12 ms·
Global Wave of Debt Is Largest, Fastest in 50 Years
- rolltiide 7y agoMoney is free for the credit worthy. And by credit worthy that has nothing to do with your social/credit score.
- vladimirralev 7y agoAt the same time the business media can't stop talking about both US and global savings glut being the issue. The Fed says the average American doesn't save enough. Every few hours talking heads turn around and say something completely different with no change in fundamentals. The whole system has turned into a joke. We get to see Powell answering the same questions with less sophistication than a fifth grader. While serious analysts actually do the math and prove policy makers' models diverged from their stated goal decades ago.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoThe saving glut and the wave of debt are the exact same phenomenon. Savers can only save if someone else is borrowing. Collectively low US savings rates show up in the current account deficit -- the US attracts savings from abroad.
- vladimirralev 7y ago> The saving glut and the wave of debt are the exact same phenomenon. Savers can only save if someone else is borrowing. I've heard this before and it doesn't go far to explain any of this. The modern plumbing between savers and borrowers makes this almost meaningless. There is the fractional reserve system to begin with. Savings are only a tiny fraction of the money actually borrowed out there. On top of that, the collateral is historically overvalued while rates are low. I don't know if you are suggesting that savings = debt, that's a subject to interpretation but the way most economists understand it that's not true in this system by a long shot. > the US attracts savings from abroad I assume by savings from abroad you mean foreigners buy dollars to buy stocks and (to a lesser extent) bonds. I don't think this refers to actual cash which is the savings from "the savings glut".
- rolltiide 7y agoThese are related issues. The debt glut exists because interest rates are low, interest rates are low for the specific goal of making savers feel like owning US debt or parking money in bank accounts is a waste of time. The goal is for those savers to give random entrepreneurs their money to do fuck all with to "stimulate the economy", and the market is saying "hell no, instead of me earning minuscule interest, I'll literally pay you so I don't have to do that", so governments and corporations issue even more debt at lower and even negative yields.
- skybrian 7y agoLeaving banking to one side, here are the key facts about foreign investment: 1) Nobody sells stuff for free. This includes foreigners selling us imported goods. They will always be compensated somehow. 2) Investors try not to lose money. This includes foreign investors. 3) The U.S. has been running a trade deficit for decades. The result is that foreign investment in the U.S. keeps going up. As long as imports don't balance exports, the difference becomes an increase in foreign ownership of US investment assets. There are two ways for foreign investment to stop increasing. Either the trade balance reverses (fewer imports and more exports) or foreign investors lose their investments and write them off. This does happen sometimes; consider the Saudis, Softbank, and WeWork. In a way, this is good from the US point of view, because foreign losses mean we did eventually get some of our previous imports for free. It's a good trade! But, usually investors learn from their mistakes, so this can't be guaranteed. Not wanting to lose money (but not wanting to spend it either) means there is a high demand for safe investments like Treasury bonds. This drives interest rates down. In the meantime, more imports fuel ever more demand for apparently good investments. This is part of the demand side of the "global savings glut" (it doesn't mean actual cash). Many countries would like to increase exports and own more foreign investments. Much of Wall Street financial innovation comes from attempting to give these investors what they think they want. Some of the things they come up with may actually be good investments and others might just look good. This trend can keep going as long as there are countries trying to become richer via export-led growth, foreign investors don't lose confidence, and foreign consumers aren't empowered and encouraged to buy enough international goods to match their countries' exports. Even troubled times might not cause investors to stop investing in the more stable countries due to lack of good alternatives. Instead there is a "rush to safety".
- skybrian 7y agoThe problem with talking about averages is that it hides differences between people. Apparently some people save too much (there is a lack of profitable investments and interest rates are low due to supply and demand) while other people save too little (they don't have enough savings for emergencies, let alone retirement). It sounds like inequality to me.
- Proven 7y ago> Apparently some people save too much That's not true. People save according to their preferences and abilities. The whole point of banking system is to lend money. The reason banks can lend is because some people save "too much" (don't spend almost everything they earn). People who are net borrowers would pay a lot more in interest if other people saved less. > It sounds like inequality to me. People are not equal in their abilities, but in their rights. There's no right to have a ton of money in the bank.
- grok2 7y agoWhat does this mean for a lay-person in the so called "emerging and developing economy"? How do they prepare for any fallout?
- nradov 7y agoIf you expect a wave of debt defaults then that will cause asset price deflation. So accumulate cash now and then use it to buy assets at a discount after the fallout. Of course trying to time the market seldom works for individual investors.
