17 ms·
Brazil Bolsonaro: Facebook told to block accounts of president’s supporters
- thimabi 6y agoThe technical argument from the court is quite intriguing. The Supreme Court justice only wants to prevent access to the blocked profiles within Brazil. However, he says Facebook should not allow Brazilians themselves to view such profiles by “subterfuge” (by changing their registered country on Facebook settings or using VPNs, according to the Court’s tech advisors). In the end, the most efficient way for Facebook to comply with this order is a worldwide ban. Facebook may have a shot at reversing the ban and the fines on its appeal. But it certainly doesn't help that several previous orders on this case had been ignored before.
- cma 6y agoThe plus side may be that social media is split up country by country and communicates via federation. Then ad revenue from zero sum competitive spending can remain in country instead of 15% of small business income and taxi dispatch fees flowing out of the countries to a couple winner take all, first mover advantage, megacorps located in America.
- ben_w 6y agoWhile that sounds desirable in itself, I don’t think it would actually solve the issue the judge is concerned about.
- emn13 6y agoIt would render american social media largely irrelevant in brazil, and vice versa: some call it the balkanization of the internet. On the one hand, that's a terrible shame - on the other, the extreme lack of accountability and monopolistic power of the internet giants may mean that's the most pragmatic route for some accountability. I'm not sure what to make of all this, but I definitely don't think it's anything simple or clearcut.
- irthomasthomas 6y agoWhere did you read the technical arguments? The article doesn't mention them. In fact, the article is very light on information, and only left me confused about the situation, like why are the presidents supporters calling for a coup? And how does blocking a dozen accounts change anything, really? Would the people behind them not simply open more sockpuppet accounts?
- ratww 6y ago> why are the presidents supporters calling for a coup Acts asking for a militar coup have been happening for the last few years among the radical right. Their demands are not clear enough, so most news reports are about them happening and events surrounded them, such as the president appearing in some of them. [1] [2] --- I'm not going to guess what they want, so let's just translate what their banners say. Hopefully I can be unbiased. - "Military intervention / Close the supreme court and congress / With Bolsonaro as president" [3] - "Military tribunal", "Criminalize Communism", among others I can't read [4]. - "Military intervention so that Bolsonaro can govern". In the back: "criminalize communism" [5]. - "AI-5 with Bolsonaro in power" [6]. The last one is about AI-5. AI-5, according to Wiki: "resulted in the forfeiture of mandates, interventions ordered by the President in municipalities and states and also in the suspension of any constitutional guarantees which eventually resulted in the institutionalization of the torture commonly used as a tool by the State." [7] The previous reference is in english. --- > And how does blocking a dozen accounts change anything, really? Would the people behind them not simply open more sockpuppet accounts? Some of them are under house arrest and forbidden from using social networks. [7] The others are stopped for different reasons, but according to a news website "there's still no information about the reasons". [8] If they open sock puppets, this will probably be dealt with in a case by case basis. --- Sorry for the excessive number of sources. This is still ongoing and very hard to explain, so I have no recourse. [1] https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-52353804 https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-52353804 [2] https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2020/04/19/bolsonaro-discursa-em-manifestacao-em-brasilia-que-defendeu-intervencao-militar.ghtml https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2020/04/19/bolsonaro-d... [3] https://media.gazetadopovo.com.br/2020/04/22162620/manifestacao-intervencao-brasilia-sergio-lima-afp-960x540.jpg https://media.gazetadopovo.com.br/2020/04/22162620/manifesta... / https://mediastorage.cnnbrasil.com.br/IMAGES/00/00/00/3368_745E8B537C8E0C3D.jpg https://mediastorage.cnnbrasil.com.br/IMAGES/00/00/00/3368_7... [4] https://conteudo.imguol.com.br/c/noticias/c0/2020/06/21/21062020---ato-de-apoiadores-de-bolsonaro-tem-pedidos-anticonstitucionais-de-intervencao-militar-1592766183921_v2_450x337.jpg https://conteudo.imguol.com.br/c/noticias/c0/2020/06/21/2106... [5] https://static.poder360.com.br/2020/06/Apoiadores-Bolsonaro-QG-Exercito-IntervencaoMilitar-Constituicao-comunismo-27-868x644.jpg https://static.poder360.com.br/2020/06/Apoiadores-Bolsonaro-... [6] https://static.poder360.com.br/2020/04/bolsonaro-AI-5.jpg https://static.poder360.com.br/2020/04/bolsonaro-AI-5.jpg [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_Act_Number_Five https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_Act_Number_Five [8] https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-53570792 https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-53570792 [9] https://economia.ig.com.br/2020-07-31/luciano-hang-da-havan-tem-conta-retida-no-twitter-pela-justica.html https://economia.ig.com.br/2020-07-31/luciano-hang-da-havan-...
