8 ms·
It costs $10k to ‘own’ a Chick-fil-A franchise
- Nextgrid 7y agoI always found franchise initial startup costs to be predatory, as they get paid either way regardless of whether the franchisee actually succeeds. In my opinion they should be abolished and franchisors should only rely on royalties, so that they have an incentive to help the franchisee succeed if they want to make money.
- whatshisface 7y agoWho should abolish them?
- staticautomatic 7y agoAre you being facetious?
- Forge36 7y agoIt's a valid question. State government? Local? Federal? International agreement? The franchise brand owner had no incentive, so while it's possible to abolish them through government. It's not clear why we'd go that direction. Given the franchise brand owner takes on additional risk it's not clear why they'd move to take on risk without gain
- projektfu 7y agoIn the US, the SBA could go a long way to abolishing them if they so chose. "No more franchises in the 7A program. Have a nice day."
- kelnos 7y agoGiven how much it costs to open the restaurant itself, it seems like the franchise fee (for most franchises) is an odd thing to focus on. If I'm going to be spending $1.6M-$2.3M just to build a Taco Bell location, I'm honestly not going to be too concerned about the $30k franchise fee I need to pay corporate up-front. It's a drop in the bucket. Regardless, corporate is always incentivized to help their franchisees succeed; they wouldn't really have a business without them, and of course they want their cut of sales/profits to be a higher absolute value.
- lonelappde 7y agoA franchise is barely above MLM. Local "owner" is really an employee, takes on the risk and gets minimal profits.
- kelnos 7y agoFor Chik-fil-A, yes, since corporate fronts all the money and owns the location and improvements; there, you're maybe a little more than an employee-manager, but not by much. For most others, not so much, since you own the result of your initial investment.
- sixtypoundhound 7y agoUh...this is a common conflict between owner-operators and franchise groups. Also a common area of abuse. There was a sandwich shop chain in the US where this got very ugly a few years ago...
- reiichiroh 7y agoWas it Quiznos with the franchisee committing suicide in the store bathroom with a shotgun?
- sixtypoundhound 7y agoYup. But it was more than that one guy, the whole model was crap and they kept selling more units... https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/financing/brief-history-quiznos-collapse https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/financing/brief-his...
- philwelch 7y agoWhich is really a shame since the sandwiches are so good.
- lettergram 7y agoI actually don’t see it that way. Often a franchise will vet the owner, provide setup assistance, provide location recommendations, train employees, etc. That doesn’t occur in all cases, but arguably most franchises do this and it’s part of the initial fees.
- reaperducer 7y agoPlus, the national will often pick up all or a large portion of advertising costs.
- projektfu 7y agoIn many franchise documents I've seen, those costs are shared by the franchises and charged out separately from the royalties. Same for IT expenses and the like.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoIf you dont want to pay you join a different franchise or start your own restaurant. I fail to see the issue. Nobodys putting a gun to your head to open up a CFA restaurant.
- rjvir 7y agoIt's possible to be predatory without holding people at gunpoint.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoAgain, nobody is telling you to join them if you dont want to though. You can make a competing restaurant yourself.
- aryamaan 7y agoA predatory option can be present with a choice to join it. People can choose to not take such a deal but those who did, they got the worse of the deal by large margins. Even if they did choose that option, doesn't mean that deal was fair to them.
- ianai 7y agoYes. All it takes is a modestly good marketing strategy and legalese muddying the water enough to not make it completely obvious until it’s too late to back out or too complicated to advise to others.
- dkarras 7y agoI can't really follow your logic there. In my mind for something to be predatory it should be your pretty much only option while promising you the world, an end to your tough situation. If you have a choice and you end up worse off, you just got into a bad deal is all. The deal is fair because both parties thought it was a good deal, no one was forced or desperate. There was no scam involved either (everyone got what they were promised). I can't see how that can be predatory, or even unfair.
