18 ms·
If you wanted to get into the criminal drug trade, how would you start? Is there a guide somewhere I can follow? $13M in cash is an impressive amount. It makes
by sillysaurusx 6y ago
If you wanted to get into the criminal drug trade, how would you start? Is there a guide somewhere I can follow?
$13M in cash is an impressive amount. It makes me wonder: There must be all kinds of operations happening around us daily, yet nobody knows about them. And those operations need members. Where do they come from?
The inner workings of this stuff is fascinating. To be honest, I wish it were possible to go observe the system in action as a spectator. I'd love to see how the packaging is done, the supply lines, the transport logistics...
(I balance this with a deep hatred for cartels. If you trace these questions far enough, it seems to often lead to "the cartels are at the center of it all." And they're responsible for unspeakable miseries.)
To be clear, my question is: how is the knowledge necessary for such operations preserved? I'm a programmer. I learned it from the internet. Where do they learn? And these aren't street dealers. It's an organized, carefully designed, well-oiled machine. How does this machine work? How does it survive the loss of so many members?
- Apofis 6y agoThere's a ton of "inside look" type videos on Vice on YouTube if you're interested. Try a "{any drug name} vice" query.
- red_admiral 6y agoYou would join an existing organisation, as you'd have no chance setting yourself up as a "startup" - existing gangs would not take kindly to someone trying to disrupt their business.
- reedwolf 6y agoThe criminal world offers a fascinating glimpse into what pure, unrestrained capitalism would look like. If we look at what trading corporations do in times and places where they can get away with it, we see: -Aggressive acquisition of natural resources to protect the supply chain -Use of armed force to gather and protect said natural resources and the geographic territory wherein they're contained. -Use of armed force to protect and expand market capitalization (markets, trade routes etc) This is pretty much identical to what a drug cartel does on a day-to-day basis.
- dionysus_jon 6y agoBy definition trade in capitalism is done willing. That is not capitalism.
- orthoxerox 6y agoPeople buying drugs do so willingly.
- dionysus_jon 6y agoindeed, but that wasn't the bit I was talking about. I was replying to the comments about use of force.
- rbrtl 6y agoRather depends on your definition of willing.
- zer0tonin 6y agoThat's nowhere in the common definition of capitalism.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> By definition trade in capitalism is done willing. Not by the definition used by the people who named and defined capitalism. It's true that after that, the conceit that capitalism involved only voluntary, uncoerced trade was adopted by it's defenders as a rationalization of the system, but that was not true of either the specific real world systems for which the name “capitalism” was coined to refer or subsequent real world examples, and certainly has nothing to do with the definition of capitalism. If you want to distinguish the proposed scenario from capitalism, it would be in that it does not involve private property rights in the means of production, but instead on their forcible seizure and defense, but that's a slippery distinction because commonly such systems evolve into a degree of legitimization and trade with recognized rights between the parties, and the roots of capitalist property also start in forcible seizure which is later legitimized.
- gambiting 6y ago>>And those operations need members. Where do they come from? Friends and friends of friends. If you hang out with "dodgy" people you will eventually see those opportunities pop up.
- EthanHeilman 6y agoHowever those are exactly the sort of people that a well run criminal organization would keep at a distance. The opportunities one gets from dodgy people are dodgy opportunities. The recruiting of violent, power seeking, poor impulse control people was one of the major factors in the decline of the five families. When better opportunities existed for 2nd and 3rd generation Italian-Americans, many took those better non-criminal opportunities. An organized crime life is a pretty hard life. This dramatically hurt the number of good candidates that organized crime could recruit from. The candidates they did recruit often placed their individual desires over the needs of the organization. This destroyed the internal trust which was a major enabler of their success.
- seibelj 6y agoYou may be interested in the book “Wiseguy”, a very interesting, informative, and often hilarious book about Henry Hill, a member of the mafia in New York. https://www.amazon.com/Wiseguy-Nicholas-Pileggi/dp/1439184216 https://www.amazon.com/Wiseguy-Nicholas-Pileggi/dp/143918421... It explains in great detail how he got into the mob and how the mob works. I would assume many organized crime groups follow similar paths. Essentially young kids with problems with authority meet hoodlums who can vouch for them, they get into the lifestyle, and start learning how to hustle. No one rats because doing so means death. This book is also what the superb movie Goodfellas is based on, which is a fairly close portrayal of the book.
