13 ms·
Leaked S-1 screenshots show Palantir losing $579M in 2019
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThere are lots of people who fit the description of "a Palantir shareholder", and of course faking a screenshot is trivial. What has TechCrunch done to confirm the reliability of their source or otherwise verify the leak?
- msoad 6y agoI'm guessing this is intentionally leaked by Palantir to test the waters for IPO. No one with access to that document will risk the legal ramification of leaking it just for fun
- LegitShady 6y agoI don't know. Thiel has enough enemies that assuming it's Palantir doing it seems naive. There are plenty of people willing to attack him "for fun"
- NationalPark 6y agoSomeone trying to destroy a business because of a personal grudge? Say it ain't so...
- jessaustin 6y agoRegardless of one's opinions of Thiel, most opposition to Palantir would be political rather than personal. This firm's actions have made society poorer and less free, in multiple nations.
- regs 6y agoCare to cite an example?
- jessaustin 6y agoAnyone who wants to quibble that it's fine to lock up people who lack documentation or who live across the street from a drug dealer, can have that conversation without me. I'm sure if you consult a search engine you can find lots of other stuff like this: https://slate.com/technology/2019/05/documents-reveal-palantir-software-is-used-for-ice-deportations.html https://slate.com/technology/2019/05/documents-reveal-palant... https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/27/17054740/palantir-predictive-policing-tool-new-orleans-nopd https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/27/17054740/palantir-predict...
- scumbert 6y agoWhich is it, detractors-- Palantir's products are smoke and mirrors, or they are effectual at making society less free?
- jessaustin 6y agoApparently some of Palantir's line is so secret we don't know about it. The products we have heard of, like "Gotham" (?!!), are ineffective at the task of "assisting police without violating human rights". That task is important to humans, but not to some of those who decide where police departments spend money. It's a principal-agent problem.
- rsynnott 6y agoIf a product aimed at law enforcement, say, doesn't work, but does make law enforcement more arbitrary, then both are satisfied. Not saying that's the case here, but one could be forgiven for assuming that a lot of 'predictive policing' stuff is snake oil, but dangerous snake oil.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI agree that's plausible speculation, but it's still speculation. It seems like a pretty serious failure of media literacy to assume that these screenshots are authentic without any concrete knowledge of how their authenticity was confirmed.
- Panini_Jones 6y agoI'm not sure it's in TechCrunch's interests to tell us how credible their leakers are. Leakers probably have repeat value and they don't want to poison their relationship.
- rsynnott 6y agoGiven how few people presumably have legitimate access to these, Techcrunch probably couldn't say much without risking identifying their source. When people leak to media, they often do so on condition that they won't be identified.
- pc86 6y agoNo screenshots in the article.
- jessaustin 6y agoPresumably TC would like to avoid a Reality Winner situation. Can one be certain that an image has been processed enough to avoid all watermarking etc?
- iso1631 6y agoThey own the UK now, however the process that led to this tanked the UK economy so it's not worth as much as expected.
- api 6y agoI must point out that it is not uncommon for any tech company to lose money for a long time, especially if they are being bankrolled on the other side.
- H8crilA 6y agoIt is uncommon to the successful ones. Microsoft, Google, Facebook, Apple - all profitable at IPO time. Look up old S-1s.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>It is uncommon to the successful ones. Exactly. People love to point at Amazon as long unprofitable, but don't realize the company was generating massive cash flows for reinvestment, too. There's no inherent reason startups or tech companies should lose money endlessly.
- ttymck 6y agoSoftbank is responsible for spreading that assumption, no? Fairly recently? (Uber, et al.)
- govg 6y agoI mean, there are two things here a) even Softbank doesn't assume indefinite losses/ unknown profitability, they have an exit horizon in mind that just happens to be larger than that of most other funds, and b) a lot of tech startups that have IPO'ed in the recent past have all been unprofitable when going public, and Softbank isn't responsible for most of them. A notable exception was Zoom ( I'm talking about last year ) who were profitable before the IPO, as far as I remember.
