24 ms·
F-35’s gun that can’t shoot straight adds to its roster of flaws
- honestoHeminway 7y agoWorking weapons are not a substainable buisness model, as they reduce the customer base.
- rtkwe 7y agoThe whole program is just a nightmare which kind of seems inevitable when you're trying to make a plane to replace every other (edit: small) plane in the US fleet...
- cultus 7y ago$1.5 trillion for an inferior plane. The sunk cost fallacy is amazing.
- HenryKissinger 7y agoThe oft touted 1.5 trillion figure is the total estimated cost of the program over 55 years. https://www.aviationtoday.com/2018/09/04/f-35-program-update/ https://www.aviationtoday.com/2018/09/04/f-35-program-update...
- danShumway 7y agoIs that taking into account inflation? ~20 million per year 40 years ago is comparatively a lot more money than it would be today. I can't tell if the 55 year period should make the total program cost seem better or worse to me.
- evgen 7y agoYes, it is in 2020 dollars and future costs are adjusted for expected inflation.
- claydavisss 7y agoPer-unit costs are now lower than the F16
- evgen 7y agoIt is 1.5 trillion OVER SEVENTY YEARS (in 2020 dollars) for every cost associated with the plane. That number includes design and manufacturing, fuel, munitions, maintenance and every other operational cost over the lifetime of the program. The plane is superior to anything else in the sky except possibly the gold-plated F-22 (and it is a hell of a lot cheaper than an F-22.) Sunk cost indeed...
- greedo 7y agoInferior to what? Show me another plane that's currently deployed and in use that can perform the roles the F-35 is tasked with.
- wmeredith 7y agoThere isn't one, including the F-35 apparently.
- greedo 7y agoThe use of the gun is perhaps 1% of the role of this fighter. The number of times a fighter has used a gun in air combat in the last 30 years is non-existent. For strafing, (generally out of favor for CAS due to non-combatant casualties) the gun is inaccurate. This will be updated with a software fix. If you read the reports of pilots flying the aircraft during Red Flag and other exercises, the plane is excellent. But there's a continual axe grinding over this plane that is factually inaccurate.
- AdrianB1 7y agoIn aviation every kilogram of weight is costing a lot, carrying a useless gun is pointless. If the gun use is too low to make it accurate, it is better to completely eliminate that quarter ton of metal.
- greedo 7y agoPolitics and institutional inertia will often overwhelm engineering. The USAF has a strong memory of deploying the F-4 Phantom to Vietnam without a gun. They believed that the Sparrow (AIM-7) and Sidewinder (AIM-9) were mature enough to win most encounters. Turned out not to be the case, and gun pods were quickly designed and shipped out. These aren't optimal since they induce a significant amount of drag, as well as taking up an external mountpoint. So since then, the idea has stuck around that a fighter must ship with a gun. The F-35A models have internal guns, while the B (STOVL variant) and C (Naval variant) can use an external gun pod. This is a tough engineering task since the pod needs to be stealthy. The value of the gun on all three variants is really limited IMHO. The F-35A only carries 182 rounds, and the B/C gunpod 220. That's just not much ammo for CAS, nor even A2A engagements.
- tra3 7y agoI'm writing a post on software estimation, how it's difficult to estimate things correctly. One of the arguments that I want to make is that estimating poorly is not restricted to the software industry (obvious in retrospect). Military and public infrastructure projects are an excellent source of poorly estimated projects. I've been collecting data about F35 specfically, 'cause it's so recent and the cost overruns are just mind boggling. Anyway, here's an article from last year [0] that discusses how project management for the F35 prorgram reclassifies "blockers" and "criticals" into "major" and "medium" (severity levels of the issue). Especially like how the IFF transponder fails to send out a distress call if a pilot ejects, or how the arresting hook (for carrier landings) bends the airframe. [0]: https://www.pogo.org/investigation/2018/08/f-35-program-cutting-corners-to-complete-development/ https://www.pogo.org/investigation/2018/08/f-35-program-cutt...
- davidgl 7y agoGreat discussion - https://codeburst.io/software-estimation-in-the-fractal-dimension-914569e2ccb9 https://codeburst.io/software-estimation-in-the-fractal-dime...
- laydn 7y agoWell there is no indication about the severity of these ~800 bugs, but ~800 non-severe bugs in a system this complex is actually pretty good in my opinion.
