12 ms·
Nine in ten adults think buying latest smartphone is waste of money
- SigmundA 6y agoI typically got a new iPhone every two years up to the X. The increase in battery, cpu performance and camera quality was worth it. The X is fast enough with great camera and still good battery life although I can tell the battery is starting to loose noticeable capacity, still fine for daily use. Will probably upgrade to a 12 which will be a three year change. Apple has kept me happy with ongoing software updates, I can hand the X down and it will continue to be supported for a couple more years and be useful. I can see the trend continuing though where I might go 4 or 5 years or more between phones as the tech gains become smaller and battery life extends. They become more like cars (which I typically keep 10 years).
- sinstein 6y agoAgreed. I upgraded to the X from a 6S and that was a huge bump in performance and capabilities. Now that X is starting to show its age I am considering switching to the 12. All the upgrades since the X so far have not been appealing and did not warrant spending that much to me.
- sek 6y agoYou can replace the battery for a fraction of a new one, I basically have that already. My second battery of my 6s now makes trouble again, no other issues. I struggle to come up with a good reason why I shouldn't get a new battery for another 2 years.
- juniper_strong 6y agoThat's hilarious. They make the battery impossible to replace for consumers and then you need a new phone every two years and you see that as a feature. AAPL is a strong buy.
- SigmundA 6y agoThats my point you don't need a new phone every two years, at three years I notice a slight decrease in battery life, I would imagine it will keep being useful for another two easily and I could take somewhere to get a new battery if I really wanted. On the other hand I have old windows phone devices that had replaceable batteries I never utilized as they stopped updating the software after a year. Sounds like the Android side is similar. My Apple device have been some of the longest lived useful computing devices I have used even with the difficult to replace battery.
- sandworm101 6y agoSo fully 10% of the adult populatiom thinks buying the latest iPhone isn't? Thats a rather healthy market for any luxury good.
- thepangolino 6y agoCould be they’re on much older phone and/or quite flush with cash.
- koheripbal 6y ago10% of any respondents will always reply strangely to a survey. "adults" should probably be in quotations.
- sandworm101 6y agoLord help us at the next election.
- kingosticks 6y agoHow about that little referendum we had a while back?
- ben_w 6y agoThe richest 10% of the UK[1] have enough to afford the latest smartphone each year with no real difficulty. [1] income threshold per taxpayer: £35,345, but unlike US almost nobody bothers with private medical insurance
- sandworm101 6y agoAt 36k or even 100k/year, spending 1000/year on new phones is a big deal. Giving up 1% of your income each year isnt taken lightly.
- nullsense 6y ago>Giving up 1% of your income each year isnt taken lightly. Unless you're like me in which case you give up about 10% of your income each year on absolutely frivolous shit you just had to have but then used for about a week only to never touch again. Oh the joys of totally shot impulse control. That definitely includes a few smartphones. I think next time though I'll just get a dingy piece of crap. All a smartphone really is to me is a browser in my pocket. Don't need a 4k screen for that. Won't fall for the stupid gimmicks next time. Well.. I say that but, if I had much control over it it wouldn't be called impulse buying :(
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIt’s amazing how Apple anticipated this to pivot to services which now account for a ~20% of their business: https://techcrunch.com/2019/04/30/services-really-are-becoming-a-bigger-part-of-apples-business/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/04/30/services-really-are-becomi...
- hi5eyes 6y agoisnt this switch in guidance mainly because the revenue from games/mtx is only going to grow and apple has almost exhausted the market of people that can afford iphones
- penagwin 6y agoTo be fair I'm sure Apple did lots of research and already knew these numbers. I'm curious to if they "abuse" this to get better sales of the "last gen" iphones.
- faitswulff 6y agoThe recent iPhone SE play was pretty cogent as well.
- icegreentea2 6y agoIt's not amazing. The numbers have been pointing this way for nearly approaching 5 years (https://www.statista.com/statistics/276306/global-apple-iphone-sales-since-fiscal-year-2007/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/276306/global-apple-ipho... - peak iPhone unit sales was in 2015). Everyone knew this was coming. It happened to TVs, it happened to desktops, it happened to laptops, and it's happening to phones. Apple's biggest competitors are either playing a different game (the Chinese companies get to serve a completely different domestic market, and their international plays are at the very least part of a national soft power strategy), or already diversified (Samsung).
- KMnO4 6y agoI’m not sure what policies are in other countries, but Canada’s providers offer financing for all phones on 2 year contracts. You are forced into a high cost plan (it’s not uncommon for a flagship phone to require a $90+ plan), and on top of that pay PHONE_COST/24 as a monthly payment (an extra $30-50). I wonder how many adults think “easy comfortable payments over 24 months” isn’t the same as spending >$1000 for the latest phone up front.