- Forge36 7y agoI recall subway had "low" startup costs and it resulted in too many locations. What incentivizes the new location to do due-diligence in picking a good location? If this is placed into the chain owner: What's the difference between a franchise vs single owner?
- jrs235 7y agoChick-fil-A corporate determines all new locations. Corporate cares about the success of their locations because they own the lot, own the building, own the equipment, own just about everything and lease it back to the operator. If an operator violates the franchise agreement they get evicted and or lose their equipment and can no longer operate. It's how Chick-fil-a is able to maintain quality and control. Ever wonder why a Chick-fil-a location doesn't buck corporate and open on Sundays? Because they'd lose everything they need to run their business.
- maxerickson 7y agoThe other costs are plenty of incentive to choose a location carefully. Even for a Subway. Earning back $350,000 takes a lot of sandwiches.
- virtuous_signal 7y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/28/business/subway-franchisees.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/28/business/subway-franchise... Apparently too many subways has caused bully by Subway the corporation of franchisees over good locations.
- listenallyall 7y agoOpening a Subway franchise is a great way to ensure you'll always be employed -- at a 50+ hour per week job earning about $40k per year. The business model and royalty rate generally require the owner to be an unpaid, full-time employee for the store to turn a profit.
- BurningFrog 7y agoIf you read the article, this is where Chik-fil-A is radically different - and cheaper - than its competitors. This naturally means it's very hard to qualify for one.
- sparkie 7y agoThey have a brand image to uphold. If anybody were to be able to open up a franchise and run it badly (ie, have rats running around), this would have a serious negative image on the whole brand and would sway people away from eating at the same branded joints again, even though other joints are run by different people. As such, it is necessary to vet the potential franchisee to ensure they're going to support and improve your brand image rather than damage it. Requiring a "deposit" as such is part of this, as the franchisee will need to at least recover the amount invested by providing good service.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoAnd yet people choose to buy franchises rather than start their own independent shops. Proliferation of franchises indicates that this is mutually beneficial. Also, bear in mind that the franchise's corporate brand reputationsuffers when a franchise fails, so there's inherently some risk sharing.
- allovernow 7y agoNot commenting on franchising, but I'd point out that, for example, loan sharks are "mutually beneficial" and exist across societies, but they can still be quite predatory.
- codegeek 7y agoIt is a bit unfair to compare loan sharks to business models liek franchises. Loan sharks can lend you money for anything even if you want to go spend it on something useless that doesn't create any value. Starting a Franchise business creates value even if it may not be highly profitable for someone. I wouldn't call Franchise model predatory even though I am personally not a fan of it because I like complete freedom in starting/running a business. Personally, I wouldn't do franchise (I am too much of a free bird to be caged) but calling it predatory is too much.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoLoan sharks appeal to the desperate. If you are in a pickle, you NEED a loan, you don't NEED to start a franchise.
- pbhjpbhj 7y ago>people choose to buy franchises rather than start their own independent shops // [Agreeing] There are massive costs (relatively speaking) for an independent involved in just learning/optimising the supply chain. With a franchise you, presumably, can skip this which gives a huge head start. Also if it's a brand chain then you have the benefit of brand level advertising (which works at a different psychological level to shop/activity/product advertising) which should be more efficient per "lead".
- 7y ago
- micmil 7y agoThere's nothing "predatory" about assuring that your business partner actually has enough capital to operate a business. The startup costs may be significantly lower for a freestanding restaurant but you also have to shoulder the burden of marketing and establishing a customer base. A national chain doesn't just sit on its ass and collect money from franchisees. The costs of marketing and R&D are enormous but in the franchise model these things are offloaded from the individual restaurant to the parent company. The parent company has no interest in that location ever closing. They're not house flippers or day traders. They rely on stable long-term income, not random tiny spikes a few times a year. Franchise fees are barely even a blip on the radar of a company like McDonald's.
