12 ms·
It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning
- cultus 6y agoThat's easy to say when your local politics isn't controlled by homeowners who have financial incentive to oppose density.
- adwww 6y agoI don't know if that's true though. Your standalone plot is surely worth more in an area that more people want to live in, and where developers could potentially buy it off you to subdivide and turn into multiple homes?
- sushshshsh 6y agoOver my dead body. Seriously, I lived in all kinds of apartments for 15 years and there will always be some kind of horrific nuissance no matter how hard everyone tries to be respectful of each other. I'm all for increasing density, go ahead and build your buildings higher. But don't do it at the expense of people who are willing to pay high premiums to have a small piece of land to avoid the noise, smell, polution, and crowding of apartments.
- cheschire 6y agoMany folks felt the exact same about losing the Wild West to “civilization.” Doesn’t mean you or they were wrong, but you’re most likely going to be plowed over by the machines of progress.
- jansan 6y agoBy progress you mean population growth?
- kgermino 6y agoAbolishing single family zoning won’t do anything to prevent you from buying a single family house. The vast, vast, majority of houses will still be detached single family. It’s just allowing the option to build an in-law unit and rent it out, or split the house into a duplex, or build a townhouse (houses with shared walls).
- analog31 6y agoIt might just prevent you from living in it, for instance if it happens to be in between a discotheque and a pig farm. What makes me nervous would be not knowing if my long term investment in a living space could be erased by some arbitrary use of the neighboring land. And individual homeowners would have no power against corporate owners of the land.
- greenonions 6y agoWhy is the government obligated to protect your investment? They aren't obligated to keep stock prices high, or to protect the companies land nearby.
- luckylion 6y ago> Why is the government obligated to protect your investment? They are not. But they want people to invest, and people will not invest if they have no ability to predict the future circumstances. That's why governments try to create long-term systems and aren't running on mood swings. Nobody will invest anywhere if all the parameters are up for redefinition every day. "Oh, you built your factory based on proximity to the high way and train line? Well guess what, those are lame, and we've decided to remove both because we want to be cool. We are not obligated to protect your investment."
- greenonions 6y agoThey will invest, they will just price in the risk. The same as any other asset. We don't discourage this behavior in other areas, so again, why do we protect house assets? This is especially striking with homelessness being such a massive issue. Why would we protect and inflate housing investments when so many are perishing on the street?
- cultus 6y agoSo the government should manipulate the housing market to benefit a small class of people who can afford single family homes in a place, even if it is detrimental the to vast majority? If you want to live in a SFH, perhaps a dense urban core is not ideal for you.
- pseudolus 6y agoThe article is calling for the abolition of single-family zoning, not the imposition of zoning laws that mandate the construction of multi-family dwellings. Essentially, the author is a property rights proponent - if you own the land you should be able to construct whatever premises pleases you on it.
- geebee 6y agoShould you be able to trade your right to construct whatever you want in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that your neighbors will be similarly restricted in what they can build? Plenty of people would like to voluntarily enter that arrangement. Same with short term rentals - many people would like to trade their right to run a hotel out of their residence in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that they won't end up living next to a hotel.
- obblekk 6y agoYes, but the law should enforce your agreement with your neighbors, not obligate you to form an agreement as it does today. I think the biggest issue in zoning is the lack of a path to unzone something. If I convince all my immediate neighbors to let me build up (perhaps by giving them some equity in the new building) I should be allowed by the law to build. Today, even if my whole block wants to build up, we cannot.
- geebee 6y agoYes, good point. I would support a more local regulation on much of this (same for Airbnb, I see no reason why people in the sunset should determine whether people in bernal can short term rent their properties). Personally, I don't think you should have to get universal agreement either. Maybe a simple majority? Life does chance, cities grow to new borders, single family zoning that made sense a generation ago can be absurd later. As for zoning vs private contract... well, for historical reasons, that's just how it works in older urban neighborhoods. That's the mechanism by which these property rights are decided. It's not ideal. But at my core, I do think the right to live in areas with certain building restrictions is a kind of personal property right just as real as the right to build whatever you want.
- ohples 6y agoI'm willing to make the concession that any urban area with > 100,000 should probably not have single family zoning. Build your McMansion out int the boonies, just don't expect me to subsidize it with my tax dollars
- seattle_spring 6y agoSeems like quite the strawman. A 1200 sq ft, or even 2000 sq ft home is not even close to a "McMansion", and a few miles from the urban core is not "the boonies."
