17 ms·
> All of us should be regularly lobbying our lawmakers to make student loans dischargeable by bankruptcy, just like any other loan. The reason they aren't disc
by jedberg 7y ago
> All of us should be regularly lobbying our lawmakers to make student loans dischargeable by bankruptcy, just like any other loan.
The reason they aren't dischargeable is because what bank in their right mind would give a loan to an 18 year old with no collateral? They only guarantee they get that it will be paid back is the fact that it can't be discharged.
Student loans would dry up overnight if they could be discharged at bankruptcy.
That being said, I actually think that's a good thing, because it would force colleges to charge reasonable tuition rates and also offer scholarships if they want to get the best students.
But barring shifting to a European model of college funding, I don't see the US allowing dischargeable loans, nor do I think they should, because the reality of it is that colleges won't reduce their rates nor increase their scholarships, they would just be completely out of reach of poor and middle class students.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>colleges won't reduce their rates nor increase their scholarships, they would just be completely out of reach of poor and middle class students. If you let that run its course for a couple years then either the employers will have to relax their degree requirements or colleges will have to relax their price requirements. It'll be a game of chicken.
- 0xffff2 7y agoOr maybe they won't. Chronic underemployment has been a thing since at least 2008. Given a reality where there are simply more people than jobs that need doing, shutting the poor out of the education system seems like just another way to increase wealth inequality.
- pfdietz 7y agoDo employers have degree requirements? A 1970 SCOTUS case put strong constraints on what employers could require, at least with respect to high school diplomas. The same logic would apply to college degrees. Unless a direct link to a job (not just a general linkage) could be demonstrated, if there is a de facto racial discriminatory effect (and there would be, just from different rates of graduation from college) then the requirement would be illegal. I've been waiting for someone with a bone to pick against higher education to file a lawsuit over this. It could devalue college degrees. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co.
- Swizec 7y agoHere’s a lifehack: Attend college in Europe then move to USA for that high paying job. Works really well. Cheap to free education, better skills because you’re not just living the college life and professors have little incentive to make it easy. It’s great. Hell you don’t even have to fully graduate to get most of the benefit.
- jedberg 7y agoAren't European colleges the same price as American colleges if you're not European?
- Macha 7y agoDepends where you go. I know we had some Chinese students in my college, they paid €10000 a year, compared to the Irish students who paid €3000 a year. As far as I've heard, US colleges are on the order of $10000+ per semester.
- AuryGlenz 7y agoMy school was 30,000 a year, and my wife’s state school was definitely less than 10k a year. There’s a really wide variance.
- pc86 7y agoThere's also a point about sticker price vs. actual price. Anyone actually paying six figures for a Bachelor's degree is not only getting fleeced by an expensive school, but also can probably afford it (no need-based scholarships or grants?) and is also not very smart (no merit-based scholarships or grants?).
- unexpected 7y ago$10,000 a semester is cheap. The current price at the university I attended is $73k a year.
- evolve2k 7y agoGermany for example offers free education for Americans/foreigners. I remember this was discussed a while back on HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9308261 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9308261
- decompiled_dev 7y agoThe school admitting the student should co-sign the loan. If the school is confident in the value of their program they should assume the risk.
- jedberg 7y agoA funny idea, but also a great way to make sure that schools only offer majors with a high average post-grad salary.
- 0xffff2 7y agoIs that bad? Humanities departments are already shrinking without any changes because there's just no demand. It doesn't seem entirely unreasonable to me that if you are determined to get a degree in philosophy, which has virtually no job prospects outside of teaching the next generation of philosophy students, you have to go do that at one of a handful of schools that carve out a niche for themselves with a philosophy department.
- jedberg 7y ago> Is that bad? It depends on your point of view. Should college be a trade school or should it stick to it's roots of broadening one's horizons? I found my philosophy classes quite enlightening. They were required for my degree in CogSci. If my school didn't have a philosophy major, it wouldn't have a philosophy department, and I would never have had those classes. Also, there are some majors that lead to professional school. English/Rhetoric are often majors of people going into law school for example.
- jackcosgrove 7y ago> Should college be a trade school or should it stick to it's roots of broadening one's horizons? The term "liberal arts" means "free arts". The root of this term is that Athenian society was composed of a small class of free families and everyone else was a slave owned by those families. The free families were wealthy enough to afford a liberal education for their free sons. Everyone else had to work. Those are the roots of the liberal arts.
