12 ms·
Study finds learning music won’t make children smart
- pseudolus 6y agoA link to the referenced journal article "Cognitive and academic benefits of music training with children: A multilevel meta-analysis" published in Memory and Cognition [0]. [0] https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/s13421-020-01060-2 https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/s13421-020-01060-2
- wufufufu 6y agoStudying music will make you better at music. Studying IQ tests will make you better at IQ tests. I think we put too much emphasis on general intelligence when it's not well defined and easily gamed. It's also a talking point for racists.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sn41 6y agoChess grandmasters don't make great mathematicians. Similarly, great warriors may not become great scientists. I don't see a lot of people making jumps from one technical field into another. They make a jump from one technical field to a general field, like politics or Venture capital.
- dr_orpheus 6y agoReminds me of one of my favorite comics from Saturday Morning Breakfast cereal https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2010-01-29 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2010-01-29
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 236dev 6y agohow is putting an emphasis on general intelligence a talking point for racists?
- mindcrime 6y agoThe post you're responding to may have been alluding to the controversy around the book "The Bell Curve" and follow-on discussion, where the questions of race and intelligence became a real hot button. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bell_Curve#Allegations_of_racism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bell_Curve#Allegations_of_...
- yboris 6y agoI'm thinking that racism in root is the belief of superiority of one race over another. In the past, tests were designed in ways that (perhaps unintentionally) disadvantaged people of color (for example tests included [white] cultural knowledge). While better tests have been developed, if in the end they show that (even if only on average) there is a minor difference in test scores between whites and blacks, racists will point to it as definitive proof (with no care about the tests' external validity).
- quonn 6y agoCan you please give an example of this supposed cultural knowledge? In particular one that PoC raised in the same country and having the same education would supposedly have a disadvantage in?
- yboris 6y agoMy memory of the claims I came across during my time in Educational Psychology Ph.D.: tests in the distant past (early 1900s) were often culturally biased (even if unintentionally). I couldn't quickly find examples, but the gist is language or customs more available to rich white kids than otherwise (think playing golf, polo, etc). One quick post I came across when looking just now is about "oarsman" and "regatta", words more-likely to be familiar to rich white kids than otherwise: https://www.clearchoiceprep.com/sat-act-prep-blog/the-most-infamous-example-of-cultural-bias-on-the-sat https://www.clearchoiceprep.com/sat-act-prep-blog/the-most-i...
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI have a similar view. The only thing that holds me back from chucking it out in total is the research showing a bunch of better life outcomes correlated with IQ. I'm open to being set straight on this point but my understanding is that research is largely apart and of a better quality than the more race bating stuff of 'The Bell Curve' crowd. Edit: Full disclosure, I am really shooting from the hip here so please go easy. This is an issue I've bumped into a couple times and have never gone super in-depth on.
- chillwaves 6y agoThen call it a "successful in capitalist society" test.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoThe current name implies it is a measure of a fairly poorly defined thing, general intelligence. So yes, I think changing the name would be a good idea. Of course there is a reason when neurologists do tests for cognitive decline or deficiency they use a range of tests, IQ being only one of several employed.
- kqr 6y agoThere's something I've read about IQ where the correlation you speak of only applies to the, say, lower half of the range. I.e. someone with an IQ of 90 will do better in life than one with an IQ of 75, but you won't find a significant difference when comparing 110 and 125. So basically IQ "works" in the lower range, and this shows through as a weaker correlation across the entire range, even though it is meaningless in the upper range. This would then make sense too -- in the low end, IQ is affected by things like malnutrition, lead poisoning, and the like, which happen to people who live in areas where everyone are having worse life outcomes, but not because of their IQ. I wish I had a reference for this hypothesis but I lost it. if someone does please hit me up.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoSocial skills, family background, and physical looks correlate far more with success than raw IQ. Raw IQ is overrated. See e.g. https://www.jstor.org/stable/20628656?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/20628656?seq=1 ~125 eases entry into well-paid middle class jobs. Over 140 people start to seem weird by median standards. Over 160 they can seem very weird indeed, and are likely to become isolated without a compatible environment. So they're just as likely to fail spectacularly as to become innovative successes.
- BurningFrog 6y agoHow are IQ tests "easily gamed"? I suspect that is only true for really smart people :)
- lhorie 6y agoEasiest way to "game" it is to take it multiple times or practice/cram for it.
- skinkestek 6y agoAt least around here it seems people are allowed to take the Mensa test multiple times. I never took the official one but I understand a lot of effort goes into constructing test sets that doesn't benefit from cramming but (except for getting used to the format, which you can do online) only on raw "processing power". I'm not a scientists or a psychiatrist so take my word for just that: my understanding. Also I note that from what I hear on HN it seems to be that in USA IQ tests contain both spelling and history questions which - in my ears sounds like something very different from a raw IQ test.
