18 ms·
Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a major genealogy database
- subhro 6y agoThis was bound to happen at some point of time. I have been having repeated "conversations" with my dad about why he and I should NOT send a cheek swab to 23andme (or any similar services). Today I think I will be able to drive the final nail in that coffin.
- site-packages1 6y agoFor those who are annoyed about the name of the site not being in the title: GEDMatch was phised a few days ago, then yesterday phishing led to the data exfiltration from the Israeli DNA site MyHeritage. https://www.myheritage.com/ https://www.myheritage.com/
- markdown 6y agoI thought myheritage was owned by the Mormons.
- hangonhn 6y agoJust out of curiosity, is there a reason for Mormons to especially care about their genealogy?
- js2 6y ago> One of the core tenets of Mormon faith is that the dead can be baptized into the faith after their passing. Baptism of the dead evolved from the beliefs that baptism is necessary for salvation and that the family unit can continue to exist together beyond mortal life if all members are baptized. > Mormons trace their family trees to find the names of ancestors who died without learning about the restored Mormon Gospel so that these relatives from past generations can be baptized by proxy in the temple. For Latter-day Saints, genealogy is a way to save more souls and strengthen the eternal family unit. http://www.pbs.org/mormons/etc/genealogy.html http://www.pbs.org/mormons/etc/genealogy.html
- SomewhatLikely 6y agoWhy not just baptize every human then?
- bobbylarrybobby 6y agoHa! Get a load of this guy, caring about people outside his family /s
- perl4ever 6y agoThat's the whole point; they intend to baptize everyone living or dead, and theoretically even the dead get to decide whether to accept. Genealogy is a side effect of this, I have the vague impression that they need to know who you are to baptize you; however, everyone on the planet is a member of the same "family".
- gliese1337 6y agoThat is a correct impression. A name, date, and associated place, with all three assumed to uniquely identify an individual in most cases, are required to perform the ordinance. Most typically, that's a birth name and a date and place of birth, date and place of death, or date and place of marriage. If it turns out that there were two people with the same name born in the same town on the same day... well, the angels will help figure that out later.
- mkhpalm 6y agoI think they actually try to in what they call baptism for the dead.
- edbaskerville 6y agoThere has been a bit of that. Although it is officially against church policy, some Mormons have baptized some deceased Jews, including Anne Frank: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/03/us/jews-take-issue-with-posthumous-mormon-baptisms-beliefs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/03/us/jews-take-issue-with-p...
- holografix 6y agoProbably a practical and financial reason such as the Catholic Church not allowing priests to marry and have children as a form of preventing priests passing on accumulated wealth or power to their offspring.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoThat's a pretty strange claim, do you have any evidence for it? Priests are not exactly wealthy, in general.
- getmoheb 6y agothey're not now. but christianity is an old religion. after it became the official religion of Rome their aristocracy increasingly took up bishoprics, wich were much more powerful then, and acted as great lords do. paul johnson's a history of christianity is a good read if you want to know (lots and lots) more
- andrewxhonson 6y agoIn addition to (and in conjunction with) the other comment about baptism for the dead, it is believed to be a fulfillment of an Old Testament prophecy of pointing "the hearts of the children to their fathers" before the end of the world. Only names and some important life event dates are required for baptisms, but there is also an emphasis on learning much more about them if possible.
- throwawayForMe2 6y agoFamilySearch is the Mormon site.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoAdding that FamilySearch hasn't joined the other genealogy sites in their DNA Addictions. & MyHeritage has clearly lost their way. They've all but abandoned their research role (their once-excellent post 1940 records are nearly unsearchable now) to one obsessed with DNA & image gimmickry.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hpoe 6y agoNope, you're thinking of Family Search that is owned and operated by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 6y agoAnd possibly Ancestry.com, they don't have ties with the church per say, but they do have very strong ties to Utah.
- KMag 6y agoWhat does the GED stand for? Genetic ??? Database? To someone who grew up in the U.S., GEDmatch sounds like a dating site for people who took a test in lue of completing secondary education.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoOne use of GED is for GEnealogical Data[base], or Genealogy Data. GED files have been used for decades in genealogical circles at least. So I think that's what they're referring to? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEDCOM https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEDCOM, for example.
