17 ms·
I have seen things
- blowski 7y agoThe “I am old” trope is just so uninteresting. To me, it’s a sort of humblebrag - because I’m older than you, my opinions are more valuable. There are infinite things I don’t understand, some because I’m too young, some too old, but mostly just because I haven’t yet gone down that path in life. For what it’s worth, I was born in 1982.
- hamburglar 7y ago> The “I am old” trope is just so uninteresting. To me, it’s a sort of humblebrag I assure you, it isn't. I mean, I'm sure it's uninteresting, but it isn't intended to be a humblebrag. I practically cheered when the OP indicated that they don't understand "stories" because I legitimately don't, but I also have this realization that the reason I don't understand stories is that I'm just kind of inflexible and grumpy about new things at times. That's not admirable. That's not useful. But it's the truth. I truly don't understand why some pictures are shown at the very tippy top of my facebook feed, but I only get to look at them for 10 seconds. Is there a reason for this? Does someone find it beneficial? Do the kids laugh at me for even stopping to think about it? (Yes. Yes they do.) This is not a badge of honor.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dmje 7y agoYeh, fk "Stories", whatever they are. Actually, also, fk Facebook too. It's not admirable or useful, no. But, I find it's kind of relaxing to have a near total lack of FOMO. I've become the guy I never thought I'd become, but I'm totally comfortable with that. Is this a humblebrag? I have no idea, but it's definitely calming to not have to give a shit about all the new things. I'm 47 (1972) so relate a lot to this guy.
- rimliu 7y agoI would not say that I don't understand "stories", but I dislike. The worst thing, there are no stories in "stories".
- jaclaz 7y agoAs a diversion, JFYI: https://tinyapps.org/blog/200702250700_why_in_my_day.html https://tinyapps.org/blog/200702250700_why_in_my_day.html ... kids today ...
- cambalache 7y agoMeh, I am +/- 2 years within the author's age, and although I grumble here and there about young people practices (latinx?? yikes) I think I have an OK understanding of popular culture, including Internet things. Come on: memes, dabbing, dubs,tik tok,fortnite dances, Pewdiepie.Most of them are silly and funny things, not the exact solution of GR for 2 neutron stars colliding. I will admit that there are things I believe, but I am not 100% sure if they are true because of my age. For example, although I hate nostalgia, I am convinced that modern mainstream music, let's say after the 2000s is severely lacking compared to what happened in the previous 60 or so years. There always be great musicians, doing great music, but right now the current popular stuff have been homogenized and sterilized to make it pallatable worlwide.
- cultus 7y agoYou really are pretty mistaken on the music (I'm 35). I'm guessing you are just exposed to bad pop acts like Mylie Cyrus. Keep in mind that most popular music in the 1960's and 1970's sucked too. For every Beatles there was 10 Monkees. There's been an incredible amount of innovation in music in the last few years (except rock. It's dead). Creation has been democratized, so there's more people making music than ever before. You just have to know where to look. I listen to KEXP Seattle [0] quite a bit, which is a community-supported station. [0] https://www.kexp.org/ https://www.kexp.org/
- dctoedt 7y ago> For every Beatles there was 10 Monkees. Hey, wait a minute! The Monkees were pretty good for what they were (mass-production pop) — at least in the early days when they were doing Boyce & Hart compositions.
- conjectures 7y agoThere is a shedload of good music out there, but the distribution mechanism has changed. If you actively look on Spotify, you'll start to find things. That is unless it's a simple case of the music in [decade I was 13-23] was the best!
- alexilliamson 7y agoJust want to add that I'm 28 and have never figured out snapchat/stories. Personally, I'm not sure how to use them, and from other people, I find them SUPER boring.
- emsimot 7y ago> but I only get to look at them for 10 seconds You can touch the screen and hold to keep the picture there for longer. If it's like Instagram stories you can tap the far left side of the screen to go backwards as well.
- kubanczyk 7y agoIt is interesting. Young people can consume just about anything and it still makes them... better? I guess that's the word. One day you notice that you circle around in brownian motion. I should have started to learn more discrimination techniques years ago. It is so terribly hard to navigate the sea of interesting stuff and find the droplets that are also interesting, but that also have ability to change your mind (think LW and the likes). That's like... the ultimate skill. If it isn't ultimately interesting, then what is?
- mnd999 7y ago> To me, it’s a sort of humblebrag - because I’m older than you, my opinions are more valuable. I am getting older too, but I’m constantly learning things from people younger than me - increasingly more so than those older than me. And that’s okay. Sure I’ve done more and seen more but how much of it is actually relevant? Some for sure, but this world changes so fast. Are my opinions valuable? Yes. More so simply because of my age? No.
- allenu 7y agoI’m about a year younger than the author of the blog post and I agree with you. This is something that has been scaring me a little in the last year: getting older does not mean life as a whole gets easier. There are just more advanced things that keep you up at night. And yes, the world changes so quickly that you soon realize that you too are becoming irrelevant. What a curse to feel the optimism and specialness of youth only to see it slowly fade away.
- falcolas 7y agoI’m not sure that things are actually changing all that quickly. Instead, we’re just watching a pendulum swing from one extreme (control) to another extreme (freedom). And its this repeated movement between the two extremes which are providing our incremental improvements, since we keep the good parts from each end, and use those as the foundation for what the next extreme will look like. Programming provides an interesting microcosm of this, if you look at overall attitudes towards variable typing. What have I learned? Nothing new; “this too shall pass” is a phrase much older than I am. But I’m able to accept it, and take advantage of the gains of the wild pendulum’s swing without being caught up in it myself.
