7 ms·
Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? We already heavily subsidise child-rearing through taxes and other benefits. As I s
by nicbou 6y ago
Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless?
We already heavily subsidise child-rearing through taxes and other benefits. As I said elsewhere, there are mechanisms for supporting parents already. If you tried to let any other charitable endeavour take over your work schedule, you wouldn't expect your compensation to remain unaffected.
I'm not resentful at parents. It just seems completely unfair to make childless employees subsidise this adventure, as if they didn't already do it through 40 years of tax contributions.
Besides, let's not pretend that people choose to have kids as a service to humanity. I've never, ever heard anyone claim that. People have kids because they're fun, and because making them is fun.
- jdm2212 6y ago> Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? That's the thing -- you won't actually go volunteer with the homeless. (Or at least, 99% of us wouldn't.) But parents actually have to change those diapers. If there's a little kid running around in the background of that Zoom call, someone is doing a lot of hard work to keep the kid alive. And unlike volunteering at the homeless shelter, they can't just decide they don't feel like it.
- nicbou 6y ago> you won't actually go volunteer with the homeless This was in response to the parent post: > an essential service that some people perform to ensure that society as we know it can continue to exist If this was the reason why parents get a free pass, people who provide essential services would also get to do it on their employer's dime, at the expense of their colleagues. My point across this entire comments section is that this privilege is arbitrary. A lot of people do hard work for all sorts of important reasons, but when they miss work, it gets mentioned in their performance review.
- jdm2212 6y agoSystemic problems require systemic solutions. One-off problems require one-off solutions. Parenting in the pandemic is a systemic problem. And even in non-pandemic times, we have public schools, child services, parental leave, etc. The national guard and jury duty are likewise systemic problems; we need lots of guardsmen and lots of jurors. Homelessness is a systemic problem, but the particular way you choose to do community service (or not do it) is for you to sort out mostly on your own.
- davidgay 6y ago> If this was the reason why parents get a free pass, people who provide essential services would also get to do it on their employer's dime, at the expense of their colleagues. They do. They're called government employees, and they are paid by taxes at the expense of everyone.
- rpdillon 6y agoI guess you're advocating that parents get lower performance ratings during the pandemic if their responsibility to their family has caused them to do lower quality work for their employer. I think that's sort of absurd (for all the reasons jdm2212 has pointed out), but, as a parent of two grade-school children myself, I'd take that deal of it made all the childless people feel they were being treated fairly. I am concerned that performance reviews are generally about communicating paths for development and progress against some goal. I'm not sure how valuable that feedback will be for parents who suffer low performance because of child-rearing responsibilities. I wouldn't suddenly work more hours to improve my performance at the expense of my children's education during this period. It's a poor trade for everyone involved, except perhaps my employer, and even then, it's likely only beneficial for them in the short-term.
- bitexploder 6y agoTech is full of entitled low empathy technocrats. This may seem harsh, but it is very true in my experience. Especially at organizations that skew younger and have discriminatory or ageists hiring practices. It gets talked about obliquely and there are a lot of compelling and meritocratic arguments about how unfair all of this is to people without kids, but ultimately the concessions are few and far between. This mostly comes down to empathy and it is a skill many young technologists have not cultivated by choice or through a general life path to this point. Yes, I am making a lot of generalizations but I don’t think they are a reach.
- listennexttime 6y agoI'm a low empathy technocrat because: (1) I chose not to have children, and (2) I find it unfair that I'm expected to work longer hours for the same compensation/work profile. Is that it? ... No, that's not it. Your position assumes that: (1) Child-rearing is some a-priori, guaranteed good, and (2) That it apparently should be subsidized by employers, (3) and (both implicitly and explicitly, from you and others) at the expense of their non-child having coworkers. Am I getting something wrong, or missing something? I absolutely think parents should get a break during the pandemic. I think everyone should. The work people are doing here to act like we should worship the ground parents walk is easily the most shocking thing I've witnessed. Honestly, it's not at all a stretch to say you basically insist parents get extra compensation (in the form of extra paid vacation). Call me whatever name you want, but people are well within their rights on this, of all places, to raise an eyebrow. --- The other generous interpretation is that there is some base assumption that we ALL (parents and non-parents) should running ourselves at 90+% capacity. And that children are an accept caveat since parents are usually at 100% capacity. What a terrifying dismal way to look at life. I hope that's not it.
