16 ms·
X410 – X Server for Windows 10
- Lammy 7y agoNice to see this on here. I really enjoy using this as well as Token2Shell (SSH client) from the same dev: https://token2shell.com/ https://token2shell.com/
- lerpapoo 7y agowindows on linux or linux on windows...WHO will WIN?
- pjmlp 7y agoThis is nothing new, I have used X Windows servers on Windows all the way back to 1999, there are quite a few to choose from. If anything the amount to choose from went down not up, slowly replaced by RDP clients. So that tells who will will win.
- int_19h 7y agoThat might change with WSL drastically increasing the demand for such a thing. With enough resources, doing it as an X server is the better approach because it gives more flexibility - top-level windows can be shown directly on the host desktop etc. And with enough demand, there are resources for something like X410... I've used both Xrdp and X410 for my WSL UI needs, and so far X140 has been a much better experience by far.
- pjmlp 7y agoYeah, as if that is anything new versus Cygwin with XWin32 for example.
- int_19h 7y agoIn terms of sheer number of active users, yeah, I'm fairly sure it is. There's lots and lots of developers who live in the Microsoft bubble, who might have never even heard of Cygwin - but who will hear about WSL from their routine conferences, training etc.
- beatrobot 7y agoRDP also supports showing only the windows instead of the full desktop session.
- clouddrover 7y agoThe end users.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoOr just Linux with WINE, without Windows.
- jng 7y agoIs there even a doubt? Windows has a chance at supporting the open, documented interfaces of Linux. Linux has no chance at supported the closed, undocumented interfaces of Linux.
- pritambaral 7y ago> the closed, undocumented interfaces of Linux. Perhaps you meant "Windows"?
- jng 7y agoIndeed, thanks for the correction.
- thejosh 7y agoWhat do actual users who would want to run Linux actually run? Probably games? Maybe office?
- meddlepal 7y agoI dual boot right now and hop into Windows only for games. Wine is janky so that's not a good solution. I've been a pretty devoted Linux user for close to 20 years but I'm starting to seriously consider switching to a WSL setup in the future.
- cercatrova 7y agoYou can try a Windows VM with GPU passthrough, there's Looking Glass with transparently sends the VM pixels to a Linux window with native performance. https://looking-glass.hostfission.com https://looking-glass.hostfission.com
- meddlepal 7y agoThanks, I'll take a look at this!
- kdamica 7y agoI've been using VcXsrv (https://sourceforge.net/projects/vcxsrv/ https://sourceforge.net/projects/vcxsrv/) to do the same thing for a few months. It works well in most cases, but it can be janky. The scaling doesn't always work well if you're using a hidpi screen, and I had one application that was crashing consistently under certain circumstances. Definitely going to try this out, but I wonder if it's worth paying for when I have a free alternative that does most of what I need it to do.
- taffit 7y agoBeen using VcXsrv as well in combination with WSL2. However the clipboard stopped working randomly (but at every session). Only a complete restart of the WSL-services and X-server made it work again. This is what brought me to try X410, and I never had a problem with the clipboard there. Using it now in combination with WSL2, qtile and Terminator as terminals (I have to stick with Windows in my company).
- nessunodoro 7y agoVcXsrv is great for bridging WSL and the Windows GUI, e.g. launching an x11 image viewer from WSL bash
- kingosticks 7y agoI've been using it for literally years to access the GUIs of programs running on Linux workstations from my Windows 10 machine over our LAN. I don't think it's ever crashed for me with the 3 or 4 programs I run but it's sometimes a little slow, although I'm not convinced that's the fault of vcxsrv. I have no other problems with it, my experience with scaling has been surprisingly good. I see no reason to pay for an alternative.
- kdamica 7y agoMy crash happened whenever I tried using a Matlab MLX file (which are similar to Jupyter notebooks in Matlab, if you aren't familiar). Since I don't use them much, this was easy to work around. Not clear to me whether the problem was Matlab or VcXsrv.