- staticautomatic 6y agoI upvoted you and FYI the word you’re looking for is “lieu”.
- KMag 6y agoMuch appreciated.
- GnarfGnarf 6y ago"GED" is the first three letters of the genealogy data interchange format called GEDCOM (GEnealogy Data COMmmunication).
- pricci 6y agoI think it was like this: Millions of GEDMatch accounts where opted in to share info with the police, without consent. Also, user emails where leaked, which lead to a phishing attack targeting MyHeritage users. 16 of them fell for it and they passwords were stolen.
- loughnane 6y agoThis is why I’ve been putting off getting my genome sequenced. One breach and it’s out there forever. I’ve heard good things about nebula[0] as a way to get an anonymous genome but have yet to be motivated enough to take the plunge [0] https://nebula.org/whole-genome-sequencing/ https://nebula.org/whole-genome-sequencing/
- cblconfederate 6y agoIf you were putting off 23andme in 2009 you would miss out on their health reports (they have banned since). If you were putting off whole genome sequencing last year, it will be banned by next year. I m afraid it works the opposite: early adopters take risks and reap some rewards , late adopters are being played by regulators, spying govts and scammers.
- KMag 6y agoPseudononymously getting yourself sequenced is the way to go, but if enough relatives have their genes leaked under their real names, piecing together family trees isn't difficult. One half-hearted option is to order a kit "as a gift" from one of the major sites and register it under a pseudonym. You're taking a risk that they're not keeping track of which kit serial number is shipped to which shipping address, and hoping the timing of the order can't be too easily correlated with the serial number.
- vmception 6y agosurely enough of your cousins did that it doesn't matter
- vimax 6y agoWhat a bullshit argument. Can't have complete security so might as well have no security. You're cousins genome, no matter how close, is not your genome. Why make it easier on those surveiling us?
- vmception 6y agoI dont mean they should do it, I am saying their protest is in vain... because that is a factual reality. The security ship has sailed, this is the Black Mirror episode.
- est31 6y agoNot saying that building databases of DNA is a good idea, but DNA is basically public information. Everyone whose hands you shake (nowadays quite rare) gets copies of it. The Amazon package you get has genes of every human who touched it. If you send it back, you are sending Amazon your genes. The only issue is the sequencing and the consent to use it for purposes like "improving our services" aka improving the ads targeting or insurances (once the DNA company is bought by an insurance). Consent is arguably less of an issue for hackers.
- ivalm 6y agoIt is a bit like face recognition databases. In principle, the data is already public-enough. In practice, building these databases enables qualitatively higher levels of surveillance.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- est31 6y agoDefinitely agree. The point I'm trying to make is that DNA is a bit more "private" than your face, as there is a nontrivial cost to sequence it, but in general it's the same level. One day we'll be able to read thoughts and I'm pretty sure that some folks will build thought databases and people might even share their thoughts with the public... and ad companies will love it because they love checking the reactions of people to ads.
- jeffbee 6y agoHow, exactly? It's not like I can use wide-area instrumentation to locate you via your genome. You can imagine how to do it with cameras and faces, but I just don't see the method for DNA.
- throwawayDNA 6y agoImagine the BLM protests (since that will probably be popular with the HN crowd). There’s video footage of a guy in a mask spitting on the ground after throwing a rock. He’s wearing a mask. His second cousin did 23 and me. Actually, statistically many of his second cousins did 23 and me. Therefore we know who he is. If only one second cousin did 23 and me, we’ve narrowed the suspects to, perhaps, a few hundred. Filter by apparent height, gender and you have a very narrow set of suspects.
- moltar 6y agoThat’s why I bought the tests on Amazon on Father’s Day sale. Then used completely fake info and fake email to register on the testing company site. Totally anonymous as there’s no way to link the purchase to results.
- tolbish 6y agoYou used a fake address to send the results?
- crumpled 6y agoEventually that data will become associated with your real identities. How could it not? you're obviously so-and-so's grandfather/first-cousin/whatever, and they gave their names.
- jobigoud 6y agoFor 23AndMe you can buy the kit in cash in a store like Target and post the sample. Then use anonymous connection and email to use the website and get the results.