- wokwokwok 6y ago> If this was the reason why parents get a free pass... You’re framing this discussion as something you flat out don’t accept as reasonable, despite the thoughtful responses in the thread. Is there any point in actual engaging, or have you already made your mind up? Perhaps, rather than repeatedly and blindly repeating your view over and over, like you might somehow convince parents that they’re bad humans who deserve to be punished, try considering the views of the others here... This a pandemic, if there was ever a situation where the situation was a bit more complicated and a bit more empathy to the circumstances was required, this is it.
- ryandrake 6y agoMany companies do give time off for charity work or public service, match charitable giving, etc. I’d have no problem with my company giving my single, childless colleagues time off or schedule flexibility to engage in some social or public good.
- alisonkisk 6y agoDid any of these companies offer to pay their single workers to work on Covid support systems or handle a shift at the grocery store?
- notyourwork 6y ago> But parents actually have to change those diapers. Parents actually have to have kids to be in a position of caring for a dependent.
- rpdillon 6y agoSure. The point is, once you do, it's a commitment. You don't get to opt out when you feel like you need a break.
- notyourwork 6y agoI don't dispute the point that children require commitment. I'm not sure how that makes employees with children less accountable for work than those who don't have children. What if I have no children but I have a grandparent who is ill and requires care. My point is that if employees with families require support during these hard times, there are probably many who don't have children who also have changed their lives due to this pandemic. Perhaps we should relax the expectations for EVERYONE and not find one circumstance more special than others.
- kelnos 6y agoI think many companies are relaxing expectations for everyone. I have quite a few non-parent co-workers who have taken leave due to the mental health impact COVID has had on them, and my employer has been incredibly flexible in making sure they are able to take care of themselves. I (also as a non-parent) have been mostly ok, but I've been taking more Fridays off than I would otherwise, just to have some more recharge time. But I don't think there's necessarily a one-size-fits-all allowance solution. Taking care of a grandparent does not require the same time commitment, and, crucially, the same lack of control over one's schedule, as child care. Barring emergencies, you can schedule when you take care of your grandparent. With children, you are on call all day long, and kids can and will interrupt you for whatever (or no) reason. You can't just put them in a room by themselves for 8 hours and expect things to go well. Hell, with most young kids you can't even put them in a room by themselves for 30 minutes and expect things to go well.
- jbay808 6y agoMaybe taking care of aging parents with dementia is a better example, although it's less voluntary than children are.
- betterunix2 6y agoParenting is not voluntary. Yes, becoming a parent is voluntary, but once you have a child in your home you cannot put being a parent on hold while you focus on other things.
- jbay808 6y agoI didn't say that parenting is voluntary.
- kelnos 6y agoIf not, then what's the point of the comparison you're making?
- jbay808 6y agoThat your parents might get dementia, and you might even have to quit your job to take care of them full time if you don't get sufficient leave, and unlike children, that's not even something that you likely made a plan and budget for in advance, or a lifestyle that you chose willingly despite the stress. It's just one of many possible severely challenging, non-optional commitments that can arise in life. (This is in the context of supporting making parent leave available for non-parents).
- betterunix2 6y agoActually where I work you do not get "parental" leave, you get "family" leave which can also be used to care for aged parents (for a time, just like parental leave, until more permanent arrangements can be made). It is also irrelevant to the article, which is not about normal benefits that parents utilize, but the extraordinary considerations being made right now (and again, where I work, those extraordinary policies can be invoked for taking care of any family member, not just children and not just blood relatives). Note also that parents did not choose the situation we are currently in. This is not a matter of lifestyle choice. The lifestyle we chose when we decided to have kids included the expectation of childcare during the day and that is what is failing here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Kluny 6y agoIt sounds like you're being facetious, but plenty of employers will pay for you to do community service. For example, HeroWork is an organization similar to Habitats for Humanity, which does construction work for charities. Trade firms such as electricians and plumbers donate their employees' time (and wholesale accounts, and equipment) to do the work.
- Aeolun 6y agoOne of the many reasons I have had kids is as a service to humanity. It’s definitely fun, but way too many people just cannot be bothered so someone has to. I kind of want our race/country/planet to continue existing even if I can’t.
- thehappypm 6y agoIt’s not a service to humanity. There are 7 billion of us out here. There are plenty of great reasons to have kids but I don’t buy the “for the greater good” argument.
