9 ms·
Turns out claims Airbnb was taking houses out of the rental market were right
- jgwil2 7y agoWas this ever seriously debated? As far as I know the only question ever was the size of the effect, not whether there was any effect at all.
- claudeganon 7y agoGo read any of the old HN threads on AirBNB. Saying this had these kind of effects was decried as “hotel industry propaganda.”
- omnimus 7y agoI've never seen "hotel industry propaganda" but the effects on market were debated and often very doubted. Now it seems there is evidence.
- smabie 7y agoI mean unless the houses were going to sit empty otherwise, then of course there would be an affect. Not really sure what the article is trying to say.
- umeshunni 7y agoIt's not an article. It's a tweet by some rando who just learned about demand and supply.
- cardiffspaceman 7y agoIt's tweets about a report, not just some data-free rant. https://www.daft.ie/blog/the-covid-19-crisis-is-already-affecting-the-irish-rental-market/ https://www.daft.ie/blog/the-covid-19-crisis-is-already-affe...
- joejohnson 7y agoGood to see hard data supporting this, but this was always obviously the case. Only reason there was even a conversation was because Airbnb lobbied and placed ads in specific markets to mislead renters about their economic impact.
- hocuspocus 7y agoI honestly don't understand why European cities don't go nuclear against AirBnB. There's so much money to be made in fines and instant political approval from virtually every tenant.
- smabie 7y agoI mean, just stay one day at the airbnb and then negotiate with the landlord for a month or two. I've done this multiple times and gotten very good prices. So It's not like airbnb properties are deadweight, they can (and do) get converted to medium or long-term rentals all the time.
- hocuspocus 7y agoIf you're a resident looking for a proper long-term lease, this is just not how things work.
- smabie 7y agoI think you would be surprised. Millions of undocumented immigrants (and a lot of citizens as well) in the US do this all the time, for years and years.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 7y agoIf Airbnb operators bid higher than long-term renters, why shouldn't they get the apartments? This animus against Airbnb seems irrational to me. Property should go to its most productive use, and the most productive use is the one for which someone is willing to pay the most money.
- harimau777 7y agoI don't think that how much someone is willing to pay is a good way to measure what something's most productive use is. For one thing, it fails to account for the degree to which people have differences in what they are able to pay.
- quotemstr 7y agoWe use prices to ration access to scarce resources. What's the alternative? A command economy. Tons of historical experiments show that it doesn't work. And why shouldn't ability to pay affect the ability to access resources? What would be the point of money otherwise? How do you know that the most productive user a resource is something other than the highest bidder? On what basis can you make that determination? Prices are universal.
- harimau777 7y agoI don't think that we can perfectly know what the best use of a resource is. However, I think that we can often perform better than price does. For example, it would generally be better to allocate a unit of food to people who are starving than to people who already have excess food. Note that in some cases that won't be the optimal way to distribute the food. For example perhaps the starving person is actively hurting society while the person with excess food wanted to use the food to perform research that promotes greater food production in the future. However, taken as a whole, allocating at least some food based on need is going to perform better than allocating all food based on price.
- jacquesm 7y agoBecause people being born in some place need somewhere to live without being displaced by hordes of locusts looking to see the sights.
- tempsy 7y agoIt always bothered me how Airbnb never addressed its impact on the residential housing market. Between the safety issues, Covid, stories on scams, and the greater awareness around its impact on housing I hope local governments really start regulating them more.
- jacquesm 7y agoDid anybody even doubt this? In cities like Amsterdam, Barcelona and Berlin this was blatantly obvious.
- ahupp 7y agoNote that 64% of new listings is very different than 64% of all properties. e.g, last I looked 1.5% of SF properties were on AirBnB (down from 3% before the recent regulations), though unclear what fraction were available for rent full-time. So at least in SF I don't think removing AirBnB would really change supply in a meaningful way.
- as-j 7y agoIt would make a big difference to me. :) But it would not change supply. I have an airbnb off my garage. It's a granny flat, a bed, a small bathroom and a kitchenette. A sink, but just a hot plate a fridge and no oven. It's not somewhere you'd want to live for a long time, in my opinion. But it's a great place to crash for a few days, have a cold breakfast, some oatmeal, reheat left overs, etc. There's people like me who it helps live in SF and offset property taxes, price of the house, etc. Bad actors/bad markets/etc certainly do exist, but like all things it's complicated.
- claudeganon 7y agoIt’s not really though. SF has a housing crisis. We would all be better off if an unhoused person was living there or someone with lower paid but necessary job (e.g. caretaker at a nursing home). Making money off people on vacations is worse than providing stable housing for people in the city.
