11 ms·
> Microsoft has been continually tweaking the way the Windows 10 updating process works based on "user feedback" I... what... where... when? Seriously, how ab
by raxxorrax 6y ago
> Microsoft has been continually tweaking the way the Windows 10 updating process works based on "user feedback"
I... what... where... when?
Seriously, how about just giving control to users? And btw, I still see machines were the telemetry service eats CPU. If you cannot get it to work, remove it. It shouldn't be part of an OS anyway. Don't tell me users like it, you could just offer an app in that case.
I don't get how neglected they have treated their flagship for desktop computers. Software as a service is good for my
tax declaration, but I really hate this trend.
- rkagerer 6y agoThe rest of that quote concerning user feedback reads "...which seems to be, in large part, complaints."
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> Seriously, how about just giving control to users? Have you been living in a cave since 1999? Computing isn't about empowering people anymore, it's about extracting money and data (read: more money!) from them!
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI'm going to try and be not cynical for a second - in 1999 computing truly empowered a small group of enthusiasts. Yes, lots of people had access to computers, but for many it was a word processor with slow internet, and a ton of vulnerabilities and viruses. Now many many more have been empowered, but at a cost of less peak power.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoI'd argue that they aren't really empowered. I don't feel empowered by my phone because everything is under someone else's control. I am only permitted to use applications as long as they don't want root access to the device. That trend is becoming more and more pervasive in other aspects of computing too.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI get that - we've lost control of the device, but we now have ubiquitous access to computing - reliable, (relatively) safe access to the internet everywhere for nearly everyone. That wasn't a thing 20 years ago - computers were more arcane and required expertise to maintain. I totally understand we've lost access to the devices, I'm just arguing that there's an other side to this whole thing.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> I get that - we've lost control of the device, but we now have ubiquitous access to computing - reliable, (relatively) safe access to the internet everywhere for nearly everyone. Debatable. What makes computing so much more interesting than other tools is the ability to program them, to make the tool what you need it to be for what you want to do. 80s computer systems got this: they booted into a programming environment. 90s computer systems got this: they gave us HyperCard, VB, Delphi, etc and productivity software like Excel (which I contend is still the most widely used programming environment on earth) became programmable and extendable too. Turning first time computer users into programmers was a goal because that's what computers were for! We don't really have computers like that anymore. What we have are appliances. Sure, they have a lot of add-on modules, but you're not encouraged to program them, to adapt them to your needs, you're encouraged to buy that from somebody else with money and/or turning over data. A lot of those "tools" seek to addict you to their usage so you can be peppered with advertisements. You're consuming, not computing.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoWe have different definitions of computing - For me computing is the ability to perform work and get information on a computer, which I think is a lot better these days. Not everyone cares to be a programmer, and to put computers behind that wall serves to stop people from accessing them. That feels kind of like gate-keeping, especially as the modern internet is so incredibly complicated that casual dabbling isn't really good enough to get things done - where in this case "getting things done" is pulling information from web pages, paying bills, emails, etc. It can be a hobby, absolutely, but one that you need to be dedicated to, and as such, not for most people.
- reaperducer 6y agofor many it was a word processor with slow internet, and a ton of vulnerabilities and viruses. As far as I can tell, for the most part not much has changed. The only difference is now people write to one another via Facebook instead of mailing letters to one another. They still complain about the speed of their connections. Vulnerabilities and viruses haven't gone away. About the only things that are different is that we now take pictures with our telephones every six minutes, and the internet has increased the ability to make people mad at one another.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI'm slowly becoming more and more convinced that people don't remember 20 years ago - systems are so much faster and stable now it's a whole new world. My system rarely if ever crashes - 20 years go it would be a daily thing. People are going to complain no matter what. What matters is that things are actually better - people being upset about that doesn't actually indicate whether things are better.
- anoncake 6y agoEverything capitalist is.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> Software as a service is good for my tax declaration Could you elaborate on that? When buying a permanent license you should be able to deduct the full sum as a cost of doing business, it shouldn't matter if it's Saas or not.
