20 ms·
Firefox is showing the way back to a world that’s private by default
- dcabrejas 7y agoI love what Firefox stands for. They are not the only one but for sure they are keeping the balance of the web when it comes to privacy and security. Unfortunately as their market share drops, they have less and less say in the future of the platform.
- Etheryte 7y agoI'm not sure whether to agree with your last statement. While historically, Firefox lost troves of market share to Chrome, currently they seem to be fairly stable [1]. While tech boards are definitely a small fraction of users, the general notion around Firefox seems to be more positive recently than say, a few years ago, so I wouldn't be surprised to see them take back at least some of the lost share. While Chrome is currently a very dominant player, it's around the same level of usage that Internet Explorer was historically so market shifts of that scale are definitely possible. [1] https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share#monthly-201002-202002 https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share#monthly-2010...
- cm2187 7y agoPlus Google may want to keep them alive like MSFT with Apple or Intel with AMD to keep the regulators away.
- Arnt 7y agoWell, that's true, "may". Why, though? As far as I can tell the only part of Google that competes with Firefox is Chrome, and Chrome doesn't seem to be profitable, or even intended to be profitable. As far as I can tell Chrome's just a moat to keep people from using the Facebook app instead of a web browser. So... why? Tell me why I'm wrong, teach me something today.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoThey might face regulation e.g. in the EU (but also the US) based on antitrust or competition laws, as they would effectively be dominating the browser market. That would limit their freedom to operate, so I can believe that it's in their best interest to "allow" competitors like Firefox to capture a small market share. Effectively they could kill them easily as a large percentage of Mozilla's revenue (I think more than 50 %) comes from the Google search deal, and I don't think that deal is really vital to Google. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation
- Arnt 7y agoBut if Firefox only competes with Chrome, and the regulators are angry because of Chrome, why would Google not simply shut Chrome down? I mean that I don't see any reson why Chrome needs to compete against Firefox. I can see arguments why Google needs to compete against Facebook: Those two compete for advertising customers. Funding one, two, a few browsers makes sense if the goal is to keep eyeballs on the web rather than letting Facebook tempt them into a walled garden. But why would Google care which of the browsers has most success? And if Google doesn't, why would regulators care?
- ThePhysicist 7y agoChrome is a strategic tool for Google that they use to funnel users to their services, collect data and influence web standards in their favor (among other things).
- adgasf 7y agoGoogle keeps Chrome around because the alternative is just too risky for their core business. If (for example) everyone used IE then Microsoft would be able to shut out Google's ads.
- Arnt 7y agoThat's what I thought too (ie. that Google is critically dependent on web browsers that don't discriminate against Google somehow, and is paying for two such browsers). But so many people say that Chrome and Firefox are competitors that I'm curious to hear arguments for that.
- thdrdt 7y agoWell your example is kind of perfect. Around 70% of the Firefox users are blocking trackers. And Statcounter is using trackers for their stats. So the stats are very misleading. They might even prove that Firefox is very privacy aware.
- aembleton 7y agoIt would be good if Cloudflare would publish browser stats. They collect stats from user agents that are likely to be more accurate and probably cover more of the web than Stat Counter.
- Scapeghost 7y agoApple has some good muscle in the privacy war too, if for no other reason than to reduce Google's advantage. Not sure what Microsoft's game plan is though, apart from preloading Windows with spyware.
- 76543210 7y agoDon't confuse marketing with how the company actually acts.
- viraptor 7y agoDo you want to fill in the details about how you see the company acting? It's a pretty glib statement otherwise.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoThem and how going to Chinese market is a fair example.
- terminaljunkid 7y agoI will fill in.. Google never "sells" your data to third parties. They keep the data themselves for advertisement purpose. On the contrary, apple shares any collected data with advertisement partners. Apple fanboys don't realize this. Apart from agressive and deceptive marketing, Apple is a shitty company that asserts patents on rounded corners of phones and optional chaining in programming languages (Swift). They are objectively more evil than Google in my book. Apparently I am biased. I would not have been in CSE if Google didn't commoditize the market. My first encounter to programming was on an Android terminal. But that's another story.
- Scapeghost 7y agoNone of that is true, aside from maybe your first encounter with programming.
- Lio 7y agoFor me it’s about the dev experience. I’ve noticed that Firefox dev tools are getting better over the last year or so. They’ve got some neat things like their CSS Grid editor and websocket inspector. I still find it easier to clear application data in Chrome and Google Hangouts echos for me in Firefox but I’m moving towards Firefox by default on every platform.