- as-j 7y agoThe city prohibits from being rented long term since it lacks a full kitchen. The SF rules are, I could not airbnb if I could rent it long term.
- claudeganon 7y agoIs this still true under the all statewide ADU legislation that came into effect this year? https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesfinancecouncil/2020/03/12/californias-new-accessory-dwelling-units-laws-what-you-should-know/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesfinancecouncil/2020/03/12...
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoIf we restricted the manufacturing of cars, soon there would be articles about how car rental services are taking cars out of the car market.
- burkaman 7y agoYes? What's your point?
- lend000 7y agoInstead of worrying about how people choose to rent their properties, they should instead look to the source of high rental prices, which is bad zoning laws and insufficient total units. Meanwhile Airbnb creates a level of convenience and affordability that makes travel accessible to the masses. I'm sure the software engineers down-voting wouldn't be significantly affected if Airbnb was forced out of operation. Just another version of NIMBYism.
- brlewis 7y agoI've been summarizing the debate here, and so far yours is the comment that contributes most to the top level: https://en.howtruthful.com/o/airbnb_should_be_regulated_because_of_its_effect_on_rental_housing_supply/5e61ead6b1bab9f609bf93908f6a6aff https://en.howtruthful.com/o/airbnb_should_be_regulated_beca...
- mumblemumble 7y agoAt least based on the prices I've seen when considering my options, the big potential for savings with airbnb is if you choose to take advantage of the kitchen, so that you're not paying to eat out for every meal. But, if affordability really is your top goal, you'll do even better if you go with a hotel that offers kitchenette suites. In my experience, they typically offer a lower nightly fee than having an airbnb to yourself (especially if you are staying at least a week and don't require someone else to come make your bed for you ever day), and still let you save on meal costs. (Airbnbing a room out of someone's house is even less expensive, but I don't think that style of airbnb rental is really the subject of much controversy.)
- dehrmann 7y agoThis doesn't prove it at all. There's an increase in available hotel rooms, too. That doesn't mean there aren't Airbnbs that would otherwise be longer-term rentals. Of course there are, the logic is just bad. This also doesn't necessarily mean rentals used for Airbnbs are inherently "bad," either. It's complicated.
- Jommi 7y agoYeah, lots of people have been forced to prematurely leave to go back to their home country.
- cletus 7y agoCan we change the submitted post? I didn't see any sources quoted on that Tweet, just an animation. Side note: please stop submitting or otherwise citing "Twitter threads". They're terrible. But there does seem to be some basis for this eg [1] [2]. And I can believe it. I've long since held the opinion that Airbnb is a cancer on society. While Uber allows you to get value from a vehicle you may already own (at the cost of wear and tear, mind you) and there are many, particularly those in the US, who seem to hold this view that "it's my home, I can do what I want with it", the reality is that neighbours of that Airbnb bear the externalities and the cost of your listing and it's not easy for most people to up and move. Another way of putting this is that it is a tragedy of the commons as Airbnb "hosts" extract value from a community that bears the cost with little choice in the matter. This lazy (and typically selfish) twisted version of "free market" thinking quickly erodes when, for example, I propose using my house that's next to yours as a tannery or a toxic waste storage site. My only complaint about jurisdictions trying to crack down on this is that their efforts have been too slow and anaemic. NYC is plagued with what are essentially illegal hotels. There are a reason that hotels exist in the current form and place. It's for the safety of guests (eg compliance with fire codes) and the benefit of residents (ie zoning). [1]: https://www.independent.ie/world-news/coronavirus/homes-for-rent-climb-as-airbnb-market-tumbles-39063281.html https://www.independent.ie/world-news/coronavirus/homes-for-... [2]: https://www.balls.ie/the-rewind-news/something-interesting-happening-dublin-rental-market-428463 https://www.balls.ie/the-rewind-news/something-interesting-h...
- tdhz77 7y agoGet off my lawn!
- secondbreakfast 7y agoThere are negative externalities to Uber too, such as Traffic and pollution.
- koolba 7y agoThat’s not so clear cut. The alternative to Uber is not just staying home or riding a bike, at times it’s driving your own car and circling for 30 minutes trying to find a parking spot.
