38 ms·
Most “mandatory requirements” in corporations are imaginary
- spiritplumber 6y agoOnce you have people in your organization, you can manipulate the internal economy of favors and perks in order to increase your ability to control their behavior.
- luhem7 6y agoA Gervais principle man?
- arethuza 6y agoForget INTP, Sociopath|Clueless|Loser is definitely the most effective categorisation of roles in organisation I have encountered: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/the-gervais-principle/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/the-gervais-principle/
- spiritplumber 6y agoThis is really interesting, thanks for sharing it! Is this how American offices actually work?
- yebyen 6y agoI just learned about this apparently popular interpretation and after going out and reading about it enough, I had to come back and find this thread just to say: "I'm in this photo and I don't like it".jpg I'm afraid it might be true! This explains a lot for me.
- simonbarker87 6y agoThis is why managers need a high level of emotional intelligence, the ability to empathize and quickly place themselves in the position of others. Without those three qualities management is ill equipped to handle these kinds of things sensibly. Sadly the above traits are more deemed leadership qualities rather than management qualities and so often missing in management. Leadership skills are far harder to teach than management skills and also rarer in the population than the number it management roles there are to fill.
- reportgunner 6y agoI have also personally witnessed a corporation insisting that I learn exclusively management practices in a multi-session Leadership Education and 'selling' it to me as "leadership".
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoTo add to that, if you have a senior IC with leadership skills and a manager without, the senior IC won't last long, either through rage quitting or slow-walking out the door by the manager who's threatened by the senior IC.
- zimbatm 6y agoEven the best manager is faced with a bandwidth problem. It's impossible to collect accurately everything that the engineers are doing. And each layer of management is applying its own compression on what information they get from the levels below. What is frustrating when having the feet on the ground (or in the code), is that we clearly see the issues on our level. But conveying that in a understandable and nuanced manner would require too much context. IMO a good solution is to leave breathing room in the agenda and trust that the engineers will work on fixing those issues. By making them somewhat autonomous they can skip the politics and get right down to make their lives and the product a better place.
- Perseids 6y agoA complementary phrasing is to apply the subsidiarity principle ("the principle that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed at a more local level" – OED) to companies, which would be the antithesis of micro-management. When your boss is an enabler first and a decision maker second, they are already following a variation of that principle. I wish there was a standard way to work against the institutionalized trust issues that creep up in larger companies. E.g. when managers can only take actions if they can show an issue exists using their (arbitrary) metrics, and not when their reports directly tell them about it.
- 6y ago
- ciguy 6y agoFounders should keep this in mind anytime they are negotiating contract terms with a corporation also. There is no such thing as a "standard" contract and almost all "mandatory" clauses are not actually mandatory. This also applies to real estate transactions and almost any other high stakes negotiating. Standard and mandatory are terms used to trick inexperienced or less powerful people/entities into agreeing to terms more favorable to an opponent. None of this means you can necessarily axe all the requirements though. It entirely depends on your negotiating position. If a company wants to work with you badly enough they'll pay their lawyer the $500 hourly to modify the contract or approve your changes.
- capableweb 6y agoEveryone should keep this in mind for every type of contract. In the beginning of my adult life, I was under the expression that contracts were static and immutable. As I got more experience, I tried being more demanding (and my skills were also more in demand) when setting up contracts and I have at multiple points managed to change what was supposed to be "mandatory" and "unchangable" many times, from rental contracts to employment contracts and many other things.
- manquer 6y ago> If a company wants to work with you badly enough This is usually the problem for many founders early on, if you already have a great product market fit then everything will bend to your demands and even turn down customers if they are not flexible enough. Most products do not have that very strong PMF early on.
- geoffwa 6y agoI feel that as organization size increases, individual responsibility decreases. At some point there’s a limit where individuals become responsible for nothing and everything is a policy or process. It would be interesting to try to study or quantify this with different orgs and roles.
- Gieskanne 6y agoFunny enough i though so as well but discovered quite quickly that without this stuff, a lot of people are doing shit. Do i think someone needs to tell me not to put every shitty tool on my work laptop which has a corp certificate? Access to vpn and corp network? With access to HyperScalers? No. What do my collegues? Everything. Oh there is a nice new shiny tool and it sends metrics to an external service, lets try this out...
- maccard 6y agoI'm not in favour of the "BigCorp controls my entire machine" approach, but this is silly. It's not a lot of people doing shit, it's a problem of scale. Have you verified that every single application installed on your machines sends no telemetry, no crash reporting, and has no random web servers running that run arbitrary code? It's likely that you've missed one application. Now multiply that by 10,000 employees - all it takes is one application per person, and you have a massive amount of data being leaked.
- Gieskanne 6y agoWhen you reach a certain scale, you will verify the tools which are running on the machines of your employees. I'm not seeing a problem with it and my default stack is not that big: chrome, intellij, shell etc. it is reasonable and someone has to do it.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoThis is allegedly what happened to the entire German population during the holocaust. They even made up a word for it something like "office talk." People displaced their personal responsibility with lies like "I HAVE to, it's the company policy. I just do my job. I don't make the rules."
- Gieskanne 6y agoIf i pay an external $1000 per day and that price doesn't change when they are in my office or at home, i would put them in my office for obvious security risks. If corona means i can't get my work done, i have a new risk. Security risk for external consultants having full access at their home vs. no one can work -> i might choose the externals giving access. Its not imaginary.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoPretty sure my home is more secure than your office. Literally no one wanders in here and tries to steal corporate secrets / install malware. It happens all the time in actual offices, and it's surprisingly easy to gain access to the most "secure" offices.