- leshenka 7y agoI love CSS Grid inspector in FF! I also like the "Changes" tab in Inspector that lets me play with CSS in browser and copy-paste it in editor later. The only thing I miss from Chrome is "emulate focused page" checkbox, it's useful when you're debugging dropdowns, for example.
- raxxorrax 7y agoYou do not need to balance privacy with security. That is in most cases a false dichotomy. On the contrary, real security needs privacy and the other way around. Especially on the web there are nearly no exceptions to this. Don't think too much of my ranting against the security argument, but I see it as a pure invention of politics from "hard liners" with a solid extroverted inferiority complex and a bad emotion driven risk assessment. Otherwise I agree that Firefox stands for privacy and security.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoGiven firefox users massively block trackers, way more than chrome which actually links your google account with your browser login, I wonder how accurate are the stats. Firefox did lose market shares, but it's possible we see lots of chrome users also because they are more visible. Related, although a different problem, one of the biggest stat providers is Google analytics, and a lot of sites make decisions based on those, but Google has no incentive to check if they are missing some non chrome users.
- DeusExMachina 7y agoI think (but I have no idea) that browsers are tracked by their user agent, which they always send.
- krige 7y agoIndeed, however Firefox often masks its user agent as websites falsely report broken and missing features for non-chrome browsers. User agent is growingly meaningless as a metric.
- randomdude402 7y agoOne of the first things I do on a new Firefox install is add a user-agent switcher and set it up to tell sites I am using chrome for exactly this reason. Somehow we have gone back to the dark ages of web where sites complain unless you are using one specific browser. It was the more technical minded people who spread the word and mindshare of browser choice back then to get us out of that mess, and now the same group has gotten us back into it worse than ever. I'll never understand how this happened.
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoUser agent override is a builtin feature in firefox for ages.
- 7y ago
- bad_user 7y agoIf Firefox keeps being relevant for software developers, by continuing to improve their dev tools and providing an API that yields more potent extensions (like the Tree Style Tabs), then I believe Firefox will continue to be very relevant, because its market share will continue to be made of users with the ability to influence policies, in corporations, public institutions and inside their own family, not to mention compatibility with Firefox will be preserved. Firefox has nearly lost developers to Chrome, because (1) Chrome was designed for web apps and you can see this in their process per tab model and isolation, features which took a loooong time to be implemented by their competition, (2) Chrome's dev tools have been for a while superior and still are in some areas, (3) Chrome is popular, it makes sense to target the browser that's most popular, so might as well use it as a default and (4) Chrome really had better performance than Firefox, or at least perceived performance, especially when it comes to Google's own apps. Nowadays Firefox has finally moved to having a permissions system for its add-ons and to using multiple processes for its tabs, while still being better in terms of memory usage, especially with a lot of tabs open, a use-case that was and is still viable on top of the latest Firefox. I'm now more familiar with its dev tools and they've gotten better. Performance is sometimes on par with Chrome, sometimes better, sometimes worse ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ ... people complain about the performance of Gmail, but truth be told the performance of Gmail is now crap on top of Chrome too and I'd rather use native clients. And I'm super pleased with many of the privacy changes they've been doing — built-in blocking of trackers, DoH (yes, I think DoH is great), multi-account containers which also allows for sandboxing Facebook or Google, plus I'm pretty sure they'll continue to support uBlock Origin, which isn't something we can say about Google and their deprecations in manifest v3. They still have a lot to work on — better dev tools, battery life on MacOS could be better, a customizable interface that doesn't rely on "legacy stylesheets" (primarily thinking of hiding main tab bar while using the Tree Style Tabs add-on), etc, but I'm sure they'll get there and I'm happy with how it is right now. I used to use Firefox because I wanted to keep them relevant, but nowadays I feel like Firefox is simply the better browser and it will continue to be relevant for as long as software developers such as myself keep using it.
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoNoScript (block by default) is the most potent extension a software developer needs in a browser.
- mariushn 7y agoSome reasons for decreasing market share: https://news.softpedia.com/news/microsoft-begins-showing-an-anti-firefox-ad-in-the-windows-10-start-menu-529137.shtml https://news.softpedia.com/news/microsoft-begins-showing-an-... https://www.zdnet.com/article/former-mozilla-exec-google-has-sabotaged-firefox-for-years/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/former-mozilla-exec-google-has... This also means decreasing referral revenue from Google, so fewer resources available. I believe Mozilla should strike back with https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/open-letter-mozilla-please-offer-g-suite-alternative-marius-andreiana https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/open-letter-mozilla-please-of...
