33 ms·
Varoufakis to Publish Notorious Eurogroup Recordings from 2015 Meetings
- Gravityloss 7y agoThis is a really good chance for EU to become more open and organized. I know of MEPs that have pushed for more open decision making in the past, and not making a lot of progress.
- kolikotime 7y agoThis would be quite spicy to hear.
- tasubotadas 7y agoThat's a really shitty move. >a USB of the conversations he had secretly recorded while attending a Eurogroup discussion in Brussels People in private converse completely differently (more freely) than in public. Judging people on what they said there by a public standard (it's impossible that this will not happen) is extremely unfair. Especially since Varoufakis knew that he will be recorded, he has probably chosen his wordings accordingly.
- odshoifsdhfs 7y agoWhile what you say is true, the contents of these meetings should be public knowledge. A lot of citizens of a few countries had their lives almost destroyed by the decisions of these politicians, so is only fair they know what was discussed, who defended them, etc. Let us not forget the pressure the ECB (and other european institutions) put on some countries that have come to light after the fact. (Like only allowing emergency liquidity assistance to be used based on bailout conditions, thus interfering and blackmailing supposed sovereign governments) edit: And to be fair, while I don't like Varoufakis, the fact his party wants these recordings to come to light, means there is probably something there are is damning to someone
- tasubotadas 7y agoWell, I kinda do not like Varoufakis, because he came off as an entitled know-it-all prick (a not so rare trait in academia). He made lots of bold claims but in the end, nothing really got accomplished. EDIT: Regarding the fact that the public deserves to know, I disagree. The public can act completely irrationally against its own interests under FUD (I guess we have some recent examples from the UK and the US), and in a lot of cases, they are better off not knowing. That's why you elect representatives (that will get into all the details of the problem) and place your trust in them. If you do not trust you representatives - do not elect them. [1] https://www.cityam.com/greece-s-golden-boy-and-his-tragic-fall-grace/ https://www.cityam.com/greece-s-golden-boy-and-his-tragic-fa... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_U4U7M4WOPU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_U4U7M4WOPU
- tsimionescu 7y ago> The public can act completely irrationally against its own interests under FUD (I guess we have some recent examples from the UK and the US), and in a lot of cases, they are better off not knowing. FUD comes exactly out of not knowing. The more obscure the workings and negotiation of power are, the more mystique they hold and the more chances for spin they have. Democracy is not and must not be limited to choosing your representative once every four years - it should be a living system of dialogue, where you constantly offer feedback and hear back from your representative (not saying it has to be personal). This is the only way to build trust and have a responsive system.
- sgift 7y ago> Regarding the fact that the public deserves to know, I disagree. The public can act completely irrationally against its own interests under FUD (I guess we have some recent examples from the UK and the US), and in a lot of cases, they are better off not knowing Can you please clarify if I misunderstood you: You argue that people shouldn't know the truth, because when someone lies to them they act against their own interests?
- atmosx 7y ago> He made lots of bold claims but in the end, nothing really got accomplished. Depends on the perspective I guess. I believe he accomplished a lot, as he raised the awareness on how the EU is run indirectly by an unaccountable group of politicians serving specific interests. It's no small feat.
- ninjamayo 7y agowhat happened afterwards to Greece is also pretty shitty
- tasubotadas 7y agoWhat happened? It's a success story. I get that people do not like the fact that they can't retire now at 55yo or that they had to privatize a few big national companies, but I think it's a perfect example where the doctor knows better than the patient what's best for them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jokoon 7y agoAmputating a limb or surviving chemotherapy is hardly a success story, especially when the operation is hardly over yet. What happened to greece was a disaster. Of course it required to be handled by adults, and they did what was necessary. But the whole thing is hardly "a success story".
- odshoifsdhfs 7y agodo you live in greece by chance? I don't, but the friends I have there don't consider it a success story. Maybe it is nice they got a surplus now (after 10 years!) but during those 10 years a lot of suffering and pain to their population. Even the IMF has admitted it was a bad prescription (1) [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/business-22791248 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-22791248
- alexsideris 7y ago> It's a success story. Haha! That was a good one.
- Ygg2 7y agoHey man, it was a success story. For Germany. First their banks are salvaged. Then they get infusion of cheap Greek labor. It's a win-win.
