8 ms·
I often see criticism of the school system like yours. I think it comes from a perspective of a fairly intelligent, self-motivated individual, probably from a f
by adrianN 6y ago
I often see criticism of the school system like yours. I think it comes from a perspective of a fairly intelligent, self-motivated individual, probably from a family that valued education. However many children lack one or more of those factors. For them the intrinsic motivation is to play video games all day, or talk to their friends, or smoke weed. There is no intrinsic motivation for most children to learn all the subjects taught in school. I think the school system is fairly good at forcing all children to learn at least a little about all subjects. This comes at the price of not optimally supporting students who would do much better in a different kind of system.
- yellowapple 6y ago> I often see criticism of the school system like yours. I think it comes from a perspective of a fairly intelligent, self-motivated individual, probably from a family that valued education. I ain't vain enough to consider myself even "fairly intelligent", but I can say that I ain't very self-motivated, nor have I been since elementary school, and in hindsight my education system's insistence on strangling such intrinsic motivation in favor of extrinsic motivation is exactly what killed said self-motivation. "Grades are all that matter, and mine ain't anywhere near good enough to go to a good college, so why bother trying?" It's something I'm actively working on trying to fix to this day, but old habits die hard.
- jariel 6y agoDecent high school grades are not that hard to get. It's not 'strangulation' to have to take 'English, Geography, History and Math'. I wish I had paid more attention in English class, I did not respect how important it was going to be until later in life, for example. The course load in Eng. or in Grad School - now that can be overwhelming to the point of exhaustion.
- krageon 6y agoYour experience mirrors mine, but it's not like that for everyone. There's a group of people for which a given level of highschool education is going to be a crushing workload. Minimising their effort doesn't help them to get to a better mindset, so why do it at all?
- ajmadesc 6y agoDecent Eng Grad School grades are not that hard to get. It's not 'exhausting' to have to take 'Electrodynamics, Orbital Mechanics, or Geophysics' I wish I would have paid more attention in Project Management class, I did not respect how important it was going to be until later in life, for example. See how stupid that sounds
- Aeolun 6y agoSounds about as stupid as the first version? Theoretically the courses are probably designed to allow most people to succeed.
- watwut 6y agoYour version sounds stupid, because Electrodynamics and Orbital Mechanics are notoriously difficult classes where even those who passed them use expressions like "working hard" and "difficult". And many students actually fail them. High schoool English, Geography, History and Math is referenced as easy by many students. Typical student does not have a problem to pass that class.
- jariel 6y agoYes, your version does sound stupid. English, Math, History and Geography at the high school level are fairly straight forward, and the subjects are important to a rounded character. They really are not hard. Most of Grad school is utterly gruelling, there isn't time to sleep, students pulled in different directions, and studying mostly arcane subjects that really are not important to anyone.
- yellowapple 6y ago> Decent high school grades are not that hard to get. "Decent" high school grades are seldom adequate to even meet acceptance requirements for "good" colleges, let alone actually compete with the straight-A students also applying to said colleges. Not that this really does anything to address the broader point: that "get into college because you'll make more money" is one of many extrinsic motivators American schools seem to push in order to strangle intrinsic motivators.
- spanhandler 6y agoRight, but the other 99.9% of people don’t go to a “good” college. Plenty of ones that are considered quite good by the Little Folk—the mere commoners—can be attended with grades far from a 4.0 and nothing special in the extracurriculars department, if your test scores are decent (and I assure you, the cutoff for lots of them is way under what you’d consider good)
- cameronbrown 6y agoYour university does not define you. Plenty of people go to a crap university, yet can still be the top of their field one day.
- yellowapple 6y agoIt's easy to say that now, we being adults long out of high school. Do you really expect a high schooler to understand that? I sure as hell didn't back then (my guidance counselor strongarmed me into a curriculum specifically around meeting UC and CSU requirements, despite me having nowhere near the GPA to get into any such school), and thus admission into a 4-year university was an extrinsic motivator that seemed unrealistic and was therefore ineffective.
- cameronbrown 6y agoWell, I only left high school last year... I don't think it's impossible to at least guess this. I think I got very lucky in realising that the school's goals (push me to university) were not aligned with my own.