- Symmetry 6y agoThere are lots of tests out there that all correlate with general mental ability. Some of these, like mental rotation tests, benefit a lot from practice. Some of them, like Raven's Progressive Matrices, don't. The tests used in modern IQ tests are the ones where practice don't give much benefit.
- teachrdan 6y agoAs a child who was tracked into gifted classes since elementary school, I vividly remember whole lessons dedicated to strategically taking standardized tests. An example of a tricky question we learned to answer correctly: "1. Big is to bigger as little is to ____" is "A. tiny," not "B. big", because the question is looking at changes in intensity, not just increasing size. We were also taught general test-taking strategies like budgeting time for an entire test, making an educated guess on, or skipping & returning to, tricky questions, and so forth. Getting explicitly taught these skills made me perform better on standardized tests. And families like mine, with the socio-economic resources to get their kids taught these skills, will do better on standardized tests--including IQ tests--as a result.
- smegma2 6y agoHow is it not well defined when we can observe positive correlations between unrelated cognitive tasks?
- threatofrain 6y agoStudying music will make you way better at music than studying sequences of ravens matrices will make you good at ravens matrices.
- vixen99 6y agoI love the way a whole area of academic endeavour is put in its place. You simply haven't read the literature. Like it or not hundreds of studies have demonstrated that IQ is predictive of life success across many domains. https://archive.ph/PCvgk https://archive.ph/PCvgk
- yboris 6y agoTerrible reporting when it doesn't include a link to the publication: https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/s13421-020-01060-2 https://link.springer.com/article/10.3758/s13421-020-01060-2
- deeblering4 6y agoI’m not sure an IQ test is the best metric when looking at the benefits of playing an instrument. Music teaches patience, dedication and rewards self-motivation and self-teaching, among other things.
- rubber_duck 6y agoThey mention no increase in academic performance, since those other traits should positively impact that as well I'm guessing it's not transferable.
- vchak1 6y agoNot to mention that the main benefit of playing an instrument is... playing the instrument!
- mywittyname 6y agoUnless you're a teenage boy. Then the primary benefit of playing the instrument is the attention of teenage girls.
- Tade0 6y agoI started playing the guitar when I was sixteen. My good friend from high school who knew the start of a single ballad but otherwise couldn't play got waaay more attention. Perhaps it had something to do with the fact that I was a proper nerd and he was built like a greek god.
- apoverton 6y agoFrom the article: “The authors found studies with high-quality design, such as those which used a group of active controls – children who did not learn music but instead learned a different skill, such as dance or sports, for example – showed no effect of music education on cognitive or academic performance.“ If you can acquire the skills you mentioned doing other activities then it doesn’t mean learning music is worthless just means music doesn’t hold a special ability to do it relative to certain other activities.
- yboris 6y agoFrom the conclusion of the published article: > music may be beneficial for non-cognitive constructs in children such as prosocial behavior and self-esteem ... [though] any enticing and empowering activity may improve children’s well-being
- angst_ridden 6y ago"Smart" is one of those nebulous things, until people give it a too-narrow definition like IQ. It's important to acknowledge that there are many kinds of intelligence, not all of which are pure logic or knowledge-gathering.
- rc_mob 6y agoI like this definition of intelligence “Intelligence is the ability to adapt to change.”
- osobo 6y agoI couldn't disagree more.
- username90 6y agoOr to create change.
- rytill 6y agonot "the ability to acquire and apply knowledge and skills"?
- atoav 6y agoSo a thermostat is intelligent?
- lopmotr 6y agoNo because it can't protect itself from water or run away from a lion. It's extremely limited in the range of environments it can adapt to.
- epx 6y agoThis only concerns tiger moms. I learnt a bit of music when 10-12 and I am forever grateful for that, because music is a bridge between your senses and a lot of physics phenomena. It is a way to create bridges between feelings/senses and knowledge. For example, you can hear how a DSP filter or a modulator changes the original signal; you find the reasons why an engine with a certain number of cylinders sounds better; and so on. Having some IQ is one thing, using it is another.
- omarhaneef 6y agoI learned to play the guitar, so I guess that is why I can recognize when my gear makes that horrible grinding sound. If I hadn't learned the chords to "All along the Watchtower", I'd probably be stranded on the side of the road right now.
- klft 6y agoAnd If you got stranded you don't worry because you know that there must be some kind of way out of here.
- hackeraccount 6y agonice.
- temporallobe 6y agoSaid the joker to the thief.
