13 ms·
Stripe Will Pay Workers $20k to Leave New York and San Francisco
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jdavis703 6y agoThis is a great deal for Stripe, but bad for workers. $20k could easily be eaten up just on moving expenses (breaking a lease, hiring movers, etc). Let’s say an engineer making $150k year manages to frugally move for only $5k. That means, after one year they’re already loosing money. And when it comes to find a new job, they very well be in a tighter labor pool compared with what they had in NYC or SF.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jtchang 6y ago$20k is just relocation. Not to make up for the reduction in salary.
- kodablah 6y ago> but bad for workers. $20k could easily be eaten up just on moving expenses That's the point of the $20k, to cover the move. The deal is to keep your job at 90% of your salary while potentially living in a place that is only 75% (or less) of the cost of living as SF/NY. Get yourself a nice big place, some indoor/outdoor breathing room, etc.
- bobthepanda 6y ago90% of your 2020 salary. I would not be shocked if next year the people who took this deal were not given raises as high as Bay area employees because "lower cost of living".
- ska 6y agoLet's say the 20k is a wash on moving. Your 150k/year engineer is going to net about 100k, dropping it to 135k/year will have a net of about 90, so round numbers call it a 10k "loss" after taxes on income. So if they save 1k/mo in expenses, they are ahead 2k a year net. I've made moves before that shifted my monthly expenses far more than that. It's not obvious there aren't win-win version of this.
- wobblykiwi 6y agoAre there any states that tax 30+% on income? That's a ridiculously high number. Every other state has lower taxes than California.
- ska 6y agoTry this with an income tax estimator. You need FICA, state, local, federal etc. people often underestimate all of this when they are tossing tax rates around. Effective tax rate for a single earner of 150,000 in NYC with no extra deductions is a bit over 32%. Remember that the before-tax delta here gets applied at the marginal rate, so it's always going to be knocked down a fair bit for higher earners; the net impact will be smaller. Anyway I assumed above leaving NYC for somewhere else in NY. It's easy to come up with scenarios where you might actually take home more with the pay cut (e.g. SF, CA -> Houston, TX). Housing costs there would be way lower (less than 1/2?).
- jdavis703 6y agoThere’s a myth about California’s sky high taxes. Looking at the overall tax burden (sales, property, income, etc) as a percent of income, CA doesn’t really even crack the top 10 states.
- nullc 6y agoCalifornia figures are distorted by existing long term property owners effectively getting a windfall at the expense of more recent property owners.
- dangus 6y ago
- driverdan 6y agoYou could move to almost any other state and end up ahead. CA's extreme taxes and the bay's high cost of living are easily more than the 10% you'd lose in salary, especially if you move to a state with no income tax.
- jtsiskin 6y agoEven entry level at stripe is above $150k: https://www.levels.fyi/company/Stripe/salaries/Software-Engineer/ https://www.levels.fyi/company/Stripe/salaries/Software-Engi...
- ZephyrBlu 6y ago> Let’s say an engineer making $150k year manages to frugally move for only $5k. That means, after one year they’re already loosing money How do you come to that conclusion without taking COL into account?
- hinkley 6y ago> That means, after one year they’re already loosing money. Only if you live in a van, by yourself. Most of that money is going to a landlord, or the bank. There are quite a few reasons you could decide to do this. Huge promotion for your partner (it's great that we make so much money, but there are plenty of people with higher earning potential than us, and you might have married one.) Ill family member. Pulmonary disease. In-state tuition for your twin children. Continuing education, or plans to switch careers or retire in a few years. All of these may end up being cheaper for you than the $15k a year you're losing.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoAnd they have moved their partner and possibly kids to an area with lesser opportunities - and may have lost the ability to go back to a higher COL.
- lastofthemojito 6y agoI don't know how Stripe's offices are arranged (what sort of work is done where), but it seems strange to me that the bonus to relocate is a fixed amount but the adjustment to salary is a percentage. I've got to think well-paid software folks are going to look at the $20k and scoff. I know I'd be underwater on that deal in less than a year. On the other hand, administrative folks, HR, etc ... they might see it as a more appealing deal. I wonder if there's some sort of ulterior motive here for Stripe?