- plorkyeran 6y agoThere is also a huge difference between not making a profit and burning money. Amazon made it past the point of having a runway very quickly.
- 6y ago
- iammru 6y agoPalantir throws people at big data problems. It seems that they have some tech but a lot of critical work is done by their highly paid consultants.
- paxys 6y agoAll their out-of-the-box products have been failures. They are a 100% consulting company.
- siliconvalley1 6y agoConsidering much of their work is classified it's incredibly unlikely you are aware of most of their product's successes or failures.
- paxys 6y agoTheir contacts are classified. Regular products (Gotham, Metropolis, Foundry) are not. We've had multiple demos of all this and more from their sales teams and other sources over the years.
- shepardrtc 6y agoAre any of their products worthy of the hype?
- iammru 6y agoThey do have unique IP about analyzing patterns in "network" of x (people, places, etc). So pretty useful for telecommunications and defense/intelligence agencies
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gabaix 6y agoI interviewed there for a product management position. It was clear they were not a product company, but they badly wanted to be one. Being a product company is so much better in Silicon Valley. Revenues scale. Engineers work on general problems. Skills are reusable. At the time (2014) they were building Gotham and Metropolis. There was a small team of product evangelists in the team, whose role was to find commonalities between projects. I could feel they were conflicted. It looked like the platforms were not valued by the customers. Customers valued answers to their operational problems. And problems across companies and industries get solved very differently. Crossing data between license plates wasn't the same as extracting data from credit card statements. Platforms may provide foundations to speed up implementation and save money, but nothing customers could value directly. I could tell they wanted to be a product company. Palantir is structured like a regular Silicon Valley company. They have a CEO, a COO, and product roles. They give stock options and now are forced to go public. And they never never present themselves as consultants. One of my friends there took offense at describing the company as 'Tech McKinsey'. Compare it with firms such as McKinsey and BCG. They are private partnerships. They pay junior consultants higher than any other company at equivalent positions, they give no shares until partners. The partners at these firms possess the network. They do the selling, and that's all they are focused on. Answering customers' problems. It might scale less, but it provides a 100% tailored solution to the customer. The only question is that what customers value. Do they value Palantir platforms with high recurring fees? Or did they like the first data joins, but eventually thought it was too expensive, or they should build it themselves? Which would mean Palantir has to constantly generate new contracts, much like McKinsey and BCG. Only Palantir knows.
- mbesto 6y agoIt's losing money but it's slowing that loss relative to revenues. I don't understand what the story is here?
- siliconvalley1 6y agoThat yet another "Unicorn" is actually just smoke and mirrors, isn't profitable and has no realistic path to ever being so?
- kirillzubovsky 6y agoPerhaps that’s an incorrect assumption, that a unicorn needs to be profitable. All they need is to be growing, and show a potential for future upside. If they make net zero, or even keep losing money, doesn’t matter as long as the growth continues because there is always going to be someone else further down the road willing to buy into the story. In theory.
- siliconvalley1 6y ago> there is always going to be someone else further down the road willing to buy into the story. This doesn't point to a successful value adding business but rather mass market delusion...
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoI mean... if you buy it and flip it in a year for an extra $300 million or a cool billion, who cares if it's a bigger fool theory in effect.
- ta17711771 6y agoYou, when you're the bigger fool.
- jmnicolas 6y ago> there is always going to be someone else further down the road willing to buy into the story Until there isn't and the Ponzi scheme collapse.
- gen220 6y agoDo we have any idea where the big expenses stem from? It's hard to form useful judgements on a single data point. > In relative numbers, operating expenses changed from 157% of revenues in the first half of 2019 to 107% of revenues in first half of 2020 [while revenue grew 49% yoy]. Seems to suggest that a lot of the expenses were elective, or non-elective but have a sub-linear correlation to revenue growth. Honestly, these numbers are not as bad as the opinions interspersing the numbers makes it out to be. Sounds to me like a private company that's tightening the belt while leaning into being a public company and continuing to grow.