- Gieskanne 6y agoCompany has their office under control but not yours. Doesn't matter if you think your office is more secure. Mine has access control. Also we are not talking about the person who is really smart about it we talk about the avg person. There are plenty of stories of laptops being stolen in coffee shops or from a train. And its also a Network thing. Do i want you to be able to pull/push something into my corp network fromyour home network?
- bartvk 6y agoBut shouldn't you have to weigh this against the fact that a bit more freedom makes people happy?
- corty 6y agoNo, because keeping external consultants happy is not the job of the company. They only have to keep their own employees happy, external consultants are seen as temporary, cheap, illoyal and taking away normal employees' jobs. Most parts of the hierarchy (except the very top) will try to inconvenience them if possible.
- 6y ago
- pubkraal 6y agoYour example forgets to acknowledge that while there may have been good reasons for people to not be allowed to work remotely, COVID is a very pressing reason to do allow it, and the benefit of allowing people to work remotely vs getting absolutely nothing done or getting fined by the government for forcing people to come in is extremely obvious. So much so that the cons of allowing this have to be put aside, or remediated differently (which in some cases can even require investment). It's a risk assessment that suddenly tilted the other way. I don't agree with "everybody should work from the office" sentiments, myself, but I have seen this happen very clearly in many organizations.
- cjfd 6y agoThis is one thing to try to find out when one applies for a job. What kind of stupid requirements are there and is this company prone to senseless prescriptions? Even if one thinks that a particular senseless prescription is not very burdensome to oneself it still indicates an inclination to senseless prescriptions. One should avoid such places when one looks for a job. And that actually is a risk that management is perhaps not very aware of. The people who have the most choice of places to work can just decide not to work for you if you like to push your employees around.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe reason contractors and consultants have silly requirements like this placed on them is because they’re service providers, not employees. The managers are the customers in this arrangement, and customers often want silly things, like your physical presence in the office, because perhaps that just makes them feel better, and it’s fine if some silly thing makes your customer feel better. The broader issue he’s talking about is simply the inefficiency of large organisations. There are many things that start to become much less efficient the more you scale up the size of an organisation, including risk management. This is because the feedback loops between decision and outcome starts to get much longer, the causal relationship between decision and outcome starts to become much more blurry, the distance between decision maker and impacted user gets bigger, and management starts to be comprised of less leaders and more bureaucrats. Not only is this unavoidable, but it’s a good thing. Large businesses benefit from the economies of scale, but smaller organisations get to compete with them, because smaller organisations have the potential to be orders of magnitude more efficient than large ones. It also creates market opportunities for other B2B companies to come along and address some of their efficiency issues. I’ve done lots of consulting and contractor work, and one of the primary factors that drives demand for my services is enterprise inefficiency. Even if you put aside any consideration for how slow they are to adapt to new technology, a lot of demand for my contracts has been driven by strict corporate salary bands. The board sets the maximum rate that an engineer is allowed to be paid, and any team in the company that requires skills that the market has priced above that rate can only access them through external contractors/consultants. I’d bet the same is true for the OP, even if they don’t know it, so perhaps they shouldn’t be so quick to deride enterprise inefficiency.
- lwhi 6y agoThe dynamics feel a bit like good cop / bad cop on an organisational level. "I'd personally love to let X occur .. but it's not allowed due to company policy. This is mandatory." I have always believed everything is negotiable in business. As people, we're subject to the rule of law, and obviously our businesses need to operate accordingly. However, the policies that a company uses are really just a snapshot of current thinking. Nothing more than that; and thinking obviously changes.
- arethuza 6y ago"and thinking obviously changes" Sometimes it doesn't - sometimes people vehemently insist on application of policies even though what they produce is ridiculous. At a former employer I was quoted £70K (yes seventy thousand) for internal hosting of a not particularly business critical single static HTML page that would be accessed by maybe 100 people. I actually got a breakdown and it all made sense if you applied the policies the infrastructure team had invented - it didn't matter that the result was nonsense.
- namibj 6y agoWhat does one have to do to get to such crazy numbers for a task so simple?
- hyperman1 6y agoLet's see: A risk and impact analysis, a requirement check, a capacity audit, a full blown security audit, a data retention policy, a storage size study, a ton of policies to fill in so you get a dns name, a financial audit, setup of a new bookkeeping post so all these activities have somewhere to book their time, a project for that post, a language and style audit, a translation study to decide nothing needs a translation, ... I easily see more than 100 people working on this.
- arethuza 6y agoWell, apparently it counted as a separate application - so that required redundant (virtual servers) plus back-end databases. Add DR environment and live replication of VMs and databases, database backup retention planning, off-site storage costs. Ultra high performance SAN storage for all of that. Add pre-prod and test environments as well and it soon adds up.... apparently. Turns out the internal infrastructure recharging model didn't scale down and as it was a "process" it couldn't be changed.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoNice, yes spread the truth. All policy is negotiable. Rule by consent of the governed and all that.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoAren't all rules imaginary? > Every time someone in the management chain has axed the proposal with some variation of "this policy can not be changed because this is our policy and thus can not be changed", possibly with a "due to security reasons" thrown in there somewhere. That's circular, no doubt there. We've decided this rule must remain in place, because it's a rule. This decision-making process doesn't make any sense, but I still don't see the sense in calling the rule 'imaginary'. Is the real point here that sometimes bad rules remain in place until some external event forces a change? Doesn't sound so profound.
- tokai 6y agoThe management could be keeping the real reason from the contracters. It's not good for moral to say "No - cause we don't trust you".
- corty 6y agoThat is usually true, hidden agendas play a big role here. In Germany similar rules about contractors are often in place to prevent outsourcing. Contractors shouldn't be too comfortable and cheap, so the workers council and union enforce such rules so their established clientele still has some advantages over the external people.
