6 ms·
The reluctant debut of the A14 processor
- jiggawatts 6y agoDid anyone else notice that the AI section is now bigger than the traditional CPU cores? What applications benefit from this? The only use-case I've seen for AI in Apple's mobile devices is the face unlock.
- emteycz 6y agoApple is planning on releasing AR headset, isn't it?
- Skinney 6y agoApple does all machine learning on-device. So stuff like handwriting recognition, Siri, automatic improvements of photos etc. makes heavy use of it.
- jononor 6y agoAll inference on-device you mean? I presume that the vast majority of their models are trained in the cloud. Apart from some fine-tuning for personalization maybe.
- Flockster 6y agoThe recognition of faces and settings of images for example is fully done on the phone. But that is done overnight when the phone is plugged in.
- manojlds 6y agoWhile they did say machine learning, all the examples are of inference, and not training. So you don't have to ask if they meant inference when it is very clear what they mean.
- lostmsu 6y agoOutside of marketing speak, it is not really machine learning if the machine is not learning.
- junipertea 6y agoI wouldn't expect "this phone can run for 10 hours and train a model", even though it clearly is also possible.
- ksec 6y ago>What applications benefit from this? The only use-case I've seen for AI in Apple's mobile devices is the face unlock. Oh no. You could have double the CPU core and it wouldn't make 95% of common use case any faster. But NPU ( Neural Processing Engine ) and GPGPU have lots of potentials. Siri being the first one, When you take photos its uses NPU to adjust the image. Your Speech recognition for lots of different languages. Handwriting, Your Photo Gallery Face Recognition, on iPad Handwriting / Image to Text Recognition. And lots of thing likely to do with AR. And all of them has great impact to user experience previously not available. Not to mention both GPU and NPU scales very well with transistor budget.
- IshKebab 6y agoSpeech recognition, image recognition, photo/video enhancement, face recognition, predictive text, etc. There aren't a huge number of applications, but there are enough to justify it, especially because it makes a big difference where it can be used.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iamgopal 6y agoAI creates possibilities of creating meaningful signal from extremely noisy environment, enabling lots of miniaturisation in sensors, which again enables tons of cross domain applications. e.g. low cost spectrometers for blood testing.
- jpalomaki 6y agoHomekit cameras support face recognition. I assume this runs on ”home hub”, either your Apple TV or HomePod.
- RupertWiser 6y agoTotally get this from a business perspective but speaking for myself, I was actually far more interested in seeing the new chip in the iPad. I have no doubt that the iPhone 12 will be another confident black rectangle. Having usb c and the stronger processor work its way down the price points was far more exciting of an announcement for me. I don’t really ever find myself yearning for a stronger CPU on my iPhone XR but if Apple is serious about replacing PCs with iPads, it seems like having strong chips in their cheaper models is a great position to fight from.
- nicoburns 6y agoIt's the mac chips I'm really interested in seeing. That's the unknown quantity.
- josephg 6y agoLikewise. I'm still rocking a 2016 13" macbook pro with a dual core CPU and integrated graphics. I'm looking at picking up this year's iphone, and it might be faster in every way than my laptop. (But with less RAM and storage) If true, I'm not really sure what to do about that. I doubt I can offload rust compilation to an iphone.
- nicoburns 6y agoYeah, I have the 2015. You can actual compile Rust on an iphone (but I think you'd have to sync the code thei manually), but I think for Rust you really want one the AMD processsors with 8+ cores. I guess the new macbooks might be able to compete. We'll have to see.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoApple states that: > two high performance A13 cores are 20% faster with 30% lower power consumption than the Apple A12's, and the four high efficiency cores are 20% faster with 40% lower power consumption than the A12's. A13's eight-core Neural Engine dedicated neural network hardware is 20% faster and consumes 15% lower power than the A12's > A14 up to 40% faster than A12, with 30% faster graphics performance than A12, and machine-learning performance is up to 10 times faster.
- stepsrabbit 6y agoIs there any reason for them to compare the A14 to the A12 instead of the A13? Other than making the numbers look more impressive, of course.
- twoodfin 6y agoThey’re comparing it to the SoC in the previous generation of the iPad Air.
- hitchhikerr 6y agoThey were comparing it to the previous iPad Air, which had an A12.
- dep_b 6y agoIt's a bit strange in the same year they're going to present the first laptops sporting the new ARM chip. I mean the performance increase can be declared by the clock increase the smaller process allows alone. So either they put all of their engineering capacity towards a blistering fast desktop / laptop CPU or they really have a problem in their SoC engineering department. Also they reserved all of TSMC's 5nm capacity for the A14. Like that was a last ditch effort to make it _look_ faster after all?
- my123 6y agoThe upcoming Snapdragon and Exynos chips are on Samsung's 5nm process, so they should be relatively comparable. I wouldn't worry on that front. > So either they put all of their engineering capacity towards a blistering fast desktop / laptop CPU TSMC promises up to a 30% improvement in power consumption or up to 15% more performance over the current N7 node in the 5nm process. This relatively matches with Apple's claim this gen. So Apple might have put the engineering effort on desktops & laptops this time.