- teachrdan 6y agoSerious question: If they were "tightening the belt," wouldn't their expenses go down? Why would they lose over a billion dollars over two years before going public if they weren't showing hockey stick growth?
- gen220 6y agoNot necessarily. Expense is an important figure, but the ratio (operating expense : revenue) is more important, IMO. They need to demonstrate they can grow revenues without a proportional growth to operating expenses, and that they can sustain this trajectory until revenues > operating expenses. An operating expense:revenue ratio of 107% (i.e. you spend 1.07 for every 1.00, which is their H1 2020 numbers) is bad in isolation. But when it was 157% at the same time last year? The fact that they could move from 157% to 107% while significantly growing revenue is a very positive signal.
- siliconvalley1 6y agoSomeone invest in my startup. It's genius. I'll sell $1 Bills for $.50, I'll never make a profit but my user growth will be off the charts! Me, my cofounders and any VC stupid/genius enough to invest in us will make millions when we IPO, cash out and go bankrupt all within 5 years!
- baby 6y agoHow do you monetize?
- jbay808 6y agoThe plan is to start charging $2 once everyone is already on the platform.
- siliconvalley1 6y agoHaha no that's so 2012. To buy the $.50 dollar you have to use our app, that also happens to be a high end privacy invasion tool and we'll sell all our user data to the highest bidder!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- KKKKkkkk1 6y agoAll these unicorns are staying private so long that the average Joe is not getting any opportunity to get in on the wealth creation due to draconian SEC regulations. WeWork, Theranos, now Palantir. Luckily Uber went public!
- Panini_Jones 6y agoWould you like to invest in Theranos?
- 1-more 6y agoWell I thought it was funny at least.
- dmode 6y agoYou win the internet
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bobwernstein 6y agolollll
- paxys 6y agoThe bizarre part to me is that Palantir was founded in 2004. How have they survived 16 years with constant large losses? There is no way they've had that much funding.
- tempsy 6y agoGAAP or non-GAAP? If it's GAAP then losses can largely stem from stock awards paid to employees...
- jcdavis 6y ago1. They have in fact had "that much" funding, $2.6B according to Crunchbase 2. Likely their actual cashflow is not as bad - I suspect that, likely other tech cos, they have a lot of expenses in the form of stock comp, which is not an actual cash cost to the company. but must be accounted for per GAAP.
- baby 6y agoGovernment funded companies are really something else
- rconti 6y agoGovernment?
- justapassenger 6y agoWith enough of hype and right people behind your company, it's very easy to get money in silicon valley.
- xenospn 6y agoNot just in silicon valley.
- hangonhn 6y agoCredit has been pretty free flowing since 2008 and with near 0% interest rate a lot of different classes of investments aren't as attractive. SV and tech has greatly benefited from this as they're one of the sectors of the US economy that has really stood out in terms of growth.
- code4tee 6y agoI don’t see the market being very favorable toward floating another “geriatric unicorn” with this sort of financial profile. I also continue to not understand what their product really is and if it’s actually valuable. They seem to just throw armies of people at data problems which might produce some results but is hardly a scalable or valuable business model.
- mrich 6y agoHow does such a secretive company, mostly dealing with government, spend so much money on sales & marketing? (61% of revenue, "roughly $450 million for both years") I mean, just bribing people to get the contracts should be an order of magnitude cheaper, right?
- shuckles 6y agoIs that high compared to other consulting shops with a large enterprise sales teams? IBM or Deloitte Digital?
- gambler 6y agoBribes? Uh, I mean, the cost of establishing positive relationships?
- tehwebguy 6y agoPeople are downvoting you but I fail to see any other ways for Palantir to spend that much money on marketing products that such a small number of potential clients would both want and afford. For reference Nike only spent 7-8 times that on marketing in the same year.