- capableweb 6y agoNo, in short, the real point seems to be while the actual workers (non-management) would benefit the most from the rule change, managers (and further up the chain) mostly sees the risk and not the benefits, so they are the most likely to avoid changing the rules. Since the chance of getting blamed for changing the rules and impacting something negatively is bigger than getting blamed for _not_ changing the rules, and they are the ones actually allowed to making changes, you don't see a lot of the rules changing.
- tialaramex 6y ago> Aren't all rules imaginary? No. The Laws of Football and the Laws of Australia are imaginary in the sense you mean, but the Law of Gravity isn't. Mother Nature's rules are different than ours, stubborn far beyond all reason and not recorded anywhere for our inspection. Video games are interesting because we make them, yet for the most part some of their rules are like Ma's rules not ours. Watching Mario Maker 2 troll levels, the fact is that even if the player, and the viewer, and even the people at Nintendo who made the game think that Skipsqueak can't jump through that platform, if the game was coded such that it does, it will anyway. Anyway, I think part of what you're missing is that the people in this story often don't know the rule is imaginary. Sometimes it's an excuse, but sometimes they honestly just assumed there was a reason for things being as they are and never stopped to go find out why. Not everybody has the sort of inquisitive nature that would afford that, some lines of business crush that right out of you.
- wyclif 6y agoTo state a corollary of this: most "mandatory experience" on tech job requirements are imaginary. Therefore, if you're a job seeker, and especially if you're a woman or a minority, you shouldn't let not having any of these imaginary requirements stop you from applying for whatever job you want, especially if it's a junior role.
- avh02 6y agoI got my first junior role by applying for a senior role. Granted, I was definitely lucky they had one, but I got my foot through the senior screening tests and then realised I was in over my head. HR was kind enough to redirect me to a newly opened junior position in another part of the company. Been with that company (directly or indirectly) for a total of 5 years now.
- wyclif 6y agoI wonder how often that happens. I'm guessing it happens more often than HR thinks it does. I've heard quite a few stories like yours. Usually it's from somebody who can pass all the screens but doesn't have enough years of experience to make the hiring committee feel comfortable, so they get offered a junior role that technically wasn't open and is created specifically for that person to grow in. Anyway, it's a smart move for companies that can recognise talent.
- trabant00 6y agoI find these types of articles to be truisms. We have some imperfect system. Everybody knows about the problems it has. Somebody writes an article about how stupid and wrong those problems are. How does that help anybody? The real question is how you fix those problems without introducing others. Passed a certain age and work experience you start to notice that the bureaucracy that stops you from doing quick smart fixes also stops a lot of people from doing serious damage to the company. And yes, in some cases external factors will force a quick reevaluation of that bureaucracy. And you can say "I told you so all along!". But again, that's zero value to the business. The real value is in the work done to plan and execute a change is a way that assures no collateral damage and also to satisfy humanly needs/desires in the hierarchy. People want to cover their asses, but guess what, when you put the responsibility of a change on the smart ass that always annoys coworkers with his brilliant ideas they tend to back away from it cause his ass is precious to him too. TLDR: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence
- Aeolun 6y agoIf only people were willing to place all responsibility with me. I’d happily take it if we don’t have to deal with all the senseless policies/teams any more. The bureaucracy stops idiots from being idiots. The logical solution is to not hire (or retain) idiots, not to add more bureaucracy.
- trabant00 6y agoFrom your post I think you are quite young and inexperienced. There's not enough non-idiots to run companies. Having to deal with them is a fact of business, you can't simply isolate from the world. The fact that nobody is willing to place responsibility with you should tell the same thing. To sum it up: try to talk about what you already did. So from experience, not what you would do in your ideal world.
- Aeolun 6y agoConsidering I have worked with extremely talented and extremely stupid people I believe I know what I’m talking about (within the limits of my experience). There seems to be absolutely zero correlation between organisational role/level and ability, instead using years of service as a proxy. I don’t really know how to fix this.
- sfifs 6y agoIn BigCorps, if there's a stupid requirement, there's usually a reason for the stupid requirement to be there in the first place but getting to the reason might require un-peeling a few org layers to since the people enforcing the policy will not be the people who wrote the policy. A more productive use of time would be to understand the reason for the policy, document out why it doesn't apply to your case and then attempt to get approval. For instance, there's a restriction at my workplace (not a software company, a regular old industry fortune 500) which prevents git installs from pushing to any non corporate GitHub repo from our work machines. The obvious reason it exists is to prevent people (a lot of who are analysts or data scientists - not professional programmers) from shooting themselves in the foot by pushing code to their personal repos in error. It's annoying to work around if you need to say push a contribution to an open source project and you could rage at the infosec for enforcing it - but it obviously exists because stupid errors would have happened. This principle is also called Chesterton's fence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton%27s_fen...
- Aeolun 6y agoI think the problem with this logic is it hinders a hundred people on a daily basis to prevent one person from doing something stupid once a year. That’s just not great ROI.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoNever underestimate the damage one person doing something stupid once can do.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI actually think this whole one person doing one stupid thing per year argument is grossly underestimating the amount of stupid available. Stupidity is one of humanity's greatest renewable resources.
- taneq 6y agoIt's a great ROI if that one stupid thing a year is someone pushing your company's codebase and all your trade secrets to a public repo.
