11 ms·
I don't fully agree with you. Back when I worked in retail or fast food, smokers could step out for a 5 minute smoke break every once in a while. As a non-smok
by nicbou 6y ago
I don't fully agree with you.
Back when I worked in retail or fast food, smokers could step out for a 5 minute smoke break every once in a while. As a non-smoker, I wasn't allowed to just sit there for 5 minutes. At the end of the day, we got paid the same, but smokers got 30 minutes off, courtesy of the non-smokers who picked up the slack.
Likewise, parents are excused from work because they have children. I fully appreciate the difficulty of being a parent and the necessity for those measures. I don't think we really have a choice. It's either that or we watch them slowly crack under the pressure.
That being said, they chose to have children, and I chose not to. Whatever I have going on instead can't have priority over my work schedule. Whether it's a side hustle or a little league baseball team, it has to wait.
To be clear, I want those parents to get the time they desperately need. However, if this arrangement is to last, then childless employees should also get time for their personal obligations, whatever they might be.
- wonnage 6y agoYou can't wave away taking care of kids as "personal obligations", as though it was akin to doing laundry or something. Also, "I chose not to" is a silly statement - do you think all the parents looked into a crystal ball and thought yes, despite the oncoming pandemic, I will have these kids"?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ethanwillis 6y agoThey get the perk of more flexibility because they're providing a service to society, raising children for the next generation. You don't get this perk because you didn't have children. Your contribution is more work because you have more time to do it.
- nicbou 6y agoThis argument is made again and again in this thread, and it never got addressed. 1. There are already functional mechanisms for contribution. A single, childless person is already contributing more through their taxes. The government already heavily subsidises child-rearing. 2. Child-rearing is given an arbitrary pass that other equally charitable actions wouldn't get. A single, childless person couldn't let his commitment to Doctors Without Borders affect his work performance. 3. I'm not sure if "children are our future" is our future. This model might not be viable forever as the world population keeps growing. This is a whole other can of worms.
- jdm2212 6y ago1. Government subsidies don't cover anything close to the cost of raising a child. 2. Child-rearing is a thing tens of millions of people actually do interleaved with full-time work, and has to be addressed by high-level decision makers. There are lots of hypothetical things a specific individual might want to do that maybe have high social utility, and that's an interesting question for them to sort out with their manager and isn't really relevant to how parents are treated. 3. A stable population -- not growing -- requires a little over 2 children per woman, and the US fertility rate is waaaay below that right now.
- leetcrew 6y agothere's no inherent need for a growing, or even stable, population. this is only a rough proxy for having a sufficiently productive working population to support those who can't work or have retired without undue hardship.
- ethanwillis 6y ago1. If you don't want to pay taxes don't be part of society. The government subsidizes child rearing because it should. But it also doesn't fully cover the cost. 2. It's not an arbitrary pass. A childless person's commitment to Doctors Without Borders is much more flexible than a parent's commitment to a living a human. 3. The world population is only really growing in less developed countries. But it doesn't matter because if you have too many people they will either die because the system can't support them. Or the system will innovate to be able to support them.
- leetcrew 6y ago> The government subsidizes child rearing because it should. why exactly? generally, it is rational to subsidize things that society does not have enough of and tax things that we have too much of. are we currently not producing enough children? this is not necessarily implied by birthrates being below the replacement rate.
- a-nikolaev 6y ago
- randyrand 6y agopeople have children for selfish reasons, not because of some responsibility to society. That’s just hogwash.
- ethanwillis 6y agoI never said they have children because of responsibility to society.
- Rapzid 6y ago> They get the perk of more flexibility because they're providing a service to society From companies? The market doesn't care about all that. It's supply and demand. If parents get "perks" from companies it's because the companies need to provide them to attract workers(on the whole).
- ethanwillis 6y agoThe market is separate from legislation. Of course without society existing and in a purely rational economic scenario the "market" and "companies" would only provide these "perks" to attract workers. Society does in fact mediate the purely rational economic incentives and companies thus don't act purely rationally, nor are they society in and of themselves. America isn't the best about it relative to European countries but even here in the U.S. the FMLA bars employers from dropping employees just because they're pregnant or having a kid.