- lumost 6y agoEnterprise sales can get expensive. They're likely booking R&D/ consulting hours as sales and marketing. It's not necessarily wrong if they hold the customer for decades, but that depends on the stickiness of the contract. I'd imagine for a company like palantir to win in the long run would require the western world to value surveillance at the same level as tanks, ships, and fighter platforms. At which point they look like a digital Raytheon or BAE.
- ng12 6y agoI was confused by that as well. Maybe that number includes the engineers contracted out to customers?
- captainmuon 6y ago
- mlazos 6y agoIMO I remember interviewing there and my bullshit detector was at 10000%. First the interviewer went off on a tangent claiming that they’re not evil (unsolicited) and second it seems like they’re capitalizing on the whole “big data” trend. They’ll find “insights” across multiple data streams without ever providing examples beyond license plate readers. I am surprised they haven’t gotten enterprise businesses to sign on - although maybe enterprise business only trust certain brands, but am not surprised they’ve gotten the government to sign on.
- nodesocket 6y agoI am very interested in investing in Palantir stock. There is political risk with Biden reducing contractor and military spend, but ultimately they provide critical software / infrastructure for the government and that won't be going anywhere.
- fourstar 6y agoSo did you pass the interview? EDIT: downvoted. Guessing you didn't and that's why you're salty. Kek.
- ashtonkem 6y ago“We’re not evil” is a bit like “don’t worry”; if it’s said too often or without prompting, it tends to make the listening party assume that they’re in fact not worrying enough
- piinbinary 6y agoI'm reminded of the Monty Python sketch where a bored airline pilot says to the passengers, "you have no cause for alarm." Similarly, if a political entity calls themselves a name containing "democratic" or "republic", you can be assured that it is not a democracy.
- skrebbel 6y agoCzech republic? Actually it's a counterpoint cause they renamed to Czechia right about when their government got less democratic :-)
- tempsy 6y agoPalantir slow walked their IPO because it is, by nature, a very secretive business that sells to law enforcement, military, banks, etc., and the transition to opening up its books and talking about their customers is inherently difficult. They were able to raise privately for a long time so they felt no reason to hurry to go public. At same time they've raised so much money that being acquired by a PE firm or basically anything else other than going public would likely be detrimental to common shareholders given liquidity preferences. And now given all the backlash that police department funding is getting and the possibility of a Biden presidency looming it's very possible that the type of "surveillance policing" that Palantir enables will be severely cut, and in fact some cities have already begun to ban these practices.
- facethrowaway 6y agoBest investments of the 21st century: 1. Peter Thiel, Facebook, $500k 2. Peter Thiel, Donald Trump, $1m No matter who wins the next election, Thiel and his buddies are guaranteed more contracts. Welcome to the new American plutocracy!
- ryansmccoy 6y agoObviously, I don't know what's going on at Palantir besides what I've read, but I know a few things about Finance. A tax loss isn't necessarily all bad news. If you have a tax loss in one year, you might be able to use that loss to offset profits in future years, to minimize taxes for your business in those years. This technique is called a tax loss carry forward because it takes a tax loss in one year and carries it into a future year. So, what they might be doing is using this as an opportunity to "throw the baby out with the bathwater," as the saying goes. Show a bunch of losses prior to IPO (setting expectations low), then show gradually improving operating results. Investors love this kind of "story" because the potential for stock to go down is less then if they were to show a booming business right off the bat. Finally, just to make a point about investors not necessarily being worried about a company showing losses, all you have to do is look at Amazon, who for years showed loses.
- stu2b50 6y agoWhat shocked me more than the loss was the honestly kinda ass revenue for their valuation. This isn't Uber with billions in revenue while losing in money. >In the screenshots of the company’s financials, Palantir lists a net loss of roughly $580 million for 2019, which is almost identical to its loss in 2018. The company listed a net loss percentage of 97% for 2018, improving to a loss of 78% for last year.
