54 ms·
LibreOffice: The Next Five Years
- Shared404 6y ago> so nobody thinks in terms of buying support for any office suite[.] In my experience working in a repair shop, people only think in these terms when buying an office suite, regardless of if they'll actually use the official support. This only applies to individuals though, not corps.
- duncanawoods 6y agoHuh. I just tried Calc (6.0.7.3, Ubuntu 18.04) again this morning for the first time in a while and it crashed in seconds after right-clicking a few column headers. It's repeatable. When trying to navigate the very confusing document recovery dialogs to restart it, it then launched as Writer not Calc. I really wish it was an option but JFC. My experience with has always been so bad it doesn't even feel worth raising a bug report.
- stormdennis 6y agoI find that calc is very good for migrating data from files that other programs, cannnot open. Import from some random file type, export as csv for example.
- sammorrowdrums 6y agoI've found that Calc is better for importing things like custom format CSV files etc. But has problems opening very large files, where Excel is better able to handle working with them. Overall that makes Calc more useful to me, but then again, I mostly write scripts when dealing with data files if I can.
- tluyben2 6y agoCould you make a video of that? I am clicking myself silly (ubuntu 18.04 / 6.0.7.3) and cannot repeat that behavior. I use calc a lot and it rarely crashes (less than excel/windows which, on my ms surface tablet, actually quite regularly crashes or hangs).
- duncanawoods 6y agoSure, here you go: https://imgur.com/a/PZMaqff https://imgur.com/a/PZMaqff org.gnome.Shell.desktop[4355]: Window manager warning: Invalid WM_TRANSIENT_FOR window 0x9000024 specified for 0x9000965 (LibreOffic). You have shamed me into raising a bug ;) edit: raised, the 6.0 branch is EOL, doesn't happen in 6.4.5.2
- tluyben2 6y agoAh, I am using i3wm as wm; that might be the difference...
- duncanawoods 6y agoI am happy to report it doesn't happen with 6.4.5.2. It's a shame that the snaps installed by default in Ubuntu haven't been updated.
- asddubs 6y agoyup, that's the thing, people love to complain on random social media platforms, but most people can't be bothered to report bugs. been guilty of it myself as well of course
- duncanawoods 6y agoThe sad thing is that it's almost futile raising a bug against complex software like this or IDEs. It doesn't matter if it's FOSS or commercial, they already have backlogs of 10000s of bugs so unless loads of other people are reporting the same bug, it almost certainly won't be fixed. I have never had a Visual Studio or Windows bug report fixed and only a few JetBrains ones fixed. However, if it's a small tool or library then it's a different story, much higher response rate.
- gitgud 6y ago> It doesn't matter if it's FOSS or commercial It does matter, you can't fix a problem with IntelliJ, you need to wait until the company considers it economically viable to fix, ie enough people report it or its critical. But if something in an Open-source system pisses you off, you can fix it yourself. It not for everyone, but at least it's possible to fix FOSS systems yourself...
- tbran 6y agoSo, I'm on the same version of Ubuntu and LibreOffice and I use Calc almost every day without problems. Also, on the infrequent occasions that I need to do document recovery (usually from my unplugged laptop running out of battery), it works flawlessly. Not to pick on you, but I feel like comments like yours are, I don't know, unnecessarily negative or nitpicky? Like, people will read your comment and think, "Oh geez, LibreOffice is crap." But it's used by portions of government on at least 754,000 machines [0] and my mom. Being used by many doesn't mean it's amazing, I suppose, but it at least means it generally works and probably isn't complete crap. [0] https://www.libreoffice.org/discover/who-uses-libreoffice/ https://www.libreoffice.org/discover/who-uses-libreoffice/
- fock 6y agoso basically iceweasel vs. firefox again. I'm fine with that (and still miss the icon)
- teekert 6y agoCould be that the enterprise will include some cloud sync for auto backup (like O365/OneDrive), of course that will not be free. Best case (call me naive) but it could just be that the personal edition simply does not ask for the syncing, worst case, it will nag you constantly.