- omosubi 6y agoNot op but I'm still in favor of getting rid of subsidies for suburbs - they distort the market to benefit mostly wealthy homeowners to begin with.
- DudeInBasement 6y agoThis guy has no idea how much those McMansions pay in taxes. "Don't expect me to subsidize..." - said the Tax Cow
- leetcrew 6y agoI'm sorry you've had such a bad experience with apartments. I find that if you pay extra for a new building in a neighborhood with a higher median age, there's really not much nuisance. I live in a small studio and I never hear or smell my neighbors. I don't think anyone is talking about banning detached SFHs here; they merely want to remove the ban on building literally anything else. SFHs are quite popular, and whatever happens, I'm sure there will still be a market for them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- troydavis 6y ago> But don't do it at the expense of people who are willing to pay high premiums to have a small piece of land to avoid the noise, smell, polution, and crowding of apartments. I think you may misunderstand what zoning does. Ending single family zoning doesn’t end single family houses, it just allows other housing types to be built as well. Many or most housing units would still be single family houses, with or without zoning. This would remove the incentive to over-supply, not the incentive to supply.
- yellowapple 6y agoI think the title's a bit more provocative than the point I took from the article: that right now the premiums for that "small piece of land" ain't quite high enough due to that being specifically subsidized, and that we should remove restrictions preventing the construction of multi-family homes or residential/commercial hybrid properties. My problem with apartments is that they ain't "mine". Not once has an apartment in which I lived allowed its tenants (myself included) to even paint the walls, let alone hang pictures with nails (gotta use those adhesive strips that absolutely suck) or mount a TV to the wall. And no way in hell would they allow me to do crazier things like putting Ethernet jacks and speaker hookups in the walls or replacing the light switches/fixtures (hell, most get uppity even if I change a burnt-out bulb) or putting in those fancy outlets with the built-in USB ports¹. Even if I were to "own" my apartment (i.e. as a condo) there's no way in hell they'd be okay with me swapping out the windows, or putting in better insulation, or installing a solar power system (and they'd probably still object to me ripping apart the walls to put in those Ethernet jacks / speaker hookups). And then on top of all that, there are countless other things I can't do by nature of not "owning" the outdoor space, either. Shed? Nope. Barbecue? Usually not. Workshop? Not unless I'm lucky enough to have an attached garage². That DIY smelter I wanna build³? Hell fuckin' nope. I feel like a happy medium (for me at least) between "stuck in an apartment" and "suburbia" would be townhomes or something similar: still "detached", but thinner and much closer together, with an emphasis on building vertical. Could even be on the same square footage of land, just thin and long instead of fat and square. More critically, though, I strongly believe the distinction between "residential" and "commercial" zoning should be significantly blurred. Both in the sense of mixed-use buildings⁴ and in the sense of small business owners living where they work / working where they live (e.g. shop or restaurant on the first floor, and the owner lives on the second floor, as was once traditional). ---- ¹: Though my previous apartment in Daly City did come with USB outlets, which was a pleasant surprise ²: Currently I am not so lucky, though the garage does have an outlet so as long as I don't draw too much down I might be able to get away with it ³: https://www.instructables.com/id/How-To-Make-The-Mini-Metal-Foundry/ https://www.instructables.com/id/How-To-Make-The-Mini-Metal-... ⁴: I'm a strong advocate for underground parking + ground floor(s) for shops/restaurants + additional floors for apartments/condos or offices; even if apartments/condos ain't my cup of tea, I'd rather live in that sort of place than a building that's just apartments
- omosubi 6y agoI'd also be in favor of getting rid of parking minimums in cities and just about everywhere else - an enormous benefit to car, oil and construction companies that just degrades the environment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 6y agoWhich will tank home prices because suburbia is genuinely not livable without a vehicle. Public transportation doesn’t work since people are super spread out, all commercial activity is miles away, your work is probably 20-60 min away by car. Abolishing parking minimums or generally discouraging cars in isolation just makes everyone worse off. You have to make the area livable without a vehicle first.
- barrkel 6y agoIncreased density makes public transport more viable. If you outlaw density increase, you're definitely not going to get good public transport.
- jansan 6y agoLet's face it, public transportation has not proved to be very helpful during the COVID-19 pandemic. Here in Germany, private cars have saved our butt. I have become much more sceptical towards public transport in the last few months.
- noirbot 6y agoHow has Japan/South Korea worked around that? When I think of countries with crowded public transit, Japan is always top of mind, but they seem to have avoided a lot of the virus transmission problems you'd think would have been associated with that.