- JoeSmithson 6y ago£13m is only what the Met (London police) seized. It was over £50m in the whole UK
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- onetimemanytime 6y ago>>If you wanted to get into the criminal drug trade, how would you start? Is there a guide somewhere I can follow? You would start from the bottom. Going around saying you want to part of the business, is a sure way to end up dead as a snitch. Yeah there's a LOT of money: cocaine costs as little as $2k a kilo in Columbia and can be sold in EU for close to $100K when accounting for cutting. I guess a lot of it is segmented. For example: one group brings 800kg from Ecuador and sells it to local gangs and so on. If they get caught, other groups fill the void.
- buckie 6y ago> These aren't street dealers. It's an organized, carefully designed, well-oiled machine. How does this machine work? How does it survive the loss of so many members? Narconomics[1] has a pretty good discussion of the economics (including recruiting) of cartels. [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Narconomics-How-Run-Drug-Cartel/dp/1610397703 https://www.amazon.com/Narconomics-How-Run-Drug-Cartel/dp/16...
- iamben 6y agoSecond this recommendation. Fascinating read.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe real barrier to entry here is the stress. Always feeling those butterflies when the phone rings - getting nervous when you see a police car - freaking out a little when the doorbell rings. It's no way to live - and don't even think about having a family/kids after you get involved. You'll die early of the stress. If you think you're a master 1337 hacker or online drug dealer - just get a job in IT security. It pays better, comes with zero stress.
- ASalazarMX 6y ago> get a job in IT security. It pays better, comes with zero stress. I beg to differ. All IT jobs have stress, but security by definition stresses you about things that haven't happened yet. If you have zero stress doing IT security, you're doing it wrong. Still immensely better than crime, though.
- driverdan 6y ago> It pays better, comes with zero stress. Spoken like someone who has never done either. 15+ years ago when I was hacking and doing credit card fraud, I could make $1000 cash a day without a lot of effort or time. Because I was careful about protecting myself and didn't work a lot I didn't have much stress. I have far more stress with a full time job. That said, the drug game would be a lot more stressful.
- rbrtl 6y agoPah, these guys are petty thieves compared to Wirecard...
- quattrofan 6y agoSo right. Add Enron, or 2008 bank crash.
- chii 6y agothe difference between blue collar crime and white collar crime is one uses guns, while the other uses pens.
- rbrtl 6y agoThe pen is mightier than the sword. It's great news that these crims have had their just desserts. It's even better the quantity of drugs taken out of circulation, and hopefully the decimation of the network. I'm well grasped of the difference between the two, and for the most part I think white collar crime is worse. It's pure greed and the same kind of exceptionalism that's been growing and growing for the last 50-60 years. Blue collar crime is as old as civilisation, white collar crime is as old as deregulation.
- chii 6y ago> white collar crime is as old as deregulation. white collar crime is as old as civilization - how do you think kings and nobles got their positions back then?
- rbrtl 6y agoI don't think we can compare feudalism with financial crime. One was the system of governance for millennia, the other was enabled by the naivety of a failed ruling class who handed the power of states to the fraudsters of global finance. Everyone understood (at a local level) how feudalism worked, I doubt many people could tell you what Wirecard were doing.
- daniel-levin 6y ago>> I'm a programmer. I learned it from the internet. Same is true of Paul Le Roux [1]. I think if you're criminally inclined you'll find a way. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Le_Roux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Le_Roux
- PoachedSausage 6y ago>Le Roux was sentenced to 25 years in prison in June 2020 after agreeing to cooperate with authorities in exchange for a lesser sentence and immunity to his most serious crimes. Surely he will have to serve his sentence in solitary because I would imagine cooperating with the authorities makes you rather unpopular in prison.
- driverdan 6y agoThat depends on the prison. If it's minimum security it's unlikely anyone would do anything. Medium or higher? Maybe.
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoIt wouldn't stop there - imagine _leaving_ prison when those who weren't caught know your name and the fact that you cooperated with law enforcement.
- Quequau 6y agoGet arrested and go to jail... that's where there's a large concentration of criminals from which you can learn.
- surething123 6y agoYou could likely learn what not to do, from them :)
- stevekemp 6y agoSuch is the plot of "A stainless steel rat is born", by Harry Harrison.
- ColinWright 6y agoAlthough selection bias tells you that they are the ones who got caught, so maybe they are not the best ones to learn from. That is also a plot-point in ASSRIB.
