13 ms·
Bosch develops rapid test for Covid-19
- kplex 7y agoAm I missing something here or does this look rather over-engineered and with limited capacity - 10 tests per device per day - I assume the device is the large central unit.
- Zealotux 7y agoIt all sounds impressive to me: >In various laboratory tests with SARS-CoV-2, the Bosch test delivered results with an accuracy of over 95 percent. I've read a lot of report on the current tests for SARS-CoV-2 having accuracy issues, does anyone know how 95% accuracy compares to the current methods?
- sheldonf 7y agoPracticing hospital physician here. We never use the term "accuracy" to describe diagnostic tests, and whenever I see that term used, I'm very suspicious of the claim being made. In other words, this Bosch announcement can probably be ignored. We use the terms "sensitivity" and "specificity" to describe diagnostic test performance, and never to my knowledge talk about a test's "accuracy." Usually accuracy refers to the sensitivity, but there's a lot of liberty taken with that term in marketing talk. For example, the existing PCR test being used does not have ideal sensitivity, which for practical purposes means that there is a substantial false-negative rate. Which is why (among other reasons) we weren't testing asymptomatic patients in the early phase.
- thinkharderdev 7y agoSo would sensitivity be the percentage of infected people who test positive and specificity be the percentage of non-infected who test negative (i.e. sensitivity = (1 - false negative probability) and specificity = (1 - false positive probability))?
- mehrdadn 7y agoYes. The intuitive way I try to remember it is to think that, in just plain English, "How sensitive is this thing?" means "How likely is it to detect whatever it's supposed to detect?" (e.g.: How likely is this security camera to detect movement?)
- fit2rule 7y ago"Sensitivity" is an inaccurate term, since for non-native English speakers, it could be misinterpreted as a term to mean some kind of emotional response. "Accuracy" is a bit more scientific- leaning and therefore easier to translate. Remember, COVID-19 is a global phenomenon, its not just relegated to the Anglo-sphere. Bosch, being a German company, is probably a bit sensitive to the accuracy of translations that will be needed to market this thing effectively around the world .. ;)
- mehrdadn 7y ago> Remember, COVID-19 is a global phenomenon, its not just relegated to the Anglo-sphere. Bosch, being a German company, is probably a bit sensitive to the accuracy of translations that will be needed to market this thing effectively around the world .. ;) ...what? I was only trying to help the parent find a way to remember which one is sensitivity and which one is specificity...
- fit2rule 7y agoYes, and you perfectly demonstrated the confusion possible by selecting the wrong terms. Sure, 'specificity' and 'sensitivity' are scientific terms - but for marketing material, can be confused with emotional responses. Thus, I believe Bosch chose 'accuracy', since this translates into other languages more effectively.
- gridlockd 7y agoIn my recollection, previously announced "quick tests" had only a 70% accuracy.
- s9w 7y agoDepending on what exactly that 95% number is, that could be incredibly bad. There is some eye-opening math about testing inaccuracies combined with low case numbers.
- prox 7y agoIt’s good to see solutions for testing are coming. This test by Singapore a*star nanobiolab can test in 5 minutes : https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/singapore-scientists-on-the-front-lines-of-fight-against-covid-19 https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/singapore-scie...
- danieldk 7y agoBesides comparing times, I guess the accuracies or FP/FN rates are also important. The linked article states 95% accuracy for the Bosch test. Are there any numbers for the 5-minute test?
- prox 7y agoIt only states high sensitivity and accuracy, you might find actual data on the a*star nanobiolab website.
- blompa 7y agoThis article [0] suggests that false negative results will not be as problematic if we manage to start screening on a population level. Inaccuracy of up to 15% could still keep the viral R0 under 1.0 (the critical value for eliminating an epidemic). From the article: > "False negative rates up to 15% could be tolerated if 80% comply with testing, and false positives can be almost arbitrarily high when a high fraction of the population is already effectively quarantined" https://medium.com/@sten.linnarsson/to-stop-covid-19-test-everyone-373fd80eb03b https://medium.com/@sten.linnarsson/to-stop-covid-19-test-ev...
