11 ms·
Why Life Can’t Be Simpler
- pwinnski 6y agoThere are many things in life that cannot be simpler without losing some level of choice that we value, I'll grant that. Nobody who has ever dealt with the United States Government, or any US State government, can tell me with a straight face that the principle is absolute. Or, put another way, I'll gladly give up all the choices that lead to misery every time I deal with the IRS or DMV in exchange for things to be as simple as they are in other countries I've visited. Choice is not the only cause of complexity.
- supercanuck 6y agoYou do this transparently when you “choose” from a list of preset internet providers or wireless plans. In any event, Governments are bad examples because they serve more interests than just “customers.” They are not businesses and it is destructive to compare them as such
- Animats 6y ago"Hello. Welcome to the Automated DMV, Mr. Smith. Your car registration needs to be renewed. Since you're here, and we recognize you, and your car is in the parking lot, and we recognize that, too, renewal will be $122. You have three parking tickets outstanding, so we will add $150 to that. You have one red light violation, and we're sending video of that to your phone if you want to contest it. But since the face and license plate match, we assume you won't, so we're adding $1025. Your total today is $1297." "Right now, you have $475 in your bank account. We can set up an easy payment plan at $150 per month plus 3% interest per month if you like, with automatic deduction. If that's OK with you, just say "Yes"."
- sdht0 6y agoThis would be pretty cool actually, if we make some key changes: "we will add" -> "do you want to add them now?" and "you have $$$ in your bank account" -> "how do you want to pay", for example. Basically, automatically giving options to the users based on access to data they should already have. Detecting the car is not even needed, just scan the driver license at a terminal and get going. DMV does not need to have direct access to your bank account, but can simply hand off the total to your banking app (say), which in turn can then offer the easy payment plan. Some credit cards already offer this option today. In general, life can be made quite simple with technology without also having to give up choices or privacy. The hard part is convincing the tech companies/govt IT bureaucracy to go this way :)
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoWe haven't gone that far but a lot of those sort of interactions have moved online in the UK. The obvious one for me is filling a tax return at the end of the year. It's automated for all but the most cmplex of cases.
- spyke112 6y agoIt's the same here in Denmark. We've also had a lot of failed tax related IT projects through the years though. But when i hear how tax collection is handled in the US, i can tell that we are really lucky with our system.
- andy99 6y agoI think a realistic example of what you mean would be looking at getting support from Uber. If you want to something from their checklist, it's simple, but if you have something that doesn't fit nicely into their FAQ, it is maddeningly impossible to have a real interaction to get your issue resolved. That is what a simple, automated solution looks like.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CGamesPlay 6y agoThere's no world in which a DMV with access to your bank account waits until your registration renewal to charge you with a traffic violation.
- dragonsky67 6y agoexcept where the people responsible for enforcing traffic laws (traffic police) are different from the people responsible for vehicle registration (state government road traffic authority).
- inglor_cz 6y agoIDK. Here in the Czech Republic, public health insurance company (VZP) tends to wait almost to the end of the debt expiration period before hitting you with debt collection including hefty interest. This is done to maximize the interest... So I can definitely imagine another autority waiting for years before squeezing you dry.
- pwinnski 6y agoYou've immediately jumped to the absolute extreme opposite in terms of automation, excluding all of the middle options that would be better than they are today, and the result is... honestly, I'd still prefer your fantasy example to what we have today. Last time I renewed my drivers license, I had to visit the DPS (Texas separates licensing people and cars, so DPS is for people) three times. In person. During a pandemic. Because of failings on the part of the DPS. This is typical.
- vangelis 6y agoThe IRS could absolutely be simpler though, but then people might not grumble about paying our taxes and who wants that.
- twelfthnight 6y agoThe quotes referenced in this article “Whether something is complicated is in the mind of the beholder" and "The total complexity of a system is a constant" appear to me to be contradicting. How can the complexity be both relative and constant simultaneously? Personally, I favor the former. An operating system, for example, seems to me to dramatically lower total complexity since a few hundred (thousand?) people can maintain it. Meanwhile, without operating systems how many hundreds of thousands of people would it take to maintain our modern tech if we all had to work on bare metal?
- atoav 6y agoMaybe there is no link between something being complicated and it's complexity. One is entirely subjective and the other isn't. Example: a typical CLI application might be incredibly complicated to my mother, while it is in fact much less complex than e.g. a GUI software she uses to make and order picture books, which to her is much less complicated. Something being complicated to someone doesn't mean it is complex. Very simple things can be complicated, very complex things can be simple.