- Psyladine 7y ago>but ~800 non-severe bugs in a system this complex is actually pretty good in my opinion. "The fly-by-wire flight software for the Saab Gripen (a lightweight fighter) went a step further. It disallowed both subroutine calls and backward branches, except for the one at the bottom of the main loop. Control flow went forward only. Sometimes one piece of code had to leave a note for a later piece telling it what to do, but this worked out well for testing: all data was allocated statically, and monitoring those variables gave a clear picture of most everything the software was doing. The software did only the bare essentials, and of course, they were serious about thorough ground testing. No bug has ever been found in the “released for flight” versions of that code. Henry Spencer henry@spsystems.net" Courtesy of John Carmack
- josefresco 7y agoThis reads like a hit piece on Lockheed Martin Corp.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AndrewBissell 7y agoMaybe because their plane sucks? Just throwing out ideas here.
- climate_realist 7y agoI think the abysmal record of the plane and the huge amount of money spent on it are more likely why it seems that way. It's really hard to say nice things about people who actually shine turds for a living.
- joncrane 7y agoI think you could do it about any of the large military contractors, to be fair.
- Analemma_ 7y agoLockheed Martin is hundreds of billions of dollars over the original budget and has continuously delivered a POS plane in exchange. If that's not deserving of a hit piece, I don't know what is.
- claydavisss 7y agoIf anyone should by sympathetic to the potential for novel, complex systems to manifest issues, it should be the readers of this site. Surely similar issues arise with anything similarly advanced. I see reports like this as a positive. The plane is still relatively new, there will be issues. The best way forward is to be brutally honest and fix them. There will be issues for years. They will be fixed. How would your own code fare under such scrutiny? I recall a recent report regarding "flaws" in the new Ford carrier's catapult system...upon close reading, the catapult had not worked correctly five times out of five hundred attempts. In the world of software we would have no issue at all proclaiming a system with a failure rate that low to be "production ready".
- akmarinov 7y agoonly 800 issues for software of this scale? That's not too bad actually.
- hart_russell 7y agoAs someone who works for the DoD, I a sadly agree with you
- NohatCoder 7y agoDepends on the type of issues. For instance a "module x won't boot" issue is pretty severe, and it means that there is likely a ton of new issues surfacing once you fix that. Also, for an adequately broken piece of software the number of registered issues mostly depend on how much work has been put into registering issues.
- arethuza 7y agoAre US Air Force F-35s expected to be engaging ground targets with their guns?
- josefresco 7y agoYes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_II#F-35A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning...
- arethuza 7y agoSorry, what I meant was more is that something they are expecting to do regularly or is it a backup if other weapons systems aren't available?
- mitchty 7y agoThey're meant to replace the A-10 eventually, so yes regularly would be appropriate. At least: "its in the expected role of the airframe"
- rurounijones 7y agoNot really. The F-35 might replace the A-10 in the CAS role but it will not be achieving it in the same manner. Whereas an A-10 may roll in for a gun-run at low altitude the F-35 will be dropping precision SDBs (Small Diameter Bombs) from high altitude instead. I would be astounded if the F-35's gun gets anywhere within spitting distance of "regular" usage, especially since getting into gun range puts your exceedingly expensive plane into range of MANPADs. I agreee that it is a requirement of the design but I have serious doubts it will ever be actually used that way.
- thearn4 7y agoYes, ultimately the intention (quite surprisingly) of the USAF is to replace the A-10 series with the F-35.
- pirocks 7y ago
- tpmx 7y agoRelated movie recommendation: The Pentagon Wars (1998). The one where "Toby" from "West Wing" (Richard Schiff) is put in charge of product managing the Bradley Fighting Vehicle that eventually tries to address every single need from every part of the army.
- maze-le 7y agoAbsolutely. This film is a "must-see" for every aspiring project manager. It is very much on point with my experience on projects for big clients: * Continuously changing list of requirements * Incoherent decision making process * Unrealistic deadlines * Upper management that pats itself on the back for ridiculous decisions It really is a good case study for failed communication in big organizations.
- tpmx 7y agoBesides all of that, it's also a really well-crafted movie.
- bazooka_penguin 7y agoConsidering its primary function is to launch targeted explosives or paint targets for other weapons platforms, without being targeted itself, the vestigal gun being inaccurate seems like a small problem.
- levosmetalo 7y agoYou need to remember that F-35 is a peace project. It is supposed to suck up money from the military industry that would otherwise be employed to do much more harm to the humans than F-35 would ever be able to.
