15 ms·
Car purchase includes a huge amount of 'non rational actor' decision making. I like old jaguars. Walnut burr, doors that go "thunk" -in every sense (fuel econom
by ggm 7y ago
Car purchase includes a huge amount of 'non rational actor' decision making. I like old jaguars. Walnut burr, doors that go "thunk" -in every sense (fuel economy, NCAP, reliability) they are irrational purchase: I still love them. And the Citroen DS19.
EVs are in a segment with high discretionary spend. Choices in discretionary spending are notoriously bound up in non-rational choices: I could invest in diamonds, or snort it as coke, or fly to the bahamas in a helicopter is totally different lifestyle choices to "I need to get to Walmart at 3am for diapers, and I cannot afford to pay for more than basic AirConditioning"
When EVs are in the segment of rational-decision bound purchases, when they are "boring" I will deem them to have succeeded.
As long as the competition is Fiskar, not VW, and Not the Ioniq, or other Japanese low-end EV, its not baked yet.
The low-end EV have to get about 50% more efficiency and drop price about 30%. There really is a sweet spot in most people's disposable income and on-road costs and range anxiety (also a highly irrational place btw) which is just around the corner:
under $20,000 in any local economy
over 300km range in real-life
chargeable for usable amounts (10%? 20%?) in under 15min
- imglorp 7y agoI think a lot of Tesla is simply that they're not the other guys. They're giving people what they want. The dinosaurs have been refusing to innovate in many areas, screwing customers with exploitive dealer networks, dragging their feet on features when it's demanded of them, or just plain making everything miserable about cars for decades. The dinosars deserve to get their ass handed to them until they wake up and serve customers.
- Areading314 7y agoDon't forget deliberately faking their emissions performance
- clouddrover 7y ago> The dinosars deserve to get their ass handed to them until they wake up and serve customers. Who are the dinosaurs? Volkswagen sells 10 million vehicles a year. Toyota sells 10 million vehicles a year. Are you claiming that Volkswagen and Toyota are somehow not serving customers? If they're not serving customers then why are they selling so many cars?
- scotty79 7y ago"dinosaurs" as in "old, fat, coldhearted, ugly lizards" not as in "extinct" It's not about the sales. It's about the brand.
- clouddrover 7y agoSo the brand's advertising has compromised rationality, which is of course the goal of all advertising. I don't see that it's useful being emotional about it. They're car companies selling cars. You're better off being realistic.
- jfim 7y agoCars are one of those markets where emotional marketing is more important to some fraction of the customer base. Some people just want a generic econobox that brings them from point A to B, and others are swayed by other things, such as leather seats, ads that show a single car driving by the ocean or in the mountains, fast acceleration, an appealing paint color, high tech looking HUDs, cup holders, moon roof, etc.
- hilbertseries 7y agoI don’t think traditional car manufacturers benefit from dealerships. That’s just some classic US regulatory capture, where car manufacturers can’t sell directly to the consumer to help protect the consumer. Because when you think of someone trying to protect you, you think a car salesman.
- risubramanian 7y agoEurope doesn't have the same franchise laws as the US, and they still use dealers.
- bonestamp2 7y agoExactly. I work in automotive and it's important to understand why traditional automakers have dealers and why Tesla doesn't. The first mass market Tesla (Model S) came to market in post app store world. By that I mean, not only is it possible but it's obvious that vehicles can and should be diagnosed and firmware should be updated over the air. The only reason they were able to throw away the dealer model is because they could collect analytics, perform diagnostics and firmware flashes over the air. Without this advancement, Tesla would need significantly more physical presence akin to dealerships (and in fact, they kind of are building a light showroom/repair network as they grow so the dealer model isn't all that crazy in some respects). Traditional automakers have been around since before OTA was possible or practical or anyone had even thought of it, so dealers were at least necessary at one point in time to perform these tasks. Now that it is possible, and many new vehicles even have wireless internet, very few traditional automakers actually perform remote diagnostics and even fewer update more than a couple ECUs (Electronic Control Units) over the air. There are a number of reasons for and against this, but at the end of the day they were forced into a situation where they needed dealers and for that reason they also have the luxury of offloading many of these tasks onto the dealers. This luxury is actually very important because a major OEM has hundreds of models of vehicles that they need to support. Tesla obviously has far fewer so they can afford to take on some of those diagnostic tasks and of course they have to because they don't have franchises with technicians in them. As for success, I believe Tesla is very successful for a variety of reasons (too many to list, but I'll mention some of the major ones): 1. They care about design. They're not the flashiest or most radical designs, but the designs are very thoughtful, tasteful, elegant and minimalistic -- all of these are qualities that are fashionable at the moment. 2. The cars are technology first... they come with a lot of useful technology that people want because it seems obvious to have these things in contemporary cars. Most other vehicles in the Model 3 price range are technology last -- the technology that seems obvious is a paid upgrade. 3. They are optimistic and progressive. Even when someone knows that some model 3s are built outside in a tent and there are mounting quality and repairability concerns, they don't care because they want to support the flier that just might make a difference in the world.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoAs far as I know Tesla is not so nice if you ever need parts to repair something. I agree that car dealership suck but I wouldn’t call Tesla the good guys.