- 7y ago
- decafbad 7y agoVcXsrv works well for me https://sourceforge.net/projects/vcxsrv/ https://sourceforge.net/projects/vcxsrv/
- cordite 7y agoHow does this website prevent me from zooming in on iOS?
- _ikke_ 7y ago<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1" /> The "width=device-width" is the cause.
- maxnoe 7y agoNo, this would only set the initial viewport, it does not prevent zooming
- rym_ 7y agoIn general why do sites or apps feel the need to block this, drives me nuts.
- skrebbel 7y agoIt used to be the case that if zooming was enabled, every normal tap would have a 300ms delay on iOS Safari. Iirc they fixed that since (not sure how, can anyone recall?). But basically most mobile web apps built a few years ago would disable zoom so they got snappy interaction.
- savolai 7y agoDoes not block zoom for me on ios 13.3.1 safari.
- jcims 7y agoI stopped using Chrome in iOS 100% b/c it gratuitously honored every whim of any designer/developer to limit my ability to zoom into the screen. Safari has proven to be much less likely to prevent the same. On this x410.dev site I can zoom in on both, but I headed over to flickr to get that good chrome no zoom cortisol hitter. I don't understand how this isn't an accessibility issue. My eyes aren't what they used to be and it's nearly impossible for me to see content some times. Yet enabling the actual accesibility features in iOS goes way overboard. Drives me insane.
- joyfulmantis 7y agoThey are asking $50 for something that there are other open source solutions for. It would be interesting to find out how much of the original source code is the developers and how much is just repackaging of one of the multitude of open source X servers for Windows that are currently available. Originally thinking it was another open source project, I looked at the website to see if there were some features that would be worth it to switch from VcXsrv. Mostly it talked about how there was a windowed mode that allowed seamless integration with Windows. Wow how revolutionary! /s
- naikrovek 7y agoI don't know how much code is shared, if any, but I do know that xming and vcxsrv both crash for me constantly and X410 doesn't. Like, ever. I got it on sale, but I'd pay full price solely for the amount of headache it has saved me.
- paulie_a 7y ago50 bucks is peanuts if it saves headaches
- otec 7y agoIt's 80% discount for next 16 days in app store apprently
- topspin 7y agoI just bought it on spec. The terms claim you can install it on 10 machines! $1/box is pretty cost effective. I've paid for xming a couple times in the last few years. Doesn't quite cut it with certain applications; various show stopper glitches. Really would like to solve the X Windows on Windows problem once and for all. There are other posts speculating on the code base; isn't this just X.Org for Windows repackaged? Yes, it is based on X.Org. The publisher explains it on the site; it's X.Org with pre-Window 10 support removed and otherwise optimized and enhanced.
- numpad0 7y ago
- uk_programmer 7y agoI've been using XMing for years (there are probably better options out there but it works for me) and there is of course vcxsrv as other people have mentioned. It looks nice and all, but there are plenty of free options available that will do the same.
- naikrovek 7y agoIf only xming and vcxsrv would stop crashing...
- stragies 7y agoI wish, there was a standard URL suffix for "Pages for Techies", like "/techspecs", or similar. Whenever I go to a Product-Page like this one, I'm instantly turned off by the flashiness and wordy prose. I want a feature list, in text form, not an intro-movie! Before closing the tab i did notice though, that this product seems interesting, and I would have liked to read more about it.
- nycticorax 7y agoYeah, it's funny how often I end up going to the Wikipedia page of a company or product to find out what they're selling in plain language.
- stragies 7y agoThe solution would be easy: Put the flashy stuff in a div with ID "advert", and the ad-blocker will hide it from view. All non-techies gets the intro-movie. Anyway: Here is the list of things I gathered from the comments (iiuc): * Uses a fork of x.org with support for legacy Windows version removed. * Costs 10$ if you find it on sale, 50$ otherwise. * Can be installed on 10 PCs. * Can be installed/updated via the AppStore. * Has a windowed mode. * Well-integrated into Windows 10 and WSL. * Takes advantage of HyperV virtio vsock for small latency enhancement. * If VcXsv or XMing are unstable for you, file a bugreport, and try if X410 is more stable. * Cannot make use of hardware assisted rendering, because of underlying WSL limitation w.r.t GVT-g in some HW configurations
- gramakri 7y agoThis is much cheaper than hummingbird exceed. It used to costs 1000s iirc.