- jdmichal 6y agoThe forced cadence of certain topics actually does have a part to play. Imagine if you could have skipped all those English classes back then. Guess what? You would be learning it all right now! Just like you're _re_learning it right now. Why? Because you now have intrinsic motivation to learn it. Having entirely skipped it, you might even have realized a lot sooner the actual need instead of limping along with whatever informational crutches you managed to walk away with. The fact that we leave little room to teach the need of a subject, and force feed it in a prescribed manner rather than allowing exploration, is all commingled together into the failure mode being discussed. Allowing children to pick what they want to explore and modeling the education after exploration is part of the baseline for Montessori education. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montessori_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montessori_education
- jariel 6y agoSo I agree about the 'cadence' bit. But this: " Imagine if you could have skipped all those English classes back then. Guess what? You would be learning it all right now!" No, no way. It's a total misunderstanding of education to contemplate this. Education is not 'some facts and things you learn that you may use later'. Education at HS level is much more fundamental than that, particularly English. It's about communicating, developing ideas, writing. Not only is it essential, it takes quite a lot of time and effort, and it's hard to just 'pick up'. I have an Angel investor friend who just set up his own basic website (simple is fine) and wrote his own little intro copy. It's atrocious. Basically, in four sentences in writing, he reveals his own lack of education to anyone who cares to read. I mean - it's not 'that that bad' - but it really is sub professional and embarrassing. He's otherwise very smart, very educated, but it turns out he can't string together a few tightly coherent sentences to make a point. There's no 'going back'. Both of should have paid more attention in school. I do agree with he cadence, I think that school days should be shorter, and there should be more music and sports, shop class and longer term projects.
- jdmichal 6y agoI agree with you. I did intend for that as a thought experiment, but I didn't make that clear. However, the part about teaching the need before the material and leaving time for exploration I'm very serious about. I think it's the biggest change we could make to the system without completely breaking the current structure of it.
- zornthewise 6y agoI am not pursuing a PhD in pure math so I certainly have both interest and ability in doing academic stuff but I found it incredibly hard to get acceptable grades in high school.
- quietbritishjim 6y ago> I am not pursuing a PhD in pure math so I certainly have both interest and ability in doing academic stuff I don't see how the second half of the sentence follows from the first half. Did that "not" slip in by accident? Or do you consider a PhD in pure maths to be evidence of not having academic ability? -- Yours, offended holder of PhD in pure maths :)
- Garlef 6y agoI guess this was written on a phone: "now" became "not"
- garyrob 6y agoI did too. But I've gotten much better at studying/learning over the years, and I attribute my high school problems with grades as a combination of ADD and my head being focused on trying to deal with what, in retrospect, were psychological problems. What I needed back then was a really great therapist and some training in mindfulness meditation. Alas.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago> "Grades are all that matter, and mine ain't anywhere near good enough to go to a good college, so why bother trying?" Or even worse when teachers decide it isn’t worth you trying because they failed to inspire you.
- droopyEyelids 6y agomaybe your vanity is so strong it prevents you from even making a fair judgement of your aptitude relative to the mean
- tmaly 6y ago> Grades are all that matter I think this has shifted somewhat to the standardized tests mattering quite a bit now these days. Should we not consider alternative methods or options for education? What should everything be concentrated into one public model that follows one national standard?
- kqr 6y agoRight. You're touching on another important factor: everyone, and especially children, want to belong to a group. They do this by adopting values similar to their peers. When those peer groups have values that include playing video games and exclude exploring learning, it's very hard to motivate members of the group to explore learning. I don't actually have any data on this, but I suspect that applies even under extrinsic motivators. In other words, telling the cool kids who hate school that they will get bad grades if they don't learn more will not make them learn more. It will simply become a badge of honour to have bad grades. Perhaps the single most important job of a teacher is to attempt to create a single group of the class[1] with which every student identifies, and then imbue that group with the value of learning. I don't think the way to do this is by promising rewards (good grades) for good performance (doing exactly what the teacher asks.) The way to do it is to encourage self-directed exploration and mastery, with a sense of a greater good. (This sounds like something out of an Italian-inspired educational philosophy, but as far as I'm concerned, it's just rather simple reasoning from the principles of motivation and social behaviour as we know them.) In the end, this is a really tough problem. If children are convinced (based on interactions with their peer groups) that learning sucks, then it's really hard to change their mind. This goes for adults as well. I'm not saying there's a magic formula to make everything work out right. What I'm saying is that there are two insufficient and contradictory methods. I think one of them is slightly less bad than the other one. [1]: It might sound like creating multiple groups would be easier and accomplish the same thing, but the danger with that is that small natural variations in the value of learning between these groups could get exaggerated in an attempt to create group identities. I.e. if one group is just about considered more school-happy than the other group, then that will become a point both groups can use to distinguish between themselves: one group will intentionally become more ignorant of the benefits of learning to separate its members from the other. It has to be one single group for them to all adopt the same value of learning. Edit: I almost forgot. For more on this, see The Nurture Assumption – well worth a read.
- mjow 6y agoI also think this is so important and so often improperly addressed in various articles about 'how kids should be taught'. I think most of us who founds 'groups' growing up can relate to this. There is almost an inevitable tendency as well for some form of contrarian group to form, perhaps it's some kind of law of social evolution that some percentage of any assembly of people will not conform and create groups around themselves which will go against the grain. No matter how good your intentions are.
