15 ms·
Fighting poverty accidentally stopped deforestation
- coderintherye 6y agoAlso an example of UBI in action.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoUBI requires a country to be pretty wealthy though, have a steady, reliable source of income such as natural resources or healthy trade.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.vn/4gTqu https://archive.vn/4gTqu
- jes5199 6y agothere’s a nonprofit called “Carbon Offsets to Alleviate Poverty” where you can buy carbon offset credits that are implemented by paying impoverished people in various parts of the world to reforest their land. I’d love to see a comparison of whether that was ultimately more or less effective than UBI at the two goals of reducing poverty and averting climate change
- renewiltord 6y agoI currently use TerraPass. Are these guys audited by third parties or something like that? Generally work in the US is more trustworthy since it's theoretically verifiable here.
- itsmeamario 6y agoCare to share why? I'd like to help, but the trouble is how am I sure that the money goes to the pockets of people who need it and not to some CEO's holiday?
- tribby 6y agotax-exempt 501(c)3 nonprofits in the US are required to file IRS form 990[1] which sheds some light on the financials of the organization. it doesn't mean that the organization is run efficiently or puts money to good use, but it does increase transparency[2] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Form_990 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Form_990 2. https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/ https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/
- renewiltord 6y agoYeah, to be clear, I'm not demanding it of you. If you just happen to know of something then I'm hoping you'll share. And yes, but slightly more. I want to know that the carbon credits are real, i.e. that I'm actually offsetting.
- yboris 6y agoA well-researched good write-up comes from Founders Pledge [0] recommending an "intergovernmental organisation of more than 50 rainforest nations which works to promote environmental sustainability while creating opportunities for economic advancement within tropically forested developing countries." [0] https://founderspledge.com/stories/climate-change-executive-summary https://founderspledge.com/stories/climate-change-executive-...
- ima_banana 6y agoThis may be a dumb question, but is there a field of study of unintended consequences?
- beamatronic 6y agoIn many cases, that's economics.
- staticautomatic 6y agoClosest I can think of is failure mode analysis.
- seltzered_ 6y agoComplexity Theory / Santa Fe Institute folks might be in this domain. Jordan Hall recommends this book for starters: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/thousand-years-nonlinear-history https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/thousand-years-nonlinear-hist...
- Frost1x 6y agoI would say emergence and emergentism come to mind which captures many of these sort of ideas: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence Oh and systems theory also comes to mind for more rigorous attempts at study: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_theory
- baddox 6y agoGame theory is concerned with what will happen in interactions between actors with certain strategies and goals, so unintended consequences tends to come up a lot. Public choice theory and social choice theory are related disciplines which concern themselves with the outcomes of various political and social mechanisms for making collective decisions based on individuals preferences and behaviors.
- adamnemecek 6y agoNo shit. It also stops crime, a lot of early and unnecessary deaths.
- projektfu 6y agoI came across a charity that gets a “double” or triple in a similar way. They build stoves for people who are currently cooking on open hearth. Those people then use less fuel, make less carbon dioxide, take less from the forest, and have vastly better respiratory health. https://guatemalastoveproject.org/ https://guatemalastoveproject.org/
- SenHeng 6y agoDon't those masonry stoves store a lot of heat in them? How does that work over the summer?
- jacoblambda 6y agoNot OP but have at least a bit of cursory experience. Masonry stoves get warm but when properly built they aren't insanely hot outside of the inside, the stove tops, and the chimney. Most of the excess heat after finishing cooking will dissipate through the chimney. Also insulation in most of the houses these are being built for isn't great. Because of this, the stove won't keep the house from cooling off at night. During the day people are out and about so it isn't too much of problem then either. Also it's probably cooler overall since less heat is lost to the environment compared to what they replaced. It's by no means a perfect solution but comparatively to what they were using before, it is leagues better.
- saalweachter 6y agoMy vague understanding is that the draft also helps -- the fire pulls the (hot) air out through the chimney, and fresh air gets pulled into the house to replace it. The house may not be any cooler than the outside, but it at least isn't (much) hotter.
- projektfu 6y agoThis culture spends all day cooking so the alternative is an open hearth burning inside the house all day. I was told by the representative of the charity that a stove is so popular that other families come to the one who has the stove and cook with them.
- ReticentVole 6y ago“You know, I have often thought that at the end of the day, we would have saved more wildlife if we had spent all WWF's money on buying condoms.” - Sir Peter Scott, Founder, WWF (1909-1989)
- redis_mlc 6y agoThat's a great quote. In a lot of countries, you have to be married to even get family planning advice, so that's a hindrance. The US has its own problems with requiring current prescriptions ($$) for anything, including the pill. (For non-US readers, a doctor's office visit without insurance is typically $100 in SF, if you can find one with a patient list opening. Plus filling the prescription.) Refillable natural gas containers would also help reduce deforestation. They're commonly used in SE Asian homes, but should be expanded to areas still cutting down trees for firewood.