- dreen 6y agoSome people are exceedingly good at working out ways around the law to make a lot money. Here is how I think their story works in many cases (I have no formal expertise): I expect these days in developed countries most of them start with credit card fraud in their teens and usually go to prison. At that point they either reform (I know of two such individuals by name, one is a friend sysadmin/CTO now and the other is Stephen Fry) or they get recruited in prison into an existing criminal org. From then on they acquire knowledge on how to crime from people who have the experience.
- elliekelly 6y agoThis is an interesting aspect of the criminal system I don’t often see discussed - for a lot of kids who are dabbling in crime and get caught sending them to prison is how their criminal network grows. It doesn’t help “reform” the edge cases so much as it allows the edge cases to be easily recruited by existing criminal operations.
- donkeyd 6y ago> how would you start? At the bottom usually. Either that, or you'll need some specific smarts or connections that are sought after. That's how it survives the loss of members. Many are low level and are replaceable, they have no actual knowledge about the high level trade. The high level bosses hide really well and try to stay untouchable by letting others do the dirty work. From what I understand about Dutch organized crime, if you'd start for yourself, you'd have to fight a turf war and will always be at the top of multiple hit lists. The safest bet is probably shipping drugs by mail through dark markets. A Dutch guy (SuperTrips) got arrested in Miami a couple of years ago. He sold drugs from his bedroom in his parental home. Was estimated to have earned 385k BTC through this. If you want to see it at work, you could go to some of the Caribbean Islands. Drug trafficking runs through many of them and you can actually see the impact it has on some communities. In Haiti, I was warned to stay away from packages on the beach (though I didn't spot any). Apparently they throw them overboard near the coast, locals find them and sell them back to drug traffickers for about €50 a kg. This way the traffickers don't need to be directly involved with bringing them to shore. Hopefully this gives you some info. There's lots of books and documentaries about this stuff too, by ex-criminals, insiders and researchers.
- eternalny1 6y ago385k BTC is $3.6 billion USD. I doubt he made _that_ much out of his parent's house.
- xtracto 6y agoA friend told me the story of his friend here in Mexico, who was just finishing school (uni) and needed some money. A friend of his offered that if he stayed at some random house for a weekend (to "guard" the house just staying there to sleep) he would be paid several thousand pesos. Not bad for a weekend of doing nothing. That weekend there was a police raid to that house. The poor guy ended up being arrested along with others and got 20 years jail time because there were drugs and guns in the house. Not worth it.
- chii 6y ago>A friend of his offered that if he stayed at some random house ...arrested along with others with friends like that, who needs enemies!
- matwood 6y agoAssuming your story true (and based on ones I've seen on 'Locked Up Abroad'), I think what happens here is that higher ups are giving the police a win. Everyone in some of these areas is on the take, but the police still need to show arrests once in awhile. So throw some guns and drugs in a house (cost of doing business), put some randoms in there, and call the raid.
- trengorilla 6y agoWell yeh, that particular idea is not worth it. It's ridiculous. On the other hand in the UK I know people who make huge amounts of tax free money and when they get caught (usually after 5-10 years) they go to prison for a year or two. Not so bad.
- isolli 6y agoYou could benefit from reading this sociologist's account: "Gang Leader for a Day": << Sudhir Venkatesh never imagined that as a result of this assignment he would befriend a gang leader named JT and spend the better part of a decade embedded inside the projects under JT’s protection. From a privileged position of unprecedented access, Venkatesh observed JT and the rest of his gang as they operated their crack-selling business, made peace with their neighbors, evaded the law, and rose up or fell within the ranks of the gang’s complex hierarchical structure. >>
- orthoxerox 6y agoBut that was in the 90's. All the tech must've changed the trade by 2020.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wyck 6y agoYour either born a hustler or born into it. In the last few decades the hustlers do need IT help, especially online gambling, money laundering, etc. But it does come with risks, you don't want to be the IT guy who recommended this cracked app.
- wizardforhire 6y ago> I wish it were possible to go observe the system in action as a spectator. Barring a time machine or wonder viewer that would make this possible I highly recommend this documentary from 2006 [1] “Cocaine Cowboys” its a tell all of the inner workings of the largest drug importers and follows the rise and subsequently fall of the cocaine trade in Florida which ultimately culminates in the major construction and modernization of Miami Florida. [1] https://imdb.com/title/tt0380268/ https://imdb.com/title/tt0380268/
- FuckButtons 6y agoI can’t speak to the British case, but the book Gomorrah goes some way to answering these questions for organized crime in Naples.
