27 ms·
Zoom says it won’t encrypt free calls so it can work more with law enforcement
- phab 6y agoI have cancelled my (paid) Zoom subscription. I will not finance companies that feel that protection from oppression is only for those that can pay.
- ghostpepper 6y agoSame, but strangely when it asks your reason for cancelling, there was no radio button for "I find your system of morals incompatible with my own". Unrelated to this, I read yesterday that Jitsi Meet now supports E2E encryption so I look forward to trying that out.
- chooseaname 6y agoSo, they'll let the Epsteins of the world pay and get E2EE, but those "Thug" protestors who want to organize and maybe can't justify the cost need to be surveilled. Set against the events of the past week, I strongly feel this message is quite tone deaf and we're continuing to see two classes. Those exempt from police authority and those who cannot afford to be. Edit: Authority isn't the right word. Oppression?
- orestarod 6y agoOf course, if you can't justify the cost to a company, you will be stripped of its services. Is that not expected of private corporations?
- chooseaname 6y agoSure, we can ignore that the Zoom CEO mentioned anything at all about law enforcement and focus solely on the financial aspect. If we do that, then why have a free segment at all? Go ahead and make it completely for pay.
- orestarod 6y agoIt's all up to financial incentives. I am not saying it is right. The whole system is not right.
- wonderwonder 6y agoIts not stripping them of service though is it? Its providing them with the zoom service, but its specifically removing encryption to expose the conversations of non paying people to the police. This is not about them saving money its about them intentionally choosing to hand up non paying customer chats to law enforcement. Also from a customer satisfaction / PR perspective I am hard pressed to think of a worse time for a company to announce this.
- orestarod 6y agoI am not applauding this. I just point out how corporations work now.
- unethical_ban 6y ago1) Encryption costs are marginal. 2) He didn't say it was a costly operation so they're charging for it. They said it was for LEO purposes.
- thelookingglass 6y agoDefinitely a strange thing opening access to only free subscribers. There's probably an argument to made on both sides, but putting this as an 'added value' for paying? Tone deaf for sure.
- andyv 6y agoOh, you won't have to be rich to purchase E2EE. I'm sure that Zoom will make it surprisingly affordable.
- pilsetnieks 6y agoIf they are willing and capable to enable/disable it over the matter of a few dollars (any amount of dollars, really,) can one actually trust that it is enabled?
- seesawtron 6y agoWell all the more reason to quit Zoom.
- lancewiggs 6y agoOr pay for it. There is always a cost for free.
- tossAfterUsing 6y agoalternatively, the FBI is sponsoring "free" for whoever wants it.
- jliptzin 6y agoGiven their eagerness to work with the FBI why would anyone not assume they’d give the FBI encryption keys for paid sessions of interest to them?
- asiachick 6y ago> There is always a cost for free. There is? I'm not sure what my cost for clang, python, llvm, firefox, is for being free. Even wikipedia, mdn, openstreetmaps, ...
- pmlnr 6y agoI donate to wikipedia. They need to pay for electricity, servers, etc as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CommieDetector 6y ago>wikipedia The cost is haveing an EXTREM leftist slant on all articles.
- walkingolof 6y agoSomeone else is paying for that, because very little happens for free.
- NonEUCitizen 6y agoIt's okay to use Zoom for a bad purpose as long as you pay?
- koolba 6y agoThere is some logic to that. Paying requires you provide something traceable to a physical identity. I still think it’s a dumb move. Imagine if “HTTPS for pay users only” was a thing.
- quickthrower2 6y agoOr https for everyone, root cert validation for paid users only
- bradlys 6y agoYou want to hash out a bad business plan - do it on our paid version of a product. Gotta spend money to burn money.
- joering2 6y agoAlso wouldn't they logic imply you have something to hide? - Special Agent Smith here, FBI - here judge sign this order? - What is it? - Its someone who we suspect of doing bad stuff, AND they are using paid version of Zoom. - Oh that's the encrypted one, right? - Yes, your Honor, the free one is non encrypted, you have to pay to hide your convo. - Here is the paper, good luck.
- quickthrower2 6y agoThere are plenty of legit reasons to want end to end encryption. What if you are discussing a patent that isn’t submitted yet? And if there is a backdoor for police there is a backdoor for more than the police.
- lilyball 6y agoIt sounds like nearly all of the people using Zoom to facilitate abuse are doing so on the free tier (with untraceable throwaway identities).
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoI think civil unrest will set back privacy efforts. Basically, when people are scared, they want the government to protect them and theirs, and privacy concerns are pushed to the back burner.
- bigiain 6y ago> Basically, when people are scared, they want the government to protect them That works only until the people you're scared of are those the government sends "to serve and protect"...
- deathgrips 6y ago>when people are scared, they want the government to protect them and theirs Should someone tell him?
- GhostVII 6y agoCan they encrypt the calls at all if they allow people to call in? They would be the ones receiving the phone call, so they would need to be able to decrypt the zoom call in order to send it over the phone. I guess they could encrypt calls only if you disable dialing in or something.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoSeems like E2E will be unavailable for meetings where there is a dial in participant. There's several other features which would need to be disabled as well to opt into E2E. https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408
- awirth 6y agoWell, respect for coming out and saying it directly.
- ankmathur96 6y agoThe reality is that this is being made out to be way more insidious than it is. Platforms should work with authorities so that bad actors like known terrorists can’t use a free platform to organize. To the crowd who says “well you can do bad stuff if you pay” - If terrorists are paying for Zoom, they’re leaving a paper trail for the FBI. Free platforms are ripe for abuse because they’re free.