- TwoBit 7y agoYou think Tesla is being mean or evil when they have a part supply problem? That seems to be what you are saying.
- muro 7y agoIf it takes so long, how about "incompetent"?
- p_l 7y agoWith other brands, you can source alternative parts and get by fine. With Tesla, a lot of the parts are still standard, but you can't replace it with same or better part that isn't sourced from Tesla supply. Even if it's the same part.
- tyfon 7y ago> With Tesla, a lot of the parts are still standard, but you can't replace it with same or better part that isn't sourced from Tesla supply. Even if it's the same part. What stops you from replacing standard parts? There are quite a few off-brand repair shops here in Norway for things like wipers, brake calipers, regular service etc.
- close04 7y agoKnowing someone in a Tesla authorized service partner I can confirm the practices are... not great. According to the agreement they signed to become an authorized partner and under the threat of withdrawing said authorization, they have quite a few limitations that make for longer wait times and more expensive repairs. For example they are not allowed to order extra parts for stock (they have to "tie" them to a car in service) and they are not allowed to use aftermarket replacement parts even if compatible. I am specifically referring to car parts, not consumables. So break pads yes, break calipers no. Light bulb yes, headlight no. For example you will not find aftermarket headlights for Tesla that you can install in an authorized shop, get warranty, and ideally not discover that the car already logged the use of an AM part. In this case most (all?) aftermarket headlights begin their life as an OEM part that gets modified and this pretty much bypasses the restrictions, technical or administrative. These restrictions may be lifted as Tesla becomes better at making cars and can dedicate resources to making more spare parts, and as they start to allow others to take a bite out of their profit by manufacturing compatible parts but we are not there yet.
- delfinom 7y ago> screwing customers with exploitive dealer networks Haha. My buddy just waited for Tesla to finish repairs on his Model 3 for 4 months and in the mean time had to have a rental. The reason? They couldn't acquire certain bolts. Give me "exploitative dealer networks" that can source parts properly to Tesla's outrageous incompetence of a service network.
- TwoBit 7y agoyour statement implies that these two things are mutually exclusive, but I'm pretty sure they are not.
- moooo99 7y ago> screwing customers with exploitive dealer networks, Not sure if Tesla's approach to that is more customer friendly. Their cars are basically iPhones on wheels, they are locked down to the same extent. iirc you cannot even get replacements for the most car parts. With traditional cars however, you can basically go everywhere and get your car fixed. No matter if it is a brand dealer or third party repair shop. edit: fixed typos
- fxtentacle 7y agoI think a big part of Tesla is plain old dishonesty, or American bragging, if you want to call it that way. Consumers want autonomous self-driving cars. So Tesla creates marketing videos and then calls their glorified lane assistance and distance keeping assistant an "autopilot". And now, Tesla buyers are frustrated that the software isn't ready yet, or dying due to bugs in said software. But Tesla gets to dodge legal responsibility by writing into the fine print of their EULA that the so-called "autopilot" isn't actually meant to be used like what autopilot means to most people. If anything, Tesla has amazing marketing.
- roenxi 7y ago> the so-called "autopilot" isn't actually meant to be used like what autopilot means to most people. Given that autopilot for cars doesn't and never has existed it is likely that it means different things to different people. When I'm driving a car, my function is pretty much a glorified lane assist. If it can do that for me then I'm sold on it being an autopilot. I don't need my car to actually be smarter than I am.
- fxtentacle 7y agoYou'd want the car to avoid mistaking reflective surfaces for tunnels. Or not seeing a truck turned sideways due to lack of AI training data. Plus your car should make it easy for you to do the right & safe thing. "The nation’s top safety investigator slammed Tesla on Tuesday for failing to take adequate measures to prevent “foreseeable abuse” of its Autopilot driver-assistance technology" https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-02-25/tesla-autopilot-crash-hearing https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2020-02-25/tesla-auto...