- gammadens 7y agoAgeism cuts in both directions and it's one of the few forms of prejudice society still tolerates for some reason. Imagine this guy's post if you substitute "too old" with "black" or "female" (or "male"). It would be cut down quickly and yet here we are expected to laugh at things. What I hate about ageism most of all is it makes it impossible to have any kind of discussion about the real merits and demerits of things if there's some kind of new versus established nature to it. In certain circles, there seems to be a false, pervasive assumption that what's new and popular among the young is better, and that uptake is just inhibited by creaky old folks; in other circles there seems to be an assumption that's what's old and established among the older crowd is that way because it's superior. The reality is that some established products are established because they are so great; and other products are great because they address limitations of existing products. But once you bring age of critics or advocates into the mix, it's all over because someone starts slyly looking at their pals over their shoulder and dismissing the discourse as due to youth or age. I've been on both sides of this, as someone the same age as the author, and it's infuriating. There are products that my generation grew that I never adopted because of concerns, and now it's the young trendy thing to do to abandon them. There are new products that are overhyped imho because they solve problems that never really existed, but the wheel gets reinvented anyway because of the constant need for people to brand themselves as innovators. On the other hand, there are new products that finally exist that I wish everyone would take up, but don't because of old products that should have never become as popular as they did, or because of the vagaries of network effects, fads, and so on. So this person doesn't get Facebook Stories or whatever the hell it is. Fine. Is there anything wrong with that? No. Can't we talk about that? Why does it have to become about age, even if he's doing it through self-deprecating (humblebragging?) humor?
- zackmorris 7y agoI disagree. I think of it in terms of lives lived within a life. I'd break mine down into: 1) 0-5 Coming into self-awareness (this is like waking up while still drunk or coming down from recreational drugs, as your consciousness reassembles from wherever it was) 2) 6-11 The universe provides for you (mom and dad are god, your needs are mostly provided for and you should do what you're told) 3) 12-17 The face of humanity (you witness the very best and worst that humankind has to offer, through the trials and tribulations of junior high and high school) 4) 18-21 College (thanks I needed that) 5) 22-29 The narcissistic years (I am so miserable, why can't I say no?) 6) 30-39 The long now (how long have I been alive?) 7) 40-49 Death begins at 40 (how could I have just been born?) 8) 50-64 I should feel older (so I've heard) 9) 65+ Unknown (are you me?) There are probably more. All I am saying is that when I hit 40, I realized that I was more than one time period removed from the young graduates just starting their careers around me. I wasn't really their brother anymore, I was their dad or weird uncle at the very least. No more getting invited to parties, no more fashion for me. Just loafers and nutritional supplements to keep me on life support until 2040 when I enter The Matrix or get reincarnated, whichever comes first. For me it's more a case of, I was much older at 18 than I am now, so when young people don't want to hear it from their elders, that's a form of conservative or elderly behavior. It's sophomoric.
- GnarfGnarf 7y ago65+: there are only a few years left, very little matters, it's wonderfully liberating.
- csomar 7y agoOkay, my comment might make me sound a bit like a douche: fb/ig stories are the youngsters version of this guy blog post. They are social tools to make them feel better about themselves.
- visarga 7y agoSame story, am 1 year older than OP. I started with ZX Spectrum though. My father was a programmer. Back then he was using punch cards (when I was a few years old), then tapes, then he got a 60MB hard drive the size of a washing machine which took one minute to spin up. A full drawer in the rack contained 256K ram. A 2400 baud modem was the size of a PC grey box.
- JeanMarcS 7y agoZX-81 here ! I burned all my birthday savings in one shot for it. And learned Z80 assembler (only way to have some (relative) speed with it)
- jeffreygoesto 7y agoFun times! Space invaders in 1k Z80 assembly, stored in a BASIC REM statement, using the display memory as "internal state"... Later I added 16k RAM, eventually the "HighRes" Graphics card and last but not least the thermo printer.
- JeanMarcS 7y agoNever had the printer, but that big tall black box graphic card yes!
- jaclaz 7y agoI win (but I am older) ZX-80! (and yes you had to actually solder components to get the thingy be able to run a sort of pong in 1 KB). The thing that remained stuck in my memory (common to all Sinclair users) is the sound of the cassette loading and (many years later) that of modems trying to connect to this or that BBS.
- poisonborz 7y agoFor a type of feature/product/concept like what Stories is, merely googling is a bad way to understand it. You have to use it to get its value. Being a data nerd at first I hated the idea of posting short ephemeral content and I thought this is a cold, isolated direction for social networks. But I do have to admit I post more, knowing this doesn't add up to the "vanity" nature of my profile. And the historical stories are still available through data takeout. Also be prepared to get into it nevertheless, Twitter will introduce a similar feat called "fleets" soon.
- mxfh 7y agoThe ephemeral siloed web contradicts everything people who grew up with the internet thought it stands for, and for people who still do phone calls, there is no real need for sharing pseudo-fleeting messages, that what whatsapp is for. And from what I understand, the period where you need to be in constant contact or broadcast to more than 10 people is pretty limited to school and early higher ed for most people in my experience. So unless stories become a way to keep in touch with your offsprings, I don't see a need or near normalness of these communication methods among people born before '85.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- saagarjha 7y ago> for people who still do phone calls, there is no real need for sharing pseudo-fleeting messages, that what whatsapp is for WhatsApp is for chats; they're not fleeting. Phone calls are fairly inconvenient to take and incomparable with "true" fleeting messages.
- mxfh 7y agoSorry was unclear about this. But that's what I meant, I rather have searchable conversations with the option to delete things, non-ephemeral by default. And whatsapp is the app older people adapted to and get along with. It's what they now.
- pram 7y agoSeems a little defensive for a joke tweet
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- imgabe 7y ago> I was born in 1976. I understand that in the eyes of millennials 1976 is around the same time period as 1796 Just to nitpick a little, the millennial generation starts with 1980-1982 depending on who you ask, so 1976 isn't that old.
- Wohlf 7y ago"Millennial" has come to mean "young people", even though the oldest gen z are graduating college now.
- m00dy 7y agocome on. He is way more close to being a boomer rather than a millennial.
- chrisco255 7y agoThe cutoff for Baby Boomers is 1962. The first Millennials were born in 1982.
- m00dy 7y agoyou basically assume that generation division is based on uniform distribution on years. But, I don't think that is the way it is.
- barrkel 7y agoGenX are closer to millennials than boomers IMO, at least the stereotypes in my head.