- sahoo 6y agoEver heard of stolen credit cards
- john_alan 6y agoCan you please move into a glass house. I just need to make sure you’re not doing anything bad, and the FBI can’t see through your walls. Also I’ll need a copy of your bank account statement. I just need to take a look. Make sure it’s ok. Unless someone else has recently. The narrative that we should sack our privacy to help “law enforcement” is fucking braindead.
- robertlagrant 6y agoIf you have a warrant, the police can both break into your house and see your records, no glass required.
- ajkdhcb2 6y agoPeople doing high-profile illegal activities will always be able to use simple open-source software, that cannot be stopped. Terrorism is not a valid reason - well, perhaps unless you're going to take the jump to including a Chinese national that says 'Tiananmen Square' to their wife in a random call, as some 'Law Enforcement' will.
- michaelmrose 6y agoWhat if the terrorists use free open source software running on their own hardware?
- iso1631 6y ago
- wallabie 6y agoMy French language classes, typically held in person after work, moved to online and over Zoom. Initially, we tried Google Meet and found it laggy and that we would often drop out. Then we moved to Zoom and it has been a much better experience. The interface is more intuitive, has a few more features and somehow the quality has improved and the connection is much smoother. I care deeply about my privacy, but I'm lucky that we don't discuss anything sensitive in our classes such that the security issues and the lack of encryption would become a big deal. EDIT: We tried Meet, not Hangouts.
- vijaybritto 6y agoWhat about Google Meet? Did you try it? I heard that its performing okay.
- InvaderFizz 6y agoWe're a Gsuite shop, so we've been using Meet since before WFH. It's fine, not great, but the connection seems stable and we have not experienced issues with conferences. Zoom is all that plus much more intuitive and easier to use. The entire Zoom experience is great from start to finish, built in background replacement is a really big draw along with the full tile layout (Meet got tiles two weeks ago). I would also say that Discord video has been great too. It's only downside is that you can only be in a session on one device. That is an extremely annoying limitation as I prefer to be mobile on my phone headset and present or stream on the computer.
- bigiain 6y ago> It's fine, not great Exactly what we've found with our GSuite and Google Meet. Works fine with 8-12 people on a call. Useable by technically adept people, but we've had to talk clients through the interface sometimes. (From today- client: "How do I share my screen" me: "click the [share screen] text in the bottom right" client: "Oh, yeah. Of course.") (If you want background replacement enough, OBS and VirtualCam lets you do it... I did it for a gag the other week to put myself inside a Russian nuclear powerplant control room for standup. It's not something I'd recommend telling anybody who's then gonna ask you to help them set it up though...)
- sunaurus 6y agoI guess the hopes of the Keybase acquisition leading to better privacy in Zoom are dead.
- malka 6y agoIt just lead to keybase's death.
- corobo 6y agoKeybase died when they added bitcoins or whatever it was. Zoom kicked the corpse.
- bjoli 6y agoWhy so dramatic? I understand the will to use zoom for free, but why should they care much for someone not paying? Video conferencing is still mostly not p2p, which means they are giving away a lot of bandwidth for free to a lot of people. If you have extra requirements, why not pay? The acquisitions and hires they have made has made sense if what they are aiming for is making a more secure and private service. I don't doubt their intention. What I don't understand is why people expect them to provide all benefits for free. Edit: does any service to multi-party e2e conferencing? What trade-offs are there?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vjeux 6y agoThis series of tweets from Alex Stamos has more specific information and tradeoffs being considered: https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408?s=21 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408?s=...
- culturestate 6y agoThis was really interesting, thanks for linking it. When he puts it in the context of their typical abuse pattern - anonymous emails, VPNs, and just a few meetings - this decision makes much more sense. I hope they expand on their thought process in a blog post at some point, I'd love to read more.
- skbly7 6y agoI like the explanation and seems fair trade off to me for complying with laws. Meanwhile, I think Zoom sucks big time with their PR team unlike Google, Microsoft, due to which they are being pushed again and again on privacy issues.
- lilyball 6y agoThat was a good thread, thanks. The relevant bits I got from it were that there are a bunch of bad actors who create new Zoom identities and host meetings a few times before moving on, and Zoom needs a means by which they “can, if they have a strong belief that the meeting is abusive, enter the meeting visibly and report it if necessary.” Their E2EE design will make it impossible for Zoom employees to enter E2EE meetings without permission, so giving E2EE to the free tier will enable people to use Zoom meetings to facilitate abuse.
- lilyball 6y agoLooking back on this comment now I realize it can be construed as condoning Zoom’s decision here. I was not intending to pass judgement with that comment, but perhaps I should: I think Zoom is wrong. End-to-end encryption should be available to everybody no matter who they are. This means making it available to bad actors too. Expanding the scope of human communication should not be used to justify state surveillance. Privacy is a fundamental human right and one we should not be forced into giving up because it annoys the government.
- stcredzero 6y agoThe more and more I see of Zoom, the less and less I think the organization is in tune with Liberal ideals and culture. At least this is less devious than coping an absolute security stance, then turning around and giving the government the keys anyways.
- monadic2 6y agoTo clarify, are you referring to the american jargon for the left wing or contemporary liberalism? Edit: downvoted on clarification is certainly a new experience.
- stcredzero 6y agoI mean the historical concept. In a way, I think Zoom's organization is somewhat more in touch with the left wing and youth culture. I have a real distaste for how Zoom (the software) does things for you, as if it knows better.
- monadic2 6y agoI can’t speak for others, but zoom is super oriented for corporate meetings and they certainly aren’t “in touch” with my culture (esp compared to facetime or facebook video chat), its current popularity is just an artifact of being the most popular corporate group video software at the time the pandemic hit the US.