- donw 6y agoI think you're both kinda right? Drive is great. Leverage it heavily as a manager. But when it comes to kids, the problems I see are that (a) cognitively speaking, children are not tiny adults; and (b) if you want them to be successful and happy adults, you need to give kids the ability to work through mountains of "I Need To Do This Even Though It Sucks" Cognitive development is an amazing process to watch -- you can see as brains grow and develop a wide variety of skills we take for granted. But what that means is that you can't treat a six-year-old as an adult. Their thinking is likely highly egocentric, because they have not yet developed the ability to realize that "my feelings and wants" are different from "other peoples' feelings and wants". In their world, when they like Pokemon, they literally believe that everybody in the world feels the same way about Pokemon that they do. They just haven't yet gained the ability to handle that concept. So, up to age eleven or so, you need to put enough structure around children to deal with their cognitive development path. Rules that are consistently enforced are critical (it's also good if those rules, in fact, make sense), with a gradual loosening of constraints as the child grows the ability to handle greater responsibilities. This path continues from eleven -- when, cognitively, your child is now a functioning adult -- onwards towards the age of majority. You still need to provide structure, but with enough freedom and ability to bend-or-change the rules such that the child can learn how to make their own decisions. Your goal is ramp them towards the full set of adult responsibilities, as quickly as they are able to handle it. The problem with a lot of "traditional" education is that it failed to do the latter in a lot of ways -- rigid structure until age of majority, and then bam!, you're an adult, good luck. This is compounded by how much regulation and how little slack there is in society. In the 70s, teenagers commonly brought rifles to school (because they were on the shooting team, or going hunting afterwards). Nowadays, kids are getting expelled for accidentally forgetting a tiny, micro-sized pocketknife. The problem with "modern" education is that there is no expectation that you will ever assume responsibility. If you've dealt with a lot of recent graduates, you probably know what I mean. They have been denied much of the experience required for them to mature as adults, all in the name of keeping them "safe". Including being "safe" from boredom. Which relates to giving kids the ability to get through mountains of drudgery. That skill is so critical. And I didn't really master it until I was an adult, much to my disadvantage. If Elon Musk and every one of his employees were to vanish tomorrow, I'd be sad. SpaceX is cool. But my life would go on. If the organization that handles sewage for my city were to vanish tomorrow, I would soon be, quite literally, in a world of shit. I doubt that working for a sewage treatment plant offers much in the way of Autonomy. Mastery, perhaps? Purpose, absolutely. And I doubt most kids grow up dreaming of being a waste engineer. It's a hard job, and it demands grit. But that job makes modern life possible, and I don't see us setting up kids to be able to tackle both kinds of challenges.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> However many children lack one or more of those factors. For them the intrinsic motivation is to play video games all day, or talk to their friends, or smoke weed. Totally unlike adults then.
- fulafel 6y agoTo be fair, even for an intelligent and educated person it's prettty likely to end with a worse benefit footprint to the world (environmentally & socially) than being with friends and playing video games / smoking weed.
- atoav 6y agoAs someone who in his (mandatory in my country) social year worked with "difficult" kids: for nearly every kid there is intrinsic motivations you can find. Of course that isn't easy and requires much more teachers and a bit more flexibility when it comes to which topics to learn, but good education is making every bodies life better and should be IMO much higher valued both in societal and monetary terms.
- acituan 6y ago> for nearly every kid there is intrinsic motivations you can find I think this can be generalized to all humans. It would be near impossible for a true lack of intrinsic motivation to have made it through evolutionary selection. Like you say, what matters is matching the child's potential with what is available in their current environment, and institutional schooling might be a very blunt tool for that. Not only it is necessarily inadequate for every individual kid, it can also occupy too much time and deprive them from the opportunity to experiment and explore to their niche in society in their unstructured free time.
- adrianN 6y agoI don't like evolutionary arguments because society changes much faster than genetic adaption can keep up with. There was no industry making money off distracting people when our intrinsic motivation system was shaped.
- acituan 6y agoCertainly our environment changes very fast but assuming all adaptation has to happen in the genetic space is fallacious. Humans are already the most generalist species ever existed; even at the most basic level we can live in environments ranging from deserts to arctic, just using our bodies we can locomote through walking, climbing, swimming, and on top of that our offsprings take the most time to raise because so much of our adaptive machinery is installed memetically on that generalist hardware (genes). Besides, even the society we change is part of our niche construction, so we do have influence over it. Maybe not huge as single individuals, but that industry making money off distracting people is still our own making, not a "force of nature", and most of what is done by us can be undone by us.
- jv22222 6y agoCheck out this article about unschooling, you might find it interesting: https://www.vox.com/first-person/2020/7/17/21328316/covid-19-coronavirus-unschooling-homeschooling https://www.vox.com/first-person/2020/7/17/21328316/covid-19...
