11 ms·
For anyone interested in this type of stuff, I can recommend reading Drive. Briefly, human behaviour can be motivated for extrinsic and intrinsic reasons. The
by kqr 6y ago
For anyone interested in this type of stuff, I can recommend reading Drive.
Briefly, human behaviour can be motivated for extrinsic and intrinsic reasons. The rewards in this article are extrinsic motivators. Exploring is rewarding in an intrinsic way; it is a strive towards autonomy, mastery, and purpose.
In adults (and in older children) applying extrinsic motivators kills intrinsic motivation. Once the extrinsic motivators stop coming in, there is no desire left to do the task. Intrinsic motivation is practically infinite, as long as the environment is set up right to enable it.
Extrinsic motivation also tends to produce behaviour that does the bare minimum to get the reward (or avoid the negative consequences) whereas intrinsic motivation is what makes us want to excel.
Of course, I've skipped many important points and not countered any counterargument here, but I recommend reading Drive first if you think you disagree.
But the worst part of it all?
The schooling system, with its grades, signed slips, and whatnot, is set up through extrinsic motivation to teach obedience, conformity, and smothering the intrinsic drive so necessary for the creative work we will expect from the children later in life.
- andrei_says_ 6y agoAlso Alfie Kohn’s Punished by Rewards, a thick tome dedicated to the research and reasons of how and why punishment and rewards don’t teach what’s intended and don’t motivate as intended... and how extrinsic motivation kills intrinsic motivation. Withdrawing rewards is punishment so both are really the same. Human beings are not designed to be trained like rats and birds, regardless of what many believe. If your kid is good at something and you want them to lose interest, encourage or reward them for doing the thing :) Or force them to do it. Just like school system does with learning.
- tpxl 6y ago>If your kid is good at something and you want them to lose interest, encourage or reward them for doing the thing :) Genuine question: What do you do if you want them to get better then?
- kqr 6y agoEngage yourself in what they are doing. Describe what you see. Tell them what that makes you feel. Be objective, rather than judging of their performance. "You have been trying to find that bug for hours. That's true perseverance!" "I like the sound effects you added. They really draw me into the game even more." "It sounds like you're using a technology you haven't before. Trying is the only way to learn new things." "This runs so smoothly!" Also, ask questions. "How did you get the enemy to follow my character?" "I feel like the game is unfair when I die here. Is there anything you can do to make this section not so difficult?" "I understood what I was meant to do right away. Can you think of why that was?" Note how you don't even have to be positive when you do it this way. Simply sharing the experience goes a long way. Encouraging critical thought and decision-making makes it even better.
- kqr 6y agoPunished by Rewards is in my reading heap but rather far down. Maybe I should prioritise it slightly higher. > Human beings are not designed to be trained like rats and birds, regardless of what many believe. I'd just want to add that according to Drive, training humans like rats and birds work great... If blind obedience, conformity, and minimal quality is something you're looking for -- which many factory line type managers wanted, for a very long time (and in many cases probably still do, sadly.) Damnit, if Punished by Rewards contradicts this, I have to read it now, don't I?
- dpwm 6y agoI'm currently reading Punished by Rewards. So far I would say that Punished by Rewards is broadly consistent with how you describe Drive. Alfie Kohn acknowledges that where the work is low skill, very dull, requires little collaboration, rewards generally work for as long as the rewards continue. But employee of the month? Stack ranking? Basically they're just going to destroy any intrinsic motivation, and lead to teams where people are reluctant to collaborate.
- andrei_says_ 6y agoThey are consistent... controlling people with punishment and rewards works, as long as the incentive is present, at the cost of destroying intrinsic motivation. It also changes the relationship, positioning the “manager” as a prison guard of sorts and tying them to that role. It teaches its subjects to do the thing but only if they get the reward and never otherwise. To comply, but only when watched, and to act in secret when fulfilling their true needs. His book focuses on parenting and one can see how punishment and rewards impact this most important relationship and negatively impact intrinsic motivation in exchange for the illusion of control.