- runawaybottle 6y agoSecure by default is no longer a staple of communication apps? I thought we established that standard. Oh well, ride your wave Zoom, don’t get mad when the inevitable funded competitors start showing up with security as a default.
- bigiain 6y agoI spend less running a Jitsi Meet cloud server than a single Zoom host account... 2 party e2e is still only experimental in Jitsi, but its coming.
- simonswords82 6y agoYou are missing the point. Zoom is popular because it's easy to use and "just works". Enterprise orgs don't care about cost.
- bigiain 6y agoI test drove Jitsi with a few different groups (including a not particularly technical frined group) with no more instruction than "Here's a link to a video meeting. If you're on mobile it'll prompt you to download the app. The password is 'foobah'", and it "just works" too. > Enterprise orgs don't care about cost. In my experience,thay also don't care too much about ease-of-use either. Purchasing deparments and managers are looking to someone who'll convince them that they won't personally take the blame when something goes wrong, which is why expensive proprietary services win over open source so often... "Sure everything's gone TITSUP[1], but it's Microsoft/SalesForce/Zoom fault. I've logged a ticket." is a magical career and face saving phrase... 1 "Total Inability To Supply Useful Product" - hat tip to El Reg...
- theandrewbailey 6y ago> Here's a link to a video meeting. If you're on mobile it'll prompt you to download the app. You can disable forcing mobile users into an app, too.
- 6y ago
- bigiain 6y agoSo it's official then, huh? It's worth $20/month to keep the FBI out of your shit? Do they _really_ think terrorists, counterintellegence agents, or criminal organisations can't afford $20/month???
- walkingolof 6y agoWhen you pay for something, you are very traceable, its a big difference.
- simplyinfinity 6y agostolen credit cards are a thing or proxy purchases
- neonate 6y agoWhat's a proxy purchase? Edit: never mind, Google told me. It's getting the older kids to buy you alcohol.
- simplyinfinity 6y agoor get homeless guy/junkie to buy 10 sim cards/prepaid phones for 20$
- walkingolof 6y agoRight, but there is always something to go on there, who made the purchases, where was the card stolen etc.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoAt which point you find a trail leading to some Russian hackers who stole the credit card and then sold it for cryptocurrency over the internet to the person you're looking for, who they have never met. It's square one. It's no easier to trace the anonymous buyer of a stolen credit card than the anonymous Zoom user to begin with.
- ashtonkem 6y agoAside from the PR fiasco, this is bad for their paying users. I can’t verify that Zoom actually encrypts my calls, I have to trust that they’re telling the truth. When I find out that they’re willing to turn off encryption for some calls to make spying on their users easier, the idea of holding business meetings on their platform becomes unpalatable.
- robertlagrant 6y agoThey're not turning off encryption; they're allowing law enforcement decryption. Whether or not you think that's okay, it's not the same thing.
- vertex-four 6y agoThey're also maybe allowing decryption by anyone else who wants to, and by law enforcement without a warrant - there's no cryptographic proof anywhere that Zoom will only hand the key to police on presentation of a warrant, and never use it themselves. In the meantime, anyone who actually cares about their privacy can use an e2e encrypted group chat today with e.g. Wire. All this gets us is that unwitting people who can't afford to pay are in the position to get spied on.
- lstodd 6y agoIt's the same thing. If it can be turned off, it will be accidentally turned off, accidentally not turned on, or a myriad other things in this general direction. I witnessed a cellular carrier discovering that they had all encryption disabled for several months. A honest mistake, but one that should have been impossible by design.
- ashtonkem 6y agoHanding law enforcement the keys is functionally the same, from my perspective. And what reassurance do I have that they won’t do that to me, a paying customer? All I have is a little icon that says “encrypted” and Zoom’s word.
- sukilot 6y agoHow is that different from rot13?
- nitrobeast 6y agoI will be surprised if Microsoft or Goolge encrypt their video calls that LE cannot access them either.
- londons_explore 6y agoNeither do end to end encryption of group video calls.
- steviedotboston 6y agoand both work with law enforcement as they are required to.
- bigiain 6y agoJitsi are doing some nice work on this... https://jitsi.org/blog/e2ee/ https://jitsi.org/blog/e2ee/ "If Emil was a rogue service provider running the bridge for the meeting, he would no longer be able to eavesdrop on it and an attempt to do so would only yield, well we already said that: an endless stream of rubbish. The only way for Emil to actually participate in the meeting would be if he was made privy to the e2ee key. In this case he was and once he enters it, everything goes back to normal" (Sadly, Chrome only for now - so if Google and state actors are your adversary, "you're still gonna get mossad'd upon"...)
- kitd 6y agoLol, Emil should join my scrums. It's an endless stream of rubbish, encrypted or not.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoBye bye Zoom.
- robertlagrant 6y agoThe death of Zoom means the dominance of Teams. Hope we're happy with the trade.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoCurrent encryption imementations (AES GCM) will not be downgraded. Meetings will still be encrypted and meeting content is still not going to be used for tracking users. E2E will be an opt in choice for paying users who are willing to sacrifice some features for the benefits from additional security. See this thread for more details: https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408 Edit to credit vjeux for the thread link
- bobbydroptables 6y agoDo I have any way to verify this as a user?
- virtue3 6y agoas the colloquialism goes: Talk is cheap...
- dijksterhuis 6y agoSure. Study a PhD in cryptanalysis and reverse engineering. If you want to look at something now, the white paper for the E2E protocol design is public and open right now: https://github.com/zoom/zoom-e2e-whitepaper https://github.com/zoom/zoom-e2e-whitepaper On a more serious note, until there is a protocol and implementation available then we can't say anything for sure. Us Security folks aren't magicians.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI like your tone, and it lead me to think: Any sufficiently advanced cryptography is indistinguishable from magic. Which isn’t entirely untrue from a layperson’s perspective. Edit: fixed a word. I’d accidentally written “is” rather than “isn’t”.