- xfitm3 7y agoStudent loans should absolutely be dischargeable. It will force tuition to drop to something affordable. It's advertised as a ticket to a good job and that's just false.
- jedberg 7y agoI addressed this in my comment. You'd end up with schools not lowering their prices, they would just be available only to the upper class.
- panzagl 7y agoThere are not enough upper class to go to all of the schools currently operating- colleges would have to lower prices or disappear.
- jedberg 7y agoYes exactly. The small schools would just disappear, and the big names would keep going.
- lallysingh 7y agoWhy? Schools can't be cheaper?
- iguy 7y agoClearly both would happen, right? Harvard doesn't set their prices based on loans, they wouldn't care. Some mid-rank colleges would disappear, and some would adapt to serve the new market.
- jedberg 7y ago> Harvard doesn't set their prices based on loans, They most definitely do: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/10/25/tuition-increase-outpaces-inflation-tuition-hikes/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/10/25/tuition-increa...
- x0x0 7y ago> Student loans would dry up overnight if they could be discharged at bankruptcy. There were student loans before 1976, when they became non-dischargeable.
- jedberg 7y agoYeah but college could be paid for with a minimum wage summer job. That change in 1976 was actually the cause of the steep rise in tuition. Can't really put the genie back in the bottle now.
- CydeWeys 7y agoWell ... You can. A lot of things will change and there'd be much disruption and churn in academic institutions, but it is possible.
- dnautics 7y agoThink of all of the bureaucrats in the colleges that will lose their jobs. Also think of all of those low and middle class students who we'll turn down since we're not willing to do wealth redistribution with our endowment (<scoff>, that's the government's job).
- staticautomatic 7y agoI find this attitude disturbing. The only things stopping real change in America are people who don't want it to happen and people who have been tricked into believing it can't.
- jedberg 7y agoI want real change, I just don't believe this is the change that makes sense. Changing the way colleges are paid for would make sense. Capping tuition would make sense. Making you pay a portion of your income back to the college for the rest of your life (or maybe just 20 years) would make sense. But allowing student loans to be discharged in bankruptcy would do more harm than good without other systemic changes.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoWe treat education as a public good. Employers don't have to pay for their employees' educations, and employees can take their skills around with them. Given that banks know their customers need employees they would get around to giving loans out to keep the supply of talent coming. There would just be far less waste if student loans were dischargeable.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIf the US treated education as a public good, then the US taxpayers would pay for education.
- jackcosgrove 7y agoMaybe not the best word to use. Education is not a private good, like that offered by a medieval guild which required the learner to work for some period for the guild like an indentured servant.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoWell there's part of the problem. Public goods are nonrival, and education isn't, especially if you want instructor attention and small class sizes.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> Given that banks know their customers need employees they would get around to giving loans out to keep the supply of talent coming. Banks generally don't give loans, the federal government does.
- maps 7y ago> But barring shifting to a European model of college funding, I don't see the US allowing dischargeable loans, nor do I think they should, because the reality of it is that colleges won't reduce their rates nor increase their scholarships, they would just be completely out of reach of poor and middle class students. The reality is that the they should be out of reach to poor or middle class students TODAY. They are not serving those people and are actively making their lives worse by saddling them with outrageous debt and no prospect of meaningful employment. If the US changed bankruptcy it would force the colleges to change as well. Lenders are not going to be sending children into the workforce with zero chance to recoup that loan, and they are not going to want to bloat the college stay to ridiculous proportions.
- jedberg 7y agoLike I said in my initial comment, I don't agree that would be the outcome. I think a lot of smaller college would fail, and the big colleges would keep their high prices, and only cater to the wealthy.
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoYou only need to look at historical examples to know that cannot be the case. Take for example, cars. That's how cars started. Look where we are today. If tuition stays sky high, it will be because of regulatory requirements (and enabling subsidies) to stay sky high, not because theres no market for education for working class folk
- bradlys 7y ago> The reality is that the they should be out of reach to poor or middle class students TODAY. That varies so much by student and to bar a whole class of people out of these things is not going to improve their outcomes. While some students are not served with better employment opportunities by going to college and earning a degree - there are many others who are. Outlawing things to a group of people isn't going to serve them better. It will mean that the entire middle class will be unable to educate into jobs. Educating them about the effort college requires to be successful once you leave would be better.