- pjmlp 6y agoIn Europe and Africa, not sure about other regions, most people only use pre paid phones.
- jaclaz 6y agoJFYI, The news here (Italy) is my bank writing me how they are offering 0% interest loans to buy (among other stuff) smartphones in their (actually their commercial partners') online catalogue. Example: Smartphone Samsung Galaxy 20 4G, 43.95 Euro x 20 months Total 879.00 Euro, 0% fees, 0% interests Too bad that that same phone can be bought at major electronics stores for 580-610 Euro. The iPhone SE 64 GB for 24.95x20, total 499.00 Euro when the street price is more like 390-420 Euro.
- remir 6y agoDepends where you are in Canada. In Québec, plans seems cheaper in general. Koodo has good promos regularly. There was one a couple of weeks ago where you could've got an iPhone 11 for $648 total by staying with them for 2 years. Promo was you pay $288 up front and the rest is paid with the $15 monthly tab on top of a plan, which starts at $40. So for $288 and then $60/month you could get an iPhone 11 with unlimited calling/SMS and 5Gigs of data. Obviously I know plans are much cheaper still in some other countries, but in Canada that was a good deal.
- the_snooze 6y ago>And eight in 10 don’t like feeling pushed by manufacturers to keep up with the times – opting to get their tech as and when they need it instead. This is why I opt to buy iPhones, even at a premium up front. I bought my iPhone 7 at launch four years ago and it's still going strong. Apple still supports it with iOS 14, so it's good for at least another year. Newer models look nice but my 7 still just works.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoWhy buy at launch? I'm usually ~2-3 years behind the latest, and especially recently that has worked absolutely fine. I buy my phones second hand in good condition for ~80% less than what they cost at launch. Looking at my current phone, a 7, I realise I'm actually 4 years behind and didn't even notice.
- the_snooze 6y agoI find buying a phone and getting settled into it a big hassle. It's more important to me to do that as infrequently as possible. The cost savings are trivial to me when amortized over the life of the phone. If I buy an iPhone at launch, then I'm set for 4-6 years before iOS updates for it cease.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf they were 80% less after 2 years, a lot more people would do it. That’s what I do as well, but I find they’re more like 50-60% off new, not 80% (which means they’re 2-3x as expensive as if they were 80% off).
- vmception 6y ago> I’m usually ~2-3 years behind the latest The trick to doing that is to buy something new, premium and high quality at first, or eventually, and first hand. It is cheaper over time. Not only will it last you 5 years or more, you can also resale it to subsidize the next new device. When you buy a cheap phone or any consumer electronic 3 years old and second hand, you are already deep into its lifecycle and utility. It will just become a paperweight when you get the next device out of necessity.
- powerapple 6y agoI bought a iPhone 11 Pro, I hardly use its camera, never play games, only whatsapp and navigation. I am not interested in downloading apps... And I am over 40 now, maybe that's why.
- smolder 6y agoSo why did you buy it, then? Do you regret it?
- powerapple 6y agoI guess I don't regret it that much. Maybe I could get a iPhone 11 instead of Pro and feel the same. Now I am thinking to get rid of my phone and use a watch instead. My old phone battery wasn't perform very well, I have heard good words about iPhone 11's battery, I think that's the reason I bought it.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoSo you've wasted a lot of money. You can do whatsapp and navigation on a $100 android phone just fine.
- qz2 6y agoAndroid is such a needy attention seeking asshole of an operating system though from experience.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoNo, it's not.
- MaKey 6y agoMy experience with Android is vastly different from yours.
- ZuLuuuuuu 6y agoThe experience of even basic daily activities can suck on a 100$ Android phone. I have a Xiaomi Mi A3, the proximity sensor algorithm is so bad that I constantly press buttons with my cheek when I am talking to someone on the phone. And Xiaomi does not provide any updates to fix this because probably it wouldn't make sense to support this cheap phone further. Having said that, op would probably do fine with a non-pro iPhone.
- m3kw9 6y agoThat’s exactly how everyone spends their money. Most things are a waste of money but they still pay for it. Oh check out that pair, that’s hot, I got to have it
- stareatgoats 6y agoSmartphones have matured; there are few new essential functionalities. Data point: the phone I use was launched 2016 and I rarely (or never? can't remember if ever) run into any problems doing whatever I need to. My guess is the same statistic would have skewed differently say 10-15 years ago.