- 6y ago
- apoverton 6y agoSomething that is not touched on in the post but the book The Color of Law touches on in depth is how single family zoning has strong racist motivations. There are many Suburban areas that had the exclusion of black people as a requirement for Federal financial support. These include areas such as Stanford/Palo Alto and Long Island in NY but the list is numerous.
- cheez 6y agoWow
- pzone 6y agoIt is briefly mentioned at the end of the article as a way to find common cause with the left on this issue.
- rayiner 6y agoThat is a great book. There are so many things people don’t know, such has how FDR’s WPA tore down integrated neighborhoods and replaces them with segregated ones: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-federal-government-intentionally-racially-segregated-american-cities-180963494/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-federal-governmen... > In Langston Hughes’ autobiography, he describes how he lived in an integrated neighborhood in Cleveland. His best friend in high school was Polish. He dated a Jewish girl. That neighborhood in Cleveland was razed by the WPA, which built two segregated [ones], one for African-Americans, one for whites. The Depression gave the stimulus for the first civilian public housing to be built. Were it not for that policy, many of these cities might have developed with a different residential pattern.
- godelzilla 6y agoWhy would right-wingers reference their own racist culpability when they can blame the government instead?
- dang 6y agoWould you please stop using HN primarily for ideological battle? It's against the rules because it destroys what this site exists for, and we ban accounts that do it regardless of which ideology they favor. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20primarily%20test&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- jansan 6y agoSerious question, how does subsidizing work in these cases. Will the government subsidize the land price in single family zones? How does it work
- mayneack 6y agoThe subsidies mentioned are federal transportation (highway) spending. Without that (or even better with it redirected into mass transit) the prospect of commuting into the city by car becomes a lot less economical.
- someguydave 6y agoFederal mortgage subsidies are tied to single family housing as well.
- vonmoltke 6y agoI'm not sure what other "subsidies" you are talking about, but the mortgage interest deduction has nothing to do with the type of construction or zoning. Neither are FHA loan programs.
- ip26 6y agoIt isn't directly tied to zoning, but it provides the greatest benefit to people with expensive houses and high incomes. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/who-benefits-tax-subsidies-home-ownership https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/who-benefits-tax-subs...
- sradman 6y ago> When it comes to housing policy, we conservatives run the risk of becoming a caricature of ourselves, long on reactionary impulse but short on principle. There are two principles dear to conservatives that form an antagonistic relationship in this case: 1. minimal government intervention, and 2. emergent common law/standards. When left alone, homeowner associations (HOAs) tend to form single-family zoning policies. I'm not sure how to square this circle.
- someguydave 6y agoHOA law is a mess and needs repeal/reform from the state governments
- megiddo 6y agoHOAs survive because they are able to socialize long-term costs of maintaining them. If an HOA mandates single-family dwellings and large set-backs, then it should be directly responsible for road maintenance, sanitation, fire, etc. If you want all those long roads, you have to pay for them. The way it works now is that a developer drops in an HOA with a restrictive covenant, then turns the mess over to the nearest city to maintain a bunch of excessive infrastructure. If an HOA can't be maintained (bankruptcy) then the covenant should be automatically dissolved and the easements lifted.
- someguydave 6y agoYes. In colorado they actually have a mechanism where the city and developer can conspire to create a special tax district for each development area.
- obblekk 6y agoI’m surprised that free market enthusiasts don’t see zoning laws as a limitation of freedom, even though it’s probably the most direct limitation by government today. There could be so much innovation in solving the NIMBY problem. Make a cash payment to neighbors while construction is happening to compensate for the nuisance, give them equity in your new building if their view is damaged, obligate builders to also build bus stops/bike lanes/whatever to make the streets navigable with high density, mixed use construction with privacy to avoid strangers. So many problems that people have with construction can be solved and incentives aligned if people had the ability to try to convince their neighbors. Instead we’ve ended up with city councils that have high incumbency rates because voting in city elections is cumbersome requiring you to convince the whole city to change zoning rather than just your neighbors. And I’m surprised politically liberal people aren’t even more in favor. So many people want to move to the west coast but can’t due to cost of living. Instead they move to the south and southwest. Even if California got a million staunch republicans, the state would vote democratic overall and get more electoral votes. In fact, I wonder if some of our political polarization is the consequence of reduced mobility due to high housing costs for new people. I’m hopeful the millennial generation fixes federal housing policy. That alone would be a meaningful contribution to society.