- macspoofing 6y agoThe $20k covers relocation costs. Whether or not you'd be 'underwater' depends on cost of living in your new location. San Fran and New York are very expensive.
- triceratops 6y ago> The $20k covers relocation costs I didn't read the article and thought it was a bonus. If it's relocation costs, that's an even worse offer than it sounds. The company will probably save that much money in the first 2 months of the employee leaving NYC and the Bay Area. EDIT: I didn't know about the 10% pay cut. That's what I get for not reading the article.
- sokoloff 6y agoSaving $20K in 2 months would be an annualized $120K/year. A 10% pay cut might represent a savings of $25K - $50K/yr. Where's the rest of the savings to the company coming from?
- triceratops 6y agoI didn't know about the 10% pay cut and assumed salaries would be adjusted to the local market. You're right. However, if the employees move to smaller markets they presumably have fewer employment options and less bargaining power in the future. So the company will save money over the long term too.
- thrownaway954 6y agothis is ridiculous, "the workers who take up the offer will have to take a 10% cut to their compensation." so you get 20K up front, which as jdavis mention, could be used up in moving, then you have to accept a 10% pay cut. so in reality, you're losing all around. just because someone moves to a new area, doesn't mean they should be punished by having a decrease in salary. this is way a scumbaggish way for a company to make money. anyone working for stripe better rethink things and go work for another company.
- swiley 6y agoThey could easily be paying half their rent (and could approach paying just 20% depending on the situation.) Most people will probably save money.
- nobody9999 6y ago>They could easily be paying half their rent (and could approach paying just 20% depending on the situation.) Most people will probably save money. I was offered this "choice" back in 2013. Despite the fact that I (and my co-workers) were almost completely remote already, we were told that if we didn't relocate to Tallahassee, FL from NYC and accept a 20% pay cut, we would need to find new employment. Even worse, should we accept this "generous offer" we would be guaranteed employment for 12 months (presumably long enough for them to find and hire locals who are compensated less, then have us train them). I did the math and while I could certainly save on rent, the costs of an automobile, its fuel and maintenance, including insurance made the transition close to a wash for me. I'd also point out that NYC is a wonderful, urban place to live. While Tallahassee is a typical sprawling, suburban place with limited (although more so than some other parts of Florida due to UofFL and it being the state capital) culturally diverse stuff. I chose not to do so (as did all but one of my colleagues -- who did so at great personal sacrifice to make sure she could continue to support her family) and haven't looked back. My experience is that such plans tend to be a salary dump by the company, made worse by the ability to slowly replace those who relocate with much cheaper local resources. Why would you want to uproot your life (and that of your family, if you have one) just so you can be replaced by someone cheaper in the not-so-distant future? That's not to say such a plan isn't a good thing for some people, but I found it to be not worth it.
- lesdeuxmagots 6y agoA flat 10% cut rather than a dynamic COL adjustment? Some people could definitely make that work. A move to a no income tax state with low COL could come out very ahead. Of course, the career implications could be more negative than it’s worth, but there’s a reason why back office / administrative / operations staff tend to be easier to move to a different state relative to technical talent, which is more densely concentrated in fewer regions.
