10 ms·
> But it wasn’t strictly an “everything is bigger in Texas” ethos that caused Houston to sprawl the way that it does. Rather, Cold War–era urban design philosop
by xg15 6y ago
> But it wasn’t strictly an “everything is bigger in Texas” ethos that caused Houston to sprawl the way that it does. Rather, Cold War–era urban design philosophy in the U.S. prioritized sprawl because older cities that had urbanized pre–World War II—New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, and Detroit—were seen as being susceptible to nuclear strikes. Less-dense cities such as Los Angeles and Houston were less likely to be targeted for a nuclear attack. Sprawl was a deterrent against Soviet aggression.
That's the first time I've heard this theory.
Would that have worked though? I don't know much about nuclear deterrence, but I'd imagine if the USSR already managed to evade the defenses and other obstacles and destroy the city center in a nuclear strike, it wouldn't be a lot of additional effort to send multiple rockets instead of only one and also target the suburbs.
Not to mention that fallout, breakdown of infrastructure, disease and hunger that followed a strike would affect the entire city in any case.
- teachrdan 6y agoPart of this is brinkmanship. Even if there was no practical way this would improve even short-term survivability, if the Soviets believed that the US believed this would work, that would be enough to show the US would not be cowed by their nuclear arsenal. It was also a way to reassure US citizens that we were not completely vulnerable to nuclear annihilation. Same with backyard fallout shelters and teaching schoolchildren to hide from nuclear explosions under their school desks--the original school shooter drills.
- r00fus 6y agoBrinkmanship or security theatre?
- 1propionyl 6y agoOr option C: greed. Any way you slice it, nuclear deterrence, missile defense, containment theory and more generally any initiative motivated by the fear of imminent nuclear holocaust and the Red Menace were huge windfalls for industrial corporations from the end of WWII onward. It was an effective way to siphon huge amounts of money from the postwar federal coffers for corporations that had made bank during the war, but were now left to justify why the government should continue shoveling money at them. Now, this may not be the case for Houston's interchanges in particular, but it was certainly the case for many such endeavors going forward for decades. See also: SDI ("Star Wars"). And of course, there were other factors like suburbanization/white flight and the ascendant automobile industry. But all of these potential motivators were (are?) very entangled and hard to fully extricate from one another.
- BucketsMcG 6y agoFor what it's worth, the same thinking was behind the new capital of Myanmar, Naypyidaw. Paranoid military leadership who thought Yangon was too vulnerable to attack, so built a new capital way inland which is massively spread out to make it harder to bomb.
- dylan604 6y agoSuch a weak argument as we (as humans) just got better at bombing things. More planes + more bombs = problem solved. "You build a bigger shield, we just build a bigger bomb" mentality has to be a core tenet of the military industrial complex.
- imtringued 6y agoActually, modern warframe is all about completing missions while using less bombs and planes. Killing residents may cripple the economy of your enemy but finding the high value targets and only bombing those is cheaper and more effective.
- jackpirate 6y agoI've also never heard this claim before despite quite a bit of work on nuclear weapons policy. I've asked a question about it on /r/AskHistorians to get more clarification: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/ik1v9q/a_recent_news_article_claims_that_cities_like_la/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/ik1v9q/a_rec...
- sudosysgen 6y agoI'm very doubtful it would have worked. The USSR had thousands of warheads, they could turn the entirety of every city into glass. I'm even quite doubtful this was a consideration.
- rsynnott 6y agoThis sounds fairly dubious. There was a period between sub-megatonne pure fission warheads being standard and multi-megatonne 'hydrogen' ones, but it was under a decade. That seems like a very narrow window to change how cities were planned.
- dylan604 6y agoUrban sprawl happened because people were tired of living on top of each other, and cities that had the room to expand used it. There was also another name used for that sprawl, white flight. I think we're seeing some of the results of that today.
- reddog 6y agoI've always thought it was funny how whites moving from the city to the suburbs is bad (white flight) and whites moving from the suburbs to the city is also bad (gentrification).
- jonsno56 6y agoWell yes, it goes to show that you can find an abundance of systemic racism against black people in all kinds of housing policy.
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt makes logical sense. You cause problem A by leaving, and then in coming back you cause problem B. The same thing happened with the Iraq War -- we caused lots of problems with the unnecessary invasion, then caused more problems by leaving. It's lose/lose. The only winning move was never to play. In the white flight analogy, the only winning move was never to seek segregation from moving out of the cities in the first place.
- dmurray 6y agoIn the same way, global warming is bad, but global cooling would be much worse. It's climate change that's the problem, disrupting human patterns that we've got used to.