- megiddo 6y agoIf it helps. I'm a free market type. We've been railing against zoning regulations for decades. Here's an article from Mises.org (about as free-market as you can find) from 2010 railing against it: https://mises.org/library/zoning-laws-destroy-communities https://mises.org/library/zoning-laws-destroy-communities
- fennecfoxen 6y agoIf you’re surprised they’re not, it’s because you’re not looking. The actual free market enthusiasts condemn it extensively. Go over to reason.com and search for their zoning coverage. Go to the AEI and find their report calling for the abolition of single family zoning. (I’d send you links, but I’m on a phone.) The main difference between them and the more left-leaning types who hate single family zoning is that they’re not too big on replacing it with other zoning.
- RNCTX 6y agoBet you won't have to dig far to find that the author of the article is an apartment developer or very adjacent to one.
- greenonions 6y agoHe's the founder of Strong Towns: https://www.strongtowns.org/about https://www.strongtowns.org/about a non profit advocacy for financial stability in communities. His background is civil engineering.
- marcoperaza 6y agoThe author has plenty of good ideological arguments but doesn't really seem interested in what the effect of eliminating single-family zoning will be on day to day life for people and communities. People like living in single-family zoned neighborhoods. People don't want high-density development in their neighborhoods. People leave behind exciting city lives and move to the suburbs because they want to live somewhere peaceful, boring, low-crime. Now someone wants to transform their neighborhood and make it look like those places they decided not to live in. As for this guy calling himself a conservative, somewhere along the way, libertarians in America began calling themselves conservatives and forgot what the term really means. Conservatism isn't knee-jerk ideological opposition to any rules.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThere are countless people who live happily in areas that don't have single-family zoning. So I don't know what effects you would expect, other than an increased availability of housing. Low-rise zoning makes sense - some people just don't like having a skyscraper next door - but I don't see any reason that a 6-unit apartment building would infringe on the day to day life of people in the 2 story house next door.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cactus2093 6y agoI wonder if COVID-19 will have any lasting effect on housing patterns. I used to be very pro-density in terms of my own preference of where to live, and I’ve never lived in the suburbs or in a single family home in my adult life. I’m finding it very challenging while locked down though, it’s making me realize I actually do value having my own space that I can own and control. I’m pretty introverted to begin with but I’ve never minded living in a big building with a bunch of strangers, but now that I see many of these strangers doing things that potentially endanger my health like walking around without masks, having illegal gatherings, and begging the management to reopen our gym in the middle of this pandemic, my outlook has completely changed. Even once this pandemic ends, I imagine I will think differently about the trade offs and risks of living in such close quarters with so many people I don’t know. This is not exactly related to single family zoning, but in the same vein I imagine if I had a single family home and someone wanted to build a huge apartment building next to me right now, I would be unhappy for the same reasons. I’ve always been morally against NIMBYism on principle, but to be honest this pandemic has really started to change my perspectives.
- yohannparis 6y agoI disagree, cities have survived worse pandemics than todays. This is why we have parks and pedestrians streets in Europe. What I see is a more livable cities across North America, like NYC or DC.
- xnx 6y agoMy guess is that the lasting effects on housing patterns from COVID-19 will be in the form of more people working from home more of the time.
- xnx 6y agoCould the zoning situation be improved with the concept of shared air-rights? Note that this is non an idea I've researched at all. Any property you own would also include partial air-rights for surrounding properties. If a new development was going to cast a shadow on to your property, they would need to buy you out of those air rights. You're never forced to sell, but many would be happy to if the price was right.
- dillonmckay 6y agoI live next door to a single—family home that was ‘converted’ to a duplex in an area where vehicles are required. There are only 2 parking spots available, and the upstairs unit was converted in such a way that the only way to get to the bathroom is through the kitchen. The side of the house was ‘modified’ to provide a front-door to the upstairs unit. However, this door is less than 6 feet from my fence, so it is impossible for anybody to move furniture in or out of the home.
- yohannparis 6y agoThis is a permit and building code issue, not a zoning one.
- dillonmckay 6y agoThat is semantics. The zoning determines what permits and codes are applicable to the zone.
- yohannparis 6y agoI disagree, you can still allow duplex, and require bigger spaces, better design floorpan, proper entrance. This has nothing to do about the fact that the zoning allows duplex.
- greenonions 6y agoDo you live there? Is this somehow your problem? Do you know anyone who would like/needs to deal with those inconveniences in order to save money on rent? I'm being a jerk, but even if you find something objectionable doesn't mean that it doesn't have a purpose. Unless you're willing to buy the place, renovate in a way you see fit, and try to rent for a profit, then you should not spend so much time being concerned about this house.