- fragmede 6y agoThat's not entirely accurate. San Francisco, and the rest of California, changed the law in 2016 so that properly trained pharmacists are allowed to prescribe the birth control pill. That training is part of the standard curriculum for new pharmacists, and training is available for pharmacists who got their license before that became part of the curriculum. Anecdotally, I will also say that Planned Parenthood of California is pretty decently funded and are able to offer IUDs (Mirena) and Depoprevera (the shot) at a reasonable price, with and with-out insurance. This practice is not limited to California, either. Washington DC and nine other states - Colorado, Hawaii, Maryland, New Hampshire, New Mexico, Oregon, Tennessee, Washington, and Utah – allow pharmacists to prescribe birth control. https://www.goodrx.com/blog/heres-how-to-get-birth-control-without-a-doctors-prescription/ https://www.goodrx.com/blog/heres-how-to-get-birth-control-w...
- Roritharr 6y agoInteresting, what other medications are US Pharmacist's allowed to prescribe? (Your Link won't open outside of the US) Antibiotics is one of the few reasons I do doctors visits every few years when I have a particularly bad inflammation of something, besides this I rarely get sick enough to need a doctor.
- MiguelVieira 6y agoEnvironmental Kuznets curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznets_curve#Environmental_Kuznets_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznets_curve#Environmental_Ku...
- CryptoPunk 6y agoAnd the best way to increase per capita income is to implement pro-market policies, that provide rights to private property and the freedom to contract: https://www.ted.com/talks/paul_romer_why_the_world_needs_charter_cities https://www.ted.com/talks/paul_romer_why_the_world_needs_cha... http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21578665-nearly-1-billion-people-have-been-taken-out-extreme-poverty-20-years-world-should-aim http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21578665-nearly-1-bill... http://www.csmonitor.com/World/2016/0207/Progress-in-the-global-war-on-poverty http://www.csmonitor.com/World/2016/0207/Progress-in-the-glo...
- eru 6y agoNot a popular insight in the western world these days, alas. Compare https://www.econlib.org/socialism-the-failed-idea-that-never-dies/ https://www.econlib.org/socialism-the-failed-idea-that-never...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 6y ago> How Fighting Poverty Accidentally Stopped Deforestation This is garbage - When know by fighting poverty, which is increasing wealth, it's good for The environment, all the social rights, IQ, crime, happiness, almost all issues the rich first world people think are important. Because the people targeted become better off and can afford to worry about these issues as well. This is why good people fight poverty, and the bad people jump ahead and fight for the things that come after poverty, because that's what makes them personally feel good.
- mrpopo 6y agoThen why are rich people bigger meat consumers and bigger CO2 emitters than poor people?
- imtringued 6y agoThey burn coal instead of wood. In practice both are equally unsustainable but deforestation is an issue with higher visibility.
- mrpopo 6y agoStrange answer. Most importantly, they consume a lot more energy, be it from coal or from wood.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThey consume more because they have more money to consume with; that's not the focal point of the article though, it focused on deforestation specifically. CO2 emissions is a different challenge, albeit related to CO2 emissions and sequestration.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoOw really? So how much more does GDP of US need to improve so that it can stop its environmentally irresponsibly behaviour?
- nwah1 6y agoLook into the Environmental Kuznets Curve and the Demographic Transition.
- Mirioron 6y agoI don't quite understand the headline. This seems like a rather obvious outcome. The big question is: what are the limits on it? Helping the poor in Indonesia (and Brazil) would diminish deforestation, but would it do the same if you were helping the poor in the US? Ukraine? My guess is that it would do barely anything about deforestation in the US, but I have no idea about Ukraine.
- princeb 6y ago> This seems like a rather obvious outcome it was not an obvious outcome. if it were obvious, you'd have the answer to your question.
- gbear605 6y agoI think it was an obvious outcome that “some people who have more money don’t have to sell wood anymore,” since there’s much less deforestation in developed countries than in developing ones. The specific outcome of how much and where is very much not obvious.
- PeterisP 6y agoWhat deforestation in the US? The forest area in the US has been stable since ~1900, and the volume of forest has been increasing in the last decades. I don't have good recent data about Ukraine, but it also seems to have increased the amount of forests e.g. in the period between 1990-2010. https://rainforests.mongabay.com/deforestation/2000/Ukraine.htm https://rainforests.mongabay.com/deforestation/2000/Ukraine.... ; this would match the general trend of the rest of Europe of an increase in forests.
- 082349872349872 6y agoFortunately (or unfortunately, depending upon where one lives), fighting poverty is like fighting pandemics: some places try it, and others declare it difficult* and leave it untried. * "difficult" being the charitable interpretation of the people who will argue, at length and in print, that having poverty or having an endemic or having brutality is somehow better than the alternatives. (in my country, it's considered shocking news that, unemployment having reached almost 4%, thousands of people showed up for food handouts during the pandemic. It's considered ongoing news that we still have double digits, about 1% of peak, of new virus cases per day. Both public mass shootings from this century are considered national tragedies)
- reinkaos 6y ago> For local communities, selling timber and clearing land for cultivation is an income stream of last resort. There's also another problem that affects places like Brazil: deforestation for cattle ranching.