- chungus_khan 7y agoThat sounds like a symptom of a hideously corrupt country.
- RugnirViking 7y agoFortunately, millitary budgets aren't actually fixed, and we could just reduce them. However, sucessive administrations have failed to do so, from both major parties.
- Pfhreak 7y agoRight now, there is a post on the front page about an American community that is flooded with sewage every time it rains. Reading about the F 35 makes me so incredibly frustrated when I think about all the good we could do with even a small portion of its budget.
- merpnderp 7y agoYou have a lot more faith in the ability of government to turn money into progress than I do. The exact same corrupt policies of farming out money to political connections for the F-35 program, resulting in marginal services/products, is what will happen in nearly every local government. I'm becoming more and more convinced that we're coasting on the infrastructure of the past and aren't really capable of organizing successful new projects that aren't destined to fail from all the corruption.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoFaith in the US govt, I think you mean. Government is remarkably effective at turning money into progress in the Netherlands. (Not that citizens don't complain incessantly)
- blattimwind 7y agoThere are many examples of effective governments, yet it still is considered an outstanding achievement.
- lowdose 7y agoI assume this is a snark, more than 300 mayors to govern 1 city the size of New York doesn't seem like an effective government to me.
- Pfhreak 7y agoIs the correct effectiveness metric the number of people involved or the outcomes for the people served by that government? I don't really care how big/small our government is if everyone is experiencing a high quality of life.
- opwieurposiu 7y agoThe F-35 project is a stealth Jobs program that pretends to be a stealth airplane program. Seen through this lens, things are actually going ok. It concentrates incompetence in the defense sector, where it can do less harm. (as long as we dont get a real war)
- DanTheManPR 7y agoThe F-35 has been highly successful at it's goal of funneling hundreds of billions of dollars into the military industrial complex.
- adventured 7y ago> funneling hundreds of billions of dollars into the military industrial complex What's the total spending on the F-35 program so far, going back to 2006?
- gknoy 7y ago> The total cost of the F-35 program is expected to be $1.5 trillion over its 55-year lifespan As of 2018, the estimated program cost was ~1.5T, or 1500 billion dollars. """The F-35 currently costs between $94 million (F-35A) and $122 million (F-35B) for low-rate initial production run 10, though sustainment cost projections are as big a concern as production costs for a program that is expected to cost $1.5 trillion over its 55-year lifespan.""" https://www.aviationtoday.com/2018/09/04/f-35-program-update/ https://www.aviationtoday.com/2018/09/04/f-35-program-update...
- csb6 7y agoAnd people have the gall to say we can’t afford universal healthcare. “Oh, but now that money is lost, and now we actually can’t afford to spend money on our own citizens,” say the next couple generations of warhawks as we spend $2.7 trillion on a drone army made of caviar. We can do better things with our money.
- jml7c5 7y ago
- EdwardCoffin 7y agoButler Lampson, in his lecture Hints and Principles for Computer System Design [1], has the following anecdote: I remember hearing from the chief program officer for the software of the new joint fighter the F-35, in the US, five or so years ago. He said "I'm the chief software program officer, and I'm absolutely certain that the approved requirements for the software for this plane cannot be met, and there's nothing I can do about it because there are so many forces being brought to bear on these requirements." (45:45 - 46:18) [1] https://www.heidelberg-laureate-forum.org/video/lecture-hints-and-principles-for-computer-system-design.html https://www.heidelberg-laureate-forum.org/video/lecture-hint... (27 August 2015)
- nabla9 7y agoThe Autonomic Logistics Information System (ALIS) system determined essential to keep F-35 flying and maintained is now scrapped and they start from beginning.
- flatfilefan 7y agoWow, that’s massive news. Could you share a link to your source please?
- mrtksn 7y agoHere: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-pentagon-f35/f-35-logistics-system-to-be-reinvented-and-renamed-official-says-idUSKBN1ZE00D https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-pentagon-f35/f-35-log...
- flatfilefan 7y agoThanks! It would be interesting to know whether purchasing countries will get sole authority in flight package definition in contrast to the ALIS where it had to be signed off in US for every sortie afaik.
- 7y ago
- dralley 7y agoThe project was doomed to this fate from the moment the requirements document was handed down, much like the Space Shuttle's last minute redesign. The F35 is 3 different planes crammed into one airframe.