- jdm2212 6y agoSomeone has to provide the goods and services you'll consume when you're old. Those people are today's kids, whose parents are doing you a big favor at considerable expense to themselves. Raising children isn't like smoking, a hobby, a side hustle, or other miscellaneous personal obligations. It's more like military service and jury duty -- an essential service that some people perform to ensure that society as we know it can continue to exist. And one which employers can, should, and often do make special allowances for.
- nickff 6y agoExcept that the children disproportionately benefit the parents (unlike jury duty or military service). This is a heads-parents-win, tails-childless-lose scenario. Your comment would be completely correct if the children ceased all communications and transactions with the parent upon entry into the labor force; but that's not what happens.
- polishdude20 6y agoWell in proportion to the time the parents spend with the kids vs the time you are inconvenienced by them spending time with their kids balances out. Of course they will have a huge benefit from raising their kids. They raised them. But you will also have a benefit from the small temporary hassle it gives you during these times.
- nickff 6y agoI am not saying that parents do not deserve attention from their children, I am only making the point that the proposed benefits are disproportionately beneficial to parents.
- polishdude20 6y agoI'm saying they are proportionally beneficial to the parents if the portion of time they spend with their kids is drastically higher than the portion of time you are inconvenienced by that act.
- tylerhou 6y agoParents chose to have children with the assumption that childcare, schooling, etc. would exist. Almost no everyday citizen could have predicted that there would be a pandemic that would bring those services down for 1+ years. Life during COVID is not what parents expected (or reasonably could have expected) when they chose to have children.
- nicbou 6y agoI agree with you. I was thinking about remote work in the long, but this was hidden in the last paragraph. > However, if this arrangement is to last, then childless employees should also get time for their personal obligations, whatever they might be.
- Cd00d 6y agoI think you'd benefit by looking into the difference between "equality" and "equity".
- kelnos 6y agoI think if this arrangement were to continue for multiple years, the likely new deal would be for parents to shift to part-time work where possible, with accompanying cultural changes such that their new situation won't turn that into a complete career dead-end. It will mean lower pay, fewer raises, and longer stretches between promotions, but it won't mean being treated less seriously from a professional development perspective. Parents who would usually pay for child care will have extra money to help offset the wage cut. Parents who would usually rely on public services for child care will require additional effort to accommodate. Meanwhile, non-parents will just work normal full-time jobs and get raises and promotions at their usual cadence, and it'll be more or less status quo. The issue now is that we're not expecting this to go on for multiple years, and are hoping that things will go back to some semblance of normal sometime early- to mid-next year (whether that comes to pass or not is irrelevant; the expectation is what matters). With that thinking, you can expect solutions to problems to be blunt and short-term, not well-thought-out policy changes and cultural shifts that in the best of times can take years to work out and transition to. And because they're blunt and short-term, they are going to have rough edges, as we're seeing here.
- Viliam1234 6y agoAs a parent, I would love to have an opportunity to work part-time. Suppose I work 3 days a week, and my wife works 2 days a week, we can arrange those days so that each day someone can be with kids. (It might hypothetically even be 3 days + 3 days if one of the jobs would allow Saturdays.) Working 3/5 time for 3/5 salary would feel fair towards my colleagues. (Many of us work on multiple projects at the same time, so from the project perspective, there would be little difference between being 3 days there and 2 days on another project, vs being 3 days there and 2 days off.) Unfortunately, in most companies this is not an option. Full time (and be happy if this doesn't include overtime) or go away. And I can't afford to go away.
- brd529 6y ago100% this. I do believe that a lot of two-job families would love for one or both parents to go part time. This way one parent doesn't have to 'give up' their career. Some generic advice I give to new grads which I never considered until I had kids was to seriously consider a medical profession because it is well-paying AND has a strong culture of part-time where shift work is the norm. I've seen parents who negotiate hard for three days a week get it, but they are quickly 'mommy tracked' and stop getting promotions. Additionally when a crisis at work happens on their off day, they still get the call. I think a tech company that figures out how to make part-time jobs work culturally will have a huge recruiting and talent advantage, especially this year. I haven't seen it pulled off yet though.
- bsder 6y ago> Some generic advice I give to new grads which I never considered until I had kids was to seriously consider a medical profession because it is well-paying AND has a strong culture of part-time where shift work is the norm. I'm going to ask you to clarify this. In my experience, medical professions are LOUSY for "part time". You are on horribly long shifts. They move around continuously. You have no control over your shifts until you get to a very significant level of seniority. And, right now, you're on the front lines of a pandemic. The only advantage to something like nursing (at least it used to be) is that no matter where your spouse is, you will have work.