- war1025 6y agoThe article leads with a quote by Don Norman. I read his book "The design of everyday things" after hearing a lot of people speak highly of it. I found it quite underwhelming. Anyone have insight of what people think is so noteworthy about that book?
- vazamb 6y agoI am not a designer/UX person but still thought I would give it a go. I couldn't get through more than 30% of it because of how boring and repetitive it was.
- chadcmulligan 6y agoSame, my thoughts are its one of those things that it was revolutionary at the time but the ideas have become so distributed now so it seems obvious. Originally published in 1988, windows 3.0 was released in 1990, it was published when MS-DOS was king.
- serjester 6y agoFor me it seemed like it fleshed out a lot of ideas about what makes good UX. I didn't think it was earth shattering but I think back to it often when I interact with the various items in my life. It's nice for someone to explicitly explain something you intuitively grasp but can't clearly explain.
- georgeecollins 6y agoHere's a little trivia: It was originally titled the Psychology of Everyday things. It was so popular with designers, particularly software designers, that they re-titled it.
- georgeecollins 6y agoWow! I was his student many, many years ago. I had to take his class because he was the head of our department. I thought I was going to do something very different with my life and I wasn't very interested, except that he was a great lecturer. In retrospect he was easily the most influential professor I ever had. If his work in something like "Design of Everyday Things" seems underwhelming I would guess that is because it has become so influential that you already have absorbed a lot of the ideas in the book. You certainly live in a world that is slightly shaped by them. As a teacher, Norman constantly taught through anecdotes about the way things work. ATMs used to give you money and then after they gave you money they would return your card. The model for the bank was take card, do transaction, return card. The problem was people kept leaving their cards in the machine. Donald Norman pointed out that the "mental model" for people was go to atm-> get money. Once the last step is accomplished the customer doesn't thinks they are done. They don't want to keep thinking about the ATM. "Mental Model" of an interface is a term you may have heard and he coined. Now every time I go to an ATM and it gives me my card back before the money, I think of him.
- Animats 6y agoLife can't be simpler yet because systems do not yet understand the consequences of their actions. The first step to advanced simplicity is making it easy to do again what you did already. This is the "reorder last shopping cart" level. The next step is to have a good understanding of what people are likely to re-order, and how often. Some marketing systems are starting to get this. If, last time, you ordered a hammer and some nails, next time you should be offered more nails, but not more hammers. One obstacle to advanced simplicity is cross-vendor integration. This is why more than one remote is often necessary. There are entertainment systems that self-configure when plugged in, but only from one vendor.
- carabiner 6y agoI see this all around me. People are fixated on careers, hobbies (FOMO), spread thin by family obligations and errands. The truth is, happiness does not derive from these things. This "busyness" is an invention. Life is simple, and happiness actually derives from having cats.
- catallergies 6y agoI'm allergic to cats. Pets also add complexity to life, e.g. when you want to go away for any length of time.
- onion2k 6y agoI'm also allergic to cats. I have two of them and live on antihistamines. It's worth it.
- earthboundkid 6y agoYou can leave cats alone for a weekend without an supervision, just a bowl of food and some water.
- williadc 6y agoYour cat isn't diabetic, I guess.
- cgriswald 6y agoMy friend did that. His cat ate all the food in a single sitting and was both fat and almost dead from not eating for two days.
- XorNot 6y agoIt doesn't work if you normally don't let your cat choose their meal times. But cats do develop food intelligence unlike dogs and will only eat what they need - the key is they have to have a reliable expectation that food is always available. An automatic feeder helps - since getting one there's always good in my cats bowl but she only eats a little at a time.
- porknubbins 6y agoFrom my perspective a huge amount of features/modes/choices in things are rarely used things that a minority might want but most people never use, so things could be much simpler. I’ve never used an Android device because I would probably go down an unproductive rabbit hole of customizing and debugging etc. iOS cuts down on my freedom but frees up mental energy for more meaningful uses.
- skmurphy 6y ago“Whether something is complicated is in the mind of the beholder.” Don Norman In the same way that a probability represents your state of information about an event or action your assessment of the complexity of a task or problem is a function of your state of information and relevant expertise. I think this has implications for models like cynefin where the assignment to a domain (simple, complicated, complex, chaotic) is presented as objective but I believe this assessment if a function of your information and understanding. One implication for designing software is to use familiar UI metaphors--which are viewed as simpler and easier to use. One implication for competitive analysis is that you cannot assume that your competitors bring the same information and level of understanding to a problem that you do. In best case you have more information and expertise. In the case you need to anticipate, you have less information and expertise, and what looks complex or chaotic to you may be complicated to a competitor.