- dillonmckay 6y agoWell, the tenants are evicted after several months. The tenants, or their visitors, will park in other peoples yards. The landlord will make deals to waive the security deposit in exchange for ‘fixing up’ the units, after the prior tenant trashes it. So, ‘saving money’, is really externalizing the costs to the surrounding neighbors. My plan is to purchase it, and raze it to the ground, honestly. So, the neighbor that has a bunch of money, and sees the lot next door become ‘denser’, why not buy all the units and create a buffer?
- dillonmckay 6y agoRight to Quiet Enjoyment https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/quiet-enjoyment-laws.html https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/quiet-enjoyme...
- chaboud 6y agoWhat manifests in the linked writing is a near-perfect articulation of the head-scratching argumentation made by old-school fiscal conservatives when confronting the actions of now-dominant social conservatives. Calls to demonstrate conservative principles of small government, to spurn the transfer of funds from blue states to red states, and to reject racist policies are appeals to fiscal conservatism and proponents of small government. Unfortunately for the author, that's a plainly antiquated cause in American conservative politics. The wedge issues, antagonistic framing, and outright racism leveraged to build a coopted support base have broken out of the petri dish and taken over the host, leaving old school fiscal conservatives and small-government idealists thoughtfully trying to state their points as they get shoved into a school locker or quietly shaking their heads as they wonder how to make the trade off worth it. In a way, it represents a now set-aside third political body, one that liberals would do well to include, learn from, and leverage. There are people who wish to ask interesting questions, theorize, advocate, and meaningfully govern (even if it's in a very different way).
- greenonions 6y agoI think the third party you're alluding to is the demographic that actually cares about improving things for most people, regardless of the political philosophy that the idea comes from. I've always thought there should be more like us than the other type of people who are purely idealogical, but that's exactly what everyone else thinks. At least I can console myself knowing I don't support such hilariously incongruent ideas as the social conservatives you mention. But I'm not sure how what I believe are good policies for most actually win out
- ralmidani 6y agoThe US still has vast swaths of untouched land. WFH is feasible for many jobs. And COVID-19 has shown how dangerous it is to keep people crowded together. If anything, it’s time to spread out even more.
- shawabawa3 6y agoThe real problem with the world right now isn't Covid but the looming threat of climate change Densely populated cities may not be good for disease prevention but they are much more efficient in terms of carbon cost per capita
- ralmidani 6y agoNot a scientist so posing these as genuine questions: do crowded cities become "hot spots" in terms of heat output (everyone has the A/C on, which leads to heat building up, which leads to people blasting their A/C even higher, etc.)? And does spreading people out give heat more room to dissipate?
- cesarb 6y agoThe term you are looking for is "urban heat island": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_heat_island https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_heat_island
- goda90 6y agoThis reminded me of an article I read about "dachas" in Russia, which are basically allotted garden plots with a small house that tons of every-day Russians have.[0] Combined with plentiful public transit, remote work, good community layouts,etc, I think the ideal living conditions for people would be something like this. Low density housing, not made up of McMansions and chemical soaked lawns, but of space where people can connect with nature, enjoy the land side by side with neighbors and family. [0]https://www.notechmagazine.com/2020/03/a-dacha-for-everyone-community-gardens-and-food-security-in-russia.html https://www.notechmagazine.com/2020/03/a-dacha-for-everyone-...
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThere’s a lot of problems that are still even unrelated to zoning. For example, San Jose has 25 feet setback rules for houses from the street. Can you imagine how much square footage could be added overnight if people were allowed to build closer to the sidewalks?
- tomohawk 6y agoThe cities in our area are heavily subsidized by the state. The state collects the vast majority of its taxes from the suburbs. In return, the cities here have non-functioning schools, despite being well funded. The cities have very high crime, and basic services in the cities are lacking. There is a perpetual cycle of 20 somethings moving into the cities as they start their careers, and then moving to the burbs within 5-10 years as they realize that their kids will be uneducated if they remain there, and they will get mugged every couple of years.
- ip26 6y agoI was excited to see a professedly conservative site confronting popular subsidies. That's something valuable the classical conservative viewpoint could contribute to the discussion. Sadly, as I reached the end I knew- only one person could have written this. Marohn is, unfortunately, still bearing his torch alone. The comments on the site are basically "don't touch my handouts" and "suburbs are the last stronghold against the brown people".