- jandrese 7y agoexceed was a pretty terrible server too. Really glitchy. Once I discovered Xming I never looked back.
- reanimus 7y agoI've been using VcXsrv to run remmina on my desktop for a while now, but it's been having issues where windows will disappear and won't return without relaunching. I'm giving this a spin to see if it works; if it does, I'll happily fork over ten bucks for it. :)
- sz4kerto 7y agoI wanted to buy this but MS Store asks me to 'associate an address with my profile', then shows a dialog where I can only select US addresses. I already have a non-US address assoc'd with my MS account, so I don't know what am I doing wrong. Edit: nevermind, I had to change the store region on the web. I hate this :)
- 29athrowaway 7y agoI hope this motivates people to fully transition to Linux. There's a lot of FUD around Linux. Just install it and see for yourself. You'll never need Windows again.
- DonHopkins 7y agoYour table is ready for you, sir. https://web.archive.org/web/20050924142700/http://reddit.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20050924142700/http://reddit.com... Did you know that Voyager 1 has just reached the edge of the solar system after 28 years in space, while Microsoft's nightmare inches closer to reality??!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 29athrowaway 7y agoTo make your Internet wayback machine experience more immersive, keep using Windows. The sluggish performance will make you feel just like in the 90s.
- Jonnax 7y agoWhat if I want to play a game? I gotta hope proton supports it. Or use Photoshop, Lightroom or any other non Linux creative application. I guess I gotta learn the free alternatives. Also how's video acceleration in the browsers? Can I play a 4k60fps video? Is there HDR support? I use Linux everyday. But misrepresenting the desktop experience isn't going to get people to switch.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoYou will be playing your favorite game with HDR enabled, and suddenly... it's auto update time! See you in 30 minutes. I just watched a 4k60 fps YouTube video just fine. I am surprised you didn't mention office suites. Softmaker Office/FreeOffice are very similar to MS Office, just 99.9% more responsive and less bloated.
- meitham 7y agoCygwin/X can be made to listen to TCP with the option ‘’-listen tcp‘’ and can work great on WSL, multi-window mode and two directions clipboard.
- zennit 7y agoWhat are you guys using this for mostly?
- toast0 7y agoI haven't used this Xserver, but I've used most (all?) of the free Xservers for Windows over time. As background Windows is my preferred desktop environment for about the last ten years[1], but I do most of my "real work" on FreeBSD or Linux; having an Xserver on windows means I can do graphical work and have it mostly work. Utilitywise, I can do things like running an image viewer to see what pictures I have in a directory. I run mythtv; most of the administration can be done through the TV facing interface or the web interface, but some things need to be done with mythtv-setup; it runs terribly over remote X (for no good reason), but at least it runs. I was writing a terrible NES emulator for fun, having an Xserver meant I could write it where I'm comfortable writing software, and display it where I'm comfortable with a desktop. I'm writing a terrible operating system, which I run with QEMU for the time being; the VGA console is an X window (I support serial console and it's better than VGA, but I like to keep an eye on the VGA, because I'd like to run it on some of my home systems, and they don't all have serial ports). [1] Although Microsoft seems to be trying to push people away again, running on the default platform has a lot of benefits.
- datnoblesavage 7y agoWhat benefits do you see from running windows? I really see none as a software dev and os enthusiast. The only reason I kept windows so long was for a game that I stopped playing 2 years ago, and the only reason I have to use it now is because the company I currently work in has made us use it. WSL makes me embarrassed to show my work colleague how good linux/vim/tmux really is (but that might be because the laptop's 8gb is almost totally used up by invisible processes (whereas the wsl portion uses around 500mb!))
