11 ms·
EU considers temporary ban on facial recognition in public spaces
- gglon 7y agohttps://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-ai/eu-mulls-five-year-ban-on-facial-recognition-tech-in-public-areas-idUSKBN1ZF2QL https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-ai/eu-mulls-five-year-...
- Krasnol 7y agoThank you for providing a useful source.
- dang 7y agoChanged from https://www.politico.eu/pro/eu-considers-temporary-ban-on-facial-recognition-in-public-spaces/ https://www.politico.eu/pro/eu-considers-temporary-ban-on-fa.... Thanks!
- cmroanirgo 7y agoThis now has a font page dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22072609 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22072609
- dang 7y agoMerged now. Thanks!
- Xelbair 7y agoArticle itself is behind paywall so i cannot comment much, but i would really hope if such ban would be implemented that it would be permanent one, along with other forms of tracking. On the other hand it is EU tackling it, so we can expect something as dumb as content filters or as good as GDPR.. EDIT: thankfully someone posted non-paywalled link :)
- Barrin92 7y agoI sincerely hope it happens. I'm tired of seeing privacy eroded in the name of safety and I hope nobody falls for the "we need to keep up with the US and China" argument that is inevitably going to be brought forward. We don't need to compete with others on technologies whose primary purpose is diminishing the rights of our own citizens, that's not an arms race we need to be part of and it seems to be increasingly the rhetoric tech companies adopt as well. One piece that I read recently that I found particularly disturbing talked about aerial surveillance of US cities. https://longreads.com/2019/06/21/nothing-kept-me-up-at-night-the-way-the-gorgon-stare-did/ https://longreads.com/2019/06/21/nothing-kept-me-up-at-night...
- neiman 7y agoI agree. Besides, there's a difference between "keeping up with development of technology" and between "keeping up in using it for dubious goals".
- Aperocky 7y ago> we need to keep up with the US and China In all of human history, as soon as people get fed, they turn into a group dick measuring contest. Well meaning people who are totally nice starts waving the banners at the sidelines. Politicians dress up impeccably and speak beautiful language at the center stage - to conduct this dick measuring contest. One of the big reason I like computers and software is that it seemed to be borne out of genuine interest than out of dick waving necessity.
- JrProgrammer 7y agoOne could of course argue that even the modern computer and therefore software was borne out of both necessity and dick measuring.
- on_and_off 7y agoSadly, one of the things that is killing my interest in software is that a large part of the efforts I have spent have been on building things that already exist and that all that collective brain power would be better spent on other problems. I guess I should start working for an open source company.
- kzrdude 7y agoThis isn't enough - a ban on spreading public pictures would be needed, because otherwise it is open for anyone to mine public image sources/"open surveillance" and running facial recognition themselves(!)
- ginko 7y agoCCTV usually already has rather strict limits on what you can do with the footage and how long you're allowed to keep it around.
- superkuh 7y agoI thought that seemed rather unlikely so I searched around a bit. Apparently it's at least partially true, https://edps.europa.eu/data-protection/data-protection/reference-library/video-surveillance_en https://edps.europa.eu/data-protection/data-protection/refer... >Although the installation of cameras might be justified for security purposes, the timely and automatic deletion of footage is essential. The EDPS requires all EU institutions to have clear policies regarding the use of video surveillance on their premises including on potential storage.
- funnygrass 7y agoSo as I see it is that they ban it temporarily until they can regulate it as now it can be used wrongly. I don't think it will ever get banned for good.
- q-base 7y agoYes, please! Stop that ridiculous surveillance. I am appalled at our minister of justice in Denmark that seems to see every week in power as a possibility to wreck havoc on our privacy.
- Tepix 7y agoSame with the interior minister of Germany who seems to strive for total surveillance.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoAnd unfortunately whatever Germany does, the rest of the EU countries later copy because if Germany does something then it must be good, right, because German efficiency or something.
- randomsearch 7y agoResponse as a Brit: “yes! That’s great news. Idiot/sinister police forces have already been trialling this, fantastic. Thank god for the EU.” (Pause) “Oh shit, I forgot.”
