11 ms·
Airbus to build 'first interplanetary cargo ship'
- jiofih 6y agoSpaceX Starship is planned for 2024, and with a cargo capacity in the hundreds of tons. Even if it gets delayed by four or five years it will be able to bring back samples before this is is even launched. NASA’s plans seem very slow in comparison.
- kiba 6y agoNASA funds SpaceX though.
- treeman79 6y agoFor big projects, a sound tactic is to spend a small portion on a cheap alternative implementation. Sometimes the smaller team will be far more successful. Better focus, a competitive drive to prove worth, etc. Unlimited budget is sometimes a hindrance.
- yohannparis 6y agoNot as much as you think: ~32% Source: https://www.spacexstats.xyz/#payloads-customers https://www.spacexstats.xyz/#payloads-customers
- kerkeslager 6y agoMarketing materials aren't plans. Musk has made a strategy of "overpromise, maybe deliver", rebranded as "vision" or "ambitious goals". Some of what his companies have delivered is impressive, but you never know what they're going to actually deliver until there are at least working prototypes.
- ben_w 6y agoYeah, but that’s true for all space companies. The surprising thing about SpaceX is that SpaceX delivers more than other corporations which promise less than SpaceX promises.
- kerkeslager 6y agoYou agree with what I said, but the sentiment with which I said it wasn't positive enough, so now you've gotta jump in to defend SpaceX? That marketing scheme sure does work. It's no surprise that the best-funded company produces the best results, but it would be interesting to find out if a more honest company could produce better results with equal funding.
- ben_w 6y agoNo, I’m saying everyone else is more guilty of the same sins. Generally with more money behind them, too.
- kerkeslager 6y ago> No, I’m saying everyone else is more guilty of the same sins. Given the sin in question is "lying", I'm pretty sure that's just not true. Can you give another example of a space corporation with such a consistent strategy of very publicly overpromising to win contracts and investment? > Generally with more money behind them, too. I'm not sure who you're referring to. NASA might have more funding, but if you subtract what they turn over to SpaceX I'm not sure that counts. Other aerospace companies have other obligations in the aero part of aerospace, so funds devoted to those obligations are not particularly relevant either.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> Can you give another example of a space corporation with such a consistent strategy of very publicly overpromising to win contracts and investment? All of them? We call them cost-plus contracts, and they're very common in space/military projects. Bid crazily low, because the bid doesn't matter! For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Webb_Space_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Webb_Space_Telescope
- jiofih 6y agoThey only got large funding from NASA after building fully production-ready rockets and demonstrating they could deliver. It took around $100m of private investment to get the first Falcon generation flying.
- kspacewalk2 6y ago> Marketing materials aren't plans. That's right, they aren't. Which is why it's mighty brave of the BBC to call it "first interplanetary cargo ship". We'll see who gets there first.
- nscalf 6y agoI that this has historically been the case, but I think there has been a lot more delivery in recent years. The estimates from Musk seem to be less off, and I think a massive part of that is that the ramp up to this point was all predicated on original design of parts. They design and build >90% of the parts in the space ships. I think now that they have a catalogue of parts they don't have to build from scratch, their design/development cycles for new products are much faster and predictable. This same thing goes for Tesla, I don't think Musk & co. get enough credit for building everything from scratch.
- qayxc 6y agoKeep in mind that the first Starship cannot return anything to Earth, due to the lack of fuel. The first Starship that might be able to return anything wouldn't be able to launch before 2026 either, so...
- ben_w 6y agoAre they not even planning to at least try and send a fuel factory on the first Mars launch?
- qayxc 6y agoI don't know. But in any case, it's not just the fuel. Have you seen the proposed Moon-Starship? They'd require some quite impressive crane to even get cargo into the ship. Additionally, there's the problem of the landing site. It's considerably more difficult to land a rocket on unprepared, rocky terrain than on a carefully prepared landing pad. Plus a suitable area has to be found first, too. There's simply no guarantee the first Starship(s) even make it to the surface in one piece, let alone ready for refuelling and launch.