- badrabbit 6y agoThat would be a lot of ICBMs. The city center is not residential. Most people that work in the city center for city's like houston or LA commute from one of many different cities. Just to wipe out half of houston you would need to simultaneously strike at least a dozen different locations. The idea was, if there is a missile on the way or if other cities are being attacked, the sprawl would allow evacuating a lot of people. I do think it is an effective strategy. Look at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, tokyo and kyoto were spared for different reasons but they were spared. No sense in wiping out every single city. For the US, a nuclear attack would probably be against symbolic populated cities like new york, san francisco or chicago, ideally the US would surrender after that point and if there is no surrender, military targets would make more sense (hawaii,san diego,san antonio,anapolis,etc...). The idea is, if you have a small number of targets to defend you can defend them better. Just like with infosec, you want to reduce attack surface so you minimize exposed services or inputs.
- cgriswald 6y agoSparing Tokyo worked because Japan didn’t have the capability to retaliate. Any launching during the mid-to-late Cold War would have been a massive first strike and possibly a retaliation at the same scale. In the early Cold War it may have been a reasonable strategy, but as another poster notes that’s a very narrow window for changing how a city grows. Even if there was an effect, I’d be very surprised if the signal wasn’t wiped out first by railroads and then by cars.
- csomar 6y agoA typical nuclear bomb has a wipe-out radius of 1-2 Km. At 10-15Km radius, you are looking at damages/injuries but not a complete wipe-out. Also residential houses are less susceptible to infrastructure breakdown vs. a high-res building.
- kiliantics 6y agoI think it's more likely the combined factors of automotive industry lobbying and redlining/white flight that led to the level of urban sprawl you see in the US
- 7952 6y agoThere is also the risk of fire storms being started that destroy a wider area than the initial blast.
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt's one of those hackneyed theories that has a grain of truth in it, but nothing more. Yes, perhaps fear of being nuked drove some people from the cities, but what actually drove a lot more people from the cities was racism, plain and simple. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight That, a lot more than fear of nuclear war, is what drove suburbanization, along with the rising spending power of the middle class that made a detached home in the suburbs and a car achievable on a single salary.
- ctoth 6y agoI remember Heinlein talking a lot about the decentralization of cities concept. A bit of googling leads me to Sumner Spaulding, who was apparently a large proponent of decentralization to avoid nuclear disaster. http://otworld.weebly.com/robert-a-heinlein-the-last-days-of-the-united-states.html http://otworld.weebly.com/robert-a-heinlein-the-last-days-of...
- MrMorden 6y agoAlso City by Clifford Simak.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoNope. Sprawl happens in places where the oil industry runs city planning. Plus, if people cant survive in your city without a car, then that kills off the poor too and drives them away. So cities sprawl to serve oil companies and to exacerbate wealth inequality. What, you people dont believe me? You seriously think we sprawl to protect ourselves from nukes? Like the enemy isnt just going to launch more nukes, or cluster nukes? If anything, the sprawl would just make the nuclear strike worse, because there's a greater chance you'll survive and have to live through revelation. Here's how you protect yourself if a nuke is on the way: you duck your head down, and kiss your ass goodbye. No it's just plain ole racist, classist, corrupt government trying to use fear of Russians to drive oblivious americans who dont pay attention, to buy more cars from their rich motor company friends. That government is mostly in the past now, but the sprawl is a monument to their philosophy, which was racist, classist and corrupt.
- rexgallorum2 6y agoI would argue the bomb was only part of it though--the other hazard was area bombing. All of those planners had seen (or participated in) the aerial bombardment of Europe and Japan during the war, and one take-away was that areas with different uses should be separated (like in the sim game Cities Skylines), e.g. industrial zones should be separate from residential zones, and all of the above should be as sprawling and low-density as possible to minimise damage from the air, be it nuclear or conventional. And yes the US highway system started out as a civil defense project as well, modelled on the German 'Autobahnen'.
- duxup 6y agoI don't doubt someone thought of / would like that idea... but I have trouble believing sprawl really was influenced by some plan involving nuclear strikes. Yeah you'd have a good chance of having more survivors due to the nature of nuclear weapons, but I don't see that influencing choices like wanting to have a suburban home and etc.
- gambiting 6y agoIt wouldn't have. In case of an all out war each side would send dozens if not hundreds of rockets at each target. US in particular had the problem where each arm of the military(airforce, army, navy and missile command) had their own and completely independent launch plans. So each one would launch their own compliment of nukes at Russian cities. Destruction of your own missiles by the already exploding weapons was actually seen as a significant issue that would lead to loss of many if not majority of weapons. Eric Schlosser's Command and Control is, as always, a great read about this.