- blowski 7y agoWhat’s the point of these labels? I know 16 year olds that talk like the stereotype of “boomers”, and 70 year olds that talk like “generation z”. Imagine we were making the same kind of generalisations about your gender, skin colour, choice of programming language - what would it add to the conversation? We may as well say “Scorpios like partying where sagitarians prefer reading books”
- ddmma 7y agoMost probably not on tiktok either
- DanielBMarkham 7y agoWhen you miss a lot of things in popular culture, you may start to become irrelevant. But I think missing a couple things is OK. I always thought there should be some form of yearly bootcamp for nerds. Drop out of larger society for most of the year, doing your thing, then for a week each year you get indoctrinated in all of the crap everybody else is doing and thinking. That way you can stay mostly culturally-relevant without spending huge hunks of your time becoming the master of the intricate details of things like Game of Thrones. Just know the general themes, be able to tell some jokes and create metaphors and illusions. I don't know who would run this bootcamp. I assume teenagers. Your teenage years are a time where it is very important to stay with the group, establish social ranking, be the master of conversation about various widespread cultural events. Those feelings never go away, but for many of us they die off as we get older, have families, and absorb ourselves in work we find important. There are some very weird things about getting older. First off, you only are old on the outside. While people, especially some younger folks, may look at you as if you were an alien that just arrived from Mars, inside you're the same old kid you always was. Just the outside has changed. When presented with a new situation, you may appear to decide more slowly, but you're also thinking about a lot of different things and options you wouldn't have thought of in your youth, and you realize that unless you're driving a racecar, most times it's better to take a minute and decide and get it right than it is deciding in two seconds and getting it wrong. You see a lot of stuff. Hopefully you learn from it!
- RocketSanchez 7y agoThis is definitely a VC attractor
- rytill 7y agoAre you referring to the dynamical systems object and saying that this is a thought process that eventually ends up VC-like?
- taneq 7y ago> Just know the general themes, be able to tell some jokes and create metaphors and illusions. Did you see that ludicrous display last night?
- srebalaji 7y agoOf course, you have seen things :)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- S_A_P 7y agoSame age as the author and his timeline is a lot like mine, albeit with advanced degrees I don’t have. I used to have all of those social media accounts and found that in my case I’m happier not having them. By all means try it out and see if it works for you, but you may prefer actually seeing things.
- wcoenen 7y agoIt's ironic to me that the post starts with a twitter poll, because I don't get twitter either, and I've tried. And I'm even a bit younger than the poster.
- Ygg2 7y agoTwitter is emotional contangion machine. It's supposed to be used to spread marketing hype, but now it mostly spreads hate. And cat pictures. It's billed as a way to be able to contact famous people.
- 83457 7y agoI think Twitter makes the most sense if you are involved in a fast moving community with a large presence on Twitter. I signed up for Twitter early and followed some devs but lost interest. Years later I got heavily involved in esports and found it helpful both in keeping up with the industry, friends I have made and promoting events/tournaments.
- gwd 7y agoHeck, I love Facebook, but I still don't understand the point of "Facebook stories". It seems to be a series of pictures that you can't control when it moves forward? Why don't you just give me a photo album, so I can look through them at my own pace?
- aflag 7y agoYou can stop it from moving by clicking and holding (both on the phone and laptop). The point is that it's a fast snippet of someone's time. Things you don't want someone referencing in the future. For instance, you may want to show your friends you are in a resort and that you are in some other friends house. But you don't want people to be able to trace down your every move by looking at your profile.
- code_duck 7y agoIt's just a duplicate of Instagram stories, which itself was a duplicate of Snapchat. Why is the interface that way? Because that's how Snapchat did it. The basic idea is that thebcontent that is ephemeral, which lowers mental barriers to adding content. Consumers have grown weary of how standard posts on Facebook or Twitter are available eyernally for stalkers, employers, and random people to see unless you delete it explicitly. "Stories" disappear after a day. As noted there's no reason that they had to do this exactly the same way as Snapchat. It could have any kind of interface such as a typical photo album, but part of the plan was copying Snapchat because they were popular and wouldn't sell out to Facebook. It's been very successful for Instagram and I assume they just wanted to extend the format to Facebook members who do not use Instagram.
- tapper 7y agoOne of the things I tell my 5 kids is "Don't be a sheep!"
- kieckerjan 7y agoOur generation is the last one who knew the world without internet. Now that was something to behold!
- sgroppino 7y ago[Edit: removed personal opinion on the fact]. Curious why you didn't mention 9/11.
- fit2rule 7y agoTry tuning in to the footage of the criminal wars America has started since then. 9/11 is nothing compared to what the West has done to the ME world.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- batirch 7y agoÇok güzeldi. Teşekkürler eskileri hatırlattığınız için!
- zanderz 7y agoI, too, am old enough to remember Before the Internet https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/06/26/before-the-internet https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/06/26/before-the-int...
- pjc50 7y agoPopular culture is always both smaller and larger than you expect. Especially in music, where particular events loom huge in the canonical history but then you realise that there can only have been a tiny number of people actually there (e.g. the famous Manchester Free Trade Hall Sex Pistols gig). But conversely it's possible to stumble across a vibrant, long-lasting, close scene of people that you've never heard of, with its own memes and legends. But the big era of a single, national popular culture was very much a product of the TV age. The easy identification of a decade with a single music genre and clothing style is over. We're fragmented now; Game of Thrones feels big but has a narrower reach than the big pop culture movements of the mid-20th century. Find your niche. It's OK. But don't mock the niches of others.
- mattmanser 7y agoIs it over? Hipsters, for example, were a large, identifiable group that I would say is only just fading now. In a decade or so the 2010s will be thought of as the hipster fashion generation with full body tats, beards, etc., even though the vast majority of people didn't dress like that. I was watching some teeny, zombie show on Netflix a few months ago that still clearly delineated teens into identifiable groups, though nerds are cool, and the group that would have been the actual nerds in times past identified themselves as just 'awkward'. AFAIK, tribality is built into our DNA, I can't see it ever disappearing, people want to belong. You can even point to some TV series like 'Russian Doll' that capture the fashion style and the 'essence' of this era.