- lilott8 7y agoIsn't this why the cosigner exists on student loans? Basically the cosigner is the one with collateral, capable of meeting the terms of the loan. While IANAL, my understanding of reading a master promissory note for student loans is that basically the debt falls to the cosigner should the primary be unable to meet the financial obligations in any way (after wage garnishing, etc).
- jedberg 7y agoYes cosigners exist, but the loan still has no collateral. Usually a loan pays for a tangible asset that can be taken away when you fail to pay.
- gwd 7y ago> The reason they aren't dischargeable is because what bank in their right mind would give a loan to an 18 year old with no collateral? If it's a bad bet for the bank, it must be far worse of a bet for young adults. That's the point -- right now we're essentially suckering millions of naive young adults into a life of wage slavery by giving them a "bet" which they are completely unequipped to evaluate; and many of them are making a bet when they shouldn't. What you're essentially arguing is, "We have to enslave these people or society wouldn't function". On the contrary: we must not enslave these people; if stop doing it, society will figure out some other way to get things done.
- mlthoughts2018 7y ago> “ If it's a bad bet for the bank, it must be far worse of a bet for young adults.“ That’s not a valid implication at all. 18 year olds change their mind all the time, base decisions on impulsive reasons, etc., that comes with immaturity, lack of experience and indecision. The loan being a bad risk for the bank is a function of youthful impulsiveness and a person without the means to pay it back yet. It’s not risky to the bank because college itself is risky or fails to deliver wage opportunities. Not saying college cost-benefit is always favorable, just that your implication is wrong.
- jedberg 7y agoTo be clear, I don't think college should be paid for with loans. I agree with you that we shouldn't be enslaving people. But I also don't think allowing these loans to be discharged in bankruptcy will solve anything (and will arguably make things worse) without systemic changes in the way college is paid for.
- gwd 7y agoIt will force "the system" to come up with some other way to pay for tuition. What do you think about Income Share Agreements? https://www.thesimpledollar.com/loans/student/income-share-agreements-a-new-way-to-pay-for-college/ https://www.thesimpledollar.com/loans/student/income-share-a...
- devit 7y agoMaybe it could be a percentage of all taxable income, kind of like giving out equity in the student themselves as a person? Although of course there is no reason for college in general to be particularly expensive.
- cure 7y agoI believe Australia has a system along those lines, with forgiveness for people who work in the public service sector.
- sgerenser 7y agoThe US has this too, has for many years: https://studentaid.gov/manage-loans/repayment/plans/income-driven https://studentaid.gov/manage-loans/repayment/plans/income-d...
- sneeze-slayer 7y agoAnd the US Department of Ed denies 99% of applications: https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2018/09/24/public-service-loan-forgiveness-rejected/#6cfe9d3e1824 https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2018/09/24/public-...
- outoftheabyss 7y agoThat's what it is here in the UK. It's around 8% of everything over £20k with loan forgiveness after 30 years.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoNo other country works this way, yet they have college. So this argument doesn’t pass the smell test.
- jedberg 7y agoThe US dug themselves into a hole in the 70s when they disallowed bankruptcies on school loans. That opened up a flood of money to 18 year olds going to college, which in turn led to the colleges massively expanding their offerings. Colleges in the US don't just educate. They are also the minor league sports programs for most sports in the US, and they provide luxury benefits like gyms and movie theaters and so on. They can't go back now. They can't just stop doing all the sports with all the fancy equipment they bought, they can't just get rid of all the luxury housing and movie theaters and so on. So yes, the US is pretty unique in this respect.
- dnautics 7y agoI think the US also did some strange things like giving GIs free tuition (not necessarily a bad thing) then artificially supporting those GIs by requiring a college degree as gatekeeping for bureaucratic jobs. If you look around places where there's lots of bureaucracy (like washington dc) there's tons of strange billboards and the like on public transit advertising graduate school (MA and PhD) targeted at beaurocrats that need to check off that box for a pay/rank/retirement increase. IIRC one of them was called "Graduate School", as in you would go to a graduate school called "Graduate School". In any case not-in-DC it's more focussed on the BA segment of the population, but artificial gatekeepering is a thing (even in tech! I know many candidates that I wanted to hire but were turned down because they didn't have a BA in CS)
- jackcosgrove 7y agoCredentials are used as a lazy proxy for ability in any number of large organizations all over the world.