- systematical 6y ago1 million and me.
- tossmeout 6y agoThere should be fines big enough to bankrupt the companies who fail to secure data this kind of data. Is there some other way to convince them to take the issue more seriously?
- MattGaiser 6y agoThat just pushes them offshore. I would rather that there be greater security training in software development programs/bootcamps. I’m a software engineer. I know a lot of software engineers. None of us have ever been trained in security. Any “best practices” are usually picked up in Stack Overflow conversations.
- tossmeout 6y agoSoftware engineers don't run these companies, executives do. Even if you have security training, that won't do you much good if leadership doesn't value security. If your company stores highly-sensitive data, you need teams dedicated to security, you need regular audits, and you need your entire company trained to handle phishing attacks.
- harimau777 6y agoIt seems to me that the way to deal with offshoring would be to bring back a modern version of outlawery. The US could basically declare: "Until this corporation pays their fines the US will not prosecute or extradite any individual or corporation who hacks them, steals their physical or intellectual property, declares debts to them canceled, or violates contracts with them."
- jhart99 6y agoVerogen might very well be in trouble because of CCPA violations either from state fines or from consumer suits.
- tzs 6y ago> There should be fines big enough to bankrupt the companies who fail to secure data this kind of data ...and then when their assets are broken up and sold off in bankruptcy, your sensitive data ends up scattered to random companies you never heard of.
- thephyber 6y agoAs someone who works in cybersecurity, it's always hard for me to interpret PR language like "orchestrated through a sophisticated attack". This could be aimed towards non-savvy readers meaning basically anything or it could be accurate and describe a nation-state (although I don't get the feeling of a sophisticated nation-state actor here). The DoJ used similar wording when prosecuting Aaron Schwartz for using Python scripts to glue together "curl" calls.
- zitterbewegung 6y agoJust wait until Krebs on Security talks about it.
- dayjobpork 6y agoKrebs on Doxxing
- game_the0ry 6y agoI think you interpreted this dishonest PR spin just fine.
- IncRnd 6y agoOften, security bulletins will use the word sophisticated when describing multi-step attacks.
- Zircom 6y agoStep 1: Type in stolen username Step 2: Type in stolen password Step 3: Click log in button Step 4: ( •_• ) ( •_• )>⌐■-■ ( ⌐■_■) Step 5: I'm in One example of a "sophisticated" attack
- apocalypstyx 6y agoNow you're making me wonder how many places the sunglasses meme in unicode could be used as a valid password.
- aahhahahaaa 6y agoSo they sent an email to their users that states: >We can assure you that your DNA information was not compromised, as GEDmatch does not store raw DNA files on the site. When you upload your data, the information is encoded, and the raw file deleted. This is one of the ways we protect our users’ most sensitive information. This is kind of BS right? It's encoded... not encrypted.
- Shared404 6y agoPresumably. However, if it was a PR drone who wrote that, it may or may not be accurate as to whether or not it was encoded/encrypted. I would just assume that it has in fact been compromised though.
- neltnerb 6y agoOr at least a summary version of it with all the data they felt was relevant to keep... so everything we currently know to be important.
- aasasd 6y agoI would hope that it means, “some data is extracted to a format that can be used for particular operations that the service is doing, but not others that are possible with the full DNA”. Sort of an index. Of course, it would still mean stolen data could be used for the same operations (and some others) if someone figures out the encoding, or data can be copy-pasted where it doesn't belong.
- nelaboras 6y agoThis seems very odd. These sites add features over time when new patterns are discovered, so I'd doubt that they delete any parts not used today because they might be useful in the future...
- slg 6y agoCan someone explain the potential short to medium term fears of one's DNA leaking? My initial assumption is that it would be less of a problem compared to nearly any other personal data leaking. Like it certainly sounds creepy, but credit card or other financial data being stolen presents a huge headache and creates a lot of work. I understand that in specific instances, for example when paternity is in question or if a person is hiding from someone this information getting out could be catastrophic, but that applies to such a tiny portion of the population. So for most people, what is the downside to some random individual knowing the country of origin one's ancestors are from or that they might have a genetic predisposition to heart disease? It isn't like any reputable company is going to be able to use this information against us. Plus in the long term there are likely going to be ways to get this information directly and almost instantaneously from any personal interaction you make since we can't really stop ourselves from shedding our DNA wherever we go.