- _Microft 6y agoThe moon-starship will not require in-situ resource utilization (ISRU), i.e. no creation of fuel and oxidizer at the target. It is supposed to land with enough propellants to make it back.
- qayxc 6y agoI only mentioned the Moon-Starship, because illustrations show nicely how far away from the surface the cargo bay is. I don't suppose the Mars version will be all that different in that regard, but we'll see.
- _Microft 6y agoAh, OK. The cargo bay door being that high up wasn't an issue in my eyes. They can build rockets after all, so they should be fine with engineering a platform and a lift. Edit: Numbers - for fun: if the cargo bay door is 2/3 up the rocket (at 33m from the ground), and someone fell off the platform of the crane at half this height (16m), they would hit the ground with a speed of 7.2m per second which is the speed they would have after falling a distance of ~2.6m on Earth.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>SpaceX Starship is planned for 2024, and with a cargo capacity in the hundreds of tons. And Full-Self-Driving will be available in the summer of 2015, and a cross country autonomous drive will happen in 2017, and this year we'll have 1,000,000 autonomous Robotaxis on the streets. Let's go!
- valuearb 6y agoAnd Falcon 9 is nearing its 100th flight, and has made first stage recovery normal, and a Starship prototype has already flown with the new engine. Based on SpaceX typical cadence, full Starship prototypes will fly this year and achieve orbit next year. That’s three years to work out the kinks for the first Mars attempts.
- thinkcontext 6y agoThough I would very much like to see Starship succeed, it must be understood just how risky a project it is. Just having the rocket be able to work in Earth orbit is a risky proposition, given its novel design and materials challenges. Add to that the many novel challenges returning Starship would entail, refueling in space, landing and taking off from Mars, setting up multi megawatts of solar, mining, methane production, etc. Consider that Falcon Heavy was something like 5 years late. That was doing something that had been done before, strapping rockets together to make a Heavy version. Starship is many times more ambitious, with any of the challenges I raised above likely to hit multi-year delays.
- valuearb 6y agoFH was done on a shoestring budget for a small market and nearly canceled when it became clear Starship was the better path. But I agree with you that Starship has some challenges, specifically proving it can handle re-entry, be easily refurbed between launches, and be easily refueled in low earth orbit. But Super Heavy is just a bigger Falcon 9, using the same landing technology. Even if a Starship Reusability falls short, it’s very clear that the combo is going to put bigger payloads than the the SLS into orbit at 1/20th the cost.
- thinkcontext 6y agoI agree they should look at putting Super Heavy into service before Starship. They could use a conventionally designed expendable upper stage, imagine how immense its payload capacity would be without having to lug the enormous Starship. It would allow them to fill out Starlink quickly and would open up the market for larger satellites sooner rather than later.
- tomp 6y ago> That was doing something that had been done before, strapping rockets together to make a Heavy version. That’s a common misconception - in fact, even SpaceX itself made this mistake! Musk said that making Heavy was almost as complex as designing a whole new rocket; which is also why they went with new next time (Starship) instead of incremental (Super Extra Heavy).
- ballooney 6y agoI've been on this website long enough to remember when everyone was saying 'of course manually-driven cars will be the exception by 2020', and believing Elon Musk's timescales has taken over as the new naive credulity of the HNer.
- wahern 6y agoWho actually believes Musk's timescales? Musk's overly optimistic yet technically plausible timescales seem to be part of the reason why his ventures are so successful. With the right culture and team members, it drives people toward the finish line. The challenge and constant pace of progress is motivating. With the wrong culture and team members (most companies, most people) it leads to crash & burn. Musk's exhausting personality is precisely what makes it all work.
- pansa2 6y ago> "This is not just twice as difficult as any typical Mars mission; it's twice squared" So, four times as difficult?
- cynicalreason 6y agoit was a test .. you're hired
- _petronius 6y agoOr maybe (2n)2 as difficult?