- fock 6y agowell, if you're paying for the cloud, you can pay for the free-as in freedom-software as well I guess ;)
- aphroz 6y agoIs there a hosted service for LibreOffice online ? I wish I could find a better replacement for Google Drive.
- leadingthenet 6y agoActually read the article...
- aphroz 6y agoThey say they don't host the service.
- npteljes 6y agoI recommend checking out ONLYOFFICE. They have a personal tier with a small online storage for free. And everything is AGPLv3. https://personal.onlyoffice.com/ https://personal.onlyoffice.com/
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoOnlyOffice have shot themselves in the foot when made it use MSO file format to store data. Should have build on ODT
- andrewshadura 6y agoOnlyOffice are not a community-oriented project, with their aggressive usage of AGPL+CLA, previous policy of withholding parts of code and throwing the rest over the wall once in a while, and their compatibility is far from what they claim: LibreOffice is far better compatible with MSO. Also, feature-wise it's crippled in comparison not only with LibreOffice proper, but even with LibreOffice Online.
- lbwtaylor 6y ago> LibreOffice is far better compatible with MSO Why do you say that? I trialed both of them with an array of complex Word documents and OnlyOffice far outperformed.
- maxmouchet 6y agoAs much as I love free software, LibreOffice interface feels old and ugly (to me, at least). It would be nice if there was more focus on the UX/UI design in open source projects. Of course, most programmers are not UX/UI designers, and designers don't tend to work for free on open source projects.
- Mekantis 6y agoThere's also the question of how open open source programmers might be to some UX/UI designer stepping in and trying to force their vision on the project.
- pulse7 6y agoBeauty/ugliness is subjective. For some it is "old and ugly", for some it is "retro".
- maxmouchet 6y agoI agree, and programmers (at least on HN) seems to prefer minimalist and/or retro interfaces. However I'm pretty confident that if I show such an interface to non technical people, they will feel that it doesn't look nice, compared to whatever proprietary app they use on their phone, Windows/Mac, ... I personally don't use Word nor LibreOffice (I use mostly LaTeX), but if we want free software to become more popular, there must be a focus on the design.
- bluGill 6y agoI don't care how ugly it is. I care about how quickly people can get their work done. The ribbon is better for this because the things most often used are right there and easy to find. Sure rarely used stuff takes longer, but that is a good trade off.
- stefankeys 6y agoIs there some way to move stuff in word so that it is more accessible. Just wondering.
- Jonnax 6y agoI haven't used Libreoffice in years. Did they ever update the UI styling? I remember it had a very "java" look to it. You know that feeling when you open an app, you know it's going to be a bit janky.
- pizza234 6y agoDo you happen to be on Mac? On Debian-based systems, AFAIK, there are specific packages for DE integration, for example, for GTK3, which makes LO look native (although, I think that the styling is highly customized, because of the functionality requirements).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- npteljes 6y agoYou can configure it to have a ribbon, and other complex toolbar layouts too. I use it for work on Linux, and I think it's quite well done - and I hate Java also.
- ACS_Solver 6y agoIt has visual class libraries that give LO a slightly different look depending on what you're running it on. I'm typing this from a Debian system running KDE Plasma, and my LibreOffice reports using the gtk3_kde5 VCL. It uses Qt5 widgets and looks, for the most part, like a regular KDE Qt5 application. It no longer looks or feels like a Java application. Because it's not - Java is optional except in LibreOffice Base. You can disable JRE in the options, and LO parts that are not Base will retain nearly all functionality.
- andrewshadura 6y agoTo be completely fair, it never looked like a Java application.
- encom 6y ago>You know that feeling when you open an app, you know it's going to be a bit janky. I've used Electron apps before, yes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kungato 6y agoIs there any electron gpl based Word and Excel alternative? I always imagined running on top of electron helped you skip a lot of work and helped the app not look like shit/LibreOffice
- anoncake 6y agoYou know what helps skip a lot of work? Not needlessly rewriting things.
- ubercow13 6y agoLibreoffice looks like a native desktop app. How do electron apps look better than that?