- _ph_ 7y agoWell, you list one of the benefits of running Windows, you can keep working at your company :p. Many companies don't allow running Linux natively. For example, because Office and Outlook are considered mandatory tools. There is other software, which is only available on Windows or the Mac. Also, it is still not a trivial thing to buy a random laptop and get full hardware support, especially with very new hardware. Not even to mention NVidia... As a consequence, Mac+VMware is my currently preferred way of running Linux, and Windows+WSL is an increasingly attractive alternative to this.
- improv32 7y agoWhat differentiates x410 from other x servers is that it support communication over VSock, which Hyper-V supports, and it's probably 3x less latency than tunneling x over ssh. Made it possible for me to comfortably use emacs in my hyper-v arch vm
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jdellinger 7y agoDoes anyone want to share how they use the WSL2 & X-Server combination? In my case, I'm mostly happy with the VSCode WSL2 integration. I keep all my projects on the linux fs and it is fast to work with. The only thing which annoys me is the window management in Windows. Too much Mouse movement and random ALT-TAB-ing. I've never got i3 to work with a Windows x server on multiple displays with high dpi. X401 also only supports a single display.
- erikbye 7y agoAs for Windows native window management, FancyZones is better than nothing. You can overlay zones, I have split each monitor in half with two zones each, then overlayed a bunch of smaller zones for stuff like terminal windows, etc. https://github.com/microsoft/PowerToys/tree/master/src/modules/fancyzones https://github.com/microsoft/PowerToys/tree/master/src/modul...
- stragies 7y agoLooks like the windows equivalent of the Gnome GTile window manager extension: https://github.com/gTile/gTile https://github.com/gTile/gTile
- jdellinger 7y agoFancyZones is great! Already a huge enhancement to the normal windows snapping. However, it only solves the window placing problem, not the window navigation problem. I would love to navigate with something like SUPER + LEFT/RIGHT, similar to i3. Currently the only possible way is to (CTRL)+ALT+TAB, which completely lacks window layout context and changes order depending on recent uses.
- skrebbel 7y agoI'm curious, I always thought that devs who choose Windows do so because they like the window management and the UI tools etc. That's my reason for sure. What's stopping you from just running proper Linux with VS Code, if you don't like the way the Windows shell works?
- ThePhysicist 7y agoThere are several free alternatives like vcxsrv (https://sourceforge.net/projects/vcxsrv/ https://sourceforge.net/projects/vcxsrv/) that I used in the past in combination with WSL to work with a proper gnome shell instead of the WSL bash shell (that doesn’t have tabs and many other niceties). Works pretty well except maybe for high DPI environments.
- oskenso 7y agoHas no one heard of moonlight? With an Nvidia card you can attach windows remote desktop - mstsc.exe to it and bam, nvenc encoded dynamic bitrate low latency remote desktop fully functional with audio!
- mkl 7y agoThat seems totally unrelated. This is primarily for running Linux GUI apps in WSL (i.e. locally), which is otherwise terminal only. Moonlight looks interesting but doesn't serve the same purpose at all.
- zeppelin101 7y agoBought this after seeing the pretty solid reviews here on this thread. I've been using VcXsrv with no problems thus far. But I really like that this project's website has nice documentation. Also, this works with no configuration required (other than the 'DISPLAY' line in the WSL bash config), which is a nice convenience. I hope this product continues to evolve and receives constant updates.
- dlkmp 7y agoI don't fully understand what this is capable of. Can I use this to run a window manager like xmonad? If so, does it work only for linux gui apps run through WSL or also for windows programs? I really love what WSL has been doing so far and this would really take it to the next level. I'd actually consider switching my private computer to Windows.
- Jnr 7y agoIt runs X on Windows. This was doable before as well. Unless you can make Windows render windows on the X server, no, you can't use your Linux window manager for Windows programs.