- randomsearch 6y agoCryptography is a religion
- skbly7 6y agoSimilar thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23400285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23400285
- dang 6y agoGood grief this one is complicated. That Bloomberg article is boring except for the sentence at the end. The submitter made the title be about the last sentence, but we changed it back to the original, which didn't satisfy anybody because the only interesting thing about the article is the last sentence. The current post seems at first glance to be a garden-variety tweet picking up on that sentence, but someone pointed out to me that it's actually by the author of the Bloomberg article, suggesting that he might be at odds with the Bloomberg editors about what aspects of the story are significant. Suddenly that's interesting. Given that Alex has been tweeting in response to this in detail (https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061790954385408), it seems like there's enough information here to support a substantive thread. Given that sneak's post was the first on this and that it links to the statement by the reporter about the only thing that anyone here cares about, it seems clear that this is the post we should leave up. So I merged the comments from the other thread hither.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoThank you for your work!
- skbly7 6y agoThanks for the merge!
- abellerose 6y agoFBI are slightly above police concerning abuse of authority. Once I reported a serious crime police in my area weren’t willing to investigate and I filed it with the fbi but never was contacted again and when I was told they would. Seeing how cops behave with the protests makes me skeptical if any law enforcement in USA is legitimate unless you’re loaded with money or social influence.
- adrianN 6y agoZoom is closed source, you could never trust their encryption to begin with.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoTheir E2E proposal design is open: https://github.com/zoom/zoom-e2e-whitepaper https://github.com/zoom/zoom-e2e-whitepaper
- adrianN 6y agoThat's nice and all, but unless you can install their software by compiling the source yourself you have no chance of verifying that the implementation is actually correct. Even with the source available that's an extremely difficult task.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoYou say no chance, I say someone is probably already starting to work on it. Don't forget we can sniff and inject packets at the network level. Just because we dont have sources doesn't mean we can't test if it works or not.
- wglb 6y agoDifficult, but not impossible, but yet still practical. It is done quite frequently.
- tptacek 6y agoAre they somehow obfuscating their binaries, or are they simply LLVM output? Is it your belief that straightforward compiler output is somehow infeasible to verify?
- occamrazor 6y agoIt’s already too hard to find security bugs in clean source code. Analyzing a binary can confirm the existence of encryption and the overall crypto scheme, but not the absence of backdoors.
- jariel 6y ago“Free users for sure we don’t want to give that because we also want to work together with FBI, with local law enforcement in case some people use Zoom for a bad purpose.” He could be a 'PR Genius' by gently coaxing people into being paying customers, but I don't think that's it, rather, this is just mind-blowing, gigantic PR lack of self-awareness verging on disaster. To just say it as he articulated it, publicly ... my gosh man. From a communications perspective this is like comedy.
- daseiner1 6y agofbi, chinese govt, top bidder... ever optional always optional
- PeterStuer 6y agoThis is complete and utter BS. EVERY communications provider has to comply with lawful intercept [1] regulation in all the regions where they operate. If they do not they find themselves hauled before the regulator and they'll be fined or worse until they do or go out of business. 'Encryption', while it would make it harder to snoop on your calls from third parties, will not 'protect' you from lawful intercept. Furthermore specific to the US Zoom also has to comply with the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act [2]. This does in no way mean Zoom can not encrypt its traffic. It just means it has to provide law enforcement the ability to covertly wiretap every and any communication. If Zoom provides end to end encryption to its paying customers, it still has to provide access to law enforcement to the content of those communications. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawful_interception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawful_interception [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Assistance_for_Law_Enforcement_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Assistance_for_...
- adtac 6y agoI'm not sure what your point is? Do you believe that all encryption is broken? If not, to the FBI, the tapped data should be indistinguishable from random bytes, from the definition of ciphertext. And that serves its purpose perfectly well. Whether or not the FBI has access to the ciphertext is immaterial.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y ago> 'Encryption', while it would make it harder to snoop on your calls from third parties, will not 'protect' you from lawful intercept. Yes it will, it will make the intercept so expensive that it will not make sense anymore for them to do it. In the first case, all they need to do to intercept is to call Zoom headquarters, or even just go to some pre-setup website and just enter the identity of the user and voíla you have the data. The cost is 1 man-hour of an agent. In the second case, the Zoom doesn't have technical ability to break the encryption, and to "lawfully intercept" they need to either break your phone or physically break into your home to install some devices, or construct elaborate servers to trick your phone into thinking it talks to real Zoom, or use the supercomputers to break some of the encryption, or use some of their hidden stashed 0-day, and thus risk exposing it by using it, and not be able to use it later for a real threat. Cost of this can be astronomical for breaking a single user. (And all of that is even more true for open-source solutions.) Also a lot of people disdain this not because they are terrorists. They disdain this type of surveillance because it has been shown many times that governments do not just track terrorists, they always end up abusing their power and track everyone, and there are agents who sometimes just make fun of people and read their emails etc. Didn't you read any of the Snowden material that was published? Encryption prevents exactly this type of ABUSE of the power by the government.
- wereHamster 6y ago> […] There will not be a backdoor to allow this. https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061796339814400 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268061796339814400 Eh, am I supposed to trust you just like that? If history taught is anything, it's that there will be.
- bkayranci 6y agopacman -R zoom
- paulcarroty 6y agoA lot of general people don't care about zoom 'dark' deals and still use it just because habit/comfort/etc. Hope many general news&blogging platform will spread the word about.