- rstupek 7y agoIronically so they could save money by not developing 3 different aircraft!
- wmeredith 7y agoWhy build three good planes when you can have one shitty one for four times the price?
- stanley 7y agoI don't have raw numbers, but last I checked the cost estimates of maintaining these aircraft over the long term is still projected to be cheaper than the alternative. Some of the aircraft flown by the USAF and the US Navy have higher annual operational costs than the sticker price of those same aircraft. The F-35 is an attempt to avoid repeating the same mistakes, but obviously, easier said than done.
- _s 7y agoThe operating costs for air or sea going vehicles is a lot of the time - at minimum - their purchase price, per year. Buy a kayak for $100? You need around $100/yr in storage, cleaning and upkeep for it. Buy a glider for $10k? You need around $10k/yr in maintenance, hangarage, taxes, insurance etc. Buy a jet for $1M? You’ll spend that much on a hanger, crew, fuel, taxes, mechanics, parts, insurance etc etc. Get an aircraft carrier for $1B? You’ll spend that much on crew, ports, maintenance, munition, training etc etc. Sure you _can_ do it cheaper, but it’s a good rule of thumb from a budgetary point of view.
- kjs3 7y agolast I checked the cost estimates of maintaining these aircraft over the long term is still projected to be cheaper than the alternative I think that if nothing else is learned from this program, it's that 'cost estimates' regarding it fit someplace between 'meaningless' and 'fraudulent'.
- ipnon 7y agoBeing in the process of reading The Machine That Changed the World (a book about the development of lean production in Japan in response to the shortcomings of mass production in the United States), I can't help but see the parallel between Toyota's ability to quickly adapt to the changing demands of different export markets with an industrial process that creates variations on a theme in direct response to the demands of the customer. Contrast this with Ford's approach of throwing all resources into the same identical product, depending on the sheer scale of the production to absorb the inevitable defects in quality and supply-chain timing.
- throw0101a 7y agoCanada is currently going through a competition to replace its (non-Super) Hornet fighters: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_II_Canadian_procurement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning... The two main candidates are the F-35 and the F-18 Super Hornet (the Saab Gripen is unlikely). There was much drama with this because the previous government announced a sole source contract. Then there was confusions as to how much it was actually going to cost. The original plans got cancelled, and now we have an RFP. Of course the F-35 is a so-called fifth generation fighter, and there's already sketches about six generation stuff: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixth-generation_jet_fighter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixth-generation_jet_fighter Soemtimes I think Canada should skip the 5G, buy the Super Hornets (and perhaps some Growlers), and then leap frog to 6G.
- uncoder0 7y agoIMO, for Canada's needs Super Hornets and a few growlers will be more than enough.
- tpmx 7y agoSweden has just this week decided it needs to own some proper firefighting aircraft. I suggest we trade SAAB Gripen aircraft for Bombardier Super Scoopers at a 1:1 ratio. List prices look roughly similar.
- tpmx 7y agoBonus video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNmenvJ_FKM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNmenvJ_FKM
- maximilianburke 7y agoFitting that Bombardier recently sold the rights to the CL-215/415 to Viking Air.
- Gunax 7y agoThe Bradley fighting airplane.
- alopex_plenus 7y agogood news for people all over the world, i guess
- m1gu3l 7y agoat what point will we be willing to accept that this is a failed project?
- sillywalk 7y agoIncredibly, but not surprisingly, they've already built 450+ aircraft, but I believe just started Operational Evaluation & Testing in December 2018. When more flaws are found, the aircraft will need retrofits. Same thing goes for the Ford Class carriers.
- thedudeabides5 7y agoHow many missile carrying drones do you think we could make for the cost of one $80mm F35? The next big war is going to be won with a lot of small, disposable vehicles rather than a couple of “can’t fail” elite machines. Kinda like Taranto, where a handful of British biplanes took down three Italian battleships https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Taranto https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Taranto
- stanley 7y agoYet it took another year, with the sinking of HMS Prince of Wales and HMS Repulse, for the British Navy to finally acknowledge that aircraft carriers, not destroyers, are the future. The F-35 program isn't going anywhere, but the Pentagon and the CIA have been quietly building out drone bases across the world for years.