- htk 6y agoCensorship is so repugnant, yet so complicated. What should be prohibited to be said, if anything? Who draws the line?
- dudus 6y agoExactly. It's possible these accounts are fake, paid by the own politicians to spread misinformation and fake news. But it's possible it's not. Brazilian courts have also become increasingly political which means a large portion of the population won't agree with their decision. It's ugly, and I have no idea what Facebook can do.
- coliveira 6y agoFacebook has to follow the law. Now, we can debate if the law is fair or not, but distributing in Brazil the content of these accounts goes against the law.
- jasonlingx 6y agoThe Brazilian Supreme Court is asking Facebook to block accounts globally, not only in Brazil.
- coliveira 6y agoThe issue is that members of Bolsonaro's fake news group were moving abroad to continue spreading their "content" from outside Brazil.
- boring_twenties 6y agoAsking? Is that what they're doing?
- User23 6y agoMore or less. I doubt Mr. Bolsonaro is going to make much effort to enforce this ruling, even if he could.
- iron0013 6y agoSounds like they were engaging in straight-up slander—-even worse than if they had “cancelled” their victims, whatever that actually means.
- smt88 6y agoSlander is a reason to have slander suits, not a ban on a class of people imposed on a social network. I'm all for the free market (i.e. users) pressuring social networks to ban certain groups, like pedophiles or neo-Nazis. I'm deeply against a government telling a social network that any broad class of people should be banned, especially if they're mainstream enough that their leader is in office.
- foepys 6y ago> I'm deeply against a government telling a social network that any broad class of people should be banned, especially if they're mainstream enough that their leader is in office. Even if those people are calling for a coup d'etat to change the democracy into a dictatorship and place this leader at the top?
- smt88 6y ago> Even if those people are calling for a coup d'etat to change the democracy into a dictatorship and place this leader at the top? If they are calling for violence, I support govt censorship only of the violent speech and only if each case is considered individually.
- pjc50 6y agoThis is the outcome of the slander lawsuits: Facebook has been ordered to stop publishing slander.
- smt88 6y agoI meant individual slander suits.
- thrway1299723 6y agoIt is worth noting that both Facebook and Twitter have appealed, citing that the measures have been too drastic. Given Twitter's and FB's history, and the fact that Bolsonaro supporters tend to be more "right wing", that's when you know that the Brazilian court order is WAY out of line ...
- vmception 6y agothat's pretty funny, but no they just don't want to deal with it, all they hear is "what do you mean, lose users?"
- hu3 6y agoI sure hope they can reverse it in court. Otherwise this will be a precedent for that judge to block any account it sees fit under the threat of imprisoning a Facebook or Twitter employer. > Given the threat of criminal liability to a local employee, at this point we see no other alternative than complying with the decision by blocking the accounts globally, while we appeal to the Supreme Court.
- gjvnq 6y ago> I sure hope they can reverse it in court. This will be diffcult because the original order already came from our Supreme Court. However, it was decided/signed by a single justice/judge. The appeal asks for the matter to be decided by whole court (11 justices).