- TheRealDunkirk 7y agoWhen the internet took off in the late 90's, the information bandwidth allowed everyone to access "the long tail" of available culture and interests, and find their precise niche. This lasted about a minute, in generational terms. Now we're all living in the long tail. Now, the long tail is all there is. THIS is why music companies have suffered; not piracy. And news; not because of ads. Business based on scarcity and promotion are dead or dying. This is why popular culture peaked in the 80's. There will NEVER be a time where the majority of the population is caught up in the same thing, where one fashion trend or one genre of music dominates.
- james_s_tayler 7y agoBoulderdash on C64. Hell yeah. This guy knows what's up.
- hanoz 7y ago> I Have Seen Things It can be a funny experience coming late to pivotal work of popular culture, I somehow managed to miss out on Blade Runner until quite recently, and watching it felt like a putting a missing jigsaw piece into place. Another one I came late to was Anchorman. Suddenly a lifetime's worth of people's odd remarks and affected mannerisms fell into their proper place.
- k__ 7y agoThis. It doesn't has to be "young peoples stuff", it's enough that you weren't interested in it decades years ago.
- twic 7y agoOne of the things i like about listening to old jazz etc records is that sometimes, you suddenly hear a moment you've heard a thousand times in a hundred hip-hop records, and now you know where that came from.
- sixstringtheory 7y agoI just listened to a 99PI episode that goes into the epistemology of song with Who Let the Dogs Out that is a fantastic listen: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/99-invisible/id394775318?i=1000465339110 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/99-invisible/id3947753...
- mhd 7y agoThis is getting a bit worse, I think, but it's always been that way. Go further back than your ancient 2004 Anchorman references and you'll get Blade Runner, Star Wars, Princess Bride, etc. One step further and you'll get 2001 (Thus Spoke Zarathustra / Blue Danube / Hal quotes), Citizen Kane ("Rosebud"), Gone with The Wind ("Frankly My Dear...") etc. Sometime after that you'll get people quoting from Shakespeare without seeing the plays (still happens, of course), and soon we'll end at Bible quotes (naturally, as practically no one could even read it), or Roman authors. And I bet someone can point me at writings by those exact Romans where they complain about the youths not being up to par with Plato. I rarely feel odd about a lack of knowledge, as there's just too much to know. Also, you've got the two issues where this is a) just used for meaningless gatekeeping anyway or b) a "cargo cult" meme already. The latter will get more and more common: Quotes and references, where the reference binds you together, not the shared knowledge of the original source.
- ilaksh 7y agoIn case anyone is interested in old computer stuff, I made vintagesimulator.com But on the topic, I'm 42 and fully expect to see even more dramatic changes in my lifetime. Including a Martian manned base, high bandwidth brain computer interfaces (Neuralink), widely deployed self-driving cars, AGI and the beginning of the post-human era.
- avip 7y agoI'm from same age group and region as this guy but started computers some 15 years after him. When I've started Uni I had no idea what a mouse is and no concept of files or folders. Today I have no idea what Instagram is and use no social media outside HN. Am super happy and proud about how things are!
- coleifer 7y agoBro did you quote yourself at the start of your post?
- klingonopera 7y ago> "I still don't have any idea what Instagram or Facebook stories is." Since the author is familiar with Twitter, one can imagine it like a tweet that self-deletes after 24h, except with Facebook's and Instagram's version of a "tweet", i.e. post. Core concept is to get people to return to the platform (daily) because of FOMO. Calling it "stories" is quite misleading actually, one (or at least I) would expect a story to be rather something permanent compared to a post, but it's exactly the other way around.
- morgengold 7y agoFrom a user perspective: why do you want to participate in this kind of thing? I get why this is good for the platform. For me (1985) it seems to have zero value. I feel old more and more.
- dade_ 7y agoMy friend in his 20s said to me 'You are old, but useful', and I responded with a gee thanks. At this point he realized I misheard him, and claims he said 'You are old, but youthful'. Anyway, it's now a joke between us and perhaps it is the best we can do: Old, but youthful and by intention or accident - useful.
- nl 7y agoWhat do you mean it has zero value? It's probably the most pure form of self expression available on social media because it's free of consequences (in theory at least). And the "return to the platform daily" thing is overstated - that's like saying a chat program makes people return to it regularly by delivering messages. It's technically right but shows a complete misunderstanding of how and why it's used. 1975. But very immature.
- Dumbdo 7y agoFor me to understand Instagram stories, it's important to kinda understand the Instagram culture. Normal posts (not stories) are pretty "high-effort" (in terms of shooting and editing) and are posted not so often, maybe every two days at max for your average teen. This left a gap for short-lived stuff (I'm currently eating in this 5* restaurant, I'm currently hiking, I'm on this "cool" party etc.) you wanted to share to a large group of your "friends" (so DM like whatsapp is not a real option because it feels attention-whoring to write it to everyone). This was mostly filled by Snapchat stories, where you could share exactly that without having to fear to spam people because it's time-limited, everyone does it and it's a very casual format. This feature was basically copied by instagram and is a success for the same reasons, expect nobody uses snapchat stories anymore. Source: I have young siblings and I kinda use that stuff as well, although not that much.
- k__ 7y agoI'm 34 and try to be open about younger peoples stuff. Got a few friends who are under 25 and work with social media everyday helps. But yeah, some stuff I just don't like or get and I don't care. I mean, there are also young people out there who don't like tiktok or mumble rap.
- H8crilA 7y agoDo you know what's their generation equivalent of shashdot / hacker news? This forum clearly seems to be getting "old".
- k__ 7y agoReddit, I think.
- inerg 7y agoI'm right in that age category and use both Reddit and HN. I would say your guess is right that most people my age use Reddit as their Slashdot. Both provide good insights but I feel the discussion is usually more useful in HN, although this depends on the subreddit. Generally I go on reddit when I'm looking for a quick distraction and HN is for when I'm looking to read things a bit more deeply.