- kqr 6y agoThen again, if one is more interested in practically applicable tips, the book How To Talk So Kids Will Listen... And Listen So Kids Will Talk is great too -- for all kinds of interpersonal relationships. It covers empathy (actually listening and confirming feelings) but is largely about how to enable extrinsic motivation, through encouraging autonomy, mastery, and purpose. One rather concrete example is that the authors argue it is no good to say, e.g. "if you take a bath you'll get this nice gift" or "if you don't take a bath I will remove your video gaming time for the day." More effective, according to the authors, are to give a choice, even if it is somewhat of a forced one: "I want you to take a bath. Do you want to bathe with your boat or your duck?" This, then, would speak to the same desire to explore as the hidden option in the article. (Or, the way I view it having read Drive: this gives the child a hint of autonomy.)
- jay_kyburz 6y agoThe question trick only works for so long. Pretty soon your kids realize there is always a third option that can be negotiated to. (Which is good) About that time you need to explain why we have regular baths.
- touisteur 6y agoBut it's great! They learn to pick-up when they're 'tricked' and they learn to chose. Man, I remember when I started deciding things for myself... at 16-17! 'so you want to go to prep school, university, or eng. school?' WTF I don't even know what I want for dinner... I feel this is something that needs to be trained the soonest possible. See what you feel when asked to chose. Decide something. See how you feel when you've taken option A or B (or feel when you don't like any of the available options! And learn to think outside the box!). See what happens when you change your mind before you started A. Or after you've started B and think 'I should have done A'. With your parents, friends, teachers. It's amazing how teaching this to my little kids with a positive and caring attitude has shown me how hard and important it all is! And it's even harder for collective decisions! Something amazing for twin children: they also have the opportunity (or the burden sometimes) to see how their choices affect others and how important negociating, defending, compromising is. Those books that GP cited are gold. The whole Positive Education movement is, I think, a way to a better future, with balanced and reasonable members of the citizenry. And I ache for all the children with have parents that don't even have the tiniest bit of empathy and interest for their children.
- discordance 6y agoThis describes 'work' life pretty well, with extrinsic motivation being a salary. If that spigot were shut off there certainly would be little desire to do the task for most.
- kqr 6y agoTrue as that may be, I think the argument that resonated with me is that there is an even more primitive type of motivation than extrinsic: the drive to survive. (Or, more generally, physical and emotional needs.) Under that hypothesis, the salary is there to take physical needs as a motivator off the table. If an employee has to worry about physical needs, there's no room at all for any other concern. Once the salary is sufficient to no longer be a point of worry (will I afford my mortgage, can I support my spouse, etc) only then will additional money serve as extrinsic motivation. (Which of course spells disaster for things like performance bonuses, which (a) are impossible to target at the right people (see Deming for more on that) and (b) literally designed to stop coming, reducing motivation overall.)
- tolbish 6y agoCan you elaborate on point (b)? I don't quite get what you mean. Performance bonuses are designed to stop happening altogether?
- Swizec 6y agoI think for most people a salary is just the constant, like air. You get it and it’s the reason you show up everyday. But your salary doesn’t change if you work hard or slack. It’s not a reward for performance. Similar to how you’d die without breathing but you don’t feel rewarded for every breath. You wouldn’t breathe more than someone else to get more alive.
- yellowapple 6y ago> But your salary doesn’t change if you work hard or slack. It’s not a reward for performance. Maybe not in an immediate sense, but working hard ostensibly makes it more likely to get promoted to a position with a higher salary, while slacking ostensibly makes it more likely to get demoted or fired. Of course, I say "ostensibly" because the real world doesn't really work like that, with hard workers getting shafted and lazy pricks schmoozing and politicking their way into the very positions those hard workers should've gotten. It'd be disheartening, but it happens to be a decent treatment for my impostor syndrome: everyone else is an impostor, too, so might as well just play along.
- dmead 6y agois mastery a new word that's come up in education? i can't help but (red) flag that word in the context of teaching children these days, maybe before the wrong people have said it.
- ornornor 6y agoWhat? Why?
- dmead 6y agoI was right. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastery_learning#General_concerns_and_opinions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastery_learning#General_conce... The only person I've heard say "mastery" are Betsy devos (when she was getting grilled by warren at her senate confirmation) and some religious conservatives i know that homeschool their children. My general impression is that it's a marketing gimmick by carter schools that want to show they're somehow innovating in education. This is probably all horse shit as the longer term outcomes in devos type schools are really bad (see: michigan). anyway, it's a flag. probably a big red one. I doubt it's taken seriously by regular school teachers whos models come from Columbia university.
