22 ms·
After many false starts, hydrogen power might now bear fruit
- admax88q 6y agoHydrogen production is almost entirely produced from fossil fuels currently. Its not really a low carbon energy source unless electrolysis can be made much more efficient. Its a shame this article didn't examine the production side of hydrogen.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoIsn’t the last 1/3 of the article about the differences between grey, blue and green hydrogen?
- admax88q 6y agoAh that's my fault then. About 2/3 of the way through the article something loaded or shifted as nobody can resist the urge to highjack scrolling and I lost the rest of the text so I stopped reading.
- ced 6y agoFrom Wikipedia: The lower the energy used by a generator, the higher its efficiency would be; a 100%-efficient electrolyser would consume 39.4 kilowatt-hours per kilogram (142 MJ/kg) of hydrogen,[24] 12,749 joules per litre (12.75 MJ/m3). Practical electrolysis (using a rotating electrolyser at 15 bar pressure) may consume 50 kW⋅h/kg (180 MJ/kg), and a further 15 kW⋅h (54 MJ) if the hydrogen is compressed for use in hydrogen cars. It's not great, but it doesn't seem unworkable. I can't read the article, but isn't the idea to use hydrogen tanks as a battery to smooth out the variability of renewables like solar?
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoHow is that different from criticism of BEVs when they’re used in areas with coal-based electricity?
- admax88q 6y agoMy understanding is moving electricity into a battery is much more efficient than using it to break water into hydrogen.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoIt’s an engineering-tradeoff. The efficiency losses in hydrogen production are offset by the ability to refuel a hydrogen tank in under a minute compared to the hours it takes to safely[1] recharge a BEV. Plus, if hydrogen fuel production is powered by environmentally friendly electricity then the efficiency losses should only worry people concerned about the heat-death of the universe (and it’s no worse than the 20% efficiency of an ICE engine. “Don’t let perfect be the enemy of good”, etc) [1] While Tesla’s V3 Superchargers are amazing in that charging stops can now be as short as 10-15 minutes to for 100+ miles of range - Superchargers should not be used for day-to-day charging because it wears out the battery too much (hence the hype over the new generation of Lithium cells, that “million-mile battery”, but for the rest of us using current-gen Lithium batteries (myself included, I drive a Tesla too) I don’t want to have to drop $20k+ for an out-of-warranty battery replacement).
- hnick 6y agoI don't think most people consider it an energy source, more so a battery or storage medium. And cheaper storage is an important part of the renewables story because local supply can be unpredictable. I saw this article earlier today along those lines: https://www.smh.com.au/environment/climate-change/alchemy-of-energy-breakthrough-offers-mass-hydrogen-storage-options-20200702-p558dj.html https://www.smh.com.au/environment/climate-change/alchemy-of... Supposedly this stores hydrogen metal hydrides cheaper than lithium batteries, whatever that means, but I'm not qualified to judge.
- dghughes 6y agoThere is a video on YouTube about Bob Lazar the area 51 guy. Only it's about how he uses solar and wind to break down water into oxygen and hydrogen. He stores the hydrogen as a metal hydride. The tanks are heated to release the hydrogen and it's used to power his car.
- goda90 6y agoThe article does talk about steam reforming vs steam reforming + carbon capture vs electrolysis of water and the carbon cost and economics of each.
- reyoz 6y agoA recent report [1] looked at the efficiencies of generating hydrogen at a waste water treatment plant to lower production costs. The WWTP provides the water and uses the oxygen that is also produced by electrolysis to increase the efficiency of the biological treatment process vs air. Some of the electricity for the electrolysis can also be sourced from biogas produced by the WWTP. [1] https://www.jacobs.com/sites/default/files/2020-06/jacobs-yarra-valley-water-towards-a-zero-carbon-future.pdf https://www.jacobs.com/sites/default/files/2020-06/jacobs-ya...