- smichel17 6y agoSeconded. My daily driver is a Galaxy S6 (launched in March 2015) and I don't feel any need to upgrade for the hardware. (Although the model I own, G920A, is particularly locked down, and which I am not happy about.) I'm hoping it lasts long enough that I can replace it with a Librem 5 as my daily driver. (Might get a pinephone earlier than that so I can help make that a reality).
- throw_m239339 6y agoYes, but it's still hard for phones to communicate with peripherals in meaningful ways, especially via USB. IOS is a bit better on that matter, Android OTG is a catastrophe. I understand why a lot of people prefer iPhone, especially artists and musicians.
- 46Bit 6y agoThe thing I valued from my latest upgrade was a better camera. But the phone cost the same as two decent DSLRs. It just doesn't make sense to upgrade again.
- fma 6y agoSame with me... I have a S8... I wouldn't mind having the triple camera lens for focus and better lighting and recording in 4K... And then eventually 5G. Everything else doesn't matter. I will wait another round before updating, though.
- fh973 6y agoDoes it have a replaceable battery?
- wasdfff 6y agoEvery DSLR does
- tiborsaas 6y agoHow many DSLR camera fits in your pocket? Everything comes with a trade-off.
- SigmundA 6y agoRight the best camera is the one you have with you when you have the shot.
- ForHackernews 6y agoNow we just need https://postmarketos.org/ https://postmarketos.org/ to mature so we can actually have maintained, secure software running on our perfectly-serviceable hardware.
- qz2 6y agoI think they’re probably wrong but it depends how you look at it. I buy the latest one when AppleCare runs out. That gives me the latest handset, 2 years protection against my own stupidity, the best eBay return after that period expires, the best battery life always and the happy period before iOS gets slow. If I don’t do that I have to pay up full price for repairs, involve third party repairer risk or write the whole handset off if I do something stupid (which does happen). Also I would have to put up with declining battery health, slower operating systems and worn connectors etc. That applies to the SE as well which has a really low total cost of ownership over two years with all risks mitigated taking resale value into account. Trick is to plan and save up for things you’re going to buy while you’re using the last one.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoSmartphones drop in value so fast, it makes sense to buy a one-two year old flagship for a third of the price. And it won't be that far behind current flagships.
- watwut 6y agoI am one of them.
- Semaphor 6y agoI still have my OnePlus 5, 3 years now. The battery is not the best anymore, and I can see myself replacing it (the battery) in 2021. I thought about getting a new one, but I don’t need a high-end camera and the market for reasonably sized smartphones is vanishing small. Whenever I see something slightly interesting, it’s even bigger than the OP5 which is already at my upper limit (and I’m a 190 cm tall person with big hands)
- Aeolun 6y agoI tried finding a small phone recently, but the smallest phone they had in the entire store was an iPhone 8/SE. It would be nice to have a phone the size of the original iPhone with a retina display :/
- lh7777 6y agoThe 2016 SE has a retina display and runs the latest version of iOS just fine. It's only a little taller but quite a bit thinner than the original iPhone. You can still buy used ones in excellent shape for well under $200. I'm not sure what I'm going to do when iOS stops supporting them -- maybe next year?
- gambiting 6y agoI'm still using a OnePlus 5T - and I'm increasingly thinking that if it ever breaks I'll just find another one on eBay. Literally don't see any point in spending £700-800 on a new model, and this one still has a headphone jack - why would I upgrade? It's still fast enough for everything, even for games - been playing Genshin Impact in max details and it's smooth as butter.
- sixhobbits 6y agoSame. first phone I've had that still feels new 3 years later
- hourislate 6y agoBy the time it breaks you'll be able to pick up an 8T (which will be a couple of years old at least). My OnePlus 3T, still going strong.
- blablablerg 6y agoOnePlus 3T gang calling in!
- AndrewDucker 6y ago8T doesn't have a headphone jack (or I'd have one myself).
- x87678r 6y agoOneplus deserves more recognition. I love my 6, it was cheap fast and is rock solid 2 years later. Last model with a Headphone jack.
- wazoox 6y agoSame :) My wife is still using my OnePlus One, running lineage OS...
- pteraspidomorph 6y agoI used mine for 5 years until it I dropped it and the screen broke (shattered, wouldn't respond to touch anymore). It was a great smartphone. I had the 64gb model.
- KKPMW 6y agoI was using 10 year old HTC ONE up until a few months back. The reason is simple - for my use cases getting a new phone didn't add anything - no new functionality, no new design. In the past new phones used to mean some kind of additional function: either colors, or mp3 support, or bluetooth. Now it's faster CPU and more pixels in your camera. After you sync stuff from your old phone you don't even notice any difference.