- dba7dba 6y agoSouth Korea is another example of fighting poverty that stopped and completely reversed deforestation. Korean peninsula in general went through extreme deforestation under Japan, especially during the WW2 era and Korean War, as supply of coal was cut off from the civilian population and redirected to war effort by Japan and Korea. In order to get fuel supply that was needed to cook food and heat homes, local hills were cleared of trees by locals. If you watch video footage of the Korean War 1950 - 53, the hills are completely devoid of trees. The trees are missing because they had all be cut down for fuel. If you talk to any older Korean men who were teens up until mid 1960s, they all remember walking 1 - 2 hrs one way up into the hills to collect firewood, piled mountain high on their A-frames (in Korean, jigae). Once South Korea started getting better off, they went to coal, oil, natural gas, and then electricity for fuel source. The South Korean government "Korea Forest Service" ministry is completely focused on restoring the depleted forests. And they seem to have done reasonably well.
- CommieDetector 6y agoOnly economic morons would be surprised.
- cookiengineer 6y agoLittle known fact: Germany was exporting wood around the beginning of the 15th century up until the point where over 80% of all forests were gone. You could say that almost all forests we have today are somewhat artificially grown. That is why, by law, forests have to be maintained and regrown if you want to harvest wood. The earliest established Forstordnung was done in 1442 in Speyer and soon after the Kurpfalz and other states/Fürstentümer adapted it. I think the latest state to adapt it was Sachsen around 1560, but I would have to look that up to be certain. Nonetheless I think this speaks volumes on how much some countries are behind when it comes to their established laws.
- blablabla123 6y agoMost trees growing in Germany grow very fast. In areas with rainforests trees are much older and the ground on which they grow is very different from the ground in german forests. Once deforested it takes decades to just recover the ground, not to speak of the trees.
- serverQuestion 6y agoGermany obviously old trees until they remove 80% of them...
- raxxorrax 6y agoIf you look at a satellite image, you quickly see that there just isn't that much space left to nature. That is true for most of central Europe. Doesn't mean it isn't green, but pristine forests don't exist anymore. There are some spaces left to itself now, but they were still touched by human cultivation.
- Nasrudith 6y agoPristine is a very high bar. There is archaeological evidence of semi-settled early agrarian existence where they would slash and burn an area to farm it and then once the soil depleted move on to a new segment of the surrounding forest and abandon their old settlement to be overgrown and renewed. Wasteful but the cycle was fully sustainable. Even without human involvement we would see some "normal curves" to tree diameters via attrition of the oldest for varied reasons - but their ring count would be higher.
- distant_hat 6y agoIndia's birth rate in villages plummeted when TV was introduced to them. These kind of effects are not that rare.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThere's a strong correlation between wealth, education, quality of life, and child birth rate. Tl;dr, improve people's lives and birth rate drops. Which may cause its own problems (e.g. in Japan), but there's a lot of countries that aren't there yet.
- gampleman 6y agoI take a bit of issue with the "accidentally". Having been in the deforestation-stopping business for some time it has been blindingly obvious that most approaches that were being taken were completely futile until socio-economic factors were solved for. For example we were building satellite technology to help environmental police patrol large rainforests to be able to focus on areas with offenders. One time we managed to find a hidden airstrip for drug trafficking which was cool. But most of the time the offenders were people who just needed to feed their kids - and look there is a mahogany tree just over there that will sell for $$$. So the cops will come, give them a fine, and then they will need the money even more. So the pattern continues. Funnily enough (NB: this is hearsay) the forests were actually better off when the area was controlled by drug gangs as the people had a source of income from the cocaine.
- seotut2 6y agoThe same phenomenon is easily observed in modern-day Romania. There's a clear inverse correlation between the wealth of a region and the deforestation in that area. Also notice that the price of wood is fairly stable all across EU because it's an open market after all. But the wages in Romania are far lower than the EU average so that's why the incentive to cut and sell wood is relatively higher here.
- simion314 6y agoIn Romania there is the issue where people still have to use wood for heating because of no access to natual gas or not enough money to buy a modern heating system, isolate the home and pay for the has, in some regions the wood is cheap in others wood is expensive.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xyzzyz 6y agoBuying coal should be an option, no? Coal is cheaper than wood.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoThis is a great example of economic harmony in nature. There has been a big debate in environmentalism whether rising incomes naturally produces more concern for and protection of the environment. The implications of that question are, very, very important.
- the8472 6y ago> Cash payments to people in impoverished areas led to a 30% drop in tree loss It did not stop deforestation. It only lowered the rate of loss. Which of course is a significant improvement but still not sustainable.
- alkonaut 6y ago"Accidentally"? Bring up google maps and look at the forest cover of Haiti vs. the Dominican Republic. You don't really need the border drawn as a line.