- me_me_me 7y agoI think same standards should be used when police records criminals, judging criminals on what they said in private by a public standard is extremely unfair to them. What about watergate was that unfair too? Sure if he was leaking offhand sexual preferences of people recorded he would be crossing a line, but somehow I doubt that's what will be leaked.
- Bartweiss 7y agoThis is why the whole idea of "in the public interest" exists. If a reporter received these same recordings in the mail, they would quite likely publish them. If they received a recording of a random person discussing their medical concerns, publishing that would be an outrageous breach of ethics. (Hence the Gawker/Thiel debacle also. When Ted Haggard was caught having gay extramarital affairs, it was considered fit for publication because he was an evangelical preacher fighting against gay marriage. When a random private individual is outed, its not a public interest matter and can be libelous even when accurate. Thiel fell somewhere in between under both legal and journalistic rules, so we got a debate.) I'm pretty baffled to see the parent comment imply that private discussions between politicians should inherently be kept secret. We could discuss specific news stories, reporters who violate attribution rules, and whether Varoufakis was bound by privacy laws or Eurogroup confidentiality rules. We could even argue the publication is in the public interest, and yet makes Varoufakis unfit to serve by destroying his ability to function with trust. But just as you say, treating "that's a private discussion" as the end of matter would excuse Watergate also.
- mempko 7y agoYou know what's a shitty move? What the euogroup did to greece and other countries.
- tasubotadas 7y agoI grew up in a country that joined the EU and boomed afterwards. We had the same crisis and probably even worse austerity measures than Greece after the 2008 crisis and some politicians are still in a tough spot until this day. In all aspects, Greece was in much better shape before the 2008 crisis than Lithuania. Now Lithuania has a higher GDP per capita than Greece. How did that happen? But never once, anyone in public considered on "asking on forgiving on our debts". It really makes me wonder the audacity of the people that claim it's the Eurogroups fault that they have lent money to Greece. It really makes a difference, when people own up to their future.
- leto_ii 7y ago> Greece was in much better shape before the 2008 crisis than Lithuania. Now Lithuania has a higher GDP per capita than Greece Shouldn't this actually make you wonder whether the Greek austerity was a good idea? > It really makes a difference, when people own up to their future. Why do you think it makes sense to hold millions accountable directly for the corrupt dealings of a few members of a country's elite (and of a few foreign bankers, politicians etc.)?
- tasubotadas 7y ago>Why do you think it makes sense to hold millions accountable directly for the corrupt dealings of a few members of a country's elite (and of a few foreign bankers, politicians etc.)? That's how democracy works. If you are not happy with your current government, elect the one you are happy with. Over time, I've found that the elected government really does represent the general population.
- leto_ii 7y agoIn representative democracies people don't really have much control over the day to day operations of the government. They are also often deliberately kept in the dark about the decisions being made. Even if they had the necessary information available, it would be almost impossible to keep up with everything since people have other more important things to do to e.g. work. > Over time, I've found that the elected government really does represent the general population. I don't know where this happens, but if/when it does it's more of a fortunate accident than the default outcome.
- leto_ii 7y ago> People in private converse completely differently (more freely) than in public. We're not talking about private individuals discussing private matters informally here. These are people with great power arguing over the fate of millions. They shouldn't be saying things that they wouldn't want exposed and there is no reason to keep this secret.
- DrScientist 7y agoWhat if people are presenting a public image that is at odds which what actually happened? Is it then legitimate to call them out? Remember these weren't 'at the bar talking rubbish' kind of conversations, these were extremely serious negotiations in a professional capacity where you would expect people to weigh words carefully.
- _jal 7y ago1) There are almost certainly other recordings of the same meeting. People who regularly attend meetings like this should be well versed in the reality of what goes on. 2) If pols do not fear things like this, they absolutely will abuse the public trust. It always happens. You cannot have meaningful representative government without meaningful information on their actions. 3) In general, support for smokey-back-room politics tends to be related to support for the outcomes of those decisions. It suddenly becomes a collusive outrage when the "wrong" ox is gored.