- epx 6y agoHappened to me as well. Saved at least two guys from losing a tire because of loose nuts, and one from losing the engine because it was sounding 'dry' or 'treble-y' because it was losing the oil. Of course, this could be the "swimmer's fallacy", perhaps I hear better than average (I certainly have poorer eyesight than average), but then again, if one gets a swimmer body but does not have access to a pool, won't become a swimmer.
- madballster 6y agoI feel reminded of "gym science" when it comes to a lot of parental development strategies for children. Everyone does it so there must be something to it. If controlled studies can't replicate any effects it does not appear to bother parents much. Why is it so hard to accept that domain transfer does not exist. If kids learn chess for a few years, they won't be better at mathematics. After five years of practicing Violin kids don't find learning a foreign language easier. Adding insult to injury, learning Latin (like many Europeans still do) contrary to common sense does not improve scholastic results of students when learning other languages.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoSome times it's not about domain transfer. It's about learning how to learn, how to accomplish goals, how to manage time, and how to focus. Focusing on specific, easily-disproven knowledge transfer questions is missing the point. A child who has a decade of experience in structured practice, focus, and learning is going to be better equipped to learn future topics than a child who doesn't have similar levels of experience pursuing goals and achieving academic accomplishments.
- benrbray 6y ago> Why is it so hard to accept that domain transfer does not exist. I think, because, that's simply not true. The question is really "to what extent does domain transfer exist, and how can we exploit it?" > If kids learn chess for a few years, they won't be better at mathematics. After five years of practicing Violin kids don't find learning a foreign language easier. If kids spend several years on intentional practice of chess or violin, they're also practicing discipline. Compared to kids who spend these years unfocused, I'm guessing this group will have an easier time learning math or French simply because they have better learning habits.
- EL_Loco 6y agoOk, I agree, but is a kid who spent several years on intentional chess practice better academically then a kid who spent several years on intentional math practice?
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe study doesn't conclude that learning music is useless. They focused only on generalized cognitive measures. Dedicated learning of any activity over time, music or otherwise, likely has long-term benefits in terms of learning how to focus, how to achieve goals, how to manage time, and other structural improvements. The authors even cite other studies showing that learning music can improve well-being, improve self-esteem, encourage prosocial behavior, and even lead to more narrow cognitive improvements in math fields that might not necessarily appear on generalized IQ tests. > First, music may be beneficial for non-cognitive constructs in children such as prosocial behavior and self-esteem (e.g., Aleman et al., 2017). These possible advantages are not likely to be specific to music, though. In fact, any enticing and empowering activity may improve children’s well-being. Second, elements of music instruction (e.g., arithmetical music notation) could be used to facilitate learning in other disciplines such as arithmetic (Azaryahu, Courey, Elkoshi, & Adi-Japha, 2019; Courey, Balogh, Siker, & Paik, 2012; Ribeiro & Santos, 2017).
- jonfw 6y agoThe question becomes 'as opposed to what?' The article says that studies which controlled against dance or sports showed no additional effect. Which looks really good for music IMO- because exercise has incredible benefits. Maybe as compared to sports, music doesn't show additional benefit- how about as compared to watching YouTube videos? Playing flappy bird? I find it hard to believe that we can really 'prove' anything with respect to child development. The studies have a phenomenally low lack of control on one end, which produces a LOT of noise. On the other end- we have no effective ways of measuring child development. Standardized tests or IQ produce metrics that are somewhat useful to measure how productive a child may be, but is that really what you want to optimize for as a parent? What we really want to do for our kids is optimize for lifelong happiness. And we aren't even remotely close to measuring that.
- Hoasi 6y ago> The question becomes 'as opposed to what?' A better question is: why do you learn or teach music? Learning music provides plenty of benefits for the development of children, but nobody teaches music with the specific goal of rendering people smarter.
- nickff 6y agoMany people force their children to learn an instrument with the expectation that it will make them more intelligent, and lead to better life outcomes.
- searchableguy 6y agoMy parents didn't do that but I did after watching a documentary that I can't remember name of. In the end though, I just beat my computer chair for a little bit of fun and haven't touched the guitar.
- fyz 6y agoNot trying to be argue for the sake of arguing, but is there some data to back this claim up? Anecdotally I'm aware of many parents who think music makes their kid well rounded, but I'm not aware of parents that specifically believe learning music makes their kid more intelligent in non-musical areas.
- gumby 6y agoThe benefit of playing music is that some people find it fun. What’s wrong with that?
- notahacker 6y agoThis. Learning music definitely makes children smarter at playing music, which is beneficial to anyone that might enjoy hearing their music or performing with them, and definitely the bit that ought to matter to the kids themselves if they're taking music lessons. If you're learning/teaching music to get better at things you care about more than music, you've got the wrong idea...
- qppo 6y agoBut it does correlate with lower risks of dementia later in life. https://www.alzdiscovery.org/cognitive-vitality/blog/does-music-benefit-the-brain#ref-1 https://www.alzdiscovery.org/cognitive-vitality/blog/does-mu...