- acqq 7y agoHow is concentrating DNS to even less "points of possible collection" of any advantage to user's privacy? My opinion is not far from nullc's: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22415794 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22415794 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22419657 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22419657 "I see this as massively centralizing DNS request data (onto cloudflare) and this change is the most problematic part of the whole thing." The less companies and locations one have to intrude to be able to "see" or influence DNS responses, the easier it is for a competent attacker. And from a legal standpoint, at once even more information which would have before remained in some other countries is easily (even trivially) obtainable.
- robin_reala 7y agoYou’re focusing on CloudFlare, but already I have a choice of a couple of DNS-over-HTTPS providers in my preferences, and I see no reason why it would stick at just two.
- acqq 7y ago> already I have a choice of a couple of DNS-over-HTTPS providers in my preferences Can you please cite that "couple" and also how you believe a typical user would ever change the default?
- robin_reala 7y agoThe dropdown has CloudFlare, NextDNS and Custom (that opens a text input). As for users changing this, sure, that’s not going to happen. But I can imagine a world where the default is that your requests are fanned out randomly to a choice of hundreds or thousands of providers, with no clear and complete picture of a single user in the event that a single provider is compromised.
- ThePhysicist 7y agoYes, that would be a good option. They should've just waited for more providers switching to DoH before they turned this on by default, IMO.
- dkdbejwi383 7y agoIf Apple allowed changing default apps on iOS I'd use Firefox everywhere.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoFirefox can't really exist on iOS, only a shell on top of apple's browser engine.
- Yoric 7y agoFor what it's worth, there used to be a "full" Firefox for iOS, about 10 years ago. Apple blocked its release, though.
- savolai 7y agoThe rendering engine is largely irrelevant to me as a user on mobile. (Though of course having the actual one would be better.) Firefox sync is the meat of the deal.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoSure if you don't want modern browser features like web worker, addons, and updates.
- endemic 7y agoAgreed, sync is a great feature, but last I checked iOS content blockers only work with Safari, not any other apps that use WKWebView. So stupidly, I have both Focus and Firefox on my iOS phone, but only Safari can use the Focus content blocker. It’s pretty terrible.
- jagger27 7y agoI find it super odd that Firefox Focus doesn't let you sign into Firefox Sync. I would just use that browser for everything.
- ymolodtsov 7y ago
- Nextgrid 7y agoWhat Mozilla is doing with Firefox regarding privacy is mostly a sham. Lots of talk but little action. First off, if they were real about privacy they'd include uBlock Origin by default (and why not HTTPS Everywhere for good measure as well). Their current tracking "protection" is an absolute joke that explicitly whitelists Facebook and Google, the two biggest offenders when it comes to privacy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20112398 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20112398 They should also remove Google Analytics from their website, or at least the pages that the browser will automatically load on first use or after an update. While Google claims they have some special relationship with Mozilla regarding this and they won't use the data for any other purposes, it's hard to trust them - Facebook for example used to say that phone numbers would only be used for 2FA and yet somehow they ended up being used for advertising. They should also make the telemetry opt-in instead of opt-out like it is now. Their current way of doing it might actually be in breach of the GDPR, as any non-essential data collection and processing must be opt-in.
- heartbeats 7y agoI don't see why you're getting downvoted. You're 100% right. Mozilla get money from Google and spend it on fun projects which have nothing to do with the web. This creates some very bad incentives with regard to privacy on the net. Mozilla don't seem to care about this, they just take the money and keep going.
- coribuci 7y ago> I don't see why you're getting downvoted. You're 100% right. Mozilla get money from Google and spend it on fun projects which have nothing to do with the web. Because there are some people here which work in "user data industry". >This creates some very bad incentives with regard to privacy on the net. Mozilla don't seem to care about this, they just take the money and keep going. Bad for you. Good for them (for the moment). They (the people who work there) will maybe regret it. But as Stasi or NSA showed there will be no discrimination in the usage of this data.
- terminaljunkid 7y agoMozilla particularly has really bad suit-dominant administration. Brendan Eich is here on HN. He can explain better.
- pixelbreaker 7y ago"Tracking shouldn't be the norm" subtitle on the verge, which currently has ~12 trackers being blocked in my browser.
- ewfwfewefewfwef 7y agoThere was a similar discussion last week (or so). It was basically said that even if "the media" does track us, it's still a good thing "they" allow some autors to write about privacy. That's my (new) opinion on this.