- philmcc 6y agoMy hunch is that if this information is used against you, you'd never know. First scenario that comes to mind: The insurance company that gives you an extremely high quote because you come back as "high risk" from a 3rd party company that they use to vet applications, and that 3rd party company uses your genetic predisposition for a condition.
- mej10 6y agoFor what it's worth, that is illegal in the USA at least. Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act passed in 2008.
- sk5t 6y agoWhich covers health insurance, not life insurance and others.
- slg 6y agoThis requires the insurance company to be doing something illegal and for it to really cause damage all their competitors have to be doing it as well. If this ever becomes widespread, it would be quickly obvious when a large number of ostensibly healthy people are given quotes that match their genetic profile but not their medical history. I'm just not sure that is a reasonable fear.
- drusepth 6y agoIs there a list somewhere of who exactly was exposed? It's difficult to remember which sites I've given DNA to and which I haven't.
- acwan93 6y agoI’ve always wondered if this were a worthy business proposition, cause I would definitely buy a product like this: Basically all of the features of 23AndMe/Ancestry/etc, but done offline. You’re given an app to download online, provided all of the hardware needed to spit in a tube, and get the same results. No data stored on a cloud server, and no centralized database of everyone’s DNA. That’s probably where the real business model is though.
- eloff 6y agoI think you're missing the part where you have to send the tube to a lab to do the actual sequencing. At that point they have your data, and even if there were to be a provider that says they don't keep it, that's about as credible as all the VPNs which "don't keep logs" where we later discover, whoops, they lied...
- acwan93 6y agoRight, maybe this is where I’m being ignorant, but would there be a way to do the actual sequencing down to a consumer device? I presume the machines used are pretty complex.
- throwawayDNA 6y agoDNA sequencers are not that expensive [1]. And I’m told the actual lab work is not that hard or dangerous (high school level?). I fact, the database correlating millions of people’s DNA with their medical history and migration history is probably the hardest part. But the potential market is there. I’d gladly play $1000 to have my sequence, even unanalyzed, with the knowledge no one else does. 1 cursory look at eBay. I don’t know if those sequencing machines are good for human DNA - I hate bio.
- hobofan 6y agoI'm assuming that you meant to link a MinION (as it's the only device I know of at that price point). They would be fit for human DNA, though a single flow cell (consumable part that will degrade after X amount of DNA read) might not be quite enough to read a whole human genome with the desired accuracy. So if you purchase all the consumables (flow cells + chemicals) in low quantities, a single human genome will probably run you around $2000 in materials. With the bulk orders from their website you could get it down to half of that (so probably even more if you were doing really big bulk orders).
- parishill 6y agoYikes... Now I'm glad I have been telling all my friends who are considering using genealogy database services to use fake names.
- cinquemb 6y agoI'd be only interested in this stuff when we can do our own dna readouts at home and compare it against population level statistics that have been published publicly by researchers
- pickledcods 6y agoThis is the same level as having a breach of biometric data. With password/payment/location breaches you have the ability to change what you entered as to invalidate/outdate the data which was stored. Having your biometric/genome authentication data stolen or made public will be a nightmare.
- russdill 6y agoAccording to GEDMatch, they do not store genomes.
- mirimir 6y agoNo, not really. There's no practical way to protect our genomes in meatspace. We're constantly shedding DNA into the environment. Hair, skin, saliva, etc. For example, an adversary can just tail us to a coffee shop or restaurant, and take a utensil or straw or napkin that we've used. And then submit the sample using a fake name, as investigators often do. Edit: Those are excellent comments about scale. But generally, if you don't want to publicize your genomic data, just don't send in a sample.
- dave5104 6y agoThat's a lot more work, and requires far more dedication and resources, than just picking up the data from a dump on the black market.
- clusterfish 6y agoBut you can't do that to a million people, only to individual targets. Economic scale matters in a lot of evil plots.