- tjoff 7y agoHaven't been using this specifically but it looks similar enough to vcxsrv. To me the big selling points of both this and vcxsrv is using seamless windows so that the windows are just like any other windows-window and not like VNC or something where you get two desktops - one for local and one for remote. In vcxsrv, and it seems this one as well, can also run a window manager. I tried i3 that way, but it is quite clunky and the shortcuts collided with windows native shortcuts in a bad way. Maybe there are fixes for that. But it will would still only be for linux apps and not windows apps.
- syockit 7y agoI (and most of my colleagues) stopped using vcxsrv at my workplace since we moved from Qt4 to Qt5. At some point in between, Qt stopped supporting native X11 painting[1] which means all of the graphics are now drawn as bitmap at server side and sent in whole to the client. That easily hoses up our network. The problem is more exarcebated now that Japan has declared state of emergency and everyone is urged to work from home. We now resort to using VNC solutions. (I wish we had developed a curses client along with the GUI for times like this) [1] https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/QTBUG-50338 https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/QTBUG-50338
- raverbashing 7y agoX over anything but a local network (and even then) is hard to make it work right. VNC and similar systems have the right idea about remote desktop access.
- stragies 7y agoW.r.t to working principle/protocol, VNC is to X11 what MOSH is to SSH-Terminal, with RDP taking the best of both worlds. The RDP-server, and -client implementations are mature on all common platforms, with a well-supported common minimum protocol version support. For anything but localhost I try to use RDP.
- jamesfmilne 7y agoX also doesn't really work if you UI is implemented with OpenGL or similar. I've been using NoMachine and it works very well. Others I know are using Teradici, or HP Remote Graphics.
- datenwolf 7y ago> X also doesn't really work if you UI is implemented with OpenGL or similar. Depends on how you use the OpenGL API. OpenGL display lists, once compiled, are extremly light on the connection. However they're also deprecreated and no longer supported in (forward compatible) OpenGL-3.3 core. But then again there's no 3.3 GLX specification.
- saboot 7y agoI was convinced to buy this when I came across their article on a simple and fast setup for getting Linux gui apps to run along side my windows desktop https://x410.dev/cookbook/wsl/xidekick/ https://x410.dev/cookbook/wsl/xidekick/ Been using that for about a year now, love it
- erikbye 7y agoIt's about the same setup for all the other servers.
- forgotmyname11 7y agoDoes this allow me to run Linux GUI applications in Docker for Win and have the X output routed to this?
- sabrehagen 7y agoYes
- LucidLynx 7y agoYes, but if you need sound, I think that the Audio driver is not publicly available...
- sabrehagen 7y agoIf someone could make Windows applications render on an X Server I'd be so happy.
- zetalemur 7y agoThat's what Wine does (and it often works surprisingly well).
- sabrehagen 7y agoI run Windows applications that require USB hardware, and Wine does not support USB devices. so I was hoping for native Windows execution rendered to an X Server.
- WhyNotHugo 7y agoWell, native windows executing under Xorg is what Wine tries to offer. It just "not complete" yet.
- asveikau 7y agoRun windows in a VM with USB pass through?
- stjohnswarts 7y agothis is what I do. It works for a lot of USB devices, but not always.
- tomxor 7y agoI can't tell if you guys are joking... are you seriously suggesting: windows kernel > WSL > proprietary x-server clone > WINE > windows apps This is madness
- stragies 7y agoI'm not ZetaLemur, but I don't believe he was suggesting what you are interpreting into this suggestion. I believe he means: "If at all possible, run your legacy windows-only applications on local Linux running on real Hardware with WINE"
- erikbye 7y agoThe free version of MobaXterm works great.
- kpocza 7y agoThis way X and music also works: https://github.com/kpocza/LoWe https://github.com/kpocza/LoWe Of course, it's a bit circumstantial...
- zhangsen 7y agoIs it feasible to run cuda dependent code using WSL and this X Server?
- ilitirit 7y agoDoes anyone have a guide to getting i3 to work using this?