- refurb 6y agoStudied in 27 pairs of twins based on self-reported leisure activities.
- danielrhodes 6y agoMaybe it doesn't make children smart, but it certainly makes them look smart.
- djsumdog 6y agoNot everything needs an objective quantifiable measure of academic performance to make it a good thing people should know. Even if Music may not have an affect on academic performance or cognitive skills, it's still a fun skill. Most primary school programs introduce kids to basic music reading, singing, and simple instruments. Some kids like it and enroll in more music programs. Some kids say it's not for them and do other things. But it's nice to give kids that introduction and those options. If you like music, it can provides decades of enjoyment to learn how to play. It doesn't make you better than people who just listen to and appreciate music, but it can enhance your happiness to be able to pick and and fiddle around with your fiddle or harmonic or guitar every once in a while. What happened to learning just for the sake of learning and enjoyment?
- lhorie 6y agoI dislike the sensationalization in the article ("Put down the banjo, Timmy"). The headline makes it sound like learning music is about as useless as sitting on your couch, as far as intelligence goes. But it goes on to say that the study talks about looking at a wide range of studies and stating that quality studies compare music learning with control groups that do other types of activities, like sports. You don't really need a PhD in psychology to figure out that any activity that involves putting effort over long periods of time will yield _some_ sort of result. Whether that actually translates directly to hyper-specific measurements (e.g. school math grades) as opposed to only "soft" long-term changes in behavior (e.g. developing an interest in the relationship between music and math, leading to e.g. an interest in software engineering over medicine, or an increased interest in arts, or whatever) seems to me like asking the wrong question. Both music and intelligence are incredibly multidimensional. Trying to narrowly define a supposed correlation between two very narrow aspects of both might be a disservice to the idea of the development of a well rounded individual. I feel that many people take these sorts of soundbite titles to heart as if they were little life hacks to "get ahead", rather than thinking about life as a holistic experience.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Farow 6y ago> The headline makes it sound like learning music is about as useless as sitting on your couch, as far as intelligence goes. Isn't that kind of what the study says though? It specifically concludes: > Moreover, recent correlational studies have confirmed that music engagement is not associated with domain-general cognitive skills or academic performance. What I understand from this study is that whether you learn music or sit on your couch will have no difference on your cognitive abilities and only make you better at music if you do the former. The study also mentions that you can't transfer skills to different domains. I think this further reinforces their conclusion. > While human cognition has been shown to be malleable to training, transfer of skills appears to be limited to the training domain and, at best, other similar domains. [...] Near transfer – i.e., the transfer of skills within the same domain – is sometimes observed, far transfer – i.e., the transfer of skills across two distant domains – is rare or possibly inexistent. While music can have positive effects, those would be mostly limited your general well-being, will not make you smarter and can be achieved through other activities as well. > Music may be beneficial for non-cognitive constructs in children such as prosocial behavior and self-esteem. These possible advantages are not likely to be specific to music, though. In fact, any enticing and empowering activity may improve children’s well-being.
- supernova87a 6y agoLearning music doesn't make you smart. But for smart kids, learning music sure as hell makes you more interesting and useful in life.
- skybrian 6y agoNote that since we are talking about averages, it could be true both that music training on average doesn't have a visible effect, but that some specific ways of doing music training are helpful and others are harmful. There are a wide variety of ways to teach music and a broad study won't figure out which ones are better or worse. Or it could be the musical training is effective for a certain people but detrimental for others, and the average would be near zero. However, there's a limit to how much research you can do. Chasing after effects on subsets of the population has problems too. https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- flyGuyOnTheSly 6y agoI would argue that studying music (especially music theory) at a young age has helped me tremendously as a programmer in my old age. I am writing an algo trading bot right now and I make a habit of reading the entire codebase fairly regularly to make sure I understand exactly what is going on at all times while the bot is running. Which seems similar to reading and understanding a sheet (or a book) of music before you play it. There must be some correlation there although I have no hard evidence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ravedave5 6y agoSome of the best programmers I know were music majors turned programmer. There's something about the creativity or learning of another abstract "language" that music brings that seems to tie well into programming.