- ben_w 6y agoFun fact I realised only recently: 2 ∘ 2 = 4 for any operator ∘ in the Ackermann sequence other than the zeroth (successor) operator. 2+2 = 2×2 = 2² = … = 4 At least, unless I messed up my proof. My highest qualification is two A-levels in maths and half of brilliant.org… https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2020/07/27/hᵤ2-2-4-for-all-u0/ https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2020/07/27/hᵤ2-2-4-for...
- MartinMcGirk 6y agoTangential to the topic of this post, but how have you found brilliant? I’ve been considering it but don’t know if it’s worth adding another subscription to my monthly spend when I could presumably get a lot of the same knowledge from YouTube (albeit in a less structured way). Any thoughts?
- ben_w 6y agoPlus: Brilliant’s computer science courses cover slightly more than my actual software engineering degree from Aberystwyth university, and their maths courses cover more than I did at A-level. The various introductions to matrices (in different contexts each time), are better than the introduction I had in my A-levels (with a good teacher!), and I would say they are of comparable goodness to 3blue1brown. Only, all of it is that good. If you get stuck because a topic assumes knowledge you don’t yet have, they have a course to teach you what you need to learn. I can’t comment on the levels of Brilliant’s physics, chemistry, or biology as I have only GCSEs in those subjects — but I can say they’re well-described and engaging. Negatives: Limited practice materials, e.g. I still suck at probability because I’m not groking the broader implications of their simpler lessons.
- zpeti 6y agoWhy don’t they just give the money to spacex? This is such typical French/eu behaviour. Let’s build something that already exists, for 10x the price, 10 years late, so that we can create jobs and have our own... Except the market viability is close to 0. how about using that money for something that’s actually innovative? Or perhaps charge less tax so people can decide on their own what’s worthwhile.
- cynicalreason 6y agocompetition is good, it's better than piling all the money in one place.
- kiba 6y agoIs it really competition when nobody is trying?
- wastedhours 6y agoSurely there's evidence they're both trying?
- Aeolun 6y agoEurope is trying to build a glorified cargo box. SpaceX is trying to build a starship. I’d be more enthusiastic if we had 2 attempts at a spaceship.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am tired of spacex fanboys that cant tell the difference between a scientific mission for research and a commercial operation
- Aeolun 6y ago> "And this satellite that Airbus will build - I like to call it 'the first interplanetary cargo ship', because that's what it will be doing. It's designed to carry cargo between Mars and Earth," It has nothing to do with fanboy or not. I’m sure there are tons of challenges involved in making this happen, but I just don’t think a cargo satellite is fundamentally very exciting. Having a human in orbit of mars would make the whole process of retrieving rock samples orders of magnitude easier.
- lt_kernelpanic 6y agoQuestion for the experts: what are the tests and analysis that we cannot do via a rover-based lab and hence need to send the samples to Earth? Asking out of curiosity (pun not intended!).
- Something1234 6y agoNot an expert, but the test chambers on a rover can't be cleaned easily or without a massive amount of complexity. They are also fairly limited and very limited use. While a sample collected and sent back can be split and used in many ways.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am no expert, but I can imagine there are many kinds of laboratory equipment that is way too heavy to pit on a rover, perhaps mass spectrometers, etc. Biological wxperiments is a big one. There is kind of outstanding question of perclorates in martian soil and its toxicity to earth organisms, plants, etc.