- roenxi 7y agoFor one that is changing the subject. For two; proving that a Tesla autopilot caused an accident and the regulators are grumpy isn't evidence of anything. Humans frequently have accidents and regulators are typically grumpy. And the evidence in that article is that the car is basically working on autopilot. So the brand name is quite reasonable. If you expect any transport system not to have accidents you are crazy - all modes of transport have accidents from time to time. Also; a tired point; but Tesla's autopilot is going to learn from each fatal accident. That is a massive difference from humans; who stop learning after fatal accidents. Fatal accidents are not going to be a major long-term problem here which stands in sharp contrast to human drivers. It isn't a particularly bad sign as it means Tesla's autopilot will have learned a valuable lesson due to someone-who-is-not-me's misfortune. I'd happily pay money for that. Deaths from bad human driving are meaningless tragedies. Deaths in a new but engineer-able system are extremely meaningful tragedies and are almost good news for everyone who isn't immediately involved.
- Hamuko 7y ago>screwing customers with exploitive dealer networks Having watched Rich Rebuilds' attempt at buying a second-hand Tesla Model X directly from Tesla, I'm not convinced that a) dealerships are bad b) Tesla are the good guys.
- growlist 7y ago> making everything miserable about cars for decades well at least we used to have some diversity in design - these days it's mostly variations on the shapeless blob theme. Yes I know, safety regulations etc etc...
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>The dinosaurs have been refusing to innovate in many areas, screwing customers with exploitive dealer networks Yeah, cars have had no innovation over time...wait, when's the last time you've been in one? And for the most part dealers are independently owned, not some scandalous way to rip off customers. I have owned many new cars in my life (I like tech, so I lease). I've never had an issue with the dealer that wasn't pleasantly resolved. I realize that isn't the case for every person, but dealers are not universally bad, or any worse than any other business. In fact, my wife likes the brand dealer so much that she continues to purchase her cars from them based on that alone. >The dinosars deserve to get their ass handed to them until they wake up and serve customers. You should look around the Tesla forums and Twitter at the complaints. The 'dinosaurs' may be bad, but the idea that Tesla service is somehow better is laughable.
- spindle 7y agoI WANT to say that a Citroen DS's adjustable suspension could be genuinely useful in some situations. But presumably nowadays DSs are so old that they break down all the time, and the fact that I want to forgive them nicely illustrates your point!
- ggm 7y agoI rode in a DS19 as a child, the owner doing adjustments in time to us singing. I also rode in the steel finish new model as a small child puked over the outside: Citroen wouldn't replace the door and he drove his luxury vehicle around for years with a rather nice blemish in the finish.. A friend had an ex-diplomatic corps DS19 which had a glass barrier between the driver and the PAX. Now that is stylish. The best I had was the Lesney toys "safari" DS19 model car in zebra stripes. Sideways open rear door on the wagon.. Death trap for non LH side parking.
- Svip 7y agoIf the DS has been taken well care of, they don't break down. My 1974 Citroën DS 23 has been running several years now without issue. While the engine isn't great, it's a sturdy one. And the hydraulics system, while complex, isn't that difficult to maintain. Just don't park it on the street during winter.
- dublinben 7y agoHow many <$20,000 new cars do you think are sold every year? Only the very insignificant subcompact segment even has an average selling price in that range. The average selling price of new vehicles is nearly $40,000. There's a lot of room for today's "boring" EVs in the $40,000 segment. https://mediaroom.kbb.com/2020-01-03-Average-New-Vehicle-Prices-Up-Nearly-2-Year-Over-Year-in-December-2019-According-to-Kelley-Blue-Book https://mediaroom.kbb.com/2020-01-03-Average-New-Vehicle-Pri...
- jandrese 7y agoDepends if you include used car sales in that figure.
- NikolaNovak 7y agoRight, but... how many $1,000,000 dollar cars get sold with how many $20,000 cars, for "Industry Average" to be $40,000? :D I notice average for Honda, Kia, Nissan etc in your linked article is $30,000... and that's explicitly exclusive of incentives and whatnots. AND inclusive of their luxury brands (Lexus, Infiniti, etc). That leaves room for lots of $20k cars, given that each of the brands has luxury models skewing the average as well. It would be interesting to see either median, or # of cars in some representative brackets.
- nradov 7y agoIn the US the median vehicle price is $36K. So few $1M supercars are sold that they have no impact on the median.