- codegeek 7y agoYou are paying for the brand, strategy, training and lot of risk factors that are mitigated due to the franchise setup. Yes, it is still risky but starting an entire business from scratch is a lot riskier. That's why you pay.
- projektfu 7y agoThe trouble is that the royalty adds to the risk. That, and you can't change suppliers if they start playing with you. Independent restaurants, if they hit their market, run into the same problem with landlords, who want to take the profit from exorbitant rents after the the lease expires.
- ReptileMan 7y agoWhen you pay franchise costs you also get a lot of know how and ready built supply chain. Those things are probably worth it. It is fried chicken after all - hardly a challenging item to cook, but to perfect it as a recipe, scale and process for "Nextgrid's artisan non franchised fried chicken" will take probably more than $10k and worse of all will take a lot of time in which you will be paying rent and salaries.
- asdff 7y agoChick fil a at least can be run pretty passively. I got to know an owner at a local franchise. He owned other franchises and gas stations, had a massive house in a gated community, and had time to lecture at a very good business school in town. He had managers on every shift running day to day so he never really needed to visit the store, but he did a couple times a week anyway to show face with the staff and even step onto the line and bag orders if it got swamped while he was there, simply to lighten the load on the staff. If this had been an independent restaurant, he might have been doing things like cooking in the back 12 hours a day to lower his payroll. Predatory is not the word I would use for most franchises these days; passive income is the word I would use.
- bnorton916 7y agoCan’t own other businesses when a Cfa operator.
- baron816 7y ago> With a 0.13% acceptance rate, it’s harder to become a Chick-fil-A franchisee than it is to...get a job at Google (0.23%) I think I'd rather just get a job at Google.
- flatiron 7y agoThey said $150-$250k a year for the owner so you would get paid better too.
- prostheticvamp 7y ago150-250k a year for a 60hr a week job as the “owner”.
- barbecue_sauce 7y agoThat sounds like reasonable compensation for a 60hr a week job.
- dudus 7y agoNot sure if you are implying this is not such a great deal but that's what it sounded to me. Maybe from the perspective of a tech person in silicon valley that's not great. But in comparison with pretty much any other job out there this is stellar.
- big_chungus 7y agoHe's also forgetting that a huge number of these are in "normal" America with much lower costs of living and no state income tax. That kind of money goes much farther there.
- kelnos 7y agoYou can't really compare it to "any other job", since a franchise owner needs to front (or be able to raise via loans or investment) a cool million or two just to get started. $150k-$250k/year is a fairly nice ROI for even $2M (though taking on loans or investment changes the math), but the calculation gets a little murkier when you factor in additionally needing to work 60 hours/week, six days/week to keep it coming in. Put another way, if you already have access to $2M, $150k-$250k/year might not seem all that attractive when compared to what you've done prior to that.
- troytc 7y agoMisleading headline? It costs $10k only compared to hundreds of thousands with other franchises. CFA covers all initial costs and simply takes much more in profit sharing than others.
- djohnston 7y agoWhat's avg annual revenue for A chick fil a?
- maxerickson 7y agoThis article lists it as $4.2 million. (vs $1.2 million for KFC and $2.8 million for McDonald's)
- FireBeyond 7y ago$4.2 million.
- csdreamer7 7y agoFrom the article. Already knew, but this summarizes the food business so beautifully. “As a fast-food franchise owner, you’re often fighting a war for pennies,” says Rose. “Food is the most competitive industry known to man: It has the highest investment level of any industry, the highest failure rate, and the lowest margins.”
- dv_dt 7y agoThere are exceptions which indicate that may not be the whole story. https://www.businessinsider.com/in-n-out-employee-pay-2018-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/in-n-out-employee-pay-2018-1 * Store managers earn an average yearly salary of more than $160,000, more than what the typical tech worker in Silicon Valley makes for the year. * High wages for fast-food workers can lead to increased productivity, less employee turnover, and bigger profits in the long run.
- adaisadais 7y agoYes, and when you make $160,000 in the rural south each dollar goes much further
- copperx 7y agoTech worker salaries are higher if you look at the total compensation.
