10 ms·
Shenzhen’s economy under strain: blame the trade war?
- larnmar 7y agoGood. The Chinese people won’t rise up against their government until the economic (relatively) good times end. What can we as citizens do to help?
- m-p-3 7y agoUnless you're a Chinese citizen, nothing. The revolution has to come from within, or it won't be seen as legitimate.
- taurath 7y agoMost citizens don’t mind the Chinese government, or at least think it’s better than alternatives. They still need the consent of the governed to rule.
- EpicEng 7y ago>Most citizens don’t mind the Chinese government, or at least think it’s better than alternatives... Sure... because economically things are relatively good, and I imagine the constant attempt to brainwash every citizen from birth has something to do with it. Many Muslim women, when asked, will say that they chose to wear a burqa, or the niqab, but I think most of us here know that they've been conditioned to think that way.
- blacksmith_tb 7y agoThat's a very slippery slope - haven't you been conditioned to think individuality and personal freedoms are vital? The concerned citizens of the PRC would love to help you with that.
- trianglem 7y agoA lot of women will swear by the burqa even if they’ve been bought up in western societies and we’re less conservative in their younger days. You underestimate the contentment that comes from prescribed piety.
- bobthepanda 7y agoIf you ask most (Han) Chinese, the thing they prize the most is stability. Nearly every change in political system, or power struggle, has resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of Chinese for the past two centuries. The current post-Deng CPC model, for all its faults, does have peaceful transitions of power. It remains to be seen whether or not today's wealthier China would also consider economic stability to be just as important.
- leereeves 7y ago> peaceful transitions of power Didn't Xi Jinping declare himself president for life?
- Teever 7y agoYes, but he declared it peacefully.
- shi314 7y agoWhat about jailing previous president and launching campaign against his supporters in name of anti corruption.
- yorwba 7y agoHu Jintao was never jailed and the anti-corruption campaign wasn't so much targeting his supporters, but instead people Hu couldn't afford to get rid of, such as former security minister Zhou Yongkang. No one received worse punishment than a prison sentence, so even if you count the anti-corruption campaign as part of the power transition, it was still a peaceful one.
- larnmar 7y agoGiven that most Chinese know perfectly well that theyand their families will wind up dead or in a concentration camp if they express dissent, in what way is it useful to ask them what they think?
- aalleavitch 7y agoIt's strange how people see everyone else's culture as brainwashing but don't stop to think about how much of their own is too.
- EpicEng 7y agoAre you really equating the US (where I live) to China? I don't imagine anyone in this thread is dumb enough to see the comparison as "US good, China bad", but if you think they reside at about the same level on the oppression and tyranny scale... I don't know what to say to you. It has nothing to do with "culture" and everything to do with an oppressive regime's stranglehold on its citizens.
- aalleavitch 7y agoI've lived in the US all my life, and I've been subjected to propaganda my entire life as well. Everyone grows up in a society that tries to justify why it's the best and everything else is worse, point at a dozen good qualities of America and I will point at a dozen evil ones. America has and continues to do horrific things. I had to see that broken down with my own eyes to figure out that I was raised on lies just as much as any other oppressive nation.
- EpicEng 7y agoYet there are degrees of oppression, propaganda, and tyranny. It's not black and white and no country is perfect, but that doesn't mean we're on equal footing.
- taurath 7y agoYou assumed there was an equation there, but there wasn't from the comment. That one may be blind to one's own inadequacies doesn't mean their calling out other's is true, but IMO taking the high ground that there's a clear better should only be taken from an actually eyes open perspective, and even then that position would be shown with a heck of a lot more empathy. People tend to just take up the moral high ground and trumpet much much better they are and not be productive in improving anything.
- claudiawerner 7y ago>but I think most of us here know that they've been conditioned to think that way. Haven't you and I been conditioned by the ideology of the liberal conception of freedom, human rights, "democracy" and morality? Do not those concepts also have their critics? Yes, I am engaging in whataboutism - but sometimes that's a good thing to see just how far the slippery slope can slide. If the Chinese populace, with its faulty ideology, and the Muslim women wearing burquas, with their faulty ideology, can be said to have such a "false consciousness", why is your (or my) ideology so much less faulty or immune to criticism? What about the very ideology you espouse that declares that overriding the will of people is justified if people are "conditioned"? It is very hard, rare in fact, to escape false consciousness. It just so happens that our false consciousness is a little different to those in other places.