- ggm 7y agoTo have a median of $36K implies there are some pretty cheap cars out there. Say my $20,000 is hyperbole. What would be more reasonable? the median, or say.. $30,000? Why?
- CydeWeys 7y ago$30k isn't the average either. The average is higher than the median value of $36k. You're confusing things by comparing one manufacturer to all auto sales. And I'd say, sort of definitionally, that the median is the most reasonable figure to use here, precisely because it excludes all those insanely expensive hypercars driving the average up.
- pengaru 7y ago> There really is a sweet spot in most people's disposable income and on-road costs and range anxiety (also a highly irrational place btw) which is just around the corner I often jump at the opportunity to talk EVs with common folks who aren't car enthusiasts but do own/operate automobiles. What I've come to appreciate is that range anxiety isn't even the primary anxiety anymore. There's enough EVs out in the wild and just general evidence of their being usable as daily drivers that it seems to be a thing of the past. What does seem to be a major source of anxiety is battery lifetime and serviceability/cost. And I think that's a perfectly rational thing. Consider what most people experience with laptops and smartphones when it comes to modern rechargeable battery technology. They swell up, they catch fire, they lose capacity, they're not even standardized on EVs so you're locked into a specific vendor, it might not even be made by the OEM anymore so you're stuck with shoddy reverse-engineered replacements (classic thinkpad owners know this experience all to well). With volatile companies like Tesla you can't even be confident they'll still be around to service the electrics/battery in 5-10 years. What I wish companies like Tesla would do is define some standard form factors for things like batteries, motors, motor controllers, and charge systems. If they'd just get things to where EVs are very much like oversized electric RC vehicles, where we can buy the vehicles potentially without any battery at all with a competitive market of battery vendors to choose from fulfilling requirements of an open standard, a lot of these sources of anxiety completely vanish. Imagine a world where you could have a Tesla delivered to your local mechanic without a motor, motor controller, or battery. It's a roller conforming to a set of standards for those components. Then you buy those to your liking from whatever vendors you prefer in the size/capacities/costs you prefer. I'm pretty confident such a situation would have EV adoption explode everywhere, nobody would be worried about having an unmaintainable rube goldberg machine of proprietary electronics collecting dust on their driveway in 10 years.
- monadic2 7y ago> When EVs are in the segment of rational-decision bound purchases, when they are "boring" I will deem them to have succeeded. Do you see something preventing or slowing this from happening? Why would society not adopt EV? Unless you’re discussing degree or rate of adoption, which I don’t care about, but your comment seems to imply doubt that EVs will ever succeed... which seems extremely short sighted and naive.
- zulln 7y ago> There really is a sweet spot in most people's disposable income [..] which is just around the corner: I interpret it totally different. I the parent like they think we are close to it.
- ggm 7y agoAbsolutely not! I think EV's will succeed. The real signal to me will be effective competition across all segments of the car market. At the moment, the non-tesla cheap alternatives are drastically range limited in many cases, and also undersold and under-available. I've been reading blogs for 2 years waiting for the AU market to bust open, to no avail. My dream is an ioniq, or for Nissan to wise up and fix the problems with their battery model (rental?) or for a european manufacturer like VW to make good on the promise of their common-design chassis and break open the market. They aren't doing this yet for very good reasons, not dissimilar to why oil companies include a small number diversifying into Solar and Wind, and a lot who are selling as much oil as they can before it becomes a stranded asset: Most of the car production line is sunk cost around ICE. re-making ito EV implies a huge re-fabrication of the plant around EV not ICE and lots of sunk costs go up in smoke. If I was a BMW or VW or Toyota or Mazda exec, and my annual bonus depended on volume profit sales, standing up to propose a giant hole of capital be dug now, to save 15 years hence is .. well.. sensible but also not in my gene pool. The current generation of auto execs have no motivation to compete right now. They'd rather buy off the Californian clean air taxes by investing in Tesla shares to green-wash their needs, believing they can rush in at the end and steal the market. There is a tension between first mover advantage and second-system effect.
- georgeecollins 7y agoIf they aren’t already “boring” after 1 million sold, when do you think they will be? https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-production-1-million-electric-cars/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-production-1-million-electri...
- ggm 7y agoWhen they don't cost $AU70,000 or more. its likely a Tesla will always be "cool" but so was a VW beetle. In truth, no car is boring. they're amazing machines. But something which takes more than the median wage ($AU50,000) to acquire, when substitutable vehicles are $AU30,000 or less (excluding luxe from the equation) puts them into a different category than a boring car.