- war1025 7y agoI feel like HN is something you age into. I don't think it necessarily has an aging demographic. When I was in college, the information on Reddit related to programming and computers was relevant. As I've gained experience, the information on Reddit has gradually become less and less useful. To the point that I don't even bother following tech-related subreddits anymore.
- sodafountan 7y agoI'm 26 and I can't for the life of me understand the appeal of tiktok, my girlfriend who's a few years younger than me likes it, we'll be sitting on the couch and she'll be watching videos and I just don't get it. On the flip side, she doesn't really like reddit which a site I use almost daily - to each their own I guess. Tiktok is the first app or piece of technology or whatever you want to call it that made me feel "old", up until now I've been able to pick up on new trends and things that are popular with ease, I used Facebook early on, Instagram when it became popular and snapchat too but tiktok just didn't stick. I guess it's a small sign of things to come as I get older.
- pier25 7y agoI expected this to be about Blade Runner.
- k__ 7y agoSame here.
- ak39 7y agoThere is irony here.
- mothsonasloth 7y agoAttack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion
- mcv 7y agoI just turned 46 and finally learned to solve Rubik's Cube. Turns out kids don't care about Rubik's Cube anymore. Still, I learned a new skill, so I'm not dead yet. (I do have a Facebook account, but I never use it. I also have a Twitter account, but only because I had to write Twitter integration at some point. I use it even less. I'm active on Diaspora and MeWe, though.)
- saagarjha 7y ago> Turns out kids don't care about Rubik's Cube anymore. Speedcubing clubs aren't really that rare in most schools.
- ak39 7y ago"A scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it." Max Planck. The great Max Planck was indeed right. But there's a flip side to this aphorism that is just as relevant (if not more) to our computer systems society. Our problem is that the new generation seems to want to re-invent what our forebears had taken great pain to describe and find theoretical and practical answers to (relational databases, data formats, UI theory etc). Our problem is that the modern computer system society suffers from a generational memory gap. Amnesia of solved problems.
- staticvoidmaine 7y agoOne of the things I find interesting is this: In computer programming, a “solution” to a problem is in essence, a structured framework of thought. As an example, why are there many different programming languages? Well in addition to various other reasons, for the sake of solving problems in a new or different way of thinking. Is youth constantly reinventing solutions to already solved problems due to amnesia, or are they perhaps creating new ways to reason about already identified problems? Just because you saw the problem first doesn’t buy you the right to providing the only solution. Computer science is unique in that it is art as much as science. Allowing for multiple frameworks of thought on a solution allows for the best solution to rise to the top. If we are still seeing an influx of new and interesting solutions to existing problems, perhaps our field isn’t as mature as we’d like to think it is.
- ip26 7y agoIs youth constantly reinventing solutions to already solved problems due to amnesia, or are they perhaps creating new ways to reason about already identified problems? I believe the commonly accepted viewpoint is simply that the established generations have too many accumulated biases or baggage, too much at stake, or dug themselves in too deep of a hole to consider new facts or new approaches to old problems. E.g. the famous quote: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." - Upton Sinclair
- jansan 7y ago"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tears_in_rain_monologue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tears_in_rain_monologue
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoI have the opposite problem that the author does. I don’t like it when people share the same interests or hobbies that I do. It just feels like a cheapened experience when the masses and normies start to enjoy it too. Invariably they start to ruin it as well.
- Gormisdomai 7y ago"If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking." I really like this balanced sentiment at the end of the article. It's easier to feel different or weird or out of touch when you affirm for yourself that you're being weird by your own choice - to the extent that you _want_ to be different to everyone else. It's a nice mean between the two extremes of going full conformist or going full hipster.
- subpixel 7y ago> When you miss a lot of things in popular culture, you may start to become irrelevant Compared to what?* I had lunch with an adult in their 30s who didn't know who Johnny Cash was. *https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCDMQqDUtv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCDMQqDUtv4
- sixQuarks 7y agoSame age as author. Through procrastinating with digg, reddit, and HN over the years, and just being a tech enthusiast before that (reading Industry Standard, Business 2.0 magazines, Web Magazine etc) - I've been on the leading edge of seeing all the new services come and go. - started using Google in early 1999 (few months after they launched) - first 30K users on LinkedIn - first day user of YouTube - first 100K users of Twitter - first 100K users of Instagram - first 30K subscriber of Casey Niestat Vlog - knew about bitcoin at 10 cents (didn't buy thanks to HN saying it was a scam/bubble) The most confusing and frustrating thing for me has been SnapChat by far. That's when I realized I'm getting old.
- dylkil 7y ago>knew about bitcoin at 10 cents (didn't buy thanks to HN saying it was a scam/bubble) they still say its a scam/bubble
- aglavine 7y agoI am a believer now: It solves inflation problem, so government will soon be smaller.
- api 7y agoIt doesn't solve the problems that led to the embrace of inflationary currencies at all. These are among others price inelasticity and the very powerful psychological "number going up is good" factor. Try explaining to an employee that their paycheck is smaller because currency has appreciated in value, or to a bank that the principal of a loan should be written down for the same reason. "But number go down bad!" Inflation hides these things. It's a hack around these problems.
- aglavine 7y agoAm employee would have her paycheck in bitcoins. Same quantity every paycheck. Inflation is an emission problem and Bitcoin solves it.
- lazyjones 7y ago4 years older than the author, learned to program on a Philips P2000. Was impressed when my dad told me how they punched cards and he could read punched tape quickly. Now I'm finally getting old apparently because I don't use VR stuff, Instagram, Snapchat and TikTok (don't use Twitter because it's such a waste of precious time). By the way, computer UIs are still too slow. Fix your web pages / networks.
- fuzzfactor 7y agoPunched a number of cards in pursuit of natural science, never did get to Fortran77 since it wasn't 1977 yet. On a new W98 PC after reverting to a more optimized W95 install without including Windows Networking, using a top hardware modem on a clean POTS line having full 56K performance, the snappy user response sometimes seen today with broadband at sites like Ebay, Amazon & Yahoo, was usually outmatched by almost all sites at the time, and that was with only a 100MHz Pentium, 32MB memory, and less than 1GB HDD. You could generally browse faster on dial-up (once logged in) than you can on broadband today. Downloads OTOH were dramatically slower with such a limited data rate. Nice MIDI was also standard on all consumer PC's, without USB latency.