- ta8594505930 6y agoThe mars rover does have a spectrometer. It's called ChemCam [1], it uses a laser to vaporize a small amount of matter and them captures the spectrographs of the resulting plasma with a camera. That doesn't take away from your point, but it is a cool piece of equipment. [1] https://mars.nasa.gov/msl/spacecraft/instruments/chemcam/ https://mars.nasa.gov/msl/spacecraft/instruments/chemcam/
- mabbo 6y agoSimple answer from a space nerd: Rovers are small, light, and have very little energy. So what we can't do is anything that requires a large or heavy device or anything that requires significant energy. They break/fail. They take forever to make happen. Want to burn 20kg of soil to see if there's any trace of specific elements? You'll need a furnace. Those are both heavy and high-energy. You could do a smaller scale test on a rover of 2g perhaps, but what if the traces are very, very small? Plus, whatever analysis tools you would use now have to also be extremely small and light, which means less capabilities. Also, rovers have limited size: we can only do a small number of tests per rover because the rover's utility belt of tools is only so large. If your experiment is really easy to do but it's not a high enough priority, it won't happen. Lastly, rovers die. You might spend 5 years building a tool, 2 years sending it on the next rover to Mars, only to have it crash or die before it's time to run your experiment. But if we sent 300kg of soil back from Mars, we could do every test we can think of, carefully, with the best tools humanity can make and as much energy as we need. Edit: +1 to what Something1234 said too! You can't clean out apparatuses easily after an experiment!
- Aeolun 6y ago10 years to implement? Aren’t we supposed to have a starship in orbit of Mars by that time?
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThats in Elon time, I would not bet my house on starship being in orbit by 2030. Secondly, there is need to independant access to space free of US technology export rules and foreign policy and sanctions. US administration has forbidden NASA collaboration with China, and as a result they built a separate space station, and are having a separate moon-capable rocket. And i would bet my house that they will get to the moon, CCP seems to plan in 20 years+ horizons, not elevtuom cycles. Perks of being a dictatorship and all that.
- lrnStats 6y agoOrbit isn't hard. The hard part is landing something that can later return to space. That said, you can't trust anything Elon says.
- bvm 6y agoOrbit is incredibly hard. It's only just possible. A few percent more gravity and we would be permanently earth-bound. Getting to orbit requires hundreds of thousands of components to function together perfectly. Failure requires one to go wrong.
- Aeolun 6y agoWhile his track record is bad at getting there on time, it’s pretty good at getting there in general.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am very haply to see the idea of electric propultion tug finally commited to implementation. This has a lot more utility than delivering samples from Mars - in principle there is a lot of equipment that could use rugging between , and Mars. I hope this becomes a configurable platform for future missions, nur just a one-off experiment.
- Tepix 6y agoIt will be interesting to see what the situation will be like when this spaceship is ready. By that time we should have Starship and New Glenn flying regularly. Even New Armstrong could be close to ready by then.
- _Microft 6y agoNew Glenn is not that different from Falcon 9 regarding reusability as they will have to expend the upper stage and fairings every single launch.
- hinkley 6y agoDidn’t they just recover both fairings on the last launch? I don’t know how you want to work the math, but it is probably best to think of it in a fractional way. Between accidents and wear do they manage better than 4 launches in average? They just managed 6 for one lower stage, with tighter turnaround time. We don’t know how much of that rocket was reused. So we might be talking about expending 20% of a lower stage per launch, and some higher ratio of upper stages.
- _Microft 6y agoYes, they did. Great achievement, I was afraid they might abandon the approach sooner or later. This only meant to say that New Glenn isn't that different from Falcon 9. Both are limited (with respect to cost and frequency of launches) in that they need to throw away hardware on every launch. Starship on the other hand will be a true game changer if it works as intended.
- hinkley 6y agoI wonder how accurate it is to call the Falcon 9 the Model T of the rocket world. I wonder how long we have to wait for the moral equivalent of the 65 Mustang, or even the '63 Stingray, complete with malfunctioning headlights. Almost all scifi is SSTO craft, or craft that never enter atmosphere. Maybe if we start building skyhooks we can split the difference, and have craft you reuse with only minor maintenance between flights.
- bufferoverflow 6y ago> The joint American-European project is expected to cost billions and take just over a decade to implement. I'm 99% sure that if SpaceX's starship takes off, it will fly to Mars and back within a few years. But still, competition is good.
- rsynnott 6y agoI don't think even Musk, master of the dubious marketing promise, has claimed that; the first ones would be one-way jobs AIUI.