- softawre 7y agoAt top level companies, yes. But the average for all tech companies in SV is likely lower than 160k.
- tempsy 7y agoI was in Vegas a few months ago and saw construction signs for a new Chick fil A at Planet Hollywood on the Strip. Can only imagine how profitable that location would be.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ConsiderCrying 7y agoMy biggest takeaway from this is that Wendy's standards are surprisingly high. Why do they require a net worth of $5 million when most seem to top out at $1 million? Is it a way of ensuring a lower closure rate as people with $5 million net worth are less likely to go bankrupt and shut down the restaurant?
- virtuous_signal 7y agoThis website[1] says that $5mm net worth standard is for multiunit franchisees, whereas it's $1mm[2] for (presumably) a single store [1]https://www.thebalancesmb.com/most-popular-food-franchises-and-how-much-they-cost-1350254 https://www.thebalancesmb.com/most-popular-food-franchises-a... [2]https://www.thebalancesmb.com/wendy-s-franchise-review-1350385 https://www.thebalancesmb.com/wendy-s-franchise-review-13503...
- ganoushoreilly 7y agoWhat's even more weird to me is that they have these high franchise standards, but apparently they don't seem to hold the franchises to high standards (at least not the stores I visit). They're always dirty / unkempt.
- sosodev 7y agoThe Wendy’s near me are all pretty high quality
- turk73 7y agoThe two Wendy's near us are both pretty awful. I'm sure it depends on the owners. But yeah, we don't go there anymore. Also the Arby's--kids got sick 2x at the local Arby's. We don't even eat a lot of fast food, just occasionally when we need to get out of the house and go someplace nearby in the winter.
- ficklepickle 7y agoThat's interesting! In Canada, the Wendy's I have been to are generally very clean.
- neuro_image3 7y agoAre there any viable franchises that are hands off? Like you put in the investment, hire manager(s) and earn revenue as the owner without having to invest a lot of time on the day to day operation?
- ficklepickle 7y agoOh man. That's a loaded question. Short answer no, long answer noooooooo. With years of work you might get close. Finding good people and aligning incentives so you retain them is not easy. Most franchisees that try and be hands-off from the start crash and burn. Which makes sense, really. If it were a lucrative passive investment, the franchisor would just throw some money at it and keep all the profits.
- adwww 7y agoTim McGraw manages this in The Blindside. That man hasn't done a day's hard work in years.
- xwowsersx 7y ago> At $4.2m per store, Chick-fil-A’s average revenue is the highest of any fast-food chain in America, dwarfing both direct competitors (KFC; $1.2m) and bigger brands (McDonald’s; $2.8m) Wow, I did not know this. Why is that?
- dantheman 7y agoYou can only own one store. So they're always owner managed.
- sixtypoundhound 7y agoThis is a secret weapon. Most organizations lose 30% - 50% of their "mojo" with each layer of separation from an "engaged stakeholder". Generally meaning someone with equity or substantial profit sharing. I'd also bet that the majority of their owners only own one business, which means they are even more engaged. Compare that with the typical master franchise operator, who may be running multiple locations and multiple brands. Unless they have an awesome process and technology team, their operational efficiency is probably a full order of magnitude below the typical highly engaged Chick-fil-A...
- manigandham 7y agoFantastic food that is higher quality than the typical chains. Served fast and close to the same prices. Individually owned and operated with tight franchise oversight. Also the faux Twitter outrage has helped give them more popularity.
- xwowsersx 7y agoHaha always backfires.
- theGays 7y agoAlso, it turns out, gay marriage is fucking retarded.