- cs02rm0 7y agoAmusing, but also as a Brit, I still think it's good news and that it adds weight to making the same arguments in the UK.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoExcept that the UK tends to like emulating the US ways rather than the EU ones.
- buboard 7y agoUK ranks much worse than most countries in the world wrt privacy. ironic considering their traditional values
- notkaiho 7y agoAs an EU citizen in the UK having to often go around that private development north of King's Cross that used facial recognition tech[0] I also would welcome this so that it wouldn't become normalised. Oh well. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/04/facial-recognition-row-police-gave-kings-cross-owner-images-seven-people https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/04/facial-re...
- TheFattestNinja 7y agoI thought it was already normalized across London, at least for the MET ? Agreed, private case is different. https://www.met.police.uk/live-facial-recognition-trial/ https://www.met.police.uk/live-facial-recognition-trial/
- 7y ago
- jakeogh 7y agoWhat can be remembered (GDPR). What can be said (Article 13). Mandatory DRM is on the EU todo.
- drukenemo 7y ago“To work out how to prevent abuses”. I read this as: “to ensure only the EU and top government can have access to such data.” I believe their end goal is centralization of power. In this case, by ensuring control on who can access such information. And it won’t necessarily be by people appointed by those we voted for. Maybe it’s the same with GDPR. I’m not so sure any big government has the pure intention to simply “protect its citizens”.
- gsich 7y agoA private company does not need to do facial recognition ... in public areas. I see no legitimate usecase.
- lopmotr 7y ago"public spaces" may include shops and other private property open to the public. Shop owners may want to use it for marketing and blacklisting known shoplifters.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoYou're suggesting that shop owners use a Howitzer to shoot flies. Using such technology for this purpose is a massive overkill and prone to abuse. I already resent some of the tracking techniques used by shops today (i.e abusing my cell phone for their tracking). I hope that some enterprising citizens (I see organizations like the CCC) publish lists of shops employing such technology. Because I, for one, wil make damn sure that they don't get my business. Not! one! penny!
- ginko 7y ago>Shop owners may want to use it for marketing Please no. I find it annoying enough that I can't click on random youtube links for fear of being bombarded with viral trash for the next few weeks. I really don't want to be bombarded by ads just because I looked into a window display for a bit too long.
- shkkmo 7y ago
- teekert 7y agoThis, the GDPR and California's Bill No. 37 [0] make me feel that there is still hope for humanity and that governments do favor civilians over companies, at least from time to time. [0] https://www.bankinfosecurity.com/californias-new-privacy-law-its-almost-gdpr-in-us-a-11149 https://www.bankinfosecurity.com/californias-new-privacy-law...
- alessioalex 7y agoThat's one of the things I like most about the EU, its strong laws in favor of citizens (privacy, health, etc).
- mpfundstein 7y agoWhile at the same time installing a totally un-democratic top down socialist system that steals half of every euro you earn...
- Tomte 7y agoEven in countries where your share of taxes and social security fees approaches 50% of your salary, most of it goes to your national state, not the EU.
- arethuza 7y agoIn the UK "0.6% of our public spending goes to the EU" https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36470341 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-3647034...
- raverbashing 7y agoAnd the bananas that don't bend, don't forget about it It's easy to be a brexiter, just make up some random BS and repeat it out loud until exaustion
- arethuza 7y agoThe EC maintains a list of myths that UK (mainly the right wing press) have invented about the EU: https://blogs.ec.europa.eu/ECintheUK/euromyths-a-z-index/ https://blogs.ec.europa.eu/ECintheUK/euromyths-a-z-index/
- simongray 7y ago> EU digital and antitrust chief Margrethe Vestager is expected to present her proposals next month. She has been such a force in the European Union during her short time in the Commission. I'm glad she's still spearheading stuff like this even if she didn't become president like some thought she would when Macron started promoting her. The funny thing is that she was also officially second in command when she was in the Danish coalition government a decade ago, but somehow the government's official policies were much closer to _her_ party's ideology (Social Liberal) than the ideology of the much bigger Social Democratic party that they were in a coalition with.