- betterunix2 6y agoPerspective from someone with a child (1.25 years old): When my wife and I chose to have a kid, there was absolutely no reason to think that we would have any difficulty finding a nanny/daycare or that we would have to try to work in the same environment that our son is playing in. When COVID-19 restrictions went into effect, we had basically no notice that we would be expected to work from home full time, that our building's common areas would all be closed a few days later, that our nanny would be unable to make the commute (no license should not have been in issue in NYC) and that daycares would all be closed exactly when we needed to find one, etc. We had to move just to get an extra room that could be used as an "office," because working from the kitchen table is impossible when a baby wants to crawl up to you, pull himself into a standing position, and grab whatever you are "playing" with. Even with the extra room, we still have trouble. Our son walks (and runs) now and is beginning to understand how doorknobs work, but he still has no concept of leaving us alone to do our work. If he has the chance to run into our office he will, and if he does not he sometimes bangs on the door and cries when nobody opens it. Either way it is a huge distraction that makes it much harder to get anything done. Try explaining to a toddler that mommy and daddy are working and see how far you get. We also continue to see chaos with our childcare arrangements, which takes its toll on productivity. Your side hustle is optional and can be put on hold. When you already have kids you cannot stop being a parent and children cannot be paused. I agree that employers should give people time for "personal obligations," and in fact mine does and my boss has been using that time to check in on elderly parents, but the fact is that parenting is one of the few 24x7 personal obligations. It is not like I can say that I am setting aside one day a week or two hours per day to be a parent. As hard as it is to deal with a toddler while trying to work, it is harder for parents who are being told that they must supervise their children's schoolwork. It is easy to forget that part of the job of a teacher is to watch over the kids in their classroom and ensure they are not just goofing off all day, but with kids doing "school from home" that is now the job of their parents. Again, it comes down to having someone else there to take on that job while parents are working, and again it is not a question of time and it is not something optional that people can put on hold until the crisis is over. Basically there is no way to make any of this sustainable. COVID restrictions make childcare arrangements more difficult and less reliable, but those gaps must be filled and in the end it is parents who have to fill them (if someone else could do so, then it would not be a 'gap').
- tptacek 6y agoIt is not reasonable to compare smokers to parents. Your irritation at smokers is reasonable, but it doesn't translate automatically to other categories of employee.
- chii 6y agoBut the irritation is at the outcome, not at the action. the OP has no irritation regarding the smoker, or the parent. It's at the irritation that certain actions are treated differently to others by the employer and is indirectly costing OP.
- adrr 6y agoI wonder if OP doesn’t believe in paid family leave like maternity or paternity leave. Or is irritated that new moms get to pump multiple times a day which is longer than any smoke break.
- wmsiler 6y ago>they chose to have children, and I chose not to Up until the pandemic, my work schedule had almost never been affected by me being parent in any way. I chose to have kids knowing that my wife and I would be able to continue working without this significantly impacting our jobs (after the first several weeks after they were born, of course), and that has always been true until this. You are acting as though parents fully understood the pandemic would happen and would affect them at the time they decided to become parents. This argument is like saying that a storm knocked down your neighbor's house, but not yours. So it's unfair that your neighbor get some leniency from work while he tries to repair it while you are expected to keep working. "He chose to build his house on that side of the street, so he has to deal with the consequences." This isn't about giving extra slack to parents. It's about giving extra slack to people who were hit particularly hard by this situation that they couldn't possibly have seen coming. I was forced to return to the office even though I'd rather be at home. I have a coworker with no kids but who takes care of his mother who is very sick and at high risk for COVID. He gets to keep working from home, which is what I'd like to do. It's never crossed my mind to be annoyed with him for that.
- gones00n 6y agoThere's risk in every major life decision, including having kids. I hope I'm not coming off as anti-children but while parents couldn't have anticipated the pandemic and its impact, they need to react to the circumstances. If their home situation requires it, then they should switch to part-time or even quit temporarily. I also agree with giving parents "extra slack", though again there are limits. At this rate the pandemic will remain with us for another year. The onus is probably in company leadership to make the necessary changes and not have colleagues start to resent one another.
