15 ms·
Boom Supersonic hopes to test-fly its supersonic plane in 2021
- tim333 6y ago>In less than 50 days, .... Boom Supersonic is planning to show off the XB-1 They're cracking along.
- rvz 6y agoGood. An actual company that is doing something worthy of actually "changing things" which I can get behind.
- crispyambulance 6y agoWell, they're not changing much. It's a ~4 hour savings, max, on a transatlantic flight. Perhaps a passenger ICBM? That would really cut down "across-the-planet" travel time down to a total of ~30 minutes. Why not? the Fantastic Four had one in their Manhattan laboratory (https://www.tumblr.com/search/passenger%20icbm# https://www.tumblr.com/search/passenger%20icbm#).
- rbanffy 6y agoThis is one of the ideas Elon Musk floated as a way to help finance Starship+Superheavy - suborbital passenger flights.
- crispyambulance 6y agoSounds like a good idea. Coffee service will be challenging however!
- rbanffy 6y agoOTOH, vomit bags would be a lot more popular.
- iancmceachern 6y agoI wonder how the current contraction in the airline industry will effect their plans or funding.
- TheRealNGenius 6y agoaffect
- detritus 6y agoIf anything, I'd see the current state of the air industry being in favour of what Boom promise - the [im?]practical concerns of the super-rich are vastly different to those of the rest of us.
- iancmceachern 6y agoI think the super rich would stick with private jets, no?
- mikepurvis 6y agoYeah, even if a private jet (whether owned or chartered) may not be as fast as this, it's going to be way less in terms of overall travel time in most cases, especially if it means you can fly out of non-busy regional airports closer to your origin and destination points.
- ceejayoz 6y agoAt the stated price point of $200M, this isn't out of reach for the super-rich. There are plenty of $100M+ privately owned jets around. (With some hilariously crazy features: https://www.greenpoint.com/747-8-aerolift/ https://www.greenpoint.com/747-8-aerolift/)
- phkahler 6y agoYou may want to read the article.
- 6y ago
- whinvik 6y agoSupersonic flight is easy. Efficient supersonic flight is hard. Aerodynamics, aerostructure, propulsion all of them are trying to break you. Controlling all of them would definitely be an achievement.
- api 6y agoAs far as I know efficiency is what has kept civilian supersonic flight from being a thing. Even military aircraft tend to only go supersonic when needed because it guzzles fuel. My biggest skepticism about Boom is that I don't see them even talking about this issue much. If they can't get big efficiency improvements I see this being a niche toy for the super rich rather than a mainstream transport option. I'm not an expert, but I wonder: can you get large efficiency improvements by going to really extreme altitude where the air is thinner? Maybe that's the long term plan. But as far as I know that may require a novel engine design or the adaptation of military engines, and the latter is a minefield if classification and ITAR regulations. Extreme altitude also means you're dead if you get a major hull breach, but the increased risk there may be statistically mitigated by decreased overall flight time... and it's still going to be safer than driving a car.
- tim333 6y agoExtreme altitude also means there's less air to hold the plane up which seems to require a lot of power for level flight. I'm not sure about ballistic flight paths - a lot of fuel to get up there and then none for a while. Apparently re Musk's old Telas that he launched towards Mars: >It has achieved a fuel economy of 9,886.9 miles per gallon (4,203.4 km/liter, 0.02379 liters/100 km), assuming 126,000 gallons of fuel. https://www.whereisroadster.com/ https://www.whereisroadster.com/ But it's not on a very popular flight route. Should be kinda near Mars Oct 7th.
- GuB-42 6y ago> Extreme altitude also means there's less air to hold the plane up which seems to require a lot of power for level flight. There is also less drag, and both lift and drag are calculated using the same formula: Cl * A * .5 * r * V^2 - Cl (Cx for drag, Cz for lift) is a coefficient depending on the wing shape, among other factors - A is the area (thickness for drag, wing surface for lift) - r is the air density - V is velocity If you divide the air density by 4 by going higher, you get the same lift and drag by going twice as fast. Which is great, and a good reason for fast planes to fly high. The reason it is so great is that in order to fly level, lift cancel gravity and thrust cancel drag. Because by going higher, we managed to keep the same lift and drag with higher speed, it means we got faster using the same amount of thrust. There are certainly complications somewhere. For example at supersonic speeds you get shock drag but suffice to say, high altitude is good for speed. Still there is a good reason why planes don't just get higher to get speed for free. And that's because planes are not rocket powered. Air breathing engines lose efficiency the faster you get, they are also designed to operate at specific speed ranges.
- kevinmchugh 6y agoAre there any other products named for their most famous externalities?
- the-dude 6y agoCockroachDB ? You know what you are getting into : bugs.