- odomojuli 6y agoDoesn't surprise me but the study also seems to be just trying to measure academic achievement. I mean sure, I'm incredibly skeptical of "baby Mozart" approaches to music. Certainly starting young and practicing early goes a long way towards being successful in anything. Discipline in any field builds discipline towards others. We can go on and on about the mathematical nature of music but I would argue it's easier for people to do it by not thinking about those things and being in touch with how it feels. I'm kind of bothered that anything to do with IQ these days is pursued by researchers or is given a fair shake by our dear readers at Hacker News. Stop trying to max your kids stats. It's incredibly dehumanizing. I get that we all want children to have the best opportunities, but maybe it'd be a more equitable situation if we stopped reducing ourselves to a numbers game. Maybe they'll be smarter when they learn to do things they feel passionate about and not conditioned to perform like a trained monkey. We already have enough performative identity for careerism in high school kids. Maybe intelligence and success comes from knowing yourself, and not from being told to do things because you get points? Sorry parents! An essential part of culture and discipline of art and pleasure might not be inherently advantageous to your child's ability to fill out tests so while you're at it make sure they never do anything for themselves beyond the sole purpose of getting in somewhere just so they can realize they don't know who they are! Edit: Also the use of "put down the banjo". Let's talk about that. This is a study done in Japan and the UK. Are they even playing the banjo? Nothing wrong with the banjo, banjo's great. But specifically going with the banjo as their title and image lends itself to a specific tone for some readers. Not exactly what some people would consider "intellectual" music for vague reasons in class and race perhaps. I'm detecting a bias here against the "utility" of folk music. I wish they'd link the actual paper. Did the researchers give a bunch of banjos as part of a controlled study? I'm so sure a lot of well-to-do parents in Tokyo and London are feeling burned by having to keep up with the competitive nature among children in banjo culture.
- mywittyname 6y ago>Stop trying to max your kids stats. It's incredibly dehumanizing. I get that we all want children to have the best opportunities, but maybe it'd be a more equitable situation if we stopped reducing ourselves to a numbers game. Sadly, in many respects, the only way to have a child who is at the top echelons is to treat them like a character in a lifelong RPG who needs to be constantly trained and optimized for such a purpose. It's not just sports either. Political & business dynasties exhibit this behavior, where a child's entire life is mapped out from years 0 to 22.
- dorkwood 6y agoMy parents (who have both never played an instrument in their lives) signed me up for piano lessons when I was a child. I'd regularly be sent home with homework that I didn't know how to complete, no one taught me how to practice, and I'd frequently show up to lessons without any idea of what I was doing. I'm sure my parents paid a hefty fee, but I got zero value out of the experience. As an adult, I revisited the piano, and learned more by myself over several weeks than I ever did going to lessons as a child. The experience taught me how to practice better, and it gave me a stronger intuition for how the brain learns. The mistake my parents made was thinking that all the learning happens at the music lesson. That simply attending classes was enough to make me a better musician and a smarter child. I wonder how many other parents out there are making that same mistake right now.
- new_guy 6y agoWhen I first started lessons (as an adult) I too thought learning only happened at the lesson, I thought it was enough to pay and turn up, in fact I was so bad/lazy I was going to get dropped as a student. But with constant daily practice now I'm not bad. Regardless of 'studies' like this, learning music is incredibly beneficial in so many different ways and every child should have the opportunity.
- tunesmith 6y agoI think learning music is very effective for self-improvement for other reasons, it's a very effective exercise in reconciling feelings with reality. Do you love a particular section of the music in your head and it's really hard? You just have to keep wrestling with reality to learn it. Are you trying to express a certain feeling with music? You have to get skilled enough at the music/instrument to be able to express it. I don't know if that means it actually helps teach emotional self-regulation in general, but I wouldn't be surprised.
- pibsd 6y agoI would say those who study music (classical) at young age come from quite wealthy families, which mean easier access to resources, e.g., books, good schools, dedicated teachers, etc which could eventually lead to better iq test results.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoPiano helped me incredibly as an emotional outlet, I wasn't good and can't really play anything without music, but it gave me a tool for cathartic expression. That might have helped with school studies and such?
- nonbirithm 6y agoI played piano also, but only because my parents prodded me to (not forced, but essentially told me I ought to do and hired a teacher so I'd have to show progress at weekly intervals). I didn't like it at all. To this day I still have an adversity to touching a physical instrument because of the memories I had of being 12, trying to challenge myself to playing a piece I liked and completely failing to reach a competent level, because I actually didn't care enough about piano as opposed to spending my time on transient time-wasters like television shows about video games, and I knew that I didn't care enough to get good, but I was encouraged to challenge myself anyways, and then I felt inferior because of seeing all the people the same age or younger around me that handled pieces many times more difficult with ease. I hated being told that I did great by everyone after a recital where I ended up pausing in silence for an entire minute, because I knew they were only trying to keep my mood from deteriorating afterwards and because I personally knew from the heart that I did not do anything resembling "great." Then I joined wind ensemble in high school. As a result I can't listen to classical music without anxiety bubbling up any longer because of the ingrained memories of being pushed to be better than other people and being compelled to get into regional division X and not realizing that as someone without a purposeful devotion to music all of that was hopeless to accomplish from the start, such that the disappointment in my lack of abilities that followed was inevitable.