- chii 6y agoi agree - if them having kids is "for the greater good", they could just as easily donate half their own paycheque to a charitable organization that deals with orphans and starving kids in parts of the world. That might make for a greater good than one additional child they may make.
- RankingMember 6y agoSeriously. We have >8% of the world population living in poverty. If these supposed self-less "I did it for the good of the species!" procreators really wanted to help humanity, we'd see a lot more adoption.
- pb7 6y ago>way too many people just cannot be bothered so someone has to This couldn't be further from the truth. I don't know anything about you but I can confidently say for every person like you, there are 5 that have a lot of kids purely out of inability or unwillingness to try not to. We are so far from not having enough children that your service to humanity is nothing but a stroke of your own ego. If you really, truly believed what you're saying, would you give up your right to have children under a guaranteed contract that someone else would in your place? Probably not.
- sinsterizme 6y agoI'm pretty sure that having kids contributes in the _opposite_ direction to the maintainability of our planet and our species as a whole. Why do you think it's a service to humanity when population growth is a growing problem, continuing to get worse, which exacerbates issues like conflict between groups, resource contention and climate issues. I want to emphasize that a sustainable average number of children per family is not zero [0] but around 1-1.5 for a sustainable population size in 100 years, according to the linked article. So given that you presumably live in a developed country (well educated, and don't need children for labour), and have a human's normal biological urges to reproduce, it's not immoral to produce children, but it's certainly not morally commendable. [0] https://mahb.stanford.edu/blog/yes-overpopulation-problem/ https://mahb.stanford.edu/blog/yes-overpopulation-problem/
- triceratops 6y ago> Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? A lot of companies will happily let you do that. Microsoft and Google even donate in $ for every hour you volunteer, up to a certain limit.
- alextheparrot 6y agoIrrespective of the reasonableness of the comment you’re responding to, I don’t think this comment is addressing the presented point. My experience with these policies is that these volunteer hours cannot be performed during work hours unless they are coordinated as by a manager in your organization as a team event. It seems that situation, wherein you cannot reduce or substitute your working hours as an individual to instead volunteer, is what they are commenting on. Parents are being allowed to do this with their parental duties, which seems to be the perceived unfairness.
- triceratops 6y agoAt the companies I mentioned you may perform volunteer work during company time, outside of team events, up to a certain limit.
- alextheparrot 6y agoAh, my experience was with Apple so I assumed it generalized to some degree, instead it is just Apple being stingy as ever. Thanks for clarifying.
- crpatino 6y ago> If you tried to let any other charitable endeavour take over your work schedule, you wouldn't expect your compensation to remain unaffected. You fail to realize that most people (as in 99%) work in order to earn a living, not for the sake of work itself. You hold a job to earn money and use that money to pay for the needs and wants that let you live the best life you can afford (with or without children). And if your job gets in the way, you quit and find a job that better fits your needs. Now, if you personally are in the 1% who derive a sense of fulfillment from your work itself, good for you. You ought to be aware that you are an extraordinary employee, or at least have the potential to grow into an extraordinary employee. If your salary does not reflect that, it is because of your lack of negotiation skills. In other words, it is not fair that people that do not give their all get the same compensation as those that go far beyond duty. The solution, however, is not to force the majority to meet exceptional expectations; it is to pay a fair price for exceptional labor.
- dcolkitt 6y ago> We already heavily subsidise child-rearing through taxes and other benefits. The US and most other Western countries run huge budget deficits at essentially zero interest costs. This is only possible because creditors have full faith in the ability of future tax payers to meet debt obligations. In light of that, I’d say the overall balance is that those with children are massively subsidizing the childless.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoHow do? The childless pay taxes and don’t have subsequent gene pool for society to take care of.. Taxes are perpetual and mandatory. It goes towards subsidizing other people’s genes and then the childless have to be thankful for that. Let’s not forget the children who grow up to be thugs and criminals. Not every fruit of the loin is a productive member of the society. I find it appalling that after 12 years of subsidied education, they still want free education, housing is a human right and most haven’t even paid off the cost of society paying for them ..never mind paying it forward for the next generation.