- kumarski 6y agoOkay, going to chime in here because this is categorically wrong on so many fronts. Tldr: Impossible for civilization to make an instantaneous non-gradual switch to hydrogen fuel cells. People like Hydrogen because they're hyped about how it is: - Clean - Plentiful - Emission-less Hydrogen is difficult to handle. - Unwieldy as a gas - Boils at 20 degrees F/ - 6 degrees C / ~420 Kelvins - Tough to maintain at a high pressure. To go 300+ miles or ~480km or more on hdyrogen is ugh tough. H - 120 MJ/kg Gasoline - 44 MJ/kg Volume wise, ugh. H- 8 MJ/L Gasoline - 32 MJ/L You need ~5-10 kilograms of H2 to deal with light duty vehicles. Compressing the stuff is annoying. Training and retraining all the gas station attendants to deal with cryogenic materials is no small undertaking. There's 100K gasoline/diesel stations in the USA. Very special handling for hydrogen. Hydrogen penetrates metals. Makes metals the enemy and things can wear down unexpectedly. Scary stuff. Preventative maintenance is complicated. Gasoline has ~4x-8x the kwh per a gallon to compressed hydrogen fuel. (my calculation might be a bit off, but not that far off.) Pumping hydrogen into a vehicle is done slowly from my recollection. Hydrogen's explosion risk is extreme, the spark from the leak could cause it. eekkkkk. Hydrogen's flames are invisible. It's a pale blue flame that's difficult to see during the day. People might come back and say there's progress with magnesium adn/or carbon nanotubes or other things, but they're all meh and don't scale. Hydrogen has a shitty power to mass ratio. It escapes independently/leaks out easily without you knowing. It's dangerously explosive! It emits lots of CO2 to make the stuff. CH4+O2 = CO2+2H2 Makes the whole thing seem like a pointless exercise. The efficiency of manufacturing hydrogen for fuel usage is probably like 10% to 30%. Can't imagine it being more than that. I'm not a Chem E though. To make a cryogenic pipeline system in the USA for H2 would cost $1T+ Every year I get asked about Hydrogen, it's all BS. Any scientist that says it's highly viable has me wondering how much money they wasted on their degree.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoWhat is your opinion of Toyota’s hydrogen storage system for cars? It seems to tick all the boxes. (I just assume Toyota isn’t going big on the Mirai for the same reason Ford and GM still only pay lip-service to BEVs: they don’t want to upset their dealer network too much)
- threatripper 6y ago
- speedgoose 6y agoI used to drive a hydrogen car once in a while a few years ago. It was nice to fill the car in a few minutes and get about 300km of range, but that was it. With the hydrogen you have so few refueling stations, they are very expensive, that range anxiety is a thing. To not improve things, reliability is very poor. My work had a hydrogen refueling station on its parking. It was often broken and actually a bit scary to walk past it. They eventually removed it, which was a good call. Another hydrogen station sharing the same design exploded a few months later. The hydrogen car sales dropped from not much to virtually zero since in the country. So to resume, hydrogen cars are expensive, refueling stations are expensive, the energy is expensive. Electric cars with large batteries are a much better solution to hydrogen cars IMHO. You can charge everywhere, the eletric grid is very will developped, the energy is cheap. The cars are also much more powerful thanks to the large batteries pack, it's useless but it feels nice.
- Dumblydorr 6y agoThe issue of charging was also there with BEVs, until Tesla straight up built a huge network of superchargers. The players in hydrogen say they will do the same. But for personal vehicles, hydrogen won't math out, it's greatest advantage is its energy density for trucks. It's for long range trucks that we will see hydrogen first. Green hydrogen will act as energy storage, big renewables grids can dump excess into green hydrogen and thus avoid curtailment. Then, you replace heavy duty trucks, which need to be able to not have heavy batteries, with fuel cell trucks, and you build out 1000 large hydrogen stations across the transit network.
- RobertoG 6y agoMaybe ships is an even better fit than trucks?