- sixtypoundhound 7y ago
- goldcd 7y agoI have myriad issues with the personal ethics of the owners of Chick-fil-A - but their model does make sense to me. They're clearly not just wanting to sell their brand - they're wanting to own their brand. The 10k is just a token - It's maybe more than you have in your clearing account, but a figure that most people could likely produce and is just an indicator that "you're serious" Important part is that they put you through the grinder to make sure you're the person they want to run their store. To be honest just looks like a regular job interview - with the exception that they charge you to join the company, but you get a cut of the profits. Not even sure if they're in the UK yet, but you can see the converse with Subway that keeps appearing all over the place, despite not having any customers.
- OatsAndHoney 7y agoThey closed immediately after they opened in the U.K. https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/u-k-s-first-chick-fil-close-following-lgbtq-protests-n1069621 https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/u-k-s-first-chick-fi...
- blibble 7y agofunny, I was there two weeks ago and it was open (article dated October)
- tenpies 7y ago> will close after its six-month lease expires That's certainly not immediately. Also not by decision of CFA. The local landlord folded and decided not to renew the lease, so after the initial 6 months, that CFA location would have to close.
- asdff 7y ago10k seems low because the true cost is baked into all the sundry branded material and foodstuff you need to buy from cfa corporate. Chicken, straws, cups, salt, mop bucket soap—I wouldn't be surprised if the true cost of being a franchisee was more or less the same as any other major chain franchise.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- RugnirViking 7y agoHonestly, until now I always thought that chick-fil-A would do like wraps with chickpeas in from the name. I wonder how little they realise their brand holds weight in the UK. I know I'm only a single datapoint, but a lot of these american fast food names that haven't come to the UK already have quite a hurdle to jump.
- philwelch 7y agoAnd not, say, serve chicken fillets?
- QuercusMax 7y agoTheir name literally means "Chicken Filet". Why would you think chickpeas?
- pwinnski 7y agoBecause in British English, that word is pronounced unlike the letter A.
- mattl 7y agoIt’s a pronunciation issue? Americans say fil-eh British say fill-it.
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoAfter getting kicked out of their first store in England the owners announced they were ending ties with anti-gay groups.
- forrestthewoods 7y ago> ending ties with anti-gay groups. Salvation Army. The Fellowship of Christian Athletes. Calling those groups "anti-gay" and protesting a fast food restaurant for donating to them is absurd.
- adaisadais 7y agoCouldn’t be more true. What a world we live in :)
- happytoexplain 7y agoThe snark seems un-called for.
- markovbot 7y agoCould you please elaborate on why those groups aren't "anti-gay"? I've never heard of "Fellowship of Christian Athletes", but the Salvation Army is absolute anti-gay.
- _jasper 7y agoFor me personally, the phrase "anti-gay group" muddies the waters because although Salvation Army (1) does (or did) have some anti-gay policies, and (2) is a "group", its main purpose is to be a food or shelter charity; not to pursue the disenfranchisement of gays through say, political compaigning. To illustrate, I might refer to an organization under religion X as an "anti-women religious group" because perhaps religion X had some policy on women's activites that I believed were sexist; then for me "anti-women religious group" would be a technically correct phrase in that X is "anti-women" and "a religious group", but the phrasing would probably be objectionable to practitioners of the religion who don't see those particular policies as fundamental to their religion, and perhaps didn't even consider the policies sexist in the first place. In general, I don't think I often see this loose use of terminology applied to other cases; like I don't think people call Nike a pro-child-labor company, although if that were the topic of discussion I might say Nike uses child labor. To me it's about avoiding ambiguity.
- fortran77 7y agoWith 50% of profits / 15% of gross, they really own the store, and they're charging you $10,000 to apply for a job interview to manage it. It's a "franchise" in name only.
- privateSFacct 7y agoExcept you get a cut of the profits - how many "managers" get that - seriously?