- HeckFeck 6y agoPlus, it is possible to customise the icons and colour scheme. There's light mode, dark mode, blue mode, even pink...
- bzzzt 6y agoDepends on which desktop. On macOS it stands out like a sore thumb. Icons are almost monochrome and indistinguishable. Also, it does not feel as smooth as a native Mac app since it uses its own toolkit instead of Mac native scrolling etc.
- kuschku 6y agoIf you want to see how moving from Java to Electron destroys an application, while making it look "better", try out GeoGebra Classic 6 and GeoGebra Classic 5. The difference is stunning. Geogebra 5, written in Java, is just so much more performant, and feels so much more like an application, not a broken website. The same actually applies to pgAdmin 3 vs pgAdmin 4.
- vetinari 6y agopgAdmin 4 is not an electron app. It is a real web app, written in Python and Flask, and Qt browser engine bundled together.
- openfuture 6y agoIt's weird to me that people complain over "old and ugly" interfaces. Consistency is worth so much more than fad-chasing. Learning something is more worthwhile if you are able to trust that it won't change underneath you. Take MS Office for example, I was made to learn how to use it in elementary school, we had an exam where we got a printed out page and had to reproduce it in an hour. This was supposed to be fundamental computer knowledge like learning to type. I still have the same keyboard layout as back then but MS Office now has some janky "ribbon interface" which bears no resemblance to how it used to be. Although it should be criminal for public schools to teach proprietary software, we can forget about that for a minute and instead consider how futile it is to teach things that are not open standards or at least free software. You have absolutely no assurance that this knowledge will still be applicable even just a few years later. My hope is that free software projects will attempt to preserve old interfaces (making them accessible via initial configuration) when they make updates. Besides, you shouldn't be replacing your GUI if your architecture hasn't got a clear separation between presentation and core logic.
- HeckFeck 6y agoRecently, I installed Office 97 onto Wine just for curiosity. I could still do much with it. The only feature I really missed from Word was academic references. I could create documents indistinguishable from modern Word using the old drawing features combined with modern fonts. The drop down menus, combined with the floating toolbars were much more intuitive than clicking up and down some "ribbon". The drop down menus map directly to the logical path of a task in my mind, eg "Insert -> Image -> From File". Having a small toolbar at the bottom with basic graphical tools is much more convenient than clicking back and forth from tab to tab. It's a shame MS couldn't accept that what they had until Office 07 was a workflow polished near to perfection, perfected after years of refinement and familiarity.
- ghaff 6y ago>perfected after years of refinement and familiarity That can be a problem though. One person's familiar tool with its well-known quirks and peculiarities is a newcomer's inscrutable and illogical interface.
- mgbmtl 6y agoI hate to rant, but there is a weird sense of entitlement in many comments. An assumption that software should "just work", be completely bug free, have the best design, have developers quickly responding to bug reports, etc, while giving away the product for free. I might not use an office suite very often, but when I do, I'm grateful it exists and is free/libre. Some orgs (gov, companies, service providers/resellers) do rely on LibreOffice, and they should really make sure that core developers can keep on going. (I work for a free software service provider/reseller and core developer, this comes up regularly)
- genidoi 6y agoThis is the de facto complaint of open source software, and initially I thought the entitlement can really only be explained by laziness, after all why don't people just bother to read the source code and contribute the feature they want? But then I realized its way way more rudimentary than that. A substantial amount of software developers struggle w/ interpersonal communication skills, and so often what may have been intended as a polite feature suggestion came across as entitlement, if not bewilderment that a feature doesn't exist through a poor choice of words combined with a lack of empathy that we see everywhere throughout the internet anyway.