- InvisibleUp 6y agoIt could simply be that growing up in an environment where being taught music is possible (with tutors and teachers and instruments all paid for) is correlated with doing better in school. If you're growing up with parents who struggle to pay the bills, who can't afford the time or money to teach their kids music, odds are those kids are struggling in other parts of their life too.
- soperj 6y agoMichael Jackson grew up dirt fucking poor. You don't need to be rich to play music.
- notahacker 6y agoYou don't need to be rich or even middle class to play music, but you're much more likely to get a flute and lessons on how to play it if you've got parents who aren't dirt fucking poor and/or totally uninterested in your education. Thus there's obvious an association between music lessons and family background that needs controlling for. As for MJ, he might not have been born rich, but nobody would say his musical accomplishments weren't linked to decisions his parents made for him.
- miles2 6y agoNot sure the smart the post talks about here is IQ, if it is, I believe there is no such thing can make children's IQ higher.
- sandworm101 6y agoWhere did the idea come from that studying music was meant to make kids smart? I don't see the presumed connection. Not everything we learn is meant to increase our cognitive abilities. Schools teach music to product more well-rounded individuals, not to make them smarter. Schools are something more than IQ factories.
- oscargrouch 6y agoI have a subjective and still esoteric(be warned) theory about attention span. As someone who have learned to play an instrument at my early teens, i've learned that to be actually good at something, you need to learn to deal with the primary discomfort feeling. You are learning to fighting your natural 'cavemen nature', the more primitive parts of your brain that are more inclined to satisfying immediate pleasures. As i've said, is a subjetive observation, but in my experience at least, people that tend to have lower quality results in what they do, apparently have lower 'attention spans'. Their effort to concentrate into something is faster, and if you see a puppy dog, or a cat, or even a human baby, you can see they are distracted easily, jumping from one subject to another very fast. Now if we think about humans that we regard the most, like Newton, Beethoven, Einstein, Curie, Rodin, etc.. The research or the product of their labor require a very big attention span, as in, they need to meditate over long periods of time on the same subject. Now, getting back to the point, i've learned that things like learning a musical instrument, programming, learning some math, or reading classics, helped me into acquiring long attention spans, resulting in a improvement on the quality of my thoughts, ideas and products of the thinking process. Maybe just learning music alone wont prove anything, but i bet that if you mix the right kind of activities, you can have at least, a starting point to sophisticated human beings.
- wintermutestwin 6y agoIMO, someone who perseveres through the horribly difficult early stages of learning an instrument to the point where they can play something passably well is learning delayed gratification. The ability to delay gratification is directly correlated with success in life: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_marshmallow_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_marshmallow_experimen...
- Edman274 6y agoThat correlation disappears once you control for wealth. People go for instant gratification once they've learned that they can't trust that the thing they're delaying gratification for will ever come. People like to make fun of people who pick 100 dollars today over 200 dollars a month from now, but for the "other half", 200 dollars a month from now might as well be an eternity from now. And because wealth tends to be heritable and have other knock-on effects, what the study is really testing for is how trustworthy a child thinks adults are with offers, which is affected by whether that child is raised in the kind of environment where nothing can be guaranteed since an entire paycheck may have been entirely used up.
- timack 6y ago"Why Rich Kids Are So Good at the Marshmallow Test" : https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/marshmallow-test/561779/ https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/marshmall...
- glangdale 6y agoIIRC the ability to delay gratification as measured by the Stanford Marshmallow Experiment is quite heavily correlated with "food security in the household" and whether you are involuntarily hungry as a kid. Half the correlation goes away in replication studies that controlled for social background.
- Juliate 6y agoWait, because there are people who make their children "do" music "to make them smart", and not for music itself (and all it encompasses)?
- ergocoder 6y agoThis sounds more like correlation. The kids who gets music lessons probably come from richer families. The cost is rather high. Instruments, uniforms, maybe private tutor, space and time to practice. Irregular schedule because of music practice. Kids from richer families are well taught and end up being more competent in general.
- fsociety 6y agoI like this and agree with it, however they should have a follow-up study to measure music’s affect on language skills.
- m1117 6y agoYes, and instead all the children should go smoke cigarettes instead and drink alcohol.
- claydavisss 6y agoThis only matters to people who still correlate intelligence with success or happiness (as mentioned elsewhere here, tiger moms). If the last fifty years has taught us anything, its that being very handy with an electric guitar vastly increases the chances of having sex with another person.
- gentleman11 6y agoI don’t care what a study says in my case: chess makes you smarter. It makes you better able to concentrate, visualize, and plan. Not sure if it helps you discover anagrams or find number patterns on an iq test but who cares
- cerebrum 6y ago> chess makes you smarter Why do you believe that? Did you do an assessment before and after practicing chess? Edit: I also linked to an article about studies in my other comment.
