28 ms·
Security Flaws in Adobe Acrobat Reader Allow Gaining Root on macOS Silently
- interference 7y agoWhat is interference? A bit of history. Several years ago, as part of an internal project, we tried to create a data analysis service that meets the following minimum requirements: - as simple as possible integration with an existing java application - support for persistent data storage - indices support - support for a distributed database and distributed operations, such as the ability to insert or modify data in a database from any of the available nodes - the easiest cluster deployment - transaction support - basic SQL support with complex event processing and stream SQL support One of the outcomes of this development was an open source product branch called interference. What can this service do? Easy integration with java application. You include the library and then simply manage all the interference functions from within the java application using session methods, JPA annotations, queries and direct access to table objects. Interference is a distributed service. This means that this service can be used within a distributed cluster, or you can build a distributed event-driven application based solely on this service, without any additional services like coordinators and so on. Now, we suggest you use interference as a distributed platform when developing data analysis applications. Interference is not an RDBMS in the usual sense. You do not use JDBC or anything like that to access the data. Instead, direct object-relational mapping is used that works directly with persistent storage and remote event transport mechanisms. Minimal common insert performance on standard i7/4core workstation is up to 10000recs/sec on indexed table with UC constraint check and up to 50000recs/sec on plain table w/o any checks. In the next time, we plan to publish an article with a detailed review of the service architecture and performance metrics. Now, read the documentation for a detailed understanding. We are always happy to answer your questions.
- MrEldritch 7y agoDoes Hacker News have a "Report" button?
- katabasis 7y agoAt this point I consider the Adobe suite to be basically the same as malware. Their apps seem to want to take over your system, install all kinds of "helpers" that run in the background constantly doing god knows what, etc. And their security record is terrible. It's a shame because as someone who has a lot of interest in design, photography, etc. I acknowledge that they create some very powerful tools. I still miss Lightroom. But I'm just not willing to give them this much control over my computing environment any longer.
- pram 7y agoYes, Creative Cloud also vomits a bunch of random stuff everywhere. Right now I can see 5 launchagent/launchdaemons just from having Photoshop and Illustrator installed, which seems insane lol
- kitotik 7y agoNot sure if they still do it, but they also used to put hidden / protected files on any and all disk volumes as part of their copy protection scheme.
- sudosysgen 7y agoWhich is pointless when you realize that their copy-protection systems are broken in minutes every time. They should honestly give up.
- jpalomaki 7y agoThey can be still efective. Even a simple scheme may prevent a corporate user misusing some 30 day trial over and over and instead go through the trouble of getting proper license.
- sudosysgen 7y agoYes, it's probably worth it to get a simple scheme for corporate users only. But Photoshop's protection isn't simple, but it is so widely cracked that in third world countries with limited internet access there are wandering sellers with DVDs of cracked Photoshop for 2-3$ (!)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BaronVonSteuben 7y agoMaybe not helpful, but shout out to one of my famous apps, evince (default gnome PDF viewer). really well polished app. I use Xournal for editing PDFs. Would love if evince could do more than just annotations.
- vernie 7y agoImagine using Acrobat Reader on macOS...
- bberenberg 7y agoWhat is your alternative of choice? As someone who has to fill out forms all the time, theirs is still the most reliable in my experience.
- saluki 7y agoCheck out preview (default app) on OSX. It handles most things you need for a pdf that you can do in reader.
- Doctor_Fegg 7y agoMost things, but not everything. Preview performance with complex PDFs is, and has always been, lacking.
- bberenberg 7y agoPreview is my first choice but when you deal with BoringOldOrg their PDFs won’t work and I have wasted a lot of time trying. Big financial orgs, state govts, etc... I understand that this isn’t the case for many people, but for someone that has to deal with these forms all the time, the Adobe app is the most consistent.
- travmatt 7y agoYou can't fill out forms with preview?
- mratzloff 7y agoForm editing is really poor in Preview.
- crazygringo 7y ago
- olyjohn 7y agoBusiness as usual with Acrobat Reader. There are so many PDF alternatives out there, I don't see why so many people keep using it. I understand that there are some Adobe-specific extensions that won't work in other viewers, but typically those are use-cases for things that should not be done via PDF.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 7y agoPlease list for me the alternatives that are so ubiquitous as PDF that I can send someone a copy of a document that they cannot modify while still being able to read/print/etc, and is not a pure image format that is multiple MBs in size.