- ekzy 7y agoI get your point but it's still a good thing that the authors are writing about tracking. It's probably a different team working on the website and I'd hope articles like this open people eyes even internally at the verge
- tialaramex 7y agoIndeed the firewall at old-fashioned newspapers (between editorial and advert sales) was vital to their independence and dissolving this (today you can buy "native advertising" which only the most careful reader will realise isn't editorial) has been part of their downfall. You actively want the people who write the stories to be shielded from whatever the people making money to pay for those stories do. Every time a journalist even feels like they shouldn't write a story because it'll lose their paper (or TV channel, or website) money that's a problem. That doesn't mean the media aren't worth criticising, but it means you should aim for it to be possible for that critique to come from within. Funding models other than advertising are good, but they're not realistic for very broad media. I might give money to a person who writes (or talks or makes videos) about a subject I care very deeply about, but who is going to give money to the people doing a morning breakfast show or a mid-size city newspaper? Those things are expensive and advertising remains a realistic way to fund them.
- IAmEveryone 7y agoJournalists writing critically about tracking should be seen as pretty clear evidence against a bunch of the conspiracy theories you often see floating around[0]. To turn this against them seems strange. Ignoring for a second that "putting trackers on the website", writing these articles, and deciding to publish them are the actions of at least three different people/groups, I don't quite get what you are accusing "them" off? It's perfectly possible to criticise trackers or advertising and still feel the need to use them for economic survival. I'd be surprised if less than 90% of the people in this thread critical of tracking have Google Analytics tags even on their personal websites, where it doesn't serve any purpose except vanity. And that's OK. Running trackers and criticising them is still better than just running them, in the same way that smoking & regular exercise is better than just smoking. [0]: HN being particularly dense (pun not entirely intended), and willing to get itself into the most weird contortions of logic to find mechanisms of how some writer might gain some immediate financial gain from some article.
- seemslegit 7y agoMozilla depends almost entirely on Google and other advertisement companies for revenue, whatever privacy posturing they put in place is just means to drive people away from extensions whose block lists Mozilla does not control.
- smt88 7y agoMost users are going to use Google regardless. You could say that the user trusts Google, even if we know they shouldn't. Firefox cripples Google's ability to track the user either way, especially with uBlock Origin and Google Container installed. Even better, it prevents ISPs and other parties that the user doesn't trust from tracking them.
- seemslegit 7y agoWhy does one's use of google services allow you to assume that they trust google but one's use of an ISP services doesn't assume they trust the ISP ?
- smt88 7y agoBecause in the US, most ISPs are a monopoly. Google isn't.
- seemslegit 7y agoOk let's roll with this, although just between the cellular data carriers there are more choices than between web-scale search engines or smartphone platforms. If you had plenty of ISPs to choose from and all were in the habit of mining and monetizing your browsing data simply because that's legal and profitable should Mozilla recognize you as implicitly trusting the most dominant one that also happens to be paying them ?
- smt88 7y agoIt's a false analogy. Not all search engines track or monetize you. A user can choose DuckDuckGo. There is no DuckDuckGo for ISPs. This hypothetical is even less relevant when you consider that Mozilla protects you from Google using blockers and also from ISPs using DNS over HTTPS.
- heartbeats 7y agoAnd yet, they don't block ads by default. They should do that. Cut a deal with some ad provider to serve non-tracking ads, and leave the rest in the dust. This would make Firefox a much more pleasant experience than other browsers, and give them some well-needed cash.
- lopis 7y agoI don't what my browser to start changing the content of the pages I visit. Blocking well known trackers, sure. But the browser should be a platform. It's not like uBlock is flawless - there are tons of false positives so using it should be your own choice.
- pornel 7y agoThat is harder to justify. Tracking is an invasion of privacy, so blocking of trackers can be seen as a defense. But blocking non-tracking ads, just because users don't like them and Mozilla could make a buck, would be seen an attack on publishers' revenue, even when publishers tried to do the right thing.
- mattmanser 7y agoYes, but it'd be more than that, it would basically be theft.
- buboard 7y agoMozilla is supposed to be a friend of webdevs. By blocking their income without providing an alternative , or some other kind of benefit, webmasters are going to turn their backs to it.
- allenskd 7y agoIt's been 2-3 years since I switched back to Firefox ever since I cut around 90% of Google out of my life, sadly I still can't find a good search engine where I don't spend more than 5 mins trying different keywords to get the results google gives me. Out of all the browsers I like that Mozilla were the first to point the finger to the elephant in the room while Microsoft, Google, Opera just turned a blind eye on privacy, although I don't think anyone expects much from Google these days. Firefox has once again became my default browser on all my devices after like 6-8 years since I last used it. I guess as far as privacy concerns goes, if you are looking for a company/browser that will continue working on protecting you from trackers by default that'd be Mozilla. Random observations that doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the topic: Firefox for windows is perfect. I actually think it's faster on Windows than on OSX for whatever reason. Playing videos, like using Netflix or Youtube is extremely sluggish on Firefox OSX, but is fine on Windows. I always end up using Safari if I want to watch a video on a higher resolution because the performance drags a lot on Firefox, especially it Netflix's overlay UI you can literally observe it's lagging behind but not in Safari.