- danans 6y ago> why don't people just bother to read the source code and contribute the feature they want? It is a bit far fetched to expect non programmer users to read the source code, much less contribute the feature (i.e. from requirements gathering to feasibility analysis, to design, implementation, testing, and release) isn't it? That is the kind of work that only a compensated team would do, especially and something as complex as an office productivity suite. In other nonprofit areas, your organizations doing work rely on charitable contributions from donors who share the same interests. Until such a time that such donors exist, it's hard to see how the development model is funded. > A substantial amount of software developers struggle w/ interpersonal communication skills, and so often what may have been intended as a polite feature suggestion came across as entitlement They might have interpersonal issues, but it seems like the deeper issue here is more with the incentive model, not with the developers' personality traits.
- eeereerews 6y ago> Another pathology is that there are companies who ship LibreOffice, often claiming support, but then file all their tickets up-stream and hope they are fixed for free. Lmao... but thinking again, given the average user's bug-filing abilities, a professional bug-filer might actually be useful.
- buovjaga 6y agoIndeed. I created this initiative some time ago, but sadly have not been able to get folks responsible for deployments involved: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/QA/Guidelines_for_public_and_private_sector_deployments https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/QA/Guidelines_for_public... I guess it's just another reflection of the passivity we witness everywhere.
- davidhyde 6y agoIt seems like this whole thing could be solved by renaming the tag from "Personal Edition" to "Lite Edition" or something. People want to use and "office" product for work, duh. The document foundation keep arguing that funding is needed and the users keep arguing that they want a free version for commercial use and that naming is important because "the boss won't read the license agreement but look at the name! Personal Edition" Why are people on the defensive always so blinded by the obvious? If you understand what people are getting upset about then, on the first line of the letter, they should state, unambiguously, exactly what people are having an issue with. Instead, the introduction is about the success of LibraOffice which is not contended and actually somewhat irrelevant. Then this: > So it is a bit surprising to see the project's core developers in a sort of crisis mode while users worry about a tag that showed up in the project's repository This sentence just tells the reader that you still don't understand what the fuss is about because you are referring to past good will and not the simple fact that the name is wrong. Readers want to know that you understand their point of view before they are willing to read about your point of view.
- mrob 6y ago"Lite Edition" isn't much better. The usual name for this kind of thing is "Community Edition", which has no negative connotations. But I don't see why it needs any special name. The LibreOffice brand is already harmed by the continued existence of OpenOffice, which many people still think of as the default free (as in beer) office suite despite its obsolescence. Complicating the LibreOffice name will only make things worse. IMO it should remain plain "LibreOffice", and the paid support version can be "LibreOffice Enterprise Edition".
- zucker42 6y agoSomeone from TDF responded to a similar comment on Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/ho0n51/update_on_libreoffice_naming_and_tdfs_ecosystem/fxfer3k/?context=2 https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/ho0n51/update_on_lib...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pythonwizz 6y agoThey do a great job. But I use [commercial] Softmaker Office. They offer a free version too: https://www.freeoffice.com/en/ https://www.freeoffice.com/en/
- uxcolumbo 6y agoThanks for posting this. I'm looking for a MS Office replacement, not heard of Softmaker Office before. I'm still using an old version of Office, but it doesn't work well on a high DPI screen. What's your experience with Softmaker Office - anything you're missing from MS Office (if you've used it before Softmaker Office)?
- joyj2nd 6y agoI miss nothing. Buts thats me. If you need visual basic scripts, maybe it is not for you. AFAIK it has its own scripting language. There is no risk to test the free version. You can actually use the free version, the limitations are not tremendous. I always buy it.
- ghaff 6y agoThere seems to be a very large elephant missing from that discussion which is the rise of SaaS office suites. Speaking personally, I'm very glad that there is a free software office suite (as well as drawing programs etc.) However, I sincerely hope that collaborating on documents and presentations by mailing them around to people and trying to merge their edits and comments is never again the norm for me. Shared documents are probably a much overlooked enabler for people to work remotely in the current situation. Added: They do mention LibreOffice Online but that seems like it should be a more central point in the discussion.
- hnarn 6y agoI agree, the main point I would expect from "The next five years of LibreOffice" would be a self-hosted competitor to Google Docs and Office 365. There's definitely a place for a local application editing documents, but I don't think that's what's going to matter the most five years from now when compared to a solid web based alternative -- and I also don't think a "code freeze" for the "normal" LibreOffice (not that I'm advocating one) would make the product unusable five years down the road.