- simonh 6y agoTransitioning to a new node can be tricky, so in the past they have been very conservative in their changes to the design when doing so. Better to do the transition with as few new potential surprises as possible. This is also true for Qualcomm so I’d expect to see similar, mainly process node driven changes in their new chips as well.
- jkestner 6y agoAka Intel's Tick-Tock cadence of releases.
- Guthur 6y agoI'm not trying to be some sort of Luddite, but at this stage what more can a phone really do. If it's 10% faster than chips that are already doing a fine job right now it just feels flat. I really love new tech and especially microprocessors but have trouble seeing how a phone breaks out of it's limiting form factor in any meaningful way right now that would make use of yet more processing power.
- simonh 6y agoPeople have been saying that for 10 years. It makes calls, it’s got location, internet, a camera. Done right? Since then we’ve got on-device powered AI voice assistants, Face ID, neural engine powered photo enhancement, health monitoring, custom silicon enhanced environment mapping AR. Goodness knows what else is coming. The advent of custom tuned accelerators such as neural engines in silicon is opening up a huge new field of applications and capabilities. That’s especially true when they are linked to these new arrays of environment and bio-sensors. The X series iPhones are doing a list of things simply impossible on previous devices. You may not care about some or all of these things, that’s fine they’re not all for everyone, but each one of them is important to some people.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoBut how much does any of that really matter? I really believe the future is in things like AI voice assistance, but IMHO stuff like that isn't really good enough yet to make a big difference. I think what Guthur may reflect upon is that we got tons of new phone models pushed into the market every single year that do very little new compared to previous models. So what if we get 50% more performance. Sounds impressive, but then you realize it is only used to create smiley animations, and other frivolous teenager nonsense. I don't think I have really seen a point in phone upgrades since iPhone 4 or so. That is about 9 years ago. Same deal with iPads, not much new anyone needs. There are a couple of things though which I do think has mattered. Retina display and the Apple pencil. But honestly the priorities are quite different from what I would want. I love my Apple products but I really wished they where a bit more modular or serviceable. By that I mean that e.g. replacing the battery should be much easier. Memory should have been easier to expand or replace.
- ksec 6y agoIt is worth pointing out A13 had a die size of 100mm2, much larger than usual, especially on a Smartphone Leading Edge Node. So the A14 is basically am A13 5nm Die Shrink with better GPU and Double the NPU. What I am interested in is the Die Size. Which I am expecting to be sub 80mm2.
- GeekyBear 6y agoTSMC says that moving from their 7nm to 5nm process node offers either a 15% speed improvement or about a 30% reduction in power consumption. The thing that I found interesting in the A14 is that this is the first time I can remember a chip designer using a die shrink mainly to cut power usage instead of increase performance. However after Anandtech's recent deep dive into Tiger Lake performance testing, you can see where cutting power use in the A14 cores might be a winning move. >Here we present the 15W vs 28W configuration figures for the single-threaded workloads, which do see a jump in performance by going to the higher TDP configuration, meaning [Tiger Lake] is thermally constrained at 15W even in ST workloads. Comparing it against Apple’s A13, things aren’t looking so rosy as the Intel CPU barely outmatches it even though it uses several times more power, which doesn’t bode well for Intel once Apple releases its “Apple Silicon” Macbooks. https://www.anandtech.com/show/16084/intel-tiger-lake-review-deep-dive-core-11th-gen/8 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16084/intel-tiger-lake-review...
- Gibbon1 6y ago> The thing that I found interesting in the A14 is that this is the first time I can remember a chip designer using a die shrink mainly to cut power usage instead of increase performance. This has been a thing with RF Chip design for the 30 years I've been paying attention. Transceiver I used 20 years ago consumed 220 mW in receive mode. One I used 10 years ago, 50 mW. Current one uses 10mW.
- GeekyBear 6y agoOn the level of a mobile device SOC, however? I can't come up with a single other example where cutting power was prioritized. Things have tended to go the other way with die shrinks that favor performance and often with ridiculous amounts of overclocking piled on top of that. >Brian and I have long been hinting at the sort of ridiculous frequency/voltage combinations mobile SoC vendors have been shipping at for nothing more than marketing purposes. I remember ARM telling me the ideal target for a Cortex A15 core in a smartphone was 1.2GHz. Samsung’s Exynos 5410 stuck four Cortex A15s in a phone with a max clock of 1.6GHz. The 5420 increases that to 1.7GHz. The problem with frequency scaling alone is that it typically comes at the price of higher voltage. There’s a quadratic relationship between voltage and power consumption, so it’s quite possibly one of the worst ways to get more performance. https://www.anandtech.com/show/7335/the-iphone-5s-review/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/7335/the-iphone-5s-review/2