- lucianoq 7y ago> People in private converse completely differently (more freely) than in public. They are deciding about life and death of people of a country (or many). They're not discussing about what's your favourite food and which sex position you like the most. Those conversation MUST be open and public, so people can judge the work of their delegates and decide to vote them again or not. If you don't want to be heard, don't present yourself as a candidate. There are plenty of roles in companies that are private enough to speak privately. Eurogroup, Ecofin, European Commission, European Central Bank, ESM are secrets just to subtract power from citizens, so to reduce democracy.
- smallnamespace 7y agoOn the other hand, organizations that are able to keep their internal deliberations private have a strong advantage over ones who must ‘think’ openly. Imagine negotiating with an employer, except your inner monologue is always spoken aloud. One unintended (?) consequence of extreme transparency for governments, is that it makes government ineffective and easily subverted or outmaneuvered by opaque organizations, like corporations and less liberal state actors.
- leto_ii 7y ago> On the other hand, organizations that are able to keep their internal deliberations private have a strong advantage over ones who must ‘think’ openly. I agree, but an advantage over whom exactly? In this case it's simply an advantage of the ruling political and economic elite over European citizens (Greeks especially). There are few instances when things really should be kept secret e.g. during wars, but this was not one of them.
- thanatropism 7y agoBut this is a story of European government bodies versus Greek government bodies. You identify SYRIZA with The People too easily. What, Varoufakis is a world-renown professor of game theory. You don’t think he has an agenda? Is it impossible that this agenda clashes against the Good of Greek People?
- cafard 7y agoIn Harold Nicholson's lectures on diplomacy, he mentions Woodrow Wilson's advocacy of open diplomacy. At Versailles, Nicholson was amused to find that the Wilson's discussions took place in a room that had a U.S. Marine with fixed bayonet patrolling outside the windows. Nicholson makes the point that the text of agreements should be known when they are made. The discussions that arrive at them, not necessarily.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoThe fact that only he knew is really the crucial point here. That gives him incredible opportunity to sway the conversation. He also has the ability to cherry-pick which recordings to choose. If you want open talks, they need to be done so with everyone on board.
- dependenttypes 7y agoWhy is it a shitty move exactly? Transparency is a good thing.
- atoav 7y agoWhile I think you're right, that heavily depends on the content of those recordings. On the low end of the scale someone could have used undiplomatic language that with the right media framing could anger a lot of people, without beeing that damning from an objective angle. On the other end however you get things that we might want to know about, e.g. when someone in a high office defends a genocide, or says something so clearly evil that the potential damage of not publishing the recording outweighs every individual right. I am not a fan of Varoufakis, but I could imagine him not taking this decision lightly (otherwise he would have published it way earlier). This points to something closer to the latter category.
- raverbashing 7y agoI think the essence of those conversation have already published by Varoufakis in a book he wrote.
- toyg 7y agoThat's true, but until now it's basically been "he said / she said". Having a recording that shows the outright callousness of certain elements of those meetings, is another thing. At the very least, it would set the historical record straight.
- phlipski 7y agoSunlight is the best disinfectant. All citizens deserve to know what their politicians are saying behind closed doors.
- koolba 7y agoThat type of blanket statement is a great example of theory vs. practice. In theory you’d want everything to be public in the interest of informing your populace. In practice that’s nonsense. There’s genuine national security concerns, forthright debate of alternatives by advisors, and discussions of limits on negotiating positions. Earring on the side of transparency is a good idea but there’s a whole lot in government that should never, and will never, be public.
- tsimionescu 7y agoHow can the public take informed decisions if the reasoned debate is always assumed to be held in secret? OK, national security and foreign negotiation is a special topic where secrecy can be warranted. But if the government of a country or union of countries is considering, say, pay cuts, why on earth would the population not be entitled to hearing all sides of the argument?
- tgv 7y agoHow can politicians take responsible measures if they can be called out on any nonsensical thing? Not that I'm against transparency, but there really are two sides to this. In the best case, politicians act in the interest of the people, which makes publication of their private dealings unwanted. In the worst case, they act against the interest of the people, which can only be dealt with by complete openness and independent justice. In practice, there's a balance between the two. And it's worse if the decision makers are judged by people that are only partially affected, such as in EU decisions.
- tsimionescu 7y agoI disagree completely. If there were real transparency, the public can also, in time, grow together with their politicians, and understand why certain decisions must be taken, and can help the public take a more active and measured role in their own government. Controlling the actions of politicians who explicitly act against the public interest is at best a minor win. Open and honest dialog is the much more important aspect of this. And the best case of this is - a politician working for the public interest convinces people to be mindful of their long term goals even when it contradicts their short term goals.