- siquick 6y ago>> I hope I'm not coming off as anti-children but while parents couldn't have anticipated the pandemic and its impact, they need to react to the circumstances. If their home situation requires it, then they should switch to part-time or even quit temporarily. Putting a family units safety and wellbeing should be a last resort solution. Major disruptions in a kids early life can have seriously negative effects on their future.
- nemo44x 6y agoWe should prioritize people with children. The entire biological point of your life is to reproduce and we should value this. If you can’t reproduce (for a variety of reasons) but you take care of a child then this should be valued just the same. Society should prioritize people with children to raise instead of having a nihilistic philosophy of “ain’t my problem”. The social benefit of well raised children benefits all. There are no benefits to having you get equal time off. You’re only serving yourself, not society. Btw - smokers got to go outside to have a smoke break because we banned smoking from inside. Before that a smoke break didn’t exist. So it’s a trade off. Smokers stop creating second hand smoke in exchange for us tolerating them getting a “break” to feed their nicotine addiction so they can function. Cigarettes are legal and taxes are collected - we should tolerate them getting time to service their addiction so the rest of us don’t have to breath it.
- LudwigNagasena 6y ago> The entire biological point of your life is to reproduce There is no biological point of anyone’s life. This is nonsensical, it is also extremely offensive both to childless by choice and, especially, to infertile people.
- nemo44x 6y agoI’m not trying to insult anyone but just stating an objective fact - life exists to reproduce life. Weak life dies out and strong life continues until it too is superseded. Evolution is a thing. Look outside and you see it everywhere. I’m not a biological essentialist but I also won’t deny this simple fact that binds humans to plants - we exist to generate new variations of ourselves. It doesn’t mean someone who won’t or can’t have children can’t contribute to humanity in a range of ways for their lives are just as worthy. But regardless if you choose to not or can not have children, this biological imperative has not selected you and your DNA will die with you. That’s just a fact.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoIt makes no sense to jump from this statement >Weak life dies out and strong life continues until it too is superseded. Evolution is a thing. Look outside and you see it everywhere. To this >life exists to reproduce life You make a logical leap when you change "we generate new variations of ourselves" to "we exist to generate new variations of ourselves." >It doesn’t mean someone who won’t or can’t have children can’t contribute to humanity in a range of ways for their lives are just as worthy. But regardless if you choose to not or can not have children, this biological imperative has not selected you and your DNA will die with you. That’s just a fact. Exactly. So it is as meaningless and wrong as saying that the point of a falling ball is to hit the floor and bounce or that the point of the sun is to become a red giant. There is no "point", it is just a fact that will happen.
- Cd00d 6y agoHonestly curious, what are these "personal obligations" that are similar to educating and entertaining children during their waking hours in dual-career homes after childcare and in-person school went poof? What I'm seeing overall is a shocking lack of empathy for that situation and seeing home-parenting obligations during a pandemic as not being too dissimilar from taking time to binge Tiger King or take a road trip.
- anonymoushn 6y agoIf someone's spouse is having a mental health crisis, dealing with that during work hours is not generally permitted, because a spouse is not a child.
- Cd00d 6y agoI'll admit that I'm not at all familiar with legal obligations to medical conditions for employers. However, anyone dealing with a "crisis", and also more explicitly a "mental health crisis", should not be punished in their job, esp during everyone-remote-pandemic-time (though overall, but I have had pretty cushy jobs since joining industry). Maybe you have a specific example where the "adult, not child" thing mattered in a crisis, but that would make me very disappointed with my company, with HR, and compel me to start doing my best to look elsewhere for more empathic colleagues.
- anonymoushn 6y agoI don't particularly want to post about my employer today.
- kelnos 6y agoThat type of thing is generally acute, not chronic. If someone needs to duck out of work on short notice for the rest of the day to help a spouse in crisis, that absolutely should be generally permitted, and I think most tech employers would be ok with that. If this crisis required the employee to take several weeks off, it would require scrambling and maybe require some unpaid leave, but it would get done. But that has nothing to do with what's going on now. We have a chronic situation where parents need to take care of their kids all day, every day, for every week and month that this pandemic shuts down schools and other child care services. You can't address this with an afternoon off or temporary leave of absence. This requires a complete change in expectations. You can't pause child care for 8 hours while mom and dad work. You can't even pause it for 30 minutes.
