of study that found the original link between smoking and lung cancer. So while being vitamin D deficient may not cause me to end up in the hospital if I get COVID, I’m going to be taking a supplement just in case.
- headmelted 6y agoIs it though? An Uber driver is likely to spend more time in a car, and therefore more likely to be in a car accident. Is a person more likely to spend time around sick people if they’re Vitamin D deficient? Yes it’s correlation, but correlation specifically without known other causes (Unlike the Uber example).
- madrox 6y agoYes, that’s the point of the Uber example, and while it’s trivial to realize what the hidden correlation is in this case it’s pointing out there could be other hidden correlations in this case we don’t automatically know. For example, vitamin D deficiency can be a symptom of an underlying issue that is actually what causes sicker patients. Or what’s even more likely, vitamin D deficiency is more prevalent among elderly and African Americans, who have been disproportionately hit harder by COVID because they’re more vulnerable to disease in general (former) or are more likely to be unable to isolate due to being an essential worker (latter). And before we start debating these specific possibilities, the point is to illustrate we can’t just assume more than the sampling method dictates. Different studies are needed.
- headmelted 6y agoGotcha, with you now. Now that you’ve phrased it this way I see your point and I’ve actually been thinking this myself for a while now. Also, you wouldn’t believe the amount of conversations I’ve had with people who are convinced it “only kills old people” who’s eyes glaze over when I explain that there are other outcomes besides living and dying. Everyone in the world seems to believe it’s a magical death lottery that instantly switches the lights off for 0.01% of people who catch it, and the other 99.99% of people are therefore completely fine. The whole world’s gone mad.
- andy_ppp 6y agoCorrelation or causation. It’s worth noting that almost all studies supplementing vitamin d have shown one thing; it increases vitamin d levels and causes you to absorb more calcium. No cancer or disease benefits shown yet. What we do know is eating healthy and getting outside to do exercise definitely helps chronic diseases and this also happens to increase vitamin d levels.
- s_dev 6y agoWe convert sunglight in to Vitamin D. Surely the most plantlike phenomena in our bodies or are there other examples of such phenomena?
- deepsun 6y agoIf I was manufacturer of vitamin D supplements, I'd certainly sponsored these studies. What about other vitamins/minerals? I'm certain we can find some other deficiency among people more likely to get sick (not necessarily of Covid19).
- tsjq 6y agoThat's my thought too. What all tests are they running on all covid patients ?
- fnord123 6y agoRelevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- _ink_ 6y agoNot sure if you want an answer, but there was study that suggests vitamin A and E are also helping to fight respiratory diseases.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JjkingofCankle 6y agoCorrelation ≠ Causation
- IgorPartola 6y agoFrom the conclusion portion of the actual paper: > 25OHD levels are lower in hospitalized COVID-19 patients compared to population-based controls and these patients had a higher prevalence of deficiency. We did not find any relationship between vitamin D concentrations or vitamin deficiency and the severity of the disease. That second part is really important. Look, I am taking a multivitamin as a result of what I’ve read but mostly because for me there is no harm in taking a multivitamin. But I have yet to see a definitive study that says vitamin D makes COVID better.
- parliament32 6y agoIt's interesting because this study was done in Spain, which reportedly only has about a 33% Vitamin D deficiency in the general population: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21179052/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21179052/
- rudolph9 6y ago100% of COVID patients have had a bowl movements. Correlation is not causation.