- tialaramex 6y agoYou see this in a lot of security pushback. "I want to do X" / "I am too lazy to do Y instead" becomes "We can't do Y, it's a mandatory requirement to do X" Very high on your response agenda should always be to ask for details. Who mandated this and how? If there's a regulation, cite the exact text of the regulation. There's a good chance the person telling you it's mandatory either knows it isn't or has never actually wondered why, and you can divert them from insisting on doing X / not doing Y to an exciting journey through their bureaucracy to find out that indeed there is no such mandate and never has been. Back when TLS 1.3 was being finalised EDCO and other groups trying to preserve RSA key exchange tried really hard to pretend that what they were doing was mandatory (it isn't and wasn't) and that their use cases were legitimate (most of them don't even appear to have a sound security rationale, let alone a legitimate purpose). When we get to September and companies that were asleep at the wheel suddenly notice the 398 day rule (Apple unilaterally changed the maximum lifetime of new certificates in the Web PKI to 398 days starting in September) you can guarantee that some of them will insist that having longer-lived certificates is somehow mandatory. [ Edited: It's the Enterprise Data Center Operators thus EDCO not ECDO ]
- aWidebrant 6y agoECDO sounds cooler.
- jiggawatts 6y agoOr just in IT in general. E.g.: "We have to have a D:\ drive for applications!" That's a rule that last made sense some time in the 90s, when it was feasible to format the system drive, reinstall windows, and then applications on a secondary drive letter would work as-is without any further steps. In the era of 10 GB application installs that deploy several hundred system-shared components, this is a hilariously out-dated mandatory process. Yet. Everywhere I go. There it is: The D:\ drive with "Apps" as the volume name.
- nisse72 6y agoRelated, after telling us for years how dangerous it would be if people flew with more than 100 ml of liquid, it's now allowed (i.e. no longer dangerous?) to carry a larger quantity of hand sanitizer because of coronavirus: https://www.tsa.gov/news/press/releases/2020/04/15/tsas-tips-flying-during-coronavirus-pandemic https://www.tsa.gov/news/press/releases/2020/04/15/tsas-tips...
- HenryBemis 6y agoIn Europe (did a lot of flying lately) the 100ml still stands for sanitizers. You can go over the 100ml only if you got a baby with you and they allow the water/milk for the baby.
- perlgeek 6y agoFunny thing is: once you travel with a baby, basically anything goes. 1L water bottle? no questions asked. Even though the baby won't drink 1L of water on a 2-hours flight. The whole restriction on liquids is fairly ridiculous, and even more of a security theater than most of the other checks. And I think the security guards know it, and use any excuse to look the other way.
- dx034 6y agoMost attackers aren't that smart. Rules like this prevent many from trying an attack as it's much harder to perform an attack if you have to take your baby with you. No one ever said the 100ml rule was good, it was just the best alternative they could come up with.
- mobjack 6y agoTo be fair, traveling with a baby makes you much less likely to attack a plane. This exception makes the TSA's policy more pragmatic and reasonable. The harm of denying a baby milk or formula is worse than the risk of terrorism in this case. Not to mention is that it lowers the incidence of crying babies on flight. The same logic could be applied to hand sanitizer restrictions in a global pandemic. Allowing people to carry a larger size could save more lives than the risk it poses. This is especially true when shortages can make it difficult to buy a travel size.
- ferros 6y agoI have been wondering what some of these middle managers are doing now that they aren’t inventing work for themselves in the office? It must be awfully hard to do this from home.
- cryptica 6y agoThis particular requirement that contractors cannot work from home had a purpose; so that full time employees have at least one advantage over contractors so that employees don't start asking to become contractors. Of course contractors get paid more so it makes no sense to be an employee... That's why companies need these odd rules; to artificially sweeten the worse deal... Even though there is no productivity benefit at all. It's all about exploiting psychology to keep costs down.
- galoisgirl 6y agoOur time on this Earth is limited and we can't do everything. We have to make decisions. "X is required" is shorthand for "we do not want to deal with the consequences of the lack of X". It's a decision. Sure, they could, but they wouldn't have resources to deal with other things. That's basically all there is to understand here. All the rest are corollaries: - Sometimes changed circumstances require revisiting some decisions. Like COVID-19. - You can try and convince people to change their decisions. Your time to do that is limited too. Chose your battles. - Decision fatigue exists. People may not want to make new decisions and will prefer sticking to old ones or push the burden onto other people. Saying it's "imaginary" is childish. Sure, policies may be arbitrary, but the constraint of only having 24 hours in a day is not.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sidcool 6y agoI had this experience with some companies I was interviewing with. They would force me to submit my most recent payslip from my previous employer. I gave up after some protest, coz they could not have proceeded with my interviews without it.
- therealmarv 6y agoIllegal in many other parts of the world (e.g. in Europe).
- as1mov 6y agoOP is probably from India, this is the norm here. Most companies will ask you for your last months of payslips, reason? Nobody knows. In general, companies treat you are like a criminal trying to con them. Submit previous payslips, last company's relieving letter, contacting the previous company, stupid non-compete clauses, bond clauses and list goes on. This is unlikely to change as most employees don't really have the bargaining power to question the rules, the workforce is abundant, they can just tell you to fuck off and hire someone else.
- Perseids 6y agoWell, you could … not have proceeded with the interviews? I'm sorry to state this to you without knowing your personal situation, but in general such shitty employer behavior is only possible because we employees bend to company pressure. Every clause in your work contract you just accept because it is a "standard clause we write in every contract" is a loss for our combined bargaining power.
- Chris2048 6y agoHad you already told them your previous salary?
- sidcool 6y agoYes, that happened a few years ago
- andi999 6y agoMy reason for this rule would be: if you allow consultanta to work from home, how do you make sure they are not double- selling their workhours? Like they bill you 8h, but only work 4h on your project.
- RegW 6y agoHowever they now have to be trusted. It might have been better to have figured out which you trust and only use those.