- zebrafish 6y agoI'm not sure what the average poster here on HN makes, but if I assume that it's ~$250K for the employees living in SF, you could move to St. Louis, MO, have your salary adjusted to $225K, get a $20K bonus for moving, and your 225,000 St. Louis dollars would be equivalent to 513,369 San Francisco dollars. I get that a 10% annual salary hit is larger than $20K for a lot of people, but the cost of living in these areas is over 100% larger than most other cities in the country. I would take that deal in a heartbeat.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoPeople perceive a lower probability of advancement in other regions, and lower probability of securing similar employment in the event of turbulence at your employer. It's a personal decision how much value to assign to these possibilities, but obviously it's significant enough to sufficient people that Stripe is having to offer extra incentive to move. Although the above is not the only factor. Obviously there are things like weather, geographic amenities, politics, etc to consider.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoI think this really depends on your lifestyle. I save > 60% of my post-tax income. I'm able to do this because, 1) luckily, I make a lot of money, and 2) I don't have any dependents or health problems. If I moved to St. Louis, I'd save an extra ~$2k a month in taxes, which is basically the cut in salary. I /only/ spend $40k a year outside of housing (I realize this is a lot). A lot of that /was/ on traveling to see friends and family, and about 10% of that is utilities, car payments, etc - things that don't really change. Let's say $20k of my spending is on local services like entertainment and restaurants and general shopping. Let's say that's 30% cheaper in St. Louis. That's $6k in savings. Plus another ~$1-2k per month in rent. Absolute tops, that's $30k per year. For context (not to brag), this is not much much more than my annual raise. Sure, if you have a giant house and several dependents, and spend ALL of your post-tax income - living in Saint Louis could offer you twice as much spending power. For a lot of people, it doesn't. Most of their money goes toward investments, and I can't buy investments any cheaper from Saint Louis than I can anywhere else in the world. Finally, if you own, even with the $12k limit on SALT, the fact that Mortgage Interest is deductible makes the difference in housing not as extreme as it might appear if you make a lot of money. Also, a lot of places with very high housing prices - unsurprisingly - have really low property taxes.
- ponker 6y agoThis is an astonishingly good offer, as NY and SF are double to 4x the cost of living of other places in the US (let alone places outside the US).
- andymoe 6y agoI hope the tech workers leaving California take into account how hostile most states are in terms of non competes for employees. Not having them enforceable here is a big part of the magic that let the tech industry thrive in the Bay Area. That said, I’m happy to tough it out here and potentially take advantage of not having to compete with as many other techies and private school kids for rentals in my neighborhood in SF.
- modeless 6y agoThis is a really good point. Will these companies make their employees sign non-competes during their move?
- andymoe 6y agoMost of the employment agreements I’ve signed with largish tech companies have the non-compete baked in there with language that it does not apply where not enforceable or a specific carve out for California. I know Amazon makes people sign one again when you on board in a new location after a transfer. (There was an article about that recently I think)
- easytiger 6y agoHow does it work in America? If one works remotely for a company based in SF from NV for example, do the employment laws of NV apply? If time is spilt between states how would it be determined? Would this only matter in the event of a dispute between the two parties?
- mushbino 6y agoIt's based on your primary residence location. "Primary" typically meaning where you reside more than half the year. In your example, it would be Nevada.
- ffggvv 6y agothe vast majority of employees just work their single job and have no side projects or gigs that would trigger a noncompete
- bradlys 6y agoA lot of people are saying this is a bad deal because you don't get to keep your entire TC when you leave the region - you effectively end up losing more TC in the long run. True but like... you also can have way lower expenses for housing... and if you move to a state with no income tax, you might not even lose almost any net income. But - uh - I think a lot of people would be happy to keep 90% of their really high silicon valley TC if they moved to another region and they got a one-time $20K relocation bonus to top it off. I'm sure many people in SV would move if they thought they could keep 90% of their TC in another area. That said - it only stays true if they stick with Stripe. As soon as Stripe doesn't employ them - they're gonna be competing for remote-only workers wages (or whatever is local too I guess) unless they move back. I see these options as really good offers for those who really want to temporarily move somewhere else, like the company/manager/whatever they currently work for, and want to come back to the tech hub in 2-3 years (new parents? young/childless married couples? someone who misses their friends "back home"? Idk). For everyone else, I don't know why you'd move away unless you were already planning on it anyway. Your savings will be short term gained and you will lose all your friendships locally. You won't likely get to keep that $400K+ TC by sticking with permanently remote jobs or by not living in a tech hub city unless you never lose your job. (Uncommon) For people who hated living in NYC or SF Bay Area then maybe this is the winning ticket to help them kickstart their jump into another region. If Stripe IPOs - they could use that stock they earned for 2 years while working remotely to buy a house almost anywhere besides NY/SF. (Effectively meaning they don't need SF/NY income anymore because they have paid the most expensive part of housing off)
- rch 6y agoThey could probably buy a house now, in the right location.