- Gravityloss 6y agoI always assumed it was a reference to the resiliency. That it should survive the apocalypse...
- the-dude 6y agoResilient bugs are the worst. Or was that intermittent?
- maltalex 6y agoI think it's named after the joke that says only thing that would survive an apocalypse would be cockroaches and relational databases.
- ape4 6y agoLike naming a computer Heat Dissipation ;)
- repsilat 6y agoThere's a bookie in the UK called "Ladbrokes". It isn't an externality, but it's thematically similar -- a commonly associated negative consequence of the business model.
- tiborsaas 6y agoSteam
- oroup 6y agoSoylent
- kilroy123 6y agoThis is one of my favorite YC companies and I'm really rooting for them. The aviation industry really needs a shakeup and more competition. Boeing has really lost their way.
- mobilefriendly 6y agoI agree but why supersonic passenger jet (a product category with a high profile failure) versus starting with a next-gen regional jet? Or a luxury private jet?
- cwhiz 6y agoPublicity. We're here talking about it because it's supersonic. Same reason Tesla started with the Roadster. Regional jets are boring.
- lumost 6y agoSupersonic passenger jets are currently an untapped market with zero competition. The traditional players have decided it's not a useful market to chase. The technology of a supersonic is also sufficiently different from a sub-sonic jet that it will be tough to chase them once they bring a product to market. Regional jets have been optimized over the better part of a century, are heavily regulated and have heavy competition from incumbent players. Based on the historic gains in commuter flight performance we're likely within 10-20% of the optimum plane configuration for any given market. A new entrant would take ~10 years to bring an aircraft to market, during which time an incumbent could introduce a competing aircraft or simply leverage their existing product lines and sales channels to compete with suboptimal aircraft.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoWho is the market for supersonic travel not already served by military aircraft that can go supersonic and space vehicles that go suborbital? I’m not saying such a market doesn’t exist, but show me these folks with their wallet open for this civil speed.
- vikramkr 6y agoI'm curious to hear more about their carbon neutral/alternative fuel source plan. What sorts of fuels can they use instead of regular jet fuel? Lowering that eco impact would get rid of a big part of the concern people have with these planes (assuming as well that the types of people to fly business/first class aren't price sensitive and wouldn't care about more expensive tickets, which seems reasonable)
- bryanlarsen 6y agoLooks like it'll be these guys supplying the fuel: https://www.prometheusfuels.com/ https://www.prometheusfuels.com/ In a decade or so Boom might be competing with SpaceX, who are planning on using suborbital versions of their Starship rocket for long distance hypersonic passenger transport. Starship runs on methane, which is the easiest hydrocarbon to generate in a carbon neutral format. Methanation is a leading candidate for carbon capture for carbon intensive industries like cement production.
- p1mrx 6y agoWow, that website has impressively terrible UX.
- mobilefriendly 6y agoBusiness travel is lucrative but only like 12% of the air travel market. It seems the market opportunity is a modern Zeppelin, not the next Concorde. An airship that is environmentally efficient, fun to travel on, has plenty of passenger space, and is perceived as safe. Airships could have far more landing sites than traditional aircraft, let alone a plane with a sonic boom. Also the future may feature SpaceX rockets for super fast global transport.
- NationalPark 6y agoI'm guessing the problem with airships is that they're too slow. When they were popular (okay, 100 years ago, some things may have changed) it took multiple days to cross the Atlantic ocean. But who knows, if it's cheap and more comfortable than flying, maybe people will see the trip as part of the experience.
- iso1210 6y agoIf they could do say 1500km at 100km/h, that would offer a great many overnight destinations - get on board, dinner on board, retire to bed, wake up, breakfast over the alps, disembark right into the resort. Certainly beats flying.
- msandford 6y agoOnce your journey gets long enough comfort starts to trump speed for a lot of people, especially if you're taking a vacation. For me that's somewhere in the region of 10+ hours of travel. After that I'll consider it a full day and I'd be very happy to trade 10hrs for 36hrs if I got a lot more comfort. Something more akin to a recliner that I could actually sleep in, enough legroom, a place to put a laptop that wasn't hunched over and awkward and maybe enough room to get up and stretch for more than 3-5min at a time. I don't know if it would be feasible to make a really wide, fat winged lifting body dirigible that you can put a huge amount of solar cells on top of but if you could do that and also make it somehow go ~150mph you're getting pretty close to 1/3 the speed of an airliner with the added advantage that you might not need anywhere near as much fuel. I go from Texas to Florida semi-regularly There's 2-4 hours of pre and post flying travel and sitting around plus about 2-2.5 hours of travel for a total of 4-6 hours of total travel time. If the flying time went to more like 6 hours and you kept the pre and post travel flying times the same it wouldn't make a huge impact on me. I might actually ask if they could slow the "plane" down so that I could make it an overnighter and hopefully get enough sleep!