- nelaboras 6y agoIt's there but with the clear and explicit intention that the free version will lag behind the commercial offers.
- leonidasv 6y agoThey have a self-hosted online suite, it's called Collabora.
- anoraca 6y agoIt's a spinoff https://www.libreoffice.org/download/libreoffice-online/ https://www.libreoffice.org/download/libreoffice-online/ The former LibreOffice development team from SUSE joined Collabora in September 2013 forming the subsidiary Collabora Productivity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collabora_Online https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collabora_Online
- stefankeys 6y agoGUI was a mistake.
- rspoerri 6y agoI‘d like to use a open source text editor. But libreoffice text rendering is so bad, i cant use it. At least thats the case for me on osx, but i think this applies to all plattforms. Just compare text rendered in libreoffice and to the one in pages. It hurts my eyes.
- phonon 6y agoThe upcoming version is moving from Cairo to Skia for text rendering. It might help.
- grandinj 6y ago(LO Dev) Unfortunately, mac has the least interested programmers available to debug issues, and there is some weird interaction going on with our rendering on macOS that we can't track down.
- stefankeys 6y agoWordstar and Wordperfect were easier to use imo.
- bzzzt 6y agoThey also missed a lot of features. And IMO not needing the 'reveal codes' screen and having to clean up markup codes manually is the reason Word won the wordprocessor 'war'.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoI still remember the inconveniently tall keyboard templates (e.g. https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&hl=en&source=hp&q=wordperfect+keyboard+template https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&hl=en&source=hp&q=wor...) for WordPerfect to tell users where all the function were. Give me the ribbon bar anyday.
- progx 6y agoCan we expect an Auto-Update within the next 5 years?
- mikece 6y agoWhat's wrong with updating via Flatpack or AppImage (or Brew or Chocolatey)?
- kleiba 6y agoDo people use LibreOffice because it's open-source or because it you don't have to pay for it? In either case, the "enterprise edition" they envision will fail to service either camp. If you have to spend any money at all, you might as well spend the money that MS Office costs. Or else, the main competitor is not MS Office but Google Docs.
- grandinj 6y agoThe idea is to entice Enterprise and similar customers to pay for support, spending a small fraction of the money they save from not buying MS, to help keep the LibreOffice eco-system going. So still much cheaper than MS :-)
- ubermonkey 6y agoThe people I know use LO for essentially political reasons. I've never really tried to use anything other than MS Office, because for my whole career I've been interacting with people on Windows using standard Windows/MSFT tools, and so any inconsistency / glitch in document exchange would automatically be my fault if I insisted on using LO or Apple's tools or whatever. Plus, honest go God, Word and Excel are really, really good at what they do. Word got their more slowly, but once Excel ate Lotus 1-2-3, there really never was another competitor there, and Excel just kept getting more and more powerful. It's a wonderful tool. (Now, there ARE people who learn Excel but refuse to go further -- into a true database, or into a proper business intelligent /reporting tool, or whatever -- and end up creating their own really janky versions of these things within Excel with macros and insane formulas hidden out in AA:5234 or whtaever; that's a problem for sure. But it's not so much an Excel problem as it is a problem with the lack of an obvious next-step ramp for those users.)
- ghaff 6y ago>But it's not so much an Excel problem as it is a problem with the lack of an obvious next-step ramp for those users This is something of a general issue that was essentially created by the success of MS Office. With "everyone" using MS Office or something quite similar, there really wasn't a huge market or interest in a different program that was just an incremental step up. There are exceptions but, for the most part, people tried to push MS Office to do things it wasn't really designed to do because the next step was jumping to some complex and expensive program from Adobe or whoever.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoI find it noteworthy that LibreOffice Online is what's bringing in cash according to TFA. What it might tell us is that the prevalence of cloud and online services today is just a consequence and natural market reaction to F/OSS proliferation. LO/OO.o themselves have open-sourced their product many years ago when it still was owned by Sun (I even know developers in Hamburg who worked on it in the 1990's when it still was called Star Office).