- oh_sigh 6y agoWhat could you do to a million or a billion people that would make life a nightmare for them if their biometric data was stolen en masse?
- 6y ago
- sneak 6y agoThis is why I did my DNA sequencing several years ago with a fake name, a sparkling brand new email address, at a unique domain registered for the purpose, with a fake name as the registrant, paid for with a prepaid card, via a VPN. I downloaded the results and let all of it lapse; other than the DNA itself, it is utterly disconnected from the rest of my digital records. It's a shame that one has to go to such lengths to safely use health-related electronic services.
- coronadisaster 6y agoProbably the worst breach in history (so far), because unlike anything else, this information can't be changed
- novok 6y agoThis is why I want a genetic sequencing lab that will sequence your genome, send it to you encrypted by your own public key and once you confirm receipt and verify it is valid, DELETE IT COMPLETELY. Along with the record you were their customer after the 6 months or whatever required for waiting out chargebacks. Then you can analyze your DNA with a desktop app that doesn't send out any data. The deleting part is hard to find.
- daave 6y agoSeems unlikely to be a sustainable business. For GEDMatch, Ancestry.com, 23andMe, etc, most of the value comes from being able to aggregate many people's data. If they had to delete it after collecting, they'd have to charge a lot more, and there's just no market for that. Perhaps they could anonymize the data (at least, purge foreign key references to account/billing info) after 6 months, but not delete it.
- 0xy 6y agoMuch like you can't anonymize browsing history data, email metadata or financial transactions -- I suspect DNA information also cannot be satisfactorily anonymized. "Anonymized data" is a marketing term.
- HeWhoLurksLate 6y agoWas going to say this as well- I highly doubt it's possible to anonymize DNA and still have useful data. 'Anonymized Data' is a misnomer.
- ShroudedNight 6y agoThis makes me wonder if there would be some use in zero knowledge protocols that use a person's DNA information for the secret.
- conception 6y agoIt’s not unstable in anyway. What he’s describing is a lab. Lots of labs will do exactly what he wants.
- flattone 6y agoBurn it all
- tafurnace 6y agoI understand the desire to trace one's family history, find/treat diseases, discover murderers, etc. However, any time I read about these types of personal information breach events (DNA and genealogy could arguably be the most personal info of all) I so badly wish we didn't have this tech to begin with and how much present day sucks compared to the past as a direct result of these personal data mining tech companies (thinking social media, surveillance as well). I also wish the general population thought more clearly about the long term consequences of their information being in the hands of others before they so naively and/or willingly divulge it. Worse yet, we often don't have the choice. Nightmare scenarios where some could wield such information to do harm are not too difficult to think up, and if we are really being honest with ourselves, are occurring present day. Personal information data playgrounds like Facebook become precision tools for deception and oppression at best, genocide at the worst (thinking Myanmar). Not to single out Facebook, imagine what a psychopathic genocidal leader could do with 23andme data. With the rampant data collection, the human population has never faced this scale and breadth of societal threat before and we are indirectly feeling the consequences of it in our lives daily. I wish we could go back.
- qserasera 6y agoI wonder if we're getting close to being able to synthesize a DNA profile and fool most of the labwork being done. Most DNA profiles are SNP's and they wont be enough to 'clone' a DNA sample.
- qertoip 6y agoSelf-hosted genome sequencing when?
- jacquesm 6y agoAnd half the DNA of all of the siblings and parents of the people that submitted their DNA, a quarter of their grandparents and grandchildren and so on. That's what I really hate about these companies, they get people to submit their DNA and the customers do not realize it isn't a decision that affects just them.
- Bobbcatt 6y agoI wouldn't consider DNA to be secret information. Given that you leave them every where you go.
- jakear 6y agoThere is a world of difference between 1. Having your DNA already in the database 2. Your DNA being out somewhere on the street where it could only be linked to you by name through a targeted reconnaissance effort
- Ultimatt 6y agoBy targeted reconnaissance effort do you mean trivial geographic correlation based on your phones location data. So if the Google Street View car had a DNA sequencer on the back and GPS recorded any fragments and location it could trivially reconstruct quite a bit. No one has done this yet, but it's utterly doable. DNA is not private information its the most public information you can imagine is not controllable in any way thats meaningful to traditional thoughts on data privacy.