- dx034 7y agoShouldn't we optimize for a higher number of false positives? In the end, sending someone in quarantine for 2 weeks without them being infected is probably less dangerous than a false negative. So making tests overly sensitive would seem more applicable to me here.
- adventured 7y ago
- buboard 7y agomy guess is that in the coming months, international travel will require a mandatory 3 hour wait at the airport to get your test result
- ginko 7y ago> Up to 1,000 tests per day on just 100 devices So.. 10 tests per day per device? That doesn't sound THAT impressive.
- lmedinas 7y ago"(...)the rapid test can detect a SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus infection in patients in under two and a half hours" (...)With the tests currently in use, patients must usually wait one to two days for a result." Well i see here a big improvement...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blompa 7y agoThe thing is though, the current PCR-based tests can be parallelised, with hundreds being run at the same time, taking just a couple of hours. The biggest waiting time comes from logistics with transportation to the labs, which is where the Bosch test is advantageous.
- PierceJoy 7y ago> With the tests currently in use, patients must usually wait one to two days for a result. Is that because it takes 2 days for the test to complete, or because there a 2 day delay from backlog + administrative time?
- PunchTornado 7y agousually shipping the samples to a lab. this test can be done on the spot in the hospital by a doctor.
- guillem_lefait 7y ago"under two and a half hours" per test. To be able to make 10 tests per day, you'll probably can't have any delay between tests : 1 day = 10 x (2 hours + 24minutes). If accuracy is an issue, why not doing a two pass procedure ? 1) test quick and cheap 2) if results have low confidence, move to longer/more reliable testing method
- blackbear_ 7y agoMore details on coronavirus testing for the interested: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41587-020-00010-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41587-020-00010-2
- ThePhysicist 7y agoSounds really impressive, but writing "1,000 tests per day with just 100 devivces" is really marketing BS I think. They should've just written "10 tests per day per device".
- gpderetta 7y agoDon't current testing machines have much, much higher throughput? Like in the thousands of tests per day? It seems the advantage of this new device is latency. Of course if they are cheap enough and easy to use that you can buy thousands of them and distribute to all hospitals then might also increase total throughput.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoIt’s a really small device as far as I understand, so you could use it in a small practice or even on the go (?). This can be an advantage as most of the lab systems weigh several tons and take up a lot of floor space, hence you can never use them in a decentralized setting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 7y agoThe intersection between moneyedness and remoteness. The more I think about it the more I suspect that the pilot market for this class of device would be the sick bay of a yacht that has its own Wikipedia page. Which is fine, but surely nothing that will have a meaningful impact on our general understanding of the epidemic.
- fabian2k 7y agohttps://www.bosch-vivalytic.com/en/product/vivalytic-tests/vri-multiplex-test/ https://www.bosch-vivalytic.com/en/product/vivalytic-tests/v... That describes how this particular test works. It's a small device with self-contained cartridges, so it's designed to be used outside a lab and doesn't require experts to operate. But as far as I can see, it only processes a single sample at a time. A typical PCR setup in the lab can handle 96 reactions at a time, though you also need controls there which I assume are built in the cartridge in some way in this test. And then there are the big automated systems. I think the benefit of this device here is only present if you already have one, it's not a way to seriously scale up testing as a whole unless these devices are very widely used already.
- numlock86 7y ago> Up to 10,000,000 tests per day ... > ... on just 1,000,000 devices Incredible marketing.
- moooo99 7y agoGiven the size of hospitals around the world, I'd assume its not unlikely that they'll buy 100+ of these devices. I agee that this is somewhat confusing, but it doesn't seem too unrealistic. Also, it seems like the actual test is the cartridge which is inserted into an existing device. So the device is probably already in use in some places and can get this extra test capability by just inserting the cartridge.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- khjklehti 7y agoHow expensive is this machine? $1k, $10k?
- pauljurczak 7y agoCertainly not $1K! BTW, at current U.S. hospital billing levels, $1K buys you a small bottle of Tylenol. Think big, my friend!