- nikolay 6y agoLatest upgrade of their macOS app bricked me and I have to use Zoom in the browser. We have a paid account and started to record our meetings and post on YouTube, although I've increased the quality setting, it's still 360p! In general, it's the most complex and confusing app, it's expensive, and the quality of the software is the worst. Unfortunately, Google Hangouts Meet isn't better and it has much higher internet connection requirements so our nonprofit was forced to use Zoom. Unfortunately, Jitsi Meet is even worse. It's kinda ridiculous that Zoom has no popular alternative in 2020.
- wj 6y agoWebEx and Skype are the popular alternatives. And if you want to talk about poor software quality I think Zoom was created because WebEx is such poor software from a user's perspective.
- mennis16 6y agoSkype absolutely wrecks my MacBook, not sure if the experience is similar on other laptops but I can't even open a PDF while on a Skype call. It would be impossible for me to give a presentation over Skype with my current setup. The software on its own seems reasonably user friendly but if the resource usage is a common issue I don't see Skype being a viable alternative right now.
- anthony_barker 6y agoI would add google meetings... I think it has the nicest interface and works better than the others cross platform. Its a pity there is no cross platform communication standard - it looks like it will evolve like messaging with dozens of companies.
- nikolay 6y agoWe have kids with Chromebooks and older laptops and on meeting with 10+ kids, Hangouts Meet becomes intolerable. Not to mention the lack of control - kids mute the teacher, can speak at any time, there's no raising hands, etc. We have to install a bunch of extensions so that we can have a basic functionality in place like the Nod Chrome extension.
- sergioisidoro 6y agoThis comes just after days after Trump tweeting that "ANTIFA" would be considered a terrorist organisation. If this kind of attitude picks up, of labelling domestic protest groups as terrorists, together with things like these, there won't be much separating the USA from an oppressive state
- igama 6y agoReply by Alex Stamos: https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268062452123496450 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/1268062452123496450
- dijksterhuis 6y agoAES GCM will still exist for free users. > ... this is in reference to end-to-end encryption, but simply ran out of space in the tweet. ... https://twitter.com/nicoagrant/status/1268020841054269440 https://twitter.com/nicoagrant/status/1268020841054269440
- sneak 6y agoNote that warrantless and illegal bulk military intelligence gathering and “law enforcement” in the US are now practically indistinguishable: several US federal law enforcement agencies, including the DEA and FBI, receive intelligence products from the military’s domestic spying apparatus, which they then use to conduct what’s known as “parallel construction”: illegal evidence that they then use in court, unrelated to the spying (because that’s illegal, as well as the evidence that they found later as a result of the illegal spying). Additionally, federal “law enforcement” (and concentration camp-operating) organizations like the CBP are engaging in domestic mass spying using aircraft to collect mobile phone identity data from millions, even for peaceful protests and the like. There isn’t really a line between “state surveillance” and “law enforcement” anymore in the US. The title of this item as I submitted it to HN prior to its edit by mods ended in “to aid in state surveillance”, which I think is a more plain, accurate, and unbiased description of the practice, as I think that pretending that this illegal military spying practice (PRISM et al) has anything to do with legitimate “law enforcement” is basically state propaganda at this point. I stand by my previous snarky, HN-rulebreaking flame of Zoom’s announcement of end to end encryption support from a month ago: > I'm sure the result of this will be lots of good and secure trustworthy software that I'll be eager to install on my computer. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23103578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23103578
- panpanna 6y agoI guess this is the SF version of "pay us or else..."
- eddieoz 6y agoThat's what you get when you are a MITM-by-design solution. In short: Zoom E2EE eventually will encrypt corporate conferences, but will not solve the privacy problems they have, because their structure stills the same. Seems it will be a feature just to make customers have the feeling they are safe (and pay more, indeed). But, as usual, they are not. Poor Keybase.
- sneak 6y agoKeybase got acquihired, which is a much better outcome for both founders and investors than that which befalls most startups that never invent a viable revenue model. Don’t shed any tears for anyone making hundreds of thousands of dollars per year while a third of the US has approximately zero income.
- jmiserez 6y agoI'm certainly sad to see a company that took security seriously and "did it right" being bought by a company that arguably did not and got large mostly by trading security for convenience, even going as far as saying they were E2EE when they were actually not [1]. How do you compete with that? Most users don't care about security/privacy and maybe that's fine but it was nice to see a company that seemed to genuinely care about these things. [1] going by the commonly used definition
- sneak 6y agoNot touching for a moment whether or not Keybase “did it right”, but, very simply: without a good revenue model, their only other option was to eventually go out of business. They were default-dead, near as I can tell from outside looking in. You can do all the open source e2e crypto trendiness you like, but unless you’re a nonprofit like Signal that can generate a stream of donations, if you don’t eventually get people to pay you for the service, you’re not going to be able to stick around. This was the best possible outcome for them, given the circumstances.
- jokoon 6y agoSkype was safe before it got acquired by microsoft. I a way, any platform that is able to evade government surveillance will be deemed as an exception, and anyone using or building such platform will be a suspect.
- simzor 6y agoAs Zoom now owns Keybase, I am really worried about the future of Keybase, especially after statements like these. This also makes none or very little sense - if this is actually just to cooperate with law enforcement, why would encrypting corporate (or paying) calls be any better, the bad people that are referred to in the statement could just get a paid plan?
- StavrosK 6y agoPaying leaves a verified trace though.
- bborud 6y agoIt sounds like bullshit. I don't think the reason to avoid keybase is necessarily because it draws their security from authorities into question, but it does call into question if a company that would say something that looks like impulsive nonsense is someone you want to trust.
- fareesh 6y agoIs keybase fully open source? Or is the server closed source?