- tlb 7y agoWhy shouldn't more people have enjoyable cars? If they can afford an enjoyable house, and they drive regularly, they should treat themselves to an enjoyable car too. The idea of buying a nice car fell into some disrepute starting in the late 70s, when the major manufacturers stopped making actual nice cars and just added some extra plastic to their economy cars to sell as the premium brand. So people buying Cadillacs in the 90s seemed like, well, chumps. But that shouldn't be a permanent indictment of nice cars! The nice cars of a former era sucked, but now we have nice cars that are actually pretty sweet. As more people realize that well-designed cars can actually make you and your family happier while driving, there'll be a lot of demand for those cars even at high price points.
- ggm 7y ago'nice' cars and 'well designed' cars are dis-joint sets.
- flattone 7y ago>Why shouldn't more people have enjoyable cars? To my eyes (auto mech first job/into car/driving experience more than i can afford): There has not been an interesting new car (on my sub 6 figure radar) in around 15 years. In Washington state subaru are pretty popular seeming (all wheel drive due to rare snowfall in the city). I hopped on the band wagon with an 04' wrx, with a sti conversion, suspension/bushings/motor/turbo etc changes). I'm having more fun with a deeper connection for 1/4 of the money than any porsche i've ever entertained on the freeway. I get that labels are cool, but at the mechanical level it's just a word for OEM perception. SO yes enjoyable cars. But sadly no nothing to buy. I would love to be a 'normal person' with a car payment and something that is 'new' and fresh. I dont want to knock any newer popular cars but good lord. . i could. Someone mentioned to me yesterday that the Tesla Cybertruck is a bit odd looking. To me everything is an ugly marshmallow these days (including my 04 i guess but it has a pleasantly stout looking rear). So dear Tesla, thanks for making new car life potentially interesting.
- thedrbrian 7y ago> To my eyes (auto mech first job/into car/driving experience more than i can afford): There has not been an interesting new car (on my sub 6 figure radar) in around 15 years. How have you missed the best selling fun car for thirty years? https://www.mazdausa.com/vehicles/2020-mx-5-miata https://www.mazdausa.com/vehicles/2020-mx-5-miata
- the8472 7y agoAnother concern for many people is charging. There are a lot of renters and apartment complexes in Europe. So the big question mark in people's heads is whether they can charge at home and have to negotiate with their landlord. This needs government regulation that guarantees tenants can get charging infrastructure installed with some reasonable cost-sharing setup.
- ggm 7y agoAs an apartment owner, we missed mandatory charging in the basement by two years (its off-the-plan, the change came after we were built. Across the road have it.). The retro-fit cost of high power is going to come. Its a lot more than build-in during construction and goes to if there are sufficient transmission infrastructure investments in the local supply path to your apt. We expect to get 32 amp circuits to every 3rd, 4th parking spot which in principle will share with a long pigtail but the advantage of a park with power will now disadvantage some owners. It requires separate billing. It means having to move the entire apt complex (460 units) to separate billing models, smart meters. It's likely we'll install the ring, the circuit, but not fit outlets unless the owner pays some quotient of the cost, and we will have to inform everyone there is a process, but not everyone can get one. It will be very unequal. Retrofit is going to be a very painful topic for years, for apartments, which is also why their lovely high, un-obstructed roof line is not covered in Solar Cells: it makes perfect sense, but its like herding kittens to get the body corporate or condo committee to agree to spend money. Or pool heating: the retrofit cost is $150,000 for something which could have been planned in for under $50,000. Insanely short sighted design decisions echo down the years.
- Symbiote 7y ago> It means having to move the entire apt complex (460 units) to separate billing models, smart meters. Isn't that coming anyway? "The EU aims to replace at least 80% of electricity meters with smart meters by 2020 wherever it is cost-effective to do so." -- although I don't know what cost-effective meant. The building I live in has smart meters, and there are two parking spaces with 400V 3-phase sockets. (I assume the car owners just paid the installation cost.) https://ec.europa.eu/energy/topics/markets-and-consumers/smart-grids-and-meters/overview_en?redir=1 https://ec.europa.eu/energy/topics/markets-and-consumers/sma...
- breakyerself 7y agoI think it's rational to want to reduce ones co2 footprint. Thats why I bought the first EV that I could afford that had enough range to cover my commute + an errand or two. Which was a model 3.
- fulafel 7y agoMost car purchas are a fundamentally non-rational decisions in the current climate crisis, if you have humane values and place some weight in the common good.
- timwaagh 7y agothe competition is KIA as they are the cheapest. but VW also has a few models. Their ID.3 which will come out soon even has the range issue fixed.