- poulsbohemian 7y agoI live in a place with a lot of tourists and second homes. AirBnB was beginning to reduce the lack of supply in the local hotel market, which caused the hotels to petition the city council to put an end to non-owner occupied short-term housing. This was done under the guise of improving the (admittedly) tight rental market. The problem is, the following things happened as a result: -- Existing short-term rental properties were grandfathered, which artificially has made those properties more valuable. -- A lot of properties that might have previously been purchased and renovated by investors sit idle because the investors can't turn them into short-term rentals. -- We have a lot of cottages / really small properties here, that are good short-term rentals but not great regular rentals. so basically a lot of garbage rentals came available that did nothing to actually help our rental market. -- The hotels knew they now had a more captive market than previously. So while I appreciate the sentiments of those who wanted to end short-terms rentals in the name of affordable housing, at least in our local market it has not been a good thing.
- llukas 7y agoGood for the owners to be precise.
- gamblor956 7y ago* A lot of properties that might have previously been purchased and renovated by investors sit idle because the investors can't turn them into short-term rentals.* This is a good thing. Because it means that the properties can be occupied by people actually living there. We have a lot of cottages / really small properties here, that are good short-term rentals but not great regular rentals. so basically a lot of garbage rentals came available that did nothing to actually help our rental market. Cottages are great rentals. They may not fit your needs, but in large cities, there will definitely be thousands or hundreds of people for who cottages are the perfect fit. Most of what you describe is actually good for the rental market for the people actually living and working in the community. The hotels knew they now had a more captive market than previously. Hotels cannot "capture" the market. They are dependent on tourists coming in to the town, and that means that other parts of the town must provide a reason to visit. Right now, hotels are bleeding money.
- gjs278 7y agogood. airbnb hosts are scum. they buy up all the houses and then rent them out. I hope they all go under. no bailouts for landlords like this.
- rsynnott 7y agoAn important caveat here is that it’s from a low base; Dublin has a massive property crisis and there are typically very few rentals on the market.
- seisvelas 7y agoGood. Rentals charge 2 months rent and a deposit. The only reason I can afford housing is because of airbnb. It's the only place I can find housing that doesn't do that BS. That's here in Merida, at least. I wish the rental market would crumble. It's absurdly difficult for a normal person to rent a decent dwelling. The hostel I rent at is full of people in a similar situation. The more conventional rentals get replaced with airbnb's that allow monthly stays, the better. The supposed legal protections of conventional renting don't exist, and airbnb is actually a better enforcer of agreements than my government.
- culturestate 7y ago> Rentals charge 2 months rent and a deposit. The only reason I can afford housing is because of airbnb There are some interesting models around the world for alleviating this specific burden that don't involve corporations being everyone's landlord. My favorite is one I learned about relatively recently: rental deposit guarantees[1] in Switzerland. The renter pays a small premium to e.g. Swiss Post, which will issue a certificate guaranteeing the amount of the deposit. The landlord accepts that certificate in lieu of cash. 1. https://www.post.ch/en/locations/rental-deposit-guarantee https://www.post.ch/en/locations/rental-deposit-guarantee
- koolba 7y ago> Good. Rentals charge 2 months rent and a deposit. The only reason I can afford housing is because of airbnb. It's the only place I can find housing that doesn't do that BS. Security deposits and upfront rent address the problem of deadbeat tenants who may destroy the property or simply not pay the rent. It’s skin in the game to show you’re responsible.
- seisvelas 7y agoUpfront rent is totally fine, Airbnb itself charges upfront. But 3 upfront rents? Ive never gotten a deposit or the extra rent back at the end. Airbnb isnt a real solution but i dont think landlords ever were either
- 7y ago
- ghouse 7y agoFirsthand experience: My family was evicted from a two unit home in SF. We lived in one unit, the owner in the other unit. One unit is now listed on Airbnb.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoIANAL. What grounds did the landlord use to evict you? How long between you guys leaving and the Airbnb business starting. Did you receive any and all relocation payments required by law, and has the landlord continued to file the required annual paperwork with SFRB? If the eviction reason was either 'owner move-in' or 'relative move-in' then, if the landlord subsequently decided to rent out the unit again with the next few years, they are required by law to first offer the unit to you at the original rent. If you decline, they can rent to someone else, but again only at the original rent (plus the city-mandated max annual increase %). (And, no, the landlord can't get around this by airbnb'ing the other unit, and moving in to your unit.) I'm less familiar with Ellis Act evictions, but my understanding is that these also prevent the landlord from re-renting the property for a significant period of time.
- wolco 7y agoAnyone think Airbnb will take a hit after people become more concerned with covid? Creating a less travel friendly society and if they have to travel for business they will demand a properly cleaned hotel room?