- eddieoz 6y agoThe server stills closed but seems there're people saying the server-side is not needed(!) to trust the platform. https://www.reddit.com/r/Keybase/comments/77c241/keybase_why_are_you_hiding_your_server_source/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Keybase/comments/77c241/keybase_why...
- minicoolva 6y agoHow about Google meeting
- esotericn 6y agoA thought: Sometimes the distinction between physical and digital security is brought up in these discussions, the idea that physical security is imperfect (you can always break a lock) but that digital security may truly be impenetrable. This is a false dichotomy. If people have a conversation in a pub or on a park bench, then law enforcement can surveil them individually or bug the venues in a targeted manner. But the same methods can also be applied to digital communication. This is opsec 101 right - if one happens to be a high value target, one would totally expect their house/apartment to be surveilled - no amount of digital privacy can make up for a pinhole camera installed on the wall behind one's monitor, LE doesn't even need the keys, they see the content directly. I think the argument that digital security is 'too perfect' falls apart if you take into account the reality that physical security is a component of that. "If you control the physical hardware" and all that. TL;DR Digital security is just a subset of physical security. You can always just drill through the side of the safe.
- pacamara619 6y agoI know right, someone think of the children!
- everdrive 6y agoI think it's pretty clear that unencrypted communication with law enforcement access allows for the discovery of individuals you'd never find via traditional means. Over the years, I've seen this argument brought up a number of times, but oddly seldom explicitly stated: It seems like law enforcement wants to be able to use digital communication to discover criminals, and privacy experts want law enforcement to rely on HUMINT, a traditional warrant, and physical access. I believe the second method is far more just, but I seldom see anyone acknowledge that it's almost certainly less effective.
- 0xFluegel 6y agoIs it less effective, though? From what I remember about successes e.g. against organized crime or other groups that operated partially or totally over the internet in the news over the last years, it was mostly the simple and dull ~~physical~~ police work that leveraged mistakes of operational security, but not an evaluation of minable data (even when learned in hindsight that it existed). E.g. looking at the logs of relevant servers and waiting for someone to login without their VPN at some point.
- saint_abroad 6y agoInteresting Zoom timing co-incident with the announcement that the DEA has been authorized to surveil protestors. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23397868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23397868 Next up: Zoom meeting attendees raided for unlawful assembly. https://www.persecution.org/2020/05/24/wuhan-preacher-taken-away-online-evangelism-event/ https://www.persecution.org/2020/05/24/wuhan-preacher-taken-... Catch up: Identifying influencers from sampled social networks. https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2018PhyA..507..294T/abstract https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2018PhyA..507..294T/abstra...
- esotericn 6y agoThe optics on this are truly awful. They want to "work more with law enforcement" - at this time? Now? As the police are moving in to cities across the US military-style?
- robertlagrant 6y agoCommenting on the PR-friendliness of something is generally the least valuable of contributions.
- rpastuszak 6y agoI understand your point, but need to disagree: PR-friendliness can have real-world implications, such as a stronger negative response of Zoom users. Another important thing to consider: Zoom is probably aware of the risks involved in this decision and, despite the PR risks, decided to go ahead. Why? Most of us here can come up with a couple of reasons.
- elric 6y agoThat, and most zoom users don't care. We use zoom at work, in spite of my repeated warnings to the contrary and my efforts (and demonstrations) of Jitsi. But they like zoom. It's convenient. It's sort of cross platform, and when it isn't, you can just dial in using a phone. Plot twist? The company I work for is a software company. We're all software engineers. And yet I'm unable to make them have a negative response to zoom. I can't imagine the greater public giving an iota.
- blackrock 6y agoSometimes, this company can’t seem to help but shoot itself in the foot. The best thing, is to encrypt everything, in order to make all the traffic look noisy and randomized. Then, for the paying customers, they can use a stronger encryption, that’s tougher to crack. Ideally, this way, all the traffic being sniffed, will look randomized. But, with the paying customers, having a tougher encryption.
- m-p-3 6y agoSo a group of corporate employees could conspire over Zoom in full confidence? Gotta protect that source of revenue I suppose.
- daffy 6y agoIs there any reason to believe that, if you pay, Zoom can't listen to your conversations anyway?
- fsflover 6y agoSame reason as with Windows probably...
- hyko 6y agoBet they work with law enforcement on “encrypted” calls as well.
- sys_64738 6y agoCan't Zoom encrypt everything and silently drop encryption with a court subpoena? That sounds like the right thing to do.
- willis936 6y agoHow is that the right thing to do? It would be the worst PR disaster the company has ever seen, which is a high bar.
- sys_64738 6y agoCo-operating with police isn't a 'PR disaster' when directed by a court. Checks and balances establish the legal framework for which Zoom aids the police - a court order. It's not hard.
- willis936 6y agoSilently putting in a back door subverts the trust of users and is worse than having no encryption at all. If they aren't upfront with having backdoors in their encryption, how can we trust that they haven't been using encryption to just establish a false sense of security and sell the keys the whole time? It's a huge pile of bad faith.
- upofadown 6y agoThis all seems rather moot: 1. There is no way to verify that you are actually connected to a particular person. i.e. Zoom has no identity management. 2. The client is closed source and can't be verified. 3. Zoom can trivially impersonate any participant as they control the servers. They can MITM at will and they won't get caught at it. This discussion is like talking about the security of the bank vault door when you are planning to make the vault out of drywall.
- sitkack 6y agoNot being E2EE, it doesn't matter what Zoom logs or does or doesn't know, packet captures can definitely record this information. This is basically extortion from Zoom, pay us or information will be in the clear that you probably don't want to be.
- upofadown 6y agoThey encrypt "end point to end point" now. It's just that they have easy access to the keys. I was suggesting that what is being proposed for the paying customers might not have any real value over what they are doing now.