- rjstreur 6y agoThe idea that you shouldn't play music because psychologists say it won't make you smarter by some quantitative metric is so on-brand for this site.
- Havoc 6y agoHow about discipline?
- nottorp 6y agoProbably goes for anything children are forced to learn. But this doesn't mean you shouldn't send young children here and there to TRY stuff... just stop early if they don't like it. Iirc my parents sent me to do music, football, computers and martial arts. Two of them i HATED, two of them i stuck with for my lifetime.
- lopmotr 6y agoPeople have such weird attitudes to IQ. Either denial of it's significance or hope to improve it by applying the right life experiences. It all seems based around the fear of the possibility that some of us really are born inferior and doomed to a worse life than others. But we are. By far the easiest way to improve a child's IQ is to select parents with high IQ. But nobody wants to deselect themselves so wanting a high IQ child goes against the instinct of wanting to reproduce for most people and they're stuck in a cognitive dissonance. We can reduce it through neglect and trauma but there's no known lasting way to enhance it beyond the natural limit each person is born with. How about just accept that we're not all born equal? Nobody worries that a dog is less intelligent than a person but we still have pet dogs and happily accept their limitations.
- sharker8 6y agoWow first chess and now this?!?!?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 6y agoYou can't change IQ (You probably can, but it's not simple) But you can change the second biggest life impacting testable factor in people, conscientiousness. Seems like learning music is a good way to learn conscientiousness. This article is really bad advice. But it does raise the question do people in the United Arab Emirates think most Americans play the banjo or are they self aware about the ironic-ness, or does the 44C weather temperate that day mean it's just to hot for them to think much about the article they wrote.
- analog31 6y agoA potential issue with music study is that only a certain fraction of kids who are given music lessons actually thrive at it. Many people remember being forced to take lessons and hating it. Others failed on multiple attempts until it finally "took." So for this reason, I'm not sure that music training is a single "thing" that can be analyzed without looking into how each person experienced it. Another possible study is to measure successful musical training by whether someone is actually a musician or not.
- Uhhrrr 6y agoIf you take out "music", it becomes, "Study finds learning won't make children smart".
- unexaminedlife 6y agoI played music for several years when in school, starting in Junior High. Didn't read the article, but the title inspired me to make a comment. I think the skills you learn in music performance are extremely valuable. Sure, there are plenty of people who "learn music" but don't apply themselves like with any discipline. This is only anecdata, but if I had to guess I'd say there is a correlation between my ability to toggle into and out of a "flow" state when working as a programmer and my past life when I spent a great deal of time learning music. Sure everyone's experience will vary, but I found that "flow" is a phenomenon I regularly experienced when performing music once I reached a certain skill level.
- dnprock 6y agoI see learning to play an instrument as a self improvement exercise. It's a process. There's a lag between our hands and our ears. It's easy for the ears to know a "good" song. It's hard for the hands to play a good song. To play a song well is to bridge the skill gap of the hands. When you can play a song well, you "complete" a task. The process improves our skills and our cognition. We can recognize "good" from "not so good". Overtime, it can improve our baloney detector. It improves self awareness. You know when you suck. And you know if you work diligently, you'd be able to improve. I think it's a valuable skill. It's more important than high SAT or IQ scores.
- jl2718 6y agoMusic is one of the most enjoyable ways to create. I don’t really care what my kids do specifically; I just want them to learn how to experiment and create and have fun and never stop playing.
- Forge36 6y agoOf all the hobbies I picked up. Music was never one I learned to be creative in. I learned to memorize existing songs.
- jl2718 6y agoI'm aware that this is the case for most people's music 'education'. Sometimes I think the same for school-taught programmers. Actually I have a hard time coming up with any kind of education that has enabled more than stifled creation. Long ago I had just one music lesson and then bailed forever; it was terribly rote, but much later as an adult I did something that changed how I saw it. My brother got a keyboard for Christmas, and nobody knew how to play, so I just started practicing the finger placements for the 'Axis of Awesome' chords, and about 4 hours later I was competently entertaining his kids with songs I was making up as I was going along. That was an incredible feeling of weightlessness and thoughtlessness, like some spirit I've never known was playing through me.
- RedBeetDeadpool 6y agoSounds like the same argument someone linked to chess - that playing chess doesn’t make one smarter. Funny thing is, do you know what has a direct influence on neuron growth? Lifting weights, running, exercise. Not saying we have it all wrong, but I would question every sensational article that’s out there.
- cerebrum 6y ago> Lifting weights, running, exercise. Your comment needs to be upvoted.