- oflannabhra 7y agoI know several CFA owner-operators, and this article is mostly on point. Some of the comments I’ve seen are a bit off. 2 of the 3 owner-operators I know have multiple locations, although this is rare. Income estimates are a bit low for typical stores I’d be surprised if any owner operator of a freestanding unit is below $250k. Also, the estimates of worked hours are a bit high. All the owner operators I know have great work-life balance, this is a function of how well they hire and train their general managers. There are also some significant advantages to non-ownership that are win-win for both the company and operators. CFA provides significant support beyond what other franchisers do: IT, capex for renovation, and training. CFA is incredibly focused on efficiency in their stores. If you’ve seen a freestanding store recently, you’ve probably seen it be renovated to allow for double drive through lanes and a walkthrough parlor for pickup. That’s not the type of thing many franchisees at other companies have the cash (or willingness) to do.
- adaisadais 7y agoExtremely well put. I completely concur. My first cousin is in the process of getting his “own” store now. While it has been a grind (he often worked the mythical 100+ hour week while in the Leadership Development Program) it will pay off handsomely. The best part of Chic-Fil-A (in my opinion) is not the food but their total devotion to the customer. The level of service you receive at a Chic-Fil-A freestanding store is unparalleled at virtually all other fast food joints (with the occasional exception of In-N-Out ((maybe the hyphens add to greater service?)) and most restaurants in general.
- aabhay 7y agoAnd perhaps apostrophes destroy the service culture? (McDonald’s, Wendy’s, Arby’s)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- adaisadais 7y agoHaha you know, I think you are onto something! But the main thing is that most fast food businesses (and businesses in general) are so focused on revenue that their employees and customers suffer. I recently used a self-serve machine at Taco Bell (love the dreadful beef chalupa) and had a poor experience. The machine was too low for my height and unadjustable. Poor design really brings out the worst in the fast food experience.
- hinkley 7y agoWhen I was a teenager, I was told by a manager that the shake machine at McDonald’s cost more than I make in a year now. The amount of credit you’re operating under as a franchise owner... I don’t know how they sleep at night.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoTeens are often broke, but not as often as a McDonald's shake machine. Funny they cost so much while being out of service so much of the time.
- hinkley 7y agoI believe I was asking why we hadn't replaced a janky part. I was told the price of the part and expressed incredulity. Grown up me still doesn't understand why the equipment costs that much, except that it's small production runs and captive audience.
- sangnoir 7y agoThere are high demands on reliability: the equipment is expected to run 10-24 hours a day for years, without harming the operator or leaking oil onto customer's food.
- jagged-chisel 7y agoI read comments like this as anthropomorphizing the machine - it's not like the machine has to remember to not harm the operator or not to leak. Anyway, I don't find this a compelling argument against allowing mechanical failures. Manufacturers these days understand the trade-offs between cost to manufacture, part reliability, and tolerance of failure. (That said, mechanical failure might not even be a problem with the machines. It could just be the need to claim their offline so that staff can service other customers better.)
- sangnoir 7y ago
- hyperpape 7y agoFun fact, related to the fact that Chick Fil-A handles much more of the operations than a normal fast food chain: they apparently run Kubernetes on the machines in a store (https://medium.com/@cfatechblog/bare-metal-k8s-clustering-at-chick-fil-a-scale-7b0607bd3541 https://medium.com/@cfatechblog/bare-metal-k8s-clustering-at...).
- 7thaccount 7y agoI have a manager friend at a Chick-fil-A. The waiting list to get a franchise is years.
- el_cujo 7y ago>found that 51% of food franchisees earn less than $50k per year and only around 7% take in $250k Unbelievable, owning a franchise seems pretty stressful just to be taking in 50k/year. I guess once you get it off the ground with good managers you don't have to baby it as much, but still.
- gbronner 7y agoFundamentally it is a different employment model. The 10k fee is to inspire commitment and weed out non-serious candidates. After that, the new manager is essentially on commission. This allows CFA to find people who are ambitious irrespective of current wealth.
- mrfusion 7y agoHow do chains know where to open new locations? You’d think they’d get it wrong a lot and you’d see a bunch opening and then closing down. But as far as I know it doesn’t seem to happen? Can you really predict what will be profitable that accurately?