20 ms·
This is very bad for the US semiconductor industry. Intel is the only US company with state of the art fabs in the US.[1] (Global Foundries 14nm fab in East Fis
by Animats 6y ago
This is very bad for the US semiconductor industry. Intel is the only US company with state of the art fabs in the US.[1] (Global Foundries 14nm fab in East Fishkill, NY, formerly an IBM fab, maybe. It's owned by the Emirate of Abu Dhabi and is being sold to ON Semiconductor.) Intel is profitable because they have high margins on x86 family parts. That margin will now start to drop as Intel faces competition from commodity ARM processors.
The US already lost the DRAM industry, the disk industry, the display panel industry, most of the small component industry, and the consumer electronics industry. In ten years, the US won't be able to make electronics in volume.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabrication_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabricat...
- Traster 6y agoFYI, TSMC has announced plans to build a 5nm fab in Arizona: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/15/tsmc-to-build-us-chip-factory.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/15/tsmc-to-build-us-chip-factor...
- modeless 6y agoIt's a small fab compared to the ones in Taiwan and by the time it's completed 5nm won't be their latest process.
- baybal2 6y agoAnd there is no guarantee that it will ever be, if the promised subsidies will not materialise.
- monocasa 6y agoIt probably will materialize. Reading between the lines, the DoD wants close to leading edge fabs on US soil where they can better (in their minds) verify the physical security of what's being manufactured, and is willing to pay absurd amounts of money to make that happen.
- pankajdoharey 6y agoAbsolutely, Arizona plant is a contingency facility TSMC plants in Taiwan lie within the range of Chinese missiles. It is important for US to not be completely blocked in case of a War. So it is certain it would be built and perhaps in record time looking at the current economic environment.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoThe yearly budget of the DoD is more than twice TSMC's market cap, and the US and Taiwan are important strategic allies. The DoD has wised up to the strategic need to maintain advanced fabs in the US and is going to pay what it costs to make it happen.
- KKKKkkkk1 6y agoThe converse of this is that protective trade policies have a cost. If the US government is going to protect its native semiconductor industry, it will be shielding inferior engineering from competition, doing so at the expense of US consumers and taxpayers.
- sterlind 6y agoThe standard of living keeps going up in China. Why is it that they haven't needed to outsource to countries with cheaper labor to stay price competitive themselves? Or will that happen, just further down the line?
- toyg 6y agoThey have massive reserves of cheap labor and cheap space that are still far from being exhausted. Some wage inflation has been observed, but we are still decades away from Chinese companies being forced to delocalize to compete.
- Animats 6y agoThat's happening. The T-shirt industry moved to Bangladesh.
- reaperducer 6y agoYep. Lots of clothing and other manufacturing has moved westward (geographically) from China. A chunk of it seems to be landing in Africa these days, and Africa is gearing up hoping to to be the world's new manufacturing go-to.
- perl4ever 6y agoI got a Kawasaki motorcycle around 2009 that was built in Thailand. Then again, the steering head came loose after I'd ridden it for a little while...
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIs labour a big proportion of their costs? I was under the impression that modern foundries are highly automated.
- valuearb 6y agoWe lost all those industries and it made us wealthier. It’s the law of comparative advantage in action.
- m0xte 6y agoAh yes sort of like when we sold out all our electronic component manufacturing in the UK to Philips in the 1960s-1980s. These eventually got spun off to the Far east. Add enough local industry to that and there are unspoken pockets of vacuum and two generations of children in poverty and unemployment instead. Very short sighted.
- jojobas 6y agoUS sells out assets and spends the money on "stuff" rather than creating new assets. That's the opposite of "wealthier".
- valuearb 6y agoGDP numbers disagree. We are still a world leading manufacturer and the world leader in services. We focus on building things that we have the largest comparative advantage. That means software, but not commodity electronics like RAM. Apple’s iPhone business collects the majority of worldwide smartphone profits. It’s iPad business collects the majority of tablet profits. It’s Macintosh business collects the majority of pc manufacturing profits. It does this by focusing on design, development, and usability, primarily through software. It keeps costs down by outsourcing assembly to Asia. If it brought that low value work back, it would make it shareholders and America poorer. It would sell fewer devices at higher prices, losing high paying developer jobs and all for a few more minimum wage level jobs. If US chip makers have competitive advantages they don’t need our help. If they don’t, helping them is diverting talented resources from better industries hat would have better increased our living standards.