- EpicEng 7y agoI'd love to hear your criticisms of "freedom, human rights, and democracy [representative government]" in contrast to the authoritarianism and xenophobia of China.
- Supermancho 7y agoWhat you consider freedom (and Human Rights) is likely different than I. However, in the US you get to live with the tyranny of the majority, regardless of what either of us think. The fact that it's (largely) an ignorant mass in charge vs a specific individual (and their motivated power structures) is different and yet the same. Culturally, China tolerates more. Give the USA a couple thousand years and it will look identical. No form of government has lasted the test of time, but authoritarian governments have statistically populated the longest lasting ones. In modernity, there has been a brief renaissance, but I don't believe that corruption of a modern democracy will take longer than it did for Rome ANYWHERE, including the USA. It's hard to be critical of becoming successful as robber barons of the USA, when there's so little culture and so much of the capital to waste. Don't mistake those qualities for innate value.
- claudiawerner 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "contrast" - China is absolutely an authoritarian country, but that does not negate the criticisms[0] of the liberal conceptions of freedom and human rights in the West - we now have to points to criticize: the Western ideology, and the Chinese one. Freedom is absolutely an important thing to have in society, but that doesn't mean that the Western (or Chinese) conceptions of it are the right ones. To say that the philosophical underpinnings of liberal freedom and democracy are immune from criticism (feminist, Marxist, or otherwise) is tantamount to dogmatism. China's concepts may be worse than the Western concepts, but the Western ones certainly aren't beyond reproach. [0] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marx/#2 https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marx/#2 [1] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/critical-theory/#2.1 https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/critical-theory/#2.1 [2] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/feminism-liberal/#Cri https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/feminism-liberal/#Cri
- taurath 7y agoYes, it is interesting that people tend to believe the one true religion happens to be the one they were born into and raised with. Just like the USA is #1 and the USA stands for freedom. Everyone is subject to brainwashing by the society they're raised in. Anyone telling you they're a completely independent person is probably fooling themselves. That there's not that much discontent is a nice feature for those who are contented.
- Mirioron 7y ago>Many Muslim women, when asked, will say that they chose to wear a burqa, or the niqab, but I think most of us here know that they've been conditioned to think that way. We all are conditioned by the culture we live in. We generally think our culture is better than theirs regardless what our culture or their culture is. People can accept a lot of limitations to their freedom as long as life is decent and people don't feel that they need more. Think of all of the libertarian arguments about how a large government limits the freedom of people, but most people in the west are okay with most of those limitations. Western countries might not be running active government propaganda, but things like Hollywood absolutely push a certain type of culture into society.
- EpicEng 7y agoI'm sure Hare would be proud, but back in reality we have to find real answers to moral questions. There are actully objective truths in life. Whether or not people can accept oppression due to cultural influences is irrelelevant; it's not a good thing. Freedom to speak and, therefore, to think, is preferable over the alternative. Not all arguments are created equal, and comparing the influence of Hollywood (while certainly real!) to that of an authoritarian government is a joke.
- blackrock 7y agoYou forgot to mention. The CIA and US Government provides active funding to Hollywood. The propaganda here is known as manufactured consent. It's actually pretty ingenious.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Many Muslim women, when asked, will say that they chose to wear a burqa, or the niqab, but I think most of us here know that they've been conditioned to think that way. "Know"? The practice is spreading among Jewish women in Israel, who appreciate that it's a strong visual signal of their piety. Should we conclude that they've been conditioned to think that way too?
- larnmar 7y agoPretty easy to get the “consent of the governed” when you kill anyone who comes close to expressing dissent.
- ETHisso2017 7y agoI would rather the Chinese people continue to enjoy prosperity, thank you very much.
- president 7y agoThere is no prosperity to be had until there is rule of law and respect for basic human dignity, among other things that are lacking in the PRC.
- imtringued 7y agoWhen you look at revolutions that resulted in democracies you can see that it was mostly the upper class that wanted the conflict. There is a reason why the protests have started in Hongkong instead of some random village.
- oblio 7y agoIt's rarely the upper class, it's usually the middle class coordinating and the lower class doing the bulk of the fighting.
- rolltiide 7y agoOne regional autonomous government slowing down won’t cause an uprising against Beijing
- baybal2 7y agoI'm afraid nothing. If you read the article well, you'd see the city is a victim of its own success more than anything. We in Shenzhen call what's going on recently as "Dubaisation" of the city. Land prices are on their way to stratosphere. Factory rentals follow rent price too. Working class is being priced out. A factory owner can sell the remaining value on the land lease for up to 40 times the average annual rent. A lot of them do. When factories close, they leave a lot of unemployed youth. Those youth who already been living from salary to salary will have hard time hanging there for longer. Shenzhen is no longer a city where people come in hopes of making money more so than spending them. If people will not have confidence in making more cash tomorrow, than they can make today, they will no longer be coming to Shenzhen, and go to other cash cow cities. Once they leave, they will not be coming back, and restarting manufacturing in the city will be getting harder and harder. This is why it is very important for city's party cadres to find ways to stop labour force exodus. It is important to prevent a feedback loop where low labour availability will driver more factory closures. High incomers will hang around in the city only for as long as there will be industrial companies to hire top tier professionals. We can not hope that the city can live off high incomers alone if their employers have no reason to stay in Shenzhen.
- helen___keller 7y ago> We in Shenzhen call what's going on recently as "Dubaisation" of the city. How does this compare to Beijing and Shanghai I wonder? I'd have to imagine all the top Chinese cities, with their absurd real estate prices, are seeing similar You could make similar analogies to top American cities too of course
- baybal2 7y ago> Beijing and Shanghai Beijing and Shanghai had relatively little industry to begin with. They don't have to "battle" the phenomenon to survive, their economies, and people lives will not crash from that.
- whatshisface 7y agoWhy not let the factories and workers move elsewhere?
- russli1993 7y agolol, as a Chinese I can say that most people here do not want to overthrow the government in disruptive ways. We can see both the good and bad things the government is doing. As for the bad thing, every government has issues, the main issue is whether the people and government itself can see them, and fix them. I would say that the system has enabled the people to change the government in the way the people want, and have the government enact on policies that benefit the people and hear people's demands. The process is different but nonetheless, through the past 30 years, the government through its actions demonstrated it is working for the people. Chinese people are not stupid, if its a rouge state up top we will overthrow it. The society will not be this stable. And no, if there is discontent, no amount of police and oppression is able to prevent a civil unrest.
- larnmar 7y agoI’m guessing you’re not an Uyghur?
- kzzzznot 7y agoCan you please elaborate on “the system has enabled the people to change the government in the way the people want”
- yorwba 7y agoThe government is very afraid of a regional uprising turning into a national one, so they're willing to do a lot to prevent that from happening. Arresting protesters and censoring the news are stop-gap measures; in many cases they don't have much choice but to address whatever grievance was leading to protests in the first place. It's not a very efficient system, but frequently it does work somehow. I guess that's what the previous commenter meant.
- president 7y ago> I would say that the system has enabled the people to change the government in the way the people want, So China is now democratic? You're either delusional, a troll, or a member of the privileged class. It's hard to say the CCP is "working for the people" when they lie to citizens about basic things like daily air pollution stats and lock people up for benign comments on WeChat. There is a reason that Hong Kong and Taiwan are trying so hard to resist being swallowed up by the PRC.
- licebmi__at__ 7y agoOne would have thought that with the most recent experiments of regime change people would be more careful or humble but here we are.
- mycall 7y agoNew people, new attempts.
- rolltiide 7y agoDouble whammy as its probably a spillover from an anathema to visiting/doing business in Hong Kong as well
- ETHisso2017 7y agoIt is a spillover from Hong Kong, but in the sense that mainland capital that would have entered HK is now investing in Shenzhen and is hence making the city too expensive for manufacturing.
- aazaa 7y ago> Growth in the first three quarters of 6.6% was substantially down on the same period last year, and a lot slower than the first six months of this year. Is it really that hard to include the growth rate for the previous period? Without that, it's impossible to put the "strain" into any kind of context. > Indeed, the implication is that the economy barely grew at all between July and September. How about a graph showing monthly growth rates? > News that Shenzhen is losing steam has seemed more ominous because it is home to some of the country’s most dynamic companies and newest industries. ... I'm not inclined to trust the anecdotes in the rest of the piece given that the author hasn't done basic numerical and visualization legwork.
- kevstev 7y agoI found it surprising that 6.6% is "slow" or "strained." Those are numbers akin to a massive boom in the US.
- hnarn 7y agoAre you surprised that growth is higher in China than in the US?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI don’t think the article is taking about the whole of China, just Schenzhen.
- ryanhuff 7y agoI believe the point of the parent is that the “slow” growth referenced in the article doesn’t really seem slow by other standards.
- Mirioron 7y agoI find this surprising. It seems obvious to me that areas in countries that are much less wealthy grow much faster than wealthy countries (if they're improving). They are essentially catching up by implementing many of the same techniques wealthy countries already figured out.
- ghostcluster 7y ago> Analysts have highlighted the steep plunge in private sector investment, for instance, which barely grew in the January to September period compared to a year ago, versus 12.3% growth over the first half of this year. My understanding is that China's meteoric rise in places like Shenzhen has caused local wages to increase and the city to become more expensive to live and do business in, thus giving manufacturing an incentive to seek less expensive areas, like Vietnam, in which the sector is rapidly growing.
- baybal2 7y agoAt least a part of the saga of rising salaries without rising productivity is due to China being very lax on interest rates and Xi's government genuinely believing in that being a recipe for growth. Xi himself is said to be very emboldened by what he sees as success of his previous attempts of running the economy by throwing money on SOEs, and he uses that to parry any attempt of central committee to reason with him. There is a well known video going around of the plenum session opening, where Xi basically says "bigger, better resourced state enterprises," and Li says "smaller, and nimbler ones" right after him. Xi ignores that China saw its fastest growth at the time of Chinese rates being rather high. Low rates demoralise the entrepreneurial community. Too many business owners exit because they can go to higher rate countries for rentier lifestyle. Too many business owners think it makes no sense to compete with people who can get billions at 1% interest and throw that to bruteforce their market position. More so, this makes it really appealing for gambling minded, and well connected individuals to take state money, and gamble them on speculations, becoming instant billionaires.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThis sums up china’s problem quite nicely. A good correction/recession would be very useful to being things back down to reality, but the party might be too brittle to weather it very well, especially since the cab has been kicked down the road for so long. The USA and by extension the rest of the world is playing a similarly dangerous game with low interest rates, though in this case connections aren’t as required. The next downturn could make 2008 look mild when it all unravels.
- kccqzy 7y ago> But a downturn in its economy in the third quarter has been equally accelerated, casting doubt on its reputation as a pacesetter for the nation. It's probably still a pacesetter, because the economy of the rest of China is under strain as well, especially other formerly rapidly growing cities.
- dogweather 7y agoCould the loss of e-packet subsidies be having an effect? Or is that too small-potatoes?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- williamsbure65 7y agoYeah
- maxander 7y agoThis is perhaps the first time I had heard of China's "Greater Bay Area" (according to wikipedia a "megalopolis" consisting of 11 cities besides Shenzhen) and, particularly in the context of this article on Shenzhen's SF-like woes, I can't help but be struck by this masterstroke of English-language branding on China's part.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoI think it would be more normal to refer to the "Pearl River Delta".
- spectramax 7y ago"masterstroke"? I am not so sure. It doesn't take a genius to come up with similar names. China loves playing these cunning, deeply callous, and reprehensible games, for e.g. CE mark: https://www.ybw.com/vhf-marine-radio-guide/warning-dont-get-confused-between-the-ce-mark-and-the-china-export-mark-4607 https://www.ybw.com/vhf-marine-radio-guide/warning-dont-get-... China has a branding problem like no other nation. The Chinese businesses keep sacrificing long term goodwill and image over short term benefits by employing shallow tactics.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoor they cannot stop themselves from copying ... Bay Area ... American dream ...
- nexus6mike 7y agoShort-term demand seems to be shifting to Vietnam. This seems to have enabled a 'wait and see' approach re: China + tariffs. However, I'd question if Vietnam has enough long-term manufacturing capacity [1] [2] [3] to sustain the short-term advantage it seems to be currently enjoying. Today, China has 16 of the world's 50 busiest ports, including Shenzhen at #3 (all as measured by 2018 TEU volume). [4] However, this is less indicative of capacity than it is of current demand / throughput. Both countries could benefit from building more deep-water ports. China currently has two Panamax ports, with a third on the way. Vietnam has none and is building its first. The U.S., by comparison, has 42 by my count. [5] Separately, there's a great Wired documentary on Shenzhen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGJ5cZnoodY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGJ5cZnoodY. [1] https://www.latimes.com/world/la-fg-vietnam-trade-war-20190712-story.html https://www.latimes.com/world/la-fg-vietnam-trade-war-201907... [2] www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3018403/chinese-manufacturers-returning-home-inefficient-vietnam [3] https://www.wsj.com/articles/for-manufacturers-in-china-breaking-up-is-hard-to-do-11566397989 https://www.wsj.com/articles/for-manufacturers-in-china-brea... [4] http://www.worldshipping.org/about-the-industry/global-trade/top-50-world-container-ports http://www.worldshipping.org/about-the-industry/global-trade... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Panamax_ports https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Panamax_ports
- twelvechairs 7y agoPanamax is simply a much less important standard for China than for the USA because of proximity to the Panama Canal. Generally they can (and do) support larger ships but often with lower draft. Much of their shipping infrastructure is better for modern larger capesize vessels than the US. There's a reason they have something like 7-8 of the top 10 world porta in basically every category and it's not because they are worried about the Panamax standard
- nexus6mike 7y agoThis is an excellent point. Certainly, China seems to be managing fine without many Panamax ports
- baybal2 7y ago
- simula67 7y agoThis was India's moment to shine. But as usual, it looks like this opportunity will also be squandered.
- est 7y agoGDP estimated to grow at 5% in 2019-20, much lower than 6.8% recorded in 2018-19 https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/gdp-estimated-to-grow-at-5-in-2019-20-as-compared-to-6-8-in-2018-19/articleshow/73139543.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/...
- krtkush 7y agoIf you take out government spendings form this, the GDP is around 3.8%
- lanyusea 7y ago6.6% is incredibly low and this number has been discussed a lot in Chinese forums. as a Shenzhen guy, I'd like to say the most important reason may be the price of the land has been increased quite a lot in the last years. Many manufacturing companies, even Huawei moved out of Shenzhen this year, some go to Dongguan, Huizhou, which are other cities of Guandong, and some go to Vietnam, Thailand. The reason is quite simple, they cannot afford the price of land to build the factory, and the salary cost is higher since the housing rent price also goes higher. Some factory owners work hard for a year, while the incoming is even less than the value increased of lands he owns. So the business all goes to the lands, housing, malls. People don't know where is the top, but people believe is far more yet. Because Hong Kong, the city next to Shenzhen, has a higher land price. For the future, the great bay area may solve this issue. Shenzhen will focus on the development of high-tech technology as a research center and enterprise center. The manufactory will move to Dongguan, Huizhou. While HongKong serves as a business/finance center. Guangdong will be the transaction center. It is possible with the highly developed traffic net. The high-speed railway connected every city of the great bay area. People and things can move fast. Taking trains has become easier and more convenient than taking buses now.
- pertymcpert 7y agoWhy did they name it Greater Bay Area when we already have a place called the Bay Area?
- baybal2 7y agoBecause it is an even greater bay area, greater than the original one, and that's the point. Subtlety is not a thing here.
- pertymcpert 7y agoIt’s either a coincidence then or a really petty/inferiority complex based name.
- OnlineGladiator 7y ago
- blackrock 7y agoI think China's next move should be to turn all their citizens into programmers. They have all the factories, the fabrication equipment, and the general know-how. And by doing so, then they get all the network effect benefits. They become programmers, researchers, programming language designers, QA engineers, systems analysts, etc., and eventually technical managers and business leaders. And they also get all the benefits of having a very technical and highly educated workforce. It's interesting that a recent survey of their school children, said that 56% wanted to become Astronauts. The next phase of their national development should probably be to move into design, research, development, and ultimately indigenous intellectual property. The past 10 years of smartphones have changed the country, that their children are exposed to all the software and technology at a young age. This should make it easier for them to become engineers, programmers, scientists, and mathematicians, as they enter college. Their current generation of engineers has proven that they have the technical capabilities to achieve that. They appear to be very good at building massive infrastructure. So they can plan, design, architect, and build out massive things (high speed rail, rockets, military planes). But let's see if they can build out small things, like software systems (OS, compilers, AI, etc.) It will be interesting if Huawei takes the lead, and their new Harmony OS becomes a viable contender in the mobile space in China. Or if it even displaces Windows and Linux as the primary desktop or server operating system within China. Maybe Microsoft would eventually port over Word and Excel to the Harmony OS? And I'm still waiting for them to come up with their own programming language. Although this might be a tall order, as C is quite popular there. However, the guy who created Vue.js is of Chinese descent, but it seems America snatched him away. Now I could be wrong, but the current perception appears as if the Trump administration is hell bent on alienating everyone of Chinese descent from working in America. If they can succeed at all this, then a slowdown in the Shenzhen manufacturing economy for export, is irrelevant. They would have evolved to the next level. They would build out their own software systems for internal consumption, and eventual export.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoI hope it is because of our hk protest.
- woutr_be 7y agoIf you read the article, you would know it isn’t. If anything, the protests would be an advantage for Shenzhen.