- dna_polymerase 7y agoSorry, German source only, but reportedly: Device is 15.000€ and a single cartridge runs between 50 and 100€ [0]. [0]: https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/industrie/pandemie-testergebnisse-in-wenigen-stunden-bosch-entwickelt-covid-19-schnelltest/25684166.html?ticket=ST-834594-shOtHKhshHHLKSqkcg1U-ap1 https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/industrie/pandemie-...
- pauljurczak 7y agoThat makes sense. There seems to be a better option available in the U.S.: Abbott ID NOW, which produces results in 5 to 13 minutes. The cost was $8K before the acquisition of Alere by Abbott: https://serfinitymedical.com/products/id-now-instrument-us-alere-nat024-928584 https://serfinitymedical.com/products/id-now-instrument-us-a...
- llarsson 7y agoWith announcements of this type of thing, what I think we all need to know is also "can you produce tons of these things right now", not just that they exist.
- GrumpyNl 7y agoMore important question is, do we trust them?
- JanSt 7y agoBosch is a huge company (400.000 employees). Don't drive your car if you don't trust them.
- bakuninsbart 7y agoThey are also owned by a charitable foundation whose express goal is the long-term welfare of the company and its employees, so they have much less pressure to extract short-term value.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mhh__ 7y agoMaking a fraudulent test now seems like a wonderful way to simultaneously piss off politicians (i.e. They'd be looking for sympathy points by reacting harshly) and literally decimating your market cap.
- buboard 7y agoMore details about the test: https://www.bosch-vivalytic.com/en/product/vivalytic-tests/vri-multiplex-test/ https://www.bosch-vivalytic.com/en/product/vivalytic-tests/v...
- stickac 7y agoHow is this better than Open qPCR which is 3-times less expensive and can give a test result in 1 hour instead of 2.5 hours?
- fizixer 7y agoDoes 'Open' mean open source? Is there a free/open-source PCR design that DIYers can build themselves as long as they have the parts/resources?
- stickac 7y agoFor OpenPCR yes, for Open qPRC not.
- lamchob 7y agoThis is just another test cardridge available for the existing on-site lab machine. The idea is that health-practitioners with access to the device can now test on premise, instead of sending samples to the lab. I can't image a lot local doctors have access to qPCR, where this device is useful for all kinds of other test.
- rubidium 7y agoIt’s helpful in this time to think of the total cost. If you have equipment already deployed where needed and people already trained that helps! We really need a whole suite of tests and so the more the merrier. Doctors and healthcare systems will need to figure out what works best for their needs.
- fbn79 7y agoIs not ROCHE systems more performants https://www.roche.com/media/releases/med-cor-2020-03-13.htm https://www.roche.com/media/releases/med-cor-2020-03-13.htm ?
- sah2ed 7y agoFrom your link: ”The widely available Roche’s cobas 6800/8800 Systems, which are used to perform the cobas SARS-CoV-2 Test, provide test results in three and half hours and offer improved operating efficiency, flexibility, and fastest time-to-results with the highest throughput providing up to 96 results in about three hours and a total of 384 results for the cobas 6800 System and 960 results for the cobas 8800 System in 8 hours. The test can be run simultaneously with other assays provided by Roche for use on the cobas 6800/8800 Systems.”
- catwell 7y agoThis is fine, but it is yet another molecular test. What we need now are serology tests. They are faster, cheaper, easier to execute (blood-based), can detect cured patients, and can scale to the population of a country. Serology tests are already used in several countries in Asia, I have little doubt they will arrive in Europe and the US soon-ish.
- mk89 7y agoIn Italy they claim to have developed such a test which is based on blood and takes only 15 minutes. https://www.vivachek.com/vivachek/English/prods/prod-covid19.html https://www.vivachek.com/vivachek/English/prods/prod-covid19...
- zajio1am 7y agoWe already have serology tests in Czechia (got several days ago from China), but there is some confusion about how useful they are. They may produce negative results even for patients with several days of clinical symptoms, so negative results still needs to ve verified with molecular test.