- rumanator 6y ago> I sure hope they can reverse it in court. Otherwise this will be a precedent for that judge to block any account it sees fit The ruling was based on track records of conducting libel campaigns targetting anyone who could jeopardize Bolsonaro's political goals, not to mention supporting military coups to allow him to become president for life and silence any critic. And it seems you're missing the fact that the ruling specifically targets sock puppet accounts controlled by a couple of Bolsonaro Minions, such as the leader of Bolsonaro's party and one of Bolsonaro's main backer. The judge didn't based his decision on whims.
- hu3 6y agoThe issue here is, as stated in the article, facebook was ordered to block worldwide access to facebook accounts based on brazilian law. I couldn't care less about what said accounts were posting if they were protected by the 1st amendment. The problem here is the precedence of an overreach.
- rumanator 6y ago> The issue here is, as stated in the article, facebook was ordered to block worldwide access to facebook accounts based on brazilian law. It really isn't. ISPs are also required to cut access to illegal content. Facebook is a service provider that willingly provides access to illegal content, thus it is required to take it down. That's the whole point of the ruling.
- ve55 6y agoVery glad I'm not Facebook. No matter what choices you make, millions (or billions) will hate you. Is decentralization the only solution, if it even is one?
- flattone 6y agoI suppose at MZ's level what billions think of you means nothing.
- ianbicking 6y agoWhat would decentralization accomplish?
- gruez 6y agoWhat is it going to take for facebook to voluntarily exit a country? Courts/governments all around the world are pushing the limits on what their jurisdictions cover, and facebook is being spineless. With this case it's somewhat reasonable, in the sense that the action mainly affects Brazilians, but how long until countries try to use its citizens as leverage to get facebook to conduct foreign influence? eg. country A (50M population) wants country B's (5M population) president to be blocked worldwide because he badmouthed country A. Will facebook exit country A, or cave to their demands because they got more leverage?
- Kaze404 6y agoI would do anything for Facebook to leave mine. If this is a step in that direction, I'm all for it.
- unishark 6y agoTo be immediately replaced by a local imitation founded by a politically-connected mogul. But at least it'll be local.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThere’s something to be said for the throat you wish to choke (metaphorically) residing in the jurisdiction. Very unhelpful when the tech oligarch you take issue with lives in a far away land outside of your reach. More broadly, “meet the new boss, same as the old boss.” (from The Who's song Won't Get Fooled Again if you’re unfamiliar)
- Kaze404 6y agoI don't see how that's any worse than the politically-connected mogul from a foreign country we have now.
- zajd 6y agoWhy would they exit? Are you under the impression that they exist to do anything more than profit as much as possible?
- emersonrsantos 6y agoYou know what’s next when they take constitutional rights from journalists and citizens.
- rumanator 6y ago> You know what’s next when they take constitutional rights from journalists and citizens. Bolsonaro's supporters were caught calling for a military coup to allow Bolsonaro to become Brazil's dictator, as well as fabricating accusations and stories that targetted anyone who was inconvenient to Bolsonaro's political agenda. You should check where you base your slippery slope fallacy because any journalist who did the same would be out of a job for plenty of good reasons.
- 0xy 6y agoMainstream media journalists regularly fabricate accusations and target people based on political agenda. Nick Sandmann sued several of them successfully for defamation, because they ruined the life of an innocent underage high school student based on politically biased reporting.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emersonrsantos 6y agoThat's not true. Journalist Allan dos Santos reports the risk of a coup d'état against Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro. The coup is allegedly being plotted by members of Brazilian Supreme Court. That's why he's silenced.