- SailingSperm 7y agoSo does this mean "using facial recog. tech on video footage taken in a public area (post capture)" OR "only banning integrated video + face recog. tech"... Hardly seems likely they'd ban all video cameras; So sending footage off to a remote location (possibly diff country) to process the file for faces is a trivial side step... Would love to think there's a comprehensive solution to this but it's a difficult thing to just say 'it's banned'.
- wor3q 7y agoThey figured it out with GDPR, so I don't think there will be a problem with that.
- tastroder 7y ago> Hardly seems likely they'd ban all video cameras Maybe for reference, NAL but that's pretty much already the case here in Germany. Save for some exceptions, that are relatively narrow (such as for law enforcement - and even there it's not whilly nilly), you can't just legally place video recording devices in public areas, even moreso if you don't own that space and provide obvious notice. Sending that data off to some remote country would be an even worse, though relatively unrelated, legal nightmare.
- La1n 7y ago>So sending footage off to a remote location (possibly diff country) to process the file for faces is a trivial side step A lot of laws are trivial to break, it would be a bad reason to not implement it.
- frollo 7y ago> sending footage off to a remote location (possibly diff country) to process the file for faces is a trivial side step That's probably a break of the GDPR so it will still be against EU law and they are taking the GDPR pretty much seriously, so getting caught is going to be a real risk. I'm sure there will be at least some attempts, but the legal framework to stop those exists.
- simongray 7y ago> EU digital and antitrust chief Margrethe Vestager is expected to present her proposals next month. She has been such a force in the European Union during her short time in the Commission. I'm glad she's still spearheading stuff like this even if she didn't become president like some thought she would when Macron started promoting her. The funny thing is that she was also officially second in command when she was in the Danish coalition government a decade ago, but somehow the government's official policies were much closer to _her_ party's ideology (Social Liberal) than the ideology of the much bigger Social Democratic party that they were in a coalition with.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't copy/paste comments on HN. It lowers signal/noise ratio and is a big pain when we go to merge duplicate threads. Edit: instead, if you see a duplicate thread, letting us know at hn@ycombinator.com is helpful. Then we're sure to know about it, and can also make sure that your comment makes it into the merged thread.
- simongray 7y agoSorry about that, but I didn't know there were any attempts to merge threads. I just saw there were two threads with 5 minutes between them and didn't want to comment in the one that would die. Will keep that in mind in the future.
- dang 7y agoThanks! Btw, if you see that in the future, letting us know at hn@ycombinator.com is helpful. Then we're sure to know about it, and can also make sure that your comment makes it into the merged thread.
- timwaagh 7y agoWill make life easier for criminals. I would love to have the arsonists who put my home on fire identified and safely locked away by a good camera. they would have had to deal with an 'attempted manslaughter' charge so they might have been prevented from causing other victims trouble for a while. So I'd love it if this exemption for security projects includes surveillance just outside the home.
- Lammy 7y agoI was with you for the first sentence, but the criminals I'm afraid of are NSA/GCHQ/FVEY/etc who absolutely would never abide by some silly "ban" on a technology like this.
- timwaagh 7y agoOf course, secret agents play by different rules. In the EU intelligence agencies generally aren't as intimidating so it's less of a concern. But if you do have reason to worry about this, investing in this technology might help a bit with spotting spies.
- ginko 7y ago>But if you do have reason to worry about this, investing in this technology might help a bit with spotting spies. This seems really doubtful. If anything the wide availability of commercial surveillance data would be a treasure trove for intelligence agencies to sift through.
- Lammy 7y agoYep, that’s exactly my fear. If we collectively think of it as banned then we will have no societal defense for it.
- shkkmo 7y agoI'm pretty sure a reasonable exception could be made for use limited facial recognition on subjects with a warrant. > Exceptions to the ban could be made for security projects as well as research and development, the paper said. That is very different from allowing homeowners to automatically identify all people in public places outside their homes.
- jonplackett 7y agoYet another reason why I’m sad the UK is leaving the EU. I believe we also have the most CCTV cameras per person in the world - or at least we’re the ‘most watched’ by sone other measure.