- npsomaratna 7y agoI switched to DuckDuckgo a few months ago, and never looked back. The results used to be far inferior to Google's - but they seem to have caught up recently. If you haven't tried them out within the last couple of months, I strongly recommend that you give them a chance.
- Pangia 7y agoI switched to DuckDuckGo a number of years ago and while yes, their results have become better there are times in my line of work where I've had to use !g search item as Google still seems have to have the best results sometimes. Granted this is maybe once or twice in 3 - 4 months I end up using !g prefix.
- pixelrevision 7y agoAnother helpful thing that can be done with Firefox is to add google.com to a container. One of the things google does that I really dislike is personalized search. Having a container specified for it lets me use the browser more naturally without having to open a private session.
- afrcnc 7y agoNo, they're not. Stop glorifying this crap and giving dissidents a fake sense of security. Recommend Tor.
- bayindirh 7y agoCan you please elaborate?
- zzzcpan 7y agoThere is an actual privacy community with Tor at the center of it, with plenty of research and serious ideas. And there is "privacy" propaganda that Mozilla and other corporations are putting out, it doesn't do anything good for privacy whatsoever, it's all bullshit. So calling it "fake sense of security" is somewhat appropriate here.
- bayindirh 7y agoI'm not against tor, I also support it but, the high cost of running exit nodes combined with suspected state-run nodes were also casting a shadow over tor when I last checked it. Mozilla's privacy run is not total stealth which, tor claims and strives to provide. On the other hand, Mozilla is providing practical cross-site tracking prevention which can be used by non tech-savvy people. IMHO, the tracking protection provided by Mozilla is beneficial for normal users. We, the more technical ones, can always setup or use something more advanced and elaborate as tor. As the cherry on top, some countries effectively block tor. Which leaves a bad taste in the mouth tbh.
- ymolodtsov 7y agoHacker News community at its finest. The guy probably runs his own FTP server instead of Dropbox, I mean, it's so easy to mount and use.
- buboard 7y agodropbox sucks these days. OneDrive is better, and syncthing for the rest
- Havoc 7y agoYup. FF + uOrigin + pi hole seem to be keeping things at bay...for now.
- 72deluxe 7y agoUntil DOHS arrives at an OS level! Then you and I are scuppered.
- LinuxBender 7y agopi-hole can address that be either adding its own DoH proxy, or by null routing / firewalling the most commonly known DoH DNS endpoints and having a local DNS record to NXDOMAIN use-application-dns.net while browsers respect it (to disable DoH). Adding Unbound DNS example below. local-zone: "use-application-dns.net" always_nxdomain This assumes that pi-hole is your router and not just a resolver. This could be done in OpenWRT as well. I just use a generic Linux router at home.
- 72deluxe 7y agoThanks for this. I'll try this on my pi-hole.
- 101404 7y agoThere are other browsers better than Ff that focus on privacy just the same, if not more aggressively. Mozilla lost track when they started with their FfPhone, FfOS, and other bullshit projects. They forgot about their core product and it shows. Ff is still way slower, even with the Rust parts they took from Servo. Then that they kick out their best developers if they have a "wrong opinion" (in the sjw's view) doesn't help either.
- jen20 7y agoWhich ones? I'm often interested in switching away from Safari, but the default has been Firefox so far, which has not been worthwhile outside of a second browser for when Ghostery et al are too aggressive for some vital site.
- 101404 7y agoI am using Brave. It's one of the browsers listed by Protonmail in their docs. That's when I decided it's probably trustworthy.
- jasonlotito 7y agohttps://protonmail.com/support/knowledge-base/recommended-browsers/ https://protonmail.com/support/knowledge-base/recommended-br... It's not listed in their recommended list.
- 101404 7y agoHere it is, as number 1: https://protonmail.com/blog/best-browser-for-privacy/ https://protonmail.com/blog/best-browser-for-privacy/ They also reference it in How-Tos, for example here: https://protonmail.com/support/knowledge-base/desktop-notifications/ https://protonmail.com/support/knowledge-base/desktop-notifi...
- BlueTemplar 7y agoIt's based on Chrome - too much risk of Google being able to cripple it if it becomes important enough?