- jojobas 6y agoYou gave me a massage for $100, I polished your nails for $100. GDP increased by $200. Who became wealthier? Apple sure makes its shareholders wealthier. I guess you can say that about its 90,000 USA employees, and that's about it- there's pretty much no supplier network to talk about.
- hwillis 6y agoI mean Intel stopped making DRAM because they were soundly outcompeted. We lost the DRAM industry before we actually stopped making DRAM. Disks afaik are still made in the US, although not only in the US.
- giantrobot 6y agoI'm no cheerleader for Intel but if Intel really wanted to they could release competitive ARM offerings. They've got enough money they could just buy an existing ARM developer and then produce those chips in their fabs. They've managed to change direction in the past. They were all-in on Itanium and NetBurst until the Opteron showed up. They then kicked both to the curb and went all-in on the Pentium-M/Core microarchitecture. Intel would be foolish to ignore the ARM market if for no other reason than the server market has started to change their focus on ops/watt rather than just ops/dollar. A 64 core ARM uses less power than a 64 thread Xeon with comparable performance. That means the lifetime cost of that ARM chip will be much lower than the Xeon since it'll cost less to power and cool it (and the datacenter). Lower power requirements can also change the calculus of datacenter siting. I don't see Intel getting to ARM ops/watt levels with their x86 designs. The Lakefield designs are promising but the "big.LITTLE" core configuration is more useful in mobile applications than servers. Intel losing out to ARM designs is really Intel's choice at this point.
- tpmx 6y agoIt's not about the instruction set/architecture. It's about the process node.
- ladyanita22 6y agoWhat do you mean? This is just about nm?
- formerly_proven 6y agoDebating which ISA enables higher performance designs has been shown in the last 25 years to be a lot like debating which JIT API will result in faster execution.
- ben-schaaf 6y agoAMD, Apple, NVIDIA and those AWS chips use TSMCs 7nm process node which has a ~50% efficiency advantage over Intel's 14nm (the actual nm isn't comparable though).
- paulie_a 6y agoIntel is very bad for the semiconductor industry. The more they are dethrowned the better.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoIf you have not heard about GlobalFoundries, they're the folks that manufacture the semiconductors for AMD, Broadcom and Qualcomm, among others.
- ohazi 6y agoYou're leaving out the part where management at Intel has been a complete shit show for over a decade. > In ten years, the US won't be able to make electronics in volume. Quite possibly, but if this happens, it'll be Intel's fault. Expecting their 500% margin on x86 to last was complete lunacy. They've had 40 years. Anything they manage to invent on the architecture side will not maintain their margin in a world where ARM is good enough. That margin is never coming back. They need to get their act together, swallow their pride, and learn how to become a foundry like every other state-of-the-art fab on the planet.
- goldfishlover 6y agoI noticed this when some folks were trying to sell safe internally https://www.scaledagileframework.com/case-study-intel/ https://www.scaledagileframework.com/case-study-intel/
- api 6y agoIt reminds me a lot of Boeing: they get an entrenched market that is very profitable and then get lazy. IMHO the problem is in the C suites, period. The executives have not provided enough leadership, nor have they recruited others to do so if they themselves are not able. We still have a ton of great semiconductor design. AMD, NVidia, and Apple's semiconductor division are here. They just don't fab here. What we have seen with China is that if manufacturing leaves eventually R&D and design will start to leave too. The manufacturers realize they could own the whole shebang if they stand up their own design, product, and marketing, and the US has no talent monopoly. I am waiting for a Chinese laptop that is built to Apple quality or better, has a fast ARM CPU, and can run either Linux or Windows on ARM. That could be disastrous for the domestic PC industry or what remains of it, especially if Apple flubs the ARM switch. Edit: Samsung could do it too. They have a sleeper line of ARM laptops, but they are underpowered. Put out one of those with 16-32 cores, 16-64GiB of RAM, 1TB+ SSD, a (maybe optional) high end GPU, and that can run ARM Linux or Windows and Samsung could have a customer. If they invested in helping Linux desktop work very well on the machine they could take a lot of developers from Apple... or if MS removes their head from their posterior and stops stuffing Windows with shit. MS could offer a reasonably priced "no BS edition" without foistware or needless telemetry and I would consider it.