- shultays 7y agoUp to 1,000 (in smaller font) tests per day on just 100 devices I guess 10 test per day per device is not as cool
- TrickyRick 7y agoIf the tests take 2.5 hours and given that there is no parallellism it's pretty basic maths to figure out that 1 device can do about 10 tests per day.
- pixiemaster 7y agoi think it’s for the time after the pandemic. so you can identity potential infected very decentralized, so it does not happen again in 2021.
- oaiey 7y agothat is the right angle I guess. This should be a local doctor device.
- mlrtime 7y agoThat depends on how small and inexpensive the device is. For arguments sake if it is the size (looks like it) and price of a small computer than you can put one anywhere and scale it massively.
- rurban 7y agoThis is not rapid, only 10 tests/day, whilst the current overly slow sequencers can do 200/day. The accuracy of 5% is also worse than other faster sequencers of 3%. And compare that to modern ThermalFischer parallel PCR sequencers, which operate in realtime, 25 tests in parallel, for 2.500€. That's a factor of 1000. With 10 modern sequencers per city you could test 10.000 per day, eg with drive-in. https://www.thermofisher.com/de/de/home/clinical/clinical-translational-research/pharmacogenomics/real-time-pcr-solutions-pharmacogenomics.html https://www.thermofisher.com/de/de/home/clinical/clinical-tr...
- rsynnott 7y agoThis is low throughput but high speed; there's a use-case for that.
- tomcooks 7y agoIsn't that the same thing?
- endymi0n 7y agoHe means low throughput and low latency, both of which are related to a concept of speed, but not the same. > Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of tapes hurtling down the highway. — Andrew S. Tanenbaum
- fhars 7y agoNo, this is faster than e.g. the Roche tests mentioned here last week, it will give you the first test result after two and a half hours, while the Roche one will take three and a half hours to give you the first result. So it is faster. But it will give you the second test result after five hours, while the Roche machine will give you the second result after three and a half hours, too. As well as the third, the fourth, and the fifth. Oh, and the onehundredandninetysecond one, too. In the 24 hours the Bosch machine produces ten results, the Roche one will produce more than fourthousand results.
- arrrg 7y ago
- incompatible 7y agoVarious groups are also using the LAMP method (Loop-mediated isothermal amplification) which can apparently give results in 30 minutes or so without expensive thermal cycling equipment. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Loop-mediated+isothermal+amplification+covid-19 https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Loop-mediated+isothermal+amplifica... Bonus article with biohackers in Sydney: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-25/amateur-scientist-making-a-rapid-test-for-coronavirus/12084974 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-25/amateur-scientist-mak...
- dmix 7y agoThis one claims 30 minutes for results for the standard product being repurposed by Bosch here as well.
- nabla9 7y ago1000 tests per day sounds like what typical hospital needs. I wonder how much 100 Vivalytic devices cost and how much those cartridges cost. Can they mix multiple samples into one test? If you take sample from 10 people, mix them to find that nobody is infected, it increases testing capability 10X.
- gmueckl 7y agoSo the test depends on single use cartridges. How many of those can be manufactured? The testing devices themselves seem to be around 15.000 Euros. So you'd have to have a very good reason to buy one - a reason that isn't throughput.
- 6510 7y agoHere is a dumb idea: Mix and test multiple people at the same time.
- donarb 7y agoThat's already being done in some places that have limited numbers of tests. The governor of Nebraska announced that they are pooling tests to save on test kits. Samples from 5 people are combined in 1 test. If the sample tests negative, those people are in the clear. If the sample tests positive, all 5 are then tested again separately.
- shd4 7y agoWell, good for them. Wait. 10 tests per day? That's nothing.