- jakear 6y agoIf an action requires less investment and provides the same value, it will happen more frequently — economics. A database lookup requires less investment than a targeted DNA harvesting, sequencing, and location correlation operation.
- zwirbl 6y agoSo because it is supposed to be trivial to identify people based on GPS, phone and DNA (which I dont believe), it doesn't matter if one gets his data into a DB, which gets leaked to the internet and then can be found/used by anyone? I don't think I follow u our reasoning. I'll also state that DNA is hardly the most public information there is, surely your face/skin color/size/other physical characteristics are more public?
- baby 6y agoOne thing I’m thinking about: this is probably an inevitable future. That we like it or not technology is going to be more and more intrusive. If not our generation, the next one, or the one after. We’ve seen that short-sighted laws have caused more harm than good on the long-term. Like the war on drugs. Knowing this, is there a future where we can lose privacy but still live a good life? And what can we do to get there?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xiler 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homomorphic_encryption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homomorphic_encryption
- alecco 6y agoThe cost of that is prohibitive except for very particular cases. On the other hand, even tiny devices have powerful computers nowadays. We don't need 3rd party cloud.
- causality0 6y agoAmazing we don't have a law granting each individual copyright of their own genome.
- smolder 6y agoWhy? Who is going to grease politicians to write that law?
- zeepzeep 6y agoI waited for this. Sorry to all that are affected, but maybe this is a sign for others, not to give their DNA to a random company.
- Traster 6y agoAnd also not to be related to someone who gave their DNA to a random company.
- raxxorrax 6y agoYeah, just like people stopped using their real identities on the net where there is absolutely nobody with an axe to grind for trivial issues. Sorry for the cynicism. What is even worse, people actually using these services create expectations towards everyone smart enough not to do that. Of course, that would mean your near relatives have to be smart enough not to use these services either... Now any health insurer could use this data to identify high risk genetic defects...
- immawizard 6y agoIsn’t it illegal to use DNA data for purposes of health insurance? How would insurance company be able to use it? Companies like kaiser run both hospitals and insurance, yet they can’t use your full medical history when determining your insurance risk. The bigger issue imho is companies using biometrics as a secure authentication, but at least in USA that’s going to be no worse than SSN mess.
- raxxorrax 6y agoLegislation is sensible and in larger insurers this promise will probably be kept. But if the info is available, people will look it up. Long time disease risk is interesting to many people. If you leave your door open, people are still not allowed to steal you things. Do you leave your door open?
- Bobbcatt 6y ago>Now any health insurer could use this data to identify high risk genetic defects... Why shouldn't they be able to? To not allow them is to force others more fit individuals to subsidise you.
- maltelandwehr 6y agoIs there any way to get my DNA analysed anonymously? Like, with just a throwaway email and payment via some service that anonymises?
- eitland 6y agoAt least it was possible for one person to send two identical samples under two different names a few years ago to one company, but if everyone has closed that loophole yet - I don't know. Alternatively (a business idea for someone here who has already registered?) you could send in other peoples samples in tour name and then request deletion via GDPR or something. Do things that do not scale and all that ;-)
- thelittleone 6y agoI consider myself a fairly optimistic person. Yet here we are deeply immersed in a world of technology that trades privacy for conveniences (that we did fine without before) and week after week these mega data stores are compromised and we just move on. The optimist in me hopes its merely incompetence and greed, but then it seems almost programmatic.
- Sudophysics 6y agoPerfect, so I, a hypothetical nation state can build targeted and tuned viral RNA for phenotypes and people I know will definitely cause me the most trouble on the battlefield, diplomats, engineering floors, and economy? Oh, corona has among the largest kilobase count? Hmmmmmm. What a fucking coincidence!
- varenc 6y ago“As a result of this breach, all user permissions were reset, making all profiles visible to all users” This seems like the opposite of how a sensible permissioning data model should work.
- 0x00000000 6y ago“But A/B testing showed more ‘user engagement’ when you default to public”
- W-_-D 6y agoWho are you quoting there?