- cesarb 6y agoIf you can read Portuguese, you can get more information here: https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-ago-01/facebook-bloqueia-acesso-perfis-bolsonaristas-mundo-inteiro https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-ago-01/facebook-bloqueia-aces... Follow the links to older articles, and several of them have at their end the original court decision. The latest one (found at https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-jul-31/moraes-aumenta-multa-forcar-facebook-bloquear-perfis https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-jul-31/moraes-aumenta-multa-f...) is https://www.conjur.com.br/dl/decisao-alexandre-moraes.pdf https://www.conjur.com.br/dl/decisao-alexandre-moraes.pdf and the previous one seems to have been (found at https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-jul-31/facebook-informa-nao-cumprir-decisao-bloquear-perfis-fora-pais https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-jul-31/facebook-informa-nao-c...) https://www.conjur.com.br/dl/decisao-alexandre-moraes-twitter.pdf https://www.conjur.com.br/dl/decisao-alexandre-moraes-twitte... Finally, the original decision seems to have been (found at https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-jul-24/decisao-alexandre-twitter-apaga-contas-aliados-bolsonaro https://www.conjur.com.br/2020-jul-24/decisao-alexandre-twit...) https://www.conjur.com.br/dl/inq-4781.pdf https://www.conjur.com.br/dl/inq-4781.pdf (a cleaner copy of this last one can also be found at the Brazilian Supreme Court website: http://www.stf.jus.br/arquivo/cms/noticiaNoticiaStf/anexo/mandado27maio.pdf http://www.stf.jus.br/arquivo/cms/noticiaNoticiaStf/anexo/ma...).
- MikusR 6y agoHow long before Facebook is forced to be sold to a Brazilian company?
- Camillo 6y agoIf China demanded that its great firewall apply to Chinese citizens abroad, this would be considered a shocking authoritarian overreach by most people in the west. Yet a judge in Brazil can order that, and it's just taken at face value? Put another way: if the BBC can identify Bolsonaro as "far-right", why not call the judge "far-left" for doing something that not even the Communist Party of China does? Or far-something, at any rate.
- ben_w 6y agoThe second paragraph doesn’t follow from the first. “Rule of law” and “stop taking the piss” aren’t left- or right-wing. Also: * China achieves the same goals with the Great Firewall * Despite this, “Gap apologised to China for selling a shirt in its North American outlets featuring a map of the country without Taiwan and Arunachal Pradesh included” - https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/china-maps-destroyed-taiwan-arunachal-pradesh-india-territory-disputed-south-tibet-a8840836.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/china-maps-des... * Even in liberal democracies: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libel_tourism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libel_tourism
- Camillo 6y agoI think I have more of a European (civil law?) conception of "rule of law", centered on the law itself: it must be clearly written, it must apply equally to everyone, etc. Americans seem to use the term for something that should more properly be called "rule of magistrates". Judges can order pretty much whatever they want (unless overruled by a higher judge); prosecutors can charge or not charge different people for the same crime at their discretion; the Supreme Court just grabbed the power to decide what is constitutional, which the constitution nowhere grants it; etc.
- senkora 6y ago> “rule of magistrates” A legal system where judicial precedent has the force of law is called a Common Law system, as opposed to a Civil Law system. Common Law is less of an American thing and more of a former British empire thing.
- castevictim 6y agoI am glad that Brazil's court still remains independent. Looks like Bolsonaro, should borrow couple of tips from his friend Narendra Modi. Modi, dismantled the institutions in India systematically to guarantee his long lasting power. e.g. The only official from the election commission who didn't give a clean-chit to Modi for his election campaign violations during last election was greeted with Income Tax raids on his family members after the election, now he has been transferred to Asian Bank(He was next in line to become Chief Election Commissioner). Look at the current Chief Justice of India, posing with limited edition Harley Davidson[0], which apparently was brought to him 'just for a demo by a local dealer and definitely does not belong to the son of a ruling party member'! Former Chief Justice of India, has been given membership in parliament! [0]https://theprint.in/india/photos-of-justice-bobde-astride-a-hunky-harley-davidson-reveal-different-side-to-indias-cji/450849/ https://theprint.in/india/photos-of-justice-bobde-astride-a-...
- m0zg 6y agoAnd yet when I pointed out that you can't do business in India without paying bribes I was downvoted to hell. :-)
- cscurmudgeon 6y agoThis is why I come to Hacker News. Absence of irrelevant political motivated posts with flimsy evidence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gavribirnbaum 6y agoBrazilian here. Unfortunately I wouldn't call them independent. They simply represent the other side. Brazil is not as united behind Bolsonaro as the media makes out to be.