- turk73 7y agoThe problem is that most cash money market or savings accounts are only insured to $250K each. If I move money out to them to await my big moment, I have to open several accounts. Back in 2007 I had funds in NetBank which happened to be the first bank to fail during the crisis. My money was bailed out 100% by the FDIC. But it was a tense time and a lesson I won't ever forget. Today, banks can fail and the laws have now changed such that savings accounts may be used to "bail in" this time. So beware--cash is not safe, actual hard cash is not safe (can get stolen, safe deposit boxes are not allowed to hold any cash), gold and silver must be in hand, but are not safe for the same reasons as cash. No investments are safe, not even money market funds--those nearly broke the dollar peg in 2009/10. So what should we do? Bitcoin? Give me a freaking break, lol! We went to FL in 2009 and I remember vividly how many condos were on sale for unbelievable prices. The thing was, you could not get financing and I had no idea how long any recovery would take if it ever came at all. I expected another leg down, not a recovery. The only reason we had a recovery is because Bush fired up the printing presses and Obama kept them going. Then gas prices went totally insane which is how they bailed out all the banks--on our fucking backs! And NOBODY went to prison! Oh, and the worst part was all the "Peak Oil" propaganda all over the Internet which had to be a psyop because they had to justify the high oil prices which were in no way justifiable at all. So after long consideration, I think this time we really should just shoot the bastards.
- koheripbal 7y agoThe real take here is 'it depends'. The important number is the debt-to-GDP ratio for each country, and which countries we're talking about. The biggest debt growth has been with China that now has a debt-to-GDP ratio of 255%. Does that number spell doom for China? Not really. It's high, but China can handle it. If it continues to grow in an uncontrolled fashion, it might be a different story. So in each case, each country is different story, and you have to look at them individually.
- markvdb 7y agoLooks like yet another warning sign of dirty work afoot. Do you have a strategy to deal with economic black swan events? I'm looking for reasonable, affordable measures that could shield my partner and myself should black swans ever strike. I'm NOT looking for alarmist prepper style rabid craziness...
- ilaksh 7y agoIt's not going to be a black swan event. It's the long term debt cycle which is a clear pattern in historical data. See Ray Dalio's explanation. Preparing for the possible collapse of the financial system does not make you crazy. Ask people in Greece or Venezuela, or great grandparents who went through the depression. I think the first smart thing is to diversify investments such as buying gold or different currencies or real estate. I have lots of other idea but based on your comment you would accuse me of being insane if I mentioned them.
- ngold 7y agoAbsolute worse case scenarios, some cash and gold and a title to a paid off property go a long way. Cash to pay property taxes for a couple years goes pretty far.
- markvdb 7y agoI'm sorry if I made you feel like I wouldn't welcome all well thought through input. That's certainly not the case. I love outside the box thinking!
- Consultant32452 7y agoI think the answer to strategies for black swan events is the same it always has been. Own a piece of land, some portion of your portfolio should probably be in gold/silver. You might toss in some crypto. Get/stay out of debt. Get a passport. Have enough savings so you can GTFO your country if necessary. Also, here's the math on catastrophic events. It's more likely than you think. https://medium.com/s/story/the-surprisingly-solid-mathematical-case-of-the-tin-foil-hat-gun-prepper-15fce7d10437 https://medium.com/s/story/the-surprisingly-solid-mathematic...
- ilaksh 7y agoIt's absolutely not just emerging or developing economies. This article is extremely misleading in that regard and its very dangerous. Do some research on your own. Many if not most wealthy countries are in serious trouble including the US and China. Take a look at what Ray Dalio says about it. He says that this is part of a pattern of long term debt cycles, it looks like 1937 and implies there is risk of a global depression, dollar losing its status and even WW III. My opinion is that at some point there will need to be a new paradigm introduced deliberately if we are going to avoid the terrible natural conclusion of the existing one.
- nradov 7y agoThere has been risk of WW III since 1946. What else is new. If you keep predicting disaster for long enough then eventually you'll be right.
- sunseb 7y agoIn 1933, there were 80 millions young German. Today, most inhabitants in the western world are too old to fight in a WW3, but at the same time, there is no more need of a massive army to trigger a WW3. :-/
- bosie 7y agoI don't know where you got that number from. Germany had a population of around 65M in 1933, so probably closer to 10M young Germans?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sunseb 7y agoIt's kind of ironic that the more a society is efficient and productive, the more it's subject to a overproduction crisis and massive unemployment. We need to change the model.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoThis is a kind of nineteenth century understanding of the economy. You can only have overproduction and massive unemployment if you have a shortfall in aggregate demand, which the government and the central bank have the power to correct.