- hwillis 6y agoTrucks are explicitly limited by weight, ships are somewhat limited by volume. Container ships especially need to be loaded way up because the cargo is less dense than eg crude oil. Heavy trucks are also a much bigger issue than international shipping, which is only ~2% of global GHG. 6.7% of US GHG emissions come from medium and heavy duty trucks, or 23% of emissions due to transportation.
- threatripper 6y agoHydrogen has an efficiency problem. You need to convert other forms of energy to hydrogen at a loss. Then you need to store it and transport it, which is costly and may impose quite some energy cost for cooling or compression. Then you need to convert it back to electricity, also at a loss. If you start at electricity, the electrical grid and batteries would be much more efficient. If you start at oil or gas, you could use convention ICEs and get comparable overall efficiencies. For them transport and delivery is a solved problem. Hydrogen fuel cells are clean where you use them. But so are batteries. Inner cities could be kept cleaner using either. Inner city traffic is mostly short range, so batteries are at an advantage. Batteries have a rare earth problem. But so do Hydrogen fuel cells. There is work to reduce it for both technologies. Hydrogen fuel cells have a problem with varying loads. You would use additional batteries in cars to supply peak demand when accelerating or store braking energy. For comparable weight, range, and price you could replace all hydrogen technology with more batteries. Those bigger batteries would also wear out slower because the power demand per cell is lower. So, when would hydrogen make sense? I think only if you don't care for efficiency. When you have so much electrical power that it costs you nothing and is available at least a few hours every night. Hydrogen would do well in a combination with large scale nuclear fission/fusion. It could take decades until we get there if we ever go that route. I see that, as batteries become less and less expensive, the niche where Hydrogen could have good advantage is getting smaller and smaller. However you twist and turn it, either oil&gas or batteries have the advantage.
- cultofmetatron 6y agosounds like Iceland would do well to export hydrogen from electrolysis
- speedgoose 6y agoTransporting hydrogen is expensive. It also has a tendency to leak.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y ago> It also has a tendency to leak. But I mean, that has to be a limitation of current technology, right? There has to be engineering solutions that we can devise to make it as safe statistically as for example gasoline transport?
- jakozaur 6y agoMain points: 1. The only hydrogen produced from electricity is ecological. Carbon capture doesn’t work today. 2. The hydrogen from electricity is expensive, though as wind and solar get exponential cheaper, we will end up with spikes excess cheap electricity (negative prices today or disconnecting plants). It makes sense to produce hydrogen during those spikes. 3. Cars on hydrogen don’t make sense at all. The massive cost of infrastructure plus batteries are superior and getting better on that front. 4. Hydrogen from electricity can replace the first reformation from natural gas. 5. Next promising use cases are industrial heating, such as steel production (instead of coal). 6. Least profitable, but still plausible, uses hydrogen as long-term energy storage and mixing it with natural gas. 7. I wonder whether generating hydrogen from seawater and getting back freshwater would improve the economics of this form of energy storage.
- harg 6y agoI don’t know if you had access to the whole article but it addresses all of the points you mention (except 7).
- maxerickson 6y ago1 kg of (electrically produced) hydrogen costs more than 1000 gallons of desal. (1 kg of hydrogen would make a few gallons of water)
- hwillis 6y agoedit: misinterpreted "desal" as diesel rather than desalinated water. Well that's just not at all true. Hydrogen by electrolysis costs <$20/kg. A much more interesting fact about a kg of hydrogen is also that it has very close to the same energy content as a gallon of diesel, and significantly more when used in a fuel cell vs an ICE. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/36734.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/36734.pdf
- maxerickson 6y ago1000 gallons of desalination costs $2 or $3. I was responding to point 7, not comparing hydrogen to diesel.
- Majromax 6y agoThis article looks like a fine discussion about the economics of hydrogen production, but unless I've missed something it skips over the immense storage difficulty. Hydrogen is a difficult thing to manage in quantity. Its density is fantastically low, so storing it in gas form requires absurd pressures -- an inherent risk to any vehicle. Storing it in liquid form goes a long way towards solving the density/pressure problem, but now the system must have a full cryogenic process to keep the hydrogen liquified. (Worse yet: over time hydrogen embrittles (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement) metals, making storage even more complicated) This isn't much different than the problems faced by rockets, and it's why liquid hydrogen is not considered a 'storable propellant' for long-duration flight. In a zero-net-carbon economy, residual demand for high power density may still have to be filled by some kind of bio-derived or synthetic hydrocarbon.