- growlist 6y agoIndeed, what amazes me is the implicit distrust so many managers have. Either they have a pretty low opinion of people, or they are lazy themselves and projecting. I've had managers openly say to me 'well we have noone else to check your estimation with'. Are there really that many devs out there that estimate 10 days, finish in 1 and take 9 off??
- andi999 6y agoIf you are 10 times faster than the average, but can only bill average rates than it might look fair to you to do the work in 1 day and take 9 off. If then you mortage needs payments, you might think why take 9 days off and not do the same for somebody else. Of course I do not endorse this behaviour, but i can see how somebody could see this not as stealing as it is.
- mugsie 6y agoWhat stops your employees doing the same thing?
- nailer 6y ago> The big question on managers' minds (either consciously or unconsciously) when approving a policy change is "if I do this and anything goes wrong, will I get blamed?". This should not be the basis of choice but in practice it sadly is. This is where things go wrong. The people who would most benefit from the change (and thus have the biggest incentive to get it fixed) do not get to make the call. Instead it goes to people who will see no personal benefit, only risk. This cones very close to hitting the nail on the head but not quite. The crux of the matter is: /Corporate risk aversion culture is only aware of the risk of change, and ignores the risk of stasis./
- mysterydip 6y agoIn one of my previous jobs at a startup (~15 people), the reason for the color scheme we were forced to use on our ecommerce product wasn't the result of some marketing study or human interface recommendation, but rather the personal preference of another employee who had a "special" relationship with the company's president.
- altacc 6y agoIn 1605 there was an attempt to blow up the British Parliament during the state opening by placing explosives in the cellars. 415 years later they still search the cellars for barrels of explosives, using oil lanterns and armed with swords. I feel that so many organisations are doing the same thing, maintaining an old solution for a problem that no longer exists. So I think it's just as, or more, important to apply this thinking to the business requirements which drive development. Half of solution architecture is asking why something is the way it is, and asking again and again until you're sure there's a real reason. A lot of the time the answer is because that's how it's always been and traces back to a technical constraint from long ago. I see this a lot with companies moving from decades old legacy systems to modern applications. Same with processes, authorisations, security risks, etc... They tend to start when somebody mad a mistake and they stick around regardless of if they're still relevant, effective or blocking progress.
- giovannibajo1 6y agoI think this is more typical in public administration. Employees just follow the existing rules/laws because it’s not their job challenging them, and decision makers are mostly concerned on shifting away blame from them. Nobody wants to be that guy that ordered to stop searching for a bomb, the day that a new bomb will be placed. The only reason why one should stop doing it is to gain efficiency (= be more productive but doing less useless things), but the efficiency metric is non existent in public administrations.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago> Employees just follow the existing rules/laws because it’s not their job challenging them, and decision makers are mostly concerned on shifting away blame from them >but the efficiency metric is non existent in public administrations. And both of these have very insidious downstream consequences. The nature of government employment selects over time for people who are dedicated to process for process sake so of course there's nobody around who asks "why?" and nobody around to say "the tradeoff is worth it let's do X instead". Politicians and high level bureaucrats control the resource streams. The less efficient the larger the resource streams and the more power they have. Not only is there no incentive for efficacy at a high level because "screw it's other people's money" but there is an incentive for inefficiency because it lets the people calling the shots preserve/grow their power. The only time you get a push for efficiency is deep in the bowels of a silo/fiefdom where the teams are small and the organizational unit's resource inputs are static but their performance metrics are pegged to outputs. Of course this sentiment dies on the way up the org chart because resources are mostly a "use it or lose it" type thing. One effect is that this drives away exactly the kind of results driven people who should be working as public service. Another effect is that it cements the status quo such that it is basically impossible for a government or government unit to pivot from "being inefficient and generally sucking" to "decent use of taxpayer's money" without an existential crisis for the organization. Basically nobody says "hey, WTF are we doing" while the organization is becoming an ineffective graft ridden mess. Everyone just keeps their head down until a shock forces them to actually solve the problems. This is why you never see government organizations in rich places like NYC, Boston or DC clean themselves up but you occasionally see government organizations in poorer places like Buffalo or Newark clean house because as painful as making do with less and cleaning your own house is to those kinds of organizations the alternative of having politicians do it for you to win brownie points is worse. The rich places can just paper over their organizational problems with money. The poorer places have to stay on task or clean house much more frequently if they don't because there's less money to float along on. BigCos have some similarly bad feedback loops but it's much more common to see them lop off an org that's dead weight because when the metric the people at the top use is profit you get much more incentives value driven behavior.
- legulere 6y agoThe solution to the problem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co-determination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co-determination
- wiradikusuma 6y agoAnother thing is consensus. If you can get buy-ins from a group of colleagues, preferably higher ranks, it'll be easier, as not a single person is to blame.
- ragebol 6y agoStory colleagues told me once: requirements for a car's rear wind shield was that is had to withstand air pressures of 120km/h. But the car could not go in reverse that fast, so the requirement did not make sense and was loosened. On delivery of the produced cars, many rear wind shields were broken. Turns out they were transported from the factory on a train, faced backwards so they could fit more cars on the train. (no idea if this really happened, but it's a nice little story)
- plafl 6y agoIt certainly looks fabricated. Even if they were transported in open wagons only the front of the train feels all the power of the wind.