- matchagaucho 6y agoHad they spent the money on ops or DoD compliant hosting infra, I would agree the long-term gains offset the near-term losses. But as an Investor, it concerns me they spent $900M on Sales and Marketing in the Gov sector over 2 years. That is essentially a lobby-dependent business model with long-term success contingent on the currently elected administration.
- ryansmccoy 6y agoYea, I don't know what's going on besides what I read. I would much rather see the screenshot for myself then have someone else explain to me what they think the most important aspects of it are.
- Pandabob 6y agoHow much is Palantir in the consulting business vs. a SaaS? Whenever I read something about it I get IBM vibes, of a company which is partly doing some software platform stuff with a mix of good ol consulting. How off base is that impression?
- Panini_Jones 6y agoIBM is one of their main competitors. When I interviewed a few years ago, it was primarily consulting. Things could have changed, but I doubt they have.
- zyang 6y agoI have seen some of their SaaS demos. It might fool some high level decision makers, but anyone with technical background can see right through their fake-n-bake garbage.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thesausageking 6y agoOne of their clever moves was calling their consultants "Forward Deployed Engineers". This let them hire better engineers than you normally could to be consultants (You're not a consultant, you're a "Forward Deployed Engineer"). This term also allowed them to book much more of their revenues as software licenses than services, which makes them look much more attractive to investors. With it, they were able to get a $20B valuation in the last round, where if they were viewed as a government IT services vendor they would've been lucky to be valued at $0.5B.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 6y agoIt's also a name that sounds familiar to military people - might have made it easier for them to sell contracts into that space.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- motohagiography 6y ago"Leaked screenshots," like this would be really funny to bait some TSLA shorts, but I think that's where trolling crosses over into market manipulation.
- chromaton 6y agoEveryone who looked into a palantir in Lord of the Rings got accurate data, but bad information. (That is, the images were real, but the context was misleading.)
- person_of_color 6y agoGo on...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AJRF 6y agoWhat does Palintir even do? It seems that they have consultants (that they called forward deployed engineers for some reason) who go into military, police & enterprise and set up some sort of bespoke data lake for all the docs and data flowing through the company. Then they give users a tool to do investigation of the data using a tool that lets them build causal links between documents or maybe entities is a better name? That seems useful - but the secrecy is weird. I saw some product videos from ages ago and it looked like software only an Enterprise could love. Looked incredibly slow, janky and overly complicated (I assume it's a convoluted interface so they can charge training fees!) Can anyone yay or nay me here - is this what they do?
- paulgb 6y agoI only know about as much as you do, but I interviewed with them ~7 years ago and played with the software a bit and from what I can tell you're spot on. My understanding is that they're basically a counterpart to the big data companies serving enterprise, except targeting the government/military space. They are obviously bound to secrecy as part of those projects, but it seems they lean in to the secrecy as a recruiting strategy because it's better to be mysterious than admit to candidates that they're a boring government contractor.
- noch 6y ago> Can anyone yay or nay me here - is this what they do? A summary/history: https://aletteraday.substack.com/p/letters-2930-palantir https://aletteraday.substack.com/p/letters-2930-palantir http://web.archive.org/web/20190724214959/http://www.socialcalculations.com/2015/08/a-pretty-complete-history-of-palantir.html http://web.archive.org/web/20190724214959/http://www.socialc... Joe Lonsdale, cofounder of Palantir, on what they built: https://www.quora.com/Did-Palantirs-founders-consider-the-ethical-implications-of-their-work-Do-they-have-thoughts-about-the-consequences-of-what-they-built https://www.quora.com/Did-Palantirs-founders-consider-the-et... Why did Peter Thiel and Joe Lonsdale found Palantir? https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Peter-Thiel-and-Joe-Lonsdale-found-Palantir https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Peter-Thiel-and-Joe-Lonsdale-f...