- blendergeek 6y agoI have a few questions that don't seem to be fully answered in the post. > This “Personal Edition” tag ... has the purpose of differentiating the current, free and community-supported LibreOffice from a LibreOffice Enterprise set of products and services provided by the members of our ecosystem. Will this "LibreOffice Enterprise" be Free as in Freedom? Would I be able to package it up myself and call it "Community ENTerprise Office Suite"?
- buovjaga 6y agoThese enterprise versions are already available since years, for example: https://www.collaboraoffice.com/solutions/collabora-office/ https://www.collaboraoffice.com/solutions/collabora-office/ https://libreoffice.cib.de/ https://libreoffice.cib.de/
- zucker42 6y agoThis isn't really changing anything. LibreOffice is under the GPL. It's just a marketing attempt to get large organizations to realize that they should contribute back to the ecosystem if they rely on LibreOffice.
- blendergeek 6y agoLibreOffice is currently under the LGPLv3 and the MPLv2, not the GPL. Further, the document refers to 'new products' that could be under the 'LibreOffice Enterprise' umbrella. Could any of these be proprietary? Do we have any assurances?
- zucker42 6y agoYou are correct. I don't know how I fabricated that idea. In response to your second point, there seems to be strong opposition to open core from some key players in the community.
- inanutshellus 6y agoEvery time I open LibreOffice and see the loading logo... I'm amazed it's free software. I'm thankful to everyone that has contributed to it.
- zelphirkalt 6y agoI am looking forward to future development of LibreOffice. For me it has become better and better. I've never had a new installation, or update of LO which made me think "If only I had stuck to the old version!" More and more I am using plain text formats these days, which I then convert into other things, but from time to time it is nice to have LO at the ready, knowing, that it is free software and as such will always be available, in our collective resources. A friend of mine recently complained about pictures disappearing and floating over text area margins in their document and having to put them back in in a 200 page document. I've never had such a problem. However, there seem to be some rough edges left to improve. I cannot complain about the user interface actually. To me it is quite intuitive and I find everything I usually need rather quickly.
- mapgrep 6y agoDemocrats in the US House of Representatives just approved a $741 billion defense spending package. It will almost certainly clear the senate and be signed by the president. Imagine taking enough of that money to support these 40 LibreOffice developers and maybe say 20 more. There would be no need for these acrobatics around source availability. I understand why the companies need to do this. But there is an existing system for funding things with widespread benefits to society. It’s called the government.
- JTon 6y agoIt begs an interesting question: does defense spending have a positive ROI? I don't know the answer to this question. But I'm thinking funding R&D, trade route protections, and perhaps some nefarious things can all contribute positively to American interests and thus American society.
- wazoox 6y agoGinormous defence spending is how the US do a "social state". That's pretty obvious once you see how defence money is peppered all across the country.
- arbitrary_name 6y agoIt's a republican jobs program.
- hguant 6y agoNah the defense industry is smarter than that - it's a bipartisan industry. F-35s have components that are built in every state for a reason.
- zanny 6y agoIt doesn't mean its productive. We could be spending half a trillion on civil engineering to rebuild cities, roads, high speed rail, canals, etc. That has appreciable and visible benefits to society. Occupying a desert on the other side of the world largely to disrupt oil pipelines seems less effective as stimulus.
- xvilka 6y agoInstead of delivering the dead and long stalled project Apache should admit the failure of OpenOffice (with their commit rate vs LibreOffice's one it's obvious) and redirect to LibreOffice instead. They should officially deprecate it. Right now they are stealing potential users of LO with their substandard product.
- jaxr 6y agoI don't mind LibreOffice's interface in general. Only a sublime style Ctrl+p find would make a huge difference. That alone would put it's interface on top of MS office in my opinion.