- gruez 6y agoI feel like the point of the story is supposed to be "all requirements have a reason behind them", but to me it's more of a case of "even a broken clock is right twice a day"
- J-dawg 6y agoIt's interesting that in tech there is this expectation that every available thing should be done to make the employee as happy and relaxed as possible. If an employer refuses to do these things it's met with "does not compute", as in this example. Granted, it does seem to make sense that your employees are as happy and relaxed as possible, but this attitude doesn't seem to exist in other industries to the same degree. For example, I have a friend who works in finance. He was allowed to work from home for the bare minimum amount of time during the pandemic, his company requested him to return to the office almost as soon as the government permitted it (despite his job being possible to do 100% remotely). He also wears formal clothes every day (another thing that is frequently viewed as ridiculous in tech). But, he makes probably 3-4 times what I do per year! It seems that in tech people expect to be "looked after" by their employer more than in other industries, yet simultaneously undervalue themselves. Caveat: this is a perspective from the UK where finance salaries are high, and tech salaries are (as far as I can tell) much lower than the USA.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoYes there's a current trend of thinking that work should be as near play as possible. There are entire classes of work, like digging ditches and driving equipment, that can be sweaty and rote. Not designed to be fun, but to get something done. For pay. This is becoming regarded as mentally or physically abusive. It helps to consider the pay as recompense for whatever hardship you endure to deliver value to the employer. Which seems obvious but apparently is not.
- prepend 6y ago> This is becoming regarded as mentally or physically abusive. An acquaintance of mine working in academia told me that her boss was being bullying and abusive. I was really concerned and asked what was happening. She told me that her boss and department were making her come into the office (pre-covid) at 9am despite that she assured them she could do all her research remotely. When she would not come in or come in late, her boss was verbally reprimanding her. This scenario is certainly bureaucratic and not the funnest, but it’s funny to me that bullying is considered making people come into work at an established time.
- roland35 6y agoI agree with the author about how the risks are more obvious to higher ups than benefits and that is why rules generally stay the same. However, one thing that I learned as a new parent is how important it is to have consistency! I think a lot of computer engineers (ie hacker news) would enjoy an organization which tinkers with policies to find the best way to do things... But I think with a large org things need to be pretty consistent. Now that said, I personally have bristled being in a company which wasn't flexible at all! So the key is to find a balance between consistency and flexibility, and give all levels of management and employees empowerment to find the best way to do things.
- bregma 6y agoCYA has been the driving force that has allowed the species to survive this long. It's a fundamental human instinct that was selected for and reinforced through our long rough evolution on the savanna, just like pattern recognition and dominance games. Do you really want to be the one responsible for wiping us all out?
- SergeAx 6y agoNo rules are appeared by itself from thin air, there was always a cause. Most of the times rules are created to reduce a cognitive load. Thus changing the rules should be based on a cause greater or equal to the one prodiced the rule. No one will change remote working rule just because of one or two outsiders' caprice (calling rule "stupid" shows just lack of understanding). World pandemy is obviously enough cause to change some rules.
- bothersumman 6y agoMany stupid policies held by corporations generally benefit another Corp or uphold other community agreement which were often made at the beginning of operation.
- bothersumman 6y agoMany policy is tangled in initial agreements made with the local community and the Corp. For example, $$ leverage when you have large groups commuting rather working remote. The commerce wheel keeps rolling
- growlist 6y agoSaw the exact same thing from our clients: utterly trenchant opposition to home working, then CV, lo and behold! Immediate switch to home working :D
- dx034 6y agoTo be fair, they probably had to choose between taking risks they previously weren't willing to take (trust in consultants should always be lower than in your own employees in my opinion) but had no choice with Covid. The last months were a matter of life or death for many companies. And to make it clear, I love home working but I also know colleagues who work without screen protection in public places or leave their laptop unlocked when they are at home and have guests. That's potentially horrible for the company but absolutely unenforceable without physical presence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fallingfrog 6y agoSometimes they are not just there out of fear, but also not for your benefit. For instance at one corporation I worked for they made a policy against communicating with other departments outside of jira tickets, in order to clamp down on any union organizing that might take place. And also to prevent us from spreading rumors about an imminent wave of layoffs. Of course they said it was for “security reasons”. So I would assume malice rather than just fear of risk for any seemingly strange policy measures. The management is not your friend.
- julianlam 6y agoOP would be better off sprinkling the occasional comma in their sentences. It is necessary in order to avoid confusion: > Every time someone in the management chain has axed the proposal with some variation of ... A comma is better used after "every time"
- flerchin 6y agoAt least part of OP's problem is that she was a consultant. She didn't work there. Note that in her story, employees of BigCorp did WFH. There's even less upside for BigCorp to change policy because it would positively impact some consultant's work/life balance. In BigCorp's mind, the consultant is exhorbitantly expensive and doesn't deserve work/life balance anyway.
- the_gipsy 6y agoI really like the graph showing "risk of blame".
- nmstoker 6y agoThis is all too common. A friend told me about his company where the IT decision makers were largely centralised, physically near their cloud servers and they frequently discounted the measurable and serious difficulties of internal tech consumers suffered in other locations for years, even though their architecture would have made it comparatively easy to rebalance things for a more global approach. Early in my career we were told of a major reorganization of my then company's network shares, required "Because of Compliance" - only once it was underway and some key points still needed to be clarified did it become clear that Compliance was not even aware of the project! Nothing happened to the individual who had lied and diverted substantial resources needlessly. The individual was not even a member of the department, so saw zero benefit either.
- mumblemumble 6y agoA fun one I experienced was awful VOIP call quality due to a policy requirement that all company network traffic route through the headquarters office, and all the latency that introduced for anyone who worked from one of the (many) other offices. Then one day the director of sales had a rather important call with a major prospective client while they happened to be visiting one of the regional offices. We were enjoying absolutely stellar-sounding phone calls within 48 hours.
- tomxor 6y agoThe whole problem seems to pivot around blame. Having only ever worked at a small company, I've enjoyed the absence of fear of blame. When the hierarchy is so minimal risk-vs-benefit seems to be easy to communicate and digest between both ends of the spectrum and accept with shared responsibility. I understand this doesn't automatically scale, but it feels unsatisfying to assume blame is as inevitable part of growth. Can anyone think of a way to avoid it? Is it a necessary side effect of larger layered hierarchy or is it something else?