- abafazi 7y agowow
- Causality1 7y agoI think most people have a cultural experience they're a little proud of avoiding. For example, I've never seen a single episode of the Simpsons. I do think, however, that we should remind ourselves that while being different is not a bad thing, it also isn't an inherently good thing. Is your life about you or is it about other people? If it's about you, then maybe it's worth checking to see if you like something that a whole lot of other people like too.
- bilekas 7y ago> Entropy is hard to beat, I know. But, not today old age, not today. Great write up and I share a lot of those fond memories!
- Koshkin 7y agoBTW not sure if it's entropy that plays the biggest role in aging, at least some of the processes responsible for it seem to be programmed (depending on the species).
- draw_down 7y agoThere is a sort of machismo/bragging about not knowing or understanding what the kids are up to these days. Do what you like but it doesn’t make you interesting or wise to not know what an Instagram story is, sorry. (I was born in ‘81 fwiw)
- mark_l_watson 7y agoI liked that. I am am 68 and although I 'retired' last year (from managing a deep learning team at Capital One), I stay active. Currently I am writing a combined iOS and macOS app (so I needed to spin up on Swift and SwiftUI, and how to use built in support for building deep learning models, instead TensorFlow which is what I am used to). I recently published a book on the very cool Hy Lisp programming language (you can read it free at https://leanpub.com/hy-lisp-python https://leanpub.com/hy-lisp-python). I get inspiration from my father. He is 98 and has taught himself 3D animation and video editing, and keeps himself very busy creating videos for the international right to die organization. (He was a physicist and is still a member of the National Academy of Sciences.) So, for all you young 50 year olds, I say to you: it is not over until it is over :-)
- jmeister 7y agoYou could also take inspiration from all the age 70+ candidates interviewing for the most important job in the world :-)
- moksly 7y agoI’m 37 and as such doesn’t qualify as old, but I recently got into the Blood Bowl hobby. I haven’t done miniatures since I was a little kid, but some of my real world friends picked it up and I was quick to jump on the wagon as I had been looking for a non-digital hobby. Anyway, being 37 my purchasing power is obviously a lot greater than it was the last time I was into miniatures, and that has lead me down a rabbit hole of hobbyists who enjoy miniature war/board games (not really sure what to call them yet). A lot of these people are well into their 60ies, yet they attend weekly brawls at local libraries. They hold weekend tournaments. Have lively Facebook groups to organise their different leagues and everyone is welcome. It’s really been inspiring to see that old age can be a lot different than what it’s been for my own family members.
- appleshore 7y agoI don’t get the idea of acclaimed non-understanding. Posting live (or recent) random photos that I don’t want permanently on my wall, isn’t a difficult phenomenon to grasp. Trying to maintain social connections by updating and reminding friends and family what you’re doing seems pretty normal. Wanting to chat dangerously or explicitly or just not wanting to torture yourself by seeing all your old Facebook Messenger chats explains the need for Snapchat rather well (and Signal). Making goofy hyper-kinetic short videos makes sense. (What doesn’t make sense to me is using TikTok over Thriller considering the social-implications of an authoritarian-owned app for free expression.) I don’t believe people when they say they don’t understand kids today or only young founders can build the tools for the next generation. What I don’t get is playing video games for 12-hours a day and immersing yourself in a digital word, with all synthetic friends so to speak. But I understand why people do it. It’s as unhealthy as any other digital obsession or anything that isolates us from the most innovation and rejuvenating social app and video game: reality.
- jhoechtl 7y agoMany of your saying resonates with what I experience(d). Never watched GoT either ;) Got my first computer later though. But BW TV and smoking on airplanes was a thing I remember well. The later absolutely incredible these days.
- rodolphoarruda 7y agoIt's interesting to see how much history and evolution of things can be seen in such a short period of time. We can assume that this will trend will get stronger to newer generations, meaning that in 20 years' time the person writing this type of essay could be making it twice or 3 times bigger due to the amount of things to be said. Looking at consumer electronic goods alone, this is a mind blogging perspective. 12 years ago I used to watch movies with my fiancee on a tube TV and DVDs. Now I watch Netflix with my kids on a 4K UHD screen connected to the Internet via a fiber optic cable. Who knows the stories my kids will be telling when they reach my age.
- k-ian 7y agook boomer
- jagira 7y agoI am quite curious about the demographics of HN. My guess is most of us here are 30+. Since this is the top story right now, this will give us a vague idea about the demographics. Reply in your age group child comment thread.
- daxfohl 7y agoPretty happy I've detached a bit. I completely quit news a year ago. Actively change the radio station when any mention of politics comes up. To the point that I didn't know there was an impeachment trial until a couple months in. I don't know or even want to know at this point whether that is over or what the outcome was. Same for brexit, the muller investigation, etc. And I feel much better about life now. Finally unblocked some news sites to follow the covid story, and a year away really worked. It's so nice to see all the political headlines and not be interested any more than if they were Hollywood or whatever else I'm not into.
- tylerritchie 7y agoIt sounds like you're making good choices for your mental health. It also seems like taking that approach to the extreme by checking out of politics entirely (e.g. not voting, or uninformed voting) is a great way to delegate really important decisions about your life and things you find important to people who you may not trust to make those decisions. For instance, I don't believe the people who vote the most often in the US (wealthier, older individuals) are best suited to choosing legislators, executives, and laws. Those individuals tend to prefer: - fewer environmental protections (I like swimming and fishing in clean rivers and oceans) -lower education funding (I wish everyone who wanted to learn about fisheries, welding, nursing, biology, etc. could afford to do so) - subsidies for themselves at the expense of younger generations (second mortgage interest deductions, elimination of estate taxes, country club tax exemptions, California's 1978 Proposition 13) - legislation based on bad science or religious faith (no guaranteed paid sick leave, backdoor encryption bills, violent video game bans, book bans, corporal punishment support, for-profit prisons, abstinence-only sex education) Calling your legislators and telling them to support or oppose legislation or impeachment isn't for everyone, similarly reading story after story about incurious individuals legislating emerging technology might be unhealthy in general. That said, voting for and against candidates and issues at election time is really a very, very inexpensive way to attempt to make your life more into what you want it to be (for either the betterment or detriment to humanity).