- chihuahua 7y agoI think GP is referring to PDF viewers other than Acrobat Reader, not file formats other than PDF.
- saagarjha 7y ago> they cannot modify Except Acrobat lets you modify PDFs. If you're trying to send someone something that they cannot usefully modify, you're kind of doomed from the start.
- reaperducer 7y agoExcept Acrobat lets you modify PDFs. If you're trying to send someone something that they cannot usefully modify, you're kind of doomed from the start. Acrobat won't let the Average Joe modify a password-protected PDF. Neither will Preview. There are ways around it, but for 95% of the people receiving a PDF, it's as good as locked.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoIt's a bit like saying that a stranger can log in to your account by typing any password 5% of the time, hardly reassuring...
- jiveturkey 7y agoI wonder why Mac OS continue to allow this. They should have learned from zoom to disallow this kind of updating altogether. I suppose they are reluctant to drop the hammer on Chrome.
- saagarjha 7y agoApple cannot disallow this, as quite a bit of software is distributed outside of the App Store.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xoa 7y agomacOS is not iOS, and at least for the time being can't be iOS either even if Apple wanted it to be because there is no crypto signed hardware chain stack on all supported Macs. Users can still modify essentially all aspects of the system if they want to (though Apple has made it more and more work for system stuff), and in turn allow software to do so as well. There is also plenty of legacy software that a lot of customers care a great deal about. So it'd be immensely difficult to try to retrofit the kind of system that would be needed to give users more control over this sort of thing, and impossible/very heavy to do so in a way that wouldn't break a lot of stuff without developers updating. It's a genuinely tough nut to crack and involves some trade offs. Apple's chosen decent-in-principle solution is to harden the base default system pretty heavily and have a curated ecosystem (the MAS) that they nudge users into by default, and where they can flat out ban this kind of thing. Ideally users who opted for other channels would know what they were doing. The big problem is that the MAS fucking sucks in a ton of unforced ways (like no update pricing system), and is also far too limited in many others (from non-Apple source options to single safety levels). So in turn a vastly higher percentage of users than would be ideal are forced to turn elsewhere for a lot of quality software even from small indy players. The many bad parts relieves pressure on lazy/bad developers to deal with parts that would be genuinely good. That's life with Apple sometimes though. They're bad at multitasking.
- saagarjha 7y ago
- heavyset_go 7y agoWhy does a PDF reader need a non-sandboxed daemon to escalate privileges?
- sersi 7y agoAnd this is why when AWS gave me the PCI AOC in a format that only works with adobe acrobat reader, I created a VM and installed it there.
- mrtweetyhack 7y agoWhat do you expect from the makers of Flash
- nneonneo 7y agoAdobe patched this to prevent symlinks but apparently didn’t bother to add any sandboxing to their root helper tool. Logically this means that any future bugs in this tool will result in the same level of exploitability. Nowadays self-updating software, from the user perspective, can be as easy as using Touch ID, so why Adobe and other companies are still messing around with complex, insecure and fragile autoupdate permission bypasses is beyond me.
- elliekelly 7y agoAnd once you install anything Adobe on your mac its basically impossible to completely remove it.
- sandymcmurray 7y agoI rely on AppZapper for this. One-click delete of apps and all related files. https://www.appzapper.com/ https://www.appzapper.com/
- unicornporn 7y agoBelieve me when I say your machine will still be sprinkled with crap after running AppZapper. If you want to remove it, you need something like https://rixstep.com/4/0/tracker/ https://rixstep.com/4/0/tracker/
- elliekelly 7y agoHas anyone had success using this with Adobe? I once had to install some Creative Cloud apps for a short-term project so I ran tree on the root directory as superuser before and immediately after installing and then used a diff checker so I’d know exactly what they put on my machine. It took forever. When I was done with the project I “uninstalled” everything and then deleted every single file and folder from the list and manually poked around to see if there was anything lurking that I might have missed. I thought for sure I’d won. About a week later I got a notification that Adobe Creative Cloud was requesting keychain access. I’m convinced it’s un-uninstallable.