- pjmorris 6y agoI once worked for a ~10 person consulting firm. We had a contract to do some IT work for a large firm's HR department. We'd joke that the HR department needed its own HR department, to work out the politics among them. And, we'd joke that we needed clients so we could borrow their office politics so we could have some. My pop-science (I learned about Dunbar's number from Malcom Gladwell's 'Tipping Point') theory for this is that we're wired to think of some small set of people (~150) as 'our group'/'my people', and that within that group we're more likely to forgive, and outside that group, we're more likely to blame.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI work in medical devices and we have a lot of that. We have tons of tedious processes that take a lot of time and don’t improve the product at all. Often they prevent fixing of problems. When you ask why things are that way the answer usually is “the FDA requires it”. But often when you read the latest regulations things it’s easy to see ways to improve our processes and still be compliant. I think the problem is that the company has found something that works in an acceptable manner and there is a big risk that any change will have unforeseen consequences so people stick to what works, no matter how badly. There is another set of internal rules that clearly make life of one function easier at the expense of others. Again, these are very hard to challenge.
- raldi 6y agoWhen someone at a company tells you policy forbids/requires something, ask who is the person setting that policy. Policies without owners are a serious antipattern, since there's nobody to explain or refine them, or add nuance or grant exemptions.
- codingdave 6y agoThis article is talking specifically about corporate policy. It is good to have solid corporate policy, but not so good if it was written without proper forethought, and even worse if they do not have a mechanism to change it. I work in this arena, in the public sector, and COVID brought massive fast changes to policy. But the public sector also already has mechanisms in place to regularly change it - regular board and city council meetings, specifically. And most organizations have a specific cadence on which they review and update their policies. But the corporate world varies - sometimes the board sets policy, sometimes the execs, sometimes a compliance officer. Whomever it is, they need to not just write policy once and forget it - they need to treat it as a living body of documents, responsive to changes in their environment. Some companies are good at this, some are not. I don't buy the conclusion of the article, though, that the leaders don't know enough to make decisions and policy becomes a way to entrench arbitrary rules and escape blame. Risk management and compliance are not about making life easy for the individual contributors. They are about looking at big picture risks such as litigation, regulatory compliance, and business continuity. They then set policy to be sure that well-meaning people who don't have visibility into those high-level concerns don't just make up their own rules. Yes, it puts some pain on us workers. But reduces risk. It is their job to choose those trade-offs. That being said, not everyone is good at it, and there does need to be solid communication in the organization to let them know what problems a policy causes, so they can decide whether or not to adjust it. There also should be a communication path for people to ask why a policy exists, and start a dialogue about it.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoThe author explains this situation as a downside of hierarchical organizations, but what other kinds of organizations are there they can claim real experience with? What the author is describing here is poorly designed management incentives.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mylinkedlist 6y agoExact same story happened to me. I am an Indian contractor working for a US client in US. I asked for work from home in India. Customer manager said security council didn't approve it. He said something like their policy is 'don't take anything to China that you are not ok with loosing, India is one level below it, safeguard everything'. Now Corona happened and the entire team in India has been working from home for last 5 months. Another one is AWS Workspace. I think its the same reasoning - that it is more secure and not having to deal with hardware. But that thing is horrible to use. Constantly getting Windows is on low memory, disconnections which can be recovered from only by a reboot that takes 40 minutes. Even on a good day, everything is slow, you can see the Window maximize/minimize in slow motion, run an IDE and try to debug to get 100% CPU. Join a conference call, can't even open any other Window without frustration. Once I am no longer working for this client, I want to give a piece of my mind to who ever is in charge of this.
- zucker42 6y ago> He said something like their policy is 'don't take anything to China that you are not ok with loosing, India is one level below it, safeguard everything'. I can't imagine someone hiring a person they have such disdain for. That's a pretty sad attitude on the manager's part.
- mylinkedlist 6y agoI believe he doesn't have any disdain for me (except may be for my skills). He had a meeting with the company's security council, and told me the decision afterwards. I think he just heard this line regarding trust from the council meeting. Not sure why he chose to tell me that. I would like to think he was just saying that to convey the mindset of the council people.
- zucker42 6y agoAh that makes sense. I didn't necessarily think he held personal disdain, just I've noticed beyond this situation the way some people seem to treat outsourced workers worse or in a disrespectful way.
- meristem 6y agoCorporate policy evolution through time: 1. given x unit of time passing, the core information that caused the assumption is forgotten or transmuted into something else. 2. given the same x unit of time passing, the context has also shifted but no tools were stated or developed to rethink the assumption. Corporate knowledge management requires effort to be done well.
- beervirus 6y agoThe fact that requirements change when circumstances change DRASTICALLY doesn't mean that they were imaginary. It just means that they were based on a situation that no longer exists. The company reacted to changing circumstances. This is how things are supposed to work.
- makecheck 6y agoI feel like I can deal with most things but “mandatory training” drives me nuts. At one company after another these are always over-produced things that impose way more distraction and time than they need to (all video/audio with little to no text transcript, stupid things like the inability to even click “next” until the unnecessary narrator finishes reading you some slide, etc.). And then they have serious technical lackings like only working in certain browsers or (my favorite) having assessment tests so broken that you literally have to be careful how you type something to avoid correct answers being deemed “incorrect”. It’s always a waste of money and time, at each job I always sent survey feedback telling them this, and no company has ever changed how they do it.
- benji-york 6y agoI like to turn these over-produced mandatory training exercises into speed-runs, posting my results to internal chat.