- RickJWagner 6y agoI love that the article shows a kid with a banjo. Something about the banjo really appeals to me-- I started learning to play it a few years back. It's truly fun. And you get to follow Steve Martin, who is both funny and knowledgeable. It's a good hobby.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoLearning music wont make your child smart, but it will come in handy when your child grows up to be viceroy of a small overseas colony and must function as a member of aristocratic society.
- 082349872349872 6y agoFor a less extreme position, consider "Study finds learning to say 'please' and 'thank you' won’t make children smart."
- antman 6y agoPersonal anecdote. I worked in a top lab in my country’s university. My lab mates went off to work in top universities, as is the tradition. The lab employed two top students in the country by some specific metric. People working there had not a common background, upbringing or optimized method of work I could identify. The only thing in common was that they all been taught to play instruments at a young age. We could have made an orchestra with the people working there. The way I saw it at the time wasn’t that they were smarter, but that they had the understanding that practicing was important and that looking or sounding ridiculous at their first steps on anything was a usual process. It wasn’t that they had developed intelligence, grit or perseverance, it was just another day for them of engaging something new, a paper or work item, and getting down to it. Lack of self doubt and emotionless engagement in unfamiliar topics is probably more important than a few points higher in an IQ scale.
- bonestormii_ 6y agoI think this is correct. I've known many people who seem so much quicker to learn new things than me, but they can't seem to do anything serious because they immediately get fed up with how "bad" everything is. Write a poem? The title sucks. Write a song? It sounds like something else. Write some code? This is ridiculously complicated and will take years. May as well not try at all. :P
- cerebrum 6y agoAre there similar studies regarding chess? I found this, it seems chess doesn't make you smarter: https://theconversation.com/does-playing-chess-make-you-smarter-a-look-at-the-evidence-76062 https://theconversation.com/does-playing-chess-make-you-smar... Relevant quote: "The fact that skills learned by training do not transfer across different domains seems to be a universal in human cognition. In other words, you get better, at best, at what you train in – which may just sound just like good old fashioned common sense."
- ipiz0618 6y agoSounds a bit counter-intuitive to me. I always thought the brains of musicians are much more analytical as playing music requires a lot of understanding and (usually) good memory. Classical and jazz musicians typically remember a lot of music in their heads, which require tremendous effort and a rigid process. Anyway, even if learning music doesn't raise IQ, there are so many benefits. Other than having an enjoyable hobby, I always thought the process of learning classical music properly is very similar to programming (or other aspects in life). You start from small segments, practice until you're good enough to move on, repeat, and slowly put larger pieces together. You then listen to your playing, find out what's unsatisfying, then repeat the process until you've mastered the piece. After learning a piece, you also need to maintain it from time to time if you still want to play it well. This kind of learning process cannot be shown in an IQ test, but is beneficial to a child's development if adopted early.
- wenc 6y agoLearning music might not may a child smarter, but it may teach the child "metaskills" like character which cannot be learned directly. Here's an (snipped) quote from something I read a while ago: [1] "When a student learns piano, all Americans can see is that the student is now equipped with the skill to play the piano. Under this view, unless the student can put that skill into use in the future somehow, the time spent on acquiring that skill is wasted. This is a deeply mistaken attitude, and the ever-smart tiger cub Sophia Rubenfeld-Chua has the perfect answer showing the flaw of that attitude: ''I’m never going to be a professional pianist, but the piano has given me confidence that totally shapes my life. I feel that if I work hard enough, I can do anything. I know I can focus on a given task for hours at a time. And on horrible days when I’m lost and a mess, I can say to myself, "I’m good at something that I really, really love." I want my kids to have that confidence – confidence rooted in something concrete, not just "aww everyone’s a winner!!!" confidence, because in your heart you never believe that.'' The point of learning the piano is NOT about acquiring the skill of playing the piano so that the student can earn a living as a pianist. It is about building the character of the person. Here is the thing about character -- you can't build it by explicitly setting out to build it. Character is not a skill like tying your shoelaces. If it must be put in terms of "skill", character is a "meta-skill" -- a foundational human skill that is necessary to perfect any number of mechanical skills. And the only way to develop this meta-skill is to develop at least one highly sophisticated mechanical skill, such that the student may acquire the meta-skill in the course of building the mechanical skill. ... it is about acquiring genuine confidence and iron discipline. With such confidence and discipline, she can move on and do anything she wants in her life because there is no task in life in which confidence and discipline hinder success." [1] http://askakorean.blogspot.com/2011/05/confucianism-and-korea-part-v-what-can.html http://askakorean.blogspot.com/2011/05/confucianism-and-kore...
- iron0013 6y agoThis has been known for so long that the “Mozart effect” is routinely used as an example of bad science in undergrad psychological research methods courses.