- greedo 7y agoDrones might be able to replace modern fighters in 25-50 years. But that assumes robust, uninterruptible communication links, or incredible advances in AI. But the reasonable future is more of what we use them for now; flying in safe environments with minimal jamming, controlled by an operator at Creech AFB. Yet as with all the hype surrounding self-driving cars on HN, the clarion call for drones as the be all and end all of future aviation is evergreen.
- jdsully 7y agoA real adversary would have the comm links jammed immediately and these drones would all be paperweights. Autonomous drones are more interesting and perhaps possible in the next generation. But we’re not quite there yet - especially with kill/no kill decisions.
- wstrange 7y agoWe have $300 cell phones that can work with offline maps and run basic ML code. Betting against autonomous drones seems short sighted. It's almost certain to happen in the near future.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoAs long as people take pride in being #1 in military spending rather than actual results, these problems will continue to exist. I can spend 500 trillion dollars in an armored rubber duck with an attached gun to it, that does not make me the strongest superpower on earth.
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.md/S8WAg http://archive.md/S8WAg
- meerita 7y agoWhile the A-10 is not comparable with the F-35 playground, it was a plane that saved the budget and fit well into the military. The service made, the capabilities and the cost was really good. Same with the F-15. I think the F-35 is the result of hubris.
- hangonhn 7y agoIt's interesting you categorize both A-10 and F-15 in the good bucket because the same group of people responsible for the A-10 (F-16 and F/A-18) were very against the F-15. The F-16 and F/A-18 were actually spun up in opposition to the F-15 by the "Fighter Mafia". That group of people favored cheap, numerous planes that did one job really well, hence the F-16 and A-10. Both of those are undoubted successes but at the same time most people would consider the F-15 a success too. I wonder if F-35 would ultimately prove to be a success the same way the F-15 did.
- meerita 7y agoIndeed, the F-16 was success, as well the F-18. F-15 was too a success, at its way. Another good example but now well retired was F-14. But the entire generation of planes of that era was really good. F-35 was beaten in dogfight by a F-16 in excercises. I don't think it's a good plane because it's heavy and want to do everything planes aren't good design either.
- metalliqaz 7y agoThe F-35 was not built for dogfighting. It is supposed to sense and launch long before the opponents are even in visual range.
- VLM 7y agoI'll go on a limb and claim for publicity and political fallout reasons there will never be enough BVR RoE airspace to make BVR relevant to aircraft design. There's a difference between the classic definition of BVR meaning slinging a missile at a blip no one has seen 30 miles away, vs the F-35 concept which is to have excellent sensor suite leading to the pilot having excellent situational awareness so the pilot can shoot down the other plane before the other plane knows they're present, etc. Its tricky to get into visual range to visually identify the target as a mig-21 and not a 767 full of civilians without at least some dogfighting performance.
- tomohawk 7y agoThis is the problem with pouring all of the requirements into one bucket. A single plane that does air superiority (F-15), stealth (F-117), naval air superiority (F-18), ground attack (A-10), vertical/short take off (Harrier), etc - it's just not going to work. What the US really needs are a small number of stealth fighters (F-22), a larger number of air superiority fighters (F-15 silent eagles), a whole bunch of light attack aircraft (A-29s), and something to replace the A-10. Sure, an A-29 is a prop plane that stands no chance against an F-15, but it is phenomenally cheap to operate, and fits a very large number of mission needs that the high performance jets are too expensive for. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_EMB_314_Super_Tucano https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_EMB_314_Super_Tucano
- WalterBright 7y agoThere's a long history of these sorts of things: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasa_(ship) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasa_(ship)
- esjeon 7y agoYou mean this part, right? > Four more heavy guns were intended for the stern, but the cannon foundry could not cast guns as fast as the navy yard could build ships, and Vasa waited nearly a year after construction was finished for its armament. When the ship sailed in August 1628, eight of the planned armament of 72 guns had still not been delivered
- gerdesj 7y agoPerhaps not quite so bad as the Vasa - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Rose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Rose At least the Mary Rose had served for over 30 years but it seems that upgrades went over the top. A 500 ton ship was turned into a 700 ton ship.
- sidlls 7y agoThis thing is right out of the Pentagon Wars. “It. Takes. Teamwork.” I’m not surprised, though; this is typical of defense contracting boondoggles.