- dependenttypes 7y agoMeanwhile firefox is the browser that calls home the most (at least on the first run) https://twitter.com/jonathansampson/status/1165858896176660480 https://twitter.com/jonathansampson/status/11658588961766604... On every single release they add new hidden options regarding tracking by mozilla (see Normandy and shield for example, which you have to go to about:config to disable). In addition to that about:addons uses google analitics and does not allow for it to be blocked by extensions, plus mozilla sites use tracking scripts (googletagmanager etc) that need modifications in about:config to be blocked (extensions.webextensions.restrictedDomains). Finally mozilla does not seem to be taking any measures to make firefox more resilient to tracking - in fact they support more and more technologies that diminish it. (web fonts, webgl, geolocation, user agent mentioning the version language and OS, etc) Edit: Sorry, by "web fonts" I meant the ability for sites to read the fonts that you have installed. I do not know if actual web fonts can be used for tracking.
- inetknght 7y agoPocket too
- Santosh83 7y agoCorrect me if I am wrong but aren't they including built-in tracker blocking with a 'strict' list that can be chosen, plus they are working on site-level isolation that is behind a config flag for now (1st party isolation) and as far as I know, they're the only browser that has multiple anti-fingerprinting measures that can be toggled by the resistFingerprinting config flag? If they default disabled web fonts, geolocation etc., they'd lose whatever little market share they have as those have become important web tech already. You can still disable all of them either by means of about:config toggles or through simple extensions like uMatrix. Not sure if Chrome even allows disabling any/all of them.
- monadic2 7y ago> If they default disabled web fonts, geolocation etc., they'd lose whatever little market share they have as those have become important web tech already. I doubt people would even notice the font side of things.
- blitmap 7y agoMy absolutely largest issue with Firefox is how settings revert after updates without any notice. It is good that updates are frequent. It is bad that settings revert and defaults are not safe. I'll never touch Chrome again.
- cptskippy 7y agoOut of curiosity, which settings are reverting for you? I can't recall settings reverting but I do occasionally get the "running slow" prompt to blow away my profile and start from scratch. If anything, I've noticed more and more settings are getting pushed into Sync and automatically propagate across instances or upon new installation. Which is nice.
- voicedYoda 7y agoRecently i was promoted to refresh my ff settings, and upon restarting, all my settings and plugins were set back up 0. Not a pleasant experience rebuilding my ff instance, but i guess it's better now than before.
- cptskippy 7y agoYup, it's not pleasant but thankfully, apart from NTLM settings, I've managed to remove most of my custom about:config settings I had used over the years, so apart from dragging Add-On icons into the Overflow Menu I don't have much customization to do. I had an issue with v73 being incompatible with whatever security software my Work PC was running and the main rendering thread crashing. After trying numerous things including rolling back to v72 and refreshing my profile, I came across a bug indicating it was scheduled to be fixed in an upcoming release which turned out to be v73.0.1 thankfully. That's the first time I can recall where Firefox did me wrong.
- timbit42 7y agoThere is a way to get those settings back.
- ninedays 7y agoAm I the only one seeing the irony of having The Verge talk about Firefox and privacy when the website is bloated with tracking scripts?
- abdulmuhaimin 7y agoI hope Firefox die just to shut up these "look how not perfect Firefox is" comments.
- nmeofthestate 7y agoWe need to ban the word "creepy" - it's lazy and vague. I could write an article about how, in order to buy something in a store, you're expected to queue up and present your chosen products to a human who picks them up and scans them - wow, "super creepy", right. An actual human running their hands over your stuff, glancing at your face and probably thinking about who you are, and why you're buying these particular products. The human might even get a look at your bank card. "What a bunch of weird nonsense" is the idea that is probably going through your head (see how I lazily assume you think like me, the article author).
- gnud 7y agoIn you example it's obvious what is happening. On the web, it's not.
- jimmydorry 7y agoBoth are kind of creepy though. It's a meaningless and lazy descriptor in the way it's currently being (ab)used.
- viklove 7y agoThe real world example would only be creepy if the cashier was keeping detailed notes of what you bought, and suggesting related products the next time you visited the store. It's not creepy because the vast majority of cashiers don't do that. The online example is creepy because almost all vendors are doing this, and even worse, they're sharing the data with each other to build detailed customer profiles so they can sell you more products. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-target-figured-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did/#136f73c26668 https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targ...
- true_religion 7y agoYou are basically relying on the cashiers poor memory to stop them from recognizing you. If you live in a small town, or even just an efficient city that sees you going to the same store often, people will recognize you.