- ilitirit 7y agoSorry, can't edit the original post any more, but it turns out this is quite simple. 1. Start a WSL terminal 2. https://x410.dev/cookbook/wsl/setting-up-wsl-for-linux-gui-apps/ https://x410.dev/cookbook/wsl/setting-up-wsl-for-linux-gui-a... 3. Start X410 in floating mode 4. sudo apt update 5. sudo apt install i3 6. i3
- tomxor 7y agoThis is getting weird, you pay for windows to use WSL then pay $50 for an X server clone... who wants to try this hard to not use the Linux kernel?
- NelsonMinar 7y agoPeople who want to run Windows software? If all you're doing is Linux and X then yeah, just run Linux.
- drewstiff 7y agoWSL 2 now _does_ use the Linux kernel.
- HelloNurse 7y agoTrue, and it counts as trying really, really hard.
- techntoke 7y agoStill isn't RTM.
- Eridrus 7y agoI have a Linux laptop from work with a small amount of supported hardware configurations. I have had issues with: UI lockups, audio failures, resume from suspend issues. Windows 10 isn't perfect, but it's a lot better at not getting in the way.
- notyourday 7y agoPhotoshop/Davinci Resolve/Capture One/Lightroom
- WhyNotHugo 7y agoWow, this looks really cool. I'm honestly really wondering how they got hidpi support, since, AFAIK, Xorg did not support hidpi (this one of the new things Wayland brought to the table).
- upofadown 7y agoIt is unfortunately more complicated than just the X server stuff. Xorg has a zoom parameter accessible via xrandr and lets you set the DPI. But that is not enough. Good discussion here: * https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/HiDPI https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/HiDPI
- AshamedCaptain 7y agoThere's absolutely no reason why Xorg "does not support hidpi". It even supports differing DPIs per screen. It does not support however _overriding_ the DPI individually per screen, but this would be trivially solved by standarizing toolkits on some other property (either a plain property or a fancy xrandr extension).
- cercatrova 7y agoFor a somewhat alternative if you want to run both Linux and Windows, you can run Linux natively and then run Windows in a VM with GPU passthrough. Then you can use Looking Glass which sends the Windows pixels to a Linux window with native performance. For the Linux machine, you can run it as a host or use something like Proxmox as a hypervisor if you need more VMs or containers. I use this setup to run Windows, macOS and Linux simultaneously, macOS mostly for iOS development. https://looking-glass.hostfission.com https://looking-glass.hostfission.com
- dr1337 7y agoHow did you get Looking Glass to work with macOS? I don't think it's supported as host OS.
- arghwhat 7y agoThey ran macOS as a guest. Looking Glass only runs on Linux.
- cercatrova 7y agoIt only works with a Linux host and Windows guest. I posted this on HN as well, and I wrote that there have been rumors that Apple might implement something similar due to development happening with virtIO drivers in macOS, so perhaps you may not have to wait long for a macOS host running Windows. I ran the 3 OS using a Proxmox (Linux) host and three guest VMs.
- Aeolun 7y agoThis sounds fantastic. Is there a more comprehensive guide somewhere on how to set this up?
- cercatrova 7y agohttps://looking-glass.hostfission.com/wiki/Installation https://looking-glass.hostfission.com/wiki/Installation Also check out their GitHub and quickstart, they have more details. The main thing is you have to run it both on Linux and Windows.
- boksiora 7y agowhy its not free ? :(
- jpeeler 7y agoThis seems relevant given that Wayland is the future: https://github.com/microsoft/WSL/issues/938 https://github.com/microsoft/WSL/issues/938
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- selfishgene 7y agoHas anyone compared X410 performance over VSOCK to FreeRDP's Thincast Workstation, which is an "optimized for graphics" remix of Virtual Box?
- selfishgene 7y agoAre VSOCK connections available yet in any open source remote X desktop solutions? Xpra, X2Go, VcXSrv, Cygwin, FreeRDP, ...
- forgotpwd16 7y agoThis is commercial and there are no features mentioned to prefer it over the excellent VcXsrv.
- en4bz 7y agoVcXsrv doesn't work well with HDPI scaling which this claims to support out of the box.