- jphenningsen 7y agoThis test is made for use at the point of care, apparently all the operater has to do is insert a swab into a cartridge and put it into the device. [0] Comparing the throughput to fully automated systems used in testing labs [1] (look at this beast!) or qPCR machines in research labs [2] is missing the point, those require high investment or skilled staff. A test that can be run quickly by any doctor would be very useful to rapidly detect new outbreaks in the time following the current lockdowns. However I suspect that the downside of this device will be the high cost of consumables, as is common for microarray biochip based devices. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgW2pYmzcco https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgW2pYmzcco [1] https://diagnostics.roche.com/us/en/products/systems/cobas-8800-system.html https://diagnostics.roche.com/us/en/products/systems/cobas-8... [2] https://www.bio-rad.com/en-us/product/cfx96-touch-real-time-pcr-detection-system?ID=LJB1YU15 https://www.bio-rad.com/en-us/product/cfx96-touch-real-time-...
- smiley1437 7y agoIt's like a Keurig single serve coffee machine but for covid-19 testing
- ksk 7y agoYeah, consumables cost is always the bug-bear for single use tech. Also, the cost of disposal/incineration can balloon up significantly.
- jackallis 7y agothis whole every-day news about rapid test dev, etc is getting frustrating. My SO is an MD in NY. All they want to hear from any company is, we have developed method that can be used to test 10k/day with results in 1 hr and will be mass producing and provding in two days.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoI'm seeing a lot of grumbling here about this being "slow", but currently most COVID testing involves shipping samples around to remote labs. A NYT article about a hospital in Brooklyn mentioned that their samples are tested in California (!), and with these labs also inundated, average time to get a result is over a week now. So if you can install these machines directly in hospitals, clinics etc, they will still be far faster than sending them off to a lab.
- mikeiz404 7y ago>In various laboratory tests with SARS-CoV-2, the Bosch test delivered results with an accuracy of over 95 percent. Curious what the false negative rate is. >[The device] can perform up to ten tests in the space of 24 hours >[Testing] can be performed directly at the point of care. This eliminates the need to transport samples, which takes up valuable time. ... With the tests currently in use, patients must usually wait one to two days for a result >... even medical personnel who have not been specially trained on it can reliably perform the test. >... it allows a single sample to be tested not just for COVID-19 but also for nine other respiratory diseases, including influenza A and B, simultaneously
- tibbydudeza 7y agoImagine how much Theranos would have been worth right now. I think cost firstly and then speed of result would be useful right now never mind the throughput.
- jacquesm 7y agoTheranos would be worth exactly $0 - their long term liabilities. You need stuff that works first.
- endorphone 7y agoAs an aside question: after each use is that entire cartridge assembly waste?
- superzamp 7y ago> Faster certainty, slower spread At this point, isn't the virus considered to be "everywhere" and testing pointless?
- StevePerkins 7y agoI honestly don't even understand what I'm reading anymore. Either on HN and Reddit, or sites like the BBC, NY Times, and CNN. Half the things I read still reflect fantasies of Asian-style containment in the West. The other half acknowledge that this is too late. That we're heading up an exponential curve now, and will be on the other side in 3-6 months (depending on measures taken). I'm no expert. But knowing what I know about my nation's government, and the likelihood of its people fully cooperating with any measures, I suspect that the second half is more realistic. Meaning that testing and contact tracing is really only going to become relevant later this year. To snuff out any minor flare-ups that occur after most of society has gotten over the curve and built up herd immunity.
- sharathr 7y agoCepheid has started shipping tests that produce results in under 45 minutes. https://www.labpulse.com/index.aspx?sec=sup&sub=mic&pag=dis&ItemID=800942 https://www.labpulse.com/index.aspx?sec=sup&sub=mic&pag=dis&...
- ck2 7y agoHas anyone made a resource yet of all the infection tests available vs antibody (immunity) tests available? Seems like that would be handy if not just fascinating
- anonsubmit2671 7y agoThere's already a 45-minute rtPCR test from Cepheid and a simple 10 minute ELISA test from SureScreen (which serves a different need, antibody detection rather than infection detection). It doesn't appear to have an FDA EUA so it may not be immediately usable in the US. The user-friendly UX and compact size seem good. The cycle time seems to be on the slow side when minutes count in an ER / ICU situation. ~9 tests per day per machine seems slow, costly and likely to occupy a lot of space for the machines and the cartridges (which contain reagents that have to be kept chilled). This seems overall like a timely product to solve immediate needs. It could've been better but it was designed quickly.