- jzl 7y agoTake a hit after? Heck, let's talk about right this second. It's already happening: https://www.wsj.com/articles/airbnb-racks-up-hundreds-of-millions-in-losses-due-to-coronavirus-11584723498 https://www.wsj.com/articles/airbnb-racks-up-hundreds-of-mil... Paywall, but even just the headline and first paragraph tell you what you need to know. And yeah, I don't see how this doesn't completely decimate their business model. The likely coming worldwide recession will see far less spending on travel, not even counting residual behavioral changes re: covid as you mention. UPDATE: Non-paywalled article: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/airbnb-mulls-cash-infusion-investors-145507408.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/airbnb-mulls-cash-infusion-in...
- blackrock 7y agoI’m rather torn about the Airbnb model. One, hotels charge way too much money. When a hotel room costs $300 to $500 per night, then this will quickly burn your travel budget. Two, Airbnb hosts are often, rather dishonest with their listings. But, Airbnb is the only way to rent someone’s house in a distant location, where your family and extended family can stay together to get away. It’s impossible to do this with a hotel, and very expensive too. Initially, some people got enterprising, and rented out their homes to help pay their mortgages. And they charged a modest fee for it. For a while, this seemed ok, as you were helping out someone to pay off their expensive mortgage. Like, Yeah! Stick it to the rich bankers, and all the jackasses that contribute to expensive housing. But then, soon others, turned it into a hotel operation, where investors would team up to buy houses and apartments, only to rent it out on Airbnb. And when this happened, everyone else started doing it, and so the initial Airbnb business model was no longer socially or morally acceptable. You and I, as an individual, cannot compete against a team of 5 investors that buys the property outright. Our individual goal, is to put down roots, build a family, and contribute to the community so our children can have a stable place to live. Their goal, is to make a profit, and later flip the house for an even larger profit. For better or worse, maybe this coronavirus will destroy the Airbnb business model. Its initial thesis, is no longer socially acceptable.
- rahilb 7y agoBefore AirBnB, you just had BnBs. In England at least they were often farmhouses, and the owner literally makes you breakfast if you were staying in their main house (this was a large part of it). I’m not sure what if any regulation applies if you are a BnB like that. In fact, it’s such a part of British culture, there is a game show where 5 BnB owners stay at each other’s places and see who is ranked best. The show airs every week. AirBNB are parasites.
- pas 7y agoIt's not AirBnB. It's again society kicking down. Many more people now travel and use AirBnB, because it made travel cheaper. The downside is that housing got even more complicated. However, building new supply is very much demand driven. And AirBnB pushed up demand, which lead to more units built. (Probably some hotels were not built, etc.) This "parasite" thinking is just impotent rage. The real problem is the lack of housing supply. City dwellers are rather resistant to change. Development is noisy, draws more traffic, casts a shadow, etc. Yet most of them are also renters. It's the classic participation asymmetry. The vocal minority trumps the silent majority.
- torgian 7y agoI’ve always stayed at Airbnb’s for my short term stays, simply because they were cheaper than hotels. Hotels cost so much for a place that doesn’t even have a hot plate.
- PeterStuer 7y agoIf anything good comes of this crisis I hope it is the dismissal of the 'gig' economy's nefarious cancerous business-models that rely on regulation dodging, negative externality dumping and worker exploitation. If we have to reboot the economy, let's get rid of the vilest anarcho-capitalist and environmental destructive cruft we have allowed to fester over the years.
- ornornor 7y agoTo be fair, only Airbnb and Airbnb landlords were thinking that Airbnb didn’t hurt the local rental market. The rest of us knew.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoTo be fair, it started out more like paid couch surfing and then pivoted. The original idea was sharing your home part-time, not dedicating a private residence to short term rental use, which is what it has mostly become. This is probably not where the founders really meant for it to go.
- averros 7y agoTurns out people who want to tell others what to do with their own property are as common as dirt.
- omnimus 7y agoMarket in Prague has been flooded with new cheap offers. The catch - It is always just for maximum 6 months. I doubt this will change anything longterm unless it becomes proof for policy makers to ban airbnb.
- Bombthecat 7y agoOn a side note : airbnb must be really happy to have all the profit, but no risk right now.
- Udik 7y agoAs someone observed in the Twitter thread, +64% only means a handful (about 150) new flats on the market, since there's so few at the moment. They are now on offer for long term rental, so once they'll be taken they'll be out of the market possibly for years. This is why comparing long term rentals and airbnb makes little sense: yes, half of the flats for rent at any given moment are for short term. But they're always the same ones, over and over again. They could increase the long term offer only for a few days before disappearing for good.