- secabeen 7y agoThe Adobe Cleaner Tools do a pretty good job: https://labs.adobe.com/downloads/acrobatcleaner.html?PID=4082247 https://labs.adobe.com/downloads/acrobatcleaner.html?PID=408... https://helpx.adobe.com/creative-cloud/kb/cc-cleaner-tool-installation-problems.html https://helpx.adobe.com/creative-cloud/kb/cc-cleaner-tool-in...
- saagarjha 7y agoThe fact that Adobe needs to distribute this tool is very, very sad.
- oneplane 7y agoBut then what? You have local admin, but still no SIP bypass as far as I know. If there is an exploit for that you do of course have the option to chain that in there as well.
- pjc50 7y agoAt this point Adobe have to be responsible for some overwhelming fraction of all desktop exploits. There's always bugs in PDF readers. Not to mention their history of Flash (admittedly bought in rather than written)
- nine_k 7y agoEven if a PDF viewer is full of security holes like a colander, I don't see why this should lead to gaining root access. Why on Earth should Acrobat have any part even running as root? This design seems detective.
- saagarjha 7y agoUpdater.
- sigjuice 7y agoAdobe needs to play ball, sandbox themselves to the hilt and get on the damn Mac App Store. If dozens of pdf apps can be there, then so can Adobe.
- applecrazy 7y agoThat’s weird, if I remember correctly, all the apps that use Sparkle to update don’t need to run as root. What makes Adobe’s apps so special that they do need privileged access?
- saagarjha 7y agoSparkle is slightly more limited in what it can do and grabs an authorization right (to run things as root) when updating using the system APIs to do so rather than always running as root. Some would say this is a much better design (myself included) but Adobe presumably did not go this way because they are either lazy or actually would like more access to the system than Sparkle needs.
- 7y ago
- cjbprime 7y agoUsing PIDs to lookup the calling process doesn't seem like a great idea given the small PID space on macOS, I wonder if there could be a race there too.
- saagarjha 7y agoGenerally, code like this should be using the XPC audit token rather than the PID for such authentication. Alas, Apple, in its infinite wisdom, has kept this SPI private and undocumented but in a "if you care about security you should be using this nudge nudge wink wink" state for many years.
- flowerlad 7y agoInstalling decades-old C++ programs on your computer is an invitation for hackers to take over your computer. That includes Acrobat and Microsoft Office. Getting you to open PDFs and Office files is one of the primary ways in which your computer is taken over by hackers. They may send you an attachment or a link by email.
- saagarjha 7y agoNothing to do with C++ here; these bugs are logic errors.
- flowerlad 7y ago> Nothing to do with C++ here Other than memory safety issues, you mean?
- saagarjha 7y ago> here Just run-of-the-mill TOCTOU and poor validation.
- flowerlad 7y agoMy comment was not about this particular instance. In general, installing decades old C++ programs is asking for trouble. C++ language, unlike Rust, Java and .NET applications tend to contain memory related bugs, and that is inherent in C/C++ language.
- _bxg1 7y agoA big part of it is the fact that both of those formats, while nominally "documents", have the ability to execute arbitrary macro code upon opening
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThe sad thing is that PDF was designed to be safe by removing all dynamic features of PostScript. Office docs on the other hand don't run macros by default and are safer today than in the distant past.
- jbverschoor 7y agoWhen will I be finally able to use adobe malware through the AppStore, fully sandboxed? That 15% recurring is not too much to spend to have a secure system without all the malware adobe installs on your laptop. Disgusting company.
- WWLink 7y agoHonestly I'm not sure the panicked security experts will ever be satisfied until macOS and the default apps are burned onto a ROM, and you must bring your Mac to the Apple Store for software updates - provide proof of ID and ownership, and then they'll replace the ROM chip. I'm pretty sure if a security analyst saw a linux machine with the root account enabled they'd have an aneurysm. OMG THEY DIDN'T EVEN ENABLE SECURE BOOT?! SHOULD BE ILLEGAL! We can't even replace the FUCKING SSD in our laptops anymore, in the name of security (theater).
- saagarjha 7y ago> the panicked security experts Security experts are not one unified group pushing for locked-down hardware.