- hamilyon2 7y agoIs there a research to back your statement? I always thought that car purchases are highly rational, and even read some compelling research about it (cannot find it right now). Yes, decision to buy particularly expensive car is very rational, with lot of time, choices and your personal preferences are of course part of it. Old cars do have their merits, and cost premium associated with them is real, economical fact. Very very little of price of car cannot be explained by market forces at work.
- nicoburns 7y agoMost Europeans are highly concerned about the climate. If you have the money, then buying a Tesla is not so irrational in that context: they still have the best EVs. Agree that they're still too expensive for the average consumer to afford, and that the specs on the low-end EV models aren't yet competitive with traditional ICE cars.
- martin_bech 7y agoThe Model 3 has won Car of the Year in most of Europe. Simply for beeing the best car you can buy right now.
- nicoburns 7y agoYeah, but the Model 3 is still expensive! Most people can't afford to spend £40k on a car.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThe range issue isn't necessary irrational if you look at fuel logistics. Current gas stations just lack the infrastructure to support as many EV-vehicles. A modern (non-Tesla) EV-Vehicle can be recharged to 80% within half an hour or so. That works without issues as long as very few people have electric vehicles. If everyone had one, we would get into problems with recharging. You can assume the infrastructure to scale with sold vehicles, but there are other requirements that suddenly become an issue. Many gas stations just don't have enough electrical power for example. You cannot look at one trip and call it irrational since it isn't applicable for your commute or short trips. I think these issues will be solved, but there are still changes needed.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoPutting chargers in gas stations may end up being the casualty. They would make more sense in diners, for example, so you can charge-and-coffee. And that distributes the load much more evenly.
- varjag 7y agoSome gas stations in Norway expand into diners as their market evaporates.
- tyfon 7y agoPetrol stations in Norway haven't made money on the petrol for the last 20 years at least. They make all the profits on hot dogs and buns and the people charging spends more time at the station = more sales.
- varjag 7y agoTrue but I've seen a bunch of Esso stations last couple years that extend the building with a sitting/serving area.
- jacquesm 7y ago> And the Citroen DS19. I've long dreamed about a project: rebuild a DS from the ground up but with a modern engine (or even electric), run the hydraulics using electronics rather than the system in use based on Mercedes S class parts. Use an original Chassis, make all the panels out of fibreglass. But that requires a lot of space and time to complete. Still, by far the most beautiful car ever made, I always felt that if Citroen had really caught the retro wave that gave us the New Beetle and the Fiat 500 that it would have been a best seller.
- michaelt 7y agoIf you like seeing 1960s cars fitted with modern engines, you might enjoy Project Binky [1] where you can watch some mechanics fit (or at least, attempt to fit) a 200-horsepower rally car engine and drivetrain into a 1960s-era Austin Mini [1] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLGSOZAHg1yQHU1tc_3Y5MTQg1qjtxA_nq https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLGSOZAHg1yQHU1tc_3Y5M...
- jacquesm 7y agoOh, that's some real dedication there. 5 years and counting.
- Svip 7y ago> run the hydraulics using electronics rather than the system in use based on Mercedes S class parts Why not just use the original hydraulics system? Its only downside is the old pipes, that can corrode. If you replace them with modern coated copper ones, leaks won't be a problem. I think you'd be introducing more problems than necessary if you replaced it with an electronic pump and height adjuster. (Speaking as someone with a DS 23. And only to be slightly pedantic, I believe the DS19 is an ID19.) Personally, I would love to buy a series 1 CX and replace its engine with an electric one. That will be my project, once I get to buy my house in the country and get my workshop. (I already have two cars that I need space for.)
- jacquesm 7y agoThe DS19 was the early, 1.9 liter engined version of the DS. There are also 2.1 and 2.3 liter versions, the 2.3 with fuel injection is the most sought after one. The ID19 is the cheap version of the same car, it was sold with a manual gearbox, 'regular' brakes and a cheaper interior. I would not use the 'green system' because the pumps, regulators, hydro computer and membrane based 'balls' are all way past their end of life. If you're going to upgrade the car you might as well take that bit along. And if the chassis you use as a base has the red system on it you're going to be spending a lot of money anyway. I'd rather use a 'supported' set of parts for something as important as staying off the ground and the S-class system works well and would easily manage a car with the weight of the DS, even when powered electrically. It would use a small fraction of the pump capacity that the DS requires. I've restored two DS's in the 80's, lots of fun to work on and to drive.