- lainga 7y agoThanks for your opinions. Please have a good participation in the political system.
- Steffi128 7y agoSince the author is using Twitter, I guess he'll get the purpose of stories once Twitter launches its new “Fleets“ feature. https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/04/twitter-starts-testing-its-own-version-of-stories-called-fleets-which-disappear-after-24-hours/ https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/04/twitter-starts-testing-its...
- xorand 7y agoOh sweet memories. I was born in 1967, so I'm older than the author, but the memories are somehow the same. I started with a Sinclair ZX Spectrum clone, called HC85, and with Basic as first language. I discovered the Mosaic browser in 1994 at Ecole Polytechnique, Paris, and understood that the future of research, publication, collaboration will be very different than the past. I'm a mathematician. I installed my first Linux in 1995. All in all in my life I bought exactly 0 bits of proprietary programs. I had for a very short time a FB account, which I deleted. I deleted my Twitter account about two years ago. I was hooked by Google+ and I had a popular collection about artificial life (now is public again). But I deleted my g+account before they closed it. All my family has smartphones, but I can't stand the limitations. When the smartphones will be liberated I'll have one. My overall impression is that, some details excepted, now that everybody has a computer in the pocket, people pass through the same learning process as we nerds did some years ago. Today is harder, because less freedom. On the other side, the new thing is that today everybody is online.
- Koshkin 7y agoSuper, grand-père !
- xorand 7y agoI upvoted this, but it is not accurate. If you're French then you may be misled by the combination of two signals: "Ecole Polytechnique (X)" (aka "social status") and birth date (aka "old"). This gives "boomer" hence the sarcasm. Now that memories are mentioned, I'm not a grand-pere, nor French. Grand-peres are proud of their '69 youth. Yes, they stopped the social elevator and I share your opinion about them. "X" was relevant only for the availability of (mostly empty) rooms full of "unix workstations" and the friends I made in Paris. During this time, your grand-pere probably was vaguely proud about the minitel and a bit disturbed about the fact that people like me are allowed to study at X.
- LeonenTheDK 7y agoI'd love to hear more about what a "liberated" smartphone looks like to you. Do you mean more like normal computers where you're free to do just about whatever (only in the smartphone form factor)?
- dpcan 7y agoHe knows that millions and millions of other people are old too doesn't he? And he thinks he's different because he doesn't consume the same pop-culture stuff that he thinks MOST people do. Only 17.4 Million people watched Game of Thrones. There are 209 Million adults in the United States. That means 8% of adults watched this program in the United States. How is that "most" by any standard anywhere? EDIT: Correction, he doesn't even say "most" he says "everyone".
- Spearchucker 7y agoPretty certain he described his generalized perception - I doubt he'd stand by it as an absolute.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lcall 7y agoWith everything going on, it is more important than ever to have purpose and direction in life. For one thing, it lets one freely & more peacefully ignore many things in popular culture, because they are irrelevant or unhelpful, and focus more on things that matter, intentionally chosen. My detailed thoughts on that, whether religious or not (no sales or JS) are at: http://lukecall.net/e-9223372036854588981.html http://lukecall.net/e-9223372036854588981.html
- nessunodoro 7y ago> "If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking." -- Haruki Murakami, Norwegian Wood There's value to this sentiment, but I disagree. I'm the same age as the author of this post, and I remember when I was in high school, my parents were transfixed by the O.J. Simpson trial - the car chase, the analysis of Marcia Clark's outfits, the whole spectacle. In college a few years later a media studies professor asked us for a show of hands as to who followed the Simpson trial. Groans, eye rolls, not many raised hands. He was blunt: ignoring media phenomena, especially repulsive ones, is a mistake, he said, if you want to understand how media affect our culture. Study them like a physician studies a virus.
- oytis 7y agoEveryone is getting old. Stay strong, Murat! Also to me a distinctive marker of being young is using Snapchat and TikTok. People of my generation (30+) are actively using stories, but haven't heard of any Snapchat experience from everyone.
- trustfundbaby 7y agoexactly, for my generation (right in between gen x and millennials) that's the marker. If someone uses snapchat, they're probably younger than we all are, by a fair amount. Nobody I know uses it, I signed up for it when I bought the stock, just to make sure I understood the appeal, ditched it and the stock about a year or two later.
- eMSF 7y ago> I was born in 1976. I understand that in the eyes of millennials 1976 is around the same time period as 1796. My son sometimes asks me if TV was invented when I was a child. Assuming these sentences are somehow connected, and you have a millenial son (which you got by the time you were about 20), and at around 25 or so he is still uncertain whether TV was invented in the 70s; I'm sorry, but he is a bit ignorant at best. Otherwise you are being more than a bit condescending towards a group of people, some of whom are little more than 5 years your junior...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoHeh. My kids ask me what it was like to see the dinosaurs. (And, yes, they know. They're pestering me, but they're not stupid.)
- rootusrootus 7y agoI didn't take the commentary nearly as seriously as you did. It sounded completely tongue-in-cheek. But, what can I say, I was born in 1974...