- drgoodvibe 6y agoIPhone 7 Plus user here. Have swapped the battery twice (the last time I did it myself). Still don’t feel the urge to buy the latest. I’m probably going to keep going with it until Apple stops supporting updates for it.
- gertrunde 6y agoWhen considering the survey findings, it is worth bearing in mind that the survey was commissioned by a company that deals in refurbished/second-hand goods, including smartphones...
- zitterbewegung 6y agoEveryone is shifting torward foldable displays and or wearables due to the fact that since we can only get marginal improvements in smartphones at this time. Sure microled displays or Telephoto lenses are neat but at this time I won't upgrade my iPhone 11 Pro for a few years because I just got a new Apple Watch series 6. I generally hold onto devices until the battery stops charging to ~80 percent or less.
- etrautmann 6y agoLet’s hope that planned battery failure doesn’t become a normal “feature”
- solarkraft 6y agoLet's also hope the .com-bubble won't burst.
- xenonite 6y agoGood that battery replacement is possible.
- Aeolun 6y agoThe biggest reason I want a new phone is a better camera. I have a DSLR, but I just don’t bring that with me all the time, and the camera on the new iPhones is really good.
- nxpnsv 6y agoI hate writing nine in 10, or 9 in ten for that matter. It's inconsistent.
- qwerty456127 6y agoI'm so glad 90% of people are at least partially sane.
- AnonC 6y agoThere is no need to buy the flagship phone every year or every two years. I can understand it if they cannot afford it, but anyone who’s into technology and can afford should make sure they have the latest software updates. They should also educate others about the importance of timely updates. If you buy an iPhone on launch, you get five or six years of software updates. I can only pity the people using their Android phones way past any hopes for software updates and being vulnerable to issues (security, software and hardware). I’m referring to most of the Android phones that don’t see updates after a year and all Android phones that don’t see updates after three years from launch. Pressuring Google or OEMs to provide software updates for longer hadn’t worked well, and Google is still slow on improving it.
- ISL 6y agoThe security issue is a growing systemic problem. The hardware is fine, but the vendors no longer support it. We are going to need a new revenue model or open-source paradigm to come to the forefront. The community approach is improving, but doesn't yet come close to the level of support one finds for Debian on the desktop.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> There is no need to buy the flagship phone every year or every two years. I can understand it if they cannot afford it, but anyone who’s into technology and can afford should make sure they have the latest software updates. They should also educate others about the importance of timely updates. This is certainly not going to happen. When you get a new phone, there are only three ways it can hurt you: (1) costing money; (2) being the wrong shape; (3) having the latest software updates. But getting the latest software updates is guaranteed to hurt you in way #3. If you update your software, a lot of it will stop working. Unsurprisingly, people have noticed this.
- robinhood 6y agoEvery employer lends me a phone (an old iPhone), so I haven't had to buy one in almost 10 years, nor having to deal with a provider, and it makes me very happy.
- bsenftner 6y agoSince they were released, I have owned exactly 3 iPhones. I'm a developer, not working in mobile, so my phone is for calls and that is about it. I've got computers all around me, there is no need to ever use my phone beyond calls and navigation apps. I see others put their identity into their phones, and I just shake my head. Just tools, people.
- rwdim 6y agoIt’s insane to believe that an iPhone 11 costs $1000 when you can buy a Samsung A11 5g with virtually every feature (except camera quality) for $179. The cost of phones should be declining with adoption, not increasing.
- pizza234 6y agoIf the cost is considered disproportionately high (I'm not entirely familiar, as I buy only budget or out-of-production ones), the implication is that one is buying a brand. Even not accounting the iPhone, I think mobile phones has been always (or at least, for a long time) considered part of one's status; that will never depreciate.
- sto_hristo 6y ago9 in 10 adults realizing that these soapbars are good enough for selfies and instagram only and the joke features of the latest phones doesn't justify spending the extra cash.
- gchamonlive 6y agoIt's sometimes necessary in order to get latest android security updates. We need a way to break free of vendor update depency with an independent distro. Many perfectly fine phones become obsolete just because of the OS not keeping up. It should be illegal to discontinue a phone and not release the boot unlock codes so that people can toy with it and hack together a usable distro.
- woodpanel 6y agoShame on me, but I'm one of those 10%. Except for (hopefully) 5G I can't even name a specific feature. But one thing I appreciate very much is its new SE-based brick-like design. The old SE was the most iconic phone on the market. But then: The design is actually the least used feature since everybody uses covers. Gaah!