- johneth 7y ago> I believe we also have the most CCTV cameras per person in the world Bear in mind that the vast majority of those cameras are privately-owned (i.e. shops, homes, etc.), not operated by the state.
- borjamoya 7y agoSometimes it's hard to tell where the line is, isn't it?
- johneth 7y agoNot really, no. If it's in a shop, it'll be operated by the shop. If it's in a supermarket car park, it'll be operated by the supermarket. If it's in a public park, pedestrianised street, or government building, it'll be state-operated.
- shkkmo 7y agoOr in the increasing number of public spaces that are privately owned. If advanced facial recognition is being used, does it really matter who owns the cameras? Especially once that data is put up for sale...
- borjamoya 7y agoI moved recently to London and one of the things that I find surprising is that surveillance is seen as normal. In fact, last Sunday there was a facial recognition deployment in Cardiff during the football match. There was a group of fans concerned about this technology--they were being targeted after all. But a lot of people just saw this as normal. Here's a picture I took of the deployment: https://borjamoya.com/media/nl/cardiff-facial-recognition.jpg https://borjamoya.com/media/nl/cardiff-facial-recognition.jp...
- nfoz 7y agoHere's a weird request: any video-recording device, when activated (shooting or ready to shoot), should be required to emit a low-power radio signal. So your own device (e.g. cellphone) can listen for that signal and let you know what is recording you and from where. Maybe it's silly or infeasible but I'd be curious where that could lead. Consider that in some cultures you're not allowed to film/photograph people in public without their consent. So this is a small step toward a technological infrastructure that could enable that social convention.
- shakna 7y agoI believe if that were the case, in any significant sized city, you would simply always get the "someone is recording you" signal. Which would normalize it even further, as it becomes unavoidable.
- nfoz 7y agoThe signal could give you an identification for who/what it is that's recording. I'd rather normalize knowing who's tracking me than normalize the tracking without me even having a chance to know. You could imagine extending the mechanism to where users can emit a "don't record me" beacon.
- derivagral 7y agoIdentification can be either fuzzed or resold to aggregators and become effectively useless. There's precendent for the emission signal in Do Not Track, but I don't think the result is what you want.
- nfoz 7y agoI'm talking about a legal mechanism relevant for the sale of hardware devices. Do Not Track was useless, but GDPR was not.
- htfu 7y agoBut what of the billions of already existing non-compliance recording devices, plus the ability to easily roll your own without including an emitter? Even if it was successfully implemented it wouldn't actually at all tell you whether you're being recorded or not. Then what's the point?
- DraftDodger67 7y agoPeople can easily be tracked via their mobile phone. This is just another area where Europe is lagging behind the rest of the world (ie. the USA) and wants to slow everyone else down so its native conglomerates can catch up. Same thing with the recent regulation on autonomous vehicles.
- RealStickman 7y agoAh yes, who needs privacy anyways. Why not just abolish everything protecting consumers. Let's live pure capitalism. /s
- rpastuszak 7y agoOur definitions of progress might differ. “We can already be tracked by X” doesn’t mean that we should stop caring about the other areas in which abuse can happen. It’s complacency, and it allows for the situation to become worse to the point of no return. We’ve seen so many examples of that in the past decade. I‘m happy that the EU is considering taking more time to implement things properly (or at least attempting to do so).
- acd 7y agoIt should also include positioning and device profiling to be effective.
- mam2 7y agoIs this for police too or civilian tech only ?
- _iyig 7y agoDoes anyone else think total bans on this technology are excessive? Why not enact strict controls on the collection and use of face/location data, yet still leave room for obviously useful applications like (for instance) arrest warrant subject recognition at bus stops, airports, train stations, etc.? It just seems ridiculous to have officers scanning CCTV for the FBI's Most Wanted when algorithms could effectively and responsibly assist them.
- shkkmo 7y agoA total ban is not being proposed. It is a temporary ban that may include exceptions for security and research projects.
- kennywinker 7y agoask a vietnam war resister if "arrest warrant subject recognition at bus stops, airports, train stations" seems like a good idea.