- jnmandal 7y agoPeople deserve to hear this. Varoufakis has tried to go through the proper channels to make this public. Now DiEM 2025 (his party) has every right to self-publish these recordings. I for one welcome the transparency.
- leto_ii 7y agoMight be worth taking a look at And the Weak Suffer What They Must?. While I still think Varoufakis is a bit too much of a calculated politician, the book is compelling in showing that the treatment imposed on Greece stemmed to an important degree from the creditor state's desire to save their own banks and from cultural animus.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lucianoq 7y agoTo the people who think Greece deserved that: lender is responsible for checking how much the borrower can take. My bank reasonably doesn't give me a billion. Default likelihood exists because there is an interest that prices it. When default happens, shame on the borrower and shame on the lender for having been a bad checker or just shame on no one if that default was one of the "expected" and covered by all the debt+interest already cashed in. An any case increasing suicide-rate and child mortality-rate is not the right answer, unless you are called "mafia" or "IMF".
- thefounder 7y agoThe lender is responsible to get its money back and pay its shareholders and that's it. Now the government is responsible to protect its people. It looks like the Greek gov(which represents the Greek people) was not very responsible when it took the loans and arguably neither when it nearly got bankrupted.
- fifnir 7y agoI want you to explain to me in what situation such a lender could ever have a loss. I want you to explain to me why it's reasonable that the lender makes profits when things go right, but the public has to take the loss when things go wrong. Isn't in the nature of a free market that lending is an inherently risky business ?
- mrtksn 7y agoSo you argue that it is O.K. to game the bank and live a lavish life destroying your own way of living and if the bank catches up and wants you to take measures so you can pay back, the right thing to do would be to jail the people who were gamed or conspired with the people who gamed the bank and simply continue the lavish life and let the people who dod not manage to game the bank(some richer and some poorer than you) keep writing checks to you so you can sustain the lifestyle you achieved by gaming the bank? Do I get this correct?
- 317070 7y ago
- Proven 7y agoNow he feels guilty for fxxxing up Greece. A majority of the Greece people and members of parliament were against the "agreement", but he signed it anyway.
- aazaa 7y agoThis article does a poor job of explaining what could be controversial about the 2015 Eurogroup Meeting. Who cares? This just sounds like Euro-Politico Soap Opera. After some digging, I found this: > The Eurogroup on the 11 July 2015 discussed the request by the Greek authorities for financial assistance from the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) and their new proposals for a reform agenda. https://www.europeansources.info/record/extraordinary-eurogroup-meeting-11-12-july-2015-euro-summit-brussels-12-13-july-2015-european-council-brussels-12-july-2015/ https://www.europeansources.info/record/extraordinary-eurogr... So presumably, the recordings provide evidence of some kind of back-door deal between the EU and Greece as terms for refinancing its debt.
- mrtksn 7y agoAs far as I remember, Varoufakis was personally offended that the eurocrats did not take him seriously and did not engage in a discussion of his ideas. He wrote about it several times, he sounded extremely disappointed that you can't have an academic discussion on that table. I had a really hard time to sympathise with him as I got the impression that he didn't pay attention to the reality of the situation and kept complaining that it's not like the way he likes it. He seems like a nice guy to drink with but not a person you would like to do business. My guess is that the recordings will prove how cool and smart is he and it wasn't his fault.
- xfs 7y ago> he didn't pay attention to the reality of the situation Or he paid too much attention to the reality of the situation. According to him, as a professional economist, the Euro is structurally unsustainable and is going to implode in the next 2008 because of the way the EU is set up politically creating a situation of a central bank without a country and countries without central banks. What angered him is the way Eurogroup bureaucrats pretend this situation does not exist, even when they themselves admit they understand the same thing, which, to an academic like him, is a crime against logic.
- mrtksn 7y ago
- petermcneeley 7y agoThis is about "elections cannot be allowed to change economic policy" It reflects the anti democratic perspective of the Eurogroup and is one of the most fundamental political issues of our times. https://www.google.com/amp/s/markcarrigan.net/2017/05/08/elections-cannot-be-allowed-to-change-economic-policy/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/markcarrigan.net/2017/05/08/ele...