- georgeburdell 6y ago>What we have seen with China is that if manufacturing leaves eventually R&D and design will start to leave too. Yep, Apple et al. are reaping what they sow here. All their employees go find suppliers in Asia for their hardware. The travel schedules are so grueling that you basically have to be from the country/province where the supplier is located for it to be a tolerable job (free trips home!). So basically, we have Asian engineers seeking out Asian suppliers on behalf of an American company where only the top few levels are American. The chance those Asian engineers are going to cut out the American company in 10 years is high.
- api 6y agoJust realized that while the ARM transition makes technical sense it probably increases the odds of Apple being commodified. Using X64 makes it at least somewhat harder for a competitor to do this by offering competitors fewer choices and higher component costs. By pushing the PC, the nucleus of all development, to ARM they are helping push the whole software industry onto a heavily globalized platform with many vendor choices and generally available IP.
- N1H1L 6y agoTSMC will be setting up a 5nm fab in Arizona from this year - production starts next year.
- neximo64 6y agoSo even if its made in the US but foreign owned it is bad. Even if the technology is superior.
- iamspoilt 6y agoI don’t get why exactly this is bad. The listed competition, namely Nvidia, AMD and Qualcomm are all American multinational corps. More competition within the US means more innovation within the US, no?
- Cu3PO42 6y agoYou're missing the part where Nvidia and AMD have their latest and greatest chips made by TSMC. Arguably the node is just as important as the design supplied. Intel does both designing and fabbing in the US.
- x87678r 6y agoThere is no money in Semiconductors. US owns the social media industry and that is where the money is, not computers.
- blt 6y agoChinese people don't use US social media networks.
- KoftaBob 6y agoBut the rest of the world does.
- skissane 6y agoVery few countries currently block access to Facebook. (China, Iran, Syria, North Korea.) And I think the situation is similar for other US-based social media sites such as Twitter. But, this list could very easily grow. There are almost 200 countries in the world, and about one-third of those are authoritarian regimes, and at least another third could be classified as semi-authoritarian. That's a lot of countries which might be inclined to ban US social media and could do so in the future. I think China could export its own social media services to authoritarian and semi-authoritarian governments in other parts of the world – a lot of those governments would be very interested in social media offerings with built-in tools to enable censorship and information manipulation.
- Iwan-Zotow 6y ago> social media offerings with built-in tools to enable censorship and information manipulation ha-ha-ha-ha-ha, Zuckerberg likes to have a word with you
- why_only_15 6y agoTSMC made $11B in profit in 2018, and that's only going up.
- BooneJS 6y agoGF's 14nm lab in Malta, NY is not going to be upgraded to 7nm also. They cancelled it.
- pankajdoharey 6y agoWell TSMC is building a new Fab in Arizona, it would be a $12 billion, 5nm chip production facility. So US Semiconductor industry will still be ahead. And sooner or later others will catch up too.
- mNovak 6y ago>> most of the small component industry It's not glamorous, but Texas Instruments still operates a pile of fabs in the US, and is well positioned for the anticipated IoT boom.
- lmm 6y agoAre they though? You can buy a fairly nice old-school TI microcontroller - or you can buy an ARM with enough onboard RAM to run Java, program it like you're writing a phone app, and pay a similar price. Battery consumption will be worse, but are your users going to notice?
- jononor 6y agoTI has a reasonable set of ARM microcontroller offerings in the TM4C lineup. Nothing unique but plenty workable.
- mNovak 6y ago>> Battery consumption will be worse, but are your users going to notice? If it's IOT, yes definitely. Some things you don't want to plug in every day--they have to run 10yrs on battery. TI is pretty good in that space.