- ysavir 6y ago"Pay us or we share your information with law enforcement". Does this legally qualify as extortion?
- sukilot 6y agoNo. Blackmail maybe.
- sitkack 6y agoMay I recommend https://jitsi.org/ https://jitsi.org/ for meetings of 5 or fewer people. Easy to deploy on any cloud provider.
- baggachipz 6y agoDoes it bog down with more than 5? For it to be a serious alternative, it needs to support meetings with dozens of participants (even if it requires beefy hardware).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deviantfero 6y agoIt fares pretty good in my opinion, I was taking Japanese classes before this COVID situation and they implemented remote classes using a self-hosted jitsi instace, we're 15 people in the jitsi room, we have the class for 5 hours and it's pretty stable, I imagine there are more rooms working simultaneously too, since we were not the only class taking place before this.
- 1over137 6y agoJitsi works great for me with 20 participants, never tried more.
- anticensor 6y agoUnfortunately yes, I mean, the software allows for thousands of participants but the stream would be terrible. For 5-50 people, use BigBlueButton instead.
- folmar 6y agoThe scaling of bandwidth with the number of people _actually transmitting video_ is not perfect, so you results will vary with internet uplink speeds.
- AndyMcConachie 6y agoNow might be a good time to mention that if you join the Free Software Foundation as an associate member you gain an account on their Jitsi server. https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/fsf-gives-freedom-respecting-videoconferencing-to-all-associate-members https://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/fsf-gives-freedom-respec...
- jrochkind1 6y agoHow well do you find jitsi works? For multi-party video? Large number of parties like zoom?
- voodoologic 6y agoI've installed the docker image and it worked as well as any other service. Ability for multiple users and pretty reliable.
- 1over137 6y agoDunno what you consider large, but it works well for me with 20 participants.
- sudoaza 6y agoSource https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/zoom-wont-encrypt-conversations-for-free-users-so-law-enforcement-can-intercept-calls/ar-BB14XJPR https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/zoom-wont-encrypt-conve...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fallingfrog 6y agoThe cops are definitely not learning from this not to abuse black people. They are instead learning how to cut off lines of movement and communication, how to kettle and gas people, and they are learning that in a crisis, nobody will stop them from doing it.
- habanany 6y agoTranslation, if you are a pedo but you pay we protect you but if you are pedo and poor you are on your own
- crb002 6y agoThat’s the same as saying they want to aid foreign government corporate espionage.
- aloukissas 6y agoThis statement from Zoom makes me believe that even for encrypted calls they may give authorities a back door (i.e. something that Apple and others have been very vocal about not doing). Do enough people care about privacy to warrant a "Signal for video conferencing" Zoom competitor?
- rebelrexx858 6y agoJitsi is a great replacement
- a3_nm 6y agoSadly, not for all use cases, in particular not for large meetings (>50 people) with video.
- cowmix 6y agoAnd, ironically, it doesn't seem to work in ChromeOS (Chromebooks).
- boogies 6y agoIt does. The administrative tools of my local school district block the official community instance https://meet.jit.si/ https://meet.jit.si/ on school-issued Chromebooks (as well as probably millions of other sites, at one point they even blocked a subdomain of the school district's own website), but the same service hosted at the other official instance https://8x8.vc/ https://8x8.vc/ works wonderfully. Edit: detail
- dade_ 6y agoIt is safe to assume that lawful access is possible on all major commercial platforms. In theory I don't see an issue with this if it is controlled by warrants and judicial process/oversight. Unfortunately the US did away with this with the Patriot Act and the CCP and Russia don't even have such a concept as mass surveillance is the law.
- diebeforei485 6y agoI think this is the right call. Putting up a financial barrier so you have fewer trolls numerically is the right solution (also- the credit card used can help track down the identity of zoom bombers).
- neycoda 6y agoWhy's there still no open-source peer-to-peer standards-based encrypted chat and video meeting software? I mean, that works well and isn't shady.
- otterley 6y agoBecause you haven’t written it yet!
- nurettin 6y agoIt is a hard problem to solve. People earn bread making and scaling this stuff.
- crazygringo 6y agoYou simply can't do P2P video meetings in a performant way because videoconferencing a) still requires STUN and TURN servers due to NAT, firewalls, mobile, etc. and b) requires a server for bandwidth reasons once you get beyond 2-5 participants, since otherwise bandwidth is N^2 for N participants. It's that simple. Now, if someday NAT's and firewalls die so every device can receive connections from anywhere, and packet multicast across the internet becomes a thing, then this could probably change. But I don't think anybody sees either of those happening anytime in the next decade (or ever), for both technical and security reasons.
- vmception 6y agoFree calls: unencrypted, content tappable, participant list subpoana'd Subscriber calls: encrypted, subscriber list subpoena'd no real thoughts on it, there wasn't a real expectation for me that Zoom was private, only convenient.
- sammycdubs 6y agoThey really timed that well
- phsjsjsjsnns 6y agoIeeieiei
- heimatau 6y agoThe craziest thing with this is that this is even a discussion. US citizens should have a 'right to privacy'. But that's been stripped away due to post-9/11 reforms, among others.
- extra__tofu 6y agoWhether or not you have a 'right to privacy' does not mean Zoom has to provide it. You can choose a provider who allows you to exercise that right.
- gitaarik 6y agoYes, but the quote says: “Free users for sure we don’t want to give that because we also want to work together with FBI, with local law enforcement in case some people use Zoom for a bad purpose,” So they want to keep the data unencrypted so they can give it to the feds. That doesn't sound like privacy to me. edit: So I mean, something like that should not be allowed by law. Though it's rather the FBI that is breaking the law here, but Zoom explicitly says they want to work together with them. So that means they approve that injustice, making them also unjust. If they would encrypt their data to protect their user's privacy, they would not be unjust on this aspect.