- throwaway5792 6y agoSo what's wrong with it?
- kzzzznot 6y agoFirst I’ve heard of this, just copied a section from the linked Wikipedia page: > The Chicago Mastery Learning Reading program was criticized for a focus on testing. A concern is that children were taught to pass tests without a focus on enduring skills. The duration of the retention of skills was questioned.
- adrianN 6y agoI often see criticism of the school system like yours. I think it comes from a perspective of a fairly intelligent, self-motivated individual, probably from a family that valued education. However many children lack one or more of those factors. For them the intrinsic motivation is to play video games all day, or talk to their friends, or smoke weed. There is no intrinsic motivation for most children to learn all the subjects taught in school. I think the school system is fairly good at forcing all children to learn at least a little about all subjects. This comes at the price of not optimally supporting students who would do much better in a different kind of system.
- yellowapple 6y ago> I often see criticism of the school system like yours. I think it comes from a perspective of a fairly intelligent, self-motivated individual, probably from a family that valued education. I ain't vain enough to consider myself even "fairly intelligent", but I can say that I ain't very self-motivated, nor have I been since elementary school, and in hindsight my education system's insistence on strangling such intrinsic motivation in favor of extrinsic motivation is exactly what killed said self-motivation. "Grades are all that matter, and mine ain't anywhere near good enough to go to a good college, so why bother trying?" It's something I'm actively working on trying to fix to this day, but old habits die hard.
- jariel 6y agoDecent high school grades are not that hard to get. It's not 'strangulation' to have to take 'English, Geography, History and Math'. I wish I had paid more attention in English class, I did not respect how important it was going to be until later in life, for example. The course load in Eng. or in Grad School - now that can be overwhelming to the point of exhaustion.
- krageon 6y agoYour experience mirrors mine, but it's not like that for everyone. There's a group of people for which a given level of highschool education is going to be a crushing workload. Minimising their effort doesn't help them to get to a better mindset, so why do it at all?
- jariel 6y agoThis is all fine and good but it misses some much more fundamental drivers, not those that are narrowly instinctive. If you want to play the violin beautifully, you have to practice for 10 years, there's no way around it. If you want to do important things, you have to train in all sorts of capacities, and put in a lot of sweat. One of the things that differentiates humans from beasts is that we have at least some sense of higher purpose and many of us derive considerable fulfilment from that. For the most part, most of our education is necessary - and the ability to focus, to plan, to think beyond just a few steps, to control one's desires and emotions, to concentrate and balance one's life energies - this requires education and maturity. Yes, it can be stifling in some ways, that's ok, we want our doctors and accountants (mostly) to be small-c conservatives. Others can write Operas. But none of it comes without a formal journey at least in some capacity. It's a neat experiment but I think it's hard to determine the results. The novelty of exploration in that context just might not be 'novelty' from the adults perspective. Try trading rewards for truly novel things, like, jumping out of planes, I wonder what the result would be.
- rajansaini 6y agoI want to respond to your point about violin-playing, because I think it will open up an interesting discussion. Anecdotally, I was always motivated to practice my instruments by the same exploratory drive discussed in the article. I was taught to ask, "what if I did XXX this way?", i.e., what happens to my sound if I play long tones, what techniques do I need to play piece Y, how do I use scale Z to improvise? Growing up, I found that those who ran on pure extrinsic factors with all discipline and no enjoyment either stopped or were stunted by locally optimal decisions. On the other hand, those who went on to study in university and play professionally seemed to derive the same obsessive enjoyment from their craft as I would a video game. Do you think these data points further prove your point about emotional maturity? Or is there something more universal, that true success requires a fierce passion?
- chrisdirkis 6y ago> If you want to play the violin beautifully, you have to practice for 10 years, there's no way around it. > > If you want to do important things, you have to train in all sorts of capacities, and put in a lot of sweat. I don't know the source of this, but I remember reading that most people who become good at things, by practicing for 10 years or whatever, were intrinsically motivated to do so. It's not a process of "want to be good -> force self to practice -> become good", but more of "want to practice -> become good". Can't remember if this was just conjecture, and I'm not a citeable source myself, but it seems like a more likely story. I know I've heard stories of talented people who got where they are because they spent all day noodling on the guitar, or writing programs, but I've heard less stories about people who didn't really enjoy the practice but forced themselves into it via willpower. Not to say that "just noodling" is all that the person needed, or that no willpower was required, but that the process might be more intrinsic for the people who are actually going to become great anyway.