- atoav 6y agoA fascinating little facette of this is that e.g. while command line applications are certainly harder to use for typical users, they are in a different sense also simpler, because a certain class of problems/worries is totally stripped away. Namely: where was that button again? Oh god they changed it again. This is knife vs bread cutting machine stuff.
- canjobear 6y ago> “Whether something is complicated is in the mind of the beholder.” Don Norman Only up to a constant. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity
- topkai22 6y agoInteresting that this article talks entirely to the complexity of technological systems and business processes. Largely, those aren't the things that make my life complex, it's other people. Being the middleman between two people who you love but hate each other is complex. Telling someone who is smart enough to do a job but hasn't been performing that they aren't getting their contact renewed is complex. Figuring out why your two year old is crying is sometimes flat out impossible. Setting up kubernetes or reading processes for what forms to bring the DMV? Annoying, but manageable. If those were the only complexities in my life, it would be simple indeed. Less rich, but simple.
- faichai 6y agoThis reminds me of scene in Mr Robot, where a non-hacker has been tasked with hacking into FBI network. All she needs to do is plug in a pre-prepared access point and type a few commands. It’s human factors i.e. being caught by FBI and associated anxiety that add complexity to the situation. Darlene has to remind her of the simplicity of the task. This had a big impact on me, as someone who has struggled with anxiety in the past.
- scollet 6y agoRaising global education levels is a start. Not just formally, but even basic understanding of multiple domains could help.
- avmich 6y ago> The total complexity of a system is a constant. If you make a user’s interaction with a system simpler, the complexity behind the scenes increases. It's almost obvious complexity can be created. So why it can't be destroyed as well?
- arctangent 6y agoFred Brooks said [1] that there are two types of complexity, accidental and essential. While accidental complexity can be reduced the theory is that the essential complexity cannot. "Accidental complexity relates to problems which engineers create and can fix; for example, the details of writing and optimizing assembly code or the delays caused by batch processing. Essential complexity is caused by the problem to be solved, and nothing can remove it; if users want a program to do 30 different things, then those 30 things are essential and the program must do those 30 different things." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Silver_Bullet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Silver_Bullet
- kilre 6y agoI guess the whole point of design or engineering for that matter is to get as close as possible to the bare minimum of essential complexity. Elegance comes to mind, if you are able to jump over several complexity traps.
- ablekh 6y agoWhile the article is quite nice, the title is certainly misleading. The article is about complexity of products and services and its management, but not about complexity of life. The latter, I believe, mostly comes from a myriad of interactions between numerous underlying psychological, social and economic networks/graphs (it's the same thing in this context: https://bence.ferdinandy.com/2018/05/27/whats-the-difference-between-a-graph-and-a-network https://bence.ferdinandy.com/2018/05/27/whats-the-difference...) of forces, types of actors, incentives and other factors.
- vffhfhf 6y agoLife is simple.. If you aim lower. There was a psychology research on how people even billionaire form a baseline similar to a homeless dude. All the stress, pressure you have is the same as everybody else and it will never change. So the goal should be do whatever you enjoy while doing the minimum effort.. Of course this type of thinking would immediately hamper progress everywhere.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brnt 6y agoWould it? People perform better when not stressed. Lazyness is a big driver for invention. Actual research is already done driven by pure interest, not driven by ambition.
- agumonkey 6y agolet's redefined work as shared laziness :)
- kortilla 6y ago> Lazyness is a big driver for invention What? I can’t see it being a good invention driver for anything other than the category of “tools for lazy people”. How was the invention of the OLED driven by laziness? How about the high bypass turbofan?
- sgillen 6y agoSo many tools take a job that was possible without the tool and make it much easier, and in that sense many tools are “for lazy people”. Examples include: autocomplete, spell check, version control, undo, in-house running water, washing machines, Zoom. Just to name a few random examples, the list is obviously gigantic.
- np_tedious 6y agoPlows and tractors
- Cloudef 6y agoSome people simply won't ever attain or feel happiness.
- chmod600 6y agoWhile there is often a trade-off between internal and external complexity, the article goes too far. For instance, having a zillion inter-related modes creates internal and external complexity without improving functionality at all. Using orthogonal controls helps a lot.