- cma 6y agoThere is a good chance state income tax will become deductible again after the election and it won't be quite such a savings.
- nostrademons 6y ago> I'm sure many people in SV would move if they thought they could keep 90% of their TC in another area. I dunno about Stripe, but a lot of folks at Google (and presumably the other FAANGs in the region) have had that option for a decade or more. I've had friends I met at Google Mountain View move to Ann Arbor, Boulder, Toronto, Tel Aviv, Boston, Seattle, etc, usually to be close to family when they're having kids. You do get CoL-adjusted but 90% of SV salary is pretty typical. Only restrictions are that you have to be a solid performer beforehand, and you have to find a team that's either in that location or that's willing to have you work remotely (many teams are happy to have remote workers, particularly ones who are high performers). > If Stripe IPOs - they could use that stock they earned for 2 years while working remotely to buy a house almost anywhere besides NY/SF. (Effectively meaning they don't need SF/NY income anymore because they have paid the most expensive part of housing off) That's the case for most people who have worked for ~5-10 years at a Silicon Valley company. When 2009 hit I had a bunch of coworkers who joked about buying up whole city blocks in Detroit and plopping down a Google office and an intentional-living commune there. A lot of mid-career engineers at a FAANG could buy a house for cash in most parts of the U.S. and then have enough left over to retire, but choose not to because at that point they've put down roots in the Bay Area (and gotten addicted to the weather and culture).
- philsnow 6y agoOne thing I've had trouble modeling is the apples-to-oranges future value characterization of property in California (and New York, I guess) vs most of the rest of the country. In CA, property values are sky high to begin with and you have to pay property tax on them, but if you buy in certain areas, you stand a fair chance of your property appreciating by 10% or more per year. Elsewhere (Smalltown USA), property values are 1/10th what they are in those same areas of CA, but you generally can't expect anywhere near the same appreciation on the property. So what, do you consider the appreciation as "inflow" (vs "income" because it's taxed differently when you sell) and take it into account when you are doing retirement planning? You definitely could, and maybe discount the appreciation by some pessimism factor to account for some possible future situation where housing values get get in half. For me it's a lot easier to think about if I just live somewhere where a house in 30 years will (inflation adjusted) cost very roughly what it does today.
- burlesona 6y agoThere's also enormous risk embodied in the sky-high real estate prices in CA and NY, namely that they might not continue appreciating, or could even flatten and drop somewhat. The prices in CA are driven by the extraordinary scarcity of housing relative to the demand created by the booming tech industry. Real estate is priced at the margins, and if the tech outflow accelerates it could tip to a new lower baseline relatively quickly (see places like Miami and Las Vegas in 2008). If that happens you risk being underwater by substantial amounts.
- pryelluw 6y agoQuestion is: Has the bonus/advancement framework changed? You could go -10% now but get it back in n amount of time. Still "behind" in a sense, but potentially ahead if you move to a low col area. I pay for a whole house in north Atlanta with less than people pay for an apartment in SF (houses also build up equity).
- angel_j 6y agoShows just how valuable neo-yuppies are to local economies and politics. Go home, you actually make it worse for everybody else. Plus, your vote matters in any other state.
- nostrademons 6y agoThe challenge with this is further career advancement. Even if you stick with Stripe, the most important and innovative work tends to stay close to headquarters, if only because the executives like to keep tabs on it. And it forecloses on the possibility of jumping ship to another company if they're doing more interesting work, or hopping aboard the next startup wave before the rest of the country knows about it. I could see it making a lot of sense for the rank & file engineer who just wants to close their JIRA tickets and go home to their family, though. And that's really the economically rational part about this: it doesn't make sense for those jobs to stay in the Bay Area when they can be done from anywhere, by anyone with baseline software engineering prowess. Over the last decade SV tech companies have grown more and more of these roles, and it's good for both the company and the worker if they can do them from areas where housing and CoL isn't so ridiculous as the Bay Area. (Not as good for the worker when the company discovers that folks in Pakistan, Thailand, and Czech Republic can do these jobs just as effectively for $30K/year, though.)