- eqvinox 6y agoFunnily enough, Sony made that decision for me by ending their awesome "compact" line. I don't even think there's a current smartphone that fits my parameters (high-end, 5" or smaller, waterproof, dual SIM.) That said, I've arrived at the "Waste of Money" conclusion regardless. What exactly is the point of buying a new one? I'll rather replace the battery on my XZ2c. It's the green option too.
- swarnie_ 6y agoCan i ask what your requirement for a dual SIM is all about? I've only seen this popular in 3rd world mnarkets.
- pkphilip 6y agoIf you use Whatsapp you could have two different whatsapp accounts - one for your business with Whatsapp Business and another regular account. For this you need two SIMs
- ptx 6y agoOne reason for this requirement is that you want one SIM for your work number and one for your private number, so that you don't have to carry two phones. (You could forward one to the other as a workaround, but that doesn't help with SMS or outgoing calls.)
- user5994461 6y agoThe second most common reason is if you're split between two countries, home somewhere and home/work abroad, you need to have a SIM for each country.
- instaheat 6y agoThat's exactly the use case for me. I own a business and don't want to give out my personal number for anything related to the business side. Helps me stay organized. I know when a call is coming through I know the nature of the call before I pick up.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- samfisher83 6y agoOne of the issue is he battery just goes bad after a year and a half so your battery life is down a lot. Then you have to send it in to get it replaced. Plus its with you all the time so it can break pretty easily.
- garyfirestorm 6y agoI was hoping this discussion could enlighten me/us about the new security measures implemented in latest phones avb? And how the latest security updates are essential in protecting your data when crossing border. That makes buying a latest device same as updating your security.
- veidr 6y agoI'll go contrarian on this one: I have bought a new iPhone every single year since the first one. It was like $650 back in 2007, and for the last couple years it's been $1700. (I always buy the maxed out model, even though the cost of the extra storage is a ripoff. But I usually sell it or bequeath it to some family member when I upgrade, and a year later the extra storage always seems in retrospect like the right move...) So that's a lot of money, and the cost is significant for most people, even us software engineer types. But: nothing I have ever seen in my life (including computers, where my adult life has so far seen me go from a 16 MHz 68020 with 4MB of RAM to a 3 GHz 10-Core Intel Xeon W with 128GB of RAM) has improved anywhere close to as rapidly as the iPhone. I feel like smartphones are one of those under-appreciated ways that "life is getting better" that's hard to quantify, but more evenly distributed. Wages may be stagnating for some swaths of society, and fascism and apartheid may be resurgent, but smartphones are getting massively better for everybody. I had an epiphany a few years back, when I glanced at the baby monitor and saw the nice old lady who helps us clean our house on Saturdays. I happened to notice that her iPhone was the same model as mine at the time, the iPhone 7 Plus — and that she was swiping through some child photos (presumably her grandchildren back in the Philippines). Now, she works full-time, but has a side hustle doing weekend cleaning for families like ours, where both parents work and have young kids. We pay her the wage she asked for, which I think is roughly prevailing hourly wage for this kind of thing in our area, and probably isn't that much different — adjusted for inflation — than in 2010 or 2000 or 1980 or 1960. But holy fucking shit, her iPhone is different! She can make unlimited free (FaceTime) video calls back home to her kids, or grandkids. She can get their latest photos, and see them on a big ultra-highres screen. She can point her camera at shit and see it translate (sloppily and drunkenly though it may seem)by the latest trained-model "AI" app from Google. Etc etc. I myself also benefit from all those things. I am not even a heavy phone user — I mean I am, I use my phone dozens of times per day, but I prefer not to use it. Almost everything it can do, my big-screen(s) computer can do better, so I always use a computer if possible. Even so: I use it to take a lot of photos/videos, and view those. I also read books, listen to audiobooks, read Twitter, or read this website. I don't use Slack on it, unless there is some important emergency or weird case at work (but then, I am glad I can). I view and edit notes, which might be shopping lists or E2E test notes or whatever. Oh and I use it to check my internal security cameras (which double as baby/child monitors). Every single new generation of phone makes many of these things massively better. So like... "waste of money"?? It's obviously subjective, but... to me buying a new car is a waste of money. Any new car. When my wife was pregnant with our third child, we bought a new Nissan X-Trail for like $25,000 and I was like Ugh what a waste of money this is like 15 years of the latest smartphone... (Well I mean, I was like that in my mind... not being the one who was actually pregnant, I said something like, "Sure, let's do that!" :-P ) YMMV obviously — if you just want a phone to make calls and send texts, then sure. But if you actually use your smarphone a dozen or more times per day, I think there are a lot of things that many people spend money on (cars, clothes) that might better fit the "waste of money" label.