- mcot2 6y agoNot to mention the efficiency of converting the stored Hydrogen to power. It’s hard to beat the efficiency of a battery and electric motor.
- dmix 6y agoNow I'm curious how Hyundai or the stations actually produce the hydrogen fuel. Edit: this video had a good overview of the various production methods, including on-site at the fuel station https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7MzFfuNOtY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7MzFfuNOtY
- darksaints 6y agoWe don't need to rely on metals for hydrogen storage...composites work just fine. And for use cases like maritime and aviation power systems, cryogenic storage isn't necessary. At all. Because even with simple styrofoam insulation, consumption rates vastly exceed evaporation rates.
- jitendrac 6y agoI think article missed a really large sector which uses coal and produces millions of tons of co2 each year, That is cement industry. Heating clinker to produce cement is energy intensive long process, where big investments towards technology for using Hydrogen can be fruitful.
- threatripper 6y agoWhy not use electricity or natural gas for heating? Both would be more efficient than using hydrogen as an intermediate step.
- jitendrac 6y agoFor current circumstances this makes sense, Natural gas is not carbon neutral. For electricity, as the renewable energy generation capacity will increase, Storage of excess will be essentially required. when in near future we develop viable tech to generate hydrogen from electricity with low or no carbon impact at reasonable efficiency,we can save them in underground reserves(Safest way in my view) and use existing piping infrastructure of natural gas for its transportation. we need to do research and wait for appropriate tech to be available.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoWood is basically emerging as an alternative in this sector lately. There are some wood based building materials coming on the market that are cheap, sustainable, light, safe, strong, etc. Think people building sky scrapers in areas with exposure to earthquakes and tropical storms safe. I'm talking about Tokyo. https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/feb/16/plyscraper-city-tokyo-tower-wood-w350 https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/feb/16/plyscraper-ci... Hydrogen is not really needed to fix this.
- jitendrac 6y agoyup, new innovation is needed in construction. But wood is not gonna replace all cement-concrete use-cases.Cement-concrete has far more usecases from skyscrapers like bridges,Dams to road construction.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- goda90 6y agoThe article didn't touch on this at all, so has anyone heard updates on attempts at doing in-vehicle hydrogen production from water and some sort of reactant? It's been years since I saw something on it, but if I recall, it used some pellets made of certain metals that react with the water to produce hydrogen. You'd fill the tank with water, and after some number of fill ups you'd also need to replenish the pellets which could be sent off for recycling. Edit: I found an article about this. It appears to have been developed by the military and has been licensed out for more development: https://techxplore.com/news/2019-07-h2-power-hydrogen-fuel-startup.html https://techxplore.com/news/2019-07-h2-power-hydrogen-fuel-s...
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoA theory like that ignores most of known basic physics. What would the energy source be? It does not matter what chemical or electrochemical reactions are possible in general, what matters is where does the energy come from. Water does not contain any energy. (Not any chemical energy that can easily be extracted. Of course it contains energy in the sense that E=MC^2, but in that sense we have about the same chance to run a car on sand, or rocks or oreos.) On the other hand, if you do have an energy source, then why would you need water at all?? You would just use the energy to drive the car (like EVs do), you wouldn't waste half of it to hydrolysis of water into hydrogen first to use that hydrogen... A theory about a "car running on water" (which, at least in my experience is often followed by conversations about how Nicola Tesla could transfer energy through the air, or about how government has all the technology for infinite energy, but they block it from being used because they are evil) - is a pipe dream which is heavily based on ignorance about physics and gross underestimation of the difficulty of real engineering problems.