- egeozcan 6y agoI'm originally from Turkey, and that's also the case with Erdoğan. I mean, they wouldn't be dictators if everyone agreed with them, no? The big problem arising from the stark polarization is that there's no uncontaminated news sources anymore. Many argue that news should be political anyway but I really miss reading stuff that doesn't fit 100 percent to a single agenda.
- nagamatsu 6y agoBrazilian here. I sincerely dislike those who were blocked, but don't be fooled, what the Supreme Court is doing here is completely dictatorial.
- rvr_ 6y agoBrazilian here. Our law is incompatible with the Internet as we know it. Below is a brief excerpt from our 1989 Constitution, translated by myself: Art. 5º Todos são iguais perante a lei, sem distinção de qualquer natureza, garantindo-se aos brasileiros e aos estrangeiros residentes no País a inviolabilidade do direito à vida, à liberdade, à igualdade, à segurança e à propriedade, nos termos seguintes: (All men are equal by the law, without any distinction, guaranteed to Brazilians and foreigners living on the Country the inviolable right to life, freedom, equality, safety, property, on the following terms:) (...) IV - é livre a manifestação do pensamento, sendo vedado o anonimato; (The freedom of speech/thinking is allowed, but anonymity is not) (...)
- matheusmoreira 6y agoYes. Courts all over the world are discovering and dealing with the difficulties of imposing their own nation's laws on an international communications network. Currently it is relatively easy to become anonymous on the internet and avoid the consequences of free speech, especially since brazilian law enforcement is not as sophisticated as organizations such as the FBI when it comes to cyber crime investigation. The end result will be the regionalization of the internet. Instead of one global network, we'll have several national or regional networks. This will be possible because internet providers are centralized services which are easily controlled by the governments.
- antropofagico 6y agoThere seems to be some confusion in the comments regarding this decision. This is not an arbitrary decision made in a vacuum. There’s an ongoing judicial inquiry, and the accounts suspended were linked to persons of interest. They’re currently being investigated for crimes in both civil and penal spheres. The accounts were not banned, they are temporarily suspended for the course of the investigation. Also, it’s explicitly mentioned that, given the evidences (which the accused parties have access to), some individual rights are being suspended, as they’re not shields for committing crimes or avoiding responsibility. The decision also mentions that Constitutional rights don’t exist on their own, they find their limits in the other equally important rights and guarantees contained in the Constitution. This is not some exotic feature of Brazilian law, it’s something also mentioned in the Declaration of Human Rights (which is also cited). Having said that, all affected parties have the right to contest the measure, this is not an autocratic decision. Finally, if Facebook and Twitter wants to operate in Brazil, they need to comply with Brazilian laws, including complying with court decisions. You can definitely argue against blocking the information world wide, but similar decisions were made by other democratic countries (like Canada).
- sizeofchar 6y ago> This is not an arbitrary decision made in a vacuum. There’s an ongoing judicial inquiry, and the accounts suspended were linked to persons of interest. They’re currently being investigated for crimes in both civil and penal spheres. Except that this "judicial inquiry" is anything but lawful. The offended side (the supreme court) is also the inquirer and the judge. There is nothing in the law that allows this, and the constitution plainly prohibits it. They are abusing their power and are censoring activists, journalists and politicians, plain and simple. > (which the accused parties have access to) Even the OAB (brazilian akin to advocates' guild) recognized this wasn't the case for at leas two weeks. And when the accused were given access to formal accusation, they only had access to a small chapter of it.
- naivedevops 6y ago> Even the OAB (brazilian akin to advocates' guild) recognized this wasn't the case for at leas two weeks. And when the accused were given access to formal accusation, they only had access to a small chapter of it. Do you have any source? I tried to google 'Roberto Jefferson OAB', but I found nothing.
- pelasaco 6y agoI hope Facebook is able to revert it. To globally block an account, could lead to some court in the country A, blocks accounts in the country B. For example, Venezuela could block politic opposition posting something in US.