- woolinsilver 6y agowooosh
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 6y agoI think it's an older issue. Before it was sold, GEDmatch was ran by several part-time developers. It was running some old PHP 5 version the last time I checked. In general I advise to be very sceptical of amateur-ran genealogy sites - I know of at least 3 search engines with obvious SQL injection issues (which allow me to run better queries, but still). All of the major commercial sites had some sort of leaks as well (I'm not sure about FamilySearch).
- marsrover 6y agoI thought the exact same thing when I got the email. I would have much preferred a permission reset resulting in profiles being locked down tightly.
- StreamBright 6y agoWhere do I reset my DNA?
- Neph 6y agoLet the Clone Wars begin! On a more serious note, is their any way to have your DNA analyzed confidentially ?
- dajomu 6y agoThere is another possibly very bad ramification of having your genetic data leaked: A disease that is tailored to kill just you or your family. Check out this talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RIj0iJXTMug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RIj0iJXTMug This is why this data is a worse leak than just your image or fingerprint or something (not that leaks of those kinds of data are ok either).
- oliv__ 6y agoLike this wasn't just waiting to happen. You voluntarily hand over your DNA to a private company. What could possible go wrong?
- wiz21c 6y agoWell, I'd add : You voluntarily hand over your DNA to a private or public company. Makes no difference. The bigger the trove, the finer the hackers.
- dontcare1 6y agoThis quote by John Young of Cryptome sums up the dark truth of the state of cybersecurity: " Wonder how long it will take to reveal cybersecurity is a Ponzi racket. Profits from commercial harvesting data of online users now exceeds the total funding of all the global spy agencies, with a healthy chunk of the steal bought by official spies and law enforcement which ignore the violation. Edu, orgs and NGOs part of the rotten racket." Essentially, every major data breach is planned by the "good guys" having a stake in criminal ops.
- jdright 6y agoDid not take long: https://mittr-frontend-prod.herokuapp.com/s/614642/dna-database-gedmatch-golden-state-killer-security-risk-hack/ https://mittr-frontend-prod.herokuapp.com/s/614642/dna-datab...
- game_the0ry 6y agoThat url is atrocious. It looks like the MIT tech review doesn't pay for its Heroku account.
- bacondude3 6y agoThis is the correct URL: https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/10/30/132142/dna-database-gedmatch-golden-state-killer-security-risk-hack/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/10/30/132142/dna-datab...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dr-detroit 6y agoIf people signing up for 23 and me / ancestry didnt want their clones to be slaves they shouldve exercised some critical thinking
- dr-detroit 6y agoshort term: low IQ high ambition college students clone your organs in a disgusting vat that never gets washed, repurposed from a salmon hatchery. They benefit nobody and mostly get poked with sticks and dissected. long term: your clone gets to live on after the 99% are eliminated by the elites.
- GnarfGnarf 6y agoThe human genome is about 3.4B base pairs (G-C, A-T). The specific DNA used for genealogical matching is 700K base pairs. So the testing companies are only using 0.02% of your DNA, hardly enough to compromise you. Furthermore, the matching process is based on SNPs (Single Nucleotide Polymorphism) and STRs (Short Tandem Repeat) in the "junk" DNA section, which constitute 92% of your DNA, and is distinct from the coding DNA that contains health traits, among others. So, not much to worry about.
- auganov 6y agoThe way GEDmatch works you can enter any "kit number" and get a long list of matching people which has their kit number, name, email and some other basic information. It sounds to me like hackers just managed to traverse the entire database to hunt for emails. Which is not exactly hard given how the site works. Most kit numbers seem to be a letter and 6 numbers so not exactly hard to brute force either. You don't even have to get that many right as for any hit you might get a list of 1000+ people and use their kit numbers to get even more. You might say that's a terrible design security-wise but that's what makes GEDmatch great for researching who you're related to. They'll either have to degrade the experience or be really stringent about rate limits and so forth.
- tschwimmer 6y agoI can’t believe this is a website. It’s essentially a rolling data breach.
- musicale 6y agoWell that's completely unsurprising.
- troynabed 6y agoAliens absconded with the DNA records obviously. Connect the dots people!
- kzrdude 6y agoIs there a download available? It could be an exciting time to do some bootleg research