- mcguire 6y agoU.S. Strategic Nuclear Forces: Background,Developments, and Issues (https://fas.org/sgp/crs/nuke/RL33640.pdf https://fas.org/sgp/crs/nuke/RL33640.pdf). The US Army hasn't had strategic nuclear weapons in a very long time, if ever. On the other hand, theater-level weapons like the Pershing (10s (mostly) to 100s of kt) do a pretty fair approximation. I'm not sure what you mean by "missile command"; Army Missile Command mostly has problems, not solutions. (They build things.) (Standard Missile 3! (https://images.wisegeek.com/billboard-ad-against-blue-sky.jpg) https://images.wisegeek.com/billboard-ad-against-blue-sky.jp...)
- rtkwe 6y agoIn the beginning stages of the Cold War and the start of urban sprawl the threat wasn't rockets but bombers. ICBMs weren't created till '57 and took over the strategic setup for killing everyone in the years after that, so there's a window there for sprawl to be a legit(ish) survival/mitigation strategy.
- siliconvalley1 6y agoWith that advent of MIRVs it makes most of this moot. A single missile could have a dozen warheads and you can blanket target massive areas.
- djsumdog 6y agoLet's take a look at Houston on a Nuke Map: https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=5000&lat=29.7589&lng=-95.3677&hob_psi=5&hob_ft=17519&ff=50&psi=20,5,1&zm=10 https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=5000&lat=29.7589&lng...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hannasanarion 6y agoThat's a modern bomb, in the 50s and early 60s, when Hobby Airport (the one in the southeast of downtown) was considered to be in the boonies, the nuclear threat looked like this: https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=20&lat=29.7589&lng=-95.3677&hob_opt=2&hob_psi=5&hob_ft=1650&psi=20,5,1&zm=13 https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=20&lat=29.7589&lng=-...
- simonh 6y ago5 Mt is huge, and far bigger than the warheads of most modern nuclear weapons. The one you show is fairly representative of a single modern warhead. Nowadays, and for many decades if you want a large area of effect, you use a MIRV vehicle and pepper the target area. This gives you wide coverage for fewer total megatons and a more compact and flexible weapon system, and hedges your bets in case any of the warheads fails or is intercepted. In fact big bombs were an early trend for two reasons. One was that the delivery system was expected to be bombers dropping one or a very few bombs with mediocre accuracy and so you wanted maximum destruction from each delivery. The other was that they were worried bombers wouldn't be able to get directly over some targets due to air defences, so you'd drop the bomb short of the target and use the massive area of effect to cover the remaining distance for you.
- mcguire 6y ago9MT W53 (Titan II warhead): Fireball covers downtown Houston, moderate damage out to the borders of Houston proper, 50% chance of 3rd degree burns as far as Sugar Land or Humble. https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=9000&lat=29.7500709&lng=-95.3681946&hob_psi=5&hob_ft=21310&ff=50&therm=_3rd-50&zm=10 https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=9000&lat=29.7500709&...
- jcrawfordor 6y agoAs a decidedly amateur historian with interest in this area, I think that claim is true on its own but also does not tell the entire story. It is true that decentralization was viewed as a major component of nuclear survivability, particularly in the earlier part of the cold war. This was the time period during which the FEMA (today's name) crisis relocation program was being devised, for example, and the high cost and complexity of crisis relocation (which, in an earlier form, was a major motivation for the Eisenhower freeway system, to the extent that it's probably fair to say that it was the main motivation with materiel movement as a second) served to highlight the inherent vulnerability of dense cities and keep it very much in the minds of government planners. Decentralized cities had an inherent advantage to planners in that money could be saved on crisis relocation efforts. Of course the crisis relocation program was never fully implemented, but the way of thinking was fairly influential. The federal government had an enormous role in suburbanization of US cities in many, many ways, which is actually part of what makes it hard to address this point. Support for suburbanization was not coming just (or even primarily) from FEMA, all kinds of federal agencies had a hand. Much of the urban renewal work of the 20th century took the effective form of relocating poor people to the suburbs and replacing their inner-city housing with industrial/commercial/transport, for example the Model Cities program of the late '60s. This was in part a result of the general feeling that the inner city was where poor people lived and so improving their economic situation required getting them out of it, part of it was merely the practical issue that substantially improving a dense area is a lot more expensive than razing it and build something new there. I don't know if these programs were strongly influenced by crisis planning, they probably were at least in part, but it seems unlikely that crisis planning was a much bigger influence in federal advocacy of suburbanization than the more organic trends of white flight and urban decay that came out of a set of race and class relations, in a potent combination with some simple budget and timeline considerations. My point is that nuclear planning was a factor, but the massive suburbanization of the postwar decades originated from many factors out of which nuclear crisis planning was only one, and I'm not convinced that it was one of the bigger ones in the end. Yes, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists very openly advocated for suburbanization of cities and that view was influential, but at the same time so much of suburbanization was motivated by a new vision of the American dream that came out of the peculiarities of post-war economics and demographics, racism, the radical popularity of the automobile (which not only enabled low-density areas but often required the destruction of high-density areas to provide freeway access to business districts), and probably at least a few other things. Any claim that "urban sprawl is a result of x" where X isn't a list of things is probably pretty hard to defend. A complete change in not just urban planning but people's patterns of life tends to require a confluence of factors.