- pmoriarty 6y agoI can recommend a book called Wiz Mob.[1] It's ostensibly a study of the specialized language of pickpockets, but actually goes in to great detail on how pickpocket gangs work. Before reading this book, and knowing nothing about the subject matter, I had somehow assumed pickpockets worked alone and were just bottom-of-the-barrel amateur opportunists. I couldn't have been more wrong, as it turned out they work in highly organized units. Fortunately, probably through the ubiquity of video surveillance, such gangs don't seem to be as widespread as they used to be. [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Whiz-Mob-Correlation-Technical-Pickpockets/dp/0742533514 https://www.amazon.com/Whiz-Mob-Correlation-Technical-Pickpo...
- simplicio 6y agoAt least in the States, pickpocketing has almost disappeared. Part of this is probably part of the general trend of falling crime rates, but also because people carry much less cash around and cel-phones etc. are difficult to fence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- s5300 6y agoI know in Mexico/other parts of South America they'd kidnap/abduct radio infrastructure workers for setting up/managing comms. Give them a fairly nice life too, except for the whole you're stuck in this position and we'll kill you and your family if you try to leave. So, basically, go down there with a sign stating what you can do and hope to get kidnapped...
- ASalazarMX 6y agoThis. For organized crime in a country when 9 out of 10 crimes go unpunished, the fastest way to startup infrastructure is kidnapping experts. You want to steal from oil pipes? Kidnap a few field workers. You want a solar-powered, encrypted, nation-wide radio network? Kidnap telecom workers.
- pjc50 6y ago> To be clear, my question is: how is the knowledge necessary for such operations preserved? I'm a programmer. I learned it from the internet. Where do they learn? And these aren't street dealers. It's an organized, carefully designed, well-oiled machine. How does this machine work? How does it survive the loss of so many members? This is what anthropologists call an "oral culture". You have to be told it verbally, because those involved are strongly deterred from writing it down. For the deeper secrets you probably have to be part of the right family. In the rougher neighborhoods you'll find plenty of people who know how the system works, if only so they know what and who to avoid getting caught up in it. (The interesting thing about the internet is how we've developed an "oral" culture that actually does get written down, because we do so much socializing through text! IRC channels and the like.)
- no-dr-onboard 6y agoHave you heard of the podcast Darknet Diaries? Jack Rhysider (the host) does a pretty remarkable job of documenting the answers to your questions by interviewing guests (in story format) who often come from the more murky areas of the internet. In particular I recommend the episode freakyclown or OxyMonster as that seems to fit what you're looking for.
- bavcyc 6y agoZeroZeroZero by Roberto Saviano may have information you'd want. Also looks like ZeroZeroZero is an Amazon Original series now as well.
- drcongo 6y ago> I'm a programmer. I learned it from the internet. Where do they learn? Crack Overflow?
- papertokyo 6y agoAlso HitHub. Heaps of free coke repositories.
- hitpointdrew 6y ago>(I balance this with a deep hatred for cartels. If you trace these questions far enough, it seems to often lead to "the cartels are at the center of it all." And they're responsible for unspeakable miseries.) This is why all drugs should be legalized (not just decriminalized, decriminalization still leaves a black market). Cartels are meeting a demand, but cartels make up their own rules and will do anything they want to stay ahead. Just legalize them, it solves so many problems. 1. Quality and proper labeling (no more mystery drugs/dosages). Buyers know exactly what they are getting, which would decrees the amount of OD's. 2. Vast reduction in violent crimes (legitimate, licensed distributors are very unlikely to have violent turf wars as this would jeopardize their license). Black market would suddenly have no market (provided the taxes on legal drugs aren't stupid), which means no money, which means there is nothing to kill/fight over. 3. Increased tax revenue It is a win/win/win for everyone, I just don't get it....and please just don't with the tear jerking "What about the children!" The kids will be fine. No legalizing doesn't send a message that "drugs are OK". No it won't make them more accessible to kids, please stop fearmongering you don't know what you are talking about.