- markstos 7y agoNow we'll see if Thunderbird will make saving sent mail opt-in for each message, for privacy. How many of your email conversations need to be preserved forever? We certainly don't walk around with an audio recorder to record every word we speak in person to people in case we want to refer back to them later. Email defaulted to storing messages years ago because it seemed cheap and valuable. Some value remains, but we no live an era of doxing and data dumps where saved communications can be a liability as well.
- reflectiv 7y ago> We certainly don't walk around with an audio recorder to record every word we speak in person to people in case we want to refer back to them later. ...not to play devils advocate, but... No we don't need it, but just like with email...that would be quite useful in many circumstances.
- ohyeshedid 7y agoFor that to be useful, the recipients on the other end would need to also delete the email. Otherwise, you've completely given control of that email content to everyone but yourself.
- edpichler 7y agoI use Firefox because while Microsoft, Google, Facebook and other giants are working hard to take ownership of the Internet, Mozilla works to keep the web open and free. I have a small SAS project, and I am sad that just 2% of my users use Firefox, while 80% of them uses Google Chrome.
- vianneychevalie 7y agoHow do you gather those analytics on browser usage? An outstanding number of Firefox users block analytics, so that may introduce a bias into those figures.
- hu3 7y agoNot OP but a statistically significant method of measuring browser marketshare is by looking at User agent on web server logs.
- Sohcahtoa82 7y agoThey may block analytics, but how many of them are spoofing their User-Agent string? You can get a lot of analytics just by looking at the web request. If someone came from Google, the Referrer header will show what their search terms were.
- segmondy 7y agoI use firefox too not because it's the best but because of privacy and to give them market support
- bunchOfCucks 7y agoOk sure bud
- dzonga 7y agoI wish other browsers e.g Vivaldi would've been built on top of the Firefox engine. The reason, I use Vivaldi is tab management. & that Firefox can be a resource hog on KDE
- m3kw9 7y agoI thought that was Safari
- retpirato 7y agohttps://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix/releases https://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix/releases this is a good extension to block tracking elements. you can also block things like javascript & you can block them on a single page , a whole site or across the board. it's available for firefox & chrome.
- fulldecent2 7y agoInspired by this post, I just installed Firefox on my iMac. Here are two problems. 1) After a vanilla installation, I clicked the profiles icon. (It's the person in a circle button.) When I click it, a popup menu shows, then it relocates north 30 pixels, then it redraws where it is supposed to be. For a software with a main interface only having 8 buttons, it is bad that one of them does not work properly. 2) I'm at work right now so I planned to migrate from Google Chrome and uninstall it. I successfully migrated my work profile. I don't see a way to use a separate profile for personal. Tried Command-Shift-M (Chrome shortcut to change profiles) and got nothing. That ended it for me.
- Vinnl 7y agoTry going to about:profiles, and be sure to check out Multi-Account Containers, which might satisfy your use case: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account-containers/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/multi-account...
- mbostleman 7y agoI've run a variety of non-Chrome browsers (currently Brave) as my default for most personal usage. But with all of them it seems like I run in to incompatibilities that cause me to fire up Chrome as a workaround. I use 5 SAAS applications to run my business and I run them all from Chrome because at one point or another I ran in to some kind of showstopper and it just wasn't practical to constantly switch to Chrome to unblock. The issues are often weird and not obvious. Last weekend I stayed at a Hampton Inn and their Wifi authentication page kept refusing to accept my last name and room number. I called the front desk which ended up being a waste of time (I was hoping maybe there was a mix up in the data). I finally ended up hot spotting. Then the next day it occurred to me that maybe it was a browser issue. Sure enough, I was able to reproduce the problem in Brave, then copied to the url to Chrome and it worked fine. Bottomline, these issues seem like a big impediment to a mainstream migration away from Chrome.
- BrendanEich 7y agoIt likely involved us blocking a 3rd party script that the hotel embedded against its 1st party interests. If you click on the lion-icon in right end of address bar and lower shields you should be able to match Chrome's behavior, if such a 3rd party script block caused the symptom.
- timbit42 7y agoThis is why it is very important that we complain when things don't work. It's the only way to slow non-Chrome browsers from becoming more and more marginalized. Hopefully we can turn the tide and eventually make using alternative browsers a pleasant experience for the non-technical users.
- retpirato 7y agois the linux version of firefox decent on a chromebook or is it a memory hog?