- nullifidian 6y agoThey don't have a modern supersonic-capable engine as of yet, which is basically a requirement for making progress in supersonic passenger transportation. They have an agreement with Rolls-Royce, but if it doesn't pan out the whole venture might flop, because we basically only have GE and RR as the keepers of the institutional knowledge about cutting-edge engine tech. Also, with the way our culture currently develops, producing tons of excess CO2 for your slightly faster than ordinary business jet or first class business trip might become a very sinful, frowned upon, bad PR thing to do. If anything I see money in making business jets more economical.
- racnid 6y agoDon't forget Pratt and Whitney, they're still a major builder of aviation (jet) engines along with Honeywell and others I'm sure to be forgetting.
- nick_kline 6y agoWhat engine will they use for testing then, what are its limitations? BC they are going > than mach 1. Edit: reread the article, I guess it's not 100% clear if they will go that fast but it's doable with existing jet engines of course, separate from new potential efficient engines.
- numpad0 6y agoIf I’m right, turbine jet engines won’t hold up against supersonic airflow anyway, so intakes has to be cleverly designed so as to feed them with subsonic air of sufficient volume at all speeds. So there might be some wiggle room between engines with sufficient TWR and durability?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Mvandenbergh 6y agoApparently they're targeting mach 2.2, faster than a concorde at mach 2. Makes sense, there's no point going slightly supersonic since you gain only a little speed over high subsonic for a lot of extra trouble. I guess this is a competitor for a Citation X+ which can reach mach 0.93
- mc32 6y agoQuestion, so this has on paper the goal of being capable of Mach 2.2. What are the Mach speed restrictions for civ aircraft over land, if any and what impact of any on viability?
- londons_explore 6y agoIn general, the mach restrictions are based on sound complaints only. Demonstrate you can make something that doesn't deafen millions of people, and you'll be granted approval to fly over land, however fast it goes.
- heymijo 6y agoHow do venture backed economics for a supersonic jet company work? My understanding of watching VC over the past decade is that it's great for hyper-scaling software companies, tenuous at best for hybrid tech/real world companies, and ruinous for companies that don't enjoy the zero marginal cost benefits of a software company at scale.
- eganist 6y agoMy assumption is that Boom's pitch relied on a relatively quick tech exit, e.g. Boeing or Airbus picking them up once boom reaches a point where either company can scale a proof of concept. If the demonstrator proves itself next year, that's when to expect an exit. I don't see Boom independently competing with either of the mainstream manufacturers here; they're likely only a vehicle for proving that the concept works, and then the whole package — patents, tooling, team, and all — is sold to a firm that can scale it. Would be interesting to see if any non-commercial firms e.g. Lockheed use Boom as a way to make inroads into the commercial sector, though. My money is on a buy-out in 2021-2022, and for bonus points, I'll include unexpected buyers who want to make inroads in the commercial space, e.g. if Lockheed wants to add commercial airliners to its portfolio and also see whether any of Boom's supersonic tech makes sense in their non-commercial projects or if Rolls Royce wants to transition away from being just an enginemaker (for Boom and others). If Boeing buys Boom, it's a lost cause and the tech will likely just end up being mothballed by bean counters for being too slow to scale.
- lacker 6y agoBoom's pitch did not rely on a quick exit, it was much more along the lines of "This will take a very long time to come to fruition. We're up-front about that. But, it has the potential to be billions of dollars, if you can be patient." VCs are often more interested in that than the quick flip....
- usrusr 6y agoVC can also be interested in a company as a quick flip opportunity when the pitch never mentions that possibility. Particularly early stage investors who buy in low enough to still win if the eventual exit is considerably below a meanwhile heavily inflated nominal valuation.
- hospadar 6y agoDon't get me wrong, supersonic planes VERY COOL and I want that for our world, but the tone of the article is a little annoying: "Why let a handful of people cross the Atlantic in a couple of hours when the jumbo jets (that were developed concurrently) can do the same at far lower cost?" Why indeed? Maybe because people want it and it's a better idea? That being said, I really hope I get to fly supersonic sometime
- sergioisidoro 6y agoWhy should we use jumbo jets, instead of sail ships? There is a cost function associated with time. For most people, there is a threshold after which further gains become insignificant per hour saved, so a Jumbo jet is not much better than a super sonic plane. But the world has also changed since the Concorde, and maybe now there's a bigger market for people for whom getting something or someone across the Atlantic in a few hours is important: Let's say, for example, that a loved one is severely ill, and you need to get there fast to say your goodbyes.
- bumby 6y agoI wonder if this tech is fundamentally different than what NASA has recently rolled out with the X59 https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-s-x-59-quiet-supersonic-research-aircraft-cleared-for-final-assembly https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-s-x-59-quiet-superso...