- credit_guy 7y agoF-35 is a popular bashing target on Hacker News. I think this is unfair. Yes, the program is worth $1.5TN, the most expensive procurement program in history. But that's for its entire lifetime, of about 60 years. Per unit, an F-35 will cost about $100MM (even less than $80MM for the main version, F-35A [0]). A few days ago we've seen the first Boeing 777X taking a test flight. That's a commercial aircraft with a list price of $400MM per unit. It's essentially a big long tube with wings and engines. Yes, the tube is carbon fiber, the wings are foldable, the engines are the newest crown jewels of GE, but it's not a fighter aircraft designed to withstand 10G acceleration, be subject to catapulted take-off and arrested landing on an aircraft carrier, be able to go supersonic, and well, obviously it's not stealthy. So, given all that, the cost of an F-35 is not exorbitant. Oh, and you bet the F-35 is a huge jobs program as well. But it's not minimum wage jobs we are talking about. It's high end jobs. And the F-35 is a profitable export as well. An export that will benefit the US, but will benefit the buyers too. Poland will buy F-35. Poland is looking nervously at Ukraine, and how Russian troops and tanks are occupying big chunks of it. The day they get some F-35s in their hangars is the day they'll start sleeping a bit easier at night. Japan has some nice naval ships that are aircraft carriers in all but name [1]. But to be meaningful, they need aircraft, and F-35B will do the job. UK's Queen Elizabeth class aircraft carrier will also use F-35B. No other fighter jet will fit the bill, either for the Japanese or for the British aircraft carriers, as they are somewhat on the short side and F-35B can take off on short runways. Israel is already using F-35s for combat missions. For those who think manned military aircraft are a thing of the past, take a moment to remember the drone that Iran captured a few years ago [2]. Drones can be hijacked, or rendered ineffective via electronic warfare. Manned aircraft less so. The US is not shying away from heavily investing in drones, but manned aircraft will have a place in the military picture for decades to come. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Izumo-class_destroyer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Izumo-class_destroyer [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incid...
- zepearl 7y agoWhich airplanes are currently supposed to be replaced by the F-35? Everything (basically from the A-10 to the F-22) or only specific (sub-ranges of) models/variants?
- onepointsixC 7y agoF-16, A-10, AV-8B, F-18. Though there will still be variants of the F-18 flying for much longer along side.
- zepearl 7y agoThx => so a maneuverable fighter (F-16), with hardcore ground-attack and survivability features (A-10), able to VTOL (AV-8B), and do whichever special things the F-18 can do (a generalist?). Forgetting about budget overruns and malfunctions etc... I personally think that it won't excel in anything (technically I think that it cannot vs. specialized aircrafts), and that putting everything on one card is extremely risky.
- onepointsixC 7y agoHere's the thing, the A-10 gun is only useful against light targets, so it would often just be a bomb/missile truck. F-16 started out as a nimble fighter but ultimately became a much heavier multi role. The F-18's are also multi roles often used as bomb/missile trucks. The AV-8B were multi role but had huge limitations in range and weight. The F35 is shaping up to be better than all. Now that it's software limitations have been pushed further it is shaping up to be quite a nimble aircraft[1]. Especially since the legacy fighters have to carry external weapons which add drag. It has superior high AoA to all four. It has better range and payload capacity than all of the aircraft it replaces. A new 100% purpose built aircraft for each role maybe could perform better but as it stands the F-35's shaping up to still be better than the aircraft it replaces. And now reaching $77.9M for Lot 14's the F-35A variant is cheaper than just about any other western modern fighter jet. The legacy jets it replaces also experienced serious issues early in their programs and were decried in the media as boondoggles[3]. They're now considered to be excellent jets. To really hit the point harder, the only F-22's, which is an air superiority fighter, combat missions and kills have been acting in ground attack missions. The F-15 which is also an air superiority fighter had an entire variation of it later built called the F-15E Strike Eagle which turned it into a multi role bomb/missile truck. In case I'm not making it clear, for all the variation that exists in different possible roles for jets they tend to usually end up centering in doing a lot of the same same work. That's why the F-35 is ultimately going to be very successful. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0hWzaKEeZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0hWzaKEeZo [2]: https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/defense/2019-10-30/lm-receives-7b-f-35-order-f-35a-price-dips-below-80m https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/defense/2019-10-30/l... [3]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkrtxDdaWuM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkrtxDdaWuM
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kaonashi 7y agoThe F-35 is doing excellently at it's actual engineered purpose, which is to extract the maximum amount of money from the DoD and into the hands of contractors while at the same time being completely unassailable politically. Better than digging ditches and filling them back in, I suppose.