- pavlov 7y agoGreece voluntarily joined a larger currency zone and reaped the benefits for a decade. Should state elections in Mississippi drive US Fed policy?
- xfs 7y agoReaped the benefits? Greece's GDP dropped 30% since 2008 it and was forced into austerity by the Troika to move debts from the left pockets of Deutsche Bank to the right pockets, with the interests paid for by Greek tax payers.
- anovikov 7y agoThing is, it's GDP exploded for now underlying economic reasons in the previous decade... and they all consumed the absolutely unearned wealth produced by nothing but cooking the books. The real "fair" solution would be: to auction off their sovereign territory to the highest bidder, and paying off debt with that cash. If they try to object, confiscate their merchant fleet and block ports with aerial minelaying.
- RobertoG 7y agoAssuming that you don't care about the Greek people (and obviously you don't) and assuming that the narrative of "we the European people" is false (that obviously it's), what about the public debt? Because all the actions that took place "to fix" Greece was in order to fix the problem of the public debt. So, I suppose that now, after all the "hard medicine" the problem is solved. Well, it's not and it's not predicted to be in the future. So, what was all this about? None of the predictions made at the time by all those hardliners in Germany and company have become a reality. Of course, the guilt is going to be again on the Greeks. Then they will complain when the people turn anti-European and rationalistic.
- tobltobs 7y agoMy first thought was: "Did he write a new book?" And indeed, "Another Now: Dispatches from an Alternative Present" will be published soon.
- alexge233 7y agoVaroufakis only cares about himself, always promoting himself and is just seeking attention. What a joke of a person! He wanted to replace Euros with a crypto-currency as IoU at some point rather than going back to Drachma. The man is an academic, not a very good at that either and a clown of a Politician. His "negotiations" cost the Greek tax payer about 100Bn Euros, and enabled DB to shift their debt to the German taxpayer, passing it as a "financial rescue".
- xfs 7y ago> He wanted to replace Euros with a crypto-currency as IoU I don't know where you get this piece of information, but in all his books he argues against Bitcoin and crypto-currency as a reserve currency, making a point of the impossibility of apolitical money.
- jayko 7y agoI dislike Varoufakis as much as the next guy but that's pure fake news. What he wanted to do is introduce a welfare system that was backed by crypto-currency issued by the Greek government in order to make welfare more transparent and efficient.
- zweep 7y agoI think that in 2020, everyone outside of a specifically secured facility should assume that are being recorded at all times.
- leto_ii 7y agoNot directly related to the article, but here's a bit of context regarding the industriousness of different populations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_average_annual_labor_hours_in_OECD_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_average_annual_labor_h... As can be seen, Greece is towards the top and Germany close to the bottom of the ranking. This should not be taken as saying that the Greeks are better than the Germans. It's just that individuals in Greece, like those in many other places, spend their lives working hard and they don't deserve to suffer for the corrupt dealings, incompetence and prejudice of their or other countries ruling elite.
- champagneben 7y agoThat list speaks nothing of industriousness. It's about how many hours are spent at work. Most people who have experienced working in different cultures could tell you that that doesn't necessarily have anything to do with how productive people are at work or how much actually gets done.
- leto_ii 7y agoProductivity is not the same as hard work. A guy with a pickax can work very hard and still be a lot less productive than a guy with an excavator.