- mrchess 6y agoAgreed on this one. I was with a company, since the beginning, that ended up blowing up. In the middle of its growth, I had to move, and ended up becoming a remote engineer. Since the acquisition, all my colleagues (who all started at the same "level" as me) have greatly surpassed me in terms of title, responsibility, and salary because "they were there". I'm not upset or anything, and in fact happy we all won in our own ways, but just echoing the idea that being nearby matters for career advancement!
- jedberg 6y agoI was watching a DJ from West Oakland on Twitch, and she was very excited that she was moving to SF next week. She said that because all the tech people left, rents in SF have fallen a lot, so much so that she's actually saving money moving to SF. It'll be interesting to see how that holds up after this is over. How many of the large employers will continue to allow work from home, or at least not work from SF?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoHow popular, in terms of audience, is DJ video streaming on Twitch? Can you share more about this phenomenon?
- jedberg 6y agoYou know, I just discovered it recently myself. There are enough DJs that you can basically get music 24/7. Maybe that's a function of the pandemic, and it will slow down once people can go out again and the DJs can work again. As far as popularity, it's totally random. I'll start with the Sofitukker stream in the morning, and just follow the raids all day. Some of the DJs will have a few 1000 streamers, and some will have 50. After a while Twitch starts suggesting channels. Looking right now at all the suggested channels, they range in viewers from 60 to 808.
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoI think I'd like to watch someone produce live on Twitch, collaborating with the audience as one progresses. Something like what Dr Mix does, but live and original: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I0djbmrnEBc&t=178s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I0djbmrnEBc&t=178s
- neivin 6y agoSF rents have fallen significantly only in "undesirable" areas which are mostly offices and high rises where rents were exorbitant anyway. My friend's shoebox apartment was $3300/mo which he renewed for another 13 months for $2200/mo with 2 months rent free. However, more residential neighborhoods have seen rents drop by only a little bit.
- jjav 6y agoI've seen this play out with several companies over the last 20 years. Company starts to push employees to work remote from anywhere. It sounds great and it is great for as long as you keep and enjoy that same job. Once you move into the boonies, company knows they have leverage on you. You can no longer ragequit on Thursday and start at a new place with a better salary next Monday. You'll be forced to hold on to this job even if it turns sour. Or what if there are layoffs. Then you're stuck in the boonies with no other employment choices other than compete for other remote jobs at a much reduced salary now. Moving back to the Bay Area is very difficult if you sold the house when moving out. TL;DR: Only move for personal reasons, not for company incentives.
- juniper_strong 6y agoThis is a false dichotomy. There are hundreds of millions of Americans that live in places that are neither the Bay Area nor the boonies. In any of the 50 biggest metro areas in the US, there are employment choices for programmers.
- jjav 6y agoYou're right, of course. What went unsaid is that with these offers the strong temptation is to move out to areas where you truly want to live, not to just another slightly cheaper large metro area with jobs. Everyone I know who took these moves went to places like a large farm out nowhere, or a cabin deep in the forest, or to a small village in the mountains or on a faraway beach. Places which defined paradise to each individual, with wonderful quality of life (but no jobs). Personally I was very strongly tempted to move to Kona (Hawaii) keeping my full silicon valley salary. Not exactly a hotbed of replacement tech jobs though, so I guess I'm glad I didn't.
- juniper_strong 6y agoOK, I see what you're saying, thanks for the clarification. I guess there is a tendency to overreact and think, "I want the exact opposite of the Bay Area", when what you really want is cheaper rent and a tad less shit on the sidewalk.
- cryptica 6y agoThey should pay me $20K to stay away.
- karlding 6y agoWhat about stock refreshers? I believe stock grants make up a pretty big portion of one's total compensation at large tech companies. According to data shared by Google and Facebook employees [0], it seems like stock makes up ~40% of your compensation for a Senior L5 role. Would those also be CoL adjusted? [0] https://www.levels.fyi/SE/Google/Facebook# https://www.levels.fyi/SE/Google/Facebook#
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI assume there wouldn’t be any public policy for that. I think privately they’d calculate that remote employees have a weaker job market and less refreshes will be required to retain them.