- pjc50 7y agoThere is a real tension which this rant is not helping with.
- jbverschoor 7y agoWell in Catalina the boot volume is separated. I just want strict sandboxing by default, just like my iPhone. Why on earth do they need access to my system. It’s an application. I hope Apple will make life for these kind of developers a living hell. Confirmation popups everywhere. It’s the only way they’ll learn. I gladly pay the premium for some piece of mind about properly architected software. Heck, it’s the same with construction.
- JadeNB 7y ago> I hope Apple will make life for these kind of developers a living hell. Confirmation popups everywhere. It’s the only way they’ll learn. Adobe knows full well that they've got sufficient lock-in that most complainers won't switch, so what will they learn?
- _bxg1 7y agoThe good news is, unlike Windows, macOS has a fantastic default PDF viewer ("Preview") and I don't know why anyone would ever install Acrobat on it
- mfer 7y agoPreview has issues with PDFs with form fields right now. It causes a bunch of people to need to install Acrobat for that use case. :(
- jmondi 7y agoInstalled Acrobat a few weeks ago for this use case specifically. I feel like Preview used to be a lot better at editing fields, recently it has been a real pain.
- ggregoire 7y agoAre there not any alternatives to Adobe Acrobat Reader on macOS for editing fields and other use cases listed in the other comments?
- leejoramo 7y agoApple's Preview does a pretty good job with generic pdf forms. Unfortunately, Adobe has created multiple types of pdf forms using different technologies and very complex specs. Apple does not support all of these. (You can also find many cases of PDF forms using Adobe tools that do not round trip between platforms). PDF Export does a good job of filing in the gaps. https://pdfexpert.com https://pdfexpert.com
- rspeed 7y agoNot just complex specs. Some of them are proprietary.
- gav 7y agoThere's some non-free options: Editing/Form Fill/etc: Nitro[1] Signing: Nitro[1], HelloSign[2], airSlate[3], Smallpdf[4] (limited functionality) [1] https://www.gonitro.com https://www.gonitro.com [2] https://www.hellosign.com https://www.hellosign.com [3] https://www.airslate.com https://www.airslate.com [4] https://smallpdf.com https://smallpdf.com
- myself248 7y agoWhy would Acrobat be running as root in the first place?
- saagarjha 7y agoThe updater is running as root.
- sjburt 7y agoIt’s a vuln in the auto-updater, which they need to plug all the vulns in the reader...
- cjbprime 7y agoDoes the updater need to run as root, though? They could install a launchd process running as the installing user who owns the /Applications folder. This is what everything else does -- privileged helper daemons are not common.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 7y ago> flaw But, but: how is it even possible for a user-mode application to break the OS security? It must be due to a flaw in the OS, right?
- saagarjha 7y agoIf you consider the ability to install code as root as a flaw in the OS, which is the security model of some platforms such as iOS.
- Koshkin 7y agoInstalling code as root does not necessarily mean granting root privileges to said code. (Even running an application under the root account shouldn't require or imply that. For example, if I use a text editor as root, I still do not want it to be able to reformat the hard drive.)
- saagarjha 7y agoThe code doing the installation as root does have root privileges.
- agustif 7y agoSo should I uninstall Acrobar Reader from my mac or not? I don't even use it that much, only for official stuff and such that requires it
- cemregr 7y agoI’ve been trying to delete every trace of creative cloud from my computer. Despite scouring the file system and rm-rf everything I can find, it comes back every restart ️
- dddddaviddddd 7y agoClean install your OS?
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoI am not sure why you are downvoted, since you are correct. The only way to be sure is to start from scratch.
- dddddaviddddd 7y agoAgreed, particularly if the software is persistent and the mechanism hasn't been determined.
- saagarjha 7y agoAside from /Applications, I'd look through ~/Library/Application Support, ~/Library/{ADOBE_LOOKING_THINGS}, ~/Library/LaunchDaemons/, ~/Library/LaunchAgents/, the /Library versions of the last two (and /System/Library if you have SIP disabled), and /Library/PrivilegedHelperTools.
- dontbenebby 7y agoIs there a simple way to check if this exploit has been used on a system?