- try_again 7y agoHaving the means in place for total surveillance and thinking it will be kept in check with "strict control" is a total delusion. Who determines what constitutes proper grounds for using the captured data? The government, I suppose? And if you want to automatically recognize certain individuals it must by design mean everyone gets scanned.
- _iyig 7y agoWe have nuclear weapons, but only certain people are allowed to use them. The IANA has root key-signing keys, but their use is strictly controlled and made highly transparent. If we approach facial recognition technology with an equal sense of caution and respect, I’m sure we can (for example) help police catch rapists, murderers, and child-abductors without building or maintaining a database of every innocent citizen’s movements.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- woodpanel 7y agoI can understand the impulse behind it, but just downright banning it will mean that after 5 years they either are prolonging the ban or will have to buy the tech from the US, China or Russia. Even if they prolong, every tech that might be a morally less questionable offshoot, will also come from said countries. I think the smarter way would have been regulation, that makes its more transparent, more controllable but keeps a window open for technology to be developed in Europe.
- kitd 7y agoThere are still a load of applications for facial recognition that don't involve use in public places. There's no reason why EU companies can't stay involved in developing the tech.
- woodpanel 7y agoThat is my point though: The "load of applications for facial recognition" doesn't need to include public space use. But nonetheless those companies that yield the ai models out of their public place usage over five years will be almost unbeatable.
- OrgNet 7y agoIt's one thing to limit facial recognition, but maybe those videos/pictures should not exist in the first place?
- uncle_j 7y agoThe problem with this is that most public places have private places right next to them. So this will be easily circumvented.
- Reggi55 7y agoIt's odd how everyone here has such an odd opinion. It's best to let what be be and regulate it asap. The outright ban just means we'll fall behind, as usual with everything.
- boredpudding 7y agoFall behind with what? Fall behind with stripping away privacy from our citizens?
- Nextgrid 7y agoOn every EU-related article there's always someone commenting about how we "fall behind"... but what did we actually lose out on due to regulation? Most US-originated tech we widely use today (operating systems, hardware) is US-originated because they were the first to come up with it may decades ago (before EU regulation was a "problem") and it doesn't make sense to reinvent the wheel, and are now using their monopoly power and network effects to prevent new players entering the market (Apple with iMessage for example). I don't see new tech we missed out on in the last decade because of regulation, so could you please elaborate with some examples?
- ivoras 7y ago... and at least dozens of EU startups who have drank from the Cool-Aid of Peter Thiel cry out in anguish ... On the one hand, it's tough to do innovative things in EU with its many rules and regulations. OTOH, sometimes they actually protect the citizens.
- im3w1l 7y agoI'm not really sure where I stand on this, but I'm starting to fear the "if surveillance is outlawed only outlaws will do surveillance." The issue I see is that surveillance is because so miniaturized and easy that I'm not sure if it will be possible to enforce these laws against "the bad guys". Ideally we should deploy technological countermeasures that prevent anyone from doing mass scale facial recognition. But failing that it may really be better to just have a free for all.
- chmod775 7y ago> "if surveillance is outlawed only outlaws will do surveillance." This is a valid argument when speaking of encryption, but I don't see how it makes any sense in this context.
- hubert1234 7y agoReally... is it so hard to imagine? Criminal gangs can put tiny cameras everywhere to track the police but the police cant do do the same to them.
- DoingIsLearning 7y agoThis is a complete non sequitur. The problem at hand is the security overreach of monitoring _everyone_. If I am not under investigation I shouldn't be monitored end of discussion. If I am under investigation, then if my case has not reviewed by a third party (judiciary power/judge) then I also shouldn't be monitored. It's basic human nature. Without checks and balances those who can abuse, will abuse. It doesn't matter which side they are on.
- keiferski 7y agoAre the police actually difficult to track? They wear uniforms and drive around with flashing lights and sirens.
- Nextgrid 7y agoWhen this actually becomes a widespread problem we can revisit the ban. Indeed, if mass-surveillance becomes so cheap that ordinary citizens can deploy it it makes sense for police & governments to also have access to it. Until then, don't.