- jdm2212 6y agoIt's not obvious to me why Zoom should have any less right than, say, a hotel to block people using its service for criminal activity. A hotel that suspects you're taping child porn in one of its rooms is well within its rights to call the police. If Zoom has reason to believe you're distributing child porn in a Zoom room, why shouldn't it be allowed to take action, too?
- sillysaurusx 6y agoBut you're arguing for the ability for hotels to install peephole cameras in every room to make sure you're not up to no good. The point of encryption is that no one knows what you're doing, because they can't see it. Just like no one can see what you're doing in a hotel, most of the time.
- mojoraja 6y agoWhat are some reliable open source alternatives for non-commercial use?
- paulryanrogers 6y agoJitsi Meet
- jrochkind1 6y agoYou think it's just cover for it being a hard technical problem for zoom? But... what the fuck? Also... I have a paid account. How can I tell if my connection is encrypted or not? Is it only if all other parties have paid accounts? Is there an indicator? Under an "encrypt some calls" approach, if even paid users can't tell easily and reliably if they have an encrypted connection... basically nobody can count on it.
- zys5945 6y agoI don't think zoom provides e2e encryption. iirc zoom decrypts all messages at their server before encrypting it again and forwarding it to the destination.
- Technetium 6y agoExactly this. End to end encryption does NOT mean "Encrypted on each end but not in the middle".
- jrochkind1 6y agoHuh, right.. so this makes it all even more confusing. Are they saying that WHEN they implement true e2e encryption, it will only be for paid accounts? Or are they saying the encryption they've already got, which they are inaccurately calling "e2e" when it is not, was formerly enabled for free accounts, but no longer will be? Or something else? (Who would have thunk that lying and calling something "e2e" that wasn't would end up confusing!) I also still don't understand if you get the encryption (whichever one they are disabling for free accounts) if the 'host' is a paid account but some/all of guests are not...
- bonestamp2 6y agoI don't think it's a hard problem, they're already doing it for paid calls. It's probably more work to do it for some calls but not others. From what I understand, zoom has the encryption keys anyway, and they decrypt and encrypt on their server during routing, which can have some benefits. But, that means it's more processor intensive (costly) to use encryption. So, I think they're not encrypting free calls just because it's an added expense (which really adds up at scale). Working with law enforcement might be true, but it doesn't make sense that it has anything to do with free calls. Again, they have the encryption keys so they could decrypt any calls that they want to work with law enforcement on. This might even be a really poor attempt at upselling to paid accounts. If you're concerned about security, I don't think zoom is the conference tool of choice -- maybe they've fixed everything I mentioned, but they still have among the worst track records. Security aside, the feature set and user experience is attractive. Except for one thing, why does it take two clicks to end a call? That's awkward every time. If people are accidentally leaving calls, that's a different problem and two clicks is a lazy solution.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lalaland1125 6y agoAh, so if I understand the Zoom CEO correctly, "protecting" pedophiles is fine as long as they pay Zoom. It's only an issue when they try to use Zoom for free.
- abootstrapper 6y agoThat’s how I understand it. What disadvantaged groups would be using Zoom for free that law enforcement would want to target? Protest organizers maybe?
- jdm2212 6y agoThe issue is that the free tier makes creating and disposing of burner accounts easy. If you pay, they have credit card info, etc. That makes it easy for law enforcement to link the Zoom account to a real person if it turns out that a particular account is a pedophile.
- ssivark 6y agoQ: Won’t criminals use the paid tier? A: No, because crime doesn’t pay I’ll see myself out :-)
- drummer 6y agoOne more reason not to use this garbage. I keep recommending Signal to everyone I know.
- kadal 6y agoI hope we get group video calls and video calls on desktop soon
- pthatcherg 6y agoI work at Signal on calling. Non-group desktop calls are coming soon (hopefully hitting beta in a few weeks). We're working on desktop group calls as well. That will take a bit longer, though. I don't have a good estimate of when it will be available
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoThanks for your work and looking forward to testing it out!
- drummer 6y agoExcellent news. It would also be helpful if we could also get (missed) call notifications on desktop. Right now if someone calls and I don't have my phone with me, I don't see their (missed) attempt on the desktop.
- steviedotboston 6y agolast time i checked Signal doesn't support group video calling. Also Group video calling features in apps like Facetime and Facebook Messenger are in a slightly different category from meeting centric apps like Zoom and Microsoft Teams.
- ghastmaster 6y agoWould compression techniques eliminate any possibilities of using steganography in real time video calls?
- drusepth 6y agoThoughts, in order: 1) Good, I guess I'll be using and promoting Zoom as much as I can 2) Well, I guess it doesn't really matter, since bad actors will have other encrypted software they can use 3) Well, I guess I'll still use and recommmend my friends use it just to avoid false-positive risks of flags from law enforcement Yes, I know this is effectively an "if you have nothing to hide" mindset. I'm okay with that.
- thewileyone 6y agoWho's placing puts on ZM now?
- homakov 6y agoI wonder can we do overlay encryption like this: some software encrypts audio and video stream from your camera, then apps like zoom transfer encrypted stream with some noise, and end user software tries to decrypt those streams. This way you can use any middleware app as long as both users have encryption software overlay. Just a crazy idea
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thebanksmoney 6y agoif paid =true and NotLaw=true then encryption =true else encryption =false
- ateamtexas 6y agohttps://ateam-texas.com/why-your-business-need-mobile-app-in-2020-complete-guide/ https://ateam-texas.com/why-your-business-need-mobile-app-in...