- hrktb 6y agoWhy such a dichotomy between intrinsic and extrinsic when any situation is a mix of both ? We do our job to get money, but we won't do any job for that sole purpose. Kids learn chemistry because they are forced to, but they'll find fun bits here and there, they'll ask teachers questions to better understand what they're taught. They won't give a crap about half of the curriculum, but the half they'll remember and will be formative is not guaranteed to be solely from the self-motivated part either. Going further what motivates us to explore also depends on the environment, what is rewarded and what is not, etc. I feel splitting things in two theoretical extremes is close to labelling actions good or bad, it's useful if we don't care about nuance, but has little use once we dive below the surface. > I recommend reading Drive first if you think you disagree. I remember getting that recommendation for "Getting Things Done" ... is Drive much better as a reading experience ? Is it readable for people who're not into self help books in general ?
- kqr 6y agoBecause there is some evidence that extrinsic motivation outcompetes intrinsic motivation. In other words, for some reason, they cannot coexist. As soon as adults feel extrinsically motivated, they start to view the situation as an economic transaction, where they will only perform tricks for treats. Typical real-world example of this: if you start charging parents (punishment) for coming late to pick up their kids from daycare, parents will become more late. One can speculate that this might be because they start thinking of it as "paying for extra time" rather than "being a nice human being to the daycare staff." The cases you mention where they do indeed apparently coexist, I suspect (but have no data to support) that the children successfully manage to ignore the extrinsic motivation because the intrinsic drive is so powerful in that instance. It's probably not a sustainable model to rely on that happening, though. Drive is decidedly not a self-help book. It's a summary of the available evidence in support of and against the existence of intrinsic motivation and how it relates to the other types of motivation (extrinsic and physical and emotional needs.)
- hrktb 6y ago> In other words, for some reason, they cannot coexist. I would be interested if you have some pointers. I've tried searching a bit but didn't hit anything. Intuitively there is a lot of things that I want intrinsically to do, but I will do a calculation wether I'll have external motivations/rewards to do it and decide from there. For instance I intrincically like programming. It still doesn't mean my intrinsic motivation to program disappeared because I get paid, nor that I won't be exploring thing that I am curious about and try to align external motivation to help me explore them. > if you start charging parents (punishment) for coming late to pick up their kids from daycare, parents will become more late. I know this case study, but as a parent I don't see this on a personal level. To put it on a different case, you get fined for parking on priority/handicaped places, but don't see rich people everywhere abusing priority parking. Some do, but most don't, so at least a majority of them don't see it as just an economic transaction. As usual, reality is more complicated.
- smhg 6y ago> The schooling system, with its grades, signed slips, and whatnot, is set up through extrinsic motivation to teach obedience, conformity, and smothering the intrinsic drive so necessary for the creative work we will expect from the children later in life. I think your expectations of the schooling system are simply skewed. At least in the countries which I lived in (Europe) the 'customer' of the schooling system is first and foremost society as a whole. The individual, the child, comes second. Not in a way that children are not important. It's just that the outcome of a well organised society is what matters. So, although not in extreme ways of course (there is no evil mastermind), conformity and the likes are important values.
- mhaberl 6y agoI agree with this. We all love to say that we want creative free thinking individuals.. but come on now - currently the society is mostly composed of conformed (without this society probably would not function, at least as it does now) and in a lesser extent the obedient. The creative and free thinking individuals push us all foward and we would not advance without them, but the majority is different. Schooling system is not what it is by accident.
- kqr 6y agoActual, socially beneficial conformity is produced just fine on its own with how humans generally are social group animals that want to fit in and not be embarrassed from doing weird, unfair, or harmful stuff. Simply interacting with other people is what makes humans follow meaningful rules. That happens whether or not we're rewarded for being good dogs in the eyes of adults. Conformity to arbitrary procedures and sets of rules is not helpful anywhere, and that's what school gives us.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoTry getting children to learn to play guitar or piano or math purely through intrinsic moyovation. They might be into it for a bit, but not enough for regular practice. But, when they have enough skill, they can then develop further intrinsic motivation to really get good. Everything in moderation.