- t0350 6y agoGuys who made things that have a zillion inter-related modes actually spent few effort to convert the "model" to a truly conceptual model which should be much simpler or as you said, orthogonal. And I believe that this is where the complexity lied in.
- wolfgke 6y ago> Why Life Can’t Be Simpler Because of the politicians and lawyers with their complicated, convoluted laws.
- unabst 6y agoThe past is gone, and we can barely predict even tomorrow. Packing all of these "days" into "life" is not simple at all. It's an error. There is no "life". It's an ideology, and letting the idea rule you too strictly will turn you into an ideologue. It's our mind that sorts our infinitely complex realities out, but also inevidably finds itself tangled in its own abstractions. Emotionally, happiness can only be felt in moments. Days where happy moments outnumber the sadder moments could be considered a happy day. But to then extend this to a lifespan is just too ambitious to be practical. It's surreal. Once you have happiness in your days, living a day at a time should suffice. And once you have happiness at arms reach, knowing that should suffice. That is a good place. That is one better model of a good "life".
- xtf 6y agoSane defaults reduce complexity And new systems resulting out of old understood ones, like SI-Units vs imperial units
- _where 6y agoExamples: Would it make sense to have more fields visible at once? Maybe making users not have to dig though 10 pages to find the “Covid” checkbox would be better. Would it make sense to have a single schema monolith with simple HTML forms vs microservices, 100 schemas, persistent connections, streaming, and burn-rate-heavy cloud infrastructure? Do you need all of those JS libraries that look simple but are actually more complex than vanilla JS to setup and maintain? Object storage seemed simple, but how will you translate all of that JSON later when the model must change over and over again? Is that code that uses lambdas and annotation-based cloud logging that is so much more readable and maintainable generating frequent delays for customers due to GC and latency than the loop and shared variable equivalent that writes to file? Counter-examples: code that could be simplified without cost, storing customer data whose structure is out of your control, use of well-maintained libraries that save time and add value, and relatively low cost use of the cloud services due to good planning and design.
- rational_indian 6y ago> Removing functionality doesn’t make something simpler, because it removes options. Simple tools have a limited ability to simplify processes. Trying to do something complex with a simple tool is more complex than doing the same thing with a more complex tool. I agree with the quote but I am not able to reconcile it with the following observations... 1. The Unix philosophy insists on making simple tools which focus on doing just one thing and only one thing. Edit: Come to think of it, simple tools can simplify a complex process if you can compose them into a complex tool to do the job. 2. I think this also runs counter to Apple's understanding of simple too (one button mouse anyone?).
- krebs_liebhaber 6y ago> Come to think of it, simple tools can simplify a complex process if you can compose them into a complex tool to do the job. unrar l "$1" | tail -n +9 | head -n -3 | awk '{$1=$2=$3=$4=""; print $0}'
- QuadrupleA 6y agoThis article seems to be using abstract academic hand waving to say "it's impossible to simplify anything". But it seems so obviously false. A "hello world" program could fetch every character from a separate database; same output but enormously more complex process. A small car could have 16 wheels, 2 engines, and be controlled by typing commands on a keypad ("steer left 3 degrees"). Don't tell me these examples are just exposing some complexity that was already there, or that complexity is a conserved constant, etc. It's amazing what can be made to sound plausible with an erudite wiring style.
- asdfgeoff 6y agoAgree that treating complexity as a constant is a bit extreme. The author lost me at the bit about Tesler's law. That said, it feels like there is likely some sort of Pareto efficient frontier with regards to complexity vs. usefulness. You can certainly have a poorly-designed system which is arbitrarily more complex without being anymore useful. But if you make things "as simple as possible" for any given amount of complexity, there will always be some underlying trade-off. Brings to mind → https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/11/11/the-law-of-leaky-abstractions/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/11/11/the-law-of-leaky-a...
- javier10e6 6y agoA victim of complexity: I remember my kid trying to open a child-proofed bottle of pills: "It's child-proof" I told her. "How does the bottle knows I am a child?" She asked.
- quacked 6y agoTo paraphrase a blog writer- "a lot of people complain about feeling disconnected, but when I ask them to describe what it would feel like to be connected, they are unable to describe anything." Many people are aware of life feeling too complicated, but very few actually have thought about what life would feel like if it were simple, and once they think about what they would need to get rid of in order to make life feel simple, most are unwilling to give up the privileges and freedom afforded to them by their "complex" lives.