- rpastuszak 6y ago> However many children lack one or more of those factors. [...] For them the intrinsic motivation is to play video games all day, or talk to their friends, or smoke weed. We grossly overestimate the amount of kids who fall into this group, maybe because we're priviledged enough exclude ourselves from it. > I think the school system is fairly good at forcing all children to learn at least a little about all subjects. Dude, ca. 20% of people in the US are either illiterate or functionally illiterate. How is that good?[1] Unless, given your previous point, they're too busy playing computer games or getting high on Satan's lettuce? Pardon the sarcasm, but this is an extremely dangerous mindset as it distracts us from the actual problem. Edit: source [1] https://www.libraryjournal.com/?detailStory=How-Serious-Is-Americas-Literacy-Problem https://www.libraryjournal.com/?detailStory=How-Serious-Is-A...
- mantas 6y agoI read it as OP saying that illiteracy rate would be even higher if not this system. It’d be great to solve internal motivation issue. It’s damn hard though. Forcing some of them to learn in other ways is better than nothing while we come up with a solution for the core issue.
- cyberdrunk 6y agoYep. I am a fairly intelligent person (your typical coder) from a family that valued education. I was nevertheless never internally driven to do anything. I played a bit with computers when I was a child - BASIC and assembler on C-64, then a little bit of AMOS and computer graphics on Amiga etc. - but it was never any sustained effort that led to anything - I was mostly just satisfying my own curiosity, which didn't run that deep. Instead, I spent the majority of my time playing games (video and otherwise), hanging out with friends, watching TV and reading books. If I wasn't forced to go to school, I think I'd just do more of those things (certainly that's what I did during vacation time). I think what the highly internally driven people cannot understand is that they're the minority and majority of people is more like me.
- qwertox 6y agoIn German "to educate/bring up someone" is "jemanden erziehen". "erziehen", if translated literally, means "to pull", "er" is something like "to act" while "ziehen" means "pull" Sometimes it feels like that, that it is necessary to pull someone into a certain direction in order to better that person. And this is usually not easy to do.
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoFair enough - but my solution to that has always been, 'pay children to pass their classes'. That would be an extrinsic motivator the kind of families you're referencing would respect. And annoyingly, when I bring this proposal up, most people talk about how important it is for learning to be intrinsically motivated.
- decasteve 6y ago> This comes at the price of not optimally supporting students who would do much better in a different kind of system. It depends on the culture of the place the school system is applied in. This kind of blanket utilitarianism by way of school is a sad state for society as a whole. In a country like Canada we have a sordid past, very recently, when implementing the residential school system [0]. That's the more extreme case but I'd argue that elements of that exist in every school system when applied in a one-size-fits-all fashion and when that system has a monopoly on education. [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Indian_residential_school_system https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Indian_residential_...
- ksdale 6y agoIt doesn't seem self-evident that forcing kids to learn a little about all subjects has that much benefit. I do taxes for a living and we have a lot of tradespeople as clients, and their life histories are surprisingly frequently - do miserably in school to the point that their self-esteem is destroyed, spend a few years bumming around, drinking too much, playing video games, get a job in the trades, realize they can make more money owning their own business, etc. By the time they come to us, you'd never be able to tell they were the worst students ever. How many people never make it out of the drinking and playing video games phase because school has convinced them that they're failures? A lot of kids would be perfectly happy starting some sort of apprenticeship when they were teenagers, and it's not obvious to me that that would be worse than forcing them through the remainder of school. I think it's hard to tell the difference between kids who have an intrinsic motivation to play video games, and kids who have an intrinsic motivation to do anything but school and have to default to video games because the world doesn't offer much of an avenue for kids to be productive on their own (unless you happen to be very interested in computers and have access to one and the internet). I say all this as someone who thinks education is profoundly important. I just don't think as much education happens in schools as we'd like to believe, especially for people who don't fit neatly in the system.
- yummypaint 6y agoFor them the intrinsic motivation is to play video games all day, or talk to their friends, or smoke weed. There is no intrinsic motivation for most children to learn all the subjects taught in school. This is a false dichotomy that gets reinforced everywhere to the detriment of all students. There is no reason those things should be mutually exclusive, but we make it so by the power of our collective expectations. Lots of people are discouraged and pushed away from their areas of interest because they aren't seen as fitting a stereotype or mold. Some people never even get a chance to discover that they have academic interests, and are effectively placed on a "remedial" track from the time they enter the school system because of their background. The messaging is that they cannot succeed without external motivation, which sets them up for failure. On the other side of the coin, it also contributes to the unhealthy pressures advanced students face. Building rigid assumptions into the education system about how students spend their leisure time is part of what kills diversity.
- tmaly 6y agoI suspect that many kids do not understand the why behind many of the subjects being taught. What intrinsic motivation could they have under these circumstances?