- tomohawk 6y ago3: tax revenue Governments can and do tax illegal drugs. Just issue tax stamps. If drugs are found without them, you also get them for tax evasion. All drugs used to be legal in the US. There is a reason that they became controlled a hundred years ago or so, and it does not involve conspiracies by big pharma. Go research the history - it's fascinating. Alcohol is one of the leading causes of death in the US. A large share of car accidents, suicides, crime, heart disease, and many other things is caused by it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rafi_kamal 6y agoThat can work for drugs with low abuse potentials, like psychedelics. But why do you think drugs like heroin will benefit the society or the people who are taking them?
- e9 6y agoNetflix has a comedy about a programmer getting into drug trade called How To Sell Drugs Online (Fast)
- deftnerd 6y agoI was once approached to develop a darknet market. I spent a few weeks scoping out the work, unpaid, before I turned down the opportunity due to the legal and ethical problems. I did spend that time pondering and scoping out the work because I found it a fascinating challenge to design an ecommerce platform with very heavy requirements for user privacy and anonymity. The source code for an existing platform that I was granted access to view showed me that a lot of encryption techniques were just smoke and mirrors. Mostly, everything was stored unencrypted or using symmetric encryption with the encryption key stored on the same filesystem as the server generating the pages. It was fun designing an asymetric multi-key encryption system, where a user's "second password" with a hash (stored with a microservice API on another server in another data center) generated one of the multiple keys required. Even server seizure wouldn't result in anything usable. Another challenge was how to prevent servers from being overwhelmed with DDoS attacks. That would have been achieved by using the Tor API to generate custom onion addresses for each user and vendor that they could bookmark. The only site that could be DDoS'd would be the landing page. It also allowed for an easy route to horizontal scaling. The old system also didn't properly delete stuff, it just flipped a boolean "deleted" field to prevent it from being visible anymore... Not very smart for data hygiene. I've been wanting to use what I planned out to build a product for the last few years, but I can't think of anything legal & legitimate that would have such strict security requirements that also has potential for profitability.
- qvrjuec 6y ago> Another challenge was how to prevent servers from being overwhelmed with DDoS attacks. That would have been achieved by using the Tor API to generate custom onion addresses for each user and vendor that they could bookmark. The only site that could be DDoS'd would be the landing page. It also allowed for an easy route to horizontal scaling. If the market were compromised and the URLs exposed, this would make it easier for a bad actor to connect a user to the URL, right?
- vegannet 6y agoThe line between being willing to take enough risk to get involved in drugs and being risk averse not to get in trouble from being involved with drugs is a very thin line. You can get rich from drugs very easily but getting rich from drugs while minimising your risk enough to live out your days comfortably is hard. The smart way for a nerd to get rich from drugs is to formulate a short-term high risk plan that utilises the dark net to acquire and sell drugs before moving on very quickly. The problem is, if you’re making a lot of money very quickly... can you give it up? What’s one more day? What’s another week? You’ve been going 6 months — what’s 7? Drug dealing groups are not a carefully designed and well oiled machine, there’s no knowledge passed down from generation to generation: there’s a group of people who haven’t yet been caught out by their mistakes. The people mentioned in this article made a mistake by using this app, and that mistake finally caught up to them. The whole drug industry is predatory, the smartest people involved in drugs are the most predatory because minimising risk for yourself means offloading that risk onto others using violence and coercion. There’s no romantic art to drug dealing: if you’re smart and willing to hurt others, you can be a millionaire before the year is out.
- pocw 6y agoYou should read the story of the silk road. There was a fascinating piece in Wired.
- Tade0 6y agoIf my local neighbourhood drug dealers are any indicator they recruit by word of mouth. A friend knows a friend who knows a friend who has a few attractive job offers so if there's somebody to vouch for you, a meeting is arranged. They usually have some front business. "My guys" had a small logistics operation(obviously) - a single tractor trailer. Apparently the local liquor store was involved as well because it was run by the same people. How do I know all this? Some of their trades, meetings and even disagreements happened out in the open. Nobody dared to be too curious about this. Also my friend's ex boyfriend was a drug dealer so she had a few stories to share. I still vividly remember this one time when I saw one man handing out brick-shaped packages which were inside a car trunk to another man. At first I didn't know what I was looking at, but seeing how my eye contact made them uncomfortable I stopped staring and went on my way.
- anoraca 6y agoThe film "Blow" is outdated but probably a good starting point on the history of how things like that develop.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tim333 6y agoYou could try reading Mr Nice https://www.amazon.co.uk/Mr-Nice-Howard-Marks/dp/0749395699 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Mr-Nice-Howard-Marks/dp/0749395699