- goda90 6y agoI found the Wikipedia article: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminum_based_nanogalvanic_alloys https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminum_based_nanogalvanic_... Saying this ignores basic physics is like saying gasoline engines ignore basic physics. No one is saying that it's free energy. The question is, what is the energy to produce/recycle the alloy? How many miles can you get out of a reasonable supply of the alloy before replacing it? If those numbers are good enough, maybe they'll perform better than battery vehicles. And so I'm asking what's the state of that research.
- svara 6y agoI've been diving into this literature a bit recently, and it's been mostly encouraging. Affordable clean energy is realistic. Clean energy sources are typically the cheapest sources of energy [0]. The intermittent production issue is solvable: At ~150 $/kWh storage, a combination of storage and renewables is the cheapest energy source 95% of the time [1]. The cost of different energy storage methods is coming down exponentially [2]. A combination of Li-Ion battery (short-term), pumped hydro (medium-term) and hydrogen (long-term, i.e. seasonal) storage is probably how to smooth out the burstiness of renewable energy production eventually [3]. When green hydrogen infrastructure is commonplace, the hydrogen can also be used to make synthetic jet fuel and feedstocks for the chemical industry. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source [1] https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(19)30300-9 https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(19)30300-9 [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/nenergy2017110/figures/1?proof=true https://www.nature.com/articles/nenergy2017110/figures/1?pro... [3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S254243511830583X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S254243511...
- FabHK 6y agoRegarding [1], the article quotes production costs of USD 50/MWh for renewables, and USD 100/MWh for coal (graph 3). You/[1] is saying that with storage costs of USD 150,000 per MWh, renewables can be competitive? It doesn't compute, unless I misunderstand something.
- tomxor 6y agoFollowing Musk's thinking... i'd really like to see that energy density volume vs mass chart adjusted for average vehicle weight. i.e see the total system, engine, storage components and fuel converter etc. On that graph, compared to petrol, liquid hydrogen appears to be about 4x larger by volume but interestingly only 2/5ths of the weight. The electric motors are lighter sure, but then what about the mass and volume of the compressed storage tank and the fuel cell itself? difficult to know if it starts to gain on IC engine again. lots of questions that make that graph feel pretty meaningless.
- ecpottinger 6y agoNot once you include the storage tanks.
- tomxor 6y agoThat's my entire point.
- spenrose 6y agoA summary of the virtuous cycle created by cheap renewables and hydrogen electrolyzation: https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2020/6/17/renewables-plus-hydrogen-almost-all-that-we-need https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2020/6/17/renewables-p... Lots of comments on this thread that reveal folks are up to date with the state of hydrogen infrastructure c. 2017. It's changing really fast as billions of dollars are poured into R&D and pilot projects. For example, storage and transport: https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-japan-hydrogen-chiyoda-corp/japans-chiyoda-says-hydrogen-pilot-project-begins-to-fuel-power-plant-idUKKBN23W1LR https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-japan-hydrogen-chiyoda-cor... Siemens has pledged to make turbines that run on 100% hydrogen by 2030: https://new.siemens.com/global/en/company/stories/energy/hydrogen-capable-gas-turbine.html https://new.siemens.com/global/en/company/stories/energy/hyd... Hydrogen trains: https://www.snam.it/en/Media/Press-releases/Agreement_Alstom_and_Snam_hydrogen_trains_in_Italy.html https://www.snam.it/en/Media/Press-releases/Agreement_Alstom... Hydrogen in steelmaking: https://www.spglobal.com/platts/en/market-insights/latest-news/metals/061620-interview-gfg-alliance-readies-liberty-alvance-simec-for-ipos https://www.spglobal.com/platts/en/market-insights/latest-ne... I could post 15 more. Our collective priors were well-grounded just a couple years ago, but it is time for a big update.