- 7y ago
- btilly 7y agoThe reason they aren't dischargeable is because what bank in their right mind would give a loan to an 18 year old with no collateral? They only guarantee they get that it will be paid back is the fact that it can't be discharged. And yet somehow banks were happy to do so until 2005. Student loans would dry up overnight if they could be discharged at bankruptcy. That being said, I actually think that's a good thing, because it would force colleges to charge reasonable tuition rates and also offer scholarships if they want to get the best students. Both of these statements I agree with. The larger the loan, the better the guarantee that banks want. Every measure that we take to make it easier for students to pay tuition without imposing cost controls results in increases in tuition. The result is that tuition has been growing faster than inflation for many decades, and the trend is unsustainable. But barring shifting to a European model of college funding, I don't see the US allowing dischargeable loans, nor do I think they should, because the reality of it is that colleges won't reduce their rates nor increase their scholarships, they would just be completely out of reach of poor and middle class students. This I disagree with. Universities are businesses. The bulk of their customers are able to pay thanks to loan guarantees backed by special government rules. Take away those loan guarantees and the universities will have to figure out how to live without customers, or without charging so much. That said, you can't get there without creating a crisis that forces universities to make hard choices that they have been avoiding for decades.
- jefftk 7y ago> somehow banks were happy to do so until 2005 Before 2005 most loans were already protected from bankruptcy, and for the others you generally needed your parents to co-sign.
- btilly 7y agoThe loans that were protected from bankruptcy from 1978 to 2005 were student loans to the federal government. They weren't private loans to banks. Therefore before 2005, banks that lent money for student loans did so without that particular extraordinary protection.
- 7y ago
- Spooky23 7y agoIt's a sure thing for the bank. Most of the loans are guaranteed by the federal government. Student loans only changed to be non-dischargable in the 70s and 80s, driven by certain professions (especially medical) and costs associated with them.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> It's a sure thing for the bank. Most of the loans are guaranteed by the federal government. Owned and issued, not guaranteed.
- novok 7y agoAmerica had dischargeable student loans before the early 2000s, and the education banking system did not implode from that. I think the student loan system would be fine with bankruptcy of student loans too after much gashing of teeth.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>The reason they aren't dischargeable is because what bank in their right mind would give a loan to an 18 year old with no collateral? Why is that a bad thing? This pushes choosing a good degree from something entirely on the 18 year old to something the market is deciding, by calculating the risk of a default, and removes much of the penalty from making a bad call from the 18 year old. Yes, not everyone will qualify for a loan, but if the bank who is interested in making money off loans decides your plan isn't worth a loan (and this bank has plenty of money to loan, so it can invest in many and aim at averages) thinks you are too likely to not get a good job and will default... maybe you should consider what that means. And it puts downward pressure on college prices, like you mention. >they would just be completely out of reach of poor and middle class students. There aren't enough colleges to survive on just upper class students. So either the colleges will go out of business or they will have to learn how to be in reach of the rest of the population.
- bsder 7y ago> Student loans would dry up overnight if they could be discharged at bankruptcy. So? That's the marketing evaluating what the loan is actually worth. Bankruptcy isn't a magic "Get Out Of Jail Free" card. Your credit is trashed at a point when you might want to get married, buy a house, start a family, etc.
- labcomputer 7y ago> Bankruptcy isn't a magic "Get Out Of Jail Free" card. Except that it is in this case. The order of operations is: 1. Take out student loan 2. Graduate 3. Get a job, spouse, mortgage, and new car 4. Declare bankruptcy to discharge student loans 5. Profit The order of steps 3 and 4 are critical. Your car and house are collateral for their respective loans, so they don't go away when you declare bankruptcy. Since you have a house and new car, you typically don't need good credit for the 5-7 years it takes before people will start loaning you money at reasonable rates again. This isn't some theoretical pattern. It's what people actually did. Especially doctors, because they could often qualify for nice mortgages while still in residency ("doctor loans").