- drivingmenuts 6y agoI’m fine with my 6S+ and don’t need any of the newer features on any of the phones. I don’t do much photography and only use about 10 apps. It’s just big enough to use for Kindle in a pinch. The biggest reason, though, is the headphone jack. $160 for wireless headphones is ridiculous. They’re easy to lose and constantly having to recharge is just fucking stupid. Modern earbuds are horribly uncomfortable for me by putting pressure in the ear canal to hold them in place, so I have to use the older earbud style. I like Apple’s stuff, in general, but I curse the day that their asshole product designers went totally wireless.
- potatofarmer45 6y agoThis survey almost certainly wrong. 9 out of 10 people when given a leading question will probably say they think buying the latest smartphone is a waste of money, but the whole point of marketing shows that's not the case. Average upgrade cycle is 24-36 months now. 75-85% of that is a "current" model. The caveat here is that "latest" device and flagship devices are not the same thing. For example, the latest oneplus can be either the flagship 8T or the new mid-range Nord.
- antiterra 6y agoJust because someone thinks it’s a waste of money or poor value doesn’t mean they won’t buy it anyway. I have an iPhone XR and, while there’s nothing about it lacking in daily use, I still have persistent thoughts of it as an older low resolution phone that I should upgrade.
- Gibbon1 6y agoIt can objectively be a waste of money but practical concerns require people to buy new phones. Users have no control over the fact that the OS and apps get ever more resource hungry despite marginal generally unimportant improvements in utility.
- daveFNbuck 6y agoA 24-36 month upgrade cycle means people aren't buying the latest smartphone every year. I don't think that the latest smartphone is a good value, and that's why I try to hold on to mine for a few years before buying a new one.
- fossuser 6y agoIf you buy the new iPhone every year you can sell the old one for around 70% of its initial cost on Craigslist in a day (if you’re in the Bay Area). For me this makes it worth it because the resell value decays over time and you always get the newest device with a fresh battery. Seems like a reasonable place to spend money for something you use probably more than anything else.
- CapriciousCptl 6y agoAnd yet they buy new ones anyway.
- MarcScott 6y agoI used to buy the latest and greatest, but stopped a few years ago. Now my main priority when buying a phone is price and battery life, and I only replace a phone when I physically break my old one. Currently using a Moto G7 Power and very happy with it. Of course if a good phone comes out with a physical keyboard, I'd grab it almost instantly.
- navanchauhan 6y ago> The research was commissioned by musicMagpie as figures from its Annual Phone Depreciation Report found mobile phones can lose up to 68 per cent of their original purchase value in the first six months. It should be noted that musicMagpie sells used phones along with other goods. I haven't been able to find anything else except more news articles.
- hehetrthrthrjn 6y agoMy phones last about 5 years and my last phone, the Moto G6 Plus, cost about $200. They're not very useful computers in relative terms, beyond being very portable, and there is a lack of compelling new features in new phones. Right now there is the spec grind which moves some people to upgrade, but most people won't see a benefit. I suspect phones are more important as a fashion accessory or status symbol at this point.
- ianbooker 6y agoFunny enough: I had the G6 Plus and I would be honestly happy to have used it even a few more years. Just the lack of security updates let me upgrade my phones nowadays.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoCamera are still making good spec progress, faster than other features. This has a big impact I feel, parents/grandparents like high quality photos of kids. And in general when you take some photos, see the results are average vs your friends latest camera I think this must trigger upgrade thoughts. I upgraded our household as VoWifi is needed due to limited reception but I suspect thats a fairly small user case...
- mceachen 6y agoThis certainly was true a decade ago. It isn't anymore. I spend a lot of time staring at photos from tons of different cameras. I pull in unprocessed raw and JPEG photos from DSLR and flagship phone reviews to verify that metadata extraction and raw image data gets decoded properly by PhotoStructure. There is surprisingly little difference in image quality from, say, the OG Google Pixel to the pixel 2 and 3. The difference between well-lit scenes at the same zoom on an iphone 8, X, and 11 is minimal. If you show someone photos from a current flagship versus a 3-4 year old flagship, composition will matter (much) more than the hardware as to which is seen as the better image.
- Gustomaximus 6y ago
- vaccinator 6y agoYou can get a phone that has 98% of their features for 1/5 of the price... it's not a hard decision if you are willing do do a bit of reasearch.
- hexbinencoded 6y agoBuying new consumer electronics or durable goods is mostly for the birds, e.g., people who have their money separated from them most easily. I have an iPhone 6S and will consider a used iPhone SE 2020 at some point when I drive this one into the ground.