- S_A_P 7y agoWhy anyone would install acrobat on a mac is beyond me. The native PDF support is plenty good and if there are adobe reader specific features I dont want them anyway. I may not be the majority opinion here, but I try not to use the format anyway if I dont need to.
- riffic 7y agoAcrobat Reader DC on macOS is nearly 600 MB. wtf
- numbsafari 7y agoIt's amazing how the software industry has managed to insulate itself from any kind of serious liability when it comes to the dumpster fire that is security and privacy. Could you imagine if other engineering disciplines had the kind of liability protection that software companies do?
- aduitsis 7y agoFaulty avionics software leading to an airplane crash will get all due liability. Faulty pdf readers leading to a pc getting taken over, doubtful.
- numbsafari 7y agoPC takeovers leading to millions of people being victims of identity theft, or used as a backdoor for national security relevant hacking efforts... We need to stop acting like these things are “insignificant” and accept responsibility for our actions.
- thatiscool 7y agois it security flaw or backdoor?
- supermann 7y agoWHY ALWAYS ADOBE PRODUCTS HAVE MAJOR SECURITY FLAWS?
- CivBase 7y agoWhy does anyone install a dedicated app for reading PDFs? Edge, Chrome, and Firefox all have built-in PDF readers. macOS's built-in Preview app can read PDFs. Just counting those four solutions, most users already have at least two PDF readers on their computer without installing Acrobat, Nitro, Foxit, or whatever. Stop installing dedicated apps for reading PDFs! They are bloatware meant to encourage users to buy PDF editors which most will never need!
- ducktective 7y agoAnnotation
- CivBase 7y agoWhile Chrome and Firefox lack support for annotating PDFs, Edge and Preview both support them.
- Gibbon1 7y agoBecause the built in ones suck for serious work.
- CivBase 7y agoCan you elaborate on the kind of "serious work" you are doing which cannot be accomplished with one of those solutions? Obviously those are all readers, so they are not able to edit PDFs or create them from scratch. However, neither can Adobe Acrobat Reader or most free PDF bloatware.
- geerlingguy 7y agoThe main purpose is trying to fill out annoying legal / banking forms that have tons of fields and sometimes field validation, digital 'eSignatures', etc. And every browser renderer treats these things differently and often breaks.
- Gibbon1 7y ago
- chrischen 7y agoHonestly I think this pales in comparison to the news of rampant security flaws in iOS: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23182862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23182862
- kstrauser 7y agoCan we agree that all of these need to be addressed, and that it's OK to be disappointed by both stories?
- kfrzcode 7y agoYes. In fact, maybe we can agree that Apple is notorious for glaring security flaws in their operating software and in turn we can, as a community, reach towards better solutions?
- chrischen 7y agoYes, if we can also agree that all lives matter.
- kstrauser 7y agoHas anyone at all said otherwise?
- kelvin0 7y agoWell if some malicious actor(s) would like to disseminate malware, the Adobe suite would be one interesting vector of massive infection.
- saagarjha 7y agohttps://duckduckgo.com/?q=adobe+acrobat+0+day+abused+in+the+wild https://duckduckgo.com/?q=adobe+acrobat+0+day+abused+in+the+...
- waynesonfire 7y agoi run foxit in sandboxie
- dilandau 7y agoI remember going blind to the "Update adobe reader" popups back in 2005 when I was using Windows XP. I can't imagine it's gotten better in the past 15 years.
- bobbyz 7y agoGood thing the Canadian government has decided to only use Adobe's proprietary pdf format (only openable by Acrobat btw) for all PDFs (lease agreements, academic forms) hahaha!
- indymike 7y agoIt's kind of amazing that PDFs are still a thing after all of these years. Also, the UI in Acrobat is one of the most creative (in a bad way) I've used since Lotus Notes.
- kfrzcode 7y agoPortable documents, easy support in the browser for reading. What's a good open-standards, portable replacement for PDF, I'm curious?
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoHTML, unless you need printing accuracy, of course.
- wintorez 7y agoAcrobat Reader is one of the most bloated softwares I've ever seen.
- paulie_a 7y agoWhy does anyone actually use adobe Acrobat reader? Antivirus should outright flag it as malware at this point.