- LinuxBender 7y agoPrivate + Shared = RAM used Program 205.6 MiB + 34.3 MiB = 239.8 MiB firefox-bin That is with 4 tabs open, one of them being Slack and one being HN. 68.x ESR. Calculated with ps_mem.py [1] [edit] ran gc / cc in about:memory to get real numbers minus cache. This is on CentOS 7 using the 5.5.6 kernel from ElRepo [2]. [1] - https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pixelb/ps_mem/master/ps_mem.py https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pixelb/ps_mem/master/ps_me... [2] - https://elrepo.org/tiki/About https://elrepo.org/tiki/About
- trey-jones 7y agoI don't even care that much about privacy, but I started using Firefox full time in October after changing computers and I think it's great. I tried a couple of years ago and found it lacking compared to Chrome, but this time I'm good.
- cyberbanjo 7y agoI've been using DDG on non-mobile device for years. One thing that always surprises me is when another DDG user doesn't know about bangs. I never witnessed the search of the 90s but Google's experience has certainly degraded for me since then.
- nottorp 7y agoI learned about DDG bangs from HN comments, for example.
- alexruf 7y agoI am using Firefox as my main browser for almost 7 years now (exclusive for ~3 years). As I see it Firefox is the only reasonable choice if you are looking for a browser respecting its users privacy. Personally I never had problems with Firefox breaking pages or having noticeable performance issues. Quite the opposite seems to be the case, since it feels faster and better with every update they released. I really can’t understand all the people constantly complaining about Firefox being slow and buggy. 90% of the time I had issues, it was because of poorly written browser extensions or ad-blockers breaking stuff. It feels like most of the people complaining about Firefox are just looking for excuses to justify why they are too lazy to migrate. The dangerous thing is when another new Chromium based browser, such as Brave or Edge, appears, which often makes it even worse for the user, since they just share your data with another company.
- franga2000 7y ago> Personally I never had problems with Firefox breaking pages My experience has unfortunately been different, but the issues are mostly limited to "modern" over-engineered web apps. 90% I encounter one though, checking the console reveals that it's using non-standard Chromium-specific features (whether a FF counterpart exists or not) or just has a lazy browser == "Chrome" check instead of proper feature detection.
- alexruf 7y agoOK, but it's not Firefox's fault if web developers don't stick to standards and use Chromium-specific features. The bad thing is, the less people using Firefox, the harder this problem becomes and Chrome defines the de-facto standards.
- franga2000 7y agoOf course not. That was basically my point - that while some pages are broken in FF, it's not actually their fault (although how much that matters is debatable as the end-users don't care).
- j4pe 7y ago
- awill 7y agoFirefox has only recently really been in the same performance ballpark as Chrome, meaning to get this privacy you had to give up performance. These days the delta is small enough that it shouldn't matter. Notable things still delaying my switch. 1. Linux. The Linux Firefox app is inferior to the Windows version. The same can't be said for Chrome. 2. Android. Firefox Preview should catch things up, and I think will be stable by the summer. Maybe I'll switch then.
- larrik 7y agoInteresting. I've been using Firefox exclusively for a few years, mostly on Linux, and haven't actually noticed it being inferior to the Windows version. What am I missing?
- franga2000 7y agoNot OP, but I'll give my list (I use it despite these issues tho): - associating programs to file extensions is not only out of sync with the system, but also a huge pain to fix manually as basically none of my programs show up in the dropdown - it uses the extraordinarily crappy GTK3 file picker, regardless of environment - hardware acceleration is hit-or-miss - no borderless top bar - drag&drop is janky (not sure if Plasma-specific) - touch scrolling and gestures need about:config tweaks to work None of these are killers for me as I really dislike the way Chromium renders pages (I know how weird that sound) and want to support Gecko even if it's partially inferior, but at least the file picker thing is an absolute disaster (not unique to FF, but they're no doubt the biggest in terms of time spent using it).
- galkk 7y agoI’m trying my best to switch to Firefox. On paper it has everything I want: nice treestyle tab plugins, less risks to have adblocker disabled. In practice it’s buggy, slow browser. I have much less extensions than chrome, and it still regularly crashes tabs and occasionally entire browser
- retpirato 7y agoI tried the same foreign language search (esperanto-"kio estas la plej bona maniero lerni esperanto?") in google & ddg & ddg gave me a full page of esperanto results while google's was a mix of Esperanto & English. both were mostly relevant though.
- badrabbit 7y agoFF needs to straighten out memory usage issues. It was using 12GB of ram earlier before I had to kill it,i was running more tabs/workload on a webkit browser and it was using around 3GB. The UI is a lot better but for some reason the memory hogging seems to just get worse. Why can't it pause tabs after a memory usage limit if it can't manage the leakage? I keep trying but even when putting up with it's slowness I can't have it basically freeze my system. This only applies to windows too. I think,maybe they test on Linux and Mac too much but most people are on windows.