- wonderlg 6y agoPlaying devil’s advocate: Is it possible that, yes, of course you can work from home, and you must do that during lockdown, but is it as efficient as working in the office? I think that’s why many don’t like remote: They can’t see you working and they’re not as comfortable video-chatting. I’m a remote-only developer, but if I could, at any time, turn to my coworker and ask about something, I’d be more efficient.
- grzm 6y agoWould your coworker be as efficient if you could, at any time, interrupt them? I agree that there are trade offs with remote work vs colocated worm. The ability to interrupt and distract more easily I don’t consider a strength of colocation.
- nawgz 6y ago>if I could, at any time, turn to my coworker and ask about something, I'd be more efficient Haha, I remember when I was in the office before this all started, I had multiple coworkers who would do exactly that. I can't tell you how jarring it is to have headphones in and be in a focus state implementing something, just to have someone imagine they are able to trample on that time for their own efficiency and ask me questions. Doubly worse was they wouldn't even think thru their questions properly Now, we're all remote, and I just hit back at their impromptu questions with "can you give me more context?" and half the time they solve it themselves. Imagine that
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoRevenge culture permeates every pixel of society. Generally, the bigger or more entrenched the entity (corp, agency), the more hardened is the revenge process. Even questioning whether revenge should be shaping our decisions is likely to be met with a measure of it.
- kerng 6y agoI recommend creating your own policy, for yourself and use it similarly in situations. It leads to fun situations and enlightening conversations when its policy versus policy. Who says which policy is more important?
- caymanjim 6y agoThe best way to deal with stupid corporate policies is to ignore them. Working remote when you're not "allowed to" is a big one to ignore, and if you don't have the access credentials you need, it might not even be possible. There are other policies that are much easier to ignore, though. Don't like the dress code? Dress however you want. Don't think the status meeting requires your attendance? Don't go. Mandatory office hours are 9-5 but you have better things to do with your morning? Show up at 11. What are they gonna do, fire you? Not likely. It's hard to hire people, and it's risky to fire people who perform well but flout pointless rules. Maybe some of your coworkers will resent you for thinking you're special and the rules don't apply to you, but don't let their jealousy stop you. If your company isn't going to treat you like an adult, you don't owe them anything.
- nlh 6y agoI really like this approach (and I tend to do this myself), but lots of people get really upset. PG wrote an essay recently in which he talks about “aggressive conformists” and “aggressive non-conformists”. You’re right in that being an aggressive non-conformist at a big company likely (though not definitely) won’t get you fired, but it certainly will rankle the aggressive conformists and not make you many friends from that group. And that may or may not be really bad for your career.
- dougmwne 6y agoProtip: don't follow this advice. Your coworkers will resent you and you'll have a bad time. Corporate rules can be broken, but it should always been done in a savvy way instead of a brazen way. In most orgs, your performance is less important than people's perception and opinion of you. Find a way to show them the respect and deference they crave, even if you break their rules anyway.
- HelloNurse 6y agoBeing annoying and arrogant is bad performance in itself: you are producing irritation and resentment (e.g. giving the impression that rules apply to everyone else).
- 6y ago
- alka0309 6y agoWe're talking about culture in tech, probably relatable: https://zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_rlmnptRyRWi6w73x-blasw https://zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_rlmnptRyRWi6w73x-blasw
- AndrewKemendo 6y agoIt's all imaginary. It's just that people are in different stages of enlightenment: These rules/laws are Real Wait, these rules/laws are made up/flawed The whole thing is made up Nothing is real Lets make up our own rules/laws These rules/laws have a functional place We should build process around these rules Every Generation washes rinses repeats forever. It doesn't matter if it's a corporate "requirement," government involvement or a scientific law, it's the same pattern.
- elwell 6y agoEveryone has their Labor Laws poster printed out and hanging beside their home office desk, right?
- jayd16 6y agoThis is predicated on the idea that the current situation is just as good as office work. That's debatable and even if you think WFH is strictly better there was cost in the growing pains. Just because you think differently about a trade off it doesn't mean decisions you don't like are "imaginary."
- rbanffy 6y agoIn some countries (I am from Brazil, where this is the case), consultants would be allowed to work remotely, because, if they came too often to the office and took direct orders from a manager, they'd be considered employees of the company, not of the consultancy. If you walk like an employee and quack like an employee, you have the legal rights of an employee.
- njharman 6y agoThis and other related issues to "decision makers being so very far removed from any actual work" is why I'm very happy I have never had to work for a company of more than a few hundred people. And hope I never will.
- PaywallBuster 6y agocorps focus on keeping the status quo, little to gain from small gains, big penalty for any possible downside.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- siliconc0w 6y agoA lot of these get baked into boilerplate legal agreements companies end up signing when partnering with other companies or dealing with compliance/certifications/auditors. It can cost a lot in lawyer time to go back and forth renegotiating and redlining contracts to get all these addressed (and it may not even be an option if you're a smaller business). And this is even if people impacted or implementing the requirements are even involved and suitably motivated to pushback.
- Agentlien 6y agoI once worked with a very talented senior artist. After a few years, he told me that he had never once submitted a time report. He felt it was needless busywork and that if he ignored managers and HR nagging about it, sooner or later they just stopped. I was horrified at the audacity and later astounded that he got away with it.
- et2o 6y agoThe two plots are begging to be plotted together ala Econ 101 plots
- me_againnnnnn 6y agoWorking Nuclear at a shipyard, if you exceed exposure limits you are going to get fired. As soon as they don't have enough people for a hot job exposure limits are immediately raised. Wait it's so dangerous I would get fired but not so dangerous that it doesn't matter if you need it done ?