- d883kd8 7y ago> The reason they aren't dischargeable is because what bank in their right mind would give a loan to an 18 year old with no collateral? Except private student loans exist
- vonmoltke 7y ago> The reason they aren't dischargeable is because what bank in their right mind would give a loan to an 18 year old with no collateral? Over 90% of loans are owned by and issued by the federal government. It's not banks Congress was protecting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dhimes 7y ago<Cue your "OK boomer" clips> Former professor (community college), father of three, two still paying tuition. Here's my take: Students should be ineligible for loans until they complete one semester of college. Colleges should make that semester a "boot camp": Varied, challenging, intellectual curriculum, forced work-together times (a study-hall "lab"), and so on. The problem I have is that a helluva lot of students who go to college right out of high school are there for the wrong reasons. They aren't applying themselves intellectually- any growth they get will be, if not despite their behaviors, at least accidental. I don't want free tuition/subsidized loans/etc. in the current situation. And I totally believe that society should make an investment- hell I've dedicated my life to it- but it's a careful investment. I want those young adults to come away from college with real intellectual growth. At least they should be able to read and think critically. And making college free in the USofA will make college costs increase (unless you think the US military spending is under control). Having an onboarding boot camp, where you have to learn to study and take it seriously or you don't get to stay, would help the First Year Experience folks (who would run it), the professors (yay!), the students, the parents who would otherwise be throwing their money away, even high school teachers. It might make enrollment drop-at least initially- but it seems like that's an issue now anyway so it might be a good time for it. Now, get the hell off my lawn!
- rolandog 7y agoBut isn't the reason for the sole existence of college loans that there aren't any regulations controlling the private education industry? More availability for loans means the schools can charge more for tuition. Just like the whole american privatized healthcare; the sky is the limit... to what they'll charge you.
- brightball 7y agoI think they should for the same reason you point out. The cost of school has gone up due to the endless supply of loan money mixing with demand. That cost will go waaaaaaay down if the loan money dries up, potentially back to the point where it was when “working your way through college” was possible.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoNow you have to explain how students got loans before 1998 and 2005, before student loans were made non-dischargeable. https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2019/01/09/student-loans-bankruptcy-discharge/#444628076d56 https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2019/01/09/student... The fact of the matter is that by making the loans non-dischargeable, lenders loosen their purse strings since risk of default is much lower. And colleges being on the receiving end of these loans are naturally going to move their prices upward to capture the increase. Going back to the way things were in 1998 would go far in bringing down the astronomical tuition increases we see year after year.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 7y agoI've always thought it would make sense to have all the involved parties take a hit if a student loan can't be repaid. For example, the loan could be split four ways. To qualify for discharging the remaining balance in bankruptcy, we could require that you've already paid at least 25%, the bank can eat 25%, the university can eat 25%, and Uncle Sam can cover the rest. If we don't force all the parties to share some of the consequences, we're basically pushing universities to charge as much as possible, banks to lend as much as possible, and 18 year old kids to enter into lifetime contracts of potentially crippling debt.
- mapgrep 7y agoRoughly 90 percent of student loans are guaranteed by the federal government. Your argument doesn’t hold.
- caseysoftware 7y ago> Student loans would dry up overnight if they could be discharged at bankruptcy. No, more likely they would be priced - both in amount lent and interest rate - according to the value of the "asset" they're purchasing. There's a reason why home mortgage and car loan rates are 3-4% while random credit card rate is 16-25%. One is used to purchase something that has long term value and may be used to create value or enable you to make money while the other one is used for Netflix and Big Macs. I'm waiting to see how things shake out in the next couple weeks. Many colleges require freshman deposits on May 1st. We don't know a) how many are coming back into physical session in the fall and b) how many parents will tolerate paying for an online degree. The next 12 months could crash the system.
- dd36 7y agoIt was that way prior to 2005 and everything was fine.
- notechback 7y agoWhy even have this as a private thing. In other countries this works fine as a public loan offer by the state (which also helps to keep fees reasonable).
- Taikonerd 7y agoSurely some kind of middle ground is possible? Something like, "student loans aren't dischargeable for 15 years after you receive them." That would eliminate the possibility of a quick "tactical bankruptcy" after college, while also allowing students who made an unwise financial deal when they were 18 not to spend their whole lives paying off debt.
- sjg007 7y agoMost student loans are guaranteed by the Federal govt. There is no risk for the lender. They just operate as a middle man basically. There was legislation to move all loans to the Dept. of Education and do away with Navient etc... but you know elections happened...