- gandalfian 6y agoI think the charts are saying roughly a litre of lithium battery has 1kwh, a litre of liquid hydrogen 3kw and a litre of petrol 10kw. By 2050 your litre of green hydrogen might cost 10 cents to make or 3c per kWh.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoElectricity is approaching 1c per kWh in some recent solar plant bids. For example, there were a few bids in the middle east recently that were getting close to that. Battery cost is on track to dip below 100$ per kwh. E.g. Tesla is rumored to be at or below that already/in the near future. By 2050, energy cost is going to be measured differently. IMHO it stops being a variable cost once it dips substantially below 1c per kwh. Your basically spending more on coffee to keep yourself going on an average journey, Arguably, if you have access to square meters, it's a cost that is amortized over the one time cost of installing wind turbines, solar panels, batteries and other infrastructure. Kind of expensive today but doable; that will be very much different 3 decades from now. Any business operating fleets of vehicles will want to minimize this cost. That means investing in cheap sources of energy and a mass switch to battery electric vehicles that is already kicking off right now. This takes time obviously and doesn't happen overnight. But it's also not going to take decades. It's one of those things where the payoff is non linear meaning it goes from "oh wouldn't that be nice" to "I must do this now to survive as a business" in just a few years. In other words, this will have largely been completed by 2050. This is good news for hydrogen as well because it means that there will be plenty of excess energy from peak solar/wind that's basically there to be used. Producing hydrogen and other synthetic fuels (and water) is an obvious way to put that to use and can be used as a solution to fix e.g. shipping, heavy industrial use, and other sectors currently depending on oil or coal. That's after we've topped up our TWH of deployed grid and ev batteries of course. And maybe we'll figure out fusion as well by that time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bambam24 6y agoDoes people get referral bonus for sharing this paid website links?
- dang 6y agoPaywalls are ok if there's a workaround. Users usually post workarounds in the thread. Yes, it sucks, but the alternatives suck worse. The Economist has been the source for a lot of good HN discussions, as have other soft-paywalled sites. We don't allow hard-paywalled ones. This is in the FAQ at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html and there's more explanation here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20paywalls&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989
- carapace 6y agoHydrogen is sexy but alcohol matches our existing context better. Small-scale alcohol fuel production integrated into regenerative agriculture farms is different from mass ethanol production. You can ferment anything that has starch or sugar, the leftovers from the distillation can be composted or fed to livestock. Most existing internal combustion engines can be modified to use alcohol fuel. And it's carbon-neutral.
- dredmorbius 6y agoFeedstock is the problem here: there's simply not enough net primary productivity on the planet, and humans already appropriate ~20%. There are some marginal gains possible, but on the order of single-digit percentages of present fossil fuel consumption. Maybe low double-digits. The US had a largely biofuel based transport system in 1900. Horses consumed 20% of all US grain production, the population was under 100m, and transport generally was a small fraction of today's values (or at least last year's) per capita: closer to 300 mi/yr, much of that walking, than 15,000.
- elago 6y agoAccording to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the U.S. has 434,164,946 acres of “cropland”—land that is able to be worked in an industrial fashion (monoculture). This is the prime, level, and generally deep agricultural soil. In addition to cropland, the U.S. has 939,279,056 acres of “farmland.” This land is also good for agriculture, but it’s not as level and the soil not as deep. Additionally, there is a vast amount of acreage—swamps, arid or sloped land, even rivers, oceans, and ponds—that the USDA doesn’t count as cropland or farmland, but which is still suitable for growing specialized energy crops. Of its nearly half a billion acres of prime cropland, the U.S. uses only 72.1 million acres for corn in an average year. The land used for corn takes up only 16.6% of our prime cropland, and only 7.45% of our total agricultural land. Even if, for alcohol production, we used only what the USDA considers prime flat cropland, we would still have to produce only 368.5 gallons of alcohol per acre to meet 100% of the demand for transportation fuel at today’s levels. Corn could easily produce this level—and a wide variety of standard crops yield up to triple this.