- rodonn 6y agoI don't know the "official" policy on this yet, but anecdotally they do not decrease your existing grants (which vest over 4 years), but the new location could affect the new RSUs you will be granted while in the new location.
- future_unclear 6y agoRemoving geography from the hiring equation is going to fuck American tech workers. Once you’ve gone digital, there’s no (on paper) difference between a programmer in the Philippines or in Iowa except the one in Iowa is much more expensive.
- twblalock 6y agoOutsourcing failed 20 years ago and it will fail now for the same reasons it did then.
- future_unclear 6y agoThe conditions are different now. Infrastructure is better, foreign workers are better trained, American company culture is different (ceos of Microsoft and Google both Indian), and the possibility of American workers creating political friction is becoming non-negligible.
- kortilla 6y agoUnless the workers in the Philippines are willing to work US work hours, they aren’t the same. As someone who has managed teams in India, overnight delays in feedback can easily stretch weeklong epics across months. You just can’t rapidly iterate with timezone latency like that. If your tasks are so well defined that a single feature request ticket can be fulfilled and satisfied on the first try, that’s cool but you’re likely not actually doing anything challenging and you’ve probably already outsourced to India.
- mantas 6y agoI did quite a bit of work little overlap. Me in Europe with clients in Japan or US west coast. Meetings on few overlapping hours and pretty much around-the-clock work was pretty good. Lots of time for deep work on both ends. If one side needs something, the other side can prepare it while former sleeps. Maybe my clients and I got lucky because little hands-on management was required and specs were quite lax? But at least in some cases it works just fine.
- 6y ago
- cblconfederate 6y agoI wonder what % of current SV employees were planning to stay there even after retirement, regardless of whether they ve made a family/house there.
- oscardelben 6y agoI'm curious about how companies that rely a lot on immigration to fill positions how they are going to convince people to move to the US and work from home.
- Proven 6y agoLeftist States pay (or forgive taxes) to get employers to move in, but employers already trapped in those Big Government hellholes pay their employees to GTFO. It's not hard to guess what will happen to those states. "My name is AOC and I'm here to help" Yeah, no. Socialism and Big Government always result in wealth destruction, give up already...
- RJIb8RBYxzAMX9u 6y agoIronic, I was offered almost $10k to relocate to the Bay Area a few years ago as part of my signing bonus. Having lived here for a few years, I'd love to be offered $20k to move away...
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoRegardless of whether a 10% salary cut is more than offset by a decrease in cost of living, the idea of an established employee, whose labor output you already currently value at their current total comp level, being paid less solely because they translate on the surface of the earth to a new coordinate is insulting and ridiculous. They aren’t suddenly less valuable to you. Their impact on revenue hasn’t suddenly changed. I would never accept such a deal. Whether I am moving to a lower cost of living area or not, that is my business and none of my employer’s business. My employer and I have an agreement about my pay based on how they value my labor and how I value my time. I am looking for raises not cuts. And raises are a function of my impact on revenue. Whether I live in Manhattan or Madison utterly plays no role in this, full stop. This very likely would be a reason to leave a company, or never consider working for them in the first place.
- a_imho 6y agoDo they offer 10% TC increase in case you move to NY/SF?
- DavidPeiffer 6y agoIf this became a thing more tech companies offered, I could see it legitimately shifting political dynamics over like 10 years. The difference in some states switching colors is sometimes quite small, and California isn't itself at risk of switching colors anytime soon.
- rdtwo 6y agoWhy not live in a tax arbitrage area like the wa side of hood river or Vancouver wa. You could basically pay no income tax then do most of your shopping in Oregon for no sales tax. You would come our way ahead and it’s a lot cheaper
- rongenre 6y agoLiving in a tech hub gives you access to a super-liquid job market. If you take the offer and move elsewhere, and you suddenly get a new boss you can't work with, you've got a lot less options. Probably a really good plan for the companies though: great way to have a loyal workforce that won't switch jobs for a 10% pay bump.