- chronofar 6y agoOr, you know, people who like their tech. I mean, I know I could use an iphone 6s or whatever other phone until it dies. But for a piece of tech I use more than any other, I'll spend the extra dough. Part hobby, part utility. Note also the extra dough here is pretty small compared to say a car hobbyist. In many other ways I'm fairly frugal. I very rarely buy new clothes for instance, and for non-tech things am pretty minimalistic. It's all about what you value.
- blackbrokkoli 6y agoSadly, another "publication" on the HackerNews frontpage with really, really low quality. Nine in 10 Adults? So how many did you survey? 2000, apparently. Not a bad number, still a bit low to use a word describing >5 billion people. Regarding "Adults": From where? How old? How rich? Does it include female Indians aged 50-80? Apparently they asked "Britons". Refreshing that it is not US biased for once, but that is something very relevant conveniently omitted from the conclusion while still being extremely vague. But let's get back to n=2000. How did they get so many? Oh, apparently they used OnePoll[1], which is a for-profit company specializing in PR-surveys. And, did you really ask "would you agree that X is a waste of money"? If I would propose such a loaded question in an academic study I would probably brought behind the barn by any respectable researcher. Ask for example "How much would you agree with the following statement: If a new smartphone model is released, I feel the need to buy it" you would probably get a very different result. But let's not unfairly presume. What did they ask? Well, the primary source is nowhere to be found. Just a bunch of News and blogs citing each other. Some wrongly cite "The musicMagpie Annual Phone Depreciation Report" [0] which does not mention this, but apparently lead to this study. Wait: musicMagpie? So, this "study" was apparently "conducted" by a used phone reseller, directly profiting from the sentiment this propaganda piece is selling? Meaning, this is literally, completely, PR fluff. I am trying hard to not pull the "HN is becoming Reddit" meme here, but please enlighten me how this uncritical reception of marketing dressed up as "science" (?) seen in this thread is different from the average /r/technology experience. [0] https://www.musicmagpie.co.uk/phone-depreciation/ https://www.musicmagpie.co.uk/phone-depreciation/ [1] https://www.thesun.co.uk/tech/12806082/new-smartphone-upgrade-price-high-cost/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/tech/12806082/new-smartphone-upgrad... edit: punctuation
- sys_64738 6y agoIt eventually gets to the point where all tech items are good enough. Even Apple's iPhone has reached a point where there's no compelling reason to upgrade. This after drip feeding features across product releases to keep users locked into an upgrade cycle. But there's just a point where even they run out of things to add. You can only make 'great' be 'better' through so many product iterations before the buyers start to yawn.
- m463 6y agoI think in the last 10 years a lot of tech products have actually regressed. phones (and cars, televisions, bathroom scales and refrigerators) force all kinds of annoying post-sales "engagement" with the manufacturer.
- macjohnmcc 6y agoI have the iPhone XS Max and I have no desire to buy the latest and greatest. I don't believe that 5G will improve the speeds I get on my phone as I get no where near the performance that 4G promises. Until the phone stops working or they come up with something really amazing I'll stick with this phone.
- jeffrallen 6y agoDamn straight. My budget for phone hardware is $100 per year, with average lifetime of 3 years. Am typing this from a perfectly functional phone on a service only (i.e. no "free" phone) subscription, unlimited data and calls.
- nullc 6y agoI cannot fathom paying significantly over $100 for a phone, especially one you carry around all the time and beat up and will be almost worthless in a couple years even if you treat it very carefully.
- wasdfff 6y agoThe only impetus for upgrading a phone for me is if it starts failing at being a phone. I upgraded my old SE to the new SE when it was on steep discount earlier this summer solely because my old one took a few tumbles in its life and was dropping nearly every call. Other than that, the phone wasn’t slow at all. The rear camera was acceptable. The battery life was fine. If it wasn’t dropping calls I would still be using that phone. In a lot of ways I miss it, primarily the size and the light weight compared to the new SE, but the design flaw of getting dust under the front camera lens pushed me to the new SE ultimately since it made the front camera next to useless after a year in a pocket. It happened in my iPhone 5, my 5s, and was never fixed in the SE1, lending further creedence to my theory that engineers at apple don’t use the products they design, or at least certainly not for the typical length of time that an end user would before being handed the next generation device to use from work, before most critical issues crop up. The longevity of recent phones is a huge contrast from the early days, where an iphone 3g would struggle to function on the mobile web or basic apps compared to the 3gs, but those days are long gone. iphones have been more than powerful enough for 99% of peoples use cases since the iphone 6s. A 6s or SE1 is still a perfectly performant phone today.