- mitchtbaum 6y agopedal power also propels
- mrtnmcc 6y agoSomething practical not mentioned here is that the proton exchange membrane in fuel cells generally degrade in a few years and need to be replaced. This is a major expense. Degradation is accelerated if the hydrogen (fuel) or oxygen (from environment) are not pure.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xivzgrev 6y agoAs soon as I read hydrogen stored in a tank - did anyone else think potential to explode in an accident?
- sgt 6y agoRight. Based on the Hindenburg accident, we should just give up on Hydrogen.
- superklondike 6y agoWhy would I want to drive to a fueling station when I can plug my ev in at home?
- superklondike 6y agoEV owner here. Why would I want to drive to a fueling station when I can fuel up at home with electricity? And from a maintenance level, ev’s have substantially fewer parts and almost zero maintenance, whereas hydrogen perpetuates the ICE-engine paradigm... frequent oil changes, many moving parts, lots of service costs at the dealership. The economics of H2 may be different at the commercial scale, but we use a Chevy Bolt in a far northern climate and get nearly 200 miles of range in the winter. The future is already here, and H2 missed the consumer vehicle bandwagon.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mdavis6890 6y agoI wish I'd stop hearing about Hydrogen as a fuel source. It's not. It's just a battery, and should simply be compared to other types of batteries, like Li-Ion. Maybe Hydrogen fuel cells are better batteries, maybe not. But it's still just a battery, and needs to be charged from the electric power grid (by using the electricity to separate hydrogen from water), just like any other battery would.
- boublepop 6y agoThe defining difference between fuel-cells and batteries is that fuel-cells don’t need to be “recharged” as in running an electrochemical reaction in reverse, they just need you to change the fuel.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoBut the fuel was charged from another source in fuel cells too. You don't mine hydrogen. The energy carrier point remains. The primary energy will be from gas, oil, coal, nuclear, hydro, solar, wind, geothermal, biomass, or tidal.
- jsilence 6y agoThe explosion limits of hydrogen are very wide. I do not want to live in a world with a widely deployed hydrogen infrastructure. Stuff is going to blow up. People are going to die. Disclaimer: chemical engineer, German University.
- MayeulC 6y agoPeople said that about electricity, too. A lot of people died. Houses burned. Norms were changed regarding cabling and earthing. Hopefully, whatever we decide to adopt as a technology will come with adequate safety norms. While only tangentially related, a lot of people think about the Hindenburg accident when talking about either hydrogen or dirigibles. But those contain less fuel than an airplane, at least in terms of energy. And 35 people died, around a third. To contrast with airliner accidents. But it sure left a mark on collective psyche. And I agree that hydrogen is incredibly volatile and explosive, which isn't a good fit for every application.
- jsilence 6y agoThe physical threat ranges of electrocution and explosions vastly differ.
- cheesecracker 6y ago"might" - so it won't, again.
- Animats 6y agoIf you want an hydrogen-powered car, buy a Toyota Mirai. They've been on sale in California since 2016. There are a few hydrogen stations where you can fill it. 5 minute refuel, about 300 mile range. (400 miles in the 2021 model.) The first three years of hydrogen are included with the vehicle purchase. Vehicle price about US$60K. (Expected to be higher for the 2021 model.) Total US sales in 2019: 1502. It's just not selling.
- userbinator 6y agoThere are a few hydrogen stations where you can fill it. ...and that's the problem. Gasoline, diesel, and electricity are all far easier to find than hydrogen. (Electrolysis is also extremely inefficient, for those who might be wondering.)
- jacquesm 6y agoHydrogen, to put it simply is a battery, not a fuel, and a relatively poor battery at that. For all the money dumped into it and the amount of research that has been done BEV is now generally considered the way forward. It also doesn't suffer from the problem that Hydrogen tends to go FOOF when you least expect it, and there isn't the pesky problem of Hydrogen embrittlement to deal with.
- nchase 6y agoSorry, haven’t read the mountain of comments yet: will it be possible to have a hybrid car that runs on Electric, with Hydrogen fuel cells as an alternative fuel source?
- willis936 6y agoSo many comments saying hydrogen, like lithium, is not a power source. They are in a fusion device ;)