- coldtea 6y ago>The US already lost the DRAM industry, the disk industry, the display panel industry, most of the small component industry, and the consumer electronics industry. In ten years, the US won't be able to make electronics in volume. That's how old empires fall and get replaced by new - and this while everybody in the old remains complacent... Most of this is out of greed - the corporations got bigger margins if they outsourced production. And the public could short term buy more for less - to the detriment of the local working class, and ultimately, the middle class. And domestic stuff like rent, health, education, etc, would remain expensive. First you lose the factory jobs, then the factories, then the readily available infrastructure to build one soon as you need it, then the investments to new technology, and ultimately, even the know-how (and meanwhile, lots of patents also go elsewhere, to your subcontractors).
- mjburgess 6y agoThat's the story the left tells to create outrage to get votes; it provides an illusory sense of control and redress. "Corporations" are profit-seeking for the entire lifetime; there isn't a point where the making-money comes to the fore and ruins everything. Automation explains almost all loss of manufacturing jobs. America today manufactures more than it ever has, with very few jobs needed. A car factory today requires a few hundred people, rather than many thousands. As for why temporary monopoly companies become less innovative, the answer there is somewhat obvious: because innovation isn't the best profit-making strategy. But that's fine: hence the breakdown of temporary monopolies via competition. Then there's the question of "why china" is where genuine competition comes from, and that's largely due to economies of scale and large pools of talent. The labour costs are secondary for the capacity to automate and integrate supply lines. America is a massive country with low density, poor infrastructure and limited talent base for relevant skills. The latter is a choice of its citizens to educate themselves in a particular way. The former is the choice of its citizens to vote for particular government programmes: low-density sprawl, and tax-cuts. If you want to "bring manufacturing back" (whatever that means) you need significant tax raises to build and subsidise significant amounts of infrastructure and subsidise education and training in the relevant skills. Of course, that isn't as satisfying for a voting for a rable-rouser.
- Polylactic_acid 6y ago>14nm >state of the art You must work at intel
- justAnotherNET 6y agoThank god intel leadership fired so many in senior engineering to replace with H1B. Clearly that was a long term strategy aimed at success and not a short term cash grab to pump stock aka executive compensation. Now that intel has inarguably turned their 3+ year process lead into a 2 year lag I’m sure the people responsible will be held accountable.
- Bayart 6y ago>The US already lost the DRAM industry, the disk industry, the display panel industry, most of the small component industry, and the consumer electronics industry. In ten years, the US won't be able to make electronics in volume. Welcome to Europe, I guess.
- Gangbusters 6y agoThe USA will increasingly morph into an economy dedicated to providing goods and services for those receiving Government welfare: the aged and under-employed. Europe is ahead of the curve on aging and devotes a huge amount of welfare to its non-European population. By contrast Taiwan is ethnically homogenous and can 'afford' to have very low tax rates: https://shieldgeo.com/payroll-and-tax-in-taiwan/ https://shieldgeo.com/payroll-and-tax-in-taiwan/ eg. 5% VAT vs 20% in Europe, 3% combined payroll tax vs 40% in Europe.
- flamble 6y agoThis is a fascinating glimpse into far-right ideology, and I'm really curious about this idea that welfare expense increases in proportion to ethnic heterogeneity. Where does it come from, or rather, how do people try to justify it?
- Gangbusters 6y agoIt comes from reality: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00148-017-0636-1 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00148-017-0636-1 "We present life cycle estimates of the potential fiscal impact of immigration considering the cost of immigration on the margin as well as on average. The main conclusion is that immigrants from Western countries have a positive fiscal impact, while immigrants from non-Western countries have a large negative one, which is also the case when considering only non-refugee immigrants. The negative effect is caused by both a weak labour market performance and early retirement in combination with the universal Danish welfare schemes." This is why more sensible European countries (like Denmark) have begun aggressive assimilation schemes, and steps to reduce immigration.
- gorgoiler 6y agoWhen you say it is owned by the Emirate of Abu Dhabi I would be curious to know how this works in terms of geopolitics. What happens to this national infrastructure in a time of war? If one country places it’s infrastructure inside another’s then in a state of war the Emirate would certainly lose access to their chip fab. They’d want to see no one else can use it either. Would something like the Global Foundries site somehow rigged to be permanently disabled, maybe even remotely, so as to not let it fall into the host state’s hands?
- razakel 6y agoYou're thinking of it as a strategic resource when it isn't - it's just an investment holding. If war looked likely they'd just sell it on the open market.