- fortran77 7y agoWhy is this problem avoided on Windows? Is there something about MacOS security model?
- saagarjha 7y agoNo, it's just that the updater code on Windows is architected differently.
- capital_guy 7y agoOf course there are. I checked the processes running on my macOS machine a few days after installing creative cloud because it kept loading upon stat. only to find there are like 5 creative cloud processes constantly running in the background. No clearly visible setting within the application to stop these or keep it from running at launch either. This type of software design is unacceptable imo
- tech234a 7y agoI tend to use Adobe's little-known Acrobat Customization Wizard DC for Windows[1] to disable some of the unnecessary features in Adobe Reader. It is free and does not require a license, nor does the enterprise installer for Adobe Reader require a license. Features I disable include the online subscription services (actually a checkbox labelled "Disable Upsell"), cloud storage integrations, and Adobe sign-in. I enable Protected View for documents from "potentially unsafe locations" (basically downloads/emails). You can also disable automatic updates, though I tend not to. These changes make the UI far less cluttered. I suspect that these changes also improve speed, security and privacy, though I have not done any particular testing to confirm that. Basically you use it by uninstalling any existing Adobe Reader installations, installing the customization wizard and then downloading the enterprise installer for Adobe Reader[2] and extracting it with 7-Zip[3] (or the commands Adobe provides in the documentation). Then, you open the msp file in the wizard and customize your options. Finally, you save the changes and run setup.exe in the directory of extracted files. Once you're done, you can uninstall the customization wizard. There is also a version of the wizard for macOS[4], but it seems to be far more limited in terms of what can be configured through the UI, and most of the configuration has to be done by manually editing plist files. [1]: https://www.adobe.com/devnet-docs/acrobatetk/tools/Wizard/index.html https://www.adobe.com/devnet-docs/acrobatetk/tools/Wizard/in... [2]: https://get.adobe.com/reader/enterprise/ https://get.adobe.com/reader/enterprise/ [3]: https://www.7-zip.org/ https://www.7-zip.org/ [4]: https://www.adobe.com/devnet-docs/acrobatetk/tools/AdminGuide_Mac/predeployment_configuration.html https://www.adobe.com/devnet-docs/acrobatetk/tools/AdminGuid...
- ogre_codes 7y agoThis is one those timeless headlines which could be from any given year over the past 20 years. Perhaps substitute "Flash" for Acrboat Reader intermittently.
- qwerty456127 7y agoThe problem is there still are PDF forms many people need Adobe Acrobat Reader for. I use Okular and SumatraPDF to read normal PDFs but there is a form I am required by the state to fill regularly so I had to manually extract Adobe Acrobat Reader from an old Ubuntu repository.
- Ciantic 7y agoIt starts to look like Mozilla's pdf.js is the most secure viewer, at least it's using the browser's sandbox that is way more battle hardened than anything Adobe can come up with.
- heavyset_go 7y agoIs there sufficient sandboxing going on under the hood with Firefox? I wrap it with firejail because I was under the impression that Firefox was lacking in that regard.
- bscphil 7y agoOn Linux, as of Firefox 60, Firefox now uses Linux namespaces to isolate the various processes it starts from the rest of the system, where supported. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Sandbox#Linux https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Sandbox#Linux This is the same approach taken by Chromium. I can't say anything for certain about other operating systems, haven't really looked into it. I suppose that doesn't answer the question of whether pdf.js specifically runs inside one of the sandboxed processes, but it seems very likely that it does.
- dathinab 7y agoWhy is self-updating software still a think? It has been known to be a potential high security risk since years. I mean there are some special software where it still makes sense, but Adobe software clearly doesn't belong into this category.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoFlash was ubiquitous few years ago. What happened? Of course, as browsers added features, there was no longer a justification for Flash. But also: security flaws. Flash had many security issues and that was also a significant motivation for its "deprecation". But it did not have to be that way. Now, the same is happening with Adobe Acrobat.
- pyuser583 7y agoAdobe has been marketing pdfs on their security. Ironic.
- dependenttypes 7y agoI do not get why people use Adobe Acrobat to read pdfs. It is extremely slow, bloated, eats up your memory, has more holes than Swiss cheese, it is non-free, and probably has all sorts of telemetry on it. I use Sumatra on windows and zathura on Linux (evince if I want to fill forms) and I have been pretty happy with it.