- DantesKite 7y agoI once attended a small lecture about an experiment where researchers trained elderly participants new skills; namely Spanish, painting, and using iPads. It was a somewhat challenging course. It required a lot of work and a few dropped out because of it. But the participants that stayed developed their skills and after a few weeks, surprised themselves and much of their friends and family with their progress. You can imagine how stunning it would be to know someone all your life and then at the ripe age of 82, watch them do something you've never seen before. Grandma went from not knowing about iPads to using them better than some 20 year olds. And Grandpa now draws and sketches figures like an artist. Who knew they had such potential? The reaction of people who didn't know them was quite interesting too. "You have such talent" (as if what they had learned was something they were blessed with). The researchers made a point to emphasize how people would phrase their compliments; it was surprisingly common (as if they had been given God-given talents, instead of raw skill through focus and training). And the participants were just as surprised about their growth. They didn't believe they could still learn something new (it wasn't a real possibility in their mind). Over the years, they had built an image of who they were, what they could and couldn't do, staying within the confines of their self-imposed limits, unconscious as they were. Listening to those researchers left me with some reflections about my own life, the trajectory of it, the things I'd choose to become. Part of me suspects there's some truth to wisdom and old age—the younger generation doesn't always step forward in the right direction. Cynicism of the youth is rightly justified. Choosing not to participate in the popular culture leaves some room for your own personal interests. What people call "weirdness". So be it. True expression sometimes leads you down unfamiliar roads. But some days, my pride and lack of knowledge feels like an excuse to stay inside hidden doors, lamenting about the change of the world, because I couldn't keep up with it. I try not to become that person. I try not to cut off too many branches. I don't know where they'll lead, what I can become. It would be a shame to grow old, to abandon all paths, because they seemed too distant.
- lubujackson 7y agoI am around the same age as this guy and so much of it is mindset. My dad worked in a university computer lab for 30 years but at some point gave up learning new technologies. He doesn't own a smartphone. Barely uses email. I set up his Roku but he won't use it, just watching whatever is on TV. Meanwhile, my neighbor is 90+ and recently asked me deep historical questions about the internet, like about ARPA, protocols, DNS... stuff many software engineers never bother learning about. He pushed until I couldn't go any deeper, then he was disappointed. It really just comes down to being more curious than lazy. And also changing how you learn what is worth learning - asking people who invest energy into what is good is a great way to save yourself time. Getting older means you recognize patterns in things, so you stop digging past the surface in a way you used to. Any time I watch an old music video on YouTube inevitably someone says "musicians today are garbage compared to this" without ever looking past (or even at) the most vanilla Top 40 music . But music is awesome right now, collaborative and unchained, whole careers spanning and unfolding on YouTube. Those same people who are posting about how great Bob Dylan is weren't listening to The Archies on Top 40 radio, they dug past it when they were young but no longer put in the effort. You need to find new ways to find the good stuff - spend energy when you are young learning how to be more efficient with your curiosity!
- noobermin 7y agoTbh I feel like Gen X'ers will make better older people than Boomers ever could.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI'm 57. I was a manager for many years, but kept my tech chops up by doing side projects in the open-source world for a long time. Some of those projects have become pretty intense and big. Nowadays, I'm working on becoming one of the best Swift programmers around. It's progressing. I'm fairly good at picking up on things, and I've been programming Swift with release-level code since the day it was announced (not 100-line Stack Overflow answer code. Full-fat App Store release code). My latest learning gig is Bluetooth. I've already written a pretty powerful OBD driver (still has more to go, but it already beats a lot of what's out there. Did I mention that I'm not bad at this stuff?). I've taken a break from that in order to write up an open series on implementing Core Bluetooth as a cross-platform (Apple Platforms) SDK. But, according to a lot of folks, I just need to walk out into the desert to die.
- nojvek 7y agoWow. Incredibly cool. Would love to see your projects. Got a GitHub link ?
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoCheck my HN handle. I have links to everything there. https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=ChrisMarshallNY https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=ChrisMarshallNY The Core Bluetooth thing is still very much a WIP. If you want to peek at it before it's ready, drop me an email.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoI will also say that writing a teaching series on this is quite humbling. If I were to implement this SDK on my own, I'd probably get it done in a day or two; but stopping to make sure that I do things in digestible chunks, and explaining what I'm doing at each step, is dragging it out a lot. It may take a couple of weeks for me to write this up.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoFor anyone that's interested, I have it pretty much done. I'll probably take the wraps off officially, tomorrow: https://littlegreenviper.com/series/bluetooth/ https://littlegreenviper.com/series/bluetooth/
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y ago> I have seen peer-to-peer networks become a thing, and then not become a thing. Mesh networks, with the ubiquity of cell phones, have got to be one of the big lost opportunities of our day and age.
- patchtopic 7y agoso do people who proudly crow that they didn't watch GoT get rewarded with little gold stars or something?
- msh317 7y agoLike the author I'm also 68 years old I'm a contributor to the open source of TensorFlow and dozens of other code projects that the youngsters today often take for granted I'm still very active I build cities for a living and I'm about to publish a new paper that bills a form of mathematics that more closely models the structure of our universe I'm a co-author on a paper recently published on a practical form of quantum communications In my youth I solved dozens of mathematical problems that others considered unsolvable The world and the universe is an amazing place and age is really just part of our imagination I also stay active everyday and contribute to my community This is a great story and a reminder of how valuable our ancestors are to our everyday lives Consider for a moment the reverence the typical first Nation communities have for the experience and wisdom of their elders
- cmarschner 7y agoI‘m about the same age as the author, and I realized (again) yesterday how little music written since about 2000 means to me. I never listen to radio music because I detest it. I don‘t understand how people get to know other kinds of music without wading through tons of really bad music. I do have a fairly good understanding of the music from the 50s to 90s though, and partly to classical music. But the music from the 00s and 10s make me feel old.
- rdxhacker 7y agoHii dear i wanna hacke cpanel plz suggested me
- rdxhacker 7y agoHii wanna cpanel hacke plz suggested me
- rdiddly 7y ago"I still don't have any idea what Instagram or Facebook stories is." Good news: They're both shit and you don't need to worry about it. Just get back to being productive, mature, calm and focused/disciplined like an old person, and let spazzy young people keep obsessing over signaling & getting laid. They're not a good source of advice for how to live YOUR life, because they've spent most of THEIR short-ass lives cooped up in schools with people almost identical to themselves, obsessing over tiny differences & declaring certain ones in or out. Be who you are or you've lost everything.