- hajimemash 6y agoWouldn't this amount to basically working less hours effectively? Maybe that's the real issue here- the majority of people are forced to devote 80% of their weekdays on work and chores (10hrs work+commute, 30 min lunch at work but personal time ie unpaid, 1hr dinner+relax, 30-60min misc chores = 3.5-4hrs out of 16hr day remaining). This seems insane to me but everyone seems to put up with it
- dclowd9901 6y agoWhile I think your argument is specious at best, your point is salient. I‘m a parent and have several co workers who do not have children, and I push them —- have to push them —- to take time off. I think there’s a lot going on here: * parents need more time to care for their kids * parents feel guilty for the time off they’re taking * non parent workers might feel some resentment, but probably not overtly * non parent workers probably feel like they need to pick up the slack Let’s be real here: very few of us are doing anything of actual consequence. Your job is not important. Your job is not you and you are not your job. Take as much time as you need, and if your company or your boss doesn’t get it, leave. I’ll fucking hire you.
- nicbou 6y agoI wrote the parent comment to flesh out my own thoughts. As I wrote it, I kept wanting to write what you put in the last paragraph. In reality, none of us work 8 hours a day, and if someone slacks off, we'll push the deadline and go home. In real reality, I'm self-employed and none of this matters. I just found that it was something interesting to discuss.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edoloughlin 6y agoThat being said, they chose to have children, and I chose not to Do you have a retirement plan and do you want a return on it? Guess who'll generate that return: other people's children. childless employees should also get time for their personal obligations That's a tricky one. Is your paragliding trip an investment that will generate future value for society?
- kelnos 6y ago> That being said, they chose to have children, and I chose not to. I don't think we should disadvantage parents because they failed to take into account the possibility of a once-in-a-century pandemic when planning their family. This reads as "oh, don't want to have extreme work+family stress during a global pandemic? Don't choose to have kids!" > Whatever I have going on instead can't have priority over my work schedule. Whether it's a side hustle or a little league baseball team, it has to wait. You're mistaking wants with needs. Child care isn't optional. Parents don't want to take time away from their workday to care for their kids right now, but they have to. You can't just stick a 5 year old in a room and be like "mommy/daddy has grown-up stuff to do, see you in 8 hours, try not to kill yourself, and oh, learn how to feed yourself as well". Your side hustle or baseball team are things you want to do, and can easily wait until the weekend or after hours. Child care is something that must be done, all day long, every day, whether someone wants to or not at any given moment. > However, if this arrangement is to last, then childless employees should also get time for their personal obligations, whatever they might be. Childless people don't have work-hours personal obligations unless they choose to. And I expect any employer, under normal times, to frown upon anyone, parent or non-parent, who tries to get out of work due to personal obligations they've intentionally set up to conflict with work. As a non-parent, I have exactly the same amount of time for my personal obligations as I did pre-COVID. COVID has not given me new required responsibilities during work hours, but parents have gotten that in spades. If you do have a new COVID-related responsibility that needs to be taken care of during work hours (like caring for an at-risk relative), then I think your employer should give you some extra flexibility as well. But your side hustle or little league team is a luxury that didn't need to intersect with work hours pre-COVID, and doesn't need to do so now.
- cseleborg 6y agoThis rhetoric of parents having made the choice to have children and its underlying assumption that we shouldn't complain quite as loudly now really makes me cringe. At the very least, it's worth noting that 100% of people promoting this argument are someone else's children. One only has the privilege of participating in the debate because someone else became a parent. Having children can be a choice in the implementation details like when, how many etc. and at the same time a benefit to, and a necessity for, society in the grand scheme of things. I don't expect praise or a medal for having children, but I do expect support and recognition. The same argument, by the way, goes to other caregivers and professions with a comparable contribution to society as a whole. But let's turn to another question instead. Is the way we think about productivity, compensation and performance still appropriate now that we've transitioned from business-as-usual world to a global battlefield of sorts with all its chaos, unpredictability and lack of controllability? What would happen if "best effort" replaced "highest return" going forward? I'm sure there are tons of other questions that could help challenge our current thinking and move the needle on making the world a better place. That would feel like an appropriate middle finger gesture towards The Virus, wouldn't it?