- thedudeabides5 7y agoI for one, would be interested to read the primary source, when it comes out. If no one else does, will try posting a link in reply to this comment when it does,
- jayko 7y agoI do fancy the moral superiority exerted by some against the Greek populace profiting by a bad line of credit. Do they also protest German and French banks betting on Greek bonds that yielded very high interest rates? When you own a financial instrument with great upside it means it also carries a lot of risk. So, according to some, profiting from high interest rates is dandy but when it's time to pay the piper (your borrower made YOUR risk materialise) they don't want to get bankrupt, just transfer back the risk you took in the form of debt. And of course the loaned money is not used to re-invigorate the local economy. It is going back into the French & German economies because the local economy of Greece is destroyed and their companies go in and undercut the local competition. e.g That's how shit-show supermarket chains like LIDL wiped out of existence very solid Greek supermarket chains that existed and were profitable for multiple decades before the financial crisis, but then had to do mergers or shut-down. Genius plan. And that's why Greece didn't deceive anybody to get into the Eurozone - the members just looked the other way. The Greeks should have had defaulted and let the creditors who where profiting all those years from junk bonds (because that's what Greek government bonds were) take the hit. They would have recovered much better by now. Finally, it's bizarre to me how many people still believe that governments represent the 'people'. No they don't, they represent their friendly neighbourhood bankster - as long as they get a good cut of the money - and the special interests which fund elected politician campaigns. Greek people preferred a default over loan bail-outs from the start. They protested heavily and in the majority but were completely ignored. Numerous MPs had the audacity to admit that they never even read the terms of the bailout. As the great George Carlin said, "They are a big club - and you ain't in it buddy"
- agumonkey 7y agoMy intellect may be too small but I never understood anything Varoufakis said. I understand how shallow and hypocritical governments can be, but I never got the point of his interviews or actions, beside ranting about how imperfect things are (kinda like Snowden).
- m0zg 7y agoIt's as though Farage was right, and there's a lot of unsavory undemocratic backroom dealing going on, cigar smoke and all.
- rumanator 7y ago> there's a lot of unsavory undemocratic backroom dealing That's an extremely loaded word for negotiating consensus. It's as if populist parties are manned by opportunists who have no qualms to throw everyone under the bus if that gives them any advantage.
- m0zg 7y agoWell, if it's all above board, they shouldn't be worried about transparency then, so what Varoufakis is doing is totally OK, am I right? Except I think there will be unsavory stuff in it, or there wouldn't be any reason for him to disclose this.
- rumanator 7y ago> Well, if it's all above board, they shouldn't be worried about transparency then That's either extremely naive or disingenuous. It's quite frequent in negotiations that you have to concede parts that might be spinned as collosal political losses even if they are completely inoquous or even in line with the greater good or your political mid to long-term interests. The sovereign debt crisis is an excellent example, as even though it was in no one's best interests to let states go bankrupt, a hand full of member states were forced to navigate populist and extremist political parties and movements who were fundamentally opposed to both the EU, euro, and bailout processes who were spinning this issue to further their personal agenda. It's absurd to even assume that needlessly exposing your nation to this sort of manipulation is in anyone's best interests.
- m0zg 7y agoWho decides what is "greater good" though? Some unelected bureaucrat in the Brussels? A globalist cabal? Frau Merkel? Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Why do you have so much trust in these "negotiations" that you don't even want to see what transpired in them?
- buboard 7y agoWhatever is in these recordings, is probably meaningless. We know EU is a bureaucratic organization, we deal with it all the time in business, in research funding, in financial filing, etc etc. We also know that people argue a lot, thats why there isn't a central government, and the rules are based on consensus, not majorities. At best he should give them to an interested journalist, who could report on whatever is interesting to be reported. Publishing them wholesale just reeks of egomania. As a greek, this kind of thing being "news" is insulting to me. This guy is a veritable idiot: a rich boy academic with little-to-show, who became popular for talking in economic gibberish to the most foolish part of the readers of The Guardian(1). After he was summarily dismissed at a cost of at least 100B, which caused needless pain and the first capital controls in my life, he proceeded to write a novel, make a movie, and write another novel for his personal vendetta. He now leads a tiny party of the worst champaigne socialists of europe[2] (who thankfully are on their way out of life). Yes, we have scumbags of this kind in this country, but this is not a representative specimen, or at least it shouldn't be the model of greek citizend who are struggling to catch up with the rest of europe. 1) I 've been tricked to watch a lot of his speeches. I couldn't find a single damn coherent actionable proposal there. 2) https://diem25.org/ap https://diem25.org/ap
- knbknb 7y agoI agree with you. He likes to give long speeches, but doesn't have anything to say.
- dimig 7y agoIf we wanted to release them, he would have already. Clearly he won’t, cause this could backfire at him. Most probably it will be evident that he was not really participating in the negotiations about the future of his own country and he was literally just a listener (and eves dropper) responding with politically correct generalities. I really want him to publish them, in order to bust the image he is trying to build (that of some type of savior). He never will, unfortunately. He “threatened” to do it to get attention, such as the one he gets in this thread, because he can sense that he has become irrelevant. Please people, stop taking him so seriously.