- moandcompany 6y agoMy recollection may not be entirely up to date, but Palantir fielded two distinct product areas: what were previously called (1) "Metropolis" and (2) "Gotham"; the distinctive difference between the two were applications and context to (1) Financial Markets / Quantitative data and (2) "Intelligence" and other unstructured data. These have likely evolved. The "Intelligence" and other unstructured data area is the main place where Palantir is most known. It's useful to think of the Palantir company as a Systems Integrator in the classical sense known to the US Federal Government's DoD and Intelligence Communities, and other governmental entities at other levels (e.g. municipal/state). You can also think of them as technology consultants that integrate with customer missions to understand and provide mission-effective technology solutions. As a systems integrator, they aim to solve customer problems and provide technical solutions; the product can be considered to be parts of their software platform(s), new tools/additions/augmentations, professional services, and relationship/engagement management. Forward deployed engineers often act as consultants/systems/sales engineers to characterize customer needs and integrate Palantir platforms with customer systems, which often includes the need to write new code/adapters/interfaces; today, you might call them data engineers. Palantir also has"Software Engineers" that primarily work on the platform(s), rather than directly with customers. Regarding "evil/not-evil" and secrecy, etc. We're living in a very divided age where many people feel their cause is righteous and more just than others across the political spectrum. We're also seeing that people are too commonly painted as "evil" if they don't share viewpoints. The thematic mission of much of Palantir's work relates to matters including National security, etc, which their employees are proud to take part in and contribute. This is tied to the meaning of "Save the Shire," where Palantir employees believe in and do their part in the mission to preserve and do good, from their perspective. Lord of the Rings references are plentiful in this world, and Palantir employees have self-referred to themselves as the "Hobbits" working to "Save the Shire." One of Palantir's early investors was In-Q-Tel, and Peter Thiel. You'll see this theme present in other places involving In-Q-Tel (it's their purpose for existing), and Peter Thiel's other investments (e.g. Anduril Industries, which has many former-Palantir employees). Other interesting facts: Palantir was/is based out of Palo Alto, CA and occupies a large chunk of Palo Alto's commercial office real estate. It's main office once, or still does, occupy Facebook's former headquarters building, 100 Hamilton Ave, from its early days.
- jshaqaw 6y ago16 years of losses for a company that does not appear to have compelling operating leverage does not seem like something which would get an enthusiastic Wall Street reception.
- gnu8 6y agoIt would be nice if these losers stopped naming crap used to violate civil rights and murder people after Lord of the Rings and other beloved fictional stories. Just call it PusGuzzler 20202 or Venomous Butt Spiders so people can recognize the company and product for what it is, ugly and terrible.
- qaq 6y agoPalantir has pretty clever shtick positioning pretty much run of the mill consulting operation as a very advanced software company.
- ThA0x2 6y agoPalantir, the virtue signalers' rally point.
- microtherion 6y agoWhat do you want? Keeping the chairman's Blood Bar stocked up isn't cheap.
- worldmerge 6y agoI know there is a lot of controversy around Palantir but I don't understand what they do. From their site it seems like they're just another data analysis company. What does Palantir do?
- bobwernstein 6y agoquoting top comment under the article: So let's break this down: A 17-year-old software firm (they are not a startup) has Has only 125 paying customers Generates 742MM in revenue Raised between $2.6 - $3.0 billion dollars in venture capital to generate that $742MM Has never broken even in 17 years Lost $580 MM Concentrates nearly a 1/3 of its revenue in 3 customers (avg rev ~$67MM per those top 3, a staggering amount for a software company of this size) Grew revenues by 25% YoY, that's good, but 91% of that comes from existing clients, that's bad Valued at $20 billion by private investors And the coup de grace, the founders want to keep 49.999% control in perpetuity regardless of their stock ownership. I expected a lot more given the hype and aura this firm has had for so many years. This company is being valued at 26x its revenue, which is insane even in SaaS land. Good luck to anyone who purchases these shares on the open market. I would highly recommend against it.