- greggman3 7y agoI think I kind of wish there were fines for this kind of issue. I know all software has bugs and I certainly wouldn't want to be on the hook for my free software but I don't charge for free software. IANAL but I seems like for many non-software products there would be legal repercussions of they caused damage or had other issues. Is there any reasonable way to apply or morph those kinds of laws to software? Ideally it seems like it would be nice if the incentives changed so running all these services in the background is too big a legal risk and they stop?
- juloo 7y agoEveryone is talking about Adobe but that's not the right question to me. - Why the PDF reader has root rights ? Apple should never have allowed this. - How a programming error in a third party software can cause this ? Seems like a bug in macOS If you can answer positively to the first question, burn your computer now.
- classified 7y agoThank Jobs my Mac does not need Acrobat to display PDF. Besides, Acrobat has become more of an malware virus than a PDF reader.
- dandare 7y agoSerious question: what is the reason for the existence of the PDF format today? From wikipedia: "to present documents, including text formatting and images, in a manner independent of application software, hardware, and operating systems." I wish W3C would come up with container format for a HTML webpage that would pack all assets and run in any standard browser.
- jrochkind1 7y agoHTML was never designed to be "device independent", display pixel-perfect the same everywhere regardless of user-agent. PDF was, in relationship with printing. I think this is clearly a quality people want (whether they "should" or not), so it's unlikely they will stop using PDF unless there's another thing that can provide that quality. I don't think HTML is the right avenue for it. I would say the ePub format comes pretty close to what you are asking for though, a container format for HTML webpage that would pack all assets and run in... well, standards-based software from several different sources. I'm not sure if browsers will actually display ePub or not? They presumably could fairly easily if they had a desire to, since it's all standard html/web technology. ePub is not W3C maintained though, I don't think. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPUB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPUB It has moved in on PDF territory in some limited areas -- mainly ebooks of course, the use-case it's focused on. I think this is because it turns out "pixel perfect same everywhere" is a clear DOWNSIDE for ebooks, you want them to be formatted properly for your device's screen size, not have the same page size everywhere. So while PDFs were sometimes used for this, it works poorly enough for the user that another solution was demanded. (and thankfully we got an open standards one). Most uses of PDF still work "good enough" for most users (certainly not all; there can be accessibilty probelms). Even if it's a nightmare under the hood, PDFs generally work "good enough" for most developers too (again not all). It's a lot of investment to reproduce to replace, it would require popular use cases failing hard probably, with money to made from serving them better.
- jrochkind1 7y ago> Today, Adobe Acrobat Reader DC for macOS patched three critical vulnerabilities If you have a mac, you might want to know what version of Adobe Acrobat Reader DC is necessary to have the patches. The OP doesn't appear to say? The CVE's referenced (which ordinarily would say the patched version I think) all still appear to be protected/private, at the point I write this. https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2020-9615 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2020-9615 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2020-9614 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2020-9614 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2020-9613 https://cve.mitre.org/cgi-bin/cvename.cgi?name=CVE-2020-9613 My Mac does have "Adobe Acrobat Reader DC" on it. [btw, when did "DC" become part of the name and what does it mean?] If I open it up and choose "Check for Updates" from the "Help" menu, it does say "Adobe Acrobat Reader is already up to date." I'm not sure exactly when/how it would have been updated though. Under "About Acrobat Reader DC", it claims to be version `2020.009.2063`. It does not include a release date with the version. Am I up to date and protected? How would I know?
- tomc1985 7y agoAnother day, another Adobe update
- korginator 7y agoBy my last count there were 36 separate sections in the Adobe acrobat reader preferences, including a fair bit of internet and javascript related preferences, and gems like "Security" and "Security (Enhanced)". I've lost track of the services they have scattered around my Mac that are running silently, doing things I can only hope are not malign. Just today I was debating whether to move back fully to Preview or keep Adobe's bloatware on my Mac, and I think this made the decision for me. Given that Adobe has generously scattered a bunch of random stuff around my Mac, could one expect something like AppCleaner to find and clean out all the bits and pieces, or is that too much to ask?