- raverbashing 6y agoCorrect, only the crew mission would return, the rest would be several one-way cargo missions
- kingkawn 6y agoPretty sure Musk said the crew mission would not return
- Valgrim 6y agoNope. The whole point of developing the Raptor Engine was (A) to be able to reuse it and (B) to refuel on mars (using the Sabatier reaction with atmospheric CO2) for a return mission.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoI believe those people would have accumulated enormous radiation dosages over the duration of the flight, they might not have a long life left and a return voyage would shorten that even more. Might as well stay put for the remaining time on Earth, err, Mars, stay in deep lava tubes and help build that colony.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago
- ape4 6y agoThe article mentions a "football sized package". Hope there is no confusion between American and European football.
- twic 6y agoOr perhaps they mean table football?
- dylan604 6y agoGood gawd, that would be more [sad|funny] than the mm/inch confusion. Can the rover use it's hands or not? Better hope they use American version of Instant Replay than the pathetic VAR implementation as well.
- Someone 6y agoReading https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Exploration/Mars_sample_return https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Ex..., they mean “basketball size”. It seems the BBC thinks their readers do not know how large those are.
- capableweb 6y agoOr maybe BBC thinks it's readers are more familiar with the size of a football (as in soccer, of course) than the size of a basketball (although they are the same, but someone who doesn't know the size of a basketball wouldn't, of course)
- Someone 6y agoI learned something checking that. A basketball (29½ inch circumference) indeed is only slightly larger (27 to 28 inch circumference) than a football. I thought the difference was larger, possibly because of the volume (about 20% more) and weight difference (22-23 oz vs 14-16 oz)
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIf NASA really wanted to answer the 'life on Mars' question, Perseverance would have included a microscope. AFAICT, the reason it doesn't is because nobody wants to stake their reputation on the hypothesis.
- lrnStats 6y agoReally? What's wrong with admitting you were wrong, and that was a discovery in its own? I recently made an error regarding essential amino acids, and it only improved the quality of suggested foods. Everyone wins. (Although you still get a few internet haters)
- bryanlarsen 6y agoYes, that's the way science should be done. But look at the number of negative result papers that get published, et cetera. How much push does a negative result give your career vs a positive one? Who's interested in spending ten years of their career pushing a test for a hypothesis that most people (and likely themselves) think is negative? And of course the microscope cannot prove the negative hypothesis, nor does it really help the negative hypothesis much.
- mhh__ 6y agoWhat hypothesis? If you found life on Mars you're going to be rendered immortal as long as knowledge survived. No one is refusing out of pride.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoGilbert Levin might disagree.
- habosa 6y agoRemember when Uber’s business got a little shaky so they started making a bunch of noise about a flying taxi project that would launch soon and be cheaper than a car? Well this smells like that. Airbus knows that orders for commercial airplanes may be low for years as we work through the fallout of this virus. So time to go to space to give the investors something to think about.
- arkitaip 6y agoDid you read the article? They are creating a satellite, ERO, set to launch 2026 for an actual mission.
- rsynnott 6y agoEh? Airbus has always been a large contractor for ESA; they make a lot of ESA probes and are a stakeholder in Arianespace, which makes the launchers. This is pretty normal for them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gostsamo 6y agoSo many people who wonder about the exact cost and do not read the article to the end... And this is the ESA bet against SpaceX btw. http://www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Space_Transportation/ESA_moves_ahead_on_low-cost_reusable_rocket_engine http://www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Space_Transportation/ESA...
- mud_dauber 6y agoI want to see it named "Nostromo". Or the "Ripley".
- adrianmonk 6y agoAre they going to have to change their name to Vacuumbus? Although, it is a cargo ship, so maybe Vacuumtruck would be more accurate.
- woodandsteel 6y agoInteresting, but the SpaceX Starship/Falcon Heavy, which will start flying in a few years, will be able to do this a thousand times better.