- mikece 6y agoIs there a manifesto or document anywhere which lays out the economic case for (US) Federal grants to develop free software? How many developers and how many projects could be staffed full-time with a billion dollars set aside annually for an Office of Open Source Software? (Of course such an office would descend into a cluster-[bleep] of political warfare over topics that have nothing to do with developing software so spending nothing probably gets as much done in this area than creating a government office which costs money and doesn’t get anything accomplished.)
- x87678r 6y agoA better deal would be Fed paying MS, then MS charging other countries all over the world and MS collects big $$$ in profits and US tax paid. Much of SV started like this too.
- mikece 6y agoMaybe I'm seeing what I want but it seems that the plan is for the document formats and editing programs to be free while generating revenue from infrastructure around delivering something "Sharepoint-like" (or a SaaS service to do similar), complete with a throat to choke/vendor to blame if things go sideways. I don't see this as fundamentally different from the choice of running CentOS versus paying for RHEL: the latter is the same software but comes with enterprise assurances that allow the CIO to sleep at night. I'm sure there's someone could write a compelling essay along the lines of "Free Software isn't free of charge" if someone were inclined to pursue it. Even people like RMS have to eat from time to time.
- simion314 6y agoAbout people hating change, in my IDE an update renamed a menu from "revert" to "Rollback" , for a while I had issues finding this menu because my brain was searching for the old text and just skipping over the new one. Is it my fault that change causes productivity loss? Should we take a pause and train ourselves after each software/webpage does a change?
- mixmastamyk 6y agoHave any of the support companies tried paying bounties for tickets? Seems like it would get revenue pointed at the bugs/enhancements that customers wanted worked on. Do they have a subscription to pay LO directly?
- galacticdessert 6y agoIt might sound stupid, but looking at the marketing plan attached to this article ( https://nextcloud.documentfoundation.org/s/jzryGw7XDkJadmo#pdfviewer https://nextcloud.documentfoundation.org/s/jzryGw7XDkJadmo#p... ) I wonder how they could deliver such an important message in such a messy way. There are context slides together with strategy slides, together with marketing slides, together with analysis slides. the best one is slide 48, which seems to be a leftover of the initial storyline? I really like LibreOffice and I try to push its usage where I can, but reading about a potentially risky development strategy in such a messy way makes me wonder if it has been thought out so well or it is a muddy idea reflected in unclear writing.
- beezle 6y agoSo much talk about UI this and that - how about leaving UI and feature set alone and instead focus on speed and memory foot print? Though recent versions are better, it still feels slow compared to Office.
- azinman2 6y agoI was hoping to find an actual plan towards making the software better, more usable, and desirable. Instead it’s just a “marketing plan” about splitting apart something that lags behind. Where’s the vision?!
- _bxg1 6y ago> The problem is compounded by companies that sell inexpensive "support" for LibreOffice, but which are not involved in its development and are not really able to provide that support. Those companies "file all their tickets up-stream and hope they are fixed for free". Companies working in that mode have no problem pricing their offerings below those of the companies doing the actual work (and thus winning much of the business that does exist). In addition, they simply call their offerings "LibreOffice", which actually looks more authentic than services from other companies, which are trying to build their own brands around LibreOffice support. Is this not a cut-and-dry case of trademark violation?
- munro 6y agoI just loaded up LibreOffice to give it a try, I would like to move off of Google as much as possible. 5 minutes in, I'm like, this is not that bad! Then this happened: > Due to an unexpected error, LibreOffice crashed. All the files you were working on will now be saved. The next time LibreOffice is launched, your files will be recovered automatically. I really require tools with multi platform live collaboration--I've been looking at Apple's Calc, as a possible switch, as well.
- pengaru 6y agoKind of odd that they don't compare themselves to Blender and its successful foundation in the article, not even mentioned once.
- ulisesrmzroche 6y agoWhy so much talk about the ribbon? This article has nothing to say about that. This is about a Personal Edition and an Enterprise edition and how little revenue its actually coming in. Basically, libre office won't be libre anymore. Looks like Enterprise is gonna have a commercial license. By the way, I think the ribbon is far better than the ugly dropdown menus. It's also been over a decade since it was introduced. Some of yall are so resistant to change is bordering on zealotry. I hate to remind everyone about dropbox but dropbox.