- walterkrankheit 7y agoIn Berlin they have a voluntary facial recognition zone at one of the train stations. Passengers can opt in and be part of the pilot program or just go through the non-facial recognition entrance. I'm guessing most in privacy-valuing Germany don't go through facial recognition.
- majewsky 7y agoActually, the Ministry of the Interior is seeking to get that tech from trial into production just now: > Germany’s Interior Minister Horst Seehofer plans to use automatic facial recognition at 134 railway stations and 14 airports, according to a news report published on 3 January. Source: https://www.euractiv.com/section/data-protection/news/german-ministers-plan-to-expand-automatic-facial-recognition-meets-fierce-criticism/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/data-protection/news/german... I wonder if that's why Vestager is tackling this issue now.
- _trampeltier 7y agoWhat is "public space"? Is a trainstation public, since the operaters are all private companys?
- tumetab1 7y agoIn EU/Europe usually a public space is stree common areas and all spaces when someone can enter at their own will legally (read shops, transport systems, cinemas, etc.). So, anything that is not a restricted space, e.g. a manufacturing plant, is an open space.
- lnnaie 7y agoThat means 5 years behind others that will be researching it and actively using and improving the tech. What a rushed decision. And that's how EU did and will always lag behind everyone else.
- hurricanetc 7y ago5 years behind in the race for totalitarianism.
- Frost1x 7y agoYou'd think by the time much of the cold war ended we would have learned that allowing technology to run away rampantly has vast reaching implications in everyone's life. I love technology as much as anyone but sometimes we have to slow down and consider the potential implications of what we're creating/contributing to. Not all technology is, in-and-of-itself arguably good for humanity.
- emilfihlman 7y agoI find it funny how "privacy" is a key issue, but other personal freedoms like ownership (say of weapons) or freedom of speech is not. Privacy is even more detrimental to police capacity to investigate and freedom of speech for you to critize and spread information about any of this, yet most people on HN hand waive these rights away because they are not trendy and there is hostility against them in the media.
- netcan 7y agoYet another big example, where tech literacy is probably a barrier to getting good policy. Layered onto the bureaucratic & political challenges that always apply to rule making... There are two operative components: cameras & software. They don't need to be on the same device or used by the same person. Increasingly, if the cameras exist, the "data" is likely to go through software at some point. Facebook, Apple, Google or whatnot... they do facial recognition & other classification by default. Any publicly available pictures can be crawled & analysed by aggregators... or whoever wants to. Most people use services that analyse image content, make images public, or both. These aren't just theoretical loopholes. There are tons and tons of private cameras out there. These will continue to "do facial recognition," or lead to it. This can probably only be a ban on certain users: police... maybe some classes of regulatable businesses. This might be ok, but I don't get the impression decision makers know this.
- ta999999171 7y agoStop telling them.
- surak 7y agoCheck the EDPB opinion that was released recently. It states quite clearly what can bu done.
- jaimex2 7y agoGood luck with that.
- buboard 7y agoif EU seriously considers privacy, the only tool that citizens can have is encryption. e.g. mandate E2E on every text-messaging communication. banning FR, while this: > Exceptions to the ban could be made for security projects as well as research and development, the paper said. Is hypocritical
- bsenftner 7y agoThis is something of a distraction from the total surveillance currently provided by everyone carrying a mobile phone. As I read people's concerns, a good majority of the concerns also apply to mobile phone tracking, yet that completely globally operational and in place system is ignored?
- blululu 7y agoWouldn’t apple’s face unlock fall under the purview of such laws? This seems fairly capricious since there is no real justification in relation to what the problem is exactly. It might be better to introduce some penalties for wrong doing before introducing an outright ban.
- lewisj489 7y agoOff topic: Does anyone else find the font they use hard to read?
- derefr 7y agoWould this include simple face detection (i.e. the first-line heuristic modern cameras use to autofocus)?
- Uhuhreally 7y agoAll of us are in hundreds of people's photos & videos every time we travel through a city and then FB/Apple/Google will recognize us anyway