- Smaug123 6y agoI believe you've missed the point almost completely. The parent comment's point is that the USA is as rich as it is because they've effectively taken out an enormous loan from the markets. The markets trust the USA to pay back this loan because they trust the USA to keep producing children, some subset of whom will collectively generate enough wealth to cover the loan. If everyone in the USA agreed not to have children any more, the country would immediately collapse (not collapse in the future when the workforce ran out, but immediately) as the market rushed to salvage what it could from the country's walking corpse.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoThere is no contract. Are we putting a contract on reproductive promise for markets? Is this a contract out on women’s uteri? This isn’t about macro economics at all. This is all about religion forcing women to breed and the tyranny of scrotums to see who can pee farther most into the gene pool. However a contract does exist between the parents of the child. With the male..due to the lack of anatomical bits to carry a fetus to term within his body or capable of feeding said offspring through mammary excretions is responsible for the well being of the offspring. Financially or otherwise. Because. Biology. In the jungle, when the alpha male is unable to provide for the litter, he gets displaced. Insect brains seem to be far superior with reasoning. Clearly mammalian instincts are not up to scratch when it comes to collecting on contracts. The female praying mantis being more sensible simply devours the male after mating. The male drone bee breaks off its penile appendage and free falls from above while in the throes of a kamikaze orgasm. Homo sapiens get to go to a job and support a child. Do it. If you can’t, don’t do it. There is no societal contract to nourish the fruit of strangers’ loins. Dear men, please curb your ejaculation. And if you can’t, make enough to support your mutated chromosome financially and when a pandemic comes around the corner, man up.
- leetcrew 6y ago> Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? maybe? at my company we get a few days worth of "VTO" (volunteer time off) per year. so if you worked here, you could absolutely do that.
- nemo44x 6y agoIf your company doesn’t give you time off to volunteer to help homeless non-profits then you might consider asking for it. Your premise is sound in my opinion. That’s a valuable and local thing. People don’t have kids directly to service humanity. But the bet effect is kids do benefit humanity. It’s worth supporting. In fact it’s quite sad how low the birth rate has become among those that can afford to have kids.
- jefftk 6y ago> Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? It depends where you work, but potentially? I work at one of the FAANGs and we can take up to 20hr/y of work hours for volunteering.
- ironman1478 6y ago"Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless?" Yes and my last job encouraged us to take days off for local volunteering work. What most of us do isn't that important in the grand scheme of things. If you can make somebody's day better or easier, why not. The software everybody is making isn't really going to come out that much faster because you took some time out of a single day your week to do anything else but work.
- bosswipe 6y agoSo you want us to quit or be fired?
- kelnos 6y ago> Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? You don't have to help the homeless during the work day; that's a choice. But parents don't get to decide not to care for their children during the work day, when school/daycare/etc. is not available. > It just seems completely unfair to make childless employees subsidise this adventure How is that happening, though? As a non-parent who chose to work from home most of the time pre-COVID (despite HQ being a 30-minute walk from home), my work life is nearly unchanged due to COVID. I get up, work 8-10 hours, and then go and do whatever I want (obviously "whatever I want" has been curtailed due to COVID, but that's not my employer's or parent-coworkers' fault). I'm not "subsidizing" anything when a parent gets more flexibility during their work day due to child care obligations. The thing that changes for the company as a whole is that projects take longer to complete because many employees have taken a productivity hit, but that's no skin off my back. > Besides, let's not pretend that people choose to have kids as a service to humanity. I've never, ever heard anyone claim that. People have kids because they're fun, and because making them is fun. Agreed, and as a non-parent I can't help but roll my eyes whenever a parent tries to tell me what a grand service to humanity their child-rearing is. But, at the end of the day, humanity would cease to exist without people having kids, so regardless of their actual motivation, they are providing a valuable service to humanity.
- UncleMeat 6y agoActually yes. Companies like Facebook and Google explicitly offer employees the ability to volunteer on company time (up to a limit).
- cseleborg 6y ago> Then is it cool if I skip a few meetings to volunteer to help the homeless? Well, why shouldn't it be? > I'm not resentful at parents. It just seems completely unfair to make childless employees subsidise this adventure, as if they didn't already do it through 40 years of tax contributions. Those children will later subsidize many childless people's retirement, either through contribution to pension funds or simply by keeping the world going. > Besides, let's not pretend that people choose to have kids as a service to humanity. I've never, ever heard anyone claim that. People have kids because they're fun, and because making them is fun. As I wrote earlier, it can be both a choice and a service to society/humanity.