- crazygringo 6y ago> Basically, libre office won't be libre anymore The personal version still will be, right? Now this would be something to worry about if all new feature development were put into enterprise, and the personal version stagnated. But from my experience in enterprise software, enterprise features are generally not even applicable to consumer users at all. They're things like single sign-on, approval workflow integration, private cloud integration and whatnot. It's not as if a bugfix for page margins will make it to the enterprise version and not the personal one. So this doesn't feel like something to worry about. If it provides the necessary financial resources to keep the personal edition alive, then I'm all for it.
- ulisesrmzroche 6y agoYeah I’m cool with it too, it’s just not quote unquote true free software anymore. Which should be big news, but basically the whole first page of comments is all about the MS word ribbon Madness of crowds for sure
- Animats 6y agoSummary" ... There is the Personal Edition, which would be "forever free" and only available from the Document Foundation. This release would be tagged, according to the plan, "volunteer supported, not suggested for production environments or strategic documents". The alternative would be "LibreOffice Enterprise", which would only be available from "ecosystem members". This version would come with commercial support and a corresponding price tag. ... "There will be an X month gap between the release of the two versions: LibreOffice Online Enterprise and LibreOffice Online Personal".
- jandrese 6y agoPersonally I find LibreOffice Writer to be fine for my regular reports until something goes wrong and then it's like old versions of Word. For example, occasionally when I'm making a numbered list the tenth item and beyond will be bounced over a full tabstop which looks horrible. Then I'm trying to work around the problem by messing with the tab stops which causes problems for the rest of the document. It's really hard to fix when something goes wrong as a casual user. Inserting images/figures is fraught with peril too. I sometimes find myself hacking the doc until it looks presentable and then not touching it. It's like those old "smart" systems that weren't quite smart enough to get it right, but would fight you tooth and nail when you tried to undo what they did. For what its worth I prefer the consistency of its interface over the ever changing ribbon of Word. Word also tries to guess what you want and when it guesses wrong it's really annoying.
- Certhas 6y agoWe kind of need a version of CC-BY-NC. Preferably with a governance model that then distributes money from commercial licenses to contributors... Or government funded Open source. There is no reason for society to try to do something as intrinsically cooperative as building software through market mechanisms.
- einpoklum 6y agoThe Document Foundation should - IMHO - employ a more nuanced, and "deeper", community funding effort. Even though, when downloading it, we see a payment link - there is almost no motivation to press it: 1. We are in a hurry to go on with the download. 2. It's called a "donation" - which it isn't. It's support for the project, financing further development and bug removal, and should be presented that way. 3. We have zero information about the situation The Document Foundation is in, what it needs money for, what its income stream look like and why, etc. I think Thunderbird (https://www.thunderbird.net/ https://www.thunderbird.net/) has been doing a better job in that respect. 4. There doesn't seem to be an effort to encourage or even make-it-easy-for users (corporate or individual) to engage in community activity, of the kind that increases commitment to the project and also awareness to the importance of supporting the project financially. ------------------------ Also - please consider actually supporting both projects I mentioned, financially: * LibreOffice: https://www.libreoffice.org/donate/ https://www.libreoffice.org/donate/ * Thunderbird: https://give.thunderbird.net/en-US/ https://give.thunderbird.net/en-US/ and consider doing some volunteer QA work on LibreOffice by reporting bugs or even getting into the code. I, particularly, am very involved with Right-to-Left, Hebrew and some Arabic language issues.
- type0 6y agoPersonal Edition implies it won't have important collaboration features needed in organizations. And whether that will be true or not isn't the issue, less volunteers and non-profits will end up using LibreOffice, instead they could just called it Community Edition like every other FOSS project. They will end up with less volunteer contributors, but maybe that's what TDF wants, it's a pity.
- f0ok 6y agoIf LibreOffice is offering a paid version for extra features / services, considering what they are already offering, I would certainly paid, or at least have a strong interest.