- selectodude 6y agoYou have to depreciate permanent licenses as if they're any other durable good. With SAAS you can just write the whole thing off as a service. They get you to the same place, but SAAS does it with significantly less fuss.
- neltnerb 6y agoWait, isn't it inexpensive enough that you can deduct it all in the first year? It's been that way for a while I thought.
- gruez 6y ago>With SAAS you can just write the whole thing off as a service. They get you to the same place, but SAAS does it with significantly less fuss. Isn't this made up for by SaaS being cheaper (at least initially) than permanent licenses? eg. office 365 personal (SaaS) is $70/year, but office 2019 (perpetual) is $250 one time. I'm not sure what the "fuss" is.
- sp332 6y agoWindows machines get forcibly updated because users kept letting their boxes be part of botnets which hurt other users.
- ballenf 6y agoOne day we'll reminisce about the time when it wasn't illegal to let your machine be on the internet without a mask.
- ta17711771 6y agoAnd we were allowed to steer the car.
- sp332 6y agoWhile criminal botherders are in a sense "more" responsible for the damage, Microsoft also has some liability in their negligence when then wrote vulnerable software. But it's relatively easy to hold MS accountable for their part than to extract damages from botherders. So MS either covers their butts by locking down the software or pays out the nose for damages.
- google234123 6y agoIf we have to give that up to save 1.35 million people's lives a year in car crashes then it's worth it.
- rbecker 6y agoAccepting such a giant restriction ('not allowed' implies no override) would mean you are at the mercy of whoever controls the self-driving cars. They can kidnap you any time you enter a car, or prevent you from using your car to escape, or just subtly make your life very difficult. Historically, people that allowed themselves to completely fall into someone else's hands have not fared well. The words 'slavery' and 'genocide' tend to come up when describing their fate.
- 6y ago
- derefr 6y ago> Seriously, how about just giving control to users? "Users" as you likely remember them—"power users by necessity", people who willingly learned the arcana of computing just to use the thing—don't exist any more. They died out in the 90s, when computers stopped booting to BASIC and dialing into BBSes. You know how it feels to use a centrally-managed corporate workstation? That's how people now expect all computers to work. They're using it; but "someone else" is the sysadmin. They don't have admin privileges; "the IT department" does, or "their phone carrier" does, or "Google" does (in the case of something like a Chromebook.) Corporations can still be the sysadmin for their own enterprise rollouts of Windows (and if you're a real "power user", I'd suggest going the route of pretending you're a corporate IT department managing a one-machine deployment—Windows is a lot more "submissive" in that state); but now Microsoft themselves are the sysadmin-of-last-resort. But don't think for a moment that before this, most users were their own sysadmin-of-last-resort. Again, that died out in the 90s, when computers stopped being "business machines" that hobbyists could do some pro-am work with (in the same sense that one might build a machine-shop in their garage); and began instead being marketed to anyone and everyone. Before Microsoft assumed the role, the sysadmin-of-last-resort for most post-Eternal-September users was either "my nephew who knows computers"; or it was "nobody"—until things got really bad, at which point they'd bring the computer into a repair shop and a random repair-tech would be the sysadmin. (It's like having no family doctor, only a free clinic you visit in emergencies!) As one of those former "nephews who knows computers", let me tell you that I'd much rather Microsoft have the job than I. > Don't tell me users like it, you could just offer an app in that case. People like the idea of donating organs, but that doesn't mean they'll ever seek out a consent form to opt into the organ-donor program. But in countries where it's opt-out, they don't bother to seek out the de-consent form, either. It's just such a far-away concern to most people, that there's too much inertia for people to change the default no matter what it is. (And if someone comes up to them and asks, they'll default to whichever option is less trouble—i.e. continuing be either opted-in or opted-out, depending—even if it's not the option that they'd prefer. They just don't want this time stolen from their day, for something they care so little about; and since changing things can often have unexpected not-mentioned-up-front labor-costs, they put negative expected-value on switching, even if they put positive value on the switched end-state.)
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- naikrovek 6y ago> how about just giving control to users? Because most users don't know WTF they're doing, especially the ones that think they do because they ran their own domain 20 years ago.