- ping_pong 7y agoFor a blueprint as to what will happen, there's really 2 scenarios: 1) hyperinflation 2) deflation. If hyperinflation is the possibility, which the Fed will favor much more than deflation, then you want to own as much debt as possible, in the form of property. Then your debt will hyper-inflate away and you'll be left with a ton of property. If the Fed loses control and we end up with deflation, you want to own as little debt as possible and as much cash as possible. If you are lucky enough to be with a life partner, you can arrange all your debt to be with one person, and all your assets to the other person, and then get a divorce if need be. Then the person holding the debt can claim bankruptcy in the case of global deflation, which would then wipe the slate clean.
- voisin 7y agoUsually assets and liabilities are linked in the form of specific collateral. Lenders have no upside but repayment and interest and are pretty wise to bad faith structures on the part of borrowers.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoThere's a more likely third scenario, which is 3) neither hyperinflation nor deflation. The US hasn't seen serious deflation since the Great Depression, and has never seen hyperinflation. Hyperinflations tend to go along with some sort of political or military disaster. A big wave of defaults is only a serious threat to the US economy if it leads to a banking crisis. That's why the global financial crisis was so much worse than the deflation of the NASDAQ bubble.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoI think when most people say hyperinflation they just mean unusually high inflation. That did exist at least once in the US (around Volker's time), but it's probably safest to bet on the status quo.
- ksec 7y agoYes. The possibility of Hyperinflation in US, EU, or even China, as much as I wanted it to happen is practically zero. Deflation isn't likely to happen either because money supply and actual value dont seems to be balanced well at the moment, not to mention money supply continues to increase. I am betting we will continue to see the current trend of ultra low growth, ( but still growth ) in the next few years before another stupid thing come along. That may be geopolitics and multiple smaller counties default triggering chain reaction.
- cs702 7y agoThe full report, titled “Global Waves of Debt,” is available at https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/32809/9781464815454.pdf https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/3... -- it is easy to read and follow. Do yourself a favor and read at least the Foreword and Overview. I also find the advance reviews from prominent economists in the initial pages of the report illuminating. The report documents four major waves of debt accumulation in emerging and developing countries since 1970: * The first such debt wave ended in the Latin American debt crisis of the 1980s.[a] * The second such debt wave ended in the the Asian financial crisis of the late 1990s.[b] * The third such debt wave ended in the global financial crisis of 2007-2009.[c] * The fourth such debt wave started in 2010, and is the fastest rising as well as the largest. -- [a] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_American_debt_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_American_debt_crisis [b] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1997_Asian_financial_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1997_Asian_financial_crisis [c] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_2007%E2%80%9308 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_crisis_of_2007%E2%80...
- nullspace 7y agoJust a +1 comment, but thanks for sharing this, it’s very much worth reading, the foreword and overview is very much written in layman language. I might try and dig into the rest of material as well. For an even simpler but informative intro to debt cycles check out this video by Ray Dalio, it’s the best layperson explanation of debt I’ve ever seen: https://youtu.be/PHe0bXAIuk0 https://youtu.be/PHe0bXAIuk0
- elfexec 7y ago> The fourth such debt wave started in 2010, and is the fastest rising as well as the largest. It's largest because unlike the first 3 regional debt waves, this one is global. US, EU, China, Japan and every major economy just printed money to kickstart growth since 2009. Should be interesting to see how this one resolves itself.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoWell, anything later should be larger just because of time and inflation. Is it larger proportionally, and if so, how much?
- lottin 7y agoNote that when they exclude China, that has predominantly domestic debt as opposed to external, it doesn't look nearly as bad.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoWell, they said emerging countries debt is raising nearly as fast as China's (which is up 72 points since 2008). I wonder who has the most exposure to this debt. My understanding is that a lot of foreign emerging debt is owned by China.