- abrbhat 6y agoThe reason this will make economic sense is that there will be no need for laid-back seats because of short travel times.
- supernova87a 6y agoBut note, this is just the small almost single-person sized prototype that's planned to fly. It is a huge leap to get to the next step, the commercial transport sized plane...
- dhosek 6y agoNobody seems to be talking about the sonic boom issue. People often assume that the sonic boom is a single event that happens when the plain exceeds the speed of sound, but rather its a continuous event that happens at supersonic speed which is why the Concord was used only for transatlantic service. A supersonic plane would not be practical for any overland route. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonic_boom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonic_boom
- tachyonbeam 6y agoIs it very loud even when planes are over 30,000 feet altitude? Can supersonic planes easily cruise at subsonic speeds when preparing to land?
- rbanffy 6y agoThey do, but the wings have a lot of drag that the engines must compensate for.
- dhosek 6y agoFrom the linked wikipedia article: >In the late 1950s when supersonic transport (SST) designs were being actively pursued, it was thought that although the boom would be very large, the problems could be avoided by flying higher. This assumption was proven false when the North American XB-70 Valkyrie started flying, and it was found that the boom was a problem even at 70,000 feet (21,000 m). It was during these tests that the N-wave was first characterized.
- rbanffy 6y agoThe Overture is smaller than the Concorde, so that a lower level of noise is expected. There has been some developments in aerodynamics for minimizing the shock by spreading it over a larger area, but, as you point out, they don't mention it. It is probably part of their "secret sauce".
- liability 6y agoAnother difference between the proposed Overture and the Concorde is the engines. Concorde used turbojets with afterburners during takeoff, while Boom proposes a turbofan design without afterburners, which should in theory make it quieter for communities adjacent to airports. However the XB-1 small scale version will use turbojets according to Wikipedia.
- gxqoz 6y agoHave they actually solved the (non-noise) environmental concerns of SST? From a NYT article a few years ago: "According to a 1999 report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, introducing 1,000 commercial SSTs more advanced than the Concorde could make the climate impact of airlines balloon by 40 percent by midcentury. That’s on top of the tripling of emissions already expected as more travelers take to the sky." https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/11/opinion/reviving-supersonic-jets-will-damage-the-climate.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/11/opinion/reviving-superson...
- apsec112 6y agoThey'll make synthetic fuel by pulling CO2 back out of the air: https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2019/06/18/1870486/0/en/Boom-Supersonic-Partners-with-Prometheus-Fuels-to-Supply-Carbon-Neutral-Fuel-for-XB-1-its-Mach-2-2-Demonstrator-Aircraft.html https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2019/06/18/187048... https://carbonengineering.com/news-updates/aerion-supersonic-and-carbon-engineering/ https://carbonengineering.com/news-updates/aerion-supersonic...
- makerofspoons 6y agoThat's insufficient to address the pollution from the aircraft. There is also water vapor, black carbon, nitrous oxide, and sulfur oxide that would need to be mitigated: https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2015/09/evolving-climate-math-of-flying-vs-driving/ https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2015/09/evolving-climate-...
- beering 6y agoYou know what's better than being carbon neutral? Being carbon negative. I'd rather Prometheus pull carbon out of the air to help cover existing fuel needs than to just offset a huge increase in jet fuel usage. I fail to see how building yet another luxury transport service will meaningfully help the world compared to tackling some of the bigger problems in energy and environment. Especially since there's no possibility that Boom is more efficient than existing modes of travel.
- holler 6y ago> In the righter-wing decades that followed its birth, we simply decided to walk back from the future. Odd statement for an otherwise interesting subject. Pretty sure there were many reasons the concorde was retired and political stripes weren’t one of them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- maltalex 6y agoThis is obviously a nitpick, but when I head the word "boom" in relation to planes, a sonic boom isn't the first thing that pops into my head. Is it just me?
- bobmalone123 6y agoWow, they are even wearing their little face mask in their promotional videos to be good citizens, give the good example (signal some virtue) and foster good behaviors. So much saccharine.
- zanecraw 6y agoyoooo this is awesome!
- mmaunder 6y agoThe aviation industry did something worse? Nope. It invented the high bypass turbofan engine which is quieter, more fuel efficient, and enabled affordable mass air transport. Concorde was incredibly noisy, unsafe (do the numbers) and only available for a tiny number of elite travelers. Most of the folks commenting here have never heard Concord take off or land. It rattled the entire city.
- stevehawk 6y agoWhat numbers? There was only one loss of life incident and it was due to parts falling off of another aircraft on the runway prior to its departure.
- mmaunder 6y agoGoogle it, there has been much reporting on the numbers. Aircraft accidents are a cascade of failures. The debris was part of a chain which ended with concord.