- mkaic 6y agoFor me it’s not even about wasting money, it’s just that the new phones don’t... offer anything I need, really. I have an SE 1 and I’m firmly of the opinion that I could wait another five or six years before upgrading. It just... works, and does everything I need it to do. Of course, that’s not to say that new phones are categorically unnecessary or useless, just in my case as a low-maintenance, non power-user, it does what I need.
- obarthelemy 6y agoAround me, ever fewer people are buying high-end phones. Our uses for smartphones haven't evolved in over 5 years, yet the hardware has progressed fast. Unless you're into AR/VR, competitive 3D gaming, or publishable photography/video, there's no reason to spend more than $300. Especially since sealed batteries and short OS updates (even on the Apple side) and rapid HW progress make Mobiles a very fungible investment. My PC is 7yo, my phone 3yo... guess which feels old, and will get a replacement budget commensurate to its useful life ?
- danmg 6y agoA $250 Chinese smartphone can match or exceed the features of an $800 offering from a "flagship" company. It is absolutely a waste of money.
- Smithalicious 6y agoI'm on a 24 month upgrade schedule mainly to benefit from improved camera tech, though I'm probably going to stop - in almost every way my current phone (Pixel 4) is a sidegrade, rather than an upgrade, to my old phone (LG V30) and I only upgraded because my old phone has gotten quite damaged - I'm very clumsy.
- maest 6y agoOfftopic: How are finding the Pixel 4? I've mulling over upgrading from my curent Pixel 1 to a Pixel 4a (not exactly the same as Pixel 4, I know). My current phone is still working mostly fine, but the camera is a bit wonky because I've dropped it too many times.
- Smithalicious 6y agoI quite like it. As expected of it being a Google phone, the software is very good and you get updates before anyone else. The camera is also good, especially the software, but I miss not having a wide angle lens and manual ISO/focus/exposure controls. Battery life isn't great compared to other phones but I charge overnight so it doesn't bother me. I also like the form factor a lot, it's quite thin which makes it much easier to use one-handed.
- commonturtle 6y agoWhy is this surprising? I also think that buying the latest smartphone is a waste of money, but every two years I find myself upgrading to the latest iPhone anyway.
- josuepeq 6y agoUsing a new sealed 2016 iPhone SE that I paid $60 for about 5 months ago. It replaced a 2016 iPhone SE I cracked the screen on. Since Apple charges $129 for a display, and since I don’t have any access to touch and proximity sensor calibration equipment, I can’t properly do it by myself. I paid $99 for that one brand new last year. It replaced a 2016 iPhone SE (from 2016) with a battery that only held a charge for a hour and also fell apart - the glue holding the display module together wore out. The 2016 iPhone SE runs the latest iOS 14. I think the 12 mp camera is suitable enough for my needs, the square sides are great for standing it up without the use of a tripod to take a photo, and I have a headphone jack still. There hasn’t been a iPhone since that’s come close to being as small. Still, I’d like to see it get even smaller. I haven’t found a single phone since that’s had a compelling reason for me to sacrifice this size without switching to Android. To date I’ve spent approximately $560 on iPhones since retiring my next favorite phone of all time: my Nokia Lumia Icon. I still miss windows phone.
- ajfjrbfbf 6y agoWhy not buy something more durable instead of buying the same phone 3 times? Something with a replaceable battery for instance.
- happynacho 6y agoBuying the latest model every year? Yes Buying the latest model every 2-3 years? No
- nazgulnarsil 6y agoapple creates a cool new design every 3 years like clockwork. iphone 4, iphone 6, iphone x, iphone 12 mini.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI would like to buy: - A dumb flip-phone. - With a B&W display. - That functions on a modern mobile cellular network. - Robust enough to handle a good dunking and a few drops. An old-school Nokia candybar or Ericson flip might fit the bill, funcctionally, except that 2G GSM is now largely phased out. Light Phone seems to be the nearest general concept. Phone, alarm, calculator, SMS (and I'd really prefer a secure messaging alternative). If there were a reasonable Linux-based tablet, WiFi or in a pinch hotspottable, it could serve all other needs.
- stunt 6y agoIt's also waste of resources. I'm still using iPhone 6 since it was launched and I only had one battery replacement so far. Probably I can easily wait one or two years. My main usage is messaging, calling, online banking, podcast, notifications. Also sometimes navigation. There are a few utilities like taking photos and using the flashlight. Nothing more. Sometimes web browsing to get the news but not as much as I spend time with my laptop.