- circlefavshape 6y ago+1 It takes at least 5 years of learning piano to get good enough to enjoy it. IMO this is why adults almost never take it up - we're just not prepared to invest in something that takes so much work with such a distant payoff
- criddell 6y agoThat might be due to the way music is taught. Rocksmith is a guitar playing video game that can be fun from day one. I don't see why similar concepts couldn't be used to teach just about any musical instrument.
- agumonkey 6y agoThis is how I survive usually. I turn whatever externally imposed duty is imposed into something that will tickle my inner curiosity / desire. Extrinsic motivation, IMO, is akin to an exchange or bargain, you have to develop a sense or skill to know how to make them. ps: more generally I'm very curious about the topic of 'pedagogics' and also the way to create harmonious, high level work environment between people (all motivated by few years of seeing nothing but drag, pain and waste in too many workplaces). If you know board, MLists or else, ping me.
- aaron695 6y ago> The schooling system, with its grades, signed slips, and whatnot, is set up through extrinsic motivation to teach obedience, conformity, and smothering the intrinsic drive so necessary for the creative work we will expect from the children later in life. We finish 50 million kids in school each year. 100's of millions have been through the US system alone over it's history. If this was simply true then I feel like there'd be some evidence by now. Yes we can do better schooling for some kids, and yes there are certainly improvements, but after 100's of year of doing it, it's not going to be a country wide system of let kids just have more freedom. The best improvement we know of is cohorts matter. Which is a zero sum game.
- betterunix2 6y agoActually the modern concept of a school was developed to train people for industrial jobs, where they would have to follow instructions and a schedule set by their superiors -- hence the strict scheduling, the rank-and-file arrangement of classrooms, and so forth. Prior to the industrial revolution most children did not go to a formal schools, and would receive their education from parents and tutors, or by some other ad-hoc arrangements. In some parts of the world it was common for traveling teachers to board with a family for some time and educate the children.
- rubidium 6y agoI don’t think anyone is encouraging total unstructured freedom. I went to a school without grades. It encourages cultivating a love of learning. There was concrete feedback on quality of work and assessments of knowledge (tests). But no public grading scale. It’s been awarded 3 blue ribbon awards and consistently outperformed its grading-based peers.
- aaron695 6y agoI know it's a lame answer because I can answer it to most new schooling concepts Cohorts. If all the students you schooled with could easily come from the other available systems and your school could only expel them at the same rates as the other schools I'd be happier.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- barrenko 6y agoI've been meaning to read that for some time now.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoI think you might like this interview with the now deceased but brilliant contrarian educator John Taylor Gatto, in which he speaks about just that in the schooling system and the crazy changes he saw when he said he moved towards a more intrinsic motivation system, though he didn't use those terms: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQiW_l848t8&list=PL463AA90FD04EC7A2 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQiW_l848t8&list=PL463AA90FD...
- narag 6y agoNot a native speaker, I can understand but his speech gives me a hard time. Could you share a pointer to a relevant segment? The complete interview is five hours!
- arminiusreturns 6y agohttps://youtu.be/YQiW_l848t8?list=PL463AA90FD04EC7A2&t=1640 https://youtu.be/YQiW_l848t8?list=PL463AA90FD04EC7A2&t=1640 is a decent starting section, and I know he is hard to listen to, but very worth it and you get used to his speaking style over time. That said, here is a transcript: https://www.scribd.com/document/76968236/SOURCED-TRANSCRIPT-The-Ultimate-History-Lesson-A-Weekend-with-John-Taylor-Gatto https://www.scribd.com/document/76968236/SOURCED-TRANSCRIPT-...
- cameronbrown 6y ago> The schooling system, with its grades, signed slips, and whatnot, is set up through extrinsic motivation to teach obedience, conformity, and smothering the intrinsic drive so necessary for the creative work we will expect from the children later in life. As a teen, I think I would've agreed with you on this, but looking back personally, I think boundaries inspired my creativity to break out of them.
- boundaries99 6y agoBoundaries are intrinsic for kids with no life experience. Obedience to hierarchy around stuff collecting is extrinsic. One must learn facts and emotional character to tell grandpa go away. We’re far to servile to decades old delusions of grandeur. Extreme ownership of social agency by one circular meme isn’t good enough.