- Animats 6y agoIt was real enough that IBM moved their corporate HQ from Manhattan to Armonk, NY. HQ is still there.
- donjoe 6y agoQuite interestingly, the social aspects of urban sprawl was completely left out when designing post WW2 cities. When people think about beautiful cities, they would mention Venice or Paris or Rome. All these cities were built for 'foot traffic' which still works perfectly fine nowadays. In those cities, the elderly and children do have an environment to move around by themselves and socialize freely. When it comes to planning cities for people, it is worth checking out Prof. Jan Gehl: https://youtu.be/9_x5Hor2MP8 https://youtu.be/9_x5Hor2MP8
- LoSboccacc 6y ago> still works perfectly fine nowadays. Rome is all but working perfectly fine, with commuter traffic locked almost daily by the tiniest fender bender happening on the highway around it Venice is likewise a mess, situation was so bas they built an highway to go around the existing highway that corrected it to the nearby areas, and the lack of easy mobility in the city center is fuelling a severe living cost inflation
- ramshorns 6y agoThat sounds like a car problem, not a problem with cities built for foot traffic.
- LoSboccacc 6y agoand how are you supposed to go to work on foot? neither the job nor the house market is flexible enough, especially now that airbnb 'disrupted' traditional renting in touristic cities.
- donjoe 6y agoYah, bcs all new structures built post WW2 were built for cars and not for people people move at 3mph, not 60mph. Rome could have invested in public transport instead of building highways. No one would be stuck in traffic. Instead, they used public space for cars. The old parts of the city though which are walkable work perfectly fine. Venice does have great ferry service and traffic in the city is almost non-existent due to lack of cars.
- RobLach 6y agoWith all claims like this, it’s rarely the case that these decisions were made on the basis of a claim like that but it was used in a compendium or arguments for whatever policy. If you’re a pro-car lobbyist for example, you might as well throw something like that in as it strengthens your case.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- csommers 6y agoI don’t believe it. They had MIRVs even back then. There’s no difference in density between .5 miles and 15 miles. You’re fucked either way with: direct impact, over pressure, and radiation/fallout. This sounds like some armchair theory.
- konjin 6y ago>Would that have worked though? I don't know much about nuclear deterrence, but I'd imagine if the USSR already managed to evade the defenses and other obstacles and destroy the city center in a nuclear strike, it wouldn't be a lot of additional effort to send multiple rockets instead of only one and also target the suburbs. The USSRs guidance computers were quite bad, and reentry would have scattered multiple payloads without those. Having talked to people in the programs from before the iron curtain fell they got around this problem by building larger bombs so the radius of destruction was larger than the radius of uncertainty around a target, to the point that dead-reckoning was viable. The maximum bomb size the USSR designed on top of Huston: https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=100000&lat=29.7589&lng=-95.3677&hob_psi=5&hob_ft=47553&ff=52&psi=20,5,1&zm=9 https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=100000&lat=29.7589&l... In short, were the USSR serious about dealing with urban sprawl it wouldn't have taken much effort to build weapons that could vaporize Huston sized cities.
- runamok 6y agoI do recall a population distribution map of the USSR vs. the US from a book I owned 30iah years ago and they were far more evenly distributed than the US.
- rauhl 6y ago> That's the first time I've heard this theory. More than just a theory. When we were clearing out my grandparents’ house we found a pamphlet (I think it was Civil Defence, but it could have been a different agency) which was basically the paper equivalent of a government-issued FAQ about nuclear war. From my own 2020 knowledge of what they knew then, it was remarkably good stuff, written for a general audience. I remember reading it and thinking that the mockery we have for ‘Duck & Cover’ really isn’t fair, at least with respect to this pamphlet: it didn’t claim that a desk would protect at ground zero, but did (correctly) note that the harmful effects of a bomb decrease over distance. I think it was from late-40s to early-50s. I recall that one of its points was that tightly-packed cities had been susceptible to the conventional bombing campaigns of the Second World War and would be even more susceptible to nuclear bombs, and consequently it made sense to spread cities out. > if the USSR already managed to evade the defenses and other obstacles and destroy the city center in a nuclear strike, it wouldn't be a lot of additional effort to send multiple rockets instead of only one and also target the suburbs. Well, it would be superlinear: if you imagine a hex grid of blast radii, the centre radius is one, the inner ring is six (cumulative seven); the next ring is is twelve (cumulative 19); the next ring is 24 (cumulative 43), and so on. 1:7, 7:19, 19:43 — it adds up!