- roenxi 7y agoReal wealth is a bit like a grain silo - if the owner stops filling it with grain but takes a cup of grain out every day to cook with then they might not run out for years. Any metrics they care to use - apart from the level of the silo - will also be really rosy. They are doing less work (no need to find grain to refill the silo!) and potentially get much more benefit (instead of finding grain for the silo, maybe the owner can go and learn to play a Ukulele; so they get grain, fun and fullfillment). This illustrates the problem with a building wall of debt - if there is a problem, by the time the problem is revealed at the point in time when options disappear and a crisis is forced. Until the moment of crisis life has been going on the way it has been for a while and everything seems work or maybe even to be getting easier. In the real world wealth doesn't behave like my imaginary grain silo, but by golly it makes me nervous watching people invest so much energy into billion dollar cash-burning machines like Uber while debt levels keep climbing. If people with money think that is acceptable, are they actually investing in building up real wealth? iPhones are lovely, but they are pretty small in the grand scheme of what is needed for physical comfort.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> iPhones are lovely, but they are pretty small in the grand scheme of what is needed for physical comfort. I disagree. The ability to securely communicate with anyone around the world instantaneously, take pictures and video, and access almost all information online is pretty valuable.
- cheez 7y agoTry living without it. It's not that big of a deal.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI would define physical comfort as including contact with friends and family.
- the_gastropod 7y ago
- littlestymaar 7y agoAs always when talking about debt, this article only discusses the right side of the balance sheet (debt) but ignore the left side (asset): every piece of debt created is someone's else asset. And if the amount of debt is rising, it means that the amount of debt security is rising also. Who owns it, and why some institutions and people are able to hoard such an increasing amount of assets should be as important to the discussion than how much debt there is, yet it remains undiscussed. (Yes QE/central banks is part of the answer now, but it only came after the previous crisis, which where caused by too much debt, so it's not at all the full answer)
- digital_voodoo 7y agoThis. One of factors allowing the rising of debt, theoretically speaking, is the value of the corresponding asset. When the latter is over-valued, debt follows.
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoIIRC, the answer is largely pension funds. Baby Boomers are starting to retire, and in order to do so they need to either own a bunch of debt securities or have a pension or retirement fund that does so on their behalf. In my view, this is pretty much entirely responsible for a large secular trend in indebtedness over the last several decades - retirees will need to sell off financial assets later, so the aggregate dollar value of their current financial assets has to rise as they save up for it.
- jbob2000 7y agoActually, of the $55 trillion in global debt, China owns $20 trillion. Much of this debt is going to developing countries. The rest is a mixture of private equity and governments, which would include pension funds, but they are not the largest debt holders by any means.
- littlestymaar 7y agoThere's a big confusion here: - your $55 billions is only public debt. - the private debt is way higher (more than $130 trillions). Sources: - public debt: https://www.economist.com/content/global_debt_clock https://www.economist.com/content/global_debt_clock - total debt: https://blogs.imf.org/2019/01/02/new-data-on-global-debt/ https://blogs.imf.org/2019/01/02/new-data-on-global-debt/
- zxcb1 7y agoMore like a tsunami with the epicentre at the 2008 US Fed; propagating as unevenly distributed hyperinflation, eventually reaching those furthest away from privileged access.
- m0zg 7y agoA mandatory reminder: if the economists could actually predict the future, they'd all be ultra-rich. That is evidently not the case. So take any prognostications with a boulder sized grain of salt.
- Gustomaximus 7y agoThey would need to be able to predict the future plus put a significant portion of their net worth on the line likely many times.
- imtringued 7y agoHow would prediction of the future allow an economist to become ultra rich? The maximum profit you can obtain from arbitrage is fixed, it does not grow as you add more market participants. Therefore as you add more and more experienced economists you would expect them to get average returns or worse. You may argue that if only a single person is able to predict the future then that person could have all the arbitrage profit for themselves. Although this is possible in theory the problem is that you are talking about a non restricted group of people called "economists" who all share a similar education background which is the exact opposite of a single person with exclusive advantages.
- m0zg 7y agoThe flaw in this logic is that you're imputing a uniform level of predictive power to all "economists". In any given group there will be people who are much better at a certain skill than others. Such people would be ultra-rich if the skill is to predict the economic future, largely at the expense of those who are not able to predict quite as well.
- AstralStorm 7y agoUltimately one man can do only so much. Thus you start to involve middlemen who do not necessarily make optimal decisions - and you have to predict their result at least in the median. Stack many levels of this, each accumulating error and delay. Good luck. There is such a thing as control efficiency gain, which you have to balance against stability and constraints. It's a really tough problem, and since economists only work with slow averages, the gains they can make are relatively small over the general growth if present. And that presumes your optimization condition is ultimately correct and complete, which most of these are not. Even an oracle would